₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,119 members, 8,521,210 topics. Date: Thursday, 19 November 2026 at 05:17 AM

Toggle theme

Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife - Culture (45) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum › Nairaland General › Culture › Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife (78796 Views)

1 2 3 ... 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 ... 52 Reply (Go Down)

Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by samuk: 9:57pm On Apr 20, 2020
IDENNAA:
Like I told you , people who share borders have a high rate to exchange cultural ideas. If your people were so numerous and influential we would have seen that in your region. All we see are borrowed traditions.

You want to believe Zik's story so quickly but you conveniently ignored the accounts of appointed anthropologists who documented the what they observed and were told when they arrived the Niger.

Didn't your Oba borrow cassock from the Portuguese?
Another archeological and anthropological kind of history, did you guys planned it. I beg, make I find something better to do.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by IDENNAA(m): 10:16pm On Apr 20, 2020
samuk:
And yet you accused Osagyefo98 of writing gibberish.

The truth is the highest ranking Igbo traditional ruler is the Obi of Onitsha, whether you admit that he is a Benin descendant or a returnee refugee from Benin as you would like to believe.
Obi of Onicha will never break kola before Eze Nri , Igwe Orizu, or even Eze Uzu. However, he is the most politically disposed traditional ruler. Obi Achebe knows this. When Anambra people gather Onicha men keep low profile....I am sure you don't know this. You must think Onicha people had some elevated status...lol


Onicha people lived in the area known Midwest and researchers could prove the location. However, they have tonns of relatives in Anioma and we can use them as historical markers.

Nothing ever suggested Onicha people were speaking Bini at some point in their existence....nothing. They and Aboh people were the first Igbo encountered by the White explorers....lol
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by IDENNAA(m): 10:22pm On Apr 20, 2020
gregyboy:
Lol, i heard this before from an igbo guy but i ignored him


I just want to say something we have islamic calender, roman calender
If the igbo introduced this calender to us in the early nigeria

How did we know eken day( the days reserved for the spirit) in Olds, how we know when to celebrate igue during every end if the year


Benins in ancient times always had thier market days and i dont think it was something particularly to igbo or benins alone but every west africa tribe.......

Because nollywood made it know doesn't change the fact that it is indigenous to the world


If you go to ghana and say shit like this them go comot your teeth
Bini had no days of week before the whites arrived and this much was documented. I cant find the link....Your historians know this.

Not trying to brag , but Nri know the days of the days, months and years.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by gregyboy(m): 10:24pm On Apr 20, 2020
IDENNAA:
Bini had no days of week before the whites arrived and this much was documented. I cant find the link....Your historians know this.

Not trying to brag , but Nri know the days of the days, months and years.
Find it am waiting.....

You have to prove your point because if not they will be regarded as mere claims
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by samuk: 10:30pm On Apr 20, 2020
IDENNAA:
Obi of Onicha will never break kola before Eze Nri , Igwe Orizu, or even Eze Uzu. However, he is the most politically disposed traditional ruler. Obi Achebe knows this. When Anambra people gather Onicha men keep low profile....I am sure you don't know this. You must think Onicha people had some elevated status...lol


Onicha people lived in the area known Midwest and researchers could prove the location. However, they have tonns of relatives in Anioma and we can use them as historical markers.

Nothing ever suggested Onicha people were speaking Bini at some point in their existence....nothing. They and Aboh people were the first Igbo encountered by the White explorers....lol
Okay, I get it, you are saying that Onitsha people are mid Westerners who migrated into Anambra state and keep a low profile when the real indigines are gathered and their Obi will never break kola when some Ezes are present and Zik and his grandmother didn't know what they were saying when they claimed to have come from Benin.

Who can argue with a man of knowledge like you that is more smarter, cleverer and knowledgeable than Zik and his grandmother put together.

Case closed then, we can all go and rest now.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by gregyboy(m): 10:59pm On Apr 20, 2020
samuk:
Okay, I get it, you are saying that Onitsha people are mid Westerners who migrated into Anambra state and keep a low profile when the real indigines are gathered and their Obi will never break kola when some Ezes are present and Zik and his grandmother didn't know what they were saying when they claimed to have come from Benin.

Who can argue with a man of knowledge like you that is more smarter, cleverer and knowledgeable than Zik and his grandmother put together.

Case closed then, we can all go and rest now.
I think he saw my map and read my post
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by IDENNAA(m): 11:39pm On Apr 20, 2020
samuk:
Okay, I get it, you are saying that Onitsha people are mid Westerners who migrated into Anambra state and keep a low profile when the real indigines are gathered and their Obi will never break kola when some Ezes are present and Zik and his grandmother didn't know what they were saying when they claimed to have come from Benin.

Who can argue with a man of knowledge like you that is more smarter, cleverer and knowledgeable than Zik and his grandmother put together.

Case closed then, we can all go and rest now.
Bini people do not own midwest....Igbo settlements in midwest far out number Bini settlements.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by IDENNAA(m): 11:42pm On Apr 20, 2020
gregyboy:
I think he saw my map and read my post
I have seen many maps and I don't understand your lame point. Abeg , come up with an argument that could hold water....grasping at straws

Let it go, guys...you cant win this!!
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by davidnazee: 12:53am On Apr 21, 2020
gregyboy:
I think he saw my map and read my post
Have you read the autobiography of Olaudah Equiano? He is the first Igbo man to read and write in the 17th century. He was a former slave who after gaining his freedom got an education and was one of the first people to start the abolition of slavery.
In his book he wrote that he was born in Essaka which is around Anambra and that his place was part of Benin Kingdom and they were ruled by the Oba of Benin.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by gregyboy(m): 1:23am On Apr 21, 2020
davidnazee:
Have you read the autobiography of Olaudah Equiano? He is the first Igbo man to read and write in the 17th century. He was a former slave who after gaining his freedom got an education and was one of the first people to start the abolition of slavery.
In his book he wrote that he was born in Essaka which is around Anambra and that his place was part of Benin Kingdom and they were ruled by the Oba of Benin.
Quote the book.....

It will be nice to read
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by davidnazee: 1:42am On Apr 21, 2020
gregyboy:
Quote the book.....

It will be nice to read
I'm looking for it. hold on
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by davidnazee: 1:50am On Apr 21, 2020
gregyboy:
Quote the book.....

It will be nice to read
Here’s a screenshot from his book. You can read about him and his work on jstor.

Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by samuk:
davidnazee:
Here’s a screenshot from his book. You can read about him and his work on jstor.
In today Nigeria, the Westerners and easterners equate population size to great historical achievements, which is the reason they keep referring to the size of Benin in their arguments and those amongst them that should know better are blinded by bigotry.

Most Yoruba can not tell you their real/Ife history ealier than 1930, if you push them further, you may be lucky to get as far back as 1850, anything beyond that, they will need the aids of archeologists and anthropologists to start explaining myths as history.

Most Igbo are even worse than the Yoruba, majority of them don't know their history beyond 1966, you push them further, you may get to 1914 and anything earlier, they start to call on archeologists and anthropologists.

The Yoruba started their Oduduwa republic with the Ife myth while the Igbo are using Nri for their Biafra. Yoruba wants to erase every town and city in Yoruba land that had Benin influence and replace them with Ife, everybody in Yoruba land are suddenly now from Ife including those whose history predates Ife by centuries.

The Igbo who would also like to replace all Benin influenced kingdoms in south south and south east with their Biafra project are having even tougher times than the Yoruba. How would you expect the Obi of Agbor to recognise any Eze in south east as his superior.

Unfortunately for both east and west, Benin history is written, not just oral, legends and myths. They can be referenced.

You have just referenced Olaudah Equiano book that was written in late 1700s and it puts the heart of Igbo land firmly under the control of Benin kingdom.

They would like to rubbish Zik for his autobiography, what about Olaudah. These guys think history are made up stuffs, history is created.

You don't just wake up and pronounce greatness on your self, you create it.

The Yoruba and Igbo are having same problems, they want to tell all sorts of stories as history, when you challenge them to produce concrete eyewitness written accounts as evidence, they start calling on the works of archeologists and anthropologists for interpretations, which are merely opinions of those individual experts.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by gregyboy(m): 8:56am On Apr 21, 2020
samuk:
In today Nigeria, the Westerners and easterners equate population size to great historical achievements, which is the reason they keep referring to the size of Benin in their arguments and those amongst them that should know better are blinded by bigotry.

Most Yoruba can not tell you their real/Ife history ealier than 1930, if you push them further, you may be lucky to get as far back as 1850, anything beyond that, they will need the aids of archeologists and anthropologists to start explaining myths as history.

Most Igbo are even worse than the Yoruba, majority of them don't know their history beyond 1966, you push them further, you may get to 1914 and anything earlier, they start to call on archeologists and anthropologists.

The Yoruba started their Oduduwa republic with the Ife myth while the Igbo are using Nri for their Biafra. Yoruba wants to erase every town and city in Yoruba land that had Benin influence with Ife, everybody in Yoruba land are suddenly now from Ife including those whose history predates Ife by centuries.

The Igbo who would also like to replace all Benin influenced kingdoms in south south and south east with their Biafra project are having even tougher times than the Yoruba. How would you expect the Obi of Agbor to recognise any Eze in south east as his superior.

Unfortunately for both east and west, Benin history is written, not just oral, legends and myths. They can be referenced.

You have just referenced Olaudah Equiano book that was written in late 1700s and it puts the heart of Igbo land firmly under the control of Benin kingdom.

They would like to rubbish Zik for his autobiography, what about Olaudah. These guys think history are made up stuffs, history is created.

You don't just wake up and pronounce greatness on your self, you create it.

The Yoruba and Igbo are having same problems, they want to tell all sorts of stories as history, when you challenge them of concrete eyewitness written accounts, they start calling on the works of archeologists and anthropologists for interpretations which are merely opinions of those individual experts.
Many yorubas are calling me winch because am saying the truth of Oduduwa the Oduduwa
They forgot they were the ones who were constantly pushing benin every time nearer to the truth, some even brought articles to our disposal
To read some even told the truth to our face
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by Edeyoung: 11:17am On Apr 21, 2020
Now i know why the story was always not adding up if only our traditional rulers will come out openly to tell us the truth.....
The truth is some truth can be told you just havd to fiquare and when you do it becomes dangerous
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by Nobody: 12:35pm On Apr 21, 2020
samuk:
In today Nigeria, the Westerners and easterners equate population size to great historical achievements, which is the reason they keep referring to the size of Benin in their arguments and those amongst them that should know better are blinded by bigotry.

Most Yoruba can not tell you their real/Ife history ealier than 1930, if you push them further, you may be lucky to get as far back as 1850, anything beyond that, they will need the aids of archeologists and anthropologists to start explaining myths as history.

Most Igbo are even worse than the Yoruba, majority of them don't know their history beyond 1966, you push them further, you may get to 1914 and anything earlier, they start to call on archeologists and anthropologists.

The Yoruba started their Oduduwa republic with the Ife myth while the Igbo are using Nri for their Biafra. Yoruba wants to erase every town and city in Yoruba land that had Benin influence with Ife, everybody in Yoruba land are suddenly now from Ife including those whose history predates Ife by centuries.

The Igbo who would also like to replace all Benin influenced kingdoms in south south and south east with their Biafra project are having even tougher times than the Yoruba. How would you expect the Obi of Agbor to recognise any Eze in south east as his superior.

Unfortunately for both east and west, Benin history is written, not just oral, legends and myths. They can be referenced.

You have just referenced Olaudah Equiano book that was written in late 1700s and it puts the heart of Igbo land firmly under the control of Benin kingdom.

They would like to rubbish Zik for his autobiography, what about Olaudah. These guys think history are made up stuffs, history is created.

You don't just wake up and pronounce greatness on your self, you create it.

The Yoruba and Igbo are having same problems, they want to tell all sorts of stories as history, when you challenge them to produce concrete eyewitness written accounts as evidence, they start calling on the works of archeologists and anthropologists for interpretations, which are merely opinions of those individual experts.
Nicely written, you make the Edo people proud by speaking with wisdom, logics and facts. Well done.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by Nobody: 12:36pm On Apr 21, 2020
davidnazee:
Here’s a screenshot from his book. You can read about him and his work on jstor.
Nicely done, I am proud of you guys.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by samuk:
Nicely written, you make the Edo people proud by speaking with wisdom, logics and facts. Well done.
Thanks, at times you just have to break it down in the language they can understand and can hardly argue with without ridiculing and making themselves look stupid.

They run into the thread with insults and when you break it down to them, the sensible ones leave without a fight.

The guy argued that what Zik wrote was a fabrication from his uneducated grandmother.

What about Olaudah that was an eyewitness to the events he wrote about in the 1700s.

What did Zik stands to gain to fabricate his history in retirement after achieving everything achievable in life.

Some of them are just too ignorant.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by davidnazee: 2:40pm On Apr 21, 2020
samuk:
Thanks, at times you just have to break it down in the language they can understand and can hardly argue with without ridiculing and making themselves look stupid.

They run into the thread with insults and when you break it down to them, the sensible ones leave without a fight.

The guy argued that what Zik wrote was a fabrication from his uneducated grandmother.

What about Olaudah that was a eyewitness to the events he wrote about in the 1700s.

What did Zik stands to gain to fabricate his history in retirement after achieving everything achievable in life.

Some of them are just too ignorant.
I don’t believe the problem is Yoruba, Igbo or Edos.. The problem began with the foreign historians who wrote rubbish history and handed it to us to fight over..
The first time the story of Oduduwa/Oranmiyan/Eweka was heard and documented was in the 1930s by Talbot. Few years after, Binis pushed back and gave their own account to established an unbroken link between the ogiso and oba dynasties.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by Edeyoung: 2:57pm On Apr 21, 2020
davidnazee:
I don’t believe the problem is Yoruba, Igbo or Edos.. The problem began with the foreign historians who wrote rubbish history and handed it to us to fight over..
The first time the story of Oduduwa/Oranmiyan/Eweka was heard and documented was in the 1930s by Talbot. Few years after, Binis pushed back and gave their own account to established an unbroken link between the ogiso and oba dynasties.
I believe there was never ogiso it was oba throughout
Benins never mentioned anything of such to the white how come in the 30s ogiso came up


I believe ogiso was another fictious character to potray the ekaladeran myth

I believe it was always oba through out

Oba owodo banished ekaladeran were he later seeked refuse in ughoton and died

Ogiso were made up shit

Itsekiri gave the name ile binu

Ekaladeran died at ughoton

Oba is indigenous title to edo


Can our monarch stop playing this political game and come out clean
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by IDENNAA(m): 4:20pm On Apr 21, 2020
davidnazee:
Have you read the autobiography of Olaudah Equiano? He is the first Igbo man to read and write in the 17th century. He was a former slave who after gaining his freedom got an education and was one of the first people to start the abolition of slavery.
In his book he wrote that he was born in Essaka which is around Anambra and that his place was part of Benin Kingdom and they were ruled by the Oba of Benin.
Now, you want to take what Olauda said but disregard the account that puts your Oba beneath a king from the east...you guys are too danm funny
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by davidnazee: 4:58pm On Apr 21, 2020
IDENNAA:
Now, you want to take what Olauda said but disregard the account that puts your Oba beneath a king from the east...you guys are too danm funny
The account that puts the Oba beneath a king from the east was narrated by who?
Olaudah is an Igbo man who wrote what he witnessed.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by gregyboy(m): 5:29pm On Apr 21, 2020
IDENNAA:
Now, you want to take what Olauda said but disregard the account that puts your Oba beneath a king from the east...you guys are too danm funny
Oghene from the east is still unknown talking about the location......

No one ogene never ruling benin

What we are saying ogene is not ife probably nupe, or Zimbabe or even a myth. but benin never had any connections with them
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by IDENNAA(m): 6:16pm On Apr 21, 2020
gregyboy:
Oghene from the east is still unknown talking about the location......

No one ogene never ruling benin

What we are saying ogene is not ife probably nupe, or Zimbabe or even a myth. but benin never had any connections with them
Your own chief submitted a superior king from the east exist that your Oba pay himage to...do you believe this or not ? If not, why did you accept Zik's account ?
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by gregyboy(m): 7:06pm On Apr 21, 2020
IDENNAA:
Your own chief submitted a superior king from the east exist that your Oba pay himage to...do you believe this or not ? If not, why did you accept Zik's account ?
I believe it but scholars are yet to identify the location of oghe
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by TerraCotta(m):
I’ll try to keep this short so it’s not an intimidating read but hopefully this will help dispel some of the falsehoods and misunderstandings I’m seeing on this thread.

There seems to be some confusion about what constitutes “history” and why archaeology and anthropology are key to our understanding of the African and global past, even with cultures that have thousands of years of “written” history.

The word “archaeology” quite literally means “ancient history” in Greek (from arkhaios = “old, ancient”; logos = “words, study”) but is defined as “the study of human history and prehistory through the excavation of sites and the analysis of artifacts and other physical remains.”

It’s quite acceptable as evidence of past events and is often the sole means of determining the events of evolution of “prehistory”. In some cases, archaeology may supersede or provide more trustworthy evidence than written chronicles, which can clearly be incomplete. This is obvious from examples in European or Asian history, where archaeologists recovered the sites of ancient Troy and Crete or the Chinese “Terracotta Army” of China’s first emperor on the basis of oral traditions, despite not being fully identified by written records alone. Obviously we have no written records for the period of human evolution or when dinosaurs roamed the earth, so archaeology (or paleontology) is the key discipline in investigating those eras.

I don’t know of any serious historian in the world that would discount archaeology or anthropology and their value in helping us fill in the (very large) gaps in the written record anywhere in the world, in any period and for any group. Two short examples should demonstrate this clearly:

A) A few weeks ago, an archaeological report added significant new information to what we know about London’s past, suggesting it’s 3000 years older than previously believed : https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/archaeology/london-history-prehistoric-ceremony-site-archaeology-a9455621.html

B) Last year, other archaeologists look at material evidence from the Woodstock concert in 1969, and found contradictions with the eyewitness recollections of an event that happened just 50 years ago, with living attendees: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/archaeologists-find-woodstock-really-did-take-life-its-own-180972504/

These disciplines are even more important in places like the vast majority of Africa, where there are very few indigenous written languages and records (although more are still being identified) and only slightly more written observations from foreign visitors.

Archaeology is actually just one branch of the larger science of anthropology. This field includes the disciplines of biological or physical anthropology—the basis of current human DNA analyses and migration, fossil records of dinosaurs and so on; cultural or social anthropology, which analyzes past and current societies and the economic, religious etc. changes they have undergone; linguistic anthropology, clearly focused on the evolution of languages; and archaeology, which has been defined above.

I genuinely hope this helps some people understand why we need all these disciplines (along with specialists in art history, chemical analysis and other fields) to get a full picture of the human past.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by samuk:
TerraCotta:
I’ll try to keep this short so it’s not an intimidating read but hopefully this will help dispel some of the falsehoods and misunderstandings I’m seeing on this thread.

There seems to be some confusion about what constitutes “history” and why archaeology and anthropology are key to our understanding of the African and global past, even with cultures that have thousands of years of “written” history.

The word “archaeology” quite literally means “ancient history” in Greek (from arkhaios = “old, ancient”; logos = “words, study”) but is defined as “the study of human history and prehistory through the excavation of sites and the analysis of artifacts and other physical remains.”

It’s quite acceptable as evidence of past events and is often the sole means of determining the events of evolution of “prehistory”. In some cases, archaeology may supersede or be trustworthy evidence than written chronicles, which can obviously be incomplete. This is obvious from examples in European or Asian history, where archaeologists recovered the sites of ancient Troy and Crete or the Chinese “Terracotta Army” of China’s first emperor on the basis of oral traditions, despite not being fully identified by written records alone. Obviously we have no written records for the period of human evolution or when dinosaurs roamed the earth, so archaeology is the key discipline in investigating those eras.

I don’t know of any serious historian in the world that would discount archaeology or anthropology and their value in helping us fill in the (very large) gaps in the written record anywhere in the world, in any period and for any group. Two short examples should demonstrate this clearly:

A) A few weeks ago, an archaeological report added significant new information to what we know about London’s past, suggesting it’s 3000 years older than previously believed : https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/archaeology/london-history-prehistoric-ceremony-site-archaeology-a9455621.html

B) Last year, other archaeologists look at material evidence from the Woodstock concert in 1968, and found contradictions with the eyewitness recollections of an event that happened just 50 years ago, with living attendees: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/archaeologists-find-woodstock-really-did-take-life-its-own-180972504/

These disciplines are even more important in places like the vast majority of Africa, where there are very few indigenous written languages and records (although more are still being identified) and only slightly more written observations from foreign visitors.

Archaeology is actually just one branch of the larger science of anthropology. This field includes the disciplines of /biological/ or /physical/ anthropology—the basis of current human DNA analyses and migration, fossil records of dinosaurs and so on; /cultural/ or /social/ anthropology, which analyzes past and current societies and the economic, religious etc. changes they have undergone; /linguistic/ anthropology, clearly focused on the evolution of languages; and archaeology, which has been defined above.

I genuinely hope this helps some people understand why we need all these disciplines (along with specialists in art history, chemical analysis and other fields) to get a full picture of the human past.
No doubt archaeology is important in studying and telling ancient histories but those archeological histories could be misrepresentation of the facts without a collaborative eyewitness accounts.

Now let me give few examples to buttress my point.

1. During WW11, between 1940 to 1945 the German Nazi looted artworks, currencies, gold, silver, diamond, etc, across Europe and from their victims especially the Jews. The estimated value of their loot at that time was €450 million, which is an equivalent of billions of dollars in today's value.

These items were stored and hidden in Wintershal AG's Kaiseroda potassium mine at Merkers. The America soldiers discovered this location by accident.

If this incident had happened thousands of years ago, during the ancient period of no written records, and these items were discovered today, would it be right for any archeologists to conclude that this items were made or manufactured in the location they were found.

What if the items found in Ife were also stolen from somewhere else and hidden in what would have been a forest centuries ago, what if there was a market in that location for the sales of such items.

How do you come to the conclusion that those artworks were actually made in Ife and that they were not brought down there. What happened to the ancient craft men that would have made them.

Archeologists may be able to tell few things about the items they are studying but not necessarily the true stories of how the items go to that locations.

2. Even after the German Nazi loot were discovered, some soldier who were transporting the loot back to headquarters stole some gold bars and other items which they hide in the forest to be retrieved later, but years later when they returned, they couldn't locate the location because the landscape had changed due to vegetation. These golds and other items remained buried till now. When they are found in the future, it will be wrong to say they were made in their current hidden locations.

Are there any collaborative eyewitness accounts of Bronze casting in Ife before few items were dug up from the ground.

If there were Bronze casters, what happened to them and why did they go into extinction.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by gregyboy(m): 10:07am On Apr 22, 2020
samuk:
No doubt archaeology is important in studying and telling ancient histories but those archeological histories could be misrepresentation of the facts without a collaborative eyewitness accounts.

Now let me give few examples to buttress my point.

1. During WW11, between 1940 to 1945 the German Nazi looted artworks, currencies, gold, silver, diamond, etc, across Europe and from their victims especially the Jews. The estimated value of their loot at that time was €450 million, which is an equivalent of billions of dollars in today's value.

These items were stored and hidden in Wintershal AG's Kaiseroda potassium mine at Merkers. The America soldiers discovered this location by accident.

If this incident had happened thousands of years ago, during the ancient period of no written records, and these items were discovered today, would it be right for any archeologists to conclude that this items were made or manufactured in their current location.

What if the items found in Ife were also stolen from somewhere else and hidden in what would have been a forest centuries ago, what if there was a market in that location for the sales of such items.

How do you come to the conclusion that those artworks were actually made in Ife and that they weren not brought down there. What happened to the ancient craft men that would have made them.

Archeologists may be able to tell few things about the items they are studying but not necessarily the true stories of how the items go to that locations.

2. Even after the German Nazi loot were discovered, some soldier who were transporting the loot back to headquarters stole some gold bars and other items which they hide in the forest to be retrieved later, but years later when they returned, they couldn't locate the location because the landscape had changed due to vegetation. These golds and other items remained buried till now. When they are found in the future, it will be wrong to say they were made in their current hidden locations.

Are there any collaborative eyewitness accounts of Bronze casting in Ife before few items were dug up from the ground.

If there were Bronze casters, what happened to them and why did they go into extinction.
Yea you got a point there thought like this had crossed my mind,
What if ife art was not made in ife they probably found it somewhere and they began worshiping the artwork as gods and even began practicing the facial scarification on the artworks taking a look at the artworks non of this artwork really describes the dressing of a Yoruba man
Because they were dound in ife doesn't make them ife artworks
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by samuk:
gregyboy:
Yea you got a point there thought like this had crossed my mind,
What if ife art was not made in ife they probably found it somewhere and they began worshiping the artwork as gods and even began practicing the facial scarification on the artworks taking a look at the artworks non of this artwork really describes the dressing of a Yoruba man
Because they were dound in ife doesn't make them ife artworks
In the past fossils of animals that were met to be native to Africa were found in different continents and because the scientists at the time couldn't explain how such animals could have crossed the vast oceans and seas to get to where they were found in prehistoric times before humans were able to make canoes and ships, they assumed that those animals must have evolved in those continents.

It was when it was discovered in 20th century that the entire landmass of the earth used to be one unbroken piece, that it became clear to scientists that those animals must have crossed from Africa to those continents before the continent broke away from each other and the spaces between them filled with oceans and seas.

The continent is still drifting apart, albeit in centimetres every year.

The fact that some artworks were dug up in Ife doesn't mean that those artworks were originally made in Ife.
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by gregyboy(m): 11:17am On Apr 22, 2020
samuk:
In the past fossils of animals that were met to be native to Africa were found in different continents and because the scientists at the time couldn't explain how such animals could have crossed the vast oceans and seas to get to where they were found in prehistoric times before humans were able to make canoes and ships, they assumed that those animals must have evolved on those continents.

It was when it was discovered in 20th century that the entire landmass of the earth used to be one unbroken piece, that it became clear to scientists that those animals must have crossed from Africa to those continents before the continent broke away from each other and the spaces between them filled with oceans and seas.

The continent is still drifting apart, albeit in centimetres every year.

The fact that some artworks were dug up in Ife doesn't mean that those artworks were originally made in Ife.
Yea we need to start questioning our history instead of believing what we were told
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by TAO11(f):
Hahahahhahaha ...

Once upon a time, the art historian and archaeologist, Frank Willet wrote as follows about the Ita-Yemo, Ife artworks:

"Here unquestionably were art works of first importance ... They were so very different from any works of negro art, and so very sophisticated in a European manner that they stood apart from the rest of African sculpture."

Frank Willett, "Bronze and Terra-Cotta Sculptures from Ita Yemo, Ife", The South African Archaeological Bulletin, Vol. 14, No. 56 (Dec., 1959), p.135.


The foregoing laughable, jealousy-induced Nairaland comments finally come to prove my argument that Ife had a super-advanced military ascendancy which overshadows even the leading black African civilization that must have produce such "art works of first importance". /s grin grin

It takes a super excellent military ascendancy to successfully clash with a leading black African civilization and despoil some of its most treasured national assets. /s cheesy grin

These national assets were so despoiled by the invading Ife military to the extreme extent that almost no trace of such specific "eloquent [art] of a symmetry, a vitality, a delicacy of form directly reminiscent of ancient Greece" were left remaining on the foreign African soil of its "original" producers. /s grin cheesy

This implied imagery of ancient Ife's military ascendancy over black Africa reminds me of a sad incident cry which took place in Benin kingdom in the year 1897 cry when some invading devilishly powerful foreign military grounded and despoiled Benin. The dark memories of this ugly incident is not quick to escape the minds of the Binis even till date.

How come, then, that those anonymous people whom Ife conquered and despoiled from are quick to forget absolutely everything of such an ugly historical incident, to the extent that nothing of such ugly incident is recollected in their traditions, or in the traditions of their conqueror (i.e. Ife)?? /s grin cheesy

The simple explanation for this is that: alongside their artworks, the invading Ife army also looted their collective memory and their collective sense of history. /s cheesy

The latest:
When I say: "Britain is Ife", you say "Benin is Anonymous". grin cheesy

Jealosy-induced jokes will always remain what they are anyways! grin

Cheers to sane Nairalanders!
Re: Benin Kingdom In Edo State Remained Part Of The Expansive Yoruba - Ooni Of Ife by samuk: 3:43pm On Apr 22, 2020
TAO11:
Hahahahhahaha ...

Once upon a time, the art historian and archaeologist, Frank Willet wrote as follows about the Ita-Yemo, Ife artworks:

"Here unquestionably were art works of first importance ... They were so very different from any works of negro art, and so very sophisticated in a European manner that they stood apart from the rest of African sculpture."

Frank Willett, "Bronze and Terra-Cotta Sculptures from Ita Yemo, Ife", The South African Archaeological Bulletin, Vol. 14, No. 56 (Dec., 1959), p.135.


The foregoing laughable, jealousy-induced Nairaland comments finally come to prove my argument that Ife had a super-advanced military ascendancy which overshadows even the leading black African civilization that must have produce such "art works of first importance". /s grin grin

It takes a super excellent military ascendancy to successfully clash with a leading black African civilization and despoil some of its most treasured national assets. /s cheesy grin

These national assets were so despoiled by the invading Ife military to the extreme extent that almost no trace of such specific "eloquent [art] of a symmetry, a vitality, a delicacy of form directly reminiscent of ancient Greece" were left remaining on the foreign African soil of its "original" producers. /s grin cheesy

This implied imagery of ancient Ife's military ascendancy over black Africa reminds me of a sad incident cry which took place in Benin kingdom in the year 1897 cry when some invading devilishly powerful foreign military grounded and despoiled Benin. The dark memories of this ugly incident is not quick to escape the minds of the Binis even till date.

How come, then, that those anonymous people whom Ife conquered and despoiled from are quick to forget absolutely everything of such an ugly historical incident, to the extent that nothing of such ugly incident is recollected in their traditions, or in the traditions of their conqueror (i.e. Ife)?? /s grin cheesy

The simple explanation for this is that: alongside their artworks, the invading Ife army also looted their collective memory and their collective sense of history. /s cheesy

The latest:
When I say: "Britain is Ife", you say "Benin is Anonymous". grin cheesy

Jealosy-induced jokes will always remain what they are anyways! grin

Cheers to sane Nairalanders!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rp8flCwvoAU
1 2 3 ... 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 ... 52 Reply

Elele Kingdom In Ikwerre Celebrate New Yam Festival (photos) • Reps Move To Halt Alleged Plan By Edo State Govt To Split Benin Kingdom • Abiriba Kingdom In Abia Holds 600-Year-Old ‘Itu Eye’ Ceremony In Grand Style • 2 • 3 • 4

Why Oba Of Benin Was Covering His Mouth • Alaafin Of OYO With Yoruba Descendants In Brazil (pictures) • Nigeria's National Anthem In Yoruba Language