Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,153,231 members, 7,818,781 topics. Date: Monday, 06 May 2024 at 02:54 AM

800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. - Religion - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. (1089 Views)

Help! Please I Want Answers To Some Fundamental Biblical Question / Answers To Jehovah Witnesses Devil-inspired Questions About JESUS CHRIST!!! / Getting Immediate Answers To Prayers!!! (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by Nobody: 8:24pm On Feb 14, 2008
therationa has asked many questions on this forum and has posted some really amazing conclusions and opinions. My take on this is that his 'research' is rather shallow and skewed to conform to his prejudices.

The great theologian Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) answered most of his questions over 800 years ago. So, by asking these questions, therationa is revealing to us how backward and behind-the-times his research work is.

Aquinas' 'Summa Theologica' (http://www.sacred-texts.com/chr/aquinas/summa/index.htm) contains the answers to all his questions.

I have pasted a few of the questions answered by Aquinas below. Therationa should deepen and refine his 'research' and learn how to ask the right questions.

------

Table of Contents


Question. 1 - The Nature and Extent of Sacred Doctrine (Ten Articles)

Article. 1 - Whether, besides philosophy, any further doctrine is required?

Article. 2 - Whether sacred doctrine is a science?

Article. 3 - Whether sacred doctrine is one science?

Article. 4 - Whether sacred doctrine is a practical science?

Article. 5 - Whether sacred doctrine is nobler than other sciences?

Article. 6 - Whether this doctrine is the same as wisdom?

Article. 7 - Whether God is the object of this science?

Article. 8 - Whether sacred doctrine is a matter of argument?

Article. 9 - Whether Holy Scripture should use metaphors?

Article. 10 - Whether in Holy Scripture a word may have several senses?

Treatise on The One God (QQ[2-26])

Question. 2 - The Existence of God (Three Articles)

Article. 1 - Whether the existence of God is self-evident?

Article. 2 - Whether it can be demonstrated that God exists?

Article. 3 - Whether God exists?

Question. 3 - OF THE SIMPLICITY OF GOD (EIGHT ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether God is a body?

Article. 2 - Whether God is composed of matter and form?

Article. 3 - Whether God is the same as His essence or nature?

Article. 4 - Whether essence and existence are the same in God?

Article. 5 - Whether God is contained in a genus?

Article. 6 - Whether in God there are any accidents?

Article. 7 - Whether God is altogether simple?

Article. 8 - Whether God enters into the composition of other things?

Question. 4 - THE PERFECTION OF GOD (THREE ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether God is perfect?

Article. 2 - Whether the perfections of all things are in God?

Article. 3 - Whether any creature can be like God?

Question. 5 - OF GOODNESS IN GENERAL (SIX ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether goodness differs really from being?

Article. 2 - Whether goodness is prior in idea to being?

Article. 3 - Whether every being is good?

Article. 4 - Whether goodness has the aspect of a final cause?

Article. 5 - Whether the essence of goodness consists in mode, species and order?

Article. 6 - Whether goodness is rightly divided into the virtuous*, the useful and the pleasant? [*“Bonum honestum” is the virtuous good considered as fitting. (cf. SS, Q[141], A[3]; SS, Q[145])]

Question. 6 - THE GOODNESS OF GOD (FOUR ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether God is good?

Article. 2 - Whether God is the supreme good?

Article. 3 - Whether to be essentially good belongs to God alone?

Article. 4 - Whether all things are good by the divine goodness?

Question. 7 - THE INFINITY OF GOD (FOUR ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether God is infinite?

Article. 2 - Whether anything but God can be essentially infinite?

Article. 3 - Whether an actually infinite magnitude can exist?

Article. 4 - Whether an infinite multitude can exist?

Question. 8 - THE EXISTENCE OF GOD IN THINGS (FOUR ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether God is in all things?

Article. 2 - Whether God is everywhere?

Article. 3 - Whether God is everywhere by essence, presence and power?

Article. 4 - Whether to be everywhere belongs to God alone?

Question. 9 - THE IMMUTABILITY OF GOD (TWO ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether God is altogether immutable?

Article. 2 - Whether to be immutable belongs to God alone?

Question. 10 - THE ETERNITY OF GOD (SIX ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether this is a good definition of eternity, “The simultaneously-whole and perfect possession of interminable life”?

Article. 2 - Whether God is eternal?

Article. 3 - Whether to be eternal belongs to God alone?

Article. 4 - Whether eternity differs from time?

Article. 5 - The difference of aeviternity and time

Article. 6 - Whether there is only one aeviternity?

Question. 11 - THE UNITY OF GOD (FOUR ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether “one” adds anything to “being”?

Article. 2 - Whether “one” and “many” are opposed to each other?

Article. 3 - Whether God is one?

Article. 4 - Whether God is supremely one?

Question. 12 - HOW GOD IS KNOWN BY US (THIRTEEN ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether any created intellect can see the essence of God?

Article. 2 - Whether the essence of God is seen by the created intellect through an image?

Article. 3 - Whether the essence of God can be seen with the bodily eye?

Article. 4 - Whether any created intellect by its natural powers can see the Divine essence?

Article. 5 - Whether the created intellect needs any created light in order to see the essence of God?

Article. 6 - Whether of those who see the essence of God, one sees more perfectly than another?

Article. 7 - Whether those who see the essence of God comprehend Him?

Article. 8 - Whether those who see the essence of God see all in God?

Article. 9 - Whether what is seen in God by those who see the Divine essence, is seen through any similitude?

Article. 10 - Whether those who see the essence of God see all they see in it at the same time?

Article. 11 - Whether anyone in this life can see the essence of God?

Article. 12 - Whether God can be known in this life by natural reason?

Article. 13 - Whether by grace a higher knowledge of God can be obtained than by natural reason?

Question. 13 - THE NAMES OF GOD (TWELVE ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether a name can be given to God?

Article. 2 - Whether any name can be applied to God substantially?

Article. 3 - Whether any name can be applied to God in its literal sense?

Article. 4 - Whether names applied to God are synonymous?

Article. 5 - Whether what is said of God and of creatures is univocally predicated of them?

Article. 6 - Whether names predicated of God are predicated primarily of creatures?

Article. 7 - Whether names which imply relation to creatures are predicated of God temporally?

Article. 8 - Whether this name “God” is a name of the nature?

Article. 9 - Whether this name “God” is communicable?

Article. 10 - Whether this name “God” is applied to God univocally by nature, by participation, and according to opinion?

Article. 11 - Whether this name, HE WHO IS, is the most proper name of God?

Article. 12 - Whether affirmative propositions can be formed about God?

Question. 14 - OF GOD’S KNOWLEDGE (SIXTEEN ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether there is knowledge [*Scientia]?

Article. 2 - Whether God understands Himself?

Article. 3 - Whether God comprehends Himself?

Article. 4 - Whether the act of God’s intellect is His substance?

Article. 5 - Whether God knows things other than Himself?

Article. 6 - Whether God knows things other than Himself by proper knowledge?

Article. 7 - Whether the knowledge of God is discursive?

Article. 8 - Whether the knowledge of God is the cause of things?

Article. 9 - Whether God has knowledge of things that are not?

Article. 10 - Whether God knows evil things?

Article. 11 - Whether God knows singular things?

Article. 12 - Whether God can know infinite things?

Article. 13 - Whether the knowledge of God is of future contingent things?

Article. 14 - Whether God knows enunciable things?

Article. 15 - Whether the knowledge of God is variable?

Article. 16 - Whether God has a speculative knowledge of things?

Question. 15 - OF IDEAS (THREE ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether there are ideas?

Article. 2 - Whether ideas are many?

Article. 3 - Whether there are ideas of all things that God knows?

Question. 16 - OF TRUTH (EIGHT ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether truth resides only in the intellect?

Article. 2 - Whether truth resides only in the intellect composing and dividing?

Article. 3 - Whether the true and being are convertible terms?

Article. 4 - Whether good is logically prior to the true?

Article. 5 - Whether God is truth?

Article. 6 - Whether there is only one truth, according to which all things are true?

Article. 7 - Whether created truth is eternal?

Article. 8 - Whether truth is immutable?

Question. 17 - CONCERNING FALSITY (FOUR ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether falsity exists in things?

Article. 2 - Whether there is falsity in the senses?

Article. 3 - Whether falsity is in the intellect?

Article. 4 - Whether true and false are contraries?

Question. 18 - THE LIFE OF GOD (FOUR ARTICLES)

Article. 1 - Whether to live belongs to all natural things?

Article. 2 - Whether life is an operation?

Article. 3 - Whether life is properly attributed to God?

Article. 4 - Whether all things are life in God?
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by therationa(m): 8:28pm On Feb 14, 2008
Imagine if you lived 1200 years ago and had asked the questions I have been asking. Were would you have gone for the answers. Would you have had to wait 400 years for the arrival of Aquinas on the scene? smiley
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by Nobody: 8:30pm On Feb 14, 2008
@therationa
You have done very badly in your literature review. You should learn to stand on the shoulders of giants. Please do some more groundwork before asking questions that have been answered hundreds of years ago.
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by 4Him(m): 8:34pm On Feb 14, 2008
therationa:

Imagine if you lived 1200 years ago and had asked the questions I have been asking. Were would you have gone for the answers. Would you have had to wait 400 years for the arrival of Aquinas on the scene? smiley

i see as usual u have made no attempt to even look at imhotep's study . . . feel free to make up another thread asking for dinner answers.
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by Nobody: 8:36pm On Feb 14, 2008
therationa:

Imagine if you lived 1200 years ago and had asked the questions I have been asking. Were would you have gone for the answers. Would you have had to wait 400 years for the arrival of Aquinas on the scene? smiley
@therationa

Most of the people in the list below (and their works listed below their names) existed before the year 400AD. The knowledge of Christ had taken deep root as at then. These people also asked and answered the questions you are so happy to post for us on this forum.

--------

Alexander of Alexandria [SAINT]
- Epistles on the Arian Heresy and the Deposition of Arius

Alexander of Lycopolis
- Of the Manicheans

Ambrose (340-397) [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- On the Christian Faith (De fide)
- On the Holy Spirit
- On the Mysteries
- On Repentance
- On the Duties of the Clergy
- Concerning Virgins
- Concerning Widows
- On the Death of Satyrus
- Memorial of Symmachus
- Sermon against Auxentius
- Letters

Aphrahat/Aphraates (c. 280-367)
- Demonstrations

Archelaus
- Acts of the Disputation with the Heresiarch Manes

Aristides the Philosopher
- The Apology

Arnobius
- Against the Heathen

Athanasius [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- Against the Heathen
- On the Incarnation of the Word
- Deposition of Arius
- On Luke 10:22 (Matthew 11:27)
- Circular Letter
- Apologia Contra Arianos
- De Decretis
- De Sententia Dionysii
- Vita S. Antoni (Life of St. Anthony)
- Ad Episcopus Aegypti et Libyae
- Apologia ad Constantium
- Apologia de Fuga
- Historia Arianorum
- Four Discourses Against the Arians
- De Synodis
- Tomus ad Antiochenos
- Ad Afros Epistola Synodica
- Historia Acephala
- Letters

Athenagoras
- A Plea for the Christians
- The Resurrection of the Dead

Augustine of Hippo [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- Confessions
- Letters
- City of God
- Christian Doctrine
- On the Holy Trinity
- The Enchiridion
- On the Catechising of the Uninstructed
- On Faith and the Creed
- Concerning Faith of Things Not Seen
- On the Profit of Believing
- On the Creed: A Sermon to Catechumens
- On Continence
- On the Good of Marriage
- On Holy Virginity
- On the Good of Widowhood
- On Lying
- To Consentius: Against Lying
- On the Work of Monks
- On Patience
- On Care to be Had For the Dead
- On the Morals of the Catholic Church
- On the Morals of the Manichaeans
- On Two Souls, Against the Manichaeans
- Acts or Disputation Against Fortunatus the Manichaean
- Against the Epistle of Manichaeus Called Fundamental
- Reply to Faustus the Manichaean
- Concerning the Nature of Good, Against the Manichaeans
- On Baptism, Against the Donatists
- Answer to Letters of Petilian, Bishop of Cirta
- Merits and Remission of Sin, and Infant Baptism
- On the Spirit and the Letter
- On Nature and Grace
- On Man's Perfection in Righteousness
- On the Proceedings of Pelagius
- On the Grace of Christ, and on Original Sin
- On Marriage and Concupiscence
- On the Soul and its Origin
- Against Two Letters of the Pelagians
- On Grace and Free Will
- On Rebuke and Grace
- On Rebuke and Grace
- The Predestination of the Saints/Gift of Perseverance
- Our Lord's Sermon on the Mount
- The Harmony of the Gospels
- Sermons on Selected Lessons of the New Testament
- Tractates on the Gospel of John
- Homilies on the First Epistle of John
- Soliloquies
- The Enarrations, or Expositions, on the Psalms

Bardesanes (154-222)
- The Book of the Laws of Various Countries

Barnabas [SAINT]
- Epistle of Barnabas

Basil the Great [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- De Spiritu Sancto
- Nine Homilies of Hexaemeron
- Letters

Caius
- Fragments

Clement of Alexandria [SAINT]
- Who is the Rich Man That Shall Be Saved?
- Exhortation to the Heathen
- The Instructor
- The Stromata, or Miscellanies
- Fragments

Clement of Rome [SAINT]
- First Epistle
- Second Epistle [SPURIOUS]
- Two Epistles Concerning Virginity [SPURIOUS]
- Recognitions [SPURIOUS]

Commodianus
- Writings

Cyprian of Carthage [SAINT]
- The Life and Passion of Cyprian
- The Epistles of Cyprian
- The Treatises of Cyprian
- The Seventh Council of Carthage

Cyril of Jerusalem [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- Catechetical Lectures

Dionysius of Rome [SAINT]
- Against the Sabellians

Dionysius the Great
- Extant Fragments
- Exegetical Fragments

Ephraim the Syrian (306-373) [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- Nisibene Hymns
- Miscellaneous Hymns -- On the Nativity of Christ in the Flesh, For the Feast of the Epiphany, and On the Faith ("The Pearl"wink
- Homilies -- On Our Lord, On Admonition and Repentance, and On the Sinful Woman

Eusebius of Caesarea (c. 265-c. 340)
- Church History
- Life of Constantine
- Oration of Constantine "to the Assembly of the Saints"
- Oration in Praise of Constantine
- Letter on the Council of Nicaea

Gennadius of Marseilles
- Illustrious Men (Supplement to Jerome)

Gregory the Great, Pope (c. 540-604) [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- Pastoral Rule
- Register of Letters

Gregory Nazianzen [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- Orations
- Letters

Gregory of Nyssa [SAINT]
- Against Eunomius
- Answer to Eunomius' Second Book
- On the Holy Spirit (Against the Followers of Macedonius)
- On the Holy Trinity, and of the Godhead of the Holy Spirit (To Eustathius)
- On "Not Three Gods" (To Ablabius)
- On the Faith (To Simplicius)
- On Virginity
- On Infants' Early Deaths
- On Pilgrimages
- On the Making of Man
- On the Soul and the Resurrection
- The Great Catechism
- Funeral Oration on Meletius
- On the Baptism of Christ (Sermon for the Day of Lights)
- Letters

Gregory Thaumaturgus [SAINT]
- A Declaration of Faith
- A Metaphrase of the Book of Ecclesiastes
- Canonical Epistle
- The Oration and Panegyric Addressed to Origen
- A Sectional Confession of Faith
- On the Trinity
- Twelve Topics on the Faith
- On the Subject of the Soul
- On All the Saints
- On Matthew 6:22-23

Hermas
- The Pastor (or "The Shepherd"wink

Hilary of Poitiers [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- On the Councils, or the Faith of the Easterns
- On the Trinity
- Homilies on the Psalms

Hippolytus [SAINT]
- The Refutation of All Heresies
- The Extant Works and Fragments of Hippolytus: Exegetical
- Expository Treatise Against the Jews
- Against Plato, On the Cause of the Universe
- Against the Heresy of Noetus
- Discourse on the Holy Theophany
- The Antichrist
- Appendix

Ignatius of Antioch [SAINT]
- Epistle to the Ephesians
- Epistle to the Magnesians
- Epistle to the Trallians
- Epistle to the Romans
- Epistle to the Philadelphians
- Epistle to the Smyraeans
- Epistle to Polycarp
- The Martyrdom of Ignatius
- The Spurious Epistles

Irenaeus of Lyons [SAINT]
- Adversus haereses
- Fragments from the Lost Writings of Irenaeus

Jerome [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- Letters
- The Perpetual Virginity of Blessed Mary
- To Pammachius Against John of Jerusalem
- The Dialogue Against the Luciferians
- The Life of Malchus, the Captive Monk
- The Life of S. Hilarion
- The Life of Paulus the First Hermit
- Against Jovinianus
- Against Vigilantius
- Against the Pelagians
- Prefaces
- De Viris Illustribus (Illustrious Men)
- Apology for himself against the Books of Rufinus

John of Damascus [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- Exposition of the Faith

John Cassian (c. 360-c. 435)
- Institutes
- Conferences
- On the Incarnation of the Lord (Against Nestorius)

John Chrysostom [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- Homilies on the Gospel of St. Matthew
- Homilies on Acts
- Homilies on Romans
- Homilies on First Corinthians
- Homilies on Second Corinthians
- Homilies on Ephesians
- Homilies on Philippians
- Homilies on Colossians
- Homilies on First Thessalonians
- Homilies on Second Thessalonians
- Homilies on First Timothy
- Homilies on Second Timothy
- Homilies on Titus
- Homilies on Philemon
- Commentary on Galatians
- Homilies on the Gospel of John
- Homilies on the Epistle to the Hebrews
- Homilies on the Statues
- No One Can Harm the Man Who Does Not Injure Himself
- Two Letters to Theodore After His Fall
- Letter to a Young Widow
- Homily on St. Ignatius
- Homily on St. Babylas
- Homily Concerning "Lowliness of Mind"
- Instructions to Catechumens
- Three Homilies on the Power of Satan
- Homily on the Passage "Father, if it be possible . . ."
- Homily on the Paralytic Lowered Through the Roof
- Homily on the Passage "If your enemy hunger, feed him."
- Homily Against Publishing the Errors of the Brethren
- First Homily on Eutropius
- Second Homily on Eutropius (After His Captivity)
- Four Letters to Olympias
- Letter to Some Priests of Antioch
- Correspondence with Pope Innocent I
- On the Priesthood

Julius Africanus
- Extant Writings

Justin Martyr [SAINT]
- First Apology
- Second Apology
- Dialogue with Trypho
- Hortatory Address to the Greeks
- On the Sole Government of God
- Fragments of the Lost Work on the Resurrection
- Miscellaneous Fragments from Lost Writings
- Martyrdom of Justin, Chariton, and other Roman Martyrs
- Discourse to the Greeks

Lactantius
- The Divine Institutes
- The Epitome of the Divine Institutes
- On the Anger of God
- On the Workmanship of God
- Of the Manner In Which the Persecutors Died
- Fragments of Lactantius
- The Phoenix
- A Poem on the Passion of the Lord

Leo the Great, Pope (c. 395-461) [SAINT] [DOCTOR]
- Sermons
- Letters

Malchion
- Extant Writings

Mar Jacob (452-521)
- Canticle on Edessa
- Homily on Habib the Martyr
- Homily on Guria and Shamuna

Mathetes
- Epistle to Diognetus

Methodius
- The Banquet of the Ten Virgins
- Concerning Free Will
- From the Discourse on the Resurrection
- Fragments
- Oration Concerning Simeon and Anna
- Oration on the Psalms
- Three Fragments from the Homily on the Cross and Passion of Christ
- Some Other Fragments

Minucius Felix
- Octavius

Moses of Chorene (c. 400-c. 490)
- History of Armenia

Novatian
- Treatise Concerning the Trinity
- On the Jewish Meats

Origen
- Origen de Principiis
- Africanus to Origen
- Origen to Africanus
- Origen to Gregory
- Origen Against Celsus
- Letter of Origen to Gregory
- Commentary on the Gospel of John
- Commentary on the Gospel of Matthew

Pamphilus [SAINT]
- Extant Writings

Papias [SAINT]
- Fragments

Peter of Alexandria [SAINT]
- The Genuine Acts of Peter
- The Canonical Epistle
- Fragments

Polycarp [SAINT]
- Epistle to the Philippians
- The Martyrdom of Polycarp

Rufinus
- Apology
- Commentary on the Apostles' Creed
- Prefaces

Socrates Scholasticus (c. 379-c. 450)
- Ecclesiastical History

Sozomen (c. 375-c. 447)
- Ecclesiastical History

Sulpitius Severus (c. 363-c. 420)
- On the Life of St. Martin
- Letters -- Genuine and Dubious
- Dialogues
- Sacred History

Tatian
- Address to the Greeks
- Fragments
- The Diatessaron

Tertullian
- The Apology
- On Idolatry
- De Spectaculis (The Shows)
- De Corona (The Chaplet)
- To Scapula
- Ad Nationes
- (A Fragment)
- An Answer to the Jews
- The Soul's Testimony
- A Treatise on the Soul
- The Prescription Against Heretics
- Against Marcion
- Against Hermogenes
- Against the Valentinians
- On the Flesh of Christ
- On the Resurrection of the Flesh
- Against Praxeas
- Scorpiace
- Appendix (Against All Heresies)
- On Repentance
- On Baptism
- On Prayer
- Ad Martyras
- The Martyrdom of Perpetua and Felicity (Sometimes attributed to Tertullian)
- Of Patience
- On the Pallium
- On the Apparel of Women
- On the Veiling of Virgins
- To His Wife
- On Exhortation to Chastity
- On Monogamy
- On Modesty
- On Fasting
- De Fuga in Persecutione

Theodoret
- Counter-Statements to Cyril's 12 Anathemas against Nestorius
- Ecclesiastical History
- Dialogues ("Eranistes" or "Polymorphus"wink
- Demonstrations by Syllogism
- Letters

Theodotus
- Excerpts

Theophilus
- Theophilus to Autolycus

Venantius
- Poem on Easter

Victorinus [SAINT]
- On the Creation of the World
- Commentary on the Apocalypse of the Blessed John
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by therationa(m): 8:38pm On Feb 14, 2008
Imhotep,

Sorry, I did not mean to give the impression that I was not going to read the document from Aquinas. I have had a cursory look and guess what? This is a massive document. Have you ever read it?

If I had the rest of the year I don't think I could complete reading this document even if that was the only thing I did.

If you have read it, can you summarise the salient points please.
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by Nobody: 8:40pm On Feb 14, 2008
therationa:

Imhotep,

Sorry, I did not mean to give the impression that I was not going to read the document from Aquinas. I have had a cursory look and guess what? This is a massive document. Have you ever read it?

If I had the rest of the year I don't think I could complete reading this document even if that was the only thing I did.

If you have read it, can you summarise the salient points please.

@therationa
You are a scholar. Scholars are not lazy people. TAKE TIME AND READ. Get your facts straight before generating questions that you should never had asked.
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by therationa(m): 8:41pm On Feb 14, 2008
Fair enough. To what extend are the pre-Aquinas responses similar/different from the post-Aquinas answers?
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by Nobody: 8:42pm On Feb 14, 2008
therationa:

Fair enough. To what extend are the pre-Aquinas responses similar/different from the post-Aquinas answers?

Good question. That is what you should read and discover for yourself. I cannot read/study on your behalf.
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by Nobody: 10:17am On Feb 15, 2008
@therationa

Have you learnt how to carry out literature review now? The shallowness of your questions/research work is rather disappointing.
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by Nobody: 11:54am On Feb 15, 2008
therationa has asked many questions on this forum and has posted some really amazing conclusions and opinions. My take on this is that his 'research' is rather shallow and skewed to conform to his prejudices.

Nice one ,

I can only hope we Christians would see Atheists and Evolutionist for who they are, Pitiful Men, who desperately need the touch of God in their lives since , it seems the more they think they know the less they seem to understand,

They ask questions and repeat the same questions that have either been answered now or before, and then pose those questions as reasons for their "Faith"
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by dafidixone(m): 1:41pm On Feb 15, 2008
@Imhotep,

Thanks for this good job of research. I hope this will silence those people who post, and argues blindly on this forum. They claim they have read vast on a particular subject but only to defend their assumptions with what they do not know.

Many of them will say the bible is too voluminous for them to read yet they claim it is incomplete.

Imhotep, that is a brilliant one grin.

You are a prof. on this forum. grin grin cheesy

@ therationa try to be rational this time around. Always find time to read. "He who do not read is not different from those who cannot read" DO not waste your education learn more in order for you to have intellectual development.

Shallom! smiley
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by KAG: 3:28pm On Feb 15, 2008
therationa:

Imhotep,

Sorry, I did not mean to give the impression that I was not going to read the document from Aquinas. I have had a cursory look and guess what? This is a massive document. Have you ever read it?

If I had the rest of the year I don't think I could complete reading this document even if that was the only thing I did.

If you have read it, can you summarise the salient points please.


I haven't read all of Aquinas, but he covers a lot topics and it's hard to summarise his work. The part I find interesting though - and I only know of this from secondary sources, not Aquinas himself - is his attempt to, IIRC, grapple with the idea of soul, being and the body. I hope I'm not mixing up my Christian philosophers.


If you're going to read Aquinas, anyway, I'd suggest getting a quick overview of Platonism, Aristotelean philosophy and Augustine's writings. Just a general framework should help.
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by Nobody: 3:33pm On Feb 15, 2008
KAG:

If you're going to read Aquinas, anyway, I'd suggest getting a quick overview of Platonism, Aristotelean philosophy and Augustine's writings. Just a general framework should help.

Beautiful. I hope therationa can see the grounds he is yet to cover.
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by pcicero(m): 11:40am On Feb 16, 2008
Shallow mindedness begets bigotry and ignorance. Imhotep, you are great!
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by stimulus(m): 12:08pm On Feb 16, 2008
@KAG,

KAG:

If you're going to read Aquinas, anyway, I'd suggest getting a quick overview of Platonism, Aristotelean philosophy and Augustine's writings. Just a general framework should help.

How apt! cheesy I'd thought that such a notion was perculiar to me!

- - -

Now wey bawomolo?!? grin I know, I know. . . "philosophy is an oxymoron" - but for all that, it is still philosophy! Get to work ma guy!
Re: 800 Year Old Answers To Therationa's Questions. by Nobody: 10:31am On Feb 18, 2008
stimulus:

Now wey bawomolo?!? grin I know, I know. . . "philosophy is an oxymoron" - but for all that, it is still philosophy! Get to work ma guy!

Definition -> "An oxymoron (plural oxymorons or, more rarely, oxymora) is a figure of speech that combines two normally contradictory terms. Oxymoron is a loanword from Greek oxy ("sharp"wink and moros ("dull"wink. Thus the word oxymoron is itself an oxymoron."


Now, can bawomol(o) prove to us, beyond reasonable doubt, HOW philosophy is an oxymoron We are waiting.

There is more to knowledge than name-dropping.

(1) (Reply)

What Does The Bible Say About The Mark Of The Beast? / Fake Prophets / Difference Between JESUS And MUHAMMAD/ALLAH

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 90
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.