Often times, I've seen people bidding others farewell in Arabic by saying Ma salam and the reply I often hear is Bi -Salam.
Also, local mualims encourage their wards to reply with Bi- salam.
In my opinion, I think the reply to Ma salam should be Ma salam as well or Fii amani lahi.
Can someone tell me the meaning of Bi Salam? and is my opinion correct?
CC All Muslims.

Bi -Salam means "with peace" or "in peace"

Like we say Bi smillah

'Bi' acts on the succeeding verb and changes its vowel. It also gives the meanings of ‘for or through’.


بي سالم "with peace"

It's not good to use both Ma'Salaam and Bi Salaam. Salam Alaykum and WA Alaykumus salaam is sufficient for us.

^
why are you in haste to declare somethign not good?. All types of greetings that are sahih are all okay to use. There is nothing wrong with it.

Ma-Salaam مع السلامة = Goodbye. Goodbye is used in Arabic, farewell. Farewell is used in Arabic. The word masalam is used in Arabic meaning goodbye,farewell. It's like wishing you a peaceful and safety journey or other stuff.....we said this when we goodbye someone.

^^^If you are talking as an Arabic language speaker then I say there's nothing wrong in saying: Ma'Salaam and Bi Salaam.

But, if you are talking as a Muslim, then I say, the greetings of Islam is sufficient for us. Do you claim to understand the Arabic Language or Arab traditions more than the Salafu Saalih?

THIS IS HOW BID'AH BEGINS.

^^

Smh...I won't drag this. I knew you would end up saying this. Greeting is greeting. Just like saying "eld mubarak" etc even if sahaba didn't do it. But at masjid I frequent, they are adherents of salafism and their mufti said

"greeting is greeting if the content is khayr...doesn't matter if salaf did it or not. ..ignore the zealots "

For this reason, I wont drag this with you. It has nothing to do with bidah. So get over it.

iamgenius:
^^^If you are talking as an Arabic language speaker then I say there's nothing wrong in saying: Ma'Salaam and Bi Salaam.

But, if you are talking as a Muslim, then I say, the greetings of Islam is sufficient for us. Do you claim to understand the Arabic Language or Arab traditions more than the Salafu Saalih?

THIS IS HOW BID'AH BEGINS.

Oga Bid'ah , salam alaykum self is a general greeting in Saudi Arabia (Note ;not only Muslims live there).
But why do you like the Bid'ah talk so much?

Empiree:
Bi -Salam means "with peace" or "in peace"

Like we say Bi smillah

'Bi' acts on the succeeding verb and changes its vowel. It also gives the meanings of ‘for or through’.


بي سالم "with peace"

Well, Ma salamat= With peace.
Bi salam also means with peace.

What I think is , non Arabic speakers do not want to repeat the word Ma salam when replyiny, that's why they changed it to Bi salam which also means the same thing.
But to me, it seems wrong grammatically.


Ma salamat =Ma salamat






My opinion, it might be wrong though.

Raintaker:
Well, Ma salamat= With peace.
Bi salam also means with peace.

What I think is , non Arabic speakers do not want to repeat the word Ma salam when replyiny, that's why they changed it to Bi salam which also means the same thing.
But to me, it seems wrong grammatically.


Ma salamat =Ma salamat






My opinion, it might be wrong though.

i dont think it has anything to do with non muslims actually unless it can be theoretically proven. It is common grammar in arabic. Search on net and you see arab actually seldom use it. As always, none of these is obligatory, and it is nonissue. I dont even recollect the last time i heard until you brought it up here

Empiree:
^^

Smh...I won't drag this. I knew you would end up saying this. Greeting is greeting. Just like saying "eld mubarak" etc even if sahaba didn't do it. But at masjid I frequent, they are adherents of salafism and their mufti said

"greeting is greeting if the content is khayr...doesn't matter if salaf did it or not. ..ignore the zealots "

For this reason, I wont drag this with you. It has nothing to do with bidah. So get over it.

Did I say it's BID'AH? Read what I wrote again.
The Imam is right.

Raintaker:
Oga Bid'ah , salam alaykum self is a general greeting in Saudi Arabia (Note ;not only Muslims live there).
But why do you like the Bid'ah talk so much?

Never call me at strikethrough again.

You are talking linguistically not islamically, I'm doing both. I hate my deeds and my fellow Muslims deed get wasted.

iamgenius:


Did I say it's BID'AH? Read what I wrote again.

of course you didnt but your statement is in the borderline

Empiree:
of course you didnt but your statement is in the borderline

So that we should be cautious.

iamgenius:


Never call me at strikethrough again.

You are talking linguistically not islamically, I'm doing both. I hate my deeds and my fellow Muslims deed get wasted.

OK, I won't call you that again.

Empiree:
i dont think it has anything to do with non muslims actually unless it can be theoretically proven. It is common grammar in arabic. Search on net and you see arab actually seldom use it. As always, none of these is obligatory, and it is nonissue. I dont even recollect the last time i heard until you brought it up here

Yh, its not really a serious issue.
I heard it yesterday though.
It's a common farewell greeting around here. As you said, it's non issue.

I have an interest in learning new languages. In www.bestaustralianessays.com, I have learn English language but I don't have an idea about Islamic language. It is really hard to learn.

The Arabs reply ma'as salaamah with ma'as salaamah and this is done when the conversation is about to finish and the participants want to depart... Although nothing is wrong with saying that, or saying raafaqatkas salaamah or ilal liqaa'i and so on, but saying Salaam alaykum is better, it only becomes compulsory to say salaam alaykum when responding to a salaam alaykum....

AbdelKabir:
The Arabs reply ma'as salaamah with ma'as salaamah and this is done when the conversation is about to finish and the participants want to depart... Although nothing is wrong with saying that, or saying raafaqatkas salaamah or ilal liqaa'i and so on, but saying Salaam alaykum is better, it only becomes compulsory to say salaam alaykum when responding to a salaam alaykum....

Toyeeb!

Township is a game that has been township hack distributed by Playrix Games. This game was first discharged in 2013, and from that point forward i
township cheats android