₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,283 members, 8,522,182 topics. Date: Friday, 20 November 2026 at 05:19 PM

Toggle theme

PastorAIO's Posts

Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 (of 287 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Where Do Souls of Animals Go??? by PastorAIO: 2:50pm On Nov 29, 2008
ugborikoko:
@ enitan2002

Thanks for your contribution men. It provides some explanation of where the souls of animals go. But consider this, Genesis 2:27 the bible gives a vivid account of how Adam was created. God blew into the nostrills of Adam the breath of life, and inanimate Adam became a LIVING soul. Note the adjective LIVING. Does that not say something obvious. There is no point describing soul as LIVING if there is only one state of soul. Saying living soul indicates that dead soul exist.

By the way, that place mentions that Adam BECAME a living soul. Became does not mean the soul entered him. He BECAME a living soul, not a dead soul.

Therefore dead souls exist. When animals die their souls die. It does not go to heaven, hell anywhere else. It simply ceases to exist. Think of all the dinosaurs, ants , cockroaches, existict species of animals, and the billions of insects that have walked the earth and died, why should these creatures go to some special place therafter?

Please provide some biblical backing for the claims you made,
Sir, consider this: That the body does not need to be inanimate (dead) before the soul is dead. There are many dead men walking and talking on the streets. Consider what Jesus said when he said, 'Let the dead bury the dead'. So you see the 'dead' can pick up a shovel and dig a grave in which the dead are to be buried.

So yes, dead souls exists, yet that doesn't mean that the soul is inanimate. A soul becomes alive when it is connected to the Spirit. When the body of a dead soul becomes inanimate, the dead soul does not cease to exist. It just ceases to have influence on the material world.
Christianity Etc › Re: Where Do Souls of Animals Go??? by PastorAIO: 2:36pm On Nov 29, 2008
enitan2002:
@ ugborikoko,
it seems you already had the answers to your question, if i had known, i wont have contributed at all, i thought it was a genuine question by a serious seeker of knowledge and truth.
By the way, i didnt tell you i got the knowledge from the Bible, so therefore i don't have/need to start proving some bible verses to you to back up my claims.
I hope say no be fight. The guy was only making a simple request. If you notice he is only on his 36th post, which would suggest that he is not familiar with you and your perspective on religious matters. If he presumed that you were coming from the bible that would be understandable.

If he already has his answers that doesn't mean that you shouldn't contribute. Are we not all here in a dialogue, exchanging opinions and hopefully learning from each other?
Christianity Etc › Re: Where Do Souls of Animals Go??? by PastorAIO: 1:30am On Nov 28, 2008
This is an interesting conversation that I had with alhaji Olabowale a few months back. https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-1787.0.html#msg2365946
Christianity Etc › Re: Where Do Souls of Animals Go??? by PastorAIO: 1:08am On Nov 28, 2008
I've heard that Dogs go to doggie heaven.


So there you have it. problem solved.
Christianity Etc › Re: Where Do Souls of Animals Go??? by PastorAIO: 5:22pm On Nov 27, 2008
5. Is the "breath of life" the same thing which passes through the nostrils of animals? Genesis 7:21-22. Is it the breath of life that is cut off when a human being or an animal drowns? Verse 23. Then the source of life in man and animals is the same, isn't it?

COMMENT: If the "breath of life" even remotely meant that man has an immortal soul, then so do animals, birds and even insects—gnats, fleas, mosquitoes, etc.!
From here: http://bibletools.org/index.cfm/fuseaction/Library.sr/CT/ACCC/k/731/#1365513655

This one is a very good read, although again I don't agree with all the information in there.
Christianity Etc › Re: Where Do Souls of Animals Go??? by PastorAIO: 12:11pm On Nov 27, 2008
ugborikoko:
Nice point Pilgrim, but where do animals go?
Ugborikoko, I think that your issue might hinge on the philosophical problem of Identity?
Christianity Etc › Re: Where Do Souls of Animals Go??? by PastorAIO: 12:09pm On Nov 27, 2008
ugborikoko:
@ Pastor

if what you quoted is true, that the concept of soul is indeed a concept and is ambigous, then Pastors should stop preaching about what they are not sure of. A dog dies, no one talks about it going to hell or heaven. A lion kills a person no one talks about it going to hell. Why then do people talk of humans, which they claim also have souls going some where to meet their maker or to hell for punishment?

There are fundamental questions that Christains need to ask, to be sure that they are not being misled
May I quickly post a disclaimer. I have nothing to do with that website. I just made reference to it because I felt it would help to stimulate the discussion. There are somethings I agree with and others that leave me unsure. It is true that in the bible 'soul' is used in a great variety of contexts. Sometimes it includes the physical person, and other times a distinction is made from the body and the soul. It is possible that a lot of the times the use of the word is just rhetorical.

[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=200823.msg3145892#msg3145892 date=1227781990]Hi Pastor AIO,

That was helpful. Just a line to balance off issues:

Maybe, maybe not. How? Among other things, it is not restricted to the sense above; for immortality does not always suggest "infinite existence" throughout the past. Some concepts or context of immortality include:

        ●  not liable or subject to death

        ●  not liable to perish or decay; imperishable; everlasting

In these contexts, perhaps we find a few pointers in Scripture where the term may not actually be pointing to the idea of "infinite existence throughout the past". Let's remind ourselves of a few:

        ●  1 Cor. 15:53 - "this mortal must put on immortality"

        ●  1 Cor. 15:54 - "this mortal shall have put on immortality"

Perhaps it would indicate that the one who puts on "immortality" was not having "infinite existence throughout the past". Rather, it would be pointing to the understanding that the one who puts on immortality is no longer subject to death.

I thought to point that out, because this idea of "infinite existence in the past" seems to be the basis of the confusion for some when they discuss "immortality".[/quote]I agree with you. I also want to make a distinction between Eternal and Durable. Durable exists in, and persists through, Time. The Eternal has nothing to do with time but rather exists in Timelessness. So it might be possible to be Durable forever and yet not be Eternal. However to be Durable forever is not possible, I don't think. Because in the temporal existence we live in all things are subject to change. Or as Heraclitus would put it, Panta Rhei (Πάντα ῥεῖ ).

Check this out:
Ruh and nafs, ruach and nefesh

I just wrote a paper for my Qur'an class on the Arabic terms ruh and nafs. Ruh is usually translated as "spirit," and nafs as "soul" (or "self."wink I was drawn to them because I suspected they would parallel their Hebrew cognates ruach and nefesh. And wow, do they ever! I have no idea how many people will be interested in this, but I figure at least a few of y'all might be fascinated, as I am, so I'm going to share some of what I've learned. If you've been reading VR for a while, you know I'm always looking for interreligious common ground,
From here: http://velveteenrabbi.blogs.com/blog/2008/10/ruh-and-nafs-ruach-and-nefesh.html
Christianity Etc › Re: Where Do Souls of Animals Go??? by PastorAIO: 11:13am On Nov 27, 2008
"Soul" and "Spirit" in Scripture

Christians sometimes wonder about the difference between the "soul" and the "spirit." When discussing the "soul," they wonder if it is immortal – or what happens to the "soul" when a person dies.

In order to answer these questions, we must have some basis or frame of reference for our discussion. There are many ideas about what the "soul" or "spirit" might be, but these are often simply based on feelings and speculation. A general and open-ended discussion on these concepts can bog down into a clash of uninformed opinions.

Our discussion can be more productive if we ask what the Bible say about the "soul" and "spirit." How does Scripture use these words and how does it explain what these are?
Immortal "Soul" or "Spirit"?

Regarding the nature of the soul, we would have to look at such Scriptures as Matthew 10:28, in which Jesus said the soul could be destroyed. Reflecting on such passages, it can hardly be said that the soul is immortal, unless one were to argue that "destroyed" in biblical usage meant something different from our normal conception of this word.

"Immortality," of course, suggests infinite existence not only into the future but also throughout the past. Nothing in Scripture suggests that the "soul" has such a quality. Some early church fathers, such as Origen, taught the preexistence of the human "soul," but this is not sustainable by Scripture.

As we have seen, the "soul" in Scripture is really the person as human being, who has been created by God. That which is created does not have eternal preexistence. As far as the "spirit" is concerned, this is something that is "breathed into" the human, and which creates the life of the person, as it were. Again, no idea of preexistence of the person as "soul" or "spirit" is implied in Scripture.

In some ways, from the biblical perspective, it seems that the phrase "immortal soul" may be an oxymoron, or contradiction in terms. The Bible tends to see human beings as mortal creatures, subject to death as persons, that is, as "souls" in whom the "spirit" resides. Immortality is something that humans must "put on" in the resurrection (1 Corinthians 15:50-54). It is not said to be a quality inherent in the "soul" or "spirit" of a person.

This, of course, brings up the question of how we are to understand what "soul" is. Is mind an expression of "soul," and if it is, what does this say about the latter? Do humans have a "spirit," and what would be its nature? The Bible doesn’t seem to answer these questions in any direct way, as our study of the biblical usage of nephesh, psuche, ruach and pneuma indicate.

To summarize, the Bible does not appear to be explicit about what exactly makes up human consciousness, self-awareness or mind – and how this might relate to something called "soul" or "spirit." Because of the Bible’s ambiguity or silence on the matter, the church has not issued any formal and dogmatic statements on the "soul" or "spirit in man." Our hope – and the emphasis of Scripture – is that in the resurrection we shall "put on" immortality, and through this "putting on" we shall have eternal life in God.
From here: http://www.wcg.org/lit/spiritual/soulspirit.htm
Christianity Etc › Re: 'child-witches' Of Nigeria Seek Refuge by PastorAIO: 2:01pm On Nov 24, 2008
Why is it only when western journalists report this that we realise that it is going on and are bothered to do anything about it. It has been going on under most of our noses for a very long time. What about all those journalists in Nigeria? How comes not a single one of them thought that this was a story worth publicizing. Hmmm, perhaps it's because plus the journalists, plus all the supposed professional classes, plus the idiots, they all belong to the same mindset. Not a single one of them is shocked at such evil. Not until the white man comes along and decries it. Then all of a sudden we are ashamed to be nigerian and it is so shocking. . . . (sigh) I don't know!
Christianity Etc › Re: How Does One Feel When He Or Better Asked What Is The Prove Of Being Born Again by PastorAIO: 10:44pm On Nov 22, 2008
Donpuzo:
Hi nairalanders, i want to ask what is the strange and sudden feeling i hear people talk about after conversion(being born again) I don't think i have felt such. How does it feel and whats the prove of conversion.

Pastor AIO i sure also need ur help on this one, because i have read a lot of  your posts and find them really true.

Thanks

Donpuzo aka Dogman
Hi Donpuzo,  I don't know about the strange and sudden feelings that people talk about either. But what I do know is that Jesus says, in John  chapter 3,  that unless a man be born from Above he cannot enter the kingdom of God.  When questioned further about this he went on to make a distinction between the spirit and the flesh.  What is the distinguishing thing between those in the flesh and those of the spirit?  Jesus answered, The Pneuma blows where it wants, but though you are aware of it in the present you neither know where it is coming from (it's past) nor where it is going (it's future).  In other words the Spirit's action is SPONTANEOUS.  Furthermore everyone that is of the spirit is like this, ie Spontaneous.  Ultimately this means to be free of your circumstances.

To further illustrate this let us consider the Flesh, and human neurology.  Every action can be explained and predicted by a prior event (or set of prior events in the past) and/or an intent to be accomplished in the future.  For instance, imagine a boy is lying on his bed playing a computer game when all of a sudden he jumps up and rushes to his table furiously and picks up a book which he starts to read.  Why the sudden action?  With further investigation it can be ascertained that he heard the gate of the house creaking open and he heard the familiar sound of his dad's car coming down the drive.  His Dad had warned him that he needed to spend more time studying his school books. 
Such behaviour is understandable.  The sound of his Dad's car (which he heard with his physical senses) prompted the reaction  of him jumping out of bed and rushing to pick up a book.  The behaviour is totally explained by his history.

But what if there was no sound of an opening gate or sound of Dad's car coming down the drive.  What if you asked him why he jumped so suddenly and he responded that he didn't know but the spirit moved him to do so.  That is unreasonable behaviour from a earthly/nonspiritual point of view.  Madness in fact, a folly, foolishness.  I actually dislike having to use the term unreasonable to describe it because I believe that the word Reason has been misappropriated today.  Reason originally means Logos, from which we also get the word Logic, another misappropriated term.  True Reason and Logic come actually from the Spirit and not from the Flesh. 

There is so much to say on this subject so rather than write one long tedious essay of a post, I reckon it would be better if we developed it as a dialogue with the banter going back and forth. 

Just one last thing that I want to say.  Being born of the spirit does not mean that the desires to sin are no longer there, or any of the promptings of the flesh.  Any one who says so is either a liar or is just passing on word bites that they've learnt from Liars.  The Flesh continues to exert influence or attempt to.  This is where Faith is called for, cos very often the promptings and inspirations of the spirit can be diametrically opposed to that of the flesh and it will take faith to make that leap contrary to what 'makes sense' to the fleshly thinking.  As long as we are in the flesh, the impulse to sin will never leave us.
Christianity Etc › Re: Religion Is The Opiate Of The Poor by PastorAIO: 10:52am On Nov 20, 2008
Opiates and other such drugs are the religion of the Lost.
Christianity Etc › Re: Holy Coffin: Pastors, Carpenter On War Path Over Coffin by PastorAIO: 11:59am On Nov 19, 2008
I like the sound of that carpenter guy. He even used to sleep inside the coffins! He seems like the kind of guy I would get along with. lol. I wonder if Jesus ever had any problems like this in his carpentry trade.
Christianity Etc › Re: Can A Christian Be Demon-Possessed? by PastorAIO: 11:13am On Nov 19, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3095823#msg3095823 date=1226867400]@Pastor AIO,

Yeye dey worry you! grin What have you said just now? "One of the factors that determine events that occur in the world". . hmm. Wetin be "factors"? When you define that one finish, wetin be "event"?

Lol, just feeling on the lighter side this evening and teasing you. Don't mind me - me sef, I yeye. . you know.

I appreciate your perspective and look forward to some more. Honestly, I do.

Cheers. wink[/quote]By event I mean something that happens/occurs. Events are driven by forces that we might not directly perceive. Whether it is the shifting of tectonic plates or a man getting up to brush his teeth there are forces that bring this about. These forces, or factors as I call it, are manifold. So I say that Spirit is one of them. Soul is another factor. But let me hasten to add that these two do not necessarily act independently of each other. yet there are important differences.
Christianity Etc › Re: Can A Christian Be Demon-Possessed? by PastorAIO: 11:06am On Nov 19, 2008
Here's a website discussing the difference between soul and spirit. I don't necessarily agree with all the things it says but I'm just putting it here for all who may be interested in investigating.
http://levendwater.org/companion/append13.html

and

http://levendwater.org/companion/append9.html
Christianity Etc › Re: Can A Christian Be Demon-Possessed? by PastorAIO: 9:19pm On Nov 16, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3081627#msg3081627 date=1226581427]That's okay - would you like to propose a proper definition then?[/quote]Well okay, but before we go into matter let's first go into Spirit and soul. I believe that every process of animate and inanimate being is driven by Soul and Spirit. So by Spirit I mean one of the factors that determine events that occur in the world.

Take for instance a man, he wakes up, brushes his teeth, walks out of his home and goes for a run around a park. It is his physical body that goes through these actions. Yet there is a mover that propels his body to make these actions. The mover is one of two entities. His soul or his spirit.

So first I want to define Spirit by distinguishing it from Soul. Now in they bible these two terms are called in Hebrew Ruach (spirit) and Nefesh (soul). In the new testament which is written in Greek they are called Pneuma (spirit) and Psyche (soul).

The soul is the baser part of man, It is driven by lusts, and desires. It makes us feel urges and that in turn causes us to take action to satisfy those urges. For some people certain urges are more pronounced than in other people and this is what gives us different personalities. The souls influence can be totally described by a man's neurology.

[size=14pt]The soul is a source of information.[/size] It get's information through the physical senses. ie. eyes, nose, ears etc. It's source of information is limited. Limited, that is, to location. So one cannot see what is not present. I'm in london and so cannot see what is going on on 42nd street in NewYork. It is not in my present location.

The Spirit too, is a source of information. The spirit is not subject to location and so can inform you about things that are not present, either spatially or temporally. It can basically prophesy. Being not subject to one's circumstances allows the Spirit to be autonomous in it's actions. While the Soul acts according to causes that occurred prior to it's action, The spirit is not subject to prior events. So it breaks the chain of causality.

John 3:8 The wind blows where it wills, and you hear the sound of it, but you do not know whence it comes or whither it goes; so it is with every one who is born of the Spirit.

The spirit is not predictable and cannot be prognosticated. It is not subject to laws of causality and neither can it be determined and this mark of it is seen in people who are born of the spirit. In other words it makes us capable of spontaneous action. unforeseeable action.

These are just a few insights into spirit to chew on for now.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 8:36pm On Nov 16, 2008
I think that we would get a lot further if we conducted this conversation in Cantonese, or Urdu because right now I don't think that I even understand Pilgrim's english anymore. Anyway, I've said what I have to say on the subject and it is out there for all who are interested to read it. If you get something from it, good for you, if you don't then too bad. Bye bye people.

ps. before I go, why hasn't image 123 who started the whole John 5:39 fiasco returned to contribute to the debate?
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 8:17pm On Nov 16, 2008
But what we have been discussing on this thread is only the tip of the iceberg.  Things have progressed to a much more sinister level elsewhere.  Take for instance what we find here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhema
Especially comments like this:
By contrast, the Logos (λόγος), is typically used in Scripture to refer to what God has said to His people, that is, the collection of God's sayings about Himself, His relationship with His creation and His Church. The Logos of God is true for all time and in all places[b]. It is easy to see how this can be interpreted both as the bible (God's Word Written) and in the Person of Jesus Christ (God's Word in the Flesh) [/b]as seen in John's Gospel, Chapter 1.
What this amounts to is stating that the Bible is Jesus.

Also here: http://ati.iblp.org/ati/family/articles/concepts/rhema/
The say:
The Word of God

There are two primary Greek words that describe Scripture which are translated word in the New Testament. The first, logos, refers principally to [b]the total inspired Word of God [/b]and to Jesus, Who is the living Logos.
What is going on in the pentecostal movement is in effect the raising of the bible to the level of Diety, Jesus himself.  You'll hear statements that the bible is Jesus-in-writing etc.  It is for this reason that discussions such as these are very important and I'm quite glad that we're having it.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 7:49pm On Nov 16, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3093557#msg3093557 date=1226790531]@Pastor AIO,

This is the original Greek of the verse.

ἀπεκρίθη αὐτοῖς ὁ Ἰησοῦς καὶ εἶπεν· Ἀμὴν ἀμὴν λέγω ὑμῖν, ζητεῖτέ με, οὐχ ὅτι εἴδετε σημεῖα, ἀλλ’ ὅτι ἐφάγετε ἐκ τῶν ἄρτων καὶ ἐχορτάσθητε.


Now here, as is most often the case the word ζητεῖτέ (zeteite) - you seek/search does not have a pronoun attached to it.  Which all goes to further illustrate my point. It is a totally different verb from ερευνατε which means to peruse/investigate/examine as what one would do with a text, as opposed to looking for somebody. 

Glad you recognize that the word ζητεῖτέ (zeteite) does not have a pronoun preceding it, which demonstrates that it is not the convention to always have or otherwise leave out the pronoun in Greek imperatives. All the examples cited so far (John 5:39 and 7:52 and 6:26) point to the fact that such imperatives may have the pronoun or otherwise do not have the pronoun.[/quote]I'm sorry but Zeteite is not an imperative.  Perhaps you are not aware of what an imperative is in verb construction.  An imperative is when you are telling someone to do something, whether recommending them to do it or commanding them to do it. An indicative, on the other hand, is when you are indicating that someone is doing something already.  Zeteite means 'You search'. It is an indicative.  It is indicating that the 2nd person is searching. In greek you don't put a pronoun on the indicative but it is understood that it is indicative so when translated to english you must put in the pronoun.  Imperatives never have a pronoun.

For example:  Sit down!  is imperative/  you are sitting down is indicative.

Stand up!  is imperative/ you are standing up is indicative.  

Eat bread is imperative /  you eat bread is indicative.  

so when you say . . .  
that such imperatives may have the pronoun or otherwise do not have the pronoun.
. . . that is just plain wrong because imperatives never have a pronoun.  

In english, to not put in the pronoun in an indicative is definitely an omission, and one which leads the reader to think that the word is an imperative thereby misleading the reader.  
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3093557#msg3093557 date=1226790531]Okay, I commend your submission on distingusihing between ζητεῖτέ (zeteite) and ερευνατε. For the sake of our readers, perhaps it may be necessary to point out further that in Greek ζητεῖτέ could be used for both searching for something and someone. Would it help to check with some study aids (like Thayer's Greek Definitions); and then looking at a few examples where ζητεῖτέ is used in both cases? A few of such examples:

     ■    ζητεῖτέ used in searching/seeking someone:

       John 7:11 - 'Then the Jews sought him at the feast, and said, Where is he?'

       2 Timothy 1:17  - 
      'But, when he was in Rome, he sought me out very diligently, and found me'
      _______________________________       

     ■    ζητεῖτέ used in searching/seeking something:

       Luke 15:8 - 'Either what woman having ten pieces of silver, if she lose one piece,
       doth not light a candle, and sweep the house, and seek diligently till she find it?'

       1 Cor. 1:22 - 'For the Jews require a sign, and the Greeks seek after wisdom.'

       Matthew 13:45 - 'Again, the kingdom of heaven is like unto a merchant man,
       seeking goodly pearls.'

In either cases, the words ζητεῖτέ and ερευνατε are used whether as regards seeking/searching for someone or something. And examples where ερευνατε is used as indicative for searching/seeking for something other than a text (but in connection with people) could be found in Romans 8:27 and 1 Cor. 2:10.

* Romans 8:27 - 'And he that searcheth the hearts knoweth what
    is the mind of the Spirit, because he maketh intercession for the saints according to
    the will of God.'

* 1 Cor. 2:10 - 'But God hath revealed them unto us by his Spirit:
    for the Spirit searcheth all things, yea, the deep things of God.'[/quote]even though both words are translated as You search, in fact they are two very different things. Zeteite means you search and look for something or someone that is not present.  Ereunate means you investigate, probe, examine, search through.  the object you are searching through is very much present it is a matter of investigating it.  I used a text as an example of something that you ereunate.  You can also search/investigate/ereunate the heart, and also ereunate/examine/investigate the deep things of God.  If you zeteite your text then that means you've lost the text and you are looking for it everywhere, under the table, on the shelf, in your bag  . . . where can that text be?  Yet when you are ereunate the text that means the text is right there in your hands and you are probing into it.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 7:00pm On Nov 16, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3095137#msg3095137 date=1226853471]After all has been said, my one question in all the language "research" is this: WHO has been making John 5:39 a COMMAND?!? If it was not a "command" in the first place, why can't we just see that simple point all this while?[/quote]I think the problem is lies in the fact that when justcool, myself and others have used the word command we meant it in the sense that the sentence was NOT supposed to be constructed as an imperative. While I can't speak for justcool, I know that I personally was not making a distinction between the two. I then noticed that you were making a distinction.

If I say - 'Sit Down'. That is the imperative of the verb 'To sit down'. I [/b]call it a command sentence. If however I notice that you insist that it is not a command because the person saying the imperative may only be recommending someone to sit down, or suggesting to someone to sit down, rather than commanding someone to sit down, then I am happy to change the way in which I use the word command just for you, [b]YET the fact remains that it was translated into english as an imperative when it should not have been. This is a mistranslation that has resulted in the OMISSION of the word YOU from the beginning of the text, thus allowing the text to be completely misunderstood.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 9:58pm On Nov 15, 2008
Pilgrim.1 said:
Since you say that it is not the convention to place the ‘you’ there, I wonder what you make of John 6:26 where indeed the pronoun ‘you’ appears before ‘search’? Like I said, the "imperative" in Greek does not mean everytime that it is a "command", Pastor AIO. When you read that verse even in the Greek, you find indeed that the pronoun "you" comes before the word "search"; and in doing so, it does not break the convention.
This is the original Greek of the verse.

ἀπεκρίθη αὐτοῖς ὁ Ἰησοῦς καὶ εἶπεν· Ἀμὴν ἀμὴν λέγω ὑμῖν, ζητεῖτέ με, οὐχ ὅτι εἴδετε σημεῖα, ἀλλ’ ὅτι ἐφάγετε ἐκ τῶν ἄρτων καὶ ἐχορτάσθητε.


Now here, as is most often the case the word ζητεῖτέ (zeteite) - you seek/search does not have a pronoun attached to it.  Which all goes to further illustrate my point. It is a totally different verb from ερευνατε which means to peruse/investigate/examine as what one would do with a text, as opposed to looking for somebody. 

However, come to think of it, you don't have to make zeteite the present indicative.  You could just as easily translate it as the imperative like before and you'll get
And Jesus answered them, "Verily verily I say to you, Seek Me, not because you've seen signs, but because you are full of loaves".

Which is quite a delightful interpretation of the verse, don't you think?
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 9:40pm On Nov 15, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3087731#msg3087731 date=1226673882]@Bastage,

Glad you pointed that out. This has been my point all along: John 5:39 was not a command; and among the things I tried to point out was this: "it was understood there as a challenge of recommendation".

Now that's what I mean by people dialoguing and not accusing. I appreciate that.[/quote]Maybe I owe you a small apology because I really thought that you were being a maradona when you sought to make a distinction between Command and imperative. however on reading this post again I see how your position is based on that distinction.
@Pastor AIO,

Let me go back in reference to some statements you made earlier:

Quote from: Pastor AIO
As a result in many such languages the imperative (command) can get mixed up with the present indicative.


I think that is where some people are getting it wrong, for the imperative is not strictly and always a matter of "command". In many other languages, this is very clear, for we know that in French, the imperative mood could be used to imply the following:

■ give an order
■ express a desire
■ offer advice
■ recommend something
■ make a request

Like I said as regards the imperative in John 5:39, there was no place in my rejoinders where I used that word "imperative" to imply a "command". I made that thing very clear; so if one were reading the word 'imperative', please don't assume everytime that it is always pointing to a "command".

That's what I need to clear first and then I'll share my thoughts on John 5:39.
I now think that you are using it in the sense of suggesting something to someone on the basis of their beliefs. For instance if I am trying to convince a moslem not to steal, rather than quote bible to him I am better off saying: "Read the quran, cos you think that's the truth, abi? Well the quran says you mustn't steal."
In that sense an imperative can be followed by - 'because you think . . . '.

However, accepting this point does not change much. And again it hinges on that word 'you'. The word you is not used when constructing the second person of verbs except for emphasis. For example, a similar thing occurs in Italian. Imagine I met a tranvestite. A woman that is dressed as a man, has had the sex change and would like to be addressed as a man. She says to me, " Sono uomo" Sono means I am in italian while uomo means man. But in response I can shake my head and say, "Io sono uomo". That is I am a man. The emphasis makes a distinction, an important point that I am trying to convey.

If you see the word you in ancient greek then an important nuance is being indicated. Now consider the phrase:

Search the scriptures; for (in them) you think . . . .

In greek this is : ερευνατε τας γραφας οτι υμεις δοκειτε

You is Humeis which is emboldened above. It is followed by dokete which means to suppose or to think. Now, rhetorically, why would Jesus suddenly add the personal pronoun when it is not necessary grammatically in the language. I say it is because the Supposition is theirs and their especially (if not theirs alone). He emphasises the you to imply that it is their position, not necessarily his.

Accentuation is a very important part of language and communication and in many ways writing has a destructive effect on a communication. Afterall most communication is not literal but packed full of nuances.
Take for instance this statement: She sells seashells on the seashore
What it is saying is obvious, no? Yet any actor will tell you that there are a thousand and one ways to deliver this phrase so as to give it many quite contrary meanings. Even simply by shifting the accents you can create many different nuances with much added meaning.
For instance:
She sells seashells on the seashore
Emphasising the She suggests that I'm making the point that Her and not anyone else is the one selling the seashells, so please don't go accusing me of such actions.

She sells seashells on the seashore
Emphasising Sells. What? you mean she's selling them? I thought she was supposed to be giving them out for free. I can't believe she's making money out of them.

She sells seashells on the seashore
Seashells!!!! I thought she was selling crabs! So it is seashells that she is selling. na wa o!

She sells seashells on the seashore
Surely not on the Seashore! Talk about taking coal to newcastle! Why sell them there when there are so many seashells already lying around? Haha, how silly.

So by actually stating the you (humeis) before dokete Christ is emphasizing that the supposition is theirs.


Then there is also the matter of the word Dokeite itself. δοκειτε means to think, to suppose, to reckon, to conjecture. It is where the word orthodox comes from. ortho- means Right, Dox comes from dokeite to think. Therefore orthodox is right thinking. So obviously erroneous thinking/suppositions are possible too.
Since I've already thrown in a tongue twister above, I'll throw in another for absolutely no reason at all.
Moses supposes his roses are poses but Moses supposes erroneously.
Trying saying this fast over and over again.

Back on track . . . If Jesus agreed that eternal life, Zoe Aionis (ζωην αιωνιον) was to be found in the scriptures wouldn't he have used the word Gnothi (γνώθι ), Gnosis (knowledge) rather than Dokete (supposition). Jesus could have said:"Search the scriptures, because in them you Know you'll have eternal life". But he said humeis dokeite which in ancient greek is very telling of what he is trying to say.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 1:36pm On Nov 14, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3086988#msg3086988 date=1226665835]You give it your own interpretation as best suits you. The one funny thing that I often find is that after the sarcasm and accusations that people have tried to justify, I wonder why it is often the culture that after I point out something, nobody refers to that same thing anymore. I have been accused about the point in my rejoinders as regards John 5:39, I discussed it in detail, I had pointed out simply that we were on the same page (it was not a "command"wink and you disagreed. After discussing it, nobody made reference to it anymore but the culture of justifying accusations and insults seems to be the norm. Lol, how has that very things helped you guys in this thread?[/quote]I have every intention of addressing it. But it will take time. For a start your arguments are so convoluted as usual, so I will need the time to sit down and pick at it. Suffice for now to say that I disagree with it and that I think that you are trying to use semantics to wriggle you way out of your quagmire.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 1:26pm On Nov 14, 2008
Bastage:
Off your high horse. It's very, very difficult to reason with you. Reasoning with someone who only wants their side to be heard, who preaches and discards every single point put to them is a waste of time. So you'll probably find yourself accused until you recognise that a debate has two sides.
It's also pretty silly of you to start flapping about people treating you badly when one only has to look back through this thread to see how you've addressed other people.
But truth be told Pilgrim.1, and I say this without malice, your complaining about how people treat you is really poor form.  Jesus said, do unto others as you would have them do onto you and since I've been aware of you on this forum, and your manner of engaging people, you have no right to complain about people accusing you of anything, especially when the accusations are justified.

I guess that now would be an excellent time to point out to you that your excessive use of the word 'hubris' is in fact the very height of hubris itself.  Afterall, what is more arrogant than seeing every opposing viewpoint as arrogant.  An in your case it has been absolutely every viewpoint that did not concur with yours.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 1:18pm On Nov 14, 2008
I said:
A lack of calm has been read into the first address. How? That's beyond me, but I'm sure that the 2nd dialoguer has perfectly justifiable reasons why the first address smacks of disquiet.


She said:Lol, if you had to go this length to allege I had "justified" anything in yours, what is the meaning of your agreement thereto as this:
That I said:

Quote from: Pastor AIO
I am now certain that you must be a psychic.  How did you know that I was rolling my eyes and frothing at the mouth when I wrote that post.  I was really trying to pretend to be calm.


Which made me laugh very much.  However I also realise how apt this exchange is for illustrating something that is central to this thread.  The matter of interpretation. There is a rhetorical devise called sarcasm where one says the exactly opposite (to the extreme to emphasis the ridiculousness of it) of what one means but if you are 'High context' enough rather than 'low context' then you will understand from the context that the opposite is intended.  

If I was frothing at the mouth and rolling my eyes don't you think that I'd be better of rushing to the hospital than commending you for psychically perceiving it.  I actually thought you were playing a double bluff by saying that you could tell because you have been like that too.  Wow pilgrim!  How often do you froth at the mouth and roll your eyes in a crazed manner?  I'm going to bring this up again on the 'Can a christian be possessed by demons' thread.  I just have to, it is too good.  

Anyway, I was just being sarcastic. See what too much false indoctrination can do to you.  It has made you so laughably low context. You take everything so literally now, not just the bible.  Please can you tell me what you think of Edward Hall.  see here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_context_culture

So while we are on that point I would like to know what you think about this bible passage from Mark 2: 17  "Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick;  I came not to call the righteous, but sinners."  
I've always been taught that Jesus had his tongue in his cheek when he said this.  Would you agree, or would you take it literally and say that Jesus knew that the Pharisees were without sin?
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 5:18pm On Nov 13, 2008
What are the possibilities for interpretation in all textual matters?  Arguably infinite, I think.  If text is something that lends itself so easily to interpretations of almost unlimited scope then how can it serve as a vehicle for specific meaning? 

For example consider the following exchange:


Quote from: Pastor AIO on Today at 10:54:22 AM
You just don't get it, do you? Why has there got to be a Canon? Why does there have to be an authoritative compilation when you've got the holy spirit to guide you in all things. You're so stuck on this idea of 'searching the scripture' on the basis of 'therein you will find eternal life' that if one bible is proved short of the mark, you immediately seek out another one to replace it. It's not about any canon, ma cherie, it's about the holy spirit and you need to get the Holy spirit in you so you can get the guidance you need.


ResponseI'm not stuck on any idea, thank you. If you cannot address anything calmly, I can bear with that.

A lack of calm has been read into the first address. How? That's beyond me, but I'm sure that the 2nd dialoguer has perfectly justifiable reasons why the first address smacks of disquiet.
Christianity Etc › Re: Can A Christian Be Demon-Possessed? by PastorAIO: 12:59pm On Nov 13, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3081028#msg3081028 date=1226574270]@PAstor AIO,

I don't set out to amuse anybody at anybody's expense. Often is the case that when people discuss these issues, the very next thing is that they would go precisely that route of "cognition and cognitive" talk - which was pointing to this example about the activity of the brain.[/quote]Ah okay, I wasn't aware of that. But you're talking to me now, it's alright. pele ore mi. (I hope I can call you my friend).

[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3081028#msg3081028 date=1226574270]Thanks for the compliments in blue, nothing new among all other sorts people have labelled me with. However, to save space, I think that you're just amusing yourself by assuming that science is allowed to be fanciful.[/quote]Nothing new? I bet no one has called you a dribbler before. Okay, if you want me to find more colourful and interesting labels for you I will.

Science is Fanciful, but rigorously fanciful. It is the application of rigor that gives the imaginings of scientists the power that they have today.

[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3081028#msg3081028 date=1226574270]On the other hand, many people may have various interpretations to both supernatural revelations as well theories in science. I'm not fazed anytime this happens, because the quarrels between scientists among themselves on the one hand, and among theists on the other hand, are never ending because man's interpretations are always dynamic and never ending.[/quote]I'm so glad you've said this.

We have often had to adjust our understanding of 'matter'. When we were in school, we were told that matter is in 3 forms - solid, liquid and gas. However, that idea became retired when it was found that a 4th state of matter was detected: plasma! Could it be possible that all we know about 'matter' today may be insufficient when it is revealed that 'matter' exists in forms, states, and structures that we have not been made aware of at the present? Thus my submission that incorporeal points to entities different from 'matter as we know it today'.
That is why I insist that we need a proper definition of what matter is. For instance, even energy can be converted into matter and vice versa. e equals mc squared. So is energy just another form of matter. We need a definition of what physical is, or natural, before we can start to talk meaningfully about the supernatural.
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 12:36pm On Nov 13, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3080934#msg3080934 date=1226572631]@Pastor AIO,

Good morning. I hope your day goes as you wish. wink[/quote]Good morning Pilgrim.1.  Kaaro ojire

Nairaland is seriously disrupting my runnings.  By the time I answer a couple of posts I find I don't have time to do any of the really important things that I wanted to do.  As much as it can be bemusing and even frustrating, I also enjoy it a lot.  A bit too much in fact.  

[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3080934#msg3080934 date=1226572631]I'm not stuck on any idea, thank you. If you cannot address anything calmly, I can bear with that.[/quote]I am now certain that you must be a psychic.  How did you know that I was rolling my eyes and frothing at the mouth when I wrote that post.  I was really trying to pretend to be calm.

Now, when someone is accused as I have been with all sorts (including "stupidity"wink, I'm thankful that in that condition I could still ask some questions such as you guys are asking, No? But here is the real problem: the WHY?

If that is our problem, why blame the Catholic Church and Bishops for anything at all? It makes me wonder that we feel quite at home to disdain people for being simply "Catholic" (than 'catholic') and yet we cannot do better than they have done - because we still have to go back and thankfully use what they have canonised.
Madam, I believe that when it comes to attacking Catholics on this forum you wear the Crown.  I don't disdain any catholics.

[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3080934#msg3080934 date=1226572631]If that is our problem, why attack others who are asking questions? The post keeps shifting, because one is no longer sure what the problem is anymore: from "translation errors", to "not accepting some books should not be in the Bible", to "why should there even be any canon at all". It seems that nobody is addressing any issue that is queried before the focus is shifted to something else. Is it the "translation errors" that has been the problem? Or, is it the "removed books"? Or yet, is it now "why should there be any canon"? What is next on line to shift the goal post?[/quote]Oo, sorry did I attack you?  You know, it's so true what they say about the playground bully.  All you have to do is stand up to him and he'll run away crying and claiming that he's been victimised.  But honestly, dear, you shouldn't leave your ego lying about, or it is likely to get trodden on.  

The post is not shifting, the problem is one single problem all the way through.  Namely the hand of man in the bible.  Whether in translation, in selection of books, or in indoctrination.  The Goalpost have remained exactly where they are when Kunle started this thread and your failure to slot the ball into it cannot be blamed on anything but yourself.  

[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3080934#msg3080934 date=1226572631]Consequently, if there is no need for any canon, why should anyone even want to make a fiat to anything called "scripture"? What then is the meaning of Jesus' statement that "scripture cannot be broken"? What is meant by Peter's statement about prophecy of scripture in 2 Pet. 1:20-21? What is meant by "all scripture given by inspiration of God"? What is meant by Jesus' warning in Matthew 5:17-19? What is meant by Proverbs 30:5-6? What is meant by Malachi 4:4?[/quote]Dear pilgrim I am running out of time so I'll address a few of these as quickly as I can.  Peter refers to prophecy in scripture.  We know how the prophets prophesied.  The spirit of God came on them.  He then goes on to warn us that at the same time there were false prophets amongst the people, 'secretly bringing destructive heresies'.  

When jesus said scripture cannot be broken or paul said it is given by inspiration of God, your canonical bible did not even then exist.  


Proverb says 'every word of God is true', not every fabrication of man that pretentiously claims to be scripture.

To answer your question as to a "canon", consider this: I am not stuck on anything as you alleged. You could simply ask me some questions in regards to John 5:39 if you please, and I would obliged; but that should not be used as a fausse patte to allege anything against anyone. However, if it focuses on Scripture as not necessary to the Christian faith (am only asking, correct me if you think otherwise), could I ask you what you make of Biblical prophecies, among several other things?
Dear pilgrim.1, pray tell, what are your opinions with regards to John 5:39?
Christianity Etc › Re: Can A Christian Be Demon-Possessed? by PastorAIO: 11:37am On Nov 13, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3076548#msg3076548 date=1226497919]You see, Pastor AIO, these days when people use these quizzical verbosities of "cognition and cognitive" blah-blah et al, we allow them get away with such vague terms - even in the corridors of "science". Nobody rejects these theories from scientists espousing the idea of an entity whose nature they do not know, and in which reality they only infer as being hypothetical, yet undeniable as a reality that is invisible!

On the other hand, if one were to describe spiritual realities using terms as "invisible", and say they (often) "cannot be seen", which are "incorporeal" in nature, and are "not composed of matter as we know it", immediately we have you and our dear friends arrogating some super authority to yourselves by saying "You cannot define a thing by it's opposite, or even by what it is NOT." Where you get such an idea that realities cannot be defined in that manner is beyond me![/quote]Just how did "these quizzical verbosities of "cognition and cognitive" blah-blah" get into this conversation. I've got to admit that I am often curious about the mechanism of how your mind works. Is there actually a link that takes you from one idea to another or do you just throw them in with the intent of making people chase Red herrings? Or perhaps you are just amusing yourself at our expense.

Ma cherie, if today a scientist came up with a theory and proof that refuted Einstein's theory of Relativity science would go along with it, no problemo. There is no scientific theory that cannot be overturned with sufficient evidence. Of course individual scientists have biases (not least because their egos cannot bear being surpassed by other scientists) However science is done in a community and scientists are constantly arguing and debating against themselves. It is not taboo or blasphemous to attack any scientific theory. In fact imagine what a scalp it would be for a young scientist to come up with something that overturns Darwin's Theory of Evolution completely. If it were possible, many scientists would be going for it if for no other reason than to gain the notoriety of being the one that did it. Everyday scientists debate with each other and overturn the conventional wisdoms they inherit.

Now, to complain that no one rejects fanciful scientific theories but they pounce on fanciful religionist's theories (yes, they are fanciful too) is putting science and religionism on the same footing. Science is allowed to be fanciful. Religion's claims are altogether different and if a religious theory/idea is proved false the shock to the entire edifice of the religion should be devastating (of course it isn't because religionists have wonderful dribblers like you). It should be devastating because the religionists claim that God has revealed it to them as absolute truth. If it is proved wrong then either God is a liar or they haven't got a mandate from God and they are liars and their entire religionism is a Lie.

If incorporeal means 'NOT composed of matter as we know it', tell me, what are the possibilities of matter as we don't know it?
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 10:54am On Nov 13, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3080635#msg3080635 date=1226568534]Could you guys give us your own canon that includes and excludes whatever books the Holy Spirit confirms in your own hearts after fellowshipping with Him? Granted, everybody that has been asking questions to this end is either ignorant or crazy - but at least you who are now very super-spiritual could condescend to give us your own Holy Spirit canon, No?

Talk about the idea that they "removed a lot of books", it suggests that there was already a standard canon but some of the books contained in that canon were "removed", no? What books were "removed"? What did those books say and teach? Why were they removed? Why would they have been included? And if they were also included, would that satisfy your spirituality and be confirmed by your fellowship with the Holy Spirit as the canon for the standard of Christian living so that others are no longer "ignorant or crazy"?

The Catholic Church is blamed for this, that and the other. Is it not ambidextrous that after all that has been blamed upon them, the same accusers still go back and use what the Catholic Bishops have compiled? If you want to free yourselves from your worries about what they have done, appeal to the Holy Spirit to produce your own canon and be happy with that rather than to keep blaming the Catholic scholars for anything and yet unable to take one step to do anything better than they have done! Is that too hard a task to achieve while still disenchanted against the 'Catholic Bishops' for the canon you use today?[/quote]You just don't get it, do you? Why has there got to be a Canon? Why does there have to be an authoritative compilation when you've got the holy spirit to guide you in all things. You're so stuck on this idea of 'searching the scripture' on the basis of 'therein you will find eternal life' that if one bible is proved short of the mark, you immediately seek out another one to replace it. It's not about any canon, ma cherie, it's about the holy spirit and you need to get the Holy spirit in you so you can get the guidance you need.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Truth About Christ Embassy Healing School by PastorAIO: 7:06pm On Nov 12, 2008
Chrisbenogor:
Lol
Lol
Pastor Chris was merry old artist and a merry old artist was he!
He healed the sick and raised the dead and made the blind men see!
Now every blind man was a very good actor and a very good actor was he!
There's none so fair as can compare to Pastor Chris!
Very nice rhymes, but the last line is out of rhythm. It needs two more syllables. How about:

Pastor Chris was merry old artist and a merry old artist was he!
He healed the sick and raised the dead and made the blind men see!
Now every blind man was a very good actor and a very good actor was he!
There's none so fair as can compare to Good Ol' Pastor Chris!
Christianity Etc › Re: I Am Not Blaspheming by PastorAIO: 3:00pm On Nov 12, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3076472#msg3076472 date=1226497076]@Pastor AIO,


Thank you for your graciousness. I know (and this is not new) that anything I point out these days only earns me some very nice "Christ-like" appellations from you guys - not only have I been labelled "rude, malicious, fanatic, ignorant, stupid, indoctrinated, accuser,", but the list grows by those who advise me to be "Christ-like" and are happy to still label me as you have added. No worries, but before you jail me allow some space for me to clear myself.

I am not being "willfully deceptive and mendacious". What I see is what I have pointed out and I have nothing against anyone in doing so. This is what you stated:

As I do not want to run the risk of being accused of taking your quote our of context, I have quoted everything. But what conclusion have you come to other than this:
     _____________________________________________________________________________
         It should rather be
       "Search the scriptures because I Say that therein you have eternal life"
     _____________________________________________________________________________

This is interesting! After labelling me as you pleased, you only came back to the same conclusion of what I had been pointing out? How is it that you do not have the YOU at the beginning of that verse in your own inference, Pastor AIO? Yours begins with "Search" and not "You" - is that not what I said and have been pointing to in discussing the imperative? Haa!

Second, I never assumed anywhere that John 5:39 was a command! Please go back to all my rejoinders thus far and see for yourself. I wonder if it is just that you read "pilgrim.1" that you just reacted the way you did and yet only came back to say the same thing?

Let me alloow you to rest your heart. If you are only saying the very same thing I did at that verse and yet you can be so "Christ-like" in your disenchantments, I thank you deeply from my heart. May God bless you many times over.

Shalom.[/quote]Have you totally lost your marbles. Now you're seeing things. I said that if Ereunate is to be translated as the imperative conjugation (ie the command 'search', rather than the present indicative You search) the the entire phrase sounds wrong. The only way it would sound right were if it said 'search the scriptures, for in them[b] I say[/b] you have eternal life.' But, as it is clear for all to see, that is not what the text says at all. I don't believe that you don't get that. You're just trying to dribble your way out of the fact that you have been caught red handed trying to peddle deception. We have not come to the same conclusion at all.

I translate Ereunate as the 2nd person conjugation of the present indicative. ie. 'You search the scriptures, because in them, you think to find eternal life.'
In ancient greek it is not the convention to place the you there. You know that because you've studied greek so why are you asking KunleOshob to show you the 'you'. Now tell me, is that not Mendacity and evidence of a desire to deceive? I will withdraw my allegations if you show me how it is not so. I do not throw such accusations at people lightly. If other people have said other things about you, I am not them and I do not know the history behind their calling you names, however I do know that there is no smoke without a fire so perhaps you need to give what they are saying some consideration. Maybe. I don't know, but I would if a lot of people started saying things about me that I didn't like. I would first try to find whether they have a point.
Christianity Etc › Re: Can A Christian Be Demon-Possessed? by PastorAIO: 2:42pm On Nov 12, 2008
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3073449#msg3073449 date=1226440270]Of course, it is a way of deliberately assuming that one cannot see what is stated that makes you assume no substance in what I shared. Put another way, what you are hoping to highlight is the vacant and simplistic assumption that I might have defined "spirit" by saying it is "not human", and then when (if) you had asked what is "human", I might have said it is "spirit".

You see, this simplistic cacophony was what made me highlight the point that, unless you deliberately are given to miss the gist here, then certainly it should not have been difficult to see. For which reason I used the example of dark matter to show you that it is a false assumption to state that definitions cannot be made using what a that entity does not entail! That is a fallacy, my dear, and no matter how you hoot against it, it is still a fallacy. Meanwhile, if one should be honest, the simplistic way you assumed I had explained "spirit' is far different from what I had posted.[/quote]What?!!! Are you reading minds now. I'm hoping to highlight what? What has human and Spirit got to do with saying that Spirit is Incorporeal and Invisible.

If someone asked you to describe me and you told them that 'well, he is not Chinese', I guess that would help to narrow the possible number of people I could be to 4/5ths of the worlds population. But it is hardly a sufficient definition by which to begin a search. Where to you start? With looking for oyinbos, or aboriginal australians, or latinos, or negros.
Well I guess that you're right that a negative description is information of some sort about it. But that Spirit is Incorporeal, ie not having a physical body, and Invisible, ie NOt seen by the eyes are negative descriptions. And BTW you contradict yourself by saying it is invisible and then showing youtube videos of demons on guy's shoulders and other such stuff.

At least with Dark matter the scientists start with observable phenomena. Dark matter causes Gravity. They then go on to further classify this cause of gravity as being invisible which is something they find very puzzling. There is so much to say about your posts and you write such long ones too that I'm almost tired before I even start. I've got a busy day to get back to so I shall have to return later.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 (of 287 pages)