₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: RegisterLoginWith GoogleTrendingRecentNew

Stats: 3,327,355 members, 8,430,617 topics. Date: Saturday, 20 June 2026 at 07:06 PM

Toggle theme

Who Would Win In A War Between Russia And The US? - Education (3) - Nairaland

Nairaland ForumNairaland GeneralEducationWho Would Win In A War Between Russia And The US? (6837 Views)

1 2 3 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Who Would Win In A War Between Russia And The US? by Voldoz(op): 5:28am On Mar 06, 2022
orble:
This Voldoz of a guy, what did you drank?

Who Russia don't have allies.. like seriously all nations of the earth are Russia's enemies?

Who told you US would win- and it would dominate Russia?

Who told you Russia employs older jets and technology compared to the US?

Who told The Russians cannot afford a large carrier fleet ?

Who told you the red army is less advance?

Who told you The US has the best of the best in about everything?

Who told the fleet with 12 hyper-expensive carriers is even pivotal in modern warfare?

Who told you the US more technologically advanced military THAN RUSSIA?

Who told you US economy to withstand shocks better than Russia?

Who told you US has the geographical works in today's hypersonic wars?

Who told you that US has a lot of control over independent foreign markets?

Do this man think the rest of the world is US hegemon?

Do this man think top countries go to war with canoes?

Go and check the countries that US command to the inauguration/establish Jerusalem as Israeli capital.

If you don't know them google list of poorest countries.

I'm for the USA, but that doesn't make me think fo0lishly.
Ogbeni this information is from quora. Countless of people speak similar, I don't support us or Russia but I know when one is a bigger boy.

Only their military allocation alone is supposed to do the maths for you.
Re: Who Would Win In A War Between Russia And The US? by Nobody: 9:41am On Mar 06, 2022
Metachit:
It's funny reading this, if you are well over 20 years.

Never in this lifetime, compare the US and Russia in terms of military assessment or even more likely a war breakout.

I'm not a US sheepie nor a Putin hater, but let me I'm categorically telling you now, no country on the face of this earth stands a chance against the US. Even the Nato countries plus Russian and Chinese Forces won't match.

America is miles ahead and their media will never let you know where they are in terms of technological advancements. I laughed offy ass when the russian general said they won't provide rocket engines for US.

Does he know how many rocket engine manufacturers in the US currently?

US is only match for any extra-terrestrial forces out there in the universe, that's greater than humans. That's the kind of war, US is preparing for.
Nasa would never tell you what they left in the moon and on the mars but I'm here to tell u that they have weaponised these places.

How did they get clear satellite images of russian troops surrounding Ukraine border?
Let's not forget too quickly
Satellite pictures? Space travel? Rocket engine manufacturers?

Anybody can get satellite images.

The US has a far larger economy than Russia- with the US economy being 13 times larger (in terms of GDP)
The US economy is more advanced than the Russian economy with a far higher GDP per capita. This advancement also allows the US economy to withstand shocks better
The US has the geographical advantage. It would be nearly impossible to invade the US given it’s bordered by the 2 largest oceans. Russia meanwhile is bordered by US allies and even if we take the allies out of the equation, Russia is more exposed than the US
Likely both nations are impossible to conquer though and they will never go to war against each other
Re: Who Would Win In A War Between Russia And The US? by colestephan86: 10:08am On Mar 06, 2022
Voldoz:
Let’s start with a few assumptions

1. No nukes

2. No allies. Russia doesn’t have many military allies and the US has dozens- obviously, this tilts things.

Let’s assume (rather unrealistically) that there is a war between just the US and Russia. Who would win?

The US would win- and it would dominate.


(note these numbers are a little off- the now favor the US more than before)

Airforce:

The US boasts the strongest air force on earth. Not only is it the largest by a margin, but it is also the most technologically advanced by quite a degree.

350,000 personnel
5,800 aircraft

The Russian airforce is very large and advanced- yet its total cost is about 20% of the US airforce. Russia employs older jets and technology compared to the US


190,000 personnel
4,000 Aircraft

Navy:

The US Navy is by far the largest and most expensive fleet on earth. The US focuses on surface fleet action with combat being centered around “supercarriers” and carrier strike groups.

350,000 personnel
480 ships

2,5000 aircraft
The Russian Navy operates differently than the US Navy. The Russians cannot afford a large carrier fleet and so they utilize more submarines and missile strike craft. This strategy can work when employed correctly but doesn’t do well against large surface fleets.

150,000 personnel
350 ships
no aircraft in significant numbers

Ground forces:


The US Army is not the largest on earth but it is most expensive. US troops are some of the best equipped and best trained troops on earth. The US spends love static defense. US forces like infantry to be well supported by APCs, tanks, and airsupport.

1 million personnel without about half being active duty
The Russian army is much smaller than the US army by a margin and is also less advanced. Russia has banked on Armored warfare and thus has a larger fleet of tanks and armored vehicles than the US.

900,000 personnel with 280,000 being active duty
Military the US and Russia have different strategies when it comes to war. The US has the best of the best in about everything while Russia employs what it can afford.

Looking at the Navy’s of these 2 nations is a great example. The US has a massive surface fleet with 12 hyper-expensive carriers. Russia cannot afford more than 2 or 3 carriers so they know they cannot compete on the surface. Thus Russia has invested in missile craft and submarines, hoping this will allow them to combat the US fleet for a cheaper cost.

In the end though the US simply has the larger military and the more technologically advanced military. That's not all either.

The US has a far larger economy than Russia- with the US economy being 13 times larger (in terms of GDP)

The US economy is more advanced than the Russian economy with a far higher GDP per capita. This advancement also allows the US economy to withstand shocks better.

The US has the geographical advantage. It would be nearly impossible to invade the US given it’s bordered by the 2 largest oceans. Russia meanwhile is bordered by US allies and even if we take the allies out of the equation, Russia is more exposed than the US.

Likely both nations are impossible to conquer though

The US has a lot of control over foreign markets and global trade and it could easily blockade Russia into economic ruin.
Let's put media stories aside. I feel Russia is a country that has the capacity to face US.
From Putin's statement that any country who tries rubbish will experience what their country has never see before in the history of their country.
It's very evident that the US is avoiding a confrontation with Russia at all cost.
If the US is actually as powerful as they claim, how come the US lost a 20 years war with the Taliban's in Afghanistan.
Re: Who Would Win In A War Between Russia And The US? by seanwilliam(m): 10:36am On Mar 08, 2022
colestephan86:
Let's put media stories aside. I feel Russia is a country that has the capacity to face US.
From Putin's statement that any country who tries rubbish will experience what their country has never see before in the history of their country.
It's very evident that the US is avoiding a confrontation with Russia at all cost.
If the US is actually as powerful as they claim, how come the US lost a 20 years war with the Taliban's in Afghanistan.
the war in Afghanistan was not confrontational
Re: Who Would Win In A War Between Russia And The US? by fortune1894(m): 10:48am On Mar 08, 2022
Voldoz:
Bro that's invalid both military never fought against each other. The post says if both goes head to head not with side wars.

Not directly as the USA vs the USSR

There are answers mentioning the cuban missile crisis, U2 spy plane and even vietnam however I disagree.

Cuban missile crisis was *mostly* a standoff and not a real battle.

U2 spy plane is just a classic case of spy mission gone bad and as involvement was denied, strong retaliation other than counter-reconnaissance would have caused public defacement.

Vietnam along with all other wars in the cold war is a classic case of two bosses sending their “minions" against each other.

The Vietnam war was between north and south Vietnam however there were American forces in Vietnam in fact the Americans had such a presence that many saw it as a war between USA and north Vietnam on the side of north vietnam however there were a lot if soldiers and especially resources from the USSR.

The same happened with korea and a lot of these wars.

So yeah remember that the cold war is an ideological conflict wherein the Capitalist West under the leadership of USA fought against communist East under leadership of Ussr.

So the countries in the Western “free world" fought against the communist satellite states to limit the spread of communism and the communist satellite states fought to spread communism.

In conclusion no USA and USSR never directly fought as the USA vs the USSR, but they also did in that their soldiers faced each other in the ranks of the military forces representing their respective ideals.

Quora.
they v been fighting proxy wars using other countries as their battlefields hence destroying economies infrastructures etc of those countries
Re: Who Would Win In A War Between Russia And The US? by fortune1894(m):
franchasng:
lol, you guys are funny sha.


My cousin and childhood mate is a US Naval seal, currently posted in Japan.


Like one poster said, no country on earth can challenge USA in any war, US will win even a coalition of Russia, China, India, North Korea, Iran, EU, Africa. That's to tell you how strong they are.


US have ready to strike military bases in virtually all continents of the world.



And Nuclear weapon isn't the deadliest weapon right now. US military have been seriously researching on laser weapons for years now and will be unveiling laser weapons in 2023, the first in the history of human existence.



Russia only hurry to catch up on whatever weapon they learnt or heard US has. US leads, others follow.



A poster told you about extraterrestrial warfare outer space, that's the kind of war US have been preparing for not just earthly war or your Russia kind of mundane war.


Are you aware that NASA have been having contact with some extraterrestrial lives who have been trying to invade earth?


I once followed NASA and their extraterrestrial life researches and damn it, i became paranormal at some time.


Just in case you don't know, i founded a group some years back called Scientists For Africa Mission to Space and we had so many members from different countries including Russians. I became scared and backed out when I started receiving private messages from funny names on Google+ then.


There are things i won't reveal till death so i will stop here.



I just keep laughing at those funny Russia and Putin supporters mocking the US. They dont know sha.


Russia is no doubt a strong nation, but they are no match to uncle Sam.


Russia know this and that's why they get jittery whenever US gets close to their borders or waters.


The only saving grace we have in the world is that US don't usually have crazy, mad Presidents like Putin, if they ever have such a leader ready to unleash US might, the world is in big trouble
I stand to be corrected but I think the EU is the deadliest coalition n US cannot defeat them, Germany in it's prime will b very tough to crack, Germany spends little or nothing in it's military budget just the same with all these EU nations which Donald trump had an issue with, they use the US as their military police n they r also very tricky,a sniff of war with the US and watch how these countries will go into mass production of military hardware n seizure of US bases abroad n no fly zone for US military aircraft, believe me the US can't win that war.
Also remember any war the US involves itself with, it always find a way to get the support of the EU claiming strategic partners by so doing the US has the EU watching their back when they embark on such wars
NB
I read someone here claiming the US has 12 carriers,which truthfully is an advantage but remember during world war 2, Germany was faced with the wrath of the worlds navy but sank more than 70 percent of it's enemies war ships using just the submarine,thou US carriers have state of the art self defence mechanisms but it's big n an easy target on the sea, it can't sustain for long a barrage of missile n torpedo strikes, IT WILL BE SUNK INTO THE BOTTOM OF THE OCEAN, thats why the US always have a fleet of destroyers n fighter jets guiding it
THATS WHY MOST NATIONS DON'T INVEST MUCH ON CARRIERS
NB
Anyone with the notion that the US can't be invaded is wrong
The US is protected by the oceans by its wings which gives it an advantage but such can be neutralized by invading mexico Cuba n island nations like Hawaii n carribean islands scattered on its waters,bases can be created on many of such islands and military assults initiated from there.
When your time as a world power is up you step aside for the next world power to take over because even then mother nature will be working against you but till then the US presently remains the world power
1 2 3 Reply

SS-18 Satan: The Most Powerful ICBM Weapon In Russia And The World?The War Between Ss2 And Ss3 Student Is A Generational OneTwitter War Between Ambrose Ali University And Delta State University234

How To Check Your Oou Result Or If Checked What Is Your ScoreLinks To Scholarships For Africans, Universities Worldwide EtcUnizik Pre-degree Form