Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / NewStats: 3,194,688 members, 7,955,585 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 September 2024 at 09:50 AM |
Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / Islam for Muslims / Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. (3652 Views)
1 Ummah Present Peace & Unity Conventions 2016 Abuja Nigeria / Calling To Allah / Prof. Mobolaji's Death: Our Ummah Lost An ICON (2) (3) (4)
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by BETATRON(m): 12:52pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
Concerning mutah here are some important points I will like to share--please read patiently 1-mutah was abolished during the time of umar let them never bring before me a man who has married a woman for a set of period,for if they do I will stone him--muslim vol8p169 the fact that he prohibited temporal marriage(mutah) proves that this type of union was common among the companion and other muslims at that time,for otherwise it would not have been necessary to abolish it--also if the messenger of Allah had abolished it,the companions will never have had recourse to it and there would have no need for umar's threat with stoning also this means that this act was common during the time of abu bakr Umar himself admittedthere were 3 things tHAT WEre PERMISSIBLE IN ThE TiME OF THE PROPHET WHIcH I HAVE FoRBIDDEN,temporary marriage,the mutah of pilgrimage and reciting 'Hasten to the best of deeds in the call to prayer--al amini al-ghadir vol6p23 umar son abdullah was asked about the mutah,He replied it was permissible.when the man remarked that abdullah's father(umar) prohibited it,he(abdullah) replied profoundly---IF MY FAThER HAS FORBIDDEN SOMEtHiNG WHICH THE PROPHET PERMITTED,SHOULD WE ABANDON THE SUNNAH OF THE PROPHET AND FOLLOW MY FATHER?---al-tirmidhi jami' al-sahih vol4p38 Narrations also states that the second caliph prohibited the act because it was abused---this begs the question,--do we abolish a thing because it is abuse by just people---is prohibition the solution for abusing a law? Also seening that the mutah wasn't abolished by the prophet and the first caliph--i want to ask do we accuse them of permitting Zina? With salaam |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by vedaxcool(m): 3:44pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
MrOlai: Thanks for most especially the bold, the guy is a liar, like Khominie (la) he insults the righteous companions at morning and then pretend to be interested in forging unity. Khomine (la) went as far as stating the companions altered the Qurán to deny the "rights" of Ali r.a My own advise is we should decrease the mention of sectarian issues even though the shias(division) only have division to offer, there are other division even with Main stream Islam, like the the 4 schools of theological thoughts and other areas, Hassan Al Banna said Muslims should focus more on things that unite them rather than things that divide them. 6 Likes 2 Shares |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by IdisuleOurOwn(m): 4:43pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
A/Salam bro Lexiconkabir. I was ban that is why I didn't reply when you mention me. I saw this thread since inception. I always read post by people I follow, I was preparing my arsenal but when I saw comments from Kennyosein, Albaqir and mrOlai I have no choice than to surrender. lexiconkabir: The above Hadith says alot. I narrated it when I create a thread on "Trials and Tribulations of the present Ummah". 2 Likes |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by IdisuleOurOwn(m): 4:48pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by Aminat508(f): 4:50pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
IdisuleOurOwn:yes nah, so many sef https://www.nairaland.com/2822636/all-need-know-adoption-islam this one nko? And I saw some on Friday by Ahmed4002 |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by IdisuleOurOwn(m): 4:53pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
Nadheer15 aka demmzy15 rest small. @lexiconkabir, don't expect this thread to make home page. |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by Ahmed4002(m): 5:17pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
Aminat508: You are right. A Lot of thread from the Islamic section have been created that deserve to be on FP. Cc Seun 3 Likes |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by Empiree: 6:20pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
As far as I am concerned, I dont care what others think of this. I believe that it's absolutely possible to unite IF ONLY each faction and individual muslims would cut down their ego. All the issues brought up here are not conditions that negate one's Islam. True or false?. Saudi and other so called muslim nations have been accused by many muslims for ruling other than Allah's and they cited evidence in Sura Maida that "...whoever does not judge by what Allah hath revealed they are kafir" Should we call all these muslim leaders kafir base on this ayah of Quran?. This is where Sheikh Faisal disagrees with Saudi salafis but those Saudi salafis snubbed bcus they are Saudis and feed under the kings and princes. But if it's other sects, they would fume. Please watch Sheik Faisal on Youtube. He accused Salafis (Saudis and salafi stooges everywhere) for their disbelieve in "Tawheed Hakkimiyah". Thats why he sees Saudi kings and some sheikhs as kufaar even though i disagree with him. Now, on the issue of "incomplete Quran", allegation levied against the Shia that has been roaming for years within the Sunni community is simply false. I used to believe that nonsense up until 2011. The allegation is false. Shia do not believe Quran is incomplete. But if we insist, then Sunnis are guilty of the same. Read the allegation brought up by kenny below. kennyosein: It's also in the Sunni literature that a verse of Rajam (stoning) used to be in the Quran. Sunni Ulama tried their best to defend this silly argument. It is still there in their literature. So i ask, isnt this a case of kettle calling pot black?. That hukm is used in the case of adulterers and adulteresses. If they'd said it is simply hukm from Hadith would have been better but they said it USED to be a verse in the Quran. This is a very serious insinuation. On cursing the sahabas, I definitely think Shia Ulama need to do more to curb that nonsense even though they disagree with those sahabas. Cursing them is not proper adhab. I know they have been working on it. On the issue of Mutah, this is another case of kettle calling pot black that has been addressed many times. As far as I am concerned, it is no issue to hate Shia or call them kufar. This is fiqh issue. carinmom: We all agree that at some point in Islamic history, mutah was halal, correct?. It is like a case of drinking alcohol. I certainly believe that mutah NO LONGER EXIST base on the verse of Quran cited by lexiconkabir. Albaqir and other shia need to put aside those frivolous ahadith supporting mutah after it was banned. Quran takes precedence over all that. Now regarding distributing condom in zaria with respect to mutah, again, this is a simple issue if we are to set aside our ego. This can simply be dissolved through dialogue. It doesnt take anyone outside the fold of Islam. I do not believe ALL shia in the world do this. Everything is very reconcilable. UNITY is not far-fetched. But if you insist, then maybe you need to go USA, one of the many reasons oyinbo dont give a fig leaf about Arab leaders is bcus they patronize prostitutes in "Sin City" (Las Vegas). Does that means ALL Saudis, Sunnis, Salafi also do this nonsense?. Of-course not. So why accuse entire Shia of distributing condoms and then attributing it to mutah?. We need to think outside the box and look at the bigger picture and put aside our ego. lexiconkabir:You see bro, remove the clog. Have you ever heard of "Misyaar Marriage"?. This is another blameworthy practice by the Sunni but it's restricted to Middle East. Not general sunni ulama. The same people who are critical of "Muta marriage" support "misyar". Misyar is legalization of prostitution. They are working hard to make it sound Islamic thing but its not. This is even worst bcus it has no evidence in Islamic history but muta had. So you need to do research before you come to conclusion. Now, I know some people are going to say I am not stable. Yes, I am. I cant support any group because they are all guilty of the same crimes they accuse the other. So why is Peace & Unity not possible when we are all guilty?. Kenny also brought this up kennyosein:Again, these are quick shallow allegations. I wont deny there are some muslims who involve in these crazy things. But if you read Ibn Tayyimmiya(ra)'s literature, the supposed salafis influential, he was accused by majority Sufis of being a kafir for attributing eyes, legs, hands to Allah due to his literal interpretation of Quran. Those who accused him, in my opinion, are correct becus the Sheik's creed is the same as Nassara and Yahudi in this sense. You know we debate Christians on NL several times and we tried to correct them about God's Attributes. This is what contemporary scholars accused Sheik ul Islam ibn Tayyimiyah of. I have however refrained myself from labeling him a kafr. I am too young for that. So my brother, UNITY is possible. There is no absolute TRUTH with any muslims. I do not believe in the idea of "save sect". Thats rubbish. Salafi and Sufis are equally guilty of each other. Sunni and Shia are also guilty of each other. So why not put aside differences and focus on what unite muslims?. You notice that in masajid, there isnt differences. Which means if we are to work together as muslims, in the masjid, we only practice what is universally accepted in the Quran and Sunnah. Other practices should be private. This is very simple. My submission. 3 Likes 1 Share |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by MrOlai: 6:33pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
vedaxcool: You're welcome my Brother. Honestly, the bolded parts got me really cracking... But why "la" for him? For me, I would prefer to seek Allah's forgiveness for him despite all his atrocities! 1 Like |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by vedaxcool(m): 7:16pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
MrOlai: Unfortunately, I learnt such slang (if you permit me to call it that) from them, they do not mind using such invectives against the righteous caliphs. 1 Like |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by MrOlai: 7:35pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
vedaxcool:Alright. 1 Like |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by AlBaqir(m): 9:09pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
Mr Empiree # You believe on one hand that hadith is integral part of deen. On the other hand, you want certain ahadith to be deleted. That's smh. In the case of Mut'ah, there are ahadith that claimed ALL Sahabah used to practice it after the demise of the prophet. So you want those sahih ahadith expunged so that other "Sahih ahadith" that say prophet forbid it before he died should take precedence?! Again that's smh. # Any hadith that is not in par with the Quran is not from Nabi (salallahu alaih wa Ahli). An ayat Sherif from the Quran EXIST for Mut'ah. And the ayah is there till Qiyamat. The ayah quoted by lexiconkabir is a Makkan ayah and it can never abrogate a later ayah (Madinah). That is the rule unless you want us to change it also. If we are to change it, then alcohol drinker will have previous ayah that doesn't ban alcohol outrightly as a prove against the later ayah that banned it totally. A question of reality of life was asked as per the Islamic solution to a soldier's sexual desire on a mission of say 3-5 years? ALL of you ran away from it. Check books of ahadith and you will see this kind of scenario was the reason Mut'ah was legalized. If Prophet allowed Mut'ah for that reason, and has banned it according to you, then what is the solution today if truly Islam give answer to every predicament? Sunni invented Misyar. Shia stood on Mut'ah. What do you legislate? # As per cursing the Sahabah. A thread with 1000+viewers was opened (still existing) about this whereby Shi'i submissions are stated. It is Haram to curse Sahabah. Those who engage in that are the Yasiriyah led by Yasir Habib. They have a satellite tv called Fadak TV. They did curse and celebrate Eid for the death of Abu Bakar et al. Shia Majority do Taqlid of either Ayatullah Imam Ali Khamenei or Ayatullah Ali Sistani. Both of them declared cursing or abusing Sahabah as HARAM and INSULT to the teachings of Aimma of Ahl al-bayt. Obviously the mainstream Shia dissociate themselves from Abu Bakar et al but there is NO sahih ahadith from the Prophet and his Ahl al-bayt that ever instruction cursing or abusing. Unfortunately, narrating what is documented as Sahih in Sunni ahadith that exposed the other side of some of these Sahabah is being dubbed "cursing and abusing"! If Sunni want Shia to stop narrating these ahadith, they should DELETE them from their books. I believe I have the right to tell my family and friends, for example, the abusive word used by some Sahabah at the sickbed of the Prophet accusing him of RAVING MADNESS. 1 Like 1 Share |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by Nobody: 10:49pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
IdisuleOurOwn:I don't even pray it does, looking at what the thread has turn into. |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by MrOlai: 11:37pm On Jan 10, 2016 |
AlBaqir: Lier! The following shameful statements of yours, what are they? This is about Abubakr, Umar, Uthman, etc: AlBaqir: This is about Ummul Muhmineen Aisha(R.A.): AlBaqir: This is about Umar(R.A.): AlBaqir: What are all these? Are they not abuses? What about the curses you people rain on Abubakr, Umar and Uthman(R.A. 'Ajmain) during your ziyaratul ashura? Or you want to explain types of curses again using your Taqiya? What about you calling Abubakr, Umar and Uthman(R.A. 'Ajmain) munafiqun...from your post here: AlBaqir: Are these not abuses and curses? And you want to cover all these by accusing Yasiriyah of doing the cursing and abusing! Like I said earlier, you're as evil as shaytan himself! Your deception is directly from shaytan, your brother! You can't deceive everybody! The earlier you repent unto Allah(SWT), the better for you! 1 Like |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by Empiree: 12:19am On Jan 11, 2016 |
lexiconkabir:We will be laughing stock on NL |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by Nobody: 12:36am On Jan 11, 2016 |
Empiree:Exactly, or is there a way I could request for the thread to be deleted? |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by Empiree: 12:54am On Jan 11, 2016 |
AlBaqir:You see, i think you attach too much attention to texts. No other books in the world is 100% granteed accuracy except the Noble Quran. We were fooled growing up to think that anything in Sahih ahadith are "authentic". They made us believe that there isnt anything wrong in sahih Muslim and Bukhari. They raised their levels to that of Quran which is very wrong. This is why you able to quote some nonsense from there even though some of them you dont understand and misquoted or misunderstood them. Qur'an verse quoted earlier by lexcon is very much sufficient for wise ones. # As per cursing the Sahabah. A thread with 1000+viewers was opened (still existing) about this whereby Shi'i submissions are stated. It is Haram to curse Sahabah. Those who engage in that are the Yasiriyah led by Yasir Habib. They have a satellite tv called Fadak TV. They did curse and celebrate Eid for the death of Abu Bakar et al. Shia Majority do Taqlid of either Ayatullah Imam Ali Khamenei or Ayatullah Ali Sistani. Both of them declared cursing or abusing Sahabah as HARAM and INSULT to the teachings of Aimma of Ahl al-bayt.The reason i dont really flex my muscles on this issue of cursing is becus i have read and watched from Shia ulama sometimes about warning shias from cursing sahabas. So i believe they are working on it. However, i have to side with mrolai sometimes bcus just when everything is going smooth, you open a thread that appears to scorn Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman(RTA). Ths is what he's trying to tell you. You do curse them and openly show schism for them. This is contrary to what Shia Ulama are working on. I know you try to justify it by using Sunni books which is irrelevant to me. 2 Likes |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by Empiree: 12:55am On Jan 11, 2016 |
lexiconkabir:Well, you can ask MOD but i wont say to delete the whole thread as there are things for others to learn. You may ask to delete specific posts that you feel are inappropriate |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by MrOlai: 7:15am On Jan 11, 2016 |
Empiree: 1000000000000000 likes! 2 Likes |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by AlBaqir(m): 9:31am On Jan 11, 2016 |
Empiree: Meaning that a large portion of the Quran and Sunni sahih ahadith should be swept under the carpet?! # Do you know the reason why it is unavoidable sometimes? Sunni generally and Wahabiyah/Salafiyah in particular are fond of raising the status of Abu Bakr, Umar et al to the extent of belittling the holy Prophet and his purified Ahl al-Bayt. This is where Shia usually come out publicly and expose the truth about these Sahabah in accordance with their books. * For example how can you in a Shia presence say some women were not properly dressed and were busy joking with the Prophet; then Umar comes in, and Shaitan jumped out through the window upon hearing Umar's voice? * Or that Prophet could not fetch enough water from a certain well for his Ummah in his dreams until Umar stepped in and rescue the Ummah? * Or that Prophet feared Jubril had gone to Umar when at a stage revelation stopped from coming to the Prophet. I can go on and on. All these according to Sunni are Sahih. It is the duty of any Muhammad's lover to defend him and absolve him of those tale in light of the Quran and other ahadith. And there is no better this can be done except exposing the true nature of these Sahabah. # Again, The truth is whenever a Shia met in civil dialogue with any Salafiyah-Wahabiyah, they love inciting hatred of you by telling the audience "these are people who abuse and curse the Sahabah". Sunni History cannot be erased or forgotten. There is no way you want to unravel the truth without stepping on toes. So, Empiree, what has the Sunni as a whole, and Salafiyah in particular done to stop their lies and propaganda against the Shia? # The Prophet (s) said: The gravest sin is going to lengths in talking UNJUSTLY against a Muslim’s honour, and it is a major sin to abuse twice for abusing once. Ref: {Sunnan Abu Dawud, Book 41, Number 4859} It is not sin to read loud what Sunni recorded in their books regarding some Sahabah unless they are ready to delete those dark sides. It is only in your world that reading those ahadith aloud is equal "abusing and cursing the sahabah". However not talking about it publicly might be courtesy AND LET THE SALAFIYAH-WAHABIYAH STOP THEIR LIES AND DELIBERATE MISREPRESENTATIONS of Shia. You can start by warning MrOlai to stop his desperate, reckless and childish attitudes which has become his sunnah rather than using wisdom, good manners and sound argument. 1 Like 1 Share |
Re: Calling To The Unity Of The Mulim Ummah. by Nobody: 7:17pm On Jan 13, 2016 |
Wa alaykum salam wa rahmatullah wa baarakatuhu I guess they've said it all. There can only be unity on truth but let's know that tolerance is pertinent to creating a health, non violent relationship among us Muslims with respect to the sect and affiliation of each. |
Explanation Of Soorah Al-ikhlaas (purity Of Faith) / Is Allah Everywhere, Sees Everything? / Ashura: Weeping For Al-hussain Ibn 'ali, A Sunnah Established By The Prophet
(Go Up)
Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 128 |