Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,194,370 members, 7,954,500 topics. Date: Friday, 20 September 2024 at 08:36 PM

Revisiting The Nma Strike - My Candid Opinion - Health - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Health / Revisiting The Nma Strike - My Candid Opinion (943 Views)

NMA Strike Suspended? / Ebola: Nigeria Reaches Out To U.S. For Experimental Drug; NMA Sets Up Committee / JOHESU Press Release on the NMA STRIKE (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

Revisiting The Nma Strike - My Candid Opinion by prettyprettywow: 1:51pm On Jul 31, 2014
I feel compelled to write on this subject because of its seriousness and the dearth of objective analyses in this forum. It is an emotive subject for both the NMA and JOHESU, and I can understand why punches fly around, but the parties must rise above petty and emotional considerations if we are to find a way forward.
The NMA has a list of 24 demands but I will limit myself to the most contentious ones. At this stage, it is probably best that I introduce myself. I am medical doctor of Nigerian heritage practising in the UK.
WHO SHOULD HEAD THE HOSPITAL
There is no contention – the medical doctor is the head of the clinical team. He/she leads the ward rounds, clinics, surgical operations, multidisciplinary meetings etc because the ultimate responsibility for patient care rests in his/her hands. The headship of the hospital is a different matter. This is an administrative role and needs not be occupied by a medical doctor. This job is better in the hands of people who have administrative or business management skills. This is the case in countries like the UK, Canada and the US, which heavily influence our health system. Therefore, it is difficult to reason with the NMA why this job should be the exclusive right of medical doctors.
NON-MEDICAL CONSULTANTS
The doctor-patient ratio in Nigeria is abysmally low and very unsafe. In my view, the role of non-medical professionals such as nurses, physiotherapists, pharmacists etc needs to expand to cope with the demands on doctors. It is important that this is done in a safe way by providing the appropriate level of training for these individuals. This is the case in countries such as the UK, Canada and the US where consultant nurses, pharmacists etc have existed for a few decades now. I do not see any problem with non-medical consultants as long as these individuals are appropriately trained and can practise competently, safely and within an agreed framework. If this arrangement enhances patient care, then where is the problem with it? Pursuing this demand is tantamount to the NMA obstructing the professional development of JOHESU members, and I don’t think this is helpful to anybody.
HAZARD ALLOWANCE
The types of hazard and the level to which healthcare workers are exposed vary considerably and depend on the type of job they do. Psychiatrists are hardly exposed to body fluids and their risks for contracting diseases like HIV and hepatitis are much lesser than a theatre scrub nurse. The risk of physical assault by a patient is higher for a psychiatrist than for a surgeon. And because psychiatry nurses spend more time with the patients, their risk of assault is arguably higher than the consultant psychiatrists. The people who work in radiology departments e.g. radiologists, radiographers, nurses, porters and so on have greater exposure to radioactive materials than everyone else in the hospital.
The health hazard allowance is a pittance – it needs to increase. However, I think it is important to get an independent risk assessor for impartial advice.
MISCELLANEOUS
I have read far too many emotional arguments on the subject of this NMA strike and very little of an objective discourse. It is important that I draw your attention to a few of these.
What has become obvious is the lack of understanding of the concept of teamwork. There is a pervasive notion among doctors that the other healthcare workers are there to serve them. JOHESU members think that doctors have become too conceited for their own good and are determined to put them in their “places”. The most important person in the hospital is the patient – not the doctor, nurse, pharmacist or laboratory scientist. Every team member is important and must be respected, including the people who do the least clinical jobs like cleaning; I don’t imagine that any hospital will remain open for long if its cleaners went on strike and dirt was allowed to accumulate to the point where it constitutes a health risk.
I have heard so many anecdotal accounts of nurses not joining doctors on ward rounds or pharmacists altering prescriptions without first discussing these with the prescribing doctors or laboratory scientist slapping doctors; and these accounts are being given as reasons why doctors must continue to head hospitals. These are disciplinary matters, which should be managed according to existing procedures. These excuses are emotional and should not be used to block the professional development of others.
Another recurrent theme in these debates is the abuse of junior doctors by both medical and non-medical staff, which appears to be endemic. There is a consistent account of junior doctors being asked to do other people’s jobs such as collecting blood from blood banks, taking samples to laboratories etc. In extreme cases, these doctors are asked to undertake non-clinical tasks by more senior doctors. This is simply unacceptable! I think it is fair to place the blame for this at the hands of consultants who are responsible to the junior doctors. But this in itself is not a good argument for blocking JOHESU members from becoming consultants in their specialties or for stopping them from heading hospitals if they have the right qualifications.
I am concerned that the NMA is losing public sympathy. Increasingly, I hear people describe doctors as selfish and heartless. This is very sad and rather unfortunate. They say doctors do not have any motivation to end the strike because patients are forced to pay exorbitant fees to them in their private hospitals. Those who cannot afford these fees are left to suffer or die. If the NMA has made any efforts to carry the public along, these do not appear to have been effective (yet).
CONCLUSION
To conclude, the current strategy (i.e., recurrent strikes) is not working. Over the last decade or two, the NMA and JOHESU have taken turns to go on strikes. Perhaps, it is time to sit both parties and resolve these contentious issues once and for all. It’s pointless for the government to enter into agreements with one party knowing fully well that the other party will ask for a near-reversal of those agreements.
It has become imperative to incorporate Ethics, Teamwork and Communications into undergraduate curricula.
Disciplinary procedures are there for a reason. They must be followed when necessary.
Although I practise abroad, I should point out that this strike affects me too. My family and friends all live in Nigeria. And who says I am not planning to come home to practise?
Lastly, let us be mindful of our own mortality – most of us will be ill someday. When this happens the only thing that will matter to us is to be looked after by caring and competent health-workers regardless of their individual specialisation. We can create that environment if we forget our individual egos and work as a team.
https://www./237385566365339/permalink/562731510497408/

1 Like

Re: Revisiting The Nma Strike - My Candid Opinion by allycat: 2:13pm On Jul 31, 2014
When did you become a Medical doctor, in previous posts you were a nurse who " paid the same school fees as those MBBS" graduates. You have constantly crtiscised and attacked doctors on this forum referring to them as those people . When did this metamorphosis occur from NP to Medical doctor.
prettyprettywow:
I feel compelled to write on this subject because of its seriousness and the dearth of objective analyses in this forum. It is an emotive subject for both the NMA and JOHESU, and I can understand why punches fly around, but the parties must rise above petty and emotional considerations if we are to find a way forward.
The NMA has a list of 24 demands but I will limit myself to the most contentious ones. At this stage, it is probably best that I introduce myself. I am medical doctor of Nigerian heritage practising in the UK.[size=8pt][/size]
WHO SHOULD HEAD THE HOSPITAL
There is no contention – the medical doctor is the head of the clinical team. He/she leads the ward rounds, clinics, surgical operations, multidisciplinary meetings etc because the ultimate responsibility for patient care rests in his/her hands. The headship of the hospital is a different matter. This is an administrative role and needs not be occupied by a medical doctor. This job is better in the hands of people who have administrative or business management skills. This is the case in countries like the UK, Canada and the US, which heavily influence our health system. Therefore, it is difficult to reason with the NMA why this job should be the exclusive right of medical doctors.
NON-MEDICAL CONSULTANTS
The doctor-patient ratio in Nigeria is abysmally low and very unsafe. In my view, the role of non-medical professionals such as nurses, physiotherapists, pharmacists etc needs to expand to cope with the demands on doctors. It is important that this is done in a safe way by providing the appropriate level of training for these individuals. This is the case in countries such as the UK, Canada and the US where consultant nurses, pharmacists etc have existed for a few decades now. I do not see any problem with non-medical consultants as long as these individuals are appropriately trained and can practise competently, safely and within an agreed framework. If this arrangement enhances patient care, then where is the problem with it? Pursuing this demand is tantamount to the NMA obstructing the professional development of JOHESU members, and I don’t think this is helpful to anybody.
HAZARD ALLOWANCE
The types of hazard and the level to which healthcare workers are exposed vary considerably and depend on the type of job they do. Psychiatrists are hardly exposed to body fluids and their risks for contracting diseases like HIV and hepatitis are much lesser than a theatre scrub nurse. The risk of physical assault by a patient is higher for a psychiatrist than for a surgeon. And because psychiatry nurses spend more time with the patients, their risk of assault is arguably higher than the consultant psychiatrists. The people who work in radiology departments e.g. radiologists, radiographers, nurses, porters and so on have greater exposure to radioactive materials than everyone else in the hospital.
The health hazard allowance is a pittance – it needs to increase. However, I think it is important to get an independent risk assessor for impartial advice.
MISCELLANEOUS
I have read far too many emotional arguments on the subject of this NMA strike and very little of an objective discourse. It is important that I draw your attention to a few of these.
What has become obvious is the lack of understanding of the concept of teamwork. There is a pervasive notion among doctors that the other healthcare workers are there to serve them. JOHESU members think that doctors have become too conceited for their own good and are determined to put them in their “places”. The most important person in the hospital is the patient – not the doctor, nurse, pharmacist or laboratory scientist. Every team member is important and must be respected, including the people who do the least clinical jobs like cleaning; I don’t imagine that any hospital will remain open for long if its cleaners went on strike and dirt was allowed to accumulate to the point where it constitutes a health risk.
I have heard so many anecdotal accounts of nurses not joining doctors on ward rounds or pharmacists altering prescriptions without first discussing these with the prescribing doctors or laboratory scientist slapping doctors; and these accounts are being given as reasons why doctors must continue to head hospitals. These are disciplinary matters, which should be managed according to existing procedures. These excuses are emotional and should not be used to block the professional development of others.
Another recurrent theme in these debates is the abuse of junior doctors by both medical and non-medical staff, which appears to be endemic. There is a consistent account of junior doctors being asked to do other people’s jobs such as collecting blood from blood banks, taking samples to laboratories etc. In extreme cases, these doctors are asked to undertake non-clinical tasks by more senior doctors. This is simply unacceptable! I think it is fair to place the blame for this at the hands of consultants who are responsible to the junior doctors. But this in itself is not a good argument for blocking JOHESU members from becoming consultants in their specialties or for stopping them from heading hospitals if they have the right qualifications.
I am concerned that the NMA is losing public sympathy. Increasingly, I hear people describe doctors as selfish and heartless. This is very sad and rather unfortunate. They say doctors do not have any motivation to end the strike because patients are forced to pay exorbitant fees to them in their private hospitals. Those who cannot afford these fees are left to suffer or die. If the NMA has made any efforts to carry the public along, these do not appear to have been effective (yet).
CONCLUSION
To conclude, the current strategy (i.e., recurrent strikes) is not working. Over the last decade or two, the NMA and JOHESU have taken turns to go on strikes. Perhaps, it is time to sit both parties and resolve these contentious issues once and for all. It’s pointless for the government to enter into agreements with one party knowing fully well that the other party will ask for a near-reversal of those agreements.
It has become imperative to incorporate Ethics, Teamwork and Communications into undergraduate curricula.
Disciplinary procedures are there for a reason. They must be followed when necessary.
Although I practise abroad, I should point out that this strike affects me too. My family and friends all live in Nigeria. And who says I am not planning to come home to practise?
Lastly, let us be mindful of our own mortality – most of us will be ill someday. When this happens the only thing that will matter to us is to be looked after by caring and competent health-workers regardless of their individual specialisation. We can create that environment if we forget our individual egos and work as a team.
Re: Revisiting The Nma Strike - My Candid Opinion by prettyprettywow: 2:25pm On Jul 31, 2014
I copied the post from a forum. not written by me. forgot to share the link. Have included the link. And what do you mean by i referred to Drs as "those people"? I always state my opinion and not criticize jare.
allycat: When did you become a Medical doctor, in previous posts you were a nurse who " paid the same school fees as those MBBS" graduates. You have constantly crtiscised and attacked doctors on this forum referring to them as those people . When did this metamorphosis occur from NP to Medical doctor.
Re: Revisiting The Nma Strike - My Candid Opinion by allycat: 3:08pm On Jul 31, 2014
I wondered oh. But you obviously don't like doctors at all and make no bones of the fact. But hey you don't have to like everybody and not everybody has to like you. That's life.
Re: Revisiting The Nma Strike - My Candid Opinion by prettyprettywow: 3:21pm On Jul 31, 2014
allycat: I wondered oh. But you obviously don't like doctors at all and make no bones of the fact. But hey you don't have to like everybody and not everybody has to like you. That's life.
I like my Dr friends ooh. My younger brother is about finishing medical school, and most of my good friends are Drs too. We all disagree to agree. It's nothing personal please. I treat people based on their personality and not their profession. If you are not likable, you are not and your choice of profession will not change that.
Re: Revisiting The Nma Strike - My Candid Opinion by Morotov1(m): 4:42pm On Jul 31, 2014
from ........Dr Ijabla Raymond , UK.
Re: Revisiting The Nma Strike - My Candid Opinion by Leopantro: 11:53pm On Jul 31, 2014
thanks for posting the link. i do hope you reas through all the 111 comments on that page. came across some very insightfull writeups there. for the benefit of those who wouldn't bother to go through the link, i would like to paste something here.we try to copy conditions in USA but skip what we don't like.

I really think that one should be
careful to assume where the shoe
pinches on someone else's feet! I
have practiced in Nigeria and now
in the US and as strongly as I have
felt about the state of the
healthcare system in Nigeria, I
have refrained from making
sweeping statements. The health
system in Nigeria is not the same
as that in the UK or US. Nurses in
the US can become Nurse
Practitioners after doing a
doctorate and do see patients but
they are not called Consultants.
Physician assistants love their jobs
because they get to see patients
but their is still oversight from a
physician. You may provide
consulting services to an insurance
company but that does not make
you a medical consultant the way
the term consultant is used in
Nigeria.
In all, we should remember that
team work is what makes a
healthcare system work. The FG
has conveniently used the current
state of animosity to foster
divisions and the members keep
seeing evil in each other instead of
joining hands to fight for a
sustainable health system for
everyone to work together without
fear and for the good of the
patient. Remember you also could
be a patient one day and all you
would want is the best hands
treating you.
Hospital administration: hot issue.
In the US, many hospitals are out
to make money and the CEO may
not be a doctor. However, there
are executive medical directors
who are physicians and in charge
of the medical side of things. In
Nigerian State Hospitals, there is
no fracas about who is in charge, I
suspect many of these issues occur
in our teaching hospitals, and I
may be wrong....... There is a DA in
charge of Administration,a CMAC in
charge of clinical services and the
CMD is the equivalent of the EMD
here. If there is a board to whom
the CMD is answerable,it allows for
checks and balances and helps
everyone feel they have voice. I am
not sure that the clamor to be CMD
by ancillary staff is legitimate
based on the healthcare system we
run in Nigeria. It's just a different
chain of command as compared to
what obtains in the US where you
have a CEO who usually is someone
with a Healthcare MBA, who
actually sometimes is also a
doctor.
One last point, every profession
has value. If you see value in what
you do, you are content within its
provisions for career development
and seek to excel at it. If you are a
nurse, nurse with all your heart;a
doctor,be your best at your
profession, a lab scientist , produce
consistent accurate results, a
pharmacist,help in picking up drug
errors and we can all ensure a safe
system for patients.

(1) (Reply)

Fear Of Ebola..see How Our Governors Are Greeting Each Other..lol / Ever Gone Crazy After Taking Too Much Alcohol? Narrate Your Craziest Experience! / EBOLA: Panic In Liberia As Dead Female Victims Resurrect On Way To Burial

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 50
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.