GMan650:


Oh yeah! You're right. But there's a theory on one of these youtube channels that Arya might be dead. The narrator explained that it made no sense as to why Jaqen will name Arya 'no-one' for killing the waif AFTER permitting the waif to go after Arya and kill her(punishing Arya for not killing the actress). So, he concluded that the waif might have killed Arya thereby using her face all this while and Jaqen was actually referring to the waif as no-one for killing Arya. The narrator also buttressed his point by claiming that a left-handed Arya suddenly became right-handed when she was paying for a cabin on her way back to Westeros and when she slashed Walder Frey. The explanation made me think that was probably why Nymeria didn't follow Arya when they saw each other.

All are conjectures tho as me no wan believe

Even though the thoery is quite convincing, I still believe is Arya BECAUSE when she takes someone's face, she takes totality of the person's physical attributes including the right handedness you pointed out... But can still be in control of her original memories and that's why they can REMEMBER to change back to their original face after taking someone's face for a mission

GMan650:


Oh yeah! You're right. But there's a theory on one of these youtube channels that Arya might be dead. The narrator explained that it made no sense as to why Jaqen will name Arya 'no-one' for killing the waif AFTER permitting the waif to go after Arya and kill her(punishing Arya for not killing the actress). So, he concluded that the waif might have killed Arya thereby using her face all this while and Jaqen was actually referring to the waif as no-one for killing Arya. The narrator also buttressed his point by claiming that a left-handed Arya suddenly became right-handed when she was paying for a cabin on her way back to Westeros and when she slashed Walder Frey. The explanation made me think that was probably why Nymeria didn't follow Arya when they saw each other.

All are conjectures tho as me no wan believe

What a theory... Sound really convincing, but i do not agree, at least not totally...

Lemme take you back to when the red woman met Arya, after revealing to her what she saw about her, told her they will meet again, their path is yet to be crossed.

About nymeria, she is now the alpha of a pack, she can't just leave that and continue being a pet, that's not who she is at least not anymore, very much like the owner, not domesticated.

Also, if arya is truly gone, then the waif has no business fighting arya's wars.

GMan650:


Oh yeah! You're right. But there's a theory on one of these youtube channels that Arya might be dead. The narrator explained that it made no sense as to why Jaqen will name Arya 'no-one' for killing the waif AFTER permitting the waif to go after Arya and kill her(punishing Arya for not killing the actress). So, he concluded that the waif might have killed Arya thereby using her face all this while and Jaqen was actually referring to the waif as no-one for killing Arya. The narrator also buttressed his point by claiming that a left-handed Arya suddenly became right-handed when she was paying for a cabin on her way back to Westeros and when she slashed Walder Frey. The explanation made me think that was probably why Nymeria didn't follow Arya when they saw each other.

All are conjectures tho as me no wan believe

If it was d Waif...Nymeria would have killed her...no cosmetic face can deceive her...it was Arya...and still remains Arya...and please how can she (Waif)wear Frey's face on top of Arya's...mmhmm..

GMan650:


Oh yeah! You're right. But there's a theory on one of these youtube channels that Arya might be dead. The narrator explained that it made no sense as to why Jaqen will name Arya 'no-one' for killing the waif AFTER permitting the waif to go after Arya and kill her(punishing Arya for not killing the actress). So, he concluded that the waif might have killed Arya thereby using her face all this while and Jaqen was actually referring to the waif as no-one for killing Arya. The narrator also buttressed his point by claiming that a left-handed Arya suddenly became right-handed when she was paying for a cabin on her way back to Westeros and when she slashed Walder Frey. The explanation made me think that was probably why Nymeria didn't follow Arya when they saw each other.

All are conjectures tho as me no wan believe

That theory is crap. Arya remains arya. The waif is dead for good! Why would the waif be fighting arya's battle? Why would d waif want to go to winterfell?

GMan650:


Oh yeah! You're right. But there's a theory on one of these youtube channels that Arya might be dead. The narrator explained that it made no sense as to why Jaqen will name Arya 'no-one' for killing the waif AFTER permitting the waif to go after Arya and kill her(punishing Arya for not killing the actress). So, he concluded that the waif might have killed Arya thereby using her face all this while and Jaqen was actually referring to the waif as no-one for killing Arya. The narrator also buttressed his point by claiming that a left-handed Arya suddenly became right-handed when she was paying for a cabin on her way back to Westeros and when she slashed Walder Frey. The explanation made me think that was probably why Nymeria didn't follow Arya when they saw each other.

All are conjectures tho as me no wan believe

After consuming expired brandy and smoking fake kush, people will now become game of thrones theorist.
If she's no-one, why;

1. Did she kill Walder Frey and household?
2. Ask Nymeria to follow her home?
3. Head home upon hearing that Jon is in winterfell?

If you say Arya is left-handed, which hand did she use to swing needle thereby putting off the light in the room when "waif" stood face to face with her in her hiding place?

Nymeria refused to follow Arya because she's still angry with her or she's now the big bad wolf in the forest and don't want to lose that by been a pet or some twisted wolfy reason...me thoughts sha

In conclusion, your guy's theory is horse-shit!

Chysler:



Even though the thoery is quite convincing, I still believe is Arya BECAUSE when she takes someone's face, she takes totality of the person's physical attributes including the right handedness you pointed out... But can still be in control of her original memories and that's why they can REMEMBER to change back to their original face after taking someone's face for a mission

Physical attributes but limited to the previous person's memories I guess

How some people go sit down dey compose theories they always burst my head




You're Shar looking for something that isn't lost

I just watched game of thrones season 7 episode 3 trailer nd it's badass. The war would be fought in episode 3, Jon snow will meet khakis . lastly cersei reject grejoy offer

Hello guys

JonSnow:
Hello guys

When next are you fighting

LannisterIMP:



What do we say to the god of death.

Not today

LannisterIMP:



Pls who is Tony Stark in GOT

Iron man in marvel comic

GMan650:


Oh yeah! You're right. But there's a theory on one of these youtube channels that Arya might be dead. The narrator explained that it made no sense as to why Jaqen will name Arya 'no-one' for killing the waif AFTER permitting the waif to go after Arya and kill her(punishing Arya for not killing the actress). So, he concluded that the waif might have killed Arya thereby using her face all this while and Jaqen was actually referring to the waif as no-one for killing Arya. The narrator also buttressed his point by claiming that a left-handed Arya suddenly became right-handed when she was paying for a cabin on her way back to Westeros and when she slashed Walder Frey. The explanation made me think that was probably why Nymeria didn't follow Arya when they saw each other.

All are conjectures tho as me no wan believe

There's nothing smart about the theory biko. ARYA IS ARYA as she has always been.
What was the last thing Arya said to Jaqen? A girl is Arya Stark and she's going home...that waif get home?
So that waif, a cleaner in one mortuary knows Hot Pie, knows the Freys,and the face to put on for Walder,plans to kill Queen Cersie,decides to go back to Winterfell on hearing about Jon,recognises and can name Nymeria.

Verdict: Some theories are mere waste of intelligence.

GMan650:


Oh yeah! You're right. But there's a theory on one of these youtube channels that Arya might be dead. The narrator explained that it made no sense as to why Jaqen will name Arya 'no-one' for killing the waif AFTER permitting the waif to go after Arya and kill her(punishing Arya for not killing the actress). So, he concluded that the waif might have killed Arya thereby using her face all this while and Jaqen was actually referring to the waif as no-one for killing Arya. The narrator also buttressed his point by claiming that a left-handed Arya suddenly became right-handed when she was paying for a cabin on her way back to Westeros and when she slashed Walder Frey. The explanation made me think that was probably why Nymeria didn't follow Arya when they saw each other.

All are conjectures tho as me no wan believe

Don't mind all those YouTube analyses jare. Not everything they analyze z true. Okk tell me do take peoples memories too after taken their face if it d Waif how did she knw it Nymeria in d first place how did she remember what his father said to her when she said she's gonna grow up nd become a knight (not me)which she also use on Nymeria when it decided not follow her. How did she knw about Hot Pie(that her fat friend she met at d taven)how did she knw about d people on d list. To mention a few

kay9:


*sad smile*
I know what you mean.


-------------------------

Queen Cersei
Ser Ilyn Payne
Ser Robert Strong
Petyr Baelish
Melisandre of the Shadow
Ellaria Sand
Daenerys Stormborn
Brandon Stark
Valar Morghulis. Amen.

Baba u like it or not Bran will not die in dx series. He has a bigger purpose than even Jon. Even if he was killed he has d power to transfer his consciousness into another person or animal.

GMan650:


Oh yeah! You're right. But there's a theory on one of these youtube channels that Arya might be dead. The narrator explained that it made no sense as to why Jaqen will name Arya 'no-one' for killing the waif AFTER permitting the waif to go after Arya and kill her(punishing Arya for not killing the actress). So, he concluded that the waif might have killed Arya thereby using her face all this while and Jaqen was actually referring to the waif as no-one for killing Arya. The narrator also buttressed his point by claiming that a left-handed Arya suddenly became right-handed when she was paying for a cabin on her way back to Westeros and when she slashed Walder Frey. The explanation made me think that was probably why Nymeria didn't follow Arya when they saw each other.

All are conjectures tho as me no wan believe

The show never established that Arya is left handed.
That's a book thing.
"I'm right-handed, and when Mom was
reading the first book, she told me
about Arya being left-handed," she says.
"From then on, I was like, 'Alright, I'm
going to try to do everything left-
handed.' When I was practicing out in
the garden and things I would do left-
handed just to feel that rhythm.
Unfortunately, when it came to filming,
sometimes I have to do things right-
handed because of the camera angle and
things like that. So some people are a
bit annoyed that Arya hasn't done
everything left-handed. I wanted to. I
really did. But sometimes it was just too
tricky and we couldn't do it."

kay9:

*sad smile* I know what you mean.

-------------------------
Queen Cersei Ser Ilyn Payne Ser Robert Strong Petyr Baelish Melisandre of the Shadow Ellaria Sand Daenerys Stormborn Brandon Stark Valar Morghulis. Amen.

.. .. all d pple u want dead?.. BTW whr is Ser Ilyn Payne.. ..

Skookum:


Don't mind all those YouTube analyses jare. Not everything they analyze z true. Okk tell me do take peoples memories too after taken their face if it d Waif how did she knw it Nymeria in d first place how did she remember what his father said to her when she said she's gonna grow up nd become a knight (not me)which she also use on Nymeria when it decided not follow her. How did she knw about Hot Pie(that her fat friend she met at d taven)how did she knw about d people on d list. To mention a few

Yes they take on their memories as well. It's all part of the glamour. They drink a potion before they put on a face. Not that i think the theory true.

Hands closed around her throat,
hard as stone, choking her. Her
own hands shot up to claw at
the arms of her attacker, but
there was no one there. A
terrible sense of fear filled her,
and she heard a noise, a
hideous crunching noise,
accompanied by blinding pain.
A face floated in front of her, fat,
bearded, brutal, his mouth
twisted with rage.

Arya seeing the memory of her first face.

dubylhover:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6JIGyEEUT0&feature=youtube_gdata_player


I think theon is a fvcking good actor...daennerys should really consider singing

..As Dany.. I rily dnt fancy her..
Bt as a personality (Emilia Clarke) I love her to bits..
her song was d dopest.. n d mannerisms was top notch.... Bomboklat!!!

[url]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJTmNqbQk1I [/url]


Just saw this very detailed narrative on YouTube check it out

hello, am new here. I noticed u guys were talking about the saddest and unexpected deaths.
For me the two deaths that touched me most were Hodor and Shireen(stannis baratheons daughter) burnt on a stake, i literally shed tears

Eberex:


There are questions though : like why murder king Frey and his household if she ain't Arya ? Are you saying when she wears Arya's face, her memories are also emboded in her new personality?

Well from how she recite those names before she sleeps is how to Invoke the faceless God to seek revenge on ones behalf.

So even if I agree to the Theory that Arya is not really Arya again her famous list will be taken care of *Massacre of the Freys is an Example*


According to how the faceless God works.

Fm4real06:

That theory is crap. Arya remains arya. The waif is dead for good! Why would the waif be fighting arya's battle? Why would d waif want to go to winterfell?

multicash:


What a theory... Sound really convincing, but i do not agree, at least not totally...

Lemme take you back to when the red woman met Arya, after revealing to her what she saw about her, told her they will meet again, their path is yet to be crossed.

About nymeria, she is now the alpha of a pack, she can't just leave that and continue being a pet, that's not who she is at least not anymore, very much like the owner, not domesticated.

Also, if arya is truly gone, then the waif has no business fighting arya's wars.

Eberex:


There are questions though : like why murder king Frey and his household if she ain't Arya ? Are you saying when she wears Arya's face, her memories are also emboded in her new personality?

You all should look back to when she was intraining. It's not only the change of face alone they are trained for to become no one. Also they have to voice out all of there past and things they have been through. So thats how the Faceless God is an excellent Assassin because all intel has been provided before it swings into action!

GMan650:


Oh yeah! You're right. But there's a theory on one of these youtube channels that Arya might be dead. The narrator explained that it made no sense as to why Jaqen will name Arya 'no-one' for killing the waif AFTER permitting the waif to go after Arya and kill her(punishing Arya for not killing the actress). So, he concluded that the waif might have killed Arya thereby using her face all this while and Jaqen was actually referring to the waif as no-one for killing Arya. The narrator also buttressed his point by claiming that a left-handed Arya suddenly became right-handed when she was paying for a cabin on her way back to Westeros and when she slashed Walder Frey. The explanation made me think that was probably why Nymeria didn't follow Arya when they saw each other.

All are conjectures tho as me no wan believe

Nymeria didn't follow Arya because she's now literally wild. She has a pack depending on her and probably a territory to defend.

That doesn't mean she won't trail Arya in subsequent episodes to see what she's really up to.

And why would the waif bother about avenging Arya's family?

And how did the Waif's face end up on the wall of faces in the House of Black and White if she killed Arya and slipped on Arya's face?

I think Masie Williams is ambidextrous in real life.

Gbola5:


Yes they take on their memories as well. It's all part of the glamour. They drink a potion before they put on a face. Not that i think the theory true.

Hands closed around her throat,
hard as stone, choking her. Her
own hands shot up to claw at
the arms of her attacker, but
there was no one there. A
terrible sense of fear filled her,
and she heard a noise, a
hideous crunching noise,
accompanied by blinding pain.
A face floated in front of her, fat,
bearded, brutal, his mouth
twisted with rage.

Arya seeing the memory of her first face.

That is in d book. There are some things in the book nd not portrayed in d movie. Like Jon is a warg in d book but so far not yet a warg in d series . Also it not metioned in d movie if they take memories too after taking face

LannisterIMP:


Well from how she recite those names before she sleeps is how to Invoke the faceless God to seek revenge on ones behalf.

So even if I agree to the Theory that Arya is not really Arya again her famous list will be taken care of *Massacre of the Freys is an Example*


According to how the faceless God works.




You all should look back to when she was intraining. It's not only the change of face alone they are trained for to become no one. Also they have to voice out all of there past and things they have been through. So thats how the Faceless God is an excellent Assassin because all intel has been provided before it swings into action!

So u also believe this theoey??

Coyotejack:
[url]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJTmNqbQk1I [/url]


Just saw this very detailed narrative on YouTube check it out

I ain't clicking. Thank you

Coyotejack:
[url]
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJTmNqbQk1I [/url]


Just saw this very detailed narrative on YouTube check it out

This is more than a detailed narrative. . . . .it just spoiled an entire episode.

If everything there is really true, then I weep for Dany.

LannisterIMP:


It's not only the change of face alone they are trained for to become no one. Also they have to voice out all of there past and things they have been through. So thats how the Faceless God is an excellent Assassin because all intel has been provided before it swings into action!

The theory didn't explain The Waif's face on the Wall of Faces.

JhyMedex:
..As Dany.. I rily dnt fancy her..
Bt as a personality (Emilia Clarke) I love her to bits..
her song was d dopest.. n d mannerisms was top notch.... Bomboklat!!!

yea her Rastafarian vibes was dope

Okay I think I need to avoid this thread until the next episode. See y'all Monday/Tuesday.

Spoilers abound!

GMan650:


Oh yeah! You're right. But there's a theory on one of these youtube channels that Arya might be dead. The narrator explained that it made no sense as to why Jaqen will name Arya 'no-one' for killing the waif AFTER permitting the waif to go after Arya and kill her(punishing Arya for not killing the actress). So, he concluded that the waif might have killed Arya thereby using her face all this while and Jaqen was actually referring to the waif as no-one for killing Arya. The narrator also buttressed his point by claiming that a left-handed Arya suddenly became right-handed when she was paying for a cabin on her way back to Westeros and when she slashed Walder Frey. The explanation made me think that was probably why Nymeria didn't follow Arya when they saw each other.

All are conjectures tho as me no wan believe

As theories go, this is not the most farfetched one I've seen, but the circumstantial evidence given for this narrative is weak.
Firstly on being no one you change faces only to change identity and I'm unsure whether a change of face automatically trans-mutates the physique into that of the face owner and i believe, not know for sure that there's a strong argument for that. Changing faces is like drawing art on an empty board piece i.e, there has to be a board piece! So for the waif to actually be arya, she has to have cut out her own face first before cutting out arya's and wearing it.
And on killing walder Frey with her right hand, i have to watch that scene again but I'll believe it is because it was more convenient because of where she was standing in relation to the position walder Frey was sitting.
And circumstantial evidence to prove arya isn't the waif is that she was extremely relieved and Happy to hear that the starks had winterfell and Jon was king in the north that she let go her vendetta and chose to go home because why faceless men might duplicate the memory and character of a face they wear, they don't duplicate their agendas, their agenda remains their own!

feelgoodInc:


What about Tony stark, the stark family need Tony stark now than ever, I believe. :-)

idiata!