this thread is created at deol's behest.she said I should create my thread instead of "derailing" the other thread:
https://www.nairaland.com/1424784/umar-ibn-alkhattab-golden-leader

she further suggested that I could seek homepage exposure.so please deols pass this thread to the homepage as service to the Ahlul-Bayt (as) and particularly Lady Fatima (as),whose anger brings the wrath of Allah (swt).

a list of reasons we do not like Umar:

1.) he ran away from the battle of Uhud,when it was rumored that the Prophet (sa) had been killed.Umar abandoned everyone and Islam itself on the battlefield as per Quran verse 3:144.

2.) He insulted the Prophet (sa) while the latter was breathing his last on his deathbed.he called the Prophet (sa) "delirious" and refused granting the Prophet (sa) his order.see Hadith of Pen and Paper.

3.) He refused to join the expedition under the leadership of Usama Ibn Zaid Ibn Harith (ra),even though the Prophet (sa) had asked him and also abu bakr to leave Medina.he stayed back sensing the Prophet (sa) was critically ill,and foreseeing an opportunity to grab power.

4.) he orchestrated the proceedings in saqifa banu saeda.

5.) he is responsible for the assault on the house of Sayyida Fatima (as),daughter of the Prophet (sa).

6.) he is one of those 12 who had tried to assassinate the Prophet (sa) in Aqabah.

7.) he questioned the prophethood of Prophet Muhammad (sa) in bay'at al-ridhwan,or the pledge of allegiance under the tree.

these are reasons why we dislike him.you can choose to love him or not.you can choose to disagree or agree with us.this is our opinion.to us our own and to you your own.there is no harm in differing views,and display of tolerance even if you don't agree with me.

@Vedaxcool and others. Please show some decorum.

This thread will be locked until its starter completes his ban for an offence committed elsewhere. Thereafter, he will be required to bring evidence from Islamic sources so that his claims may be viewed as a "differing opinion" rather than expression of unwanted and reprehensible hatred of one of the Prophet's (SAW) most honoured companions (RA).

Rafidi, notify me when your ban elapses. Mind you, several Shia scholars would condemn your post.