The controversy the US has raised surrounding Turkey’s strategic procurement of the long-range missile system isn’t about NATO’s security, but competition.
The United States’ removal of Turkey from the F-35 joint fighter programme comes at considerable cost to the NATO alliance, overlooking the fact that Turkey has spent millions on developing a $1.5 trillion stealth fighter that was only possible through joint investment in the first place.

But there is a cost for the hasty decision that Washington has overlooked.

Turkey produces nearly 900 parts for the F-35 programme, and its removal will cost the programme an additional $9 billion in taxpayer costs for participants across the board, with losses of at least half a billion dollars.

There’s a strategic price to pay as well as well, and one that is far more damaging. To deny Turkey, NATO’s second largest army, the F-35 fighter jet is to weaken NATO’s southern flank. For the US, that may not amount to much given how the disdain and disregard it's shown for NATO in recent times.

But NATO is well aware that any Russian incursion into Eastern Europe, through hybrid or conventional warfare, cannot advance without securing its flank from the southern Turkish side. It's perhaps for this reason that NATO has always maintained a sizeable presence in Turkish airfields. It's a matter of force projection.

It's easy to forget that only a short time ago, with conflict raging to Turkey's south in Iraq and Syria, both victims of rampant terrorism and civil war, Turkey was the bulwark against chaos spilling over spreading. Had Daesh reached Central Asia or the Caucuses, Europe would look very different together.

Let's be objective though. Washington’s rejection of the S-400, and its consequent suspension of Turkey from the F-35 programme was never about ‘security’.

NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg himself conceded in clear terms that Turkey has the sovereign right to determine matters of national security and territorial integrity by procuring any equipment of its choosing.

To be fair, NATO’s secretary general really couldn’t say otherwise given that Greece and Bulgaria, both NATO members, purchased the Russian S-300 missile system, with not a protest raised.

What’s different this time? The US stands to lose.

Russia’s S-400 missile platform is the best in its class and can’t be compared to the US Patriot system. For one, the Patriot is a defensive system. Second, and more importantly, the Patriot platform is surrounded in myth, and what little performance data is available about it shows a shockingly poor performance.

During the 1991 Gulf War, it only achieved a 25 percent to 50 percent intercept ratio, according to a congressional research service that tried to get to the bottom of what happened later.

Those are dicey odds at best, and given Turkey’s geopolitical neighbourhood, procuring a defensive missile system that only works one time in four is something arguably hard to justify to the Turkish electorate.

But then again, maybe the US has worked out the kinks in the Patriot missile system since?

They haven’t. Saudi Arabia learned that first-hand trying to shoot down antiquated scud missiles fired by Yemeni rebels. The very same missiles the Patriot missile system failed to shoot down in the 1991 Operation Desert Storm.

In footage taken of the missiles, some missed, while one pulled a U-turn and exploded in Riyadh itself.

The verdict is out.

The US hasn’t offered alternatives that meet Turkey’s national security needs. The Patriot missile system has also never been on the negotiating table. Turkey has been trying to procure it for decades, and the US never seems to be willing to close the deal.

If anything, the few Patriot platforms stationed along the Turkish-Syrian border were withdrawn in 2015, and later from Turkey’s Incirlik air base, leaving gaping holes in Turkey’s defence coverage.

The US is not keen to see Turkey grow stronger because it means an end to superpower politics as nation states choose the path of self-determination and self-sufficiency.

The age of superpower blocs and unilateral force is coming to an end.

The US foreign policy elite seem to have forgotten that countries have their sovereignty and unique national interests, and that the United States is not at liberty to dictate an entire people’s future.

Current US foreign policy right now relies on a bullish approach, more comfortable in pulling strings and pushing allies in line; leading by force rather than inspiration and genuine alliances of goodwill.

Here’s why Turkey is justified.

Turkey's surrounding region will not stabilise short of a strong state that can project authority and stability, demanding a strong offensive and defensive offset capability that the S-400 provides.

Relying on the US for this would be folly given how many times American unilateralism has diverged from Turkey’s interests, as with its arming the YPG and the groups that gave rise to Daesh.

There's more. The US’s refusal to extradite FETO leader Fetullah Gulen, who instigated a bloody attempted coup that saw the deaths of hundreds and injuries of nearly 2,200 speaks volumes. Specifically, it speaks of the US's readiness to support a non-state separatist group and terrorist actor over its alleged ally, a troubling reflection of the stock the country puts into its alliance with Turkey.

With brewing tensions over hydrocarbon reserves in Cyprus, Turkey is applying its own anti-access/area-denial (A2/AD) strategy, and deeply conscious of the need for that capacity.

Trust needs to be rebuilt. Meanwhile, Turkey’s indigenous, sovereign defence industry will do what it must. Technology transfer is a key pillar of Turkey’s defence complex, and one it does well. Perhaps the best example of this is Turkey’s indigenous attack helicopter, developed following a technology transfer from Italy.

President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has vowed to eliminate external dependency on foreign defence technology by 2023. In line with this, the Turkish S-400 deal includes a technology transfer clause. It’s not inconceivable to see Turkey joint-produce the S-500, an even more advanced platform with Russia in the future.

On the other hand, it took the US a full 17 months to reconsider selling their Patriot missile system to Turkey, and even then with no technology transfer clause included.

The S-400 is only as good as it's missiles, and that'll only get better with time as more older missiles are swapped out with more advanced variants. Currently reaching ranges of up to 400km away, the S-400 can fire multiple interceptors at once. The Patriot by contrast, can only fire one interceptor missile at a time with a range of 96km.

The S-400 also features the 9M96E2 hypersonic missile, bringing Turkey forward decades in defence technology by mere acquisition. The missile can fly at Mach 15 or five kilometres per second, hitting targets as low as five metres above ground, while manoeuvring at blistering speeds of 20 Gs. Humans can handle a maximum of 9 Gs for a few seconds and even then using special equipment.

Turkey made the right decision in procuring the S-400. While the loss of the F-35 is a heavy price to pay, it’s a good thing Turkeyʿs first prototype of its indigenous stealth fighter, the TAI TF-X will be ready by 2023.



AUTHOR
Abdullah Masri
Abdullah is a Middle East is a geopolitical and economic analyst based in Istanbul, Turkey.

Nice analysis

At least quote the source/ give credit to the writer...

Nice one, but one of the things the writer overlooked is that Turkey's military chiefs were aware of how the S-400 was "painting" all US planes in Syria, which include the F22 raptor. .

The term "painting" means the SAM system spots and lock on the enemy's plane, to the awareness of the pilot, telling him that "we can see you and can kill you", and we know the F22 Raptor is supposed to be "invisible".

It was from that moment Turkey knew they must buy the S400. They own the Incirlik airbase were US stealth planes are based, and so they were aware of everything that was happening in the sky over the Syrian/Turkish airspace.

Thus, they went for it with all their might, knowing well that as far as the S400 is concerned, the F35 and any other stealth plane in the world is nothing but a flying coffin.

If Turkey after spending billions on the F35 decided to sacrifice it for a SAM system produced by a country hostile to NATO, and which is also in the opposite side against Turkey in the Syrian crisis, then that tells you that there is something unique about the S400. and Turkey knew it is worth breaking some ties with the US or NATO. That is the fact!

Uncle Sam knew that for every shipping of the S400 to countries abroad, its air supremacy is being reduced and curtailed severely. That was why the US introduced CAATSA, a bill aimed at sanctioning nations that dares to buy the Russian S400. They never did that with the S300. That again tells you the SAM is so potent that the US knew that their air supremacy is now being eroded, and would only be 100% effective against hapless nations like Nigeria and the Taliban's.

Russia just made the F35 and its 1.5 Trillion dollar project obsolete without even firing a single shot.

Now tell me, why won't Turkey tow the line of reality that they recently took? Even Saudi Arabia and Qatar are also queing up for it, because they knew the truth as well. Just that they don't want to humiliate the US publicly .

All of these underlined the fact that when it comes to missile technology, the US and the rest of the gang are still in primary school.

Heck! The US is racing to produce hypersonic missiles while Russia already fields them.. The ediots can't even go to space without Russian rocket engines.

Super power indeed. Pathetic.

That’s a great analysis! Just to add to that; Turkey wanted to buy the patriot along with technology transfer, the US is not willing to give out the technology behind their main defense system and that was why the Obama administration declined.

US was ready to sell the defense system to Turkey as long as it will keep Turkey away from Russia but not with the technology.

Also, I would expect that the US take advantage of the S400 in turkeys possession to do some practice with it but they are more worried about the S400 passing the FriendsAndFoe Identification of the F-35 to Russia.

Another thing is, Russia is always selling an export version of their systems, that way it’s full capabilities remain their secret.

sunboy:
That’s a great analysis! Just to add to that; Turkey wanted to buy the patriot along with technology transfer, the US is not willing to give out the technology behind their main defense system and that was why the Obama administration declined.

US was ready to sell the defense system to Turkey as long as it will keep Turkey away from Russia but not with the technology.

Also, I would expect that the US take advantage of the S400 in turkeys possession to do some practice with it but they are more worried about the S400 passing the FriendsAndFoe Identification of the F-35 to Russia.

Another thing is, Russia is always selling an export version of their systems, that way it’s full capabilities remain their secret.

Well said. Come to think of it: if Russia is selling the S400 (though an export version), one can only imagine what the S-500 will do.. No doubt, the sons of Rus are king of the rocket doom.