Niflheim:
Masturbation is a sin? But the Hindus said that eating cow meat is the highest abomination and sin!!!

@op, do you believe what the Hindus said? And if not, why?

Timhim:
When people marry and they have sex, isn't it a sin since they defile the body of God. Even of they get married first. The girl is disvirgined and has been defiled so doing.


What If the man masturbateswith the imagination of his wife in his mind?

kulhud:



I don't believe, I am not an Hindu. I don't have the restriction from eating a cow meat.

QuietHammer:

Hypothetically, I am married with six kids with no intention of having another for financial reasons.
So, while having steamy sex with my wife on a cold night I removed my "johnnyboy" from my wife as I was about to hit the climax, choked the monkey(masturbated) for a few seconds and finished on her back like the good Apostle Johnson Sule to avoid getting her pregnant. Have I sinned?

hadow:
yes you have sinned for this is the same reason why judah's 2nd son onan was struck dead (genesis 38 :8-10)

QuietHammer:
So would my sin be me spilling my seed or me masturbating?

QuietHammer:
So would my sin be me spilling my seed or me masturbating?

kulhud:



sexual intercourse is meant for married couple so it isn't a sin. Cox the Bible made it known that *be fruitful and multiply* that can only happened is through sexual intercourse for married couple.

masturbation is bad, irrespective of the form the subject used to carried it out.



The bible never specified the kind of sin it is talking about. So it could mean that masturbation is a sin for unmarried people and not for married people who practice it with their spouses in mind.

hadow:
yes you have sinned for this is the same reason why judah's 2nd son onan was struck dead (genesis 38 :8-10)

Niflheim:
@kulhud,

Supposing I show you people who have "zero restriction" on masturbation, based on the fact that it is a part of their religious rite.........................................what will you say to that? Will you still insist that they will be eternally punished?

QuietHammer:

Hypothetically, I am married with six kids with no intention of having another for financial reasons.
So, while having steamy sex with my wife on a cold night I removed my "johnnyboy" from my wife as I was about to hit the climax, choked the monkey(masturbated) for a few seconds and finished on her back like the good Apostle Johnson Sule to avoid getting her pregnant. Have I sinned?

kulhud:



I don't believe, I am not an Hindu. I don't have the restriction from eating a cow meat.

Timhim:



Then Judah said to Onan, “Sleep with your brother’s wife and fulfill your duty to her as a brother-in-law to raise up offspring for your brother.” 9 But Onan knew that the child would not be his; so whenever he slept with his brother’s wife, he spilled his semen on the ground to keep from providing offspring for his brother. 10 What he did was wicked in the Lord’s sight; so the Lord put him to death also.




MEANING THAT HE WAS KILLED BECAUSE HE DIDNT WANT THE WOMAN TO HAVE OFFSPRINGS. GOD LOOKED AT HIM AS JEALOUS AND WICKED FOR NOT WANTING THE WOMAN TO HAVE OFFSPRINGS AND FOR KILLING THE OFFSPRINGS.