Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,153,543 members, 7,819,931 topics. Date: Tuesday, 07 May 2024 at 07:00 AM

Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich - Business - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Business / Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich (2053 Views)

How Can A Person Living In Nigeria Become Rich? / Nigeria’s CBN Is Printing Money To Keep The Govt Afloat & Alarms Are Ringing. / Why Can't A Country Just Keep Printing Money And Become Rich (2) (3) (4)

(1) (Reply) (Go Down)

Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Leorichy: 1:41pm On Jun 01, 2016
Short Answer.


Currency has to stand for something productive. If you just print yourself certificates saying you graduated from Unilorin, it will be bogus. In the same way, printing money without economic activity is a bogus and sooner or later you will be in deep trouble.







Long Answer

Because money is not wealth.This is a fundamental misunderstanding that many people have about money,and in fact probably stands at the center of why some people are good at making money while others are not, why some people are wealthy and others are not.


(First, set aside the issues of inherited wealth, or "unfairly earned" money.


Those are distortive effects, but let's focus on the dominant factor)
Wealth ("being rich"wink means producing things of value. It does not mean "having lots of money."


The key word there is value. That word is more important than wealth or money, it is the real central factor around which human endeavor and economies revolve.


Money and wealth are big words that get a lot of play, but value is a boring word that most people don't notice. It is actually the important one.


Value is what is produced when you do work, mine resources, develop an idea, produce an invention, engage in mutually-beneficial commerce, etc.

Value is the "thing" that humans make (out of nothing) by working, creating, trading, etc.


Money, on the other hand, is a store of that value.
Typically, when you create some value, you want to trade it for something else of value so you can live (or play). But value is not always portable or fungible, so money is a technology used to store and transmit value through time and space - if you own a watermelon farm, the value you've created is in the form of watermelons.


The reason you can't fix poverty by redistributing money is that poverty is not a symptom of unequal distribution of money, it is a symptom of unequal distribution of value-creating capability.


The communists called it "the means of production" - in their day, it was ownership of factories, farms, shipyards, rental property, etc. The Objectivists call it "the creative power of men's minds."




Here's what happens if you evenly redistribute all money:


Let's say you do that, and everyone in the world has a million bucks.

The next day, it all ends up in the hands of the (erstwhile) rich again, because the rich control the farms and factories that produce food, clothing, they own all the rental properties, etc.

So prices skyrocket (because suddenly everyone can "afford" everything, so demand goes up, which drives up prices), and pretty soon all the people who own the means of production get all the money back because everyone is paying them for the things they need to live.


Of course, the regular guy (or the poor) still get paid a bit of the money for their labor in wages, but the people who own the large centers of production get paid a lot more money because they are producing more stuff that people want, i.e. value.


Being wealthy actually means controlling (owning) the means of producing value. You own your body and mind, which creates some value, but some people also own vast physical or virtual mechanisms (e.g. farms and factories) that produce huge volumes of value.


Redistributing money does not
redistribute this control (ownership). So "redistribution of wealth" is a tricky thing. Money isn't wealth, and if you redistribute it, it doesn't really change anything. You need to redistribute (or even out via other means) ownership of the means of value-creation, which is a far more complicated thing to do -you can't easily tax a rich guy a portion of his factory (not as easily as you can tax liquid profits in the form of money).


Thus, the real problem you're looking to solve is "how can I make it so that the poor control a larger proportion of value-creating power?"

12 Likes 3 Shares

Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Leorichy: 1:50pm On Jun 01, 2016
If you print money and give everyone that, the consequences will be similar to these:

German kids playing with money.

Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Leorichy: 1:52pm On Jun 01, 2016
Zimbabwae guy buying 3 eggs for 100 billion.

2 Likes

Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by suyamasta(m): 1:53pm On Jun 01, 2016
Leorichy:
Short Answer.


Thus, the real problem you're looking to solve is "how can I make it so that the poor control a larger proportion of value-creating power?"
Printed money can be directed at productive activities that do not rely on importation, thereby increasing productivity and spreading wealth! to the point where poverty becomes a simple choice! for any productive idea to work money is neeeded so that printed money would go a long way!
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Leorichy: 1:54pm On Jun 01, 2016
Shortly, the 100 trillion note was introduced to buy a glass of milk.

Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by suyamasta(m): 1:56pm On Jun 01, 2016
Leorichy:
If you print money and give everyone that, the consequences will be similar to these:

German kids playing with money.
there is a difference between printed money given to everyone and printed money directed towards selected productive activities!
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Leorichy: 1:56pm On Jun 01, 2016
German woman using currency as a burning fuel.

Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Leorichy: 2:06pm On Jun 01, 2016
suyamasta:
there is a difference between printed money given to everyone and printed money directed towards selected productive activities!

Do you really read the write up?

You are literally saying the same thing,can you give an example of this "selected productive activities" and how to go about it,cos Robert Mugabe had an idea about this "selective productive activities too"

P.S. And give me an example of a country that develop her economy by giving money for "selective productive activities"
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Nobody: 2:21pm On Jun 01, 2016
On Point!
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by suyamasta(m): 2:40pm On Jun 01, 2016
Leorichy:


Do you really read the write up?

You are literally saying the same thing,can you give an example of this "selected productive activities" and how to go about it,cos Robert Mugabe had an idea about this "selective productive activities too"

P.S. And give me an example of a country that develop her economy by giving money for "selective productive activities"
Please check again there is a difference there, selective productive activities like agriculture, industries, etc Robert had a far greater challenge especially with foreign countries
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by SammieLowkey(m): 4:00pm On Jun 01, 2016
I just learned something new(pardon my Ignorance). Thanks OP!
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by neocortex: 5:07pm On Jun 01, 2016
suyamasta:
Please check again there is a difference there, selective productive activities like agriculture, industries, etc Robert had a far greater challenge especially with foreign countries

Both are still dependent on the human factor,
it is not as if agriculture is a man somewhere who
doesn't like money.
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by acefreight: 5:09pm On Jun 01, 2016
Money has to be regulated, or else it will amount to too much inflation and a worthless paper.

1 Like

Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by suyamasta(m): 5:27pm On Jun 01, 2016
neocortex:

Both are still dependent on the human factor, it is not as if agriculture is a man somewhere who doesn't like money.
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by IamKollinx(m): 9:30pm On Jun 01, 2016
Bros, money na money.
Forget long grammar! undecided
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Leorichy: 10:12pm On Jun 01, 2016
acefreight:
Money has to be regulated, or else it will amount to too much inflation and a worthless paper.

yeah
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Leorichy: 10:16pm On Jun 01, 2016
IamKollinx:
Bros, money na money. Forget long grammar! undecided
read again,maybe you will understand this time!

1 Like

Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by IamKollinx(m): 11:29pm On Jun 01, 2016
Leorichy:


read again,maybe you will understand this time!

grin grin grin
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by biznus: 6:49am On Jun 02, 2016
Is the money system a BLESSING OR A CURSE?
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Leorichy: 8:41pm On Jun 12, 2016
biznus:
Is the money system a BLESSING OR A CURSE?

more of a blessing than a curse!
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Leorichy: 8:42pm On Jun 12, 2016
SammieLowkey:
I just learned something new(pardon my Ignorance). Thanks OP!

no one knows everything bro! You are welcome!
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by PureWays(m): 11:07pm On Jun 12, 2016
Yes. Money needs to b regulated else it will be worthless. When there is too much of a thing, its value drops.
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by dgr8est(m): 3:51am On Jun 13, 2016
Sometimes I ask why do Nigeria govt go borrowing money abroad while they can simply print here... (Ignorance) and now I know... (Knowledge)


D secret of the wealthy.....
Value (stored in Money) =Wealth
Re: Answer To: Why Can't A Country Keep On Printing Money And Become Rich by Leorichy: 2:14pm On Jul 13, 2016
PureWays:
Yes. Money needs to b regulated else it will be worthless. When there is too much of a thing, its value drops.

that's it

(1) (Reply)

Make Money Downloading And Ranking Apps / Indigo Metals...... Sell All Your Scrap Metals Today At Unbeatable Prices / Some Questions About Dangote's New Refinery

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 30
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.