Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,162,158 members, 7,849,589 topics. Date: Tuesday, 04 June 2024 at 04:26 AM

When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? - Religion (8) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Religion / When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? (25582 Views)

Can A Christian Be Truly POSSESSED By An Evil Spirit? What The Bible Truly Says / Should A Man Who Is A Born-Again Christian Be A Gynaecologist? / Why Are Christians Such Liars? (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) ... (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by Nobody: 2:36pm On Feb 05, 2017
HardMirror:

I don't see you quoting any scriptures yet. I only see you glorying in murders which your God wld judge with hell fire. When last have you won a soul to christ? Have you taken time to win muslims to Jesus? How many converts do you have? God would not reward you for lives you killed, he would reward you for lives you saved. I guess you don't read your bible.


Bible orders to kill as quoted below:

Numbers 31:16-18


Deuteronomy 17:3-5


Deuteronomy 13:6-16



Mathew 10:34


To mention but a few.

1 Like

Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by ThinkSmarter: 2:41pm On Feb 05, 2017
HardMirror:

Scriptures?
Cos I don't think so. Every murderer will go to hell. Whose orders should a christian follow? God or man? Jesus would NEVER permit a man to kill another man.

Why I love Jehovah witnesses. They don't have any business with politics or military.
I don't think fighting a noble cause like military /paramilitary as far as u exhibit professionalism in the course of discharging ur duties will take u to hell.
For example, in the Bible[Old Testament ] ,God advised the Isrealites to pick the best of their able men from every tribe to make the Isreal Army.
And God hv supported them to go to war in many occasions.
I understand the angle u re viewing it, but if there is nothing like the law enforcement agencies, lawlessness would have been the other of the day, and crime would be committed with impunity.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by Sman37(m): 2:47pm On Feb 05, 2017
dallyemmy:
Luke 3:14

And the soldiers likewise demanded of him, saying, And what shall we do? And he said unto them, Do violence to no man, neither accuse any falsely; and be content with your wages.


◄ Exodus 22:20

Verse (Click for Chapter)
New International Version
"Whoever sacrifices to any god other
than the LORD must be destroyed.
New Living Translation
"Anyone who sacrifices to any god
other than the LORD must be
destroyed.
English Standard Version
“Whoever sacrifices to any god, other
than the LORD alone, shall be devoted
to destruction.
New American Standard Bible
"He who sacrifices to any god, other
than to the LORD alone, shall be utterly
destroyed.
King James Bible
He that sacrificeth unto any god, save
unto the LORD only, he shall be utterly
destroyed.
Holman Christian Standard Bible
Whoever sacrifices to any gods, except
the LORD alone, is to be set apart for
destruction."
International Standard Version
"Anyone who sacrifices to a god,
except the LORD alone, is to be utterly
destroyed.
NET Bible
"Whoever sacrifices to a god other than
the LORD alone must be utterly
destroyed.
New Heart English Bible
"He who sacrifices to another god,
except to the LORD only, shall be
utterly destroyed.
GOD'S WORD® Translation
"Whoever sacrifices to any god except
the LORD must be condemned and
destroyed.
JPS Tanakh 1917
He that sacrificeth unto the gods, save
unto the LORD only, shall be utterly
destroyed.
New American Standard 1977
“He who sacrifices to any god, other
than to the LORD alone, shall be utterly
destroyed.
Jubilee Bible 2000
He that sacrifices unto any god, except
unto the LORD only, he shall be utterly
destroyed.
King James 2000 Bible
He that sacrifices unto any god, except
unto the LORD only, he shall be utterly
destroyed.
American King James Version
He that sacrifices to any god, save to
the LORD only, he shall be utterly
destroyed.
American Standard Version
He that sacrificeth unto any god, save
unto Jehovah only, shall be utterly
destroyed.
Douay-Rheims Bible
He that sacrificeth to gods, shall be put
to death, save only to the Lord.
Darby Bible Translation
-- He that sacrificeth to [any] god, save
to Jehovah only, shall be devoted to
destruction.
English Revised Version
He that sacrificeth unto any god, save
unto the LORD only, shall be utterly
destroye.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by HardMirror(m): 3:01pm On Feb 05, 2017
africansunite:


Bible orders to kill as quoted below:
Numbers 31:16-18

Deuteronomy 17:3-5

Deuteronomy 13:6-16


Mathew 10:34

To mention but a few.
So christianity and islam are same. Good.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by HardMirror(m): 3:03pm On Feb 05, 2017
solaere:
Mr op
1st of all considering boko haram case with soldiers will u say they've sinned.?know fully well dat dis God forbidden pple are after majorly d xtain body..
2. Xtain can kill every single minute on d ground of slf defence cuz both in the old nd new testament it was recorded. if u are a blood sucking demon try me i'll defend my slf until u're dead nd while u 're in hell i shall wave u from heaven....
Why can't God fight your battles?

1 Like

Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by HardMirror(m): 3:04pm On Feb 05, 2017
mack111:
God did not sought the help of man in creating the world. Why the hell does he bother us in carrying out the duties of his project. Is he/she too lazy to do it without disturbing humans.
Abeg, help me ask o
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by Nobody: 3:22pm On Feb 05, 2017
HardMirror:
The days of fighting physical battles is over, in fact if the bible is to be followed, it is even a sin to take vengeance in any form. The New testament makes it clear that gone are the days of an eye for an eye. It is the age of turning the left cheek when the right cheek is slapped. It is an age of fighting with spiritual weapons. It is an age of evangelism and not warfare.

There seems to be Absolutely NO REASON why a christian should be a soldier. Jesus would certainly from at any of his sheep throwing bombs at souls he created.

What are your thoughts on this?

Can a soldier indeed go to heaven if killed in warfare? Can a christian be a soldier?





IS THERE ANY TIME A CHRISTIAN IS PERMITTED TO KILL? CAN A CHRISTIAN KILL IN SELF DEFENSE?


May you never be in a kill or die situation. It's easier to just open mouth and talk, relocate to southern kaduna and tell scriptures to the marauders.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by HardMirror(m): 3:26pm On Feb 05, 2017
Stupedinluv:


I don't know about some of you. But with my experience Christianity comes with a lot of mind/spirit convictions one of Which is to not carry arms against your enemies.

Anybody can be anything but at the end, it is their adherence to principles or not that proves where they really belong.

True, a nation must have armies, but trust me no child of God will be part of it for reasons well known

Soldiers serve a good purpose. They fight for the nation and secure territories. And do they deserve prayers? yes because they are instruments of God too.

When they are hit, they show no mercy but fight back. A Christian who has the conviction of God will not have the heart to do same. Like Christ he is full of mercy and leaves vengeance for God.

The real question you should be asking is: Do I trust God or my sword






You are the only christian making sense here. It's a shame many profess to be christians but are worse than infidels.
I am not a christian anymore because of issues like this. There is simply no sincerity in the church. The bible is just a book of contradictions. When I was a christian, I knew Jesus could not be pleased with soldiers who kill. It does not just add up. See christians here defending killings, they do so out of their selfish nature. They profess God but don't trust him to protect them.

1 Like

Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by Tolupage(m): 3:32pm On Feb 05, 2017
dallyemmy:
Luke 3:14

And the soldiers likewise demanded of him, saying, And what shall we do? And he said unto them, Do violence to no man, neither accuse any falsely; and be content with your wages.

I see no further basis for this argument. if Jesus did not tell the soldiers to resign seeing it was a profession that involves killing (on the right side) then a soldier is entitled to fully carry out his occupational duty.

Do violence to no man: avoid oppression and extra judicial activities.

Neither accuse any man: Do not use ur position to pervert or oppress others..

be content with your wages: continue in the work as a soldier, and make a living of it without being corrupt.

Being a soldier and killing in the line of duty ain't a sin
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by robbinn(m): 3:41pm On Feb 05, 2017
zionmade:


Who Do u think u wud have been alive to type dis shit if there were no slodiers or who do u want to protect u. Or wen God promised u protection he meant he will come himself to fight arm robbers or assasins. Now read my former post and go to ur bible and answer dis question
Why did Jesus heal the centurions servant and even said dat he had not seen such a faith in israel?
Why did d Holyspirit come upon the centurion, who are u to tell God whom he should reside in or not?
If u dnt know who a centurion is pls dnt bother answering my question
uhhhmm.. I understand wat yhu re saying nd I vry much lyk dat... cus iz evrydy we learn.. bt I aint fightin wif any 1 dat wat I understood.... tanks fr shedin more lite fr mhe on diz topic....... nw to ur question. a centurion is a person highly respected and honoured by others... in m own knowledge.... nw ansa m question who iz d owner of ur lyf God or a. military man?who Ave been keeping u alive God or a military man?plz if u can't ansa it don't borda answering.... tanks
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by Nobody: 3:45pm On Feb 05, 2017
joyeSeraph:
Just two questions, bruh......

★Do you endorse the Mosaic Laws, and all blaspheming laws in the Old Testament, as well as the punishments that come with violating them?★

✿ฺωhat-and-ωhat differentiate Christianity from Judaism?✿ฺ



You notice I used the term "unfolding" if you were to write the story of your life you might find that there are things that happened in your childhood that do not happen now BUT that does not invalidate your childhood or those experiences. People come to the Bible with the wrong approach. Sometimes this is out of intent ; to pick holes in it and sometimes it is out of ignorance. The Bible is story; historical, symbolic- prose and poetry. Like any story it is ascending. It is not a code or a manual with clauses. You should not start in the middle or at the end. Or start at the beginning and finish in the middle. It should be read through from beginning to end.

This is a book that was written over a period of 1500 year by 40 writers many who never met each other and who lived hundred of years apart.

Having laid that foundation; the blasphemy law in the Torah prescribes physical death when God was blasphemed, while in the writings of the disciples it led to spiritual death.

“Every sin and blasphemy shall be forgiven unto men; but the blasphemy against the Spirit shall not be forgiven” (Mt. 12:31)

Both involved death. One physical, one spiritual. Which one is more severe? I would imagine the latter. Remember again the "progressive and unfolding but valid" theme I began this with. Death was valid then and death is valid now.

The difference between Judaism and Christianity lies again in how they treat Jesus Christ and his death and resurrection. Judaism denies it. Christianity believes it. Again it is easy to see how this happened; once you codify the Torah it cannot unfold and if it does not unfold there can be no Jesus. Apart from this both faiths have a lot in common. But this difference is a major point of division.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by robbinn(m): 4:06pm On Feb 05, 2017
Cusdamato:
so he is now a muslim or an idol worshipper abii?? weeeelllllldoooonneeee
★u miss undastood wat i met. I didn't mean wrong in d sense of wrong.. I meant a military man nd also a Christian shuld flw d Scripture.. lyk in d Bible it said **do nt shed one anoda blood *** lyk som soldiers re heartless dey dont show mercy.. all dey want iz 2 be praised **dats wat I meant abt christain soldier nt indulging in tins lyk dat **wrong**hope u undastand nw??
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by Dareomo(m): 4:16pm On Feb 05, 2017
A Christian can be a soldier, since it was never counted sin for David when he killed Goliath and during his war front, thereby a christian soldier who kills in the war front following the rules of engagement will still make heaven.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by oglalasioux(m): 4:34pm On Feb 05, 2017
NevetsIbot:
very wrong. There's no where in d bible where it is written to kill those who don't share the same opinion with us.. No where... Blasphemy everywhere


Everyone who would not seek the Lord, the God of Israel, was to be put to death, whether small or great, whether man or woman. (2 Chronicles 15:13).

If you need more let me know.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by onos217(m): 4:36pm On Feb 05, 2017
OOOS:

I totally agree with you that christians shouldn't kill, but there are exceptions, when defending yourself, that could be unavoidable. Can Christians join the army? Deuteronomy 20: 1-4. I don't see anything wrong in it. If everyone claims their religion doesn't support them so they can't join, pls who will? Who will defend their territory from opperesors and aggressors? I bet you and I won't live to practice that religion.
You asked who will defend their territory from oppressors and aggressors .I tell you God will defend them. His promises are there if you read his word. And his promises never fail.He is defender to the defenceless.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by NevetsIbot(m): 4:42pm On Feb 05, 2017
oglalasioux:



Everyone who would not seek the Lord, the God of Israel, was to be put to death, whether small or great, whether man or woman. (2 Chronicles 15:13).

If you need more let me know.
and did you read the whole story?, dyu know under what canopy jesus puts us under now?....... Its funny to see you referring to the old testament.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by SmartyPants(m): 4:43pm On Feb 05, 2017
HardMirror:

Scriptures?
Cos I don't think so. Every murderer will go to hell. Whose orders should a christian follow? God or man? Jesus would NEVER permit a man to kill another man.

Why I love Jehovah witnesses. They don't have any business with politics or military.

Read your bible more.

Romans 13:4

4For he is God’s servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not carry the sword in vain. He is God’s servant, an agent of retribution to the wrongdoer.

You see, God hates wrongdoing so much that hell is not the only consequence of wrongdoing, and in fact, He has given us ministers to execute retribution. Of course you know very well that a sword is not used for flogging but for slicing through disobedient flesh.

Jesus himself flogged certain disobedient people.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by oglalasioux(m): 4:47pm On Feb 05, 2017
NevetsIbot:
and did you read the whole story?, dyu know under what canopy jesus puts us under now?....... Its funny to see you referring to the old testament.

You are now rejecting the old testament but your pastor uses verses from the same testament to extort money from you every month. Christians and doublespeak are (please who has that Zuma picture).
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by zionmade(m): 4:54pm On Feb 05, 2017
robbinn:
uhhhmm.. I understand wat yhu re saying nd I vry much lyk dat... cus iz evrydy we learn.. bt I aint fightin wif any 1 dat wat I understood.... tanks fr shedin more lite fr mhe on diz topic....... nw to ur question. a centurion is a person highly respected and honoured by others... in m own knowledge.... nw ansa m question who iz d owner of ur lyf God or a. military man?who Ave been keeping u alive God or a military man?plz if u can't ansa it don't borda answering.... tanks


Point of correction a centurion is a soldier who has hundred soldiers under him.
God owns my life
God protects me
God feeds me
God teaches me everything i know
God takes care of my health
But how will God do dat if there are no soldiers, if there are no farmers and parents, if there are no doctors
Everything God does for me he does through other persons
He is d creator of medical substances and he gave man d knowledge to apply it
He is d one who gave man d idea to create weapons for their defense (note D fact dat sex has caused a lot of havoc doesnt mean God didnt create sex)

1 Like

Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by NevetsIbot(m): 4:56pm On Feb 05, 2017
oglalasioux:


You are now rejecting the old testament but your pastor uses verses from the same testament to extort money from you every month. Christians and doublespeak are (please who has that Zuma picture).
if you were not so ignorant, you'd understand me...... The old testament is 'Jesus concealed'... New testament is 'Jesus revealed'..... The laws ofthe old testament were nullified by jesus in d new testament, thus, the new testament it was xtians should use as a watchword. However, some principles in the old testament still works... Tithing, nd giving for example.

By the way. Good bye
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by NevetsIbot(m): 4:58pm On Feb 05, 2017
zionmade:


Point of correction a centurion is a soldier who has hundred soldiers under him.
God owns my life
God protects me
God feeds me
God teaches me everything i know
God takes care of my health
But how will God do dat if there are no soldiers, if there are no farmers and parents, if there are no doctors
Everything God does for me he does through other persons
He is d creator of medical substances and he gave man d knowledge to apply it
He is d one who gave man d idea to create weapons for their defense (note D fact dat sex has caused a lot of havoc doesnt mean God didnt create sex)
Smart. But they'll still remain unmoved
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by oglalasioux(m): 5:00pm On Feb 05, 2017
NevetsIbot:
if you were not so ignorant, you'd understand me...... The old testament is 'Jesus concealed'... New testament is 'Jesus revealed'..... The laws ofthe old testament were nullified by jesus in d new testament, thus, the new testament it was xtians should use as a watchword. However, some principles in the old testament still works... Tithing, nd giving for example.

By the way. Good bye

Lol.

Jesus nullified all laws in the old testament but left out tithing.

Pastor spotted.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by NevetsIbot(m): 5:04pm On Feb 05, 2017
oglalasioux:


Lol.

Jesus nullified all laws in the old testament but left out tithing.

Pastor spotted.
correction.... And Giving........ I'm no pastor. Neither am i a staunch christian brother but the 'tithing,giving,mantle,annointing,blood sprinkling,feet washing' are all mysteries that work. Tithing nd giving is a universal thing. -..... Like you're saying thank you.......
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by Nobody: 5:04pm On Feb 05, 2017
HardMirror:

You are the only christian making sense here. It's a shame many profess to be christians but are worse than infidels.
I am not a christian anymore because of issues like this. There is simply no sincerity in the church. The bible is just a book of contradictions. When I was a christian, I knew Jesus could not be pleased with soldiers who kill. It does not just add up. See christians here defending killings, they do so out of their selfish nature. They profess God but don't trust him to protect them.
You are not more disappointed than myself. I am really but far from surprised.

Still a Christian but I have quietly excluded myself from church activities and resolved to study the Bible myself in my own space until I am mature enough to withstand the modern church.

I have a strong conviction that Christianity is true but I understand when people are in doubt. Doubt happens when we read the Bible or try to understand God through people...gullible, selfish people (including us)
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by Cusdamato(m): 5:07pm On Feb 05, 2017
robbinn:
★u miss undastood wat i met. I didn't mean wrong in d sense of wrong.. I meant a military man nd also a Christian shuld flw d Scripture.. lyk in d Bible it said **do nt shed one anoda blood *** lyk som soldiers re heartless dey dont show mercy.. all dey want iz 2 be praised **dats wat I meant abt christain soldier nt indulging in tins lyk dat **wrong**hope u undastand nw??
ok thanks 4 explaining now my head is back to default settings
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by AngelsAndStars(m): 5:16pm On Feb 05, 2017
Stupedinluv:
You are not more disappointed than myself. I am really but far from surprised.

Still a Christian but I have quietly excluded myself from church activities and resolved to study the Bible myself in my own space until I am mature enough to withstand the modern church.

I have a strong conviction that Christianity is true but I understand when people are in doubt. Doubt happens when we read the Bible or try to understand God through people...gullible, selfish people (including us)



.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by OOOS: 5:39pm On Feb 05, 2017
Stupedinluv:
You are not more disappointed than myself. I am really but far from surprised.

Still a Christian but I have quietly excluded myself from church activities and resolved to study the Bible myself in my own space until I am mature enough to withstand the modern church.

I have a strong conviction that Christianity is true but I understand when people are in doubt. Doubt happens when we read the Bible or try to understand God through people...gullible, selfish people (including us)



From what HardMirror wrote he has taken a stance and he's probably searching for fellow birds. He even said the bible is full of contradiction, I think he shouldn't be taken seriously. Now, you said you don't go to church again probably because of some yahoo pastors, but there are still decent churches around. Hebrews 10:25 Not forsaking the assembly of ourselves together, as the manner of some is....
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by Nobody: 5:42pm On Feb 05, 2017
OOOS:

From what HardMirror wrote he has taken a stance and he's probably searching for fellow birds. He even said the bible is full of contradiction, I think he shouldn't be taken seriously. Now, you said you don't go to church again probably because of some yahoo pastors, but there are still decent churches around. Hebrews 10:25 Not forsaking the assembly of ourselves together, as the manner of some is....

Thank you o

Examples of these decent churches Pls?
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by admus14(m): 5:43pm On Feb 05, 2017
somebody open Exodus 22: 20
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by OOOS: 5:46pm On Feb 05, 2017
Stupedinluv:


Thank you o

Examples of these decent churches Pls?
I still respect pastor Sam Adeyemi. I won't probably be able to recommend, but trust me, there are a lot if you look around
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by felixomor: 5:48pm On Feb 05, 2017
OOOS:

From what HardMirror wrote he has taken a stance and he's probably searching for fellow birds. He even said the bible is full of contradiction, I think he shouldn't be taken seriously. Now, you said you don't go to church again probably because of some yahoo pastors, but there are still decent churches around. Hebrews 10:25 Not forsaking the assembly of ourselves together, as the manner of some is....

The guy is an atheist who was once bursted for telling lies in his threads, here on Nairaland.
It was a pathetic scenario.

He is trying to resurrect his career of telling lies.
Re: When Are christians Permitted to KILL and Can A Christian Be A Soldier? by Nobody: 5:49pm On Feb 05, 2017
OOOS:

I still respect pastor Sam Adeyemi. I won't probably be able to recommend, but trust me, there are a lot if you look around
Is Sam Adeyemi a church?
If they are a lot, you should readily tell me one.

(1) (2) (3) ... (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) (11) (Reply)

Atheists In Lagos And Worldwide, Come And Witness Limb Growing Miracle!!!!! / Is Alcohol A Sin In Christiandom? / Five things Nigerian Pastors do

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 77
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.