Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,152,436 members, 7,815,991 topics. Date: Thursday, 02 May 2024 at 10:59 PM

Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank - Investment (4) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Investment / Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank (60139 Views)

Fixed Deposit Interest Rates for Diamondbank, Stanbic & Skyebank - Comparison / Zenith Bank Fixed Deposit Interest Rate / Interest Rates On Fixed Time/tenure Deposits In Nigerian Banks (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by CyberWolf: 5:01pm On Dec 13, 2014
duni04:
10% in 365 days??! When you can make10% in 1 day on equities. Only really ignorant people still subscribe to fixed deposits.
pls can you throw more light on equities?
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by DonDiego(m): 5:02pm On Dec 13, 2014
duni04:

U never lose money in equities. You buy a stake in a company and if the company does well, the price climbs and you sell higher. If it doesnt, you wait till the next quarter. Very simple. That's apart from the dividend they pay u.
If only it is as neat and simple as you make it sound. The volatility of the equities market is such that it can drive heavy losers into suicide as it did around 2008/9 here in Nigeria and around the world. The money market instrument we are discussing here isnt as volatile.

1 Like

Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by Nobody: 5:03pm On Dec 13, 2014
duni04:
10% in 365 days??! When you can make10% in 1 day on equities. Only really ignorant people still subscribe to fixed deposits.

Pls shed more light on equities bro
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by ednut1(m): 5:07pm On Dec 13, 2014
ify84:
While will I do 365 days: 10%
And get 30 days at 9.25%...

Won't I just keep repeating the 30 days option

abi, they won't allow me to keep fixing every 30days
d rate is per annum. So for 30 days. Divide 9.25% by 12. Hahahaha. Used to think like u bro. Till i went to a bank to subscribe. Only to find out.

2 Likes

Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by tayejay(m): 5:08pm On Dec 13, 2014
[/color]
naijacutee:
[color=#000099]Last month, I happened upon some money from an old investment which had matured. Rather than have it collect “one one naira” in my standard savings account, I decided not to be the fly that follows the corpse to the grave, and put it in a fixed deposit. Fixed deposits are a very popular investment option in Nigeria, and you’ll hear about them 8 times of out 10 if you do happen to ask for advice regarding how to invest money. The attraction to this sort of investment is that returns are guaranteed, and the duration of your investment is flexible. We probably like this sort of investment because they help us mitigate risks – in a country where nothing is guaranteed, we don’t tend to tie money down in long term investments and fixed deposits are the perfect solution to this investment problem. In the course of my search for a decent return on my investment, I “burnt” at least N5,000 in credit, calling banks and waiting in queues for information, and was only able to reasonably compare two banks – GTBank and First Bank.

What is a fixed deposit?
A fixed deposit is a lump sum deposited with a bank for a varying period, in exchange for interest.
How to put your money in a fixed deposit: You will need to have an existing account with the bank of your choice, and then you deposit the sum into this account. You will then need to inform your bank of your intention to “fix” the said sum for “X” number of days. It is very important that before you make your decision, that you shop around for the best rates. You are not obliged to fix your money with your existing bank, just because you bank with them. You can earn a significantly higher amount by just picking up the phone. It is the more difficult route when you consider call waiting times, credit spent etc but it is worth it, and what’s more I have done some of this hard work for you.

How long is my money fixed for?
Most banks offer flexible periods of 30 days, 60 days, 90 days, 180 days and one year.

How do I get paid?
Usually, the money is removed from your account and the interest is paid into your account. So for example, you want to fix N500,000 for 60 days and the bank has offered you an interest rate of 7%. You have N550,000 in your account. Once you confirm you’re making the arrangement and sign all the necessary documentation, the N500,000 “disappears” from your account to be “fixed”. At the end of 60 days, you get paid back your original N500,000 + an additional N35,000 interest accrued. A simplified version of what really happens behind the scenes is that the N500,000 is given to another customer who has asked for a loan – but he will be charged 20% interest (or N100,000). After 60 days, you get back your N500,000 + N35,000 (7% interest from the other customers N100,000). Not bad business for banks, if you ask me.

I disagree with u on this interest calculation and its quite misleading. You only earn the complete 7 percent in one year, but at 60 days or 2months fixed, u get paid one sixth of this amount. Mind u banks often use compound or simple interest rates not flat rate as u have portrayed it.


Bank interest rate comparisons
For my enquiries, I called First Bank and GTBank.
I rated both banks on customer service quality (pet peeve of mine, because time is money) and interest rates.
tbankvsfirstbank

Interest rates
First Bank
7 days (First bank does not offer this service)
30 days – 9.25%
60 days: 9.50%
90 days: 9.75%
365 days: 10%
GTBank
Available from N100,000 to N1m.
7 days – 3.75%
30 days – 180 days : 6.25%
Some notes:
Call times. My initial contact with both banks was on a Friday afternoon, at about 5.30pm. My second contact attempt with GTBank after the first one proved futile was at 3.20pm on a Sunday.
Omissions. I initially wanted to include Accessbank in this exercise, but have been unlucky in getting through to a knowledgeable person on customer service. The frontline staff I have spoken to, all seem to lack basic knowledge regarding what services their banks offer and where to get information outside the limits of their knowledge. I would recommend that training is provided for all front line staff as a matter of urgency, as customers otherwise have no way of getting informed about competitive rates for your most lucrative services.
Am I an agent? I work for neither of these banks. My selection of this two is purely by chance and accessibility of contact information via the bank websites. I simply picked the banks with the most prominent contact information via websites. My reviews are unbiased, and if I haven’t reviewed any others yet, don’t worry – “life is turn by turn”.

Courtesy: http://www.mrpepe.com/banking/which-is-the-best-account-for-a-fixed-deposit-gtbank-or-firstbank/



disagree with u on this interest calculation and its quite misleading. You only earn the complete 7 percent in one year, but at 60 days or 2months fixed, u get paid one sixth of this amount. Mind u banks often use compound or simple interest rates not flat rate as u have portrayed it

1 Like

Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by sekzy99(m): 5:12pm On Dec 13, 2014
naijacutee:


Thanks - hope it helps someone.
pls u did nt state d least amount first bank accepts
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by Nobody: 5:13pm On Dec 13, 2014
garrimallam:
Bros pls get the computation right:
7% interest of N500,000 for 60day is computed thus;
0.07 x 500000 x 60\365
= N5,753.425

What u assumed for 60days for 1year ie 365 days.

Thanks

The correct answer

2 Likes

Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by ednut1(m): 5:15pm On Dec 13, 2014
sekzy99:
pls u did nt state d least amount first bank accepts
100k
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by soonest(f): 5:15pm On Dec 13, 2014
Caracta:
Besides, these rates depend on negotiations. They are not fixed. I look at how much you are bringing in and the duration.

Again, these rates are not fixed. We only have fixed limits or benchmarks. Get your facts right.
For 400000 at first bank what's the fixed limit
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by Caracta(f): 5:26pm On Dec 13, 2014
soonest:

For 400000 at first bank what's the fixed limit

For how long? It depends on the duration/tenor. What you get depends on your negotiation with the bank.
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by Nobody: 5:30pm On Dec 13, 2014
naijacutee:


Thanks - hope it helps someone.
You don't know how this has really opened my eye. God bless you for posting the most reasonable topic I have seen on Nairaland for 2 months now.

I have a question, can the time be extended to 2-3yrs or any time I want. For example, I want 1million naira to be withdrawn from my account and and paid back in 3yrs time with the interest
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by Caracta(f): 5:33pm On Dec 13, 2014
ernie4life:

Advice: instead of fixing your money for 90 days in banks and the will still charge u 10% withholding tax, why not buy treasury bills from CBN which comes with no withholding tax, the interest is paid upfront, it's very secured even more than banks and the rates are always higher than the inflation rate which is about 8% now



Disclaimer : Everything written here is my opinion not yours so keep your criticism to your self

Nice one. However, for treasury bills, there is an annual charge now...though very little. It's "risk-free" too. Though sometimes, if you negotiate well, you can get higher rates from fixed deposit than treasury bills, Treasury bills has a minimum tenor of 91 days unlike fixed deposits that still takes 30 days.
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by Caracta(f): 5:35pm On Dec 13, 2014
Weselion:
You don't know how this has really opened my eye. God bless you for posting the most reasonable topic I have seen on Nairaland for 2 months now.

I have a question, can the time be extended to 2-3yrs or any time I want. For example, I want 1million naira to be withdrawn from my account and and paid back in 3yrs time with the interest

You can fix for a year and give an instruction for it to be rolled over at maturity, either principal only or principal + interest. It can go on for as long as you want. It's risky though. Just be sure it's not a bank that can disappear grin.

Good thing is, you have the option of terminating your investment at any time, You just get to lose 20% of the accrued interest. Your principal would still be intact.
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by soonest(f): 5:36pm On Dec 13, 2014
Caracta:


For how long? It depends on the duration/tenor. What you get depends on your negotiation with the bank.
For 90days. Just give me the benchmark. Thanks
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by ernie4life(m): 5:37pm On Dec 13, 2014
Caracta:


Nice one. However, for treasury bills, there is an annual charge now...though very little. It's "risk-free" too. Though sometimes, if you negotiate well, you can get higher rates from fixed deposit than treasury bills, Treasury bills has a minimum tenor of 91 days unlike fixed deposits that still takes 30 days.

My advice was specifically for 90 days tenored investment. I forgot to add range of amount though because if you are investing 5m and above u could probably negotiate a better rate on fixed deposit. Thanks for your correction
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by sekzy99(m): 5:38pm On Dec 13, 2014
ednut1:
100k
tnks. Wish dis came earlier. Squander 150k around oct on a useless course
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by iyatrustee(f): 5:40pm On Dec 13, 2014
Dalby:
The interest rate given is annual not monthly, so the calculations are wrong.
N500,000 at 7% means N35,000 / year.
for 30days i.e 1 month it is N35,000/12 since 12 months make a year N2,916.67. At the end of 30days you have N502,916.67.
wink wink wink

It's even 365days or 366( as the case may be in a leap year) used in calculating and not 12months

Bear in mind that 10% of your interest goes to govt in the name of Withholding Tax
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by Caracta(f): 5:41pm On Dec 13, 2014
soonest:

For 90days. Just give me the benchmark. Thanks

9.75%

ernie4life:

My advice was specifically for 90 days tenored investment. I forgot to add range of amount though because if you are investing 5m and above u could probably negotiate a better rate on fixed deposit. Thanks for your correction 

True that.
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by EchuaA: 5:43pm On Dec 13, 2014
@ OP dis pos is totally misleading tnx 2 @ Dalby u tried 2put d OP ryt but bear in mind dat even ur interest is taxed, eventually u r left with a paltry miserable sum dat gets u pretty disgusted angry
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by tunde705(m): 5:43pm On Dec 13, 2014
duni04:
10% in 365 days??! When you can make10% in 1 day on equities. Only really ignorant people still subscribe to fixed deposits.
bros abeg school me on this equity stuff.
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by Nicepoker(m): 5:54pm On Dec 13, 2014
Tenim47:
how does dis ad to my amount? Mtchew
cos u brain is dead. Poverty don finish u sorry.

1 Like

Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by femummy(f): 5:58pm On Dec 13, 2014
angelo82:
Rates from Access head office will be good but the mixture of old inter-continental bank staff has create Fixed Deposit cartel and the information is not clear.Access bank was doing FRD before which means fixed rate deposit and the rate was very high but the branch network cartel of Old Intercontinental has destroyed it.....Thats why contact center can't give you any viable information......Good work though!....




The reason the F R D has a high interest rate is because it is a special product and when you fix your money there, there will be no liquidation until maturity no matter the emergency, unlike the ordinary fixed deposit. They still do the fixed rate deposit in access, problem is their front desk officers don't market it.
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by angelo82: 6:03pm On Dec 13, 2014
They have removed it from their website....And the staff they don't want you to buy into it.....I have done it two times both 180days and 365days and its good until their branch starts suppressing my deposit.....Access Bank really need to pay off Intercontinental staff so that the corporate appearance of Access can actually look like Access bank because to me the behavior of some of their branches is still within Akingbolas structure....



femummy:



The reason the F R D has a high interest rate is because it is a special product and when you fix your money there, there will be no liquidation until maturity no matter the emergency, unlike the ordinary fixed deposit. They still do the fixed rate deposit in access, problem is their front desk officers don't market it.

1 Like

Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by duni04(m): 6:08pm On Dec 13, 2014
DonDiego:

If only it is as neat and simple as you make it sound. The volatility of the equities market is such that it can drive heavy losers into suicide as it did around 2008/9 here in Nigeria and around the world. The money market instrument we are discussing here isnt as volatile.
Funny u mentioned 2008 cos after the burst that year, many people bought equities at record lows and turned into overnight billionairs from 2009 to 2011, while people like you were screaming that venturing into the stock market would lead to suicide.
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by emperoracro(m): 6:12pm On Dec 13, 2014
I don't know how anyone in his right mind will go and fix a sum of money below #1M as fixed deposit, when there are several other ways of increasing ur money. FD pays very low interest. On 500k, u will get less dan 6K for 2months, wen one can get over 70k investing in other tins. Treasury bill is better,but still no worth it to me, and Equity is quite risky cos most Nigerian company are shrouded in secrecy.
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by korel9: 6:13pm On Dec 13, 2014
erico2k2:

Yes but the risk in them biz is way higher than that of Banks

Yeah I get it

Was actually referring to "Outside The Risk" thingy
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by ednut1(m): 6:14pm On Dec 13, 2014
duni04:

Funny u mentioned 2008 cos after the burst that year, many people bought equities at record lows and turned into overnight billionairs from 2009 to 2011, while people like you were screaming that venturing into the stock market would lead to suicide.
imagine i had shares in afribank. Oceanic and intercontinental like my family friend worth over 1. 5m. And it all vanished. Stop painting dis tin as if der are no risks involved. I suspect ur a stock broker

2 Likes

Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by waleadex(m): 6:17pm On Dec 13, 2014
Ebenezerk2:
No bank on earth can pay you this amount for a month, it must be for a year, you must have fixed it for a year, so they paid you upfront, you better ask them
12monthis man...
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by lukman22: 6:18pm On Dec 13, 2014
Duni04 please enlighten us on equities
duni04:
10% in 365 days??! When you can make10% in 1 day on equities. Only really ignorant people still subscribe to fixed deposits.
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by waleadex(m): 6:18pm On Dec 13, 2014
Nsonaso:
Which bank
First bank... for duration of 12months.
Re: Results On Comparing Fixed Deposit Interest Rates Between First Bank And Gtbank by emperoracro(m): 6:19pm On Dec 13, 2014
duni04:

Funny u mentioned 2008 cos after the burst that year, many people bought equities at record lows and turned into overnight billionairs from 2009 to 2011, while people like you were screaming that venturing into the stock market would lead to suicide.

You are right. But stock trading and equity isnt for everyone, no need forcing pple into it by painting it as sometin easy n risk free. Its meant for accredited investor (pple who can afford to loose their money not pple who ar still struggling). I will rather invest in start up biz dan in big firms for reasons best know to me,though i have conditions i will check out first

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (Reply)

My MMM Story -the Money, The Madness And The Miracle / Crypto Is Not Just For Me, Massive Loss (millions Gone Under 2 Days / MMM Returns With New Strategy

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 65
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.