PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 (of 287 pages)
I can't tell whether I'm amused or irritated. Is it not a known fact that in many languages in the conjugation of verbs the person is often left out. For instance in spanish if I want to say 'I'm eating payela' I don't have to say Yo Como Payela. All I have to say is 'Como Payela'. 'NO tengo dinero' means I don't have any money (A very useful phrase to know if you ever go to South America). There is no person in 'no tengo dinero'. Tengo is not just have, but I Have. As a result in many such languages the imperative (command) can get mixed up with the present indicative. 'Vive' can be a command to someone to live somewhere. On the other hand Vive can also mean 'She lives . . . ' somewhere. As it happens this is the case with the greek language. As pilgrim.1 tells us that she has studied greek I presume that she is well aware of this in the conjugation of greek verbs. In which case I can only assume that she has been willfully deceptive and mendacious. This word ερευνατε (Ereunate) can be translated as[b] you search[/b] (present indicative) or as a command Search. Which is it? Well let us consider the context in which we find it. The statement 'Ereunate the scriptures' is followed by a reason why. '- for in them you think that you have eternal life'. When someone does an action such as search the scriptures there is often a reason for it. That reason is based on a presumption or belief that they have. They search the scriptures because they think that therein lies eternal life. This following phrase tells us that Jesus is say 'You search . . .'. If it was a command it sounds wierd. It should rather be "Search the scriptures because I Say that therein you have eternal life". not 'I'm telling you to search the scripture because YOU THINK that therein you have eternal life'. because you think' tells me that Jesus is referring to an action that originates from their own impulses and not a command from Jesus. Knowing now that Pilgrim.1 is actually familiar with Greek is disturbing because it suggests to me that she is willfully trying to deceive. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3069929#msg3069929 date=1226392972]@Pastor AIO, I don't think we need to be unnecessarily tedious with this subject.[/quote]Oh, I do think we need to be fastidious with this subject, if not tedious. Anyway, as I can tell from your dialogues with Huxley, Tedium is not somthing that you shy away from. [quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3069929#msg3069929 date=1226392972]If scientists know of realities whcih they only hypothesize, cannot speak directly of their nature, and whose behaviours are not specifically identified, why then should the reality known as "spirit" become seriously a problem?[/quote]I believe I've already addressed this issue. But to summarize, the answer is because Science sets itself different parameters from religion. Meanwhile, I don't think my entries alluded to an idea that[b] an entity ought to have mass before it could be recognized as a[/b] reality. Again, I have not tried to define a "spirit" with physical indices! If anything, what we know as the quality of a spirit being "incorporeal" nevertheless is summised as a reality whose nature is such as that it is "not composed of matter as we know it". These phenomena may be hard to digest, but they do not negate the fact of their existence.I never said that you said that an entity had to have mass before it could be recognized as a reality. And, actually you have tried to define spirit with physical indices, but negatively. Saying, spirit is not this and spirit is not that, blah blah blah. And as for that idea of spirit not being 'composed of matter as we know it', talk about giving yourself room to maneuver!!! Hey, Dark matter is not matter as we know it either, maybe you could come up with a theory of Spirit being Dark matter. LOL! |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3069904#msg3069904 date=1226392363]@Pastor AIO, If you had taken the time to read carefully through what I offered, the analogy you used there is way off what you would have read. I have not defined 'spirit' by its opposite, nor by what it is not; and it is a false assumption many people make in stating that something cannot be defined by what it is not! Descriptive indices actually are used to define entities that are real in our world, so where do you get the idea that one could not do so? An example? Dark matter is said to be an entity that is present in our world; but ask a scientist who speaks of the term and he would tell you at least a couple of things which include something that it is NOT: - "non luminous matter presumed to exist in space" - "a substance that scientists think exists out in space, but for which they have no direct proof" What those sources say includes what dark matter is NOT - ie, it is NOT luminous. But let me quote yet other sources to be more direct - ■ [url=http://wordnet.princeton.edu/perl/webwn?s=dark%20matter]WordNet[/url] dictionary says the following: 'dark matter ((cosmology) a hypothetical form of matter that is believed to make up 90 percent of the universe; it is invisible (does not absorb or emit light) and does not collide with atomic particles but exerts gravitational force)" ■ Wikitionary puts it this way: '(astronomy) particles of matter that cannot be detected by their radiation but whose presence is inferred from gravitational effects' ■ Wikipedia has it as: 'In astronomy and cosmology, dark matter is hypothetical matter that does not interact with the electromagnetic force, but whose presence can be inferred from gravitational effects on visible matter.' ■ Dialogue for Kids (D4K) says: 'nonluminous (not emitting light or visible) material that cannot be seen in the sky. Dark matter is one of the most mysterious things in the universe. Scientists think that dark matter occurs everywhere but they don't yet know exactly what it is made of.' You see, Pastor AIO, these days when people use these quizzical verbosities of "cognition and cognitive" blah-blah et al, we allow them get away with such vague terms - even in the corridors of "science". Nobody rejects these theories from scientists espousing the idea of an entity whose nature they do not know, and in which reality they only infer as being hypothetical, yet undeniable as a reality that is invisible! On the other hand, if one were to describe spiritual realities using terms as "invisible", and say they (often) "cannot be seen", which are "incorporeal" in nature, and are "not composed of matter as we know it", immediately we have you and our dear friends arrogating some super authority to yourselves by saying "You cannot define a thing by it's opposite, or even by what it is NOT." Where you get such an idea that realities cannot be defined in that manner is beyond me![/quote]I ought to make myself clearer. By defining two opposite things by themselves you tell me nothing. Saying Light is the opposite of dark is okay if I know what dark is independently of light. But When my definition of dark is simply the opposite of light then I am defining both terms by themselves and that tells me nothing. Put another way, I'm going to make up a phenomenon called ignositis. What is that? Ignositis is the opposite of Depakisis. But what is Depakisis? Depakisis is the opposite of Ignositis. Now tell me, What have you learned? Apart from two nonsensical terms. Opposites (thesis/anti-thesis. Oh lawd, I tremble when I use those terms. I feel the need to add with haste that I'm not being Hegelian when I say that) are too intimately intertwined to give information about each other. When defining heads, rather than say it is that which is not tails, it is better to explain the whole concept of a coin and then state that heads is but one side of a coin. Do you get me? I have not defined 'spirit' by its opposite, nor by what it is not; and it is a false assumption many people make in stating that something cannot be defined by what it is not!Oh? So what is this? What do these terms mean? When something is defined as ethereal, we are pointing to its nature as being characterized by insubstantiality - that is, it is not defined in terms of physical qualities or solid substance. A similar idea is expressed by its being "incorporeal", which is to say that[b] it is a reality which is not composed of matter[/b] as we know it. it is a false assumption many people make in stating that something cannot be defined by what it is not! Descriptive indices actually are used to define entities that are real in our world, so where do you get the idea that one could not do so?I'm sorry, I don't understand your yoruba here. What does descriptive indices defining reality have to do with defining something by what it is not? An example? Dark matter is said to be an entity that is present in our world; but ask a scientist who speaks of the term and he would tell you at least a couple of things which include something that it is NOT:Excuse me, but modern science is not religion. Scientists do not claim to have the truth revealed to them from above but are happy to confess that they are speculating and making conjectures. This difference in claims gives Scientists a lot more leyway to make mistakes and speculate. They then go out to seek proofs of their hypothesis, but even if they found proofs, those proofs can still be overturned in light of further evidence at a later date, and if they don't find proofs that is no big deal either cos they've already admitted that it was only an hypothesis. You degrade religion by setting it side by side with science for comparison. Leave that to the atheists. While I think it's a diversion away from the main point, I want to indulge this issue of dark matter. okay? What is a fact is that there are many area of space where matter and light behave as if they are being drawn by a strong gravitational field. What is causing this behaviour? Is there a source of this gravitational field? Since the only thing that we know that exerts gravitational pull is Matter it makes sense to presume that there is a lot of matter in these regions of space. However, we do not see any matter there. That is why scientists have come up with the idea of Dark Matter, matter which cannot be seen. It is a hypothesis and given the boundaries which science has set for itself, it is allowed to make such hypothesis. God didn't tell them that there is Dark Matter. They are guessing, we know that, they know that, everybody knows that and it is absolutely no big deal. Dark matter does not have a definition. We don't even know if it exists. Something that might not exist doesn't have a definition. All we know is strange phenomena in Space. You see, Pastor AIO, these days when people use these quizzical verbosities of "cognition and cognitive" blah-blah et al, we allow them get away with such vague terms - even in the corridors of "science". Nobody rejects these theories from scientists espousing the idea of an entity whose nature they do not know, and in which reality they only infer as being hypothetical, yet undeniable as a reality that is invisible!No one rejects them because they are well within the parameters that science has set for itself. On the other hand, if one were to describe spiritual realities using terms as "invisible", and say they (often) "cannot be seen", which are "incorporeal" in nature, and are "not composed of matter as we know it", immediately we have you and our dear friends arrogating some super authority to yourselves by saying "You cannot define a thing by it's opposite, or even by what it is NOT." Where you get such an idea that realities cannot be defined in that manner is beyond me!I'll repeat, Dark matter is not a reality. It is an hypothesis used to explain a phenomenon in space. That phenomenon has positive attributes that define it, ie it emits a gravitational pull, yet contrary to matter that also emits gravity, we cannot see it so we call it Dark Matter. It might not even be matter at all, but for now we are calling it dark matter. You on the other hand have failed, quite abjectly come to think of it, to provide any positive attributes to Spirit. You have only said what it is not. At least Dark matter emits gravity, what does your Spirit do? Where you get such an idea that realities cannot be defined in that manner is beyond me!I get the idea from the fact that such definition tell me nothing. And not only me, they tell nobody nothing (yes, I can mangle the english language too). And it seems, dear pilgrim.1 that your definition has told you nothing either. |
What do these terms mean? When something is defined as ethereal, we are pointing to its nature as being characterized by insubstantiality - that is, it is not defined in terms of physical qualities or solid substance. A similar idea is expressed by its being "incorporeal", which is to say that it is a reality which is not composed of matter as we know it. f you define a demon as a "volition", you have seen none. People only observe the results of human volitions, not the volitions themselves, because volitions are abstract. A spirit is not abstract because it is a being that is ethereal and incorporeal, yet possessing a definite form. However, a demon also is a type of spirit which can exercise a volition on its own -Pilgrim.1, you have said the above. However I'm none the wiser and I'll tell you why. If I were to ask you, "What is light"?, and you were to respond that 'light is what is not Dark' you would have told me nothing. I could pursue my enquiry further and ask, 'but what is dark?', to which you would probably respond that dark is what is not light. And still, I would remain none the wiser. You cannot define a thing by it's opposite, or even by what it is NOT. You need to provide actual qualities that it exhibits. Or at least it's tendencies. What does spirit do that Matter does not do. As it happens there isn't a fixed definition of physical properties in metaphysics. That is why there are so many different types of naturalism. So perhaps you can tell us what you mean by physical properties. For instance, would having a physical location in time and space be a physical property. Must an object have mass before it can be considered physical. What about massless particles in physics? Basically, I need something more substantial that what you have posted above. |
@ Sleekymag @ PASTOR AIOThank you for that question. No it is not meant to mislead people. However it has had very many interesting results that aptly demonstrate many of the issues that I often raise. Such issues as: -The inertia and superficiality of human thinking. -Laziness of humanity -The need for spiritual discerning. Actually these are all the same issue. Let me try to explain what I am saying by giving a few anecdotes. A while back when I had just joined this forum there was a thread about Evolution (one of many) which I contributed to. Now, it is my position that evolution is undeniable. I wrote a post stating that those who deny evolution should not be given the flu vaccine which is renewed every year. Why? Because the flu vaccine has to be renewed every year for the simply reason that the flu virus evolves, so it changes from year to year. If evolution did not occur then there should be no need for a new vaccine. There should also be no need for new pesticides to get rid of mosquitos. So those that deny evolution should be denied the latest antibiotics and the latest insecticides. All these are arguments in favour of evolution, you get me. Well what have you, the very next post was by a certain creature called KAG that just poured out all sorts of invective at my person and rubbishing my post. It became clear as I was reading KAG's post that KAG hadn't read my post at all. This KAG was actually an atheist and a believer in evolution. On further investigation it turned out that all KAG saw was the name Pastor AIO and that was enough to draw the response that I got. the word Pastor triggered such a violent reaction in KAG that he became incapable of reasoning (if he ever had this capability). How could someone write such a lengthy and strongly worded response to something that they hadn't read at all? The answer is that KAG was operating on the basest level of human cognition. At this level the whole being reacts to a simple stimulus almost instinctively. This process was well demonstrated by a scientist called Pavlov. What Pavlov did was he rang a bell just before he was about to give his dog something to eat. When the dog saw the food it started to salivate. After repeating this process numerous times he eventually discovered that he could make the dog salivate just by ringing the bell (though there was no food present). The sound of the bell triggered the response which however was now inappropriate. Okay, I admit that KAG's case is particularly distinguished as being the worst that I've ever experienced, however there are many other people out there who think on this level of cognitive processing. Actually we all do to some extent but there are a few of us who can also employ higher faculties than that. The highest of those faculties comes from the spirit. So the first couple of points that I want to make from the above are: Read my posts and respond to my arguments and don't worry about whether I'm a pastor or not. Don't be lazy. Enquire into all things with that spirit that searches all things. (1cor 2:10!!! I hope this satisfies some of those that worry that I don't quote enough bible) The Spirit is not Lazy. It is the Flesh that is Lazy. It is the Flesh and it's laziness that seeks out the Authority that can spoon feed it so that it doesn't have to reason. It is this Flesh that would rather have a bible that is the '100 % undiluted word of God' so it can get into it's clever semantic processes. Now Pavlov's experiments demonstrated how the Flesh can be programed to respond in certain ways. That was just at one of the lowest levels of cognitive processing. Actually this system can get a hell of a lot more complicated. It can produce highly trained intellectual gymnasts who can do all sorts of semantic cartwheels and argue quite Maradonically. But ultimately it is still the same dead, inert stupidity. It can create nothing. It is stuck in it's speculative Religionism. So to conclude my answer to Sleekymag's question. No one can mislead you unless you are already mislead. No pushy pushy unless person dey push inself. Gbon Gbon o si, a fi ti eni ba ti ara e. |
This thread gives the perfect example of why I no longer use the term christian for myself. I just want to give Kunle some encouragement from where I am sitting. No one can tell you what is in your heart. This is your own personal journey. Don't be bullied by their doctrines and aggressive orthodoxology.[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3051065#msg3051065 date=1226058940]Kunle, Please go and study your heart. You really don't have a clue about these issues, and even if one has to take you up on simple matters in the Bible, you still don't even know the ABCs of that Book. If you are seeking to protect your predispositions, no worries: but you haven't seen anything yet until stuff begin to happen to you![/quote] |
But By Scripture was Jesus referring to the Bible? |
And church that pays rent for it's premises is business. And church that pays water rates, and electricity bills is business. If everything in church is free then what is the point of making offerings? |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=191998.msg3050175#msg3050175 date=1226044329]Great that you don't agree with him. Question is: why?[/quote]It's not 'Great' that I don't agree with him. It's just the matter of fact. Why? Well for a start he hasn't really arrived at a conclusion to agree or disagree with. That is why I said Perhaps I don't agree. He has to take a position first before I can agree or disagree. If someone is proposing an ideology that is antithetical to the fundamentals of his own faith and then passes it off as the veracity of the Christian faith, we want to know how he could rationally justify such a position.Just what are these fundamentals of his faith? He has called to question the validity of the bible (as a whole) for basing your faith on. I think it is extremely duplicitous to try to pass the bible off as a single monolithic tome on which christianity is based. The Bible consists of various books and letters. No one can doubt that the practice of christianity has changed over the millenia and it continues to change today. The early christians were not bible wielding legalists. There simply was no bible at that time. How can any christian today pass off his position as the veracity of the christian faith more than any other? It seems to irk you that he passes his position off as the veracity of the christian faith. Well, don't you do the same? How do you 'rationally justify such a position'? While I hate to speak for other people, and I'm quite sure that KunleOshob can speak for himself, I seem to recall his pointing out in previous posts that the early christian church was a hell of a lot more charitable in it's activities that the contemporary churches are. There were other practices that are today nonexistent in most churches. The question is . . . can you call it a duck when it goes 'woof' and wags it's tail. |
I don't disagree with Kunle. Okay, perhaps I don't agree either, but what I believe I see is a guy pursuing an honest enquiry. I'm not comfortable with everyone ganging up on him. He has raised numerous points over the last few months that haven't properly been addressed by those on this thread that are trying to bully him. |
Donpuzo:I agree with you that from Human perspective God can seem unjust and unfair. |
What is it about demons that allows them to be captured on film while they cannot be seen by the naked eye? Again I wonder, What is a spirit? And what are the qualities exhibited by spirit? |
What are the defining characteristics of Spirit? What are the defining characteristics of Nature? I think that naturalist have too vague a definition of what is natural. As things stand whatever they experience can be called natural because there is no fixed definition. They've reserved themselves with the right to shift the goalpost as they wish. I've even heard someone state that everything is natural including spirits. Well that just makes everything vague. I believe that when christ made a distinction between spirit and flesh he had a clear notion of what he was talking about. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3037220#msg3037220 date=1225820942]By the way, what do you make of this: https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-178839.128.html#msg3035262 ??[/quote]I don't usually put too much credence on hearsay. And that skepticism extends to things that I see on camera and youtube and stuff like that. I'll be more impressed by an argument built from something that I've experienced myself. |
[quote author=pilgrim.1 link=topic=181454.msg3034966#msg3034966 date=1225795791]1. Exorcism: The Power of Faith Highlights: ■ uncontrolled screaming ■ scatological yelling ■ loud and angry obscenities ■ animal-like groaning ■ strange voices and unusual strange strength manifested in the victim.[/quote]What do you think might be the connection with Tourette's syndrome if there is any connection at all. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tourette_syndrome http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=G_jBFbCCleY&feature=related Compulsive actions that are beyond conscious control often have a psychiatric explanation. In psychiatry we recognise a loop that explains human behaviours. First comes an URGE which gives you a feeling of dissatisfaction. This is followed by an ACTION whose purpose is to satisfy the Urge. The finally when the action is completed and the Urge is satisfied we have a feeling of SATIATION. Then at a later date another urge arises and the process starts again. So we have the loop of URGE-ACTION-SATIATION-URGE . . . . In the nervous system where this loop occurs the process can be damaged due to neurological dysfunction so we have compulsive disorders. Some people eat (action) but don't get the feeling of satisfaction after eating so they don't stop eating. Other people don't eat because they are not aware that their body needs nourishment etc. Does this not provide an explanation for uncontrolled compulsive behaviour. 2) And as regards the scatology there are very many interesting observations. This shows that there is indeed a cultural element to these disorders. Why is it that Satan never possesses people from religious backgrounds that do not recognise Satan. There is demon possession in every culture in this world but Buddhist only get possessed by Buddhist demons, Christians get possessed by Satan, Orisha worshippers get possessed by Yoruba spirits. Why is that the case? Why is it the case that Satan never ever possessed an ancient greek victim, only Kory, and Dionysus etc possessed them. We know that in every culture there is a value system and that there are things that are considered unsavoury in that culture. In western society terms like 'Nigger', 'Shit', 'Bleep' are considered unsavoury. Could we say that Tourettes and other such compulsive disorders influence us by interacting with the value systems programmed into our neurology such that what ever it is that we find of low value, and unsavoury, we find ourselves compelled to utter. If in a certain society evil is personified by a entity called Satan then the sufferer will feel compelled to say 'I am Satan'. I don't think it is possible to separate cultural circumstance from the utterances of possessed people. As it is impossible to separate it from from the utterances of Tourette syndrome suffers. 3) There is a discipline called NeuroLinguistic Programming, or NLP for short. One of it's premises is that there is a connection between emotional states of mind and certain linguistic terms. I totally agree with this premise. When dealing with someone it is important to listen carefully to their vocabulary and note the connotations they give each word they use. Words have both denotations and connotations. The denotation is the dictionary definition of the word. The connotations are the extraneous associations that comes with word. For example say I'm the boss of a guy that I need to motivate. If I say to him that if he doesn't pull himself together then I will be 'forced to let him go', I might find that he is still not motivated. He knows what I mean by 'forced to let him go' but yet it doesn't make a deep emotional connection with him. If however I said," pull yourself together or you're FIRED". He might suddenly pull his socks up. Not because I've said anything different. But the word Fired might strike a deeper emotional chord with him. It might carry emotional connotations of shame, worthlessness, low social standing. That word 'Fired' has an emotional connection that will motivate him more than 'let him go' even though they mean the same thing. Just as words can help to access emotional states so vice versa do emotional states express themselves through the use of certain words. It's like being in love with a woman and you feel the urge to say to her 'I love you', but you resist it because you know that if you were to say so she would run a million miles away from you. Having to hold those words back feels oppressive. similarly when you're angry your vocabulary changes accordingly. Certain words are associated with and convey certain emotional states. If there is a neurological disorder that causes emotional states that have no bearing on the actual circumstances of a person then that person can be seen to yell angry obscenities for no apparent reason. 4) Unusual strength can also be explained neurochemically. I've witnessed someone high on LSD get into a fight in the middle of Leicester square in london. He'd gotten into the fight with a police man and soon there were about 30 to 40 police men trying to restrain him. This was on new years eve. The fight lasted about 20 minutes in my recollection although I wasn't actually timing it. Do you know those cartoons like tom and jerry where there is a fight and all you see is a ball of dust with arms and legs sticking out. That was what it was like. There was this swirling 'ball of dust' composed of police men sweeping across leicester square and every 4 to 5 seconds a police man would fly out of the ball at an incredible trajectory like the ball was spitting out police men at all angles. Eventually they pinned the guy down but it took a long time. It is not only people on drugs that have been capable of this super human strength. Buddhist monks that study Shaolin Kung Fu have demonstrated time and time again that they are capable of feat of strength that are beyond the normal. They have a methodology for developing this ability that has nothing to do with demon possession. I think that in actually fact the strength we exhibit is influenced by our state of mind as much as by the amount of calories etc that we have available. That is why confidence and hope is such an important factor in success in life. If a man is deflated he will not be very strong but if something occurs that gives him hope, who knows where the new burst of energy comes from, but all of a suddenly he is up and running again. These are just a few thoughts. |
Chrisbenogor:I hear you. Let me try to respond point for point. Human knowledge is limited I agree, the main reason being that we have to take into consideration that all answers should satisfy all of mankind and not a particular sect.All answers, nay even one answer, cannot satisfy all of mankind. Being limited to various perspectives means that even when they come in contact with an absolute truth, each group will interprete it variously. You cannot forget that understanding and perception are subject to interpretation. Interpretation is subject to perspective. Everyone interprets stuff differently from everyone else. So I cannot make wild assumptions that this earth was created by a supernatural being, the onus would be on me to not only show to the whole world who God is and what his nature is.But do you accept the existence of a supernatural reality? I wonder. Also What is your definition of natural as opposed to supernatural? What makes the assumption of divine creation any wilder than any other assumption that is out there. Since human knowledge is limited how then can we say we know the nature of a supernatural being, the assumption that what we do not yet understand can be explained by the existence of a being we really know nothing about is as dishonest as it can get.I agree that limited human knowledge is incapable of knowing the supernatural. I even agree that there is a lot of dishonesty in the explanation of religious doctrinaires on the 'existence of a being we really know nothing about'. However I believe that we have another faculty other than that which acquires human knowledge, but we do not use that other faculty. We can call this faculty divine or just simply spiritual. Until this faculty undergoes naissance it is impossible for a man/woman to engage with the spiritual world. He is stuck with the natural thinking processes which will keep getting confounded every time it builds an idea of the world. What am I really saying? If we agree that Human knowledge is limited, how can we then fully understand a being that does not communicate with us? I mean if you say the being had the intelligence to do create this wonderful solar system, why has he refused to just reveal himself to all to see, frankly the idea of God is absurd, because its only things we cannot explain we ascribe to God and that is as dishonest as one can get.I disagree that God refuses to communicate with us. You can talk to a deaf man till you voice is hoarse but the he will not hear a single thing you are saying. Likewise, how do you expect to hear spiritual communication when you do not have the faculty to hear it. God is revealed but you can not perceive with the physical senses. I don't know what the particular idea of God is that you are talking about. But I will agree that any idea of God is absurd. These ideas are formulated by the limited human mind. God is a lot greater that what our minds can formulate. |
http://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Romans%2011:32 32For God has bound all men over to disobedience so that he may have mercy on them all. Felix culpa is a Latin phrase that literally translated means a "blessed fault" or "fortunate fall". As a religious term it refers to Adam and Eve's fall and the loss of the Garden of Eden, known theologically as the source of original sin. The phrase is sung annually in the Exsultet of the Easter Vigil: "O felix culpa quae talem et tantum meruit habere redemptorem," "O happy fault that merited such and so great a Redeemer." The medieval theologian Thomas Aquinas [1] cited this line when he explained how the principle that "God allows evils to happen in order to bring a greater good therefrom" underlies the causal relationship between original sin and the Divine Redeemer's Incarnation.From wikipedia. |
Chrisbenogor:I've asked a lot of questions. Which one? is it this one? Pastor AIO:I was saying that if human knowledge is limited (as indeed it is) then human judgement would be accordingly limited. So our evaluations of right and wrong are distorted by our limited knowledge. These evaluations are different for different people because we each have different perspectives from which we see things. If, however, knowledge was absolute. ie. Not limited to one perspective but a summation of all perspectives, including all such perspectives as are contrary to each other, then wouldn't such a position allow for an absolute evaluation. And as regards the fully practising muslim . . . I would say that if it has been appropriated to him to be a fully practising muslim then for him to do such would be righteous of him. It is not my place however to dictate to people what their appropriation is. That is between them and their creator. |
Donpuzo:Sometimes in life you don't always get what you ask for. and other times you get a hell of a lot more than you ask for. That's just the way some cookies crumble. Donpuzo:A fascinating piece of theologizing. |
[quote author=A_K_O link=topic=186585.msg3028706#msg3028706 date=1225653652]If man truly is a tripartite being; spirit, soul and body, then they co-exist.[/quote]QFT! |
donnie:This is too full of contradictions that I don't know where to start. 'naturally desires to please god'. 'even sin wilfully sometimes'. Where does the the will to sin come from if one naturally desires to please God? The secret to living above sin for the righteous man is to walk in the Spirit. The bible says: 'walk in the spirit and ye shall not fulfil the lusts of the flesh, for the flesh lusts against the spirit and the spirit against the flesh.'I'm glad you mention the dichotomy of flesh and spirit. Is it not true that even the born again have both spirit and flesh as aspects of their being? So therefore the sinful nature and righteous nature co-exist. as for that last part I don't know if you are saying that righteousness is not a matter of our actions because no matter what we do the blood of christ cleanses us and makes us righteous, or something else. As regards the 'feeling of guilt and regret that follows' doing sin I wonder, what is the impulse that leads one to seek redemption while still a sinner. Isn't there guilt and regret while still a sinner too? |
huxley:Phew! Now can we get back to Christians and demons. Thanks |
donnie:Well this is quite an interesting interpretation of scripture. I shall peruse it a bit more. Are you aware though that it's quite a different position from this: @Pastor AIOThe two either co exist in a man or they do not coexist. pick one. |
Cayon:Amen! |
The knowledge is not of the existence or nonexistence of God. It is already given that God exists and the issue is whether God's knowledge is relative or absolute. However, if you are not comfortable with the existence of God then look at it this way. Imagine knowing your situation from every perspective possible, including all contrary perspectives. In other words a totally panoramic viewpoint of a situation. Would the evaluation of such a situation be relative or absolute? |
Chrisbenogor:No sir, I understand you very well. You are saying that what is right or wrong is relative to the knowledge that people have. There are a couple of things that you should be aware of about my position though. This evaluation of right or wrong is made from a position of absolute knowledge. God knows everything so it is not a human epistemology that is in effect here. This is exactly the point that I've tried to raise in numerous threads on this forum. Human knowledge is limited to perspective yet divine knowledge is not. |
donnie: donnie:So Sir, can I presume that since you've had this new birth and this new nature which has supplanted the old, that you no longer sin. Or feel temptation to follow your old nature as it doesn't exist anymore in you. What you are saying implies one of two things. 1) You haven't committed a single sin, or had the inclination to sin since the day your stony heart was replaced. 2)Or . . . If you have sinned then you haven't been born again and your christianity is a farce. Which is it? |
Chrisbenogor:Sir, this is not something that I'm looking to learn, but rather something I'd learnt a while back and then soon unlearned when I realised it was baseless. There is no need to find any actual scenarios, commonsense will suffice to tell me you are wrong. What you have is a paradox. You are saying that all value systems are relative. However this includes your evaluation of value systems. Therefore it is a self referential statement. Your statement that all values are relative is itself relative so can not be an absolute truth. Now I am comfortable with Paradox. I think that there are many ontologically valid situations that are paradoxical, however paradox cannot occur in the physical plane. I presume that you are a materialist, ie you don't believe in the spiritual or metaphysical world, in which case there can be no room for paradox in you thinking. There is either LIGHT or there is DARKNESS, but you can't have your cake and eat it all at the same time. Unless you are a greedy pig. |
Chrisbenogor:So I beg sir, is what you wrote above merely right according to your personal belief, or have you grace us with some of the Perfect Knowledge. |
I haven't watched the video but I think No, it shouldn't |
justcool:This is actually a damn good question. What do we understand by the term spirit? I accept that spirit is to be contrasted with physical matter. And there are certain defining things that we can say about physical matter. Like it has a location, and a spatial span (eg. 3 cubic metres). Also matter exhibits certain forces. Physics tells us that these forces are fourfold. Namely, Gravitational force, Electromagnetic force, and then Strong and Weak nuclear forces. It is due to these forces that matter is perceptible to our physical senses. Can we make a similar outline for Spirit? What qualities does Spirit exhibit? These questions are very relevant if we are to make statements like a 'spirit entering a man's body'. n demon-possession, diabolical spirits actually enter into the victim's body and take up residency there - and from that position, they take control of that person's faculties and render the victim incapable of living their own lives in any way contrary to what the demon(s) desires.The highlighted part above would suggest to me that spirits actually occupy a specific location. If the spirit is in the body then the next question I find myself asking is "what part of the body is it in? the liver? the brain? or is it diffused all around the body?" Is it perceptible to the physical senses? Are phantoms and other effects of the imagination spirits? My second problem with the demon influence versus demon possession position is as follows. An addict finds within himself the urge to act contrary to his conscious volition. He might resist the urge, or the urge might overwhelm him. How strong does the urge have to be before it stops becoming a demonic influence and actually becomes demonic possession. Possessed people are not in the state of possession trance constantly. It comes in cycles. It can be predicted most of the time. It could be weekly, or even every evening. But in the daylight, or interim times, they go back to normal. During the possession trance their consciousness is blotted out. They have no recollection when they return to normal. Yet this is not the only phenomenon that does the same thing, like I mentioned before. Even having too much to drink can make you lose all memory of what you did that evening. Although some would argue that being drunk like that is also to be considered spirit possession afterall what else is good whisky if not some damn strong Spirit. Here's what Wikipedia has to say on the subject: Demonic possession is often the term used to describe the control over a human form by Satan himself or one of his assigned advocates. Descriptions of demonic possessions often include: erased memories or personalities, convulsions, “fits” and fainting as if one were dying.[1] Unlike in channelling or other benign forms of possession, the subject has no control over the possessing entity and so it will persist until forced to leave the victim, usually through a form of exorcism. Many cultures and religions contain some concept of demonic possession, but the details vary considerably. The Roma people believe that demons can also possess animals, plants, deceased persons or inanimate objects.. . . oh and by the way, the reference to familiar spirits in the OT is not the same as demons that possess people. Familiar spirits are what mediums use to contact the dead and effect certain things, the familiar is subject to the medium not the other way round. Familiaris is latin for household servant. Here is also a link for a recent case of demon possession. Although I cannot figure out why in this modern technological age the could not have made a video of the events or at least a tape recording. http://www.worldnetdaily.com/index.php?fa=PAGE.view&pageId=58835 |
[quote author=m_nwankwo link=topic=181454.msg3016364#msg3016364 date=1225373243]@Pilgrim You continue to raise the same issues. Part of the problem in this discussion seem to be the interpretation of words. You adhere strictly to the dictionary meaning of every word. To make my self clearer and less abstract I will adhere to ordinary meaning of words as in the dictionary and where I cannot, I will define or explain what I meant. Now their are two words which I used with regard to demons: will and personality. When a dictionary meaning of these words are applied to my submissions, it leads to interpretations which are not in accord with what I meant in my descriptions. Thus to be as clear as possible I retract the words will and personality. I will replace them with clearer statements as follows: Demons are evil volitions of the human spirit. Demons have a form. Demons are ethereal and not abstract. Demons have an elemental core that allows it to act. The action of a demon may be directed by its producer or by others. In this connection an envy witch (a demon) produced by Mr. A may be directed by Mr. A to attack Mr. B or be directed by envious Mr.D to attack Mr. B or may attack spirituallly weak or envious Mr F without a direction from any human being. Demons do not possess freedom of choice, the remain what their originator or producer intended them to be. An envy witch remain so and cannot change its nature. Demons can attack, influence, afflict but are incapable of possessing a human being. I guess this explanation is clealer. Now let me address some of the issues you raised: Based on my definition above, I think that your questioning of "volition" exercising "volition" does not apply anymore. A demon is a volition but the volition has no "volition" or "will". In order not to misrepresent your statements, kindly explain what you mean by "spirit is ethereal and incoporeal". Also since you said that a demon is a "type of spirit", what is spirit. An alien spirit is another human spirit that is no more in flesh and blood. I can infer (correct me if it is a wrong inference) that demons are not human spirit but diabolical spirits. Now explain how a non-human spirit will take possesion of a human body. What are spirit beings. Since you have seen spirit, what type of spirit did you see and how does it look. What is your evidence that there is no such thing as the neutral power of God? Stay blessed.[/quote]But Sir, is it not obvious from the title of the thread that the Demon that is being asked about is the demon as christians understand it. ie a demon that can possess a human being. And further whether such a demon can possess a christian. There has been no talk of demonic Volitions until you came along, and your contribution has not really helped the advancement of this thread. ps. I hope you don't find what I said rude. I don't mean to be. But it seems obvious to me that you are contributing negative equity to the thread. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 264 265 266 267 268 269 270 271 272 (of 287 pages)
here is a little test if you can find scenarios where I am wrong then it cannot be a perfect knowledge, but watch it, might be very tricky.