Katamo's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Katamo's Profile › Katamo's Posts
1 2 (of 2 pages)
pluto09:Agreed. Barring a large shock in oil prices, I don't think CBN will willingly devalue the naira. It seems this government is obsessed with defending the naira at great expense of our foreign reserves. |
aremso:So just last week CBN introduced longer-term naira/USD contracts for up to 5 year settlement. Based on the contract prices published by the FMDQ, the longest dated contract maturing in January 2025 is priced at 379.81, implying a minimal discount of 4.0% to spot rate of 364.85 in the I&E Window. This makes me believe that CBN will continue to defend the naira as they will have to take large losses on currency devaluation. But then again, CBN can sometimes be irrational! |
zohan101:I'm not sure the answer to this but I think it is no - you likely have to complete an application each time your previous investment matures and you want to reinvest. You can ask one of the banks that act as primary dealer market makers to confirm. The list of those back are in the link below: https://www.dmo.gov.ng/fgn-bonds/primary-dealers-market-makers/2516-list-of-pdmms-as-at-august-01-2018/file |
TotoNaRubber:If you understand bond math nobody can cheat you. If one is investing in these types of instruments it is very important to have a clear understanding of how they are priced and what the underlying investment risks are. |
igbizen:Correct. If you hold until maturity you do not lose any capital. Let me try to clarify a bit more since it seems people still have a lot of questions. If you sell before maturity there are three things that can happen: 1. If the interest rate for newly issued similar bonds with the same time until maturity is greater than the coupon rate on your bond you will sell each unit at a lower price than you bought 2. If the interest rate for newly issued similar bonds with the same time until maturity is lower than the coupon rate on your bond you will sell each unit at a high price than you bought 3. If the interest rate for newly issued similar bonds with the same time until maturity is equal to the coupon rate on your bond you will sell each unit at a the same price that you bought The principle is that investors will demand a return that is consistent with what the rate of return the market dictates at any point in time. As an investor, if you can buy a new issuance of 3-yr FGN savings bond at a today's yield of 11.296% (which is the same as the coupon rate since it is a newly issued bond at par), you will pay less for a 10-yr bond with 3 years left to maturity that only pays a coupon of 8% (example 1 above). However, you will be willing to pay more for a 5-yr bond with 3 years left to maturity that pays a coupon of 16% (example 2 above). If the coupon rate on the secondary market bond at the time the bond is sold is equal to the yield (or current coupon on new FGN bonds) you will pay the same price as what you would pay for the new FGN bond (par) since in reality, the payment schedule will be exactly the same as that of a new issuance, that is they are identical from a financial perspective since you are getting the same scheduled interest payments and return of principal at maturity (example 3 above). |
TotoNaRubber:No. In this example, the new buyer will pay N1,073 and receive N163.9 per year for 2 years and N1,000 return of principal at the end of the second year. The interest payment is 15.27% of the investment (N163.9/N1,073) but the return of principal is only N1,000 and not N1,703 which reduces the yield/return to 12.03%. |
TotoNaRubber:I can speak to the coupon versus yield question. If my explanation below is difficult to follow, the short answer is that the number you should be looking at and using to compare with other investment opportunities at is the yield. When a bond is issued, there is a coupon rate associated with it (in this case 16.39%). If the bond is issued at par (N1,000), then what this means that the bond investor will pay N1,000 and every year he/she will get N163.9 in interest payments (typically paid out every 6 months, so N81.95). When a bond is issued at par, the coupon rate equals the yield so an investor who holds this bond until maturity will earn a yield of 16.39% in this case. Things start getting trick when the initial investor decides to sell the bond in the secondary market. In this case, let's assume that the investor bought a 5-year bond and has held it for 3 years but wants to sell. The new buyer will therefore receive 2 years of interest payments and the return of the bond principal (N1,000 invested by the initial owner). In this situation, the bond is being sold at a yield of 12.03%. Since the yield is lower than then coupon, that means that interest rates have decreased compared to when the bond was issued. Therefore the new bond buyer will need to pay more money (above par) for a bond that pays out 16.39% interest because the interest rate today is only 12.03%. If you do the math, what this means is that the buyer will pay about N1,073 for every N1,000 par value of bond to earn a yield of 12.03%. He/she will then receive 2 years of interest payments (N81.95 every 6 months) and the return of the original face value of the bond (N1,000). |
We have difficulty servicing debts – Federal Govt https://punchng.com/we-have-difficulty-servicing-debts-federal-govt/ Should we as T-Bills investors be concerned about possible default? Interested in what other think about this |
Good thread. One of the most acclaimed books on value investing is "The Intelligent Investor" written by Benjamin Graham - widely regarded as the father of value investing. Here is a link to the e-book for those who are interested: https://www.e-reading.club/bookreader.php/133361/The_Intelligent_Investor.pdf I found chapter 20, which covers the concept of margin of safety, very educational. In any case, you will need to overlay "Nigerian factor" to some of the concepts in the book since our market is not as developed in terms of efficiency, liquidity etc. When investing, always remember that it's not what you buy that is most important, it's what you pay. Good luck investing! |
Acidosis:You would need to consider the inflation rate for the term of the TBill. So if you invest at the beginning of January 2019, you will look to the expected inflation rate for 2019. Also, be sure to use the true yield of the TBill in the calculation for a more accurate result. In this example, a 15% one-year TBill rate results in a true yield of 17.6%. |
speedyconnect3:What you are asking for is the "real return" or "real interest rate" on your investment which represents the increase (or decrease) in the purchasing power of your invested funds after factoring in inflation. To find the real return/interest rate, you simply take the nominal interest rate (that is the TB interest rate) and subtract the inflation rate. In your example, it will be 15% (nominal TB interest rate) minus 14% (inflation) which will give you a 1% real return. |
Infinitisi:You hit the nail on the head!! There are many factors that impact the price of financial assets - and in different ways. Educating yourself about this will position you to make better investment decisions. Every financial asset is useful and using the knowledge you have to best position yourself in the market is all you can do. While there are people that changed their dollars to naira at N160 and have now lost money, someone else exchanged their naira to dollars at N160 and made some nice profits. Similarly, there are those who bought dollars a year ago at N365 and kept in their dom account. Today dollar exchange rate is N360. If you had invested that money in Tbills instead of buying dollars, you would have been much better off. Stock market is another example - NSE was one of the best performing indices last year with 42% return - however, all those gains have essentially been wiped out this year. The point is that you need to understand what makes these assets move in price and be on the right side of the trade. Now, this is no easy task and if any of us knew all the answers, we probably will not be in this forum anyway. All you can do is to educate yourself so you can make informed decisions that will increase the chances of you being on the right side of the trade. Good luck investing! |
Biakwa:You can find historical Tbill rates here: https://www.cbn.gov.ng/rates/govtsecurities.asp |
jpphilips:Sound perspective which I agree with! |
Yem0350:Thanks for clarifying, Yemo. So money market rate should be compared directly with true yields then. |
silentone:The answer is that it depends. What is your time horizon for this investment? In order words, will you need to access the money sooner or later? If you want flexibility to access your cash, then money market is the way to go as these are more liquid and therefore easier to cash out in the event you want to do that. If accessing the cash quickly is not important, then we are really looking at how the returns compare against each other. From a rate of return perspective, you will need to compare the money market rate (which is an annualized number) to the true yield on the T-bills - if not you are mixing oranges and mangoes in the comparison. The true yield for the tenors you have indicated are as follows: 91 - 11.1% 182 - 14.5% 364 - 16.3% You also need to consider the fact that interest on T-bills is not taxable while earnings on momey market funds are taxable at 10% i believe. So on an after-tax basis, the money market return of 11.54% is 10.4%. In short, if liquidity is more important than rate of return, then go with money market, if not, TBill is the way to go! |
eagleeye2:Is all a matter of risk tolerance and the risk-reward trade off. If you are looking for higher returns, you typically will need to take on more risk. I agree that in order to preserve the value of your capital while invested in T-Bills, your rate of return needs to exceed the inflation rate if not your overall purchasing power will be reducing even though the amount of naira you have is increasing. However, I don't think it is appropriate for someone who is looking for a low risk investment, such as T-bills, to invest in cryptocurrencies as a way to hedge against inflation. Granted that you will get protection from inflation mostly because cryptos are priced in foreign currencies which will appreciate against the naira based on relative inflation rates as well as other factors but the additional risk associate with this puts it in a completely different category than T-bills. I agree with eagleeye2 that equities (in good companies) and real estate (bought at fair prices) are a good hedge against inflation - you can add precious metals such as gold to that list as well. These provide a hedge against inflation at much lower risks levels than cryptos whose prices are still much more volatile relative to other assets. That is not to say that they do not make a good investment under any scenario but investors need to be aware of the risks associated with these types of assets and act accordingly. Ultimately, having a diversified portfolio that contains different assets including equities, bonds, money market instruments (including T-bills), precious metals, real estate, cryptos (if you now how to identify good ones) is the way to go as you will be able to maximize your overall return for the same level of risk. This is the whole premise behind modern portfolio theory. |
katamo:Nigeria’s foreign reserves fall by $2.2bn in Oct — biggest monthly drop since 2015 https://www.thecable.ng/nigerias-foreign-reserves-fall-by-2-2bn-in-oct-biggest-monthly-drop-since-2015 |
Ugoh11:If you can do this and still make money then it you essentially have a riskless trade. I think that in reality people will exploit this opportunity and the price of the futures contract will increase (because of increased demand) and as such eliminate the arbitrage opportunity. |
TheSam:First of all, you will be hard pressed to get a loan at 2% annual interest rate. It is more likely to be in the high single digits. In any case, as others have pointed out, you will be exposed to exchange rate risk. So if the naira per dollar/euro exchange rate moves against you (that is, if it goes up) by the time your T-bills mature, you will be exchanging the same amount of naira for less dollars/euros. With the recent increase in interest rates in the US and other countries, investments in those countries are becoming more attractive to foreign investors who have been invested in the Nigerian market and you can see this in the increase in investment outflows over the last couple of months. The Nigerian government has been using foreign reserves to intervene in the forex market to keep the naira stable over the last few months - hence the trend of decreasing foreign reserves. What you propose looks to me like a risky strategy in the current environment particularly if oil prices decrease which will impact our ability to replenish our foreign reserves which we are using to keep the exchange rate stable. |
Quick update on this... My banker came back to me and confirmed that there will be no issuance next week. What she meant was that they will start accepting bids for the auction the following week (May 17th) from next week (May 10th). michellez: |
I heard that CBN indicated that there will be another bid next week (May 10th). The Q2 calendar did not have anytime scheduled until May 17th. Can anyone confirm that there will be an issuance next week and any additional details regarding that? |
This is what I indicated last month when I said that rates may go as low as 10% this year. If crude prices continue to be strong, GDP growth remians positive, and inflation continues on a downward trend, a 10% rate for the 364-day tenure is very possible, even likely, at some point this year. katamo: |
Dipo, I just realized that you are the author of these articles. I find them very informative. More grease! dipoolowoo: |
Headline inflation drops for 14th consecutive month... this will continue to put pressure on T-Bill rates; coupled with the fact that CBN is only rolling over a portion of maturing issuances. The Consumer Price Index (CPI) which measures inflation increased by 13.34 percent (year-on-year) in March 2018. This fourteenth consecutive disinflation since January 2017 is 0.99 percent points less than the rate recorded in February 2018 (14.33) percent. Increases were recorded in all COICOP divisions that yield the Headline Index. On a month-on-month basis, the Headline index increased by 0.84 percent in March 2018, up by 0.05 percent points from the rate recorded in February. The percentage change in the average composite CPI for the twelve month period ending March 2018 over the average of the CPI for the previous twelve month period was 15.60 percent, showing 0.33 percent point lower from 15.93 percent recorded in February 2018. The Urban inflation rate eased by 13.75 percent (year-on-year) in March 2018 from 14.76 percent recorded in February, while the Rural inflation rate also eased by 12.99 percent in March 2018 from 13.96 percent in February. Data source: National Bureau of Statistics |
Wrong thread... [s]Headline inflation drops for 14th consecutive month... this will continue to put pressure on T-Bill rates; coupled with the fact that CBN is only rolling over a portion of maturing issuances. The Consumer Price Index (CPI) which measures inflation increased by 13.34 percent (year-on-year) in March 2018. This fourteenth consecutive disinflation since January 2017 is 0.99 percent points less than the rate recorded in February 2018 (14.33) percent. Increases were recorded in all COICOP divisions that yield the Headline Index. On a month-on-month basis, the Headline index increased by 0.84 percent in March 2018, up by 0.05 percent points from the rate recorded in February. The percentage change in the average composite CPI for the twelve month period ending March 2018 over the average of the CPI for the previous twelve month period was 15.60 percent, showing 0.33 percent point lower from 15.93 percent recorded in February 2018. The Urban inflation rate eased by 13.75 percent (year-on-year) in March 2018 from 14.76 percent recorded in February, while the Rural inflation rate also eased by 12.99 percent in March 2018 from 13.96 percent in February. Data source: National Bureau of Statistics[/s] |
Thanks for the input awesomeJ. Happy Sunday to you too. awesomeJ: |
Can one terminate a portion of their TBill investment before maturity or does it have to be the whole thing? |
Thanks a lot. If you can connect me with you the person I will speak to him. I appreciate the recommendation! Rubbiish: |
Good suggestion sir. I am looking at the option of a steel building if it is more cost efficient and I can find an experienced company that I can work with. Rubbiish: |
Thank you sir. Good to know. I will contact him. EgunMogaji: |
Thanks a lot to you and @ AngelicBeing! EgunMogaji: |
1 2 (of 2 pages)