Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. - Christianity Etc (5) - Nairaland
Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Christianity Etc › Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. (13134 Views)
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 3:04pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
Ferisidowu:how early are you willing to go? |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 3:07pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
Splinz:this mean you disagree with Calvin |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 3:19pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
menxer:actually Calvin was excommunicated for this doctrines |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Nobody: 3:52pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
Ubenedictus:on a debate? |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by An2elect2(op): 3:53pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
Ferisidowu:I am so happy for you brother. Natural man cannot grasp these doctrines that give us comfort because that would make God seem wicked to them. It has to be those whom He has chosen to grant the things of the Kingdom and whose hearts have been changed that would understand and be consoled. Amen. Saving faith is so different from simple faith. I even opened a thread about it one time. It is saving faith that produces righteous works. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Nobody: 4:01pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
An2elect2:yes, at first glance, it looked as if God's wicked, but then when a saw 1) he made man for himself 2) he made man for HIS GLORY 3) SATAN NRVER DESTROYED GOD'S DECREE IN THE FALL, HE EVEN PUSHED IT FURTHER Saving faith is something great, it's a very big topic.... it proves that Faith is an EVIDENCE OF THINGS EVEN A SUBSTANCE A SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE OF GOD ..... Bro just try read that book called faith by A.W pink you'd love it.... that's why I laugh when atheist think that Christianity is foolish.... there's no one as wise a graced Christian...... they are the wisest .. may God continually help us... have you ever been a charismatic or Pentecostal ....? |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by An2elect2(op): 4:19pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
Ferisidowu:Yeah those 1-3 points are very correct. People would not argue against God's sovereignty and election if they centred their argument around God and His glory. But man is too full of himself. Faith by A W Pink. I will add it to my list. I hope I read it soon. Atheists? I just pray for them now. I was a sceptic too before God saved me by the power of the Gospel. I'd never know why He did but I know it had nothing to do with me because like everyone I wasn't born seeking for Him. But God changed everything. I was a Catholic before my salvation and a legionary. But after I got born again I aligned more with the Catholic charismatics. They made me stay for a while. That was about 5yrs ago. I'm a sis. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Nobody: 4:35pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
An2elect2:wow, well it's obvious that there's nothing God can't do... he won't have men boast before him... I'm sure all elect are humble beings ... God will always make them Know That they weren't saved by their works even by their faith... I was surprised when I was allowed by God's Providence to study the covenant that he made concerning Solomon to David..... how he promised to be father to him despite his short-comings .... there's something with the elect.. "THEY ALL ENJOY COVENANT OF SONSHIP" I don't value alter calls again... since pastors now use it to display their pride, thinking that the elect are born out man's will..... may God help us continually expound his words amen.. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by An2elect2(op): 5:18pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
Ferisidowu:It's true. God will always bring us to the knowledge of the truth. Because of the new hearts given us, we would humbly accept the fact that salvation is of God. Like a child we just want to know that our Father is in charge and rest. Him taking all the praise gives us delight... Yeah our shortcomings. We fall and fail so many many times. Sometimes as if we are lost again. But God never let's go. That assurance just gives me peace and makes me cry. To know God has completely forgiven me of all my sins. What mercy. What grace. What peace that we can never earn! Altar calls. Lol they are no good. Most times the sermon you hear from the pulpit does not open the heart. Why call for it. People don't get saved at altars but in their hearts and after that they confess it. And all this according to God's sovereign will and time. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Nobody: 5:33pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
An2elect2:that's true .... thanks a lot,... it brings comfort to have believing friends who believes in God's absolute sovereignty..... nice meeting you dear... I'm sure you know 5solas |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by An2elect2(op): 5:36pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
Ferisidowu:O yes I'm even following him. One of the first people I got to know here. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Nobody: 5:37pm On Jan 10, 2018 |
An2elect2: alright .. peace |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 7:55am On Jan 11, 2018 |
5solas:this is why I asked u guys that if you wish to study historic Christian teaching then you much be ready to go as far back as the 1 century AD not just stop in the 15th century. the pelagian and semi-pelegians weren't even the arminians, the pelagian heresy was propagated in the 4th century AD and was immediately condemned by the Church for teaching a work based righteousness, in fact the 4th century bishop Augustine wrote a lot of books to combat this heresy YET throughout that time nobody taught anything like the double predestination of John Calvin that makes God the author of moral evil in every sinner. your so-called correct interpretation is actually an invention, a novum concocted by John Calvin. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 7:56am On Jan 11, 2018 |
Splinz:that mean you guys reject double predestination... |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 7:59am On Jan 11, 2018 |
An2elect2:the book you are quoting is a Calvinist book that teaches double predestination. that means God predestined some people to heaven irrespective of the sins they commit and God predestined some to hell fire irrespective of their faith. it is called unconditional double predestination. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by plainbibletruth: 8:38am On Jan 11, 2018 |
A major issue that needs to be placed in focus is the JUSTICE of God. God cannot compromise any part of his essence. Therefore ANY stand taken on this issue that does not stand against the JUSTICE of God would need to be re-examined. It would either be a wrong understanding or a wrong interpretation of Scripture. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by MuttleyLaff: 8:46am On Jan 11, 2018*. Modified: 9:30pm On Jan 11, 2018 |
JMAN05:Are you saying God doesn't use the Omniscient ability always? Are you saying God is not always in the know? Are you saying God all the time is not in the knowledge of every thing, thought, action deed etcetera? Excuse my asking the same question thrice over in different words. Have to be sure I am understanding your stance JMAN05:How did you arrive at the conclusion emboldened? JMAN05:Not. No one is acting out a role. No one is cloned to perform. It means, when a wheel falls off a bicycle, you leave it, until it falters, it's after that and when the needful concerning it gets done |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 9:01am On Jan 11, 2018 |
An2elect2:wow an ex Catholic in reformed theology... do you know what happened when Calvin first invented this doctrine? let me ask you about your views on baptism, is it the same with that of the reformers. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 9:10am On Jan 11, 2018 |
Ferisidowu:no dear, I don't know if you have noticed but I actually naturally hate debate, I do them not because I like them but inspite of the fact that I hate them. my question is simple, if you believe that what you are teaching here is truly historic Christian teaching, then how far is this historic, is it just from the 15th century? how far back are you willing to go. I even heard 5solas adding Augustine to the list of his 15 century guys, will he be open to reviewing if anyone actually taught this teaching? is this really historic Christian teaching or is it really a 15 th century invention? I say it was an invention that was in fact immediately condemned when it was propounded. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 9:14am On Jan 11, 2018 |
Ferisidowu:even the early theologians teach free will. the bondage of the will was a book by martin Luther in the 16 th century. and Martin Luther wasn't an early theologian, he was a medieval theologian whose theology was condemned as the invention it was and thus heresy. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 9:16am On Jan 11, 2018 |
Ferisidowu:how to we know the elect? |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 9:18am On Jan 11, 2018 |
An2elect2:check out a few Baptist, they are the closest to reformed theology you have around.. Luther isn't considered in reformed theology, so that rules out Lutherans |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 9:39am On Jan 11, 2018 |
5solas:it seems you are even confused too about what Catholic believe, Catholics also teach predestination, in fact the reformer borrowed a lot from Catholic theology including the teachings of Augustine. the problem isn't the fact that God since the beginning of the world has decreed those for eternal life and thus by grace has justified, sanctified and glorified them....Catholics teach that, in fact Calvin borrowed that part. I.e election the problem is that Calvin also taught that God for all eternity chose some other people to go to hell and specifically damned them I.e reprobation, Calvin believed that Jesus didn't die for all he only died for those predestined for heaven, Catholics teach that the death of Jesus is superabundant and enough to save every body. because Calvin believed Jesus didn't die for all he taught that only the elect can receive grace, this means God is responsible for their evils since he never gives them grace for they are damned. God is thus responsible for their evil. Catholics teach that Jesus died for all and that his death is efficacious for some but God give sufficient grace to those who will go to hell they just reject it. the problem is that Catholics were teaching predestination while Calvin was teaching double unconditional predestination which made God guilty of evil. that is why Calvin was condemned as a heretic because he had overstretched the true doctrine and bent it. there are 3 branches of theology today that is called Christian. 1. Catholic 2. Orthodox. 3. Protestant. most times Orthodox and Catholic doctrine are reconcilable but not Protestant. Protestant theology is divided into Lutheran, reformed, aminian, new age and others, |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 9:52am On Jan 11, 2018 |
5solas:the view that salvation can be lost was there, the Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church was teaching it even Luther taught that a believer could lose his faith and salvation... Calvin went further than that and Arminius rejected Calvin, so yes Calvin's teaching was new. since according to you, you seem to know what the reformer taught, do you agree with Luther and Calvin on baptism? |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 10:01am On Jan 11, 2018 |
Scholar8200:good questions |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 10:02am On Jan 11, 2018 |
An2elect2:did you consider his teaching on baptism? |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 10:09am On Jan 11, 2018 |
An2elect2:I bolded a part of the Westminster catechism that says God does no injury to the will of his creatures... that right there is your catechism teaching Free will. God doesn't force us into grace, do you know Calvin taught irrestitable grace? |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 10:17am On Jan 11, 2018 |
An2elect2:there is no contradiction if the reward isn't based on merit but on promise. |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Nobody: 1:37pm On Jan 11, 2018 |
I don't know why this seem hard for you to understand.... neither am I going to rack my head just to start teaching you.... I didn't start with this thread so I don't know what op put down yet I'm sure even without starting with the thread that what the op is teaching about is GOD'S SOVEREIGNTY ... I don't discard free will .. yet I know it's nothing since .. . it's GOD'S PROVIDENCE THAT SHAPES OUR DESTINY ... (which you can't deny) but seeing you are a willing Brother ... I will try create a thread (when am free) so we would discuss this.. HUMAN free will is in bondage either you agree or not ... humans can't do good to God's satisfaction... although humans don't believe that they are completely bad, useless, worthless, ... yet in God's sight they ALL ARE they think themselves to be good, at least humans can do good works, can choose not to steal ryt... even a lot have died in their self righteousness thinking they would make it to heaven... but I know that if anyone make it to heaven by his works both in AD and BC then Christ died in vain |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Nobody: 1:42pm On Jan 11, 2018 |
ubenedictus it's true that humans have free will.... yet even their free will is 1) limited 2) in bondage you asked a question about elect... the elect are the who are called spiritually and follow Christ... (when I say spiritually I don't mean that they had dreams or visions oooo) I mean the effectual fervent call of the SPIRIT to worship and live for God in Jesus Christ Also human free will will always be inside God's unchanged decree |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 3:46pm On Jan 11, 2018 |
Ferisidowu:the fact that freewill is limited is true, it is taught by both the Catholic and the Orthodox Church... Augustine teaches the same... in fact that limitation has a name it is called concupiscence. the sin of Adam limited our will so much that we cannot do anything good by ourselves without grace. if grace is given then we can now be inspired to do good. but Calvin went further... he taught that the will is dead so Calvinist teach that man needs irresistible grace t Ferisidowu:the fact that freewill is limited is true, it is taught by both the Catholic and the Orthodox Church... Augustine teaches the same... in fact that limitation has a name it is called concupiscence. the sin of Adam limited our will so much that we cannot do anything good by ourselves without grace. if grace is given then we can now be inspired to do good. but Calvin went further... he taught that the will is dead so Calvinist teach that man needs irresistible grace t Ferisidowu:the fact that freewill is limited is true, it is taught by both the Catholic and the Orthodox Church... Augustine teaches the same... in fact that limitation has to name it is called concupiscence. the sin of Adam limited our will so much that we cannot do anything good by ourselves without grace. if grace is given then we can now be inspired to do good. but Calvin went further... he taught that the will is dead so Calvinist teach that man needs irresistible grace to make man do good. they teach man had to be regenerated before he can even believe. I know who the "elect" are by definition. my question is more like are you one of the elect? |
| Re: Historical Facts! Freewillism Existed For Centuries As A Heresy. by Ubenedictus(m): 3:52pm On Jan 11, 2018 |
Ferisidowu:the weakness of man and his inability to do any good by himself isn't hard for me to understand, it is a fact. what I disagree with is that human will is dead and so man needs irresistible grace, what I disagree with is the teaching that God damned some people for all eternity and simply refused to give them any grace so that they will be bad and damned. I reject the teaching of double unconditional predestination |
'forbidding To Marry' Is A Heresy Ofthe Roman Catholic Church Rooted In Paganism • The Moody Heresy: The Biggest Lie In Christianity! • Tomb Of Christ Opened For The First Time In Centuries • 2 • 3 • 4
Beware: Men Who Mocked God • Secret Sins & Consequences • Catholic Priest, Gabriel Osu Is Dead

alright .. peace