Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,151,152 members, 7,811,297 topics. Date: Sunday, 28 April 2024 at 08:37 AM

Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? - Car Talk (6) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Car Talk / Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? (36000 Views)

Does Catalytic Converter Truly Reduces Fuel Consumption? Let's Discuss . . / Car Guzzling Fuel? You Might Need Replacing Your Car Catalytic Converter / Signs Of A Bad Catalytic Converter (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by Whois(m): 10:18am On May 28, 2022
Thanks for the videos. I'm keeping the links for future purpose
Jakumo:
Catalytic converter theft has reached EPIDEMIC proportions in the USA right now. Gangs drive through neighborhoods carrying jacks and power tools, and they are capable of surgically removing the "cats" from any car in less than 15 seconds. Here is a video of a gang removing the cats from a police officer's car in California. The precious metals platinum and palladium are removed and purified for sale due to their extreme rarity and high price as raw materials in the car manufacturing industry.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tlODV1eJljM

Sometimes the raised car falls on the thief and squashes them like a rat in a trap, resulting in death or severe injury, meaning that Ogun, the God of Iron is also at work in the USA.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uC89-OzCdJs

Americans never fail to spot a business opportunity, so a new industry has been created marketing metal plates that bolt underneath cars to protect the cats from being stolen when the vehicles are parked anywhere.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nnrtLuzAg8o
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by sketcherJ(m): 10:28am On May 28, 2022
kamez:
14yrs of driving, currently own 3 cars, and somehow I am just coming across the word catalytic converter!!!

So I thought to myself, How is this even possible.......I had to run to Google..

And realized that it's because I have never had issues with my exhaust in any of my cars..
is Lexus a good brand sir? Or
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by treatise: 10:40am On May 28, 2022
Nonexisting:
So what if the windows are up on top speed but the AC is not on, like during cold weather, will it take more fuel than when AC is on?
Not at all. Wound up windows compensate for the fuel you'd have spent when the windows are down because of the drag (principles of aerodynamics)
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by EngRichie: 10:41am On May 28, 2022
Catalytic converter is not a fuel saving device but depending on engine and exhaust design, removal or restriction can increase fuel consumption.
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by Nonexisting: 10:45am On May 28, 2022
treatise:

Not at all. Wound up windows compensate for the fuel you'd have spent when the windows are down because of the drag (principles of aerodynamics)
So in essence, driving with AC on takes more fuel that when AC is not on no matter the circumstances only that windows down on top speed drags the car backwards making acceleration harder. So instead of leaving windows down on top speed, it's better to have AC on so one doesn't suffocate right?
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by treatise: 11:07am On May 28, 2022
Nonexisting:
So in essence, driving with AC on takes more fuel that when AC is not on no matter the circumstances only that windows down on top speed drags the car backwards making acceleration harder. So instead of leaving windows down on top speed, it's better to have AC on so one doesn't suffocate right?
Gbam
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by rukyboy(m): 11:30am On May 28, 2022
adanny01:


There are 2 cases with a bad oxygen sensor.

With a failed O2 sensor , the ECU goes to open loop and an error code is set which will bring on the check engine light. This is easy to diagnose.

A slow response O2 sensor is more difficult to know because it may not set an error code or check engine light and the ECU can remain on closed loop but the sensor is aged and not making fuel trim adjustment as required. It could lead to fuel consumption. Only a live scan and experience will be able to diagnose this.

I currently experience very high fuel consumption in my car. Would you avice I change only the first oxygen sensor?

My car doesn't have a CAT
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by rukyboy(m): 11:35am On May 28, 2022
treatise:


This submission isn't true. Before my catalytic converter was stolen I was able to cover 479 kilometers with 50 litres of PMS but since the theft, that same quantity of fuel can't cover 192 kilometers.

What kind of car do you use
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by treatise: 11:38am On May 28, 2022
rukyboy:


What kind of car do you use
The car that uses pms and had a catalytic converter
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by EgunMogaji2: 11:45am On May 28, 2022
When you remove your catalytic converter the following will happen:

1) Your engine will loose some back pressure, this will shift your torque curve upward. So you'll need to reach higher rpm to get the power you were getting before. You may get additional horsepower if everything is done right. Freeflowing air intake and ECU reprogram.

2) Your engine sound will change. This will ginger you into racing the engine more, mostly unnecessarily.

Both of these will lead to lower MPG.

5 Likes 1 Share

Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by mu2sa2: 11:56am On May 28, 2022
drlateef:




Yes indeed. You consume more fuel in urban built up areas like intra-city driving. The amount of fuel you consume is about twice the amount for the same distance on the highway travelling at high speed. For example, if consume 10 litres to cover 20 kilometres intra city, you will spend about 6 litres to cover same distance of 20 kilometres on highway travelling at higher speed.
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by mu2sa2: 11:59am On May 28, 2022
drlateef:




Yes indeed. You consume more fuel in urban built up areas like intra-city driving. The amount of fuel you consume is about twice the amount for the same distance on the highway travelling at high speed. For example, if consume 10 litres to cover 20 kilometres intra city, you will spend about 6 litres to cover same distance of 20 kilometres on highway travelling at higher speed.
You're talking about stop-go-stop city driving. I had in mind driving at a steady high speed like 100 km/hr and moderate speed like 60 km/hrs - certainly fuel consumption will be less at the lower speed on a highway.

1 Like

Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by Unrated900(m): 12:37pm On May 28, 2022
[quote author=Buje1987 post=113244567][/quote]
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by drlateef: 1:06pm On May 28, 2022
mu2sa2:
You're talking about stop-go-stop city driving. I had in mind driving at a steady high speed like 100 km/hr and moderate speed like 60 km/hrs - certainly fuel consumption will be less at the lower speed on a highway.


There’s a top speed at which fuel consumption is optimum even on highway. It’s around 70-80miles/hour. Below that it’s high and above that it’s higher consumption. A combination of factors are responsible for that. At lower speed, I have forgotten that phenomenon in Physics which makes the speed of movement of tyres to give a negative feedback for less consumption and maintaining the speed. But this happens at optimum speed I mentioned. At higher speed above 80miles, the effect of wind comes in to increase the consumption. Wind effect is less at that optimum speed. Other factors are engine size, the body size, shape, fuel efficiency of the car, and weight of the car, a full petrol tank contributes to the weight and causes a drag thereby causing more fuel consumption.

1 Like

Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by Reference(m): 1:22pm On May 28, 2022
GAZZUZZ:
In most modern vehicles, when there is an engine or transmission malfunction , it displays the check engine light, this switches the vehicle from standard operating design, to one that limits power output and protects the engine or transmission from further damage that could result in continued use in that state.

You would notice things like

check 4WD

Traction off

VSC OFF

And so on.

In certain circumstances the engine would be limited to revs below 3000 rotations per sec.

Irrespective of the presence or absence of a catalyst, an engine or transmission code will cause a vehicle to run less optimally which in turn would mean the vehicle consume more than it should.

Avoid errors on your vehicle at all costs.


You can also check this thread to acquire more knowledge about devices that help detect errors.

https://www.nairaland.com/6885954/xtool-advance-ad10-auto-car

You can also check this link if your car does not have a catalyst.

https://www.nairaland.com/6280487/catalytic-converter-problems-cheap-solution#96462231

Finally you can follow this link for smart devices .

https://www.nairaland.com/7147283/smart-devices-hottiecoach


Spot on.

1 Like

Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by LucemFerre: 1:34pm On May 28, 2022
On the contrary, you might get better mileage without it
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by Alusiizizi(m): 1:57pm On May 28, 2022
Buharifan:
Car experts,

Please how true is this assertion?


No it doesn't. All it does is to remove most of the toxic components in the exhaust.
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by Nobody: 3:26pm On May 28, 2022
osazsky:
u have been scamed.ur exhust get small leakage.3k for solve the issue.i dont have catalyst and my fuel consumption is ok...
depends on the car….I am not new with cars…go and ask an old mech
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by Nobody: 3:27pm On May 28, 2022
Innobee99:
Indomie is the common street name not Akara
it’s called akara around me and not indomie
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by Wwwq: 5:01pm On May 28, 2022
No
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by HazzanTazzan(m): 5:14pm On May 28, 2022
clinician2x:


Then it is a shame. You paid all that money and spent all that years for nothing. Basic comprehension skills u did not achieve. Just the basic.

I’m not surprised ... going by your track record on here, ure just loud mouthed and insult your generation at the slightest chance ... the internet is really a great tool for kids like you to display their lack of home training
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by Jakumo(m): 6:23pm On May 28, 2022
Having the catalytic converter stolen from one's car in the USA or any other nation with vehicle emissions laws is a big, big, big deal because, without the cats, the engine will NOT pass emissions tests that are a prerequisite for vehicle registration.

In short, any motorist who cannot afford the few hundred dollars needed to replace stolen catalytic converters in the USA will not be allowed to register their car to drive it legally on any street or highway. Driving an unregistered car is a good way to become a guest of the prison service therefore anyone intending to use a vehicle in the USA or EU must have those cats in place.

In Nigeria where there are NO vehicle emissions tests or requirements, losing the cats in one's car is no biggie, since that vehicle can still be driven and registered.

1 Like

Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by clinician2x: 6:24pm On May 28, 2022
HazzanTazzan:


I’m not surprised ... going by your track record on here, ure just loud mouthed and insult your generation at the slightest chance ... the internet is really a great tool for kids like you to display their lack of home training

Go over to my initial comment, write it down if you can and show someone to explain to you so you don't make the same mistake twice. At least justify your convocation for once
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by nuelleoz(m): 7:06pm On May 28, 2022
Clonelord:
You need to find the street name of that catalytic converter else men no go know wetin you dey talk About.



Street name is indomie.
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by adanny01(m): 9:58pm On May 28, 2022
rukyboy:


I currently experience very high fuel consumption in my car. Would you avice I change only the first oxygen sensor?

My car doesn't have a CAT

What type of car and year?
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by rukyboy(m): 10:54pm On May 28, 2022
adanny01:


What type of car and year?

Honda Accord DC. 2007
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by neutralmind: 11:30am On May 29, 2022
Learning...
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by adanny01(m): 4:58pm On May 29, 2022
rukyboy:


Honda Accord DC. 2007

Scan the car first and get all error codes. P0131-5 are the related error codes for AF sensor.

Note that other things can cause these codes, leaking injectors, exhaust leak, vacuum leak etc
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by emerich(m): 5:29pm On May 29, 2022
rukyboy:


Honda Accord DC. 2007
You need to get your exhaust system checked, I once accompanied a guy in his Honda Accord DC 2006 model from Zuba to Sokoto, a journey of about 9 hrs, 672 km with just 49 litres, about #8,000 fuel, a very old car for that matter at full speed and A/C at intervals, I guess the exhaust system of the car wasn't tampered with, it made me fall in love with the car even more, it's the most driven car here in Kano...
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by vihflex: 6:29am On May 30, 2022
Advanced concrete pumping machine is affordable and effective, which makes them popular. It is used to easily transfer liquid mixed material from the container to anywhere around the building. The concrete pump hose helps you join the pump to the instrument outlet and convey materials easily.
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by 9icetoo(m): 9:47am On May 30, 2022
drlateef:



There’s a top speed at which fuel consumption is optimum even on highway. It’s around 70-80miles/hour. Below that it’s high and above that it’s higher consumption. A combination of factors are responsible for that. At lower speed, I have forgotten that phenomenon in Physics which makes the speed of movement of tyres to give a negative feedback for less consumption and maintaining the speed. But this happens at optimum speed I mentioned. At higher speed above 80miles, the effect of wind comes in to increase the consumption. Wind effect is less at that optimum speed. Other factors are engine size, the body size, shape, fuel efficiency of the car, and weight of the car, a full petrol tank contributes to the weight and causes a drag thereby causing more fuel consumption.
It's actually 80km/hr or 50 miles per hour.

At 80mph, your mpg is taking a serious hit.
Re: Does Catalytic Converter Actually Reduces Fuel Consumption? by drlateef: 10:19am On May 30, 2022
9icetoo:

It's actually 80km/hr or 50 miles per hour.

At 80mph, your mpg is taking a serious hit.



As an experienced driver of many years I know that fuel efficiency is best at 70-80mph. All other factors being considered for efficiency taken control of.

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (Reply)

12 Steps To Clear A Car Through Nigeria Customs / Man Shocked As Driver Refuels Rolls-Royce From Keg (Video) / Banker Crushed To Death By BRT Bus

Viewing this topic: 1 guest(s)

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 45
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.