Christianity Etc › Re: John 3 Vs 16 Says Bible Is A Complete Hoax by PastorAIO: 2:57pm On Apr 07, 2018*. Modified: 3:23pm On Apr 07, 2018 |
I don't know what muttley started trolling me but the first time I recall him registering with a ping on my attention was in the Hebrew Monotheist thread. All I did was contribute by suggesting that cyrus did not worship Marduk but rather Ahura mazda. Here: https://www.nairaland.com/3753404/hebrew-monotheistic-belief-product-religious/1#56034992The banter went back and forth and after I demonstrated that Marduk priests made a claim for him just as Jewish priest did in the bible yet independent non religious sources show that he worship Ahura Mazda, he just went quiet on that one but ever since has taken to jump out of the bushes every time I make a post to counter with something inane. I just don't know why I bother him so much. He even got to a point he was making actually real life threats on me, telling me he knows my IP address. Anyway, I thank God for all things. MuttleyLaff: Thankfully your IP address got noted down so mental assessment teams can pay you a visit. |
Christianity Etc › Re: John 3 Vs 16 Says Bible Is A Complete Hoax by PastorAIO: 12:24pm On Apr 07, 2018 |
Ubenedictus: you guys have been at each others throat for sometime now, I think he has confused me and you. To be honest I've noticed since I've come to nairaland that some puffed up christian ideologue always takes it upon himself to troll me. His is just the latest manifestation of a phenomenon I've noticed for a long while now. The main thrust of the trolling is to demonstrate that they are smarter than me. That's the funny thing. It is even less about theology and more about who sabi pass. The list is endless. Noetic is another memorable one, but there are many more. I think that there is a strain in christianity of intellectual puffed up ness that manifests every now and again. Of course christianity has many intellectual giants like Augustine of Hippo, Thomas Aquinas etc, but at the other end of the scale is the chap who reads a tract or two, and maybe discovers a website and hey presto! he believes he knows it all. I know that I have a way of being heavy handed when I write which isn't cool, but the worst part of it is that it smokes out these types of people and then I get trolled for months. My objective is not to let it wind me up but to even just ignore them if I feel it's going to lead to saying things that I won't be proud of. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 12:15pm On Apr 07, 2018 |
Emmanystone: @the bolded, at what point in history did this happen? I mean the Jews overthrowing the Canaanite ruling class? It is the theory that I find most reasonable. It happened over the course of centuries. roughly from about 1300bce to 800 bce. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 12:13pm On Apr 07, 2018 |
Still maintaining a limited intellectual capacity. Inside all this one that you've spewed now, will you still say that Jews ought to know more than you or not? Emmanystone: If Moses didn't write the Torah, i hope you know that you and i will not come close to know it? The Jews will be in that position to know. They wont hold Moses with the kind of reverence they do.
No Nation in the Hisyory of men keeps records by mouth to mouth preservation like the Jews. Their God told them to tell their children and have their Children tell their own Children about their origin, till His promises for them are fulfilled. Emmanystone: Oh, this pastor has no idea what he is talking about. If only you knew that the Jews' temporal rejection of their Messiah is not of their making. You read and quote from the Scriptures but only when you dishonestly know that taking the verse out of context will project your twisted intent.
Now, here is what the Scriptures says about the Jews rejecting their messiah for now; I said 'for now', because, when this dispensation closes, they'll come to the realization of who Christ truly is and shall embrace Him.
GNT 11:7-12 What then? The people of Israel did not find what they were looking for. It was only the small group that God chose who found it; the rest grew deaf to God's call.
As the scripture says, “God made their minds and hearts dull; to this very day they cannot see or hear.”
And David says, “May they be caught and trapped at their feasts; may they fall, may they be punished!
May their eyes be blinded so that they cannot see; and make them bend under their troubles at all times.” I ask, then: When the Jews stumbled, did they fall to their ruin?
By no means! Because they sinned, salvation has come to the Gentiles, to make the Jews jealous of them.
[The sin of the Jews brought rich blessings to the world, and their spiritual poverty brought rich blessings to the Gentiles]
Then, how much greater the blessings will be when the complete number of Jews is included!
The Jews rejection of their Messiah opened a door for us Gentiles to accept Jesus. This is the Church Age, when this despensation closes with the rapture, all the Jews shall turn to their Messiah.
Romans 11:13-22 [b]I am speaking now to you Gentiles: As long as I am an apostle to the Gentiles, I will take pride in my work.
Perhaps I can make the people of my own race jealous, and so be able to save some of them.
For when they were rejected, all other people were changed from God's enemies into his friends.
What will it be, then, when they are accepted? It will be life for the dead!
If the first piece of bread is given to God, then the whole loaf is his also; and if the roots of a tree are offered to God, the branches are his also.
Some of the branches of the cultivated olive tree have been broken off, and a branch of a wild olive tree has been joined to it.
You Gentiles are like that wild olive tree, and now you share the strong spiritual life of the Jews.
So then, you must not despise those who were broken off like branches.
How can you be proud? You are just a branch; you don't support the roots—the roots support you.
But you will say, “Yes, but the branches were broken off to make room for me.” That is true.
They were broken off because they did not believe, while you remain in place because you do believe. But do not be proud of it; instead, be afraid.
God did not spare the Jews, who are like natural branches; do you think he will spare you? Here we see how kind and how severe God is.
He is severe toward those who have fallen, but kind to you—if you continue in his kindness. But if you do not, you too will be broken off.[/b]
Can you see why the Jews don't believe in Jesus yet?
I'm waiting for your twisted mind to come up with another twisted and warped views. |
Christianity Etc › Re: John 3 Vs 16 Says Bible Is A Complete Hoax by PastorAIO: 11:51am On Apr 07, 2018 |
I smell some sort of paranoid delusion. Ubenedictus: you guys were all on the thread, I shorten the 3 usernames, I am surprised you think I was referring to you in code in connivance with pastoraio, that is pretty surprising... are you Almighty God that I have to talk about in fear? I just don't get it.
I made a post in a thread where you guys are active and you think I was hiding it from you, aio responded without crying wolf about his username but you guys hold yourselves in such regard that to you a shorten username a a sign of ..... I just don't get it.
this is a post you made on that thread among others that made me wonder if your theology has a room for human failure among members of the body of Christ. you wrote:
Yes, the best thing to do will be to leave the place because they do not represent Christ there. But, leaving a place like that, doesn't mean you should leave Christ, because, none of those men are you model, Christ is. And, as long as you didn't see any of their trait in Christ, you follow He who called you to everladting life. That's why we have a Bible. You don't throw in the Towel and say, 'Christianity is a Farce', because Men have become senseless.
there you and aio seemed to advocate leaving a congregation if sin if found there as if it was supposed to b perfect. later you wrote
Anything less than practising pure and faultless religion that God approves of, is not true and so thereby is false religion
again the perfection of Christian living just without it flaws in human nature.
I responded cautiously saying I may b wrong about expounding your views...aio certainly felt that wasn't his view you on the other hand thinks I was gossiping about you in code. this is my post in question
I may be wrong but I see aio and emmany and mutty speak of religion in its purest idealistic form and anathemize anything that fall under and below and I am almost tempted to ask if any of you guys live out the religion you profess... in my personal experience and in the experience of those around me it isn't perfect, we fall under often, in fact Catholics make a point of describing Christian life as the personal workspace of the HOLY spirit who constantly re-converts us, remake us and remold us.... in fact the awareness that I am living in Grace isn't the most interesting thing in my Christian life, it is instead that act of falling down on my kneels as God exposes parts of my life and attitudes, behavior and thoughts I have falsely built and leads me to a new path....that is for me one of the best effects of grace. living below what is perfect has not made me a lesser Christian, it has led me forward it is part of what is genuinely Christian, the Christian is not a perfect product, in my experience he is God's work in progress. I don't agree with you guys that a Christian doesn't steal, cheat, fornicate or commit sin, cos he does, his benefit is simply the remaking, renewing and converting power of the HOLY spirit. I have never seen the Christian Church as a gathering of the perfect, that is Calvinist, for me it is a hospital for sinners, constantly healing and been healed.... I don't agree with this idea of perfection you guys seem to advocate. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 11:07am On Apr 07, 2018 |
and lest any one gets swayed by any yeye Ipuwer arguments they should consider read this: Ipuwer and the Book of Exodus
Ipuwer has been often put forward in popular literature as confirmation of the Biblical account, most notably because of its statement that "the river is blood" and its frequent references to servants running away, but these arguments ignore the many points on which Ipuwer contradicts Exodus, such as the fact that its Asiatics are arriving in Egypt rather than leaving, and the likelihood that the "river is blood" phrase may refer to the red sediment colouring the Nile during disastrous floods, or may simply be a poetic image of turmoil.[10] The archeological evidence does not support the story of the Exodus, and most histories no longer consider it relevant to the story of the emergence of Israel.[11][12] -Wikipedia |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 11:04am On Apr 07, 2018 |
William Dever, Professor Emeritus at the University of Arizona, has investigated the archeology of the ancient Near East for more than 30 years and authored almost as many books on the subject. In the following interview, Dever describes some of the most significant archeological finds related to the Hebrew Bible,
The origins of Israel What have archeologists learned from these settlements about the early Israelites? Are there signs that the Israelites came in conquest, taking over the land from Canaanites?
The settlements were founded not on the ruins of destroyed Canaanite towns but rather on bedrock or on virgin soil. There was no evidence of armed conflict in most of these sites. Archeologists also have discovered that most of the large Canaanite towns that were supposedly destroyed by invading Israelites were either not destroyed at all or destroyed by "Sea People"—Philistines, or others.
So gradually the old conquest model [based on the accounts of Joshua's conquests in the Bible] began to lose favor amongst scholars. Many scholars now think that most of the early Israelites were originally Canaanites, displaced Canaanites, displaced from the lowlands, from the river valleys, displaced geographically and then displaced ideologically.
So what we are dealing with is a movement of peoples but not an invasion of an armed corps from the outside. A social and economic revolution, if you will, rather than a military revolution. And it begins a slow process in which the Israelites distinguish themselves from their Canaanite ancestors, particularly in religion—with a new deity, new religious laws and customs, new ethnic markers, as we would call them today. http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ancient/archeology-hebrew-bible.html |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 10:34am On Apr 07, 2018 |
MuttleyLaff: Not only desperate but more
Swot up on the Egyptian sage named Ipuwer
This post is so fubar I expect this coming from a dissembler and so not surprised at the bunglings, misinformation or having the Jews mixed up with the Hyksos Only me, and I have the questionable honour of being trolled by you. Even to the point that you can claim that I was viewing a thread when I didn't even contribute to the thread. So you are even aware of where I browse. What a pitiable soul. Well you have one thing right about me. I think to highly of myself to stoop to trading un-progressive insults with you. MuttleyLaff: No one dragged you here kicking and screaming You, on your own volition, slithered in and it was when or after, I spotted you loitering about the pages of the thread, that I remarked: PastorAIO, its turn by turn, I read where you and Ubenedictus used emmany and mutty in codes to mention Emmanystone and I, and I laughed at how I got misconstrued but I will respond when you both, get to the front of the queue
Long-established you think too highly of yourself |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 12:35am On Apr 07, 2018 |
Emmanystone: So you believe a Jewish Rabbi will tell a Gentile that the Nation of Israel was never captives in Egypt at point in time, and there was never a Red Sea Crossing? The 40yrs wandering in the Wilderness never happened. You believe a Moses never lived as a human? Meaning there was no Wars which led to the Conquest of Canaan?
Are you this desperate?  I have no reason to disbelief the man. Plus, his rabbi friend is not the only rabbi that will affirm that. Not only will rabbis say it never happened but historians too will agree with them. Especially the top Jewish historians. The Egyptians would were meticulous record keepers never made a single mention of the event either. The Jews were Canaanites who overthrew their ruling class and created an anarchist society. Out of this a new religion slowly emerged out of the old religions of the canaanites. But it was a long and protracted process. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 12:26am On Apr 07, 2018 |
Emmanystone: [b][/b] For you to quote this and mention me means you believe what he said right?
So you believe a Jewish Rabbi will tell a Gentile that the Nation of Israel was never captives in Egypt at point in time, and there was never a Red Sea Crossing? The 40yrs wandering in the Wilderness never happened. You believe a Moses never lived as a human? Meaning there was no Wars which led to the Conquest of Canaan?
Are you this desperate?  Basic reasoning ability would tell you that the point o was making was that your manner of reasoning ( that Jews would know best, better than even yourself) does not favour your stance. Just the simple fact that Jewish rabbis reject your jesus as the messiah should have been enough to shut your mouth on the line of thinking. But you lacked the capacity to realise that you were arguing against yourself. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 3:44pm On Apr 06, 2018 |
Emmanystone: If Moses didn't write the Torah, i hope you know that you and i will not come close to know it? The Jews will be in that position to know. They wont hold Moses with the kind of reverence they do.
No Nation in the Hisyory of men keeps records by mouth to mouth preservation like the Jews. Their God told them to tell their children and have their Children tell their own Children about their origin, till His promises for them are fulfilled. [quote author=sonmvayina post=66482974]I
Yes that is what I mean...because the people who it was written for and the people that wrote it says it is a spiritual journey not a literal one..
The rabbi at Golders green synagogue in London told me, when I was there...we lived on the same street.. [/quote] |
Christianity Etc › Re: Des Pensees by PastorAIO(op): 11:31am On Apr 06, 2018 |
I use the term System in the scientific sense:
system is a regularly interacting or interdependent group of items forming an integrated whole.[1] Every system is delineated by its spatial and temporal boundaries, surrounded and influenced by its environment, described by its structure and purpose and expressed in its functioning. --Wikipedia
So an example of a system could be the human body. Or a Car. Or a Company. Or a Country.
There are 'closed' systems and 'open' systems. An open system can be affected by influences outside the system. So the influence of viruses outside the body can still enter the body and make it sick.
Then you also have closed systems. like an hermetically sealed container. Of course it would be impossible (or highly unlikely at the very least) to create a strictly closed system. If a hermetically sealed container can keep out air and gases from the container it cannot keep out Heat. If you warm the container from outside the contents will get hot so there is a heating influence coming in from outside.
A hermetic seal is any type of sealing that makes a given object airtight (excluding passage of air, oxygen, or other gases). The term originally applied to airtight glass containers, but as technology advanced it applied to a larger category of materials, including rubber and plastics. -Wikipedia
Well, there is one system that many agree is a totally closed system. That is the Universe. There is nothing outside of the Universe to influence what is going on in the Universe.
I say many people agree. Some won't even agree that the universe is a closed system. They will say that God is outside of the Universe and he can influence events in the Universe. However others would say that God is a part of the universe. ...
Obviously how a system is delineated is totally arbitrary. You can call a village a system, but would that include it's surrounding farms or just the dwelling places etc etc etc....
But once a System is defined we find in the interaction of it's parts the effect of all 3 tendencies with one dominating at any point. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Des Pensees by PastorAIO(op): 11:02am On Apr 06, 2018 |
PastorAIO: Every system in the world whether it be our cognitive systems, our sociopolitical systems, physical systems, or whatever, can exist in one of three phases and shifts from one phase to another.
The first phase is Inertia or Rigor.
The next phase is Dynamism or Vivacity.
And then there is Sheer Potentiality. I would like to correct myself here. Or subtly rephrase what I am saying cos I might be suggesting the wrong notion. These 3 phases should actually be seen as tendencies. So in any system there is a tendency to become Inert, and there is also a tendency to become more dynamic or volatile, and there is also a tendency to increase Potential. These 3 tendencies are in some sort of balance. Always 'pulling' against each other. One usually dominates in a system but can lose it's dominance. This is important because you might observe a system that seems quite volatile when in fact it is dominated by the tendency to Inertia and while it is still quite volatile it is quickly becoming more and more inert. |
Christianity Etc › Re: John 3 Vs 16 Says Bible Is A Complete Hoax by PastorAIO: 8:43am On Apr 06, 2018 |
MuttleyLaff: The bearing of you being that stuck up, to remark that this is not even the kind of thread that you would engage in But it is not. You are the one that has dragged me here kicking and screaming. I'm even amazed that I'm still here. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Des Pensees by PastorAIO(op): 7:36am On Apr 06, 2018 |
Ubenedictus: nope, but for the Christian faith, it is the inspired text par excellence. This is circular. I asked why is it special. You say because it's inspired I say is it the only inspired thing. You say it's inspiration is par excellence. Is that a special kind of inspiration separate from , say, the inspiration that led men to say that god is a trinity? |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 7:28am On Apr 06, 2018 |
JMAN05: How did you come to the conclusion that it is fiction, and who do you think wrote the book? Show me where I came to the conclusion it was fiction. |
Christianity Etc › Re: John 3 Vs 16 Says Bible Is A Complete Hoax by PastorAIO: 7:27am On Apr 06, 2018 |
MuttleyLaff: Snotty has a dual meaning Yet what bearing does it have ...? |
Christianity Etc › Re: John 3 Vs 16 Says Bible Is A Complete Hoax by PastorAIO: 12:58am On Apr 06, 2018 |
MuttleyLaff: Bragger One word - snotty Two words - so conceited Snotty. Definately not. I blow my nose quite thoroughly. And a take plenty of Vitamin C and Zinc. Snooty. Perhaps. But everybody has their vibe and I will defend to the death my right to remain in my vibe/camp and not venture to issues that I have no interest in. Conceited. A Conceit is a fantasy. Yes, I do have an imagination. What's your problem with that? And what bearing does that have on any thing I've said? |
Christianity Etc › Re: John 3 Vs 16 Says Bible Is A Complete Hoax by PastorAIO: 5:33pm On Apr 05, 2018 |
MuttleyLaff: PastorAIO, its turn by turn, I read where you and Ubenedictus used emmany and mutty in codes to mention Emmanystone and I, and I laughed at how I got misconstrued but I will respond when you both, get to the front of the queue I've just been made aware of this post. I scrolled up and did not even see where I'd ever contributed to this thread talk less of quoting you, and even lesser or leaster of quoting you in code. This is not even the kind of thread that I would engage in. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Des Pensees by PastorAIO(op): 5:30pm On Apr 05, 2018 |
Ubenedictus: the special status is because it is inspired, God inspired ancient men to put down for us his love story...God's will to save humanity by giving us his son.
it is that belief that makes the Bible special, it is inspired to reveal God's saving plan and his redeeming love. Is it the only inspired thing in this whole world? That's my point. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 12:57pm On Apr 05, 2018 |
Emmanystone: If that is the case, it validates the claims that Ezra wrote it? You need to ask that question of the person who told you that Ezra wrote it. It is my take that Ezra finalized it in the form that we know today. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 12:56pm On Apr 05, 2018 |
Emmanystone: The bolded is where the issue lies. Your feelings. Our feelings ahould not count here. What does the records say? My feelings do count here. What you should ask is why I feel the way I feel? Thanks for asking what the records say. I'll take it from there. It is that the bible is full of contradictions and opposing viewpoints. For me, one of the most glaring internal contradictions in the bible is the attitude of the Hebrews to foreigners. On the one hand they embrace foreigners and extend hospitality to them and then shockingly every now and again you'll find a horrendously racist passage that does not tally with the open embrace of foreigners. Consider the following passages: Deut 24:19 When you are harvesting in your field and you overlook a sheaf, do not go back to get it. Leave it for the foreigner, the fatherless and the widow, so that the LORD your God may bless you in all the work of your hands. Leviticus 19:10 Do not go over your vineyard a second time or pick up the grapes that have fallen. Leave them for the poor and the foreigner. I am the LORD your God. Deut 26 : 12 (On tithing) When you have finished setting aside a tenth of all your produce in the third year, the year of the tithe, you shall give it to the Levite, the foreigner, the fatherless and the widow, so that they may eat in your towns and be satisfied. Exodus 12 37And the people of Israel journeyed from Rameses to Succoth, about six hundred thousand men on foot, besides women and children. 38 A mixed multitude also went up with them, and very much livestock, both flocks and herds. Exodus 12 48If a stranger shall sojourn with you and would keep the Passover to the Lord, let all his males be circumcised. Then he may come near and keep it; he shall be as a native of the land. But no uncircumcised person shall eat of it. 49 There shall be one law for the native and for the stranger who sojourns among you.”Compare this attitude to that of Ezra's. 1After these things had been done, the officials approached me and said, “The people of Israel and the priests and the Levites have not separated themselves from the peoples of the lands with their abominations, from the Canaanites, the Hittites, the Perizzites, the Jebusites, the Ammonites, the Moabites, the Egyptians, and the Amorites. 2For they have taken some of their daughters to be wives for themselves and for their sons, so that the holy race has mixed itself with the peoples of the lands. And in this faithlessness the hand of the officials and chief men has been foremost.” 3As soon as I heard this, I tore my garment and my cloak and pulled hair from my head and beard and sat appalled.
12Therefore do not give your daughters to their sons, neither take their daughters for your sons, and never seek their peace or prosperity, that you may be strong and eat the good of the land and leave it for an inheritance to your children forever.’ Ezra 9 10And Ezra the priest stood up and said to them, “You have broken faith and married foreign women, and so increased the guilt of Israel. 11Now then make confession to the Lord, the God of your fathers and do his will. Separate yourselves from the peoples of the land and from the foreign wives.” 12Then all the assembly answered with a loud voice, “It is so; we must do as you have said. 13But the people are many, and it is a time of heavy rain; we cannot stand in the open. Nor is this a task for one day or for two, for we have greatly transgressed in this matter.
18Now there were found some of the sons of the priests who had married foreign women: Maaseiah, Eliezer, Jarib, and Gedaliah, some of the sons of Jeshua the son of Jozadak and his brothers. 19They pledged themselves to put away their wives, and their guilt offering was a ram of the flock for their guilt
44All these had married foreign women, and some of the women had even borne children. -Ezra 10 Ezra was a virulent racist and those passages in the book of Ezra are some of the nastiest passages I've ever read in any religious text. This man broke up families on such a grand scale. And he made the jews swear to not give their neighbours any peace or prosperity. When you look back at the torah and you see contradictory verse where in one passage the jews are open to foreigners yet in another passage they are quite racist I am inclined to accept that Ezra injected the racist passages to further his agenda. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 11:56am On Apr 05, 2018 |
Emmanystone: Can a man [Ezra] who had died before the last book of the Old Testament (Malachi)was written said to havs been the one who wrote it?
This is really not sensible if you ask me. The Bible (Torah) is a collection of books (Prophesies mostly) written by different prophets, accounts of the Kings, Shepherds, and laymen. All these men lived in different times. If you insist because Ezra is a 'Who' hence; qualifies as the writer of the Old Testament, then Ezra must be immortal. That will also mean, all the prophets never lived or lived only in Ezra's mind. I think that you have the Torah confused with the Tanakh. Please google them quick quick and come back so that we can continue the conversation. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 11:41am On Apr 05, 2018 |
Emmanystone: First seta of questions i have been trying to put forward are; Who was Ezra? When did he live? What do you mean he wrote the Torah? Is it the same with the case of Catholicism putting together the Bible books and claiming they wrote it? Ezra, Hebrew ʿezraʾ, (flourished 4th century bc, Babylon and Jerusalem), religious leader of the Jews who returned from exile in Babylon, reformer who reconstituted the Jewish community on the basis of the Torah (Law, or the regulations of the first five books of the Old Testament). His work helped make Judaism a religion in which law was central, enabling the Jews to survive as a community when they were dispersed all over the world. Since his efforts did much to give Jewish religion the form that was to characterize it for centuries after, Ezra has with some justice been called the father of Judaism; i.e., the specific form the Jewish religion took after the Babylonian Exile. So important was he in the eyes of his people that later tradition regarded him as no less than a second Moses.
Knowledge of Ezra is derived from the biblica --- https://www.britannica.com/biography/Ezra-Hebrew-religious-leaderI didn't say that he wrote the Torah, the most I've said is that he redacted the final version of the Torah that we have today. The Catholic church did not claim to write the entire bible. O ma se o! So soon after asking for objectivity saying you don't want to win the argument and in the very next line you write total falsehoods that no one said. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 11:39am On Apr 05, 2018 |
Emmanystone: [quote author=Emmanystone post=66450406]A discussion in my opinion should be to learn not to win or be the one to have the last word. That said, pls can we try be objective in our thoughts here? Lol!! I'm not even gonna bother to hold you to that. I'm not in the mood for disappointments. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 11:39am On Apr 05, 2018 |
Emmanystone: A discussion in my opinion should be to learn not to win or be the one to have the last word. That said, pls can we try be objective in our thoughts here? Lol!! I'm not even gonna bother to hold you to that. I'm not in the mood for disappointments. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 11:36am On Apr 05, 2018 |
Emmanystone: Wikipedia and others sources says the Book of Wars was a record of the wars fought by the Jews in Canaan, just as i said. What does these tell us? The man who wrote the First Five books also wrote that book.
Moses wrote those books if he didn't you won't be the one to say otherwise, the Jews will be. I think the main point where you do not get what I am saying and subsequently everything goes over your head is around this issue of a singular author of the Torah. I will repeat my point very slowly: The Torah came to it's present form over centuries of redaction and additions. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 11:25am On Apr 05, 2018 |
It is not only obvious that the Torah is drawn from previous traditions and lore of the middle east but that it is even incomplete in doing so. For example. The Creation saga in Genesis 1. There is no mention of the nitty gritty of what actually happened. Just a cursory mention like 'Elohim separated the water from the land' etc. Yet the creation story was drawn from a much richer source and to get an inkling of that source you have to go out of the Torah. Okay let's not go too far out first. Let's stay within the bible and go to the Book of Job. There we will see that the act of creation actually involve an epic battle with a sea monster called Leviathan. In Job 41 God boasts about how he defeated Leviathan in the act of creation: 1a “Can you draw out Leviathanb with a fishhook or press down his tongue with a cord? 2Can you put a rope in his nose or pierce his jaw with a hook? 3Will he make many pleas to you? Will he speak to you soft words? 4Will he make a covenant with you to take him for your servant forever? 5Will you play with him as with a bird, or will you put him on a leash for your girls? 6Will traders bargain over him? Will they divide him up among the merchants? 7Can you fill his skin with harpoons or his head with fishing spears? 8Lay your hands on him; remember the battle—you will not do it again! 9c Behold, the hope of a man is false; he is laid low even at the sight of him. 10No one is so fierce that he dares to stir him up. Who then is he who can stand before me? 11Who has first given to me, that I should repay him? Whatever is under the whole heaven is mine.
12“I will not keep silence concerning his limbs, or his mighty strength, or his goodly frame. 13Who can strip off his outer garment? Who would come near him with a bridle? Psalms 74 also talks about the same event: 12Yet God my King is from of old, working salvation in the midst of the earth. 13You divided the sea by your might; you broke the heads of the sea monstersd on the waters. 14You crushed the heads of Leviathan; you gave him as food for the creatures of the wilderness. 15You split open springs and brooks; you dried up ever-flowing streams. 16Yours is the day, yours also the night; you have established the heavenly lights and the sun. 17You have fixed all the boundaries of the earth; you have made summer and winter. This tradition of creation by defeating a sea serpent is found all through out the middle east. I wouldn't say that they got it from babylon but rather that it is part of the same traditions with not only babylon but Canaan too, and Egypt and even Greece not to mention Scandinavia or Yorubaland. But that is taking you too far out. Let us stay within the bible for now. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism And Morality; Do Atheists Have A Foundation For Morality by PastorAIO: 11:46pm On Apr 04, 2018 |
thehomer: As long as you think your God is good, it would indicate that you don't just lack a moral compass, but your compass confuses evil for good. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism And Morality; Do Atheists Have A Foundation For Morality by PastorAIO: 11:36pm On Apr 04, 2018 |
dalaman: Talk is cheap. If I slap you, you will not turn the other cheek, if I come and take your shirt you will not give me your coat. You do not love your enemies instead I believe you pray for God to help you defeat them or.protect you from them and their plans against you. You lie, you cheat, you get angry, feel envy and jealous of others on varying degrees, you do not love your neighbor as you love yourself. You can try to do these things but you can not achieve them 100% no human can. Anybody that says he can is lying that is why Christains have never been able to distinguish themselves from nonchristians throughout history despite their endless claims. So your point is that christianity is a useless religion since it cannot deliver on any of it's promises. It's adherents are the most abhorrent people. What good has it done? |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 10:10pm On Apr 04, 2018 |
Emmanystone: You said Moses couldn't have written the Torah because he was dead, i then asked who referenced the Book of the Wars of the Lord which you brought up. Which book of the Bible mentioned the Book of Wars? I don't personally know who wrote about the Book of Wars in the Torah, but I do know that it is in the Torah and I also know that Moses couldn't have written the Torah because the Torah tells us about Moses' death. You'll find mention of the Book of Wars in Numbers.
aka Bamidbar And, i asked you before why you are shifting grounds?
So now it's no longer Ezra who wrote the Torah, but 'Whoever?'. Since ezra qualifies as a 'who' then Whoever includes him too so no need to poo in your pants. Nobody is shifting any grounds. I repeat, I believe that the Torah was redacted numerous times. I also feel that Josiah's 'discovery' contributed to the Torah and it may well be Ezra who finalized the version we have today. Am not about the book of the wars which you are trying to make this about, i want to know how Ezra could have written the Torah. Pls let's dwell on this. Ezra could have had a hand in the Torah as it has come down to us because he was a very prominent figure in Jewish religion. It is believed by Jews that Ezra was second to no one except Moses amongst the prophets. He is more respected than Elijah Isaiah etc etc etc.. Ezra made many amendments to the Jewish religion and those amendments and redactions can be seen clearly where there seem to be contradictions in the letter and the spirit of the Torah. Ezra had a very racist streak and I feel that he injected that into the Torah. The reason that I brought up the Book of Wars is to show you that the Torah had other books it was sourced from and made reference to. Also folk songs and general Hebrew Lore was source material for the torah. Furthermore the reference to the Book of Wars indicates that Moses could not have written the Torah since as you say it was about the wars of canaanite conquest and those wars continued after Moses died. |
Christianity Etc › Re: DISCUSSION: YHWH (jewish) And Enki (epic Of Gilgamesh) Who Is Older? by PastorAIO: 3:37pm On Apr 04, 2018 |
Emmanystone: And the Book of Wars was referenced by Moses or Joshua who took over from Moses? The Book of Wars was referenced by the writer of the Torah whoever that may be. Quite unlikely it was Moses as I pointed out earlier. |