₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,391 members, 8,522,780 topics. Date: Sunday, 22 November 2026 at 01:25 AM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 (of 210 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 8:17pm On May 25, 2012
Enigma: ^^^ So is it in the law or not?

Is it on the statute books or not?

Why didn't your "separation of Church and State" prevent it from being a legal requirement albeit with the possibility of an exception?

Are you so ignorant not to be aware that many legal rules and/or legal requirements make provisions for exceptions ---- exceptions which may not even have anything to do with religion necessarily?

cool
Prevent what from being a legal requirement? I just pointed out to you that the phrase is not a legal requirement. Read your own references. Also, note that it says "God" not Jesus, not Holy Spirit or any other mythological creature devoted to a religion since people can believe in a God without being religious. Just so you know.
Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 8:06pm On May 25, 2012
Ptolomeus: A secular state does not mean to be an atheist state.
A religious state is one that has an official religion and that religion can intervene in public affairs or in matters of state.
This makes the official religion, has privileges over the other, and even can get to ban the practice of a religion (which is against human rights).
A secular state (I insist) is not an atheist state, but a state without religion, that does not allow any interference of religion in their decisions, and which, in turn granted to all religions the same right.
There is nothing a secular atheist.
I wonder how hard it is for these religious fanatics to understand that these laws also protect them just in case they become the minority tomorrow.
Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 8:04pm On May 25, 2012
Enigma: ^^^ See how you make a mumu of yourself and show your poor comprehension again.

Read my post again and what it says about the President.

Then read this (if you can understand it and its effect): http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/5/3331

Then go read this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Uniformed_Services_Oath_of_Office

Then go and read your link.

Then go back and read my post.

After that come and talk. smiley

cool
Seriously, this is why I say you should rectify your ignorance by reading or poor English language comprehension by going back to school. Since it seems you didn't even read your sources, let me quote what the Wikipedia one says since it also contains an explanation. Please read it. After doing that, tell me how it contradicts anything I've said.

[quote author=Text of the Oath]I, [name], do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties of the office on which I am about to enter. So help me God.[/quote]
Explanation: Note that the last sentence is not required to be said if the speaker has a personal or moral objection, as is true of all oaths administered by the United States government; Article Six of the United States Constitution requires that there be no religious test for public office.
Also keep in mind that there are non-believers in the U.S. military. Do you think they do not take oaths? Or that they have to say "so help me God"?
Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 7:44pm On May 25, 2012
Enigma: ^^Look, continue in your ignorance e.g. conflating "no test" with legal requirements concerning oath of office . If you are wise, you will go and read up and cross-check what I wrote. smiley

cool
This too is plain ignorance which can be rectified by reading or just dishonesty. Please rectify it by reading. You may begin here.
When you're through, I hope you will then understand that the "so help me God" phrase is not a legal requirement. It is optional for the very reason I gave you.
Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 7:33pm On May 25, 2012
Enigma: As has been shown already, "separation of Church and State" is not a US constitutional concept as such.
Really?

Enigma: The expression in the American context originated in a letter in which Jefferson responded to some Baptists, who were congratulating him on his appointment, basically assuring them of his support for the idea that the State should not interfere with their religious freedoms.
The state not interfering with religious freedom isn't separation?

Enigma: Basically, the duplicitous atheists have hijacked the expression and bastardised its use into a context different from its origin --- this occasionally with the assistance of the American Supreme Court. A major impetus of the First Amendment was the protection of religious minorities, in fact minority Christian groups, so that they will not suffer persecution by majority religious groups, in fact majority Christian groups. In various settlements, some "denominations" tended to predominate e.g. Catholics in some places, Anglicans in others etc. The concern about domination and persecution of the minority groups was also fuelled by the experience of many of the early pilgrims who had fled to America because of religious persecution in Europe.
How is this persecution being prevented if not by the state not interfering with religion and religions not interfering with the state's policies?

Enigma: Nowadays, every evangelical atheist mumu shouts "separation of church and state" either in ignorance (among most) and in duplicitous chicanery by the smarter ones. They have benefitted from a generally sympathetic judicial system.
Here we have gross ignorance or just plain dishonesty. Simply take the time to read the documents involved and understand their underlying principles. By a sympathetic judicial system, you mean one without atheists on the panel.

Enigma: Hmmm, food for thought:

The oath of office that must be taken by various US government officials including congress men/women, senators, cabinet members and even the Vice-President requires them to declare "So help me, God." By convention even appointees to the office of President have usually made the same declaration.

smiley
No it doesn't require them to declare "So help me, God". You're confusing tradition or political expediency for legal fact. The fact is that there is no religious test for public office. Why do you think that is so?
Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 6:21pm On May 25, 2012
OLAADEGBU: I've been telling you to change those spectacles of yours, they are becoming opaque. tongue
How difficult is it for you to post links to where you think you addressed the issue I raised? This is the sort of obfuscation one comes to expect from religious people who don't know what they're talking about.
Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 4:51pm On May 25, 2012
OLAADEGBU: All these questions has been addressed in earlier posts. Go back and read up so as to catch up.
Actually, you haven't addressed them. If you think you have, please post a link showing this.

OLAADEGBU: Since you can not, could not, would not and will not access any links or videoclips I posted there is no point repeating what these links say to you again.
You didn't actually respond to what I said. Maybe you should learn to express your ideas in words rather than posting clips that end up being irrelevant. If they're relevant, then use the arguments made in them to support your point on the separation between church and state.
Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 4:21pm On May 25, 2012
OLAADEGBU: If it hasn't been shown to be a myth can you point out where it is stated in the constitution? I'm sure you will not find it and yet you Secular humanists have petitioned and sued that the Bibles and prayer be prohibited from the public schools, that prayers should be stopped in the institutions, that the 10 commandments should be removed from public places, and the folks you have up there in the videoclip now have a President to champion their case as they want him to stop the National Day of Prayer.
Lots of things aren't stated in the constitution. For you to understand the idea behind it, you actually need to respond to what I say and to the questions I ask.
What do you understand by the phrase "separation between church and state"? And do you think it is a good idea to keep religion and government separate? If you can answer these questions, then I can help you understand what the constitution says.
There is nothing wrong with stopping this national day of prayer because it is illegal for the government to endorse a particular religion.

OLAADEGBU: It is now clear that you have now got your chance to destroy the country from within because it calls itself God's own country. If you will not pray at least allow those who have the nation's goodness at heart to do so without the unnessary prohibition from the Administration that is looking for an opportunity to stop it anyway.
Does God have a country?
The government isn't stopping you from praying or does the government go into churches and stop prayers? The law stops the government from telling the citizens to pray. Do you disagree with that idea? Also, the Bible is what is supposed to stop these hypocrites from such public pronouncements simply read your own Bible.
Christianity Etc › Re: Should Science Be The Only Legitimate Guiding Force? by thehomer: 12:32pm On May 25, 2012
Jenwitemi: No. Science shouldn't be the only legitimate guide because it is and still remains not the only means but one of many guiding forces. The second reason is that it is just as corruptible as the other means like religion and can mislead just like religion. All available doors should and must be opened to man to explore through.
I disagree that the scientific process is as corruptible as religion and that it is as misleading as religion.
Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 12:30pm On May 25, 2012
OLAADEGBU: We have discussed that the Separation of Church and State in earlier posts and it has been found out to be a myth that doesn't exist in the constitution. The first Amendment states that the Government cannot establish a religion neither can it prohibit the free expression or speech of the citizens. But that is the exact thing your humanists are doing as you can see in the videoclip below, silencing free speech while pretending to be upholding the non existent Separation of Church and State.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5HGsteD_kkU
Actually, the separation of church and state hasn't been shown to be a myth. If the government cannot establish a religion neither can it limit the free expression of its citizens, then how can you say the church and the government aren't separate? The difference would be a government endorsed religion. Do you understand what I've just said?

What are the humanists doing in the video? And are the humansits the government?
Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 11:05pm On May 24, 2012
I notice that you've run from my previous post. Don't run from this one too.

OLAADEGBU: Every religious organisation is has the freedom to conduct their National Day of Prayer but why is it that when Christians conducted theirs that Obama suddenly remembers the non existent Separation from Church and State?
Actually, there is an existence of the separation between church and state otherwise, the government would be able to outlaw various religions.

OLAADEGBU: He is happy to celebrate the Muslims' Ramadan in the White House or to declare a whole month for the celebration of Lesbian, Gays, Bisexuals and Transexual groups but he seems to feel threatened by the Christian groups and yet he wants to be seen as a Christian.
Do they celebrate Christmas or Easter in the White House?

OLAADEGBU: Go and read about the origin and progress of the National Day of Prayer and you will see that it's only Christians that were concerned about praying, fasting and reflecting for their country, it was not atheists or the Muslims.
All the more reason why it should be outlawed. It serves no other purpose than to attempt to meld religion and government.
Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 8:28pm On May 24, 2012
OLAADEGBU: What do you say about Obama preventing Franklin Graham from making a speech on the National Prayers' Day because of what he sees as violation of political correctness?
There are too many hidden assumptions in this question that make it problematic.
e.g
1. Who organizes the National Day of Prayer? Is it the government or a private group?
2. Is this practice legal? Can the Congress ask people to pray in a secular country?
3. Is Franklin Graham a True Christian?
4. Free speech means one can say what they want within limits not that they must have a certain platform to say it.
5. What is the evidence you're using to frame this question?
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is The Creator?? by thehomer: 8:15pm On May 24, 2012
tohirah: [color=#000099][/color]
Christians say Jesus is the son of God and they still claim the same jesus is the creator,originator etc. Since he is the son of God,then his father should be the one doing the creation,giving life or death etc. By the way why would you leave the father and worship the son when you can communicate with father yourself? I wanna know but no insults pls frm both religions and the "no-religion"
Well, I'm the creator. Come and worship me.
Christianity Etc › Re: Reasons Why I Know Obama Is Not A Christian by thehomer: 8:01pm On May 24, 2012
OLAADEGBU: Separation of Church and State.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aYr0IKze13s

Alan Keyes explains what the U.S. constitution says on religious liberty, that it says nothing about the Separation of Church and State. He interpretes it that the constitution doesn't give the courts the right to render judgments regarding religious expression.
You do realize that the courts don't render judgement regarding religious expression. If they did, they would have been able to shut down various religions e.g Scientology. What they do is prevent the government from sanctioning religious speech. Do you think the government should be allowed to sanction religious speech?
Christianity Etc › Re: TB Joshua's Chelsea “false Prophecy” Proved Wrong by thehomer: 8:52pm On May 23, 2012
He should have bought an octopus. What has he been doing with all the money he's been collecting?
Christianity Etc › Re: Should Science Be The Only Legitimate Guiding Force? by thehomer: 8:41pm On May 23, 2012
[quote author=emöfine2]@thehomer


Quite interesting. I believe you are right concerning different definitions stapled to spirituality – there can be an “inner”(self) and “outer”(universe) facet regarding spirituality...

Do you think emotions can guide one to a/the truth?

. . . .[/quote]Sure emotions could but due to the demonstrable unreliability of emotions in arriving at certain true conclusions, it is preferable to use more suitable means of arriving at true conclusions.
Education › Re: Emphasis On Mathematics & English Causes Mass Failure - Educationist by thehomer: 8:39pm On May 23, 2012
ishmael: You can also suggest they make physics compulsory 4 arts students to also sharpen their thinking and reasoning abilities.
why would I? Physics is a different subject from Mathematics.
Education › Re: Emphasis On Mathematics & English Causes Mass Failure - Educationist by thehomer: 8:39pm On May 23, 2012
ishmael: It was offered as a subject in the past. It's only a suggestion for it to be re-introduced back so that those that want to go in for some arts and social science courses can go in with statistics in lieu of general maths. I see no good reason why arts students should do the same rigorous maths as their science counterparts. I rest my case bro.
And I say there is no reason to separate them because all people need some basic knowledge of Mathematics. I also don't see basic Mathematics as being so rigorous that they should be limited to those in the sciences.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Homosexuality Demonic? by thehomer: 6:27pm On May 22, 2012
Deep Sight: ^^^ Mr. Idehn, pleas enote very carefully the last line the post above and I would be interested in a response to that.

But there is another argument I will be advancing in more detail later today. In summary I will suggest to you that nature (and this is evinced by evolution) promotes attributes that aid the survival of a species. Creatures that do not adapt to conform with attributes that aid survival do not survive: they become extinct. As such we can see effectively that there are attributes that aid survival and that nature promotes survival of creatures with such attributes and negate the survival of creatures without such attributes.

I will be advancing to you later today that the totality of natural evolution itself forms a strong argument that needs which are critical for survival are rendered requisite by nature - such basic needs as eating - and such basic needs for the propagation of the species as se.x - are advanced by nature. I will be advancing to you later today the argument that homose.xual se.x is thus not in tandem with the evolutionary thrust of nature - which evidentially rests on heterose.xual se.x, in terms of the survival of species.

Later, my good friend.

O, and Mr Homer, all these are for you as well to think on, and Mr. Purist, and Mr. Martian.

Cheers. Make I go find money for now.

Now, that's def natural. . .
You should be careful in your attempt to use evolution to try to demonstrate your point because evolution is considered with respect to populations and not just single individuals.
Christianity Etc › Re: Should Science Be The Only Legitimate Guiding Force? by thehomer: 6:27am On May 22, 2012
[quote author=emöfine2]Science is a fundamental aspect in human life and so is spirituality for some. Both can open up (and also close) the way an individual thinks and perceives.
However science strives to maintain objectivity whilst spirituality is subjective thus is it important to balance the two? And what happens when science is in conflict with ones belief?

Whilst another’s beliefs should not be imposed on anyone, science should at least be held as a universal basic but akin to some people’s individual beliefs some parts of science still remains theoretical.

Although beliefs should not be used to legislate a country, life is more abstract and science cannot or has yet to decisively measure certain important principles such as morality (albeit morality can be subjective).

But just because spirituality may be optional (and personal) for some unlike science which is largely compulsory and universal does that make spirituality less significant?[/quote]Problems often arise with the use of a word like "spirituality". In some cases, it would be tied to mythical beings like spirits, ghosts, Gods, demons etc. In others, it could refer to emotions that are present in pretty much all people. If it is being used in the first sense, I would say it is less significant. If it is being used in the second sense, I would say I would say it is more significant than in the first sense but ultimately depends on the person and the issue under consideration.

[quote author=emöfine2]"Science without Religion Is Lame, Religion without Science Is Blind" – Albert Einstein: Agree or Disagree?[/quote]*

I disagree with this statement because science doesn't need religion to progress. In fact, religion can be said to hinder scientific progress.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Homosexuality Demonic? by thehomer: 6:17am On May 22, 2012
Deep Sight: I should add to this the fact that if we are to accept Mr. Idehn's outrageous definition, there is nothing that ever happens that should be condemned for any reason.

Since its all "natural."
You're still making the same mistake. The fact that something occurs in nature or is considered natural doesn't mean it should never be condemned. This is why I asked you prior to this entire line of thought to clarify within yourself the distinction between something being natural and being moral.

Deep Sight: I repeat: you will not find any dictionary in the world that defines the word "natural" the way Mr. Idehn does. That is because he is mis-defining it. His definition is WHOLLY wrong.

It is curious that Mr. Homer agrees with the definition even when the definition kills off Mr Homer's characterization of some things as unnatural; whereas Mr. Idehn's definition says nothing is unnatural!

Problems! This is what happens when you deliberately mis-define words to suit a purpose.
Here, you've decided to actually ignore what I said. I asked you for your conceptions before I answered, you refused to present it. I then provided my own ideas and used them to answer and you still complain. Why don't you make up your mind on what you actually want to say?

It also appears that you didn't read my previous response to you because you're still committing the fallacy of appealing to nature. Whether or not something is natural doesn't say anything about it being moral or acceptable.
Education › Re: Emphasis On Mathematics & English Causes Mass Failure - Educationist by thehomer: 12:37pm On May 21, 2012
ishmael: No need debating with u since u cannot see any difference between statistics and mathematics. I thought u knew. And also everything is wrong with embedding statistics inside mathematics. Statistics is a distinct field from mathematics, and it is basic stats that most arts & social science courses require and and not general mathematics. It should stand on its own like it used to be in the past in WAEC just like mathematics.
I didn't say there was no difference, I said there was no need at the secondary school level for statistics to be a separate course from mathematics when the concepts can be taught in mathematics. For some reason, you still don't seem to see that the secondary school level is more for general knowledge than for specialized knowledge. Especially in these modern times when there is a lot more to learn and many more courses in the school day.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Homosexuality Demonic? by thehomer: 12:29pm On May 21, 2012
Deep Sight: No, i do not regard oral se.x to be wrong, unnatural or immoral. I should warn however that a[i]n[/i]al heterose.xual se.x has quite a few known medical implications, and I do not want to be drawn into qualifying it just right now as it will complicate the discussion. Suffice to say that I will not call it immoral or wrong, though I might say that it is unnatural and may be probematic medically.
You do not consider MouthAction to be unnatural? Okay lets see if you're being consistent.

Deep Sight: @ ALL -

This discussion commenced with thehomer's statement to the effect that he cannot see anything unnatural in homose.xuality. I believe that that contradicts the definition of the word natural.

Now, for clarity, here is the definition of the word natural, that I am working with - i did not create that word - that word has a dictionary definition and as such it would be proper in discussions to keep consistent with the proper meaning of that word. What's happening in this thread is that everyone is giving that word his own personal definition. I could do that too, but that is not proper in a debate. What Idehn has done for example is not the definition of the word natural. He has deleted the words "natural" and "unnatrural" from the English Language and for his concept of "natural" he really simply means "possible". But he is not making the fine distinction to see that this is what he is doing.

Do the words "natural" and "possible" mean the same thing? ? ?

What Idehn has done is to conclude that anything that is possible is also natural. This is a false notion of the word "natural", It ignores the fact that many things are possible which are not biologically natural to creatures and in nature. It assumes that there exist no natural rules - and worse - if there are natural rules, then it assumes that such rules do not have unnatural exemptions.

As far as this discussion is concerned, I will stick with a standard definition of the word "natural" from a dictionary as it applies in context of this discussion.

"Natural"

1.
existing in or formed by nature ( opposed to artificial): a natural bridge.

2.
based on the state of things in nature; constituted by nature: Growth is a natural process.

3.
of or pertaining to nature or the universe: natural beauty.

4.
of, pertaining to, or occupied with the study of natural science: conducting natural experiments.

5.
in a state of nature; uncultivated, as land.

http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/natural?s=t

I believe that the definition apt for this discussion is No.2 above - let us very carefully that it is not as bland as Idehn's version: it does not simply say "anything that exists or occurs" - it rather very carefully says - "based on the state of things in nature; constituted by nature: Growth is a natural process."

I particularly like the example given - Growth. That is the state of things for living things in nature, they grow. As such if a baby is born and doeas not grow it will be a mis-normer to say that such is "natural" simply because it has been seen to occur. The reverse is actually true: it is unnatural because that is not the state of things as they occur in nature - evidentially - it is an abnormaility.

This is what it means to say that it is unnatural. But Mr. Idehn's definition has effectively deleted the word "unnatural" from the dictionary, as he blandly defines natural as anything and everything that occurs. This defeats every notion of the word "natural" that can be conceived in terms of making distinctions, as there will be nothing to classify as natural or unatural given that in his estimation, everything is natural.

Going back to the definition given above (No 2) which I cited as the definition apt for this discussion, you see it says - "based on the state of things in nature". . . as such I submit that a consideration as to whether homose.xuality is natural or not should thus be directed at -

1. Observing nature - outside of humans perhaps - as humans are the subject here - and seeing if homose.xuality occurs in nature. Many people have made arguments stating that homose.xuality is natural beacuse animals have been observed to practice same. That is a false and flawed argument which I have addressed before and I will repost it here though.

2. Observing natural biology, normal hormonal balance, and human anatomy.

My contention is that if one looks at the self-evident intention of nature in terms of the male and female anatomies and their se.xual inter-relationship, it is obvious that the intention of nature is heterose.xual.
Hold on here. Note that you are the one imbuing nature with an intent here. In fact, based on the state of things in nature, how is homosexuality unnatural? Don't confuse this with you asserting that nature has a certain intent. One thing you seem to be ignoring is the fact that human sexuality which is natural based on your own accepted definition encompasses homosexuality, heterosexuality, bisexuality and asexuality. You have decided on your own ignoring the available evidence from qualified specialists that only strict heterosexuality is natural. What gives you this privilege?

Deep Sight: The point I was trying to make with all those questions I gave to thehomer was simply to make him recognize that any principle that can be used to defend homose.xuality can be used to defend the cases of necrophiliac acts or even in.cest as all being natural. They are all cases of free adult consensus except the necrophilic act which requires no consent ab initio in the scenario I mentioned. Even if thehomer will say he does not base his judgment on this principle (although he does), the other principles he mentioned also apply equally to my scenarios. They are all cases of privacy, equality, equity, absence of coercion, no harm being done to anyone else, etc. And yet thehomer described some of them as immoral or unnatural. On what basis, sir?
I hope you realize also that based on your own presentation of natural, incest is not necessarily unnatural. I gave you the basis I was using maybe you should simply refer to them again.

Deep Sight: For me, I have given my basis for regarding homose.uality as unnatural: observation of human anatomy, and the biological nature of se.xual organs coupled with some of the purposes of same disclose that that which is intended my nature is heterose.xuality. Defining the reverse as "natural" on the grounds that Messrs Homer and Idehn do, does not add up in the least.
Based on the observation of human anatomy, are masturbation and MouthAction natural? After all, neither the hand nor the mouth are organs for reproduction now are they? How about intersex states, are they natural? You see, you're simply refusing to accept the implications of your accepted definition of natural.

Deep Sight: Now since the discussion proceeded from Mr Homer's comment that he saw nothing unnatural in homose.xuality, let us restrict the discussion to that word "natural" as I originally proposed. From there it will be easy not to get mixed up with moralistic notions about right and wrong.

I personally do not really see moral wrong in any se.xual act so long as no one is coerced and no harm is done to anybody. And by harm I need to even exclude some kinky consensual harm, because you have couples who play with whips and things, they find it erotic. Do I think it is morally wrong? No, but I can make a case that it is unnatural, because the body itself is hardwired to resile from pain. The nerves send messages to the brain regarding this. The person enjoying a whipping session will have to steel himself against the natural reaction of his body, which would be to flinch and resile from such pain. Trust me I know, because i've dabbled in all that. No body can convince me it is wrong, but if someone says it is unnatural he is speaking the truth.
Since you do not see anything immoral in sexual acts, why were you railing on and on against certain sexual acts? Or are you saying that you only find "unnatural" acts disgusting? You really need to sort these things out within yourself before trying to delve deeper into the discussion to avoid certain conflations.

Deep Sight: For heaven's sake there are people who like to defecate on one another during se.x. I see such as morally neutral if it is their fetis.h or kink and harms no body else and is private. But no one can sincerely quarell if we say that it is unnatural. Whereas Mr. Idehn's definition would qualify that and everything else that exists as natural.

Homose.xuality is not natural - it is unnatural. And this is evident from even the reactions of Messrs Homer and Idehn. Particularly, Mr Idehn's definition must not be allowed to stand. It destroys the very words "natural" and "unnatural" and deletes them from the English Language.

Hope I have made some sense.
How is your assertion that homosexuality is unnatural evident from my reaction or that of Idehn? Actually, his definition is pretty good too. What you're coming up against is the basic understanding that basing an argument on the concept of nature can be very tricky. In fact, it can be considered fallacious as you're using it so much so that it has a name the fallacy of appealing to nature.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Homosexuality Demonic? by thehomer: 9:55pm On May 20, 2012
Deep Sight: @ THE HOMER,

Ok, I will humour you. Free Adult Consensus refers to the fact that a person is engaging in any particular se.xual activity -

1. On the basis of his personal free choosing

2. As an adult and

3. In agreement with his se.xual partner

4. Which se.xual partner is also operating on the same basis.

I wanted to know if this is your basis for holding nomose.xuality to be natural - because in general terms this principle is held by major schools of thought to be the appropriate principle in personal se.xual matters.

Yes ofcourse, you mentioned privacy, equality etc. - but all that also applies to the scenarios i raised. Private se.xual liasons which harm no one else.

So now please answer my question, so that we can make substantive progress.
That isn't why I consider homosexuality to be natural. This is why I initially asked you to distinguish between moral and natural. I said that by natural, I was referring to the general physical appearance and abilities of the average person.

You've still not distinguished between natural and moral. I think you need to at least do that at this point.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is God Dead? by thehomer: 9:47pm On May 20, 2012
Deep Sight: What if maximizing pleasure is actually not benevolent?

Do you think a Military Trainer who has full powers to maximize pleasure for his wards in a Military Training Camp might necessarily think that it is benevolent to do so?
There are two issues here (minimizing pain and increasing pleasure) and a God with three omni- features.
For benevolence, even if this God isn't maximizing pleasure, he should at least be reducing the pain. Note that I'm more concerned with reducing the pain than maximizing the pleasure. A God who can reduce the pain and suffering in the world but decides not to cannot be said to be benevolent to people.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Homosexuality Demonic? by thehomer: 7:25pm On May 20, 2012
Deep Sight: When you spoke in your answers here about degree of independence, that is not an allussion to adult freedom in arriving at consensual se.xual decisions, right?
How do I know whether or not it is an allusion to some principle that you just made up on your own without saying what it is? What does an adult not being coerced into performing a certain act mean that I know what your term principle of free adult consensus actually means? If you can, please go ahead and explain it using your own examples. Or are you saying that when an adult without being coerced, performs an act is acting with your so-called principle?

Deep Sight: And now, that idea has suddenly become a mystery, right?

You are running around in pitiful circles playing games with yourself.
If you're serious, you will actually say what you mean by your own term as you use it.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Homosexuality Demonic? by thehomer: 7:20pm On May 20, 2012
Deep Sight: That is why i specifically asked you to clarify if you are using that principle in arriving at your conclusions on homose.xuality.

You reverted insinuating that you don't know what "FREE ADULT CONSENSUS" means in a discussion about se.xual activity.
How can I clarify whether or not I'm using your principle if I don't know what your principle is.

Deep Sight: Who do you expect to believe that, or take you seriously on that. Do you really expect me to now start explaing what free adult consensus means in this discussion? Is there any literate person anywhere in the world that will say he does not know what that means?

You really cant expect to be taken seriously sir.
How hard is it for you to actually tell me what comes to [b]your [/b]mind when you think of this principle of free adult consensus?
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Homosexuality Demonic? by thehomer: 4:54pm On May 20, 2012
Deep Sight: ^^^ If you will sincerely tell me that you do not know what the phrase "free adult consensus" means, or that it is a confusing phrase, or that its meaning is unclear: then there is no point having a discussion on this matter as its glaring that you are deliberately being evasive, and anyone can see that.

It is even more pathetic considering that you yourself alluded to same principle when you spoke about people being coerced or being minors. It was glaring that you apprehend and use the self-same principle in arriving at your conclusions. And then when I ask you to clarify whether or not you use this priciple you suddenly claim not to even know what the words "free adult consensus" mean.

Do you really expect people to take you seriously when you do that, or to have the time to indulge such silly games?
Are you missing some doses of your medication or something? [b]You [/b]introduced the term and attributed it to me. Where have I ever used the term? You need to actually say what it is rather than saying that you think it is what I'm doing.
I alluded to it? Keep in mind that I do not know what you're talking about. And I gave you reasons for my conclusions. You on the other hand failed to give any other than your emotional feelings.
Rather than beating about the bush, why don't you actually say what you mean by that phrase now that you know that words can have different meanings when combined in a phrase. And avoid acting as though you're a mind reader. Newsflash; you're not a mind reader.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is God Dead? by thehomer:
AlvinPlantinga: I thought we were all along talking about Moral Free dom here, not just Free will to chose either to sit or stand.Moral Free Will is what deals with chosing right or wrong.therefore i am not sure what you mean when you say i am smuggling in words.
You said something about significant moral freedom. What is this? Is it another phrase for free will or something else?

AlvinPlantinga: I would have hoped that you would actually offer a counter argument showing that it is possible for God to actualise a world where Agents are significantly morally free and chose no evil. This is what you have to show for the Free WIll Defense to fail.The version of Free will i am using is quite obvious.It is the ability of human beings or agents to make choices which are not determined.It is either this or determinism.So asking which version of Free will am using is really a non-factor here.Unless ofcourse you are of the view that Compatibilism is a form of free will.
I presented you with an example of Heaven where there are agents with free will who still do not choose evil.
The version of free will you're using here is an important factor because it would help in determining the sorts of limits one wishes to place on God.

AlvinPlantinga: No let us hear your case.Since nowhere in my posts have i alluded to any other type of free will where human beings have certain constraints on their conscience to make free moral choices.
My case is simple. God with his omni- attributes, could have created a world not necessarily with people where the people there choose to do good deeds whether due to the absence of certain features or the presence of others.

Edit: To clarify what I'm saying, here is a thought experiment.

God could have created a world with ten people who are not mentally ill or suffer from any such aberrations.
In one, he could place such people in a celestial North Korea where they realize very early that every single immoral action they perform is immediately punished. They will pretty quickly come to perform only moral actions.
In another, he could have placed such people in a world where it is physically impossible for any of these people to perform immoral acts. e.g if someone wanted to murder another, some circumstance would arise which brings about a moral outcome.
Or in another world, he could place these people in heaven where all they do is sing him praises and no other desires arise in them.

AlvinPlantinga: Still not grasping Possible World terminologies.There are indeed endless possibilities.An infinite number of possible outcomes can be played out from a single event.but few or none will be actualised.As long as you get this distinction, which from your statement above, it seems you still have not grasped,then we will be talking past each other.
These are the sorts of statements that philosophers make that makes scientists wonder if when one makes such a statement, they're not simply being facetious.

AlvinPlantinga: there is no mystery in what version of free will am using.It is obvious am using an incompatibilist version of free will.there is nowhere in my posts i have suggested otherwise,now lets hear your counterargument.
Given above.

AlvinPlantinga: So far you have failed to see clearly that am using a libertarian/incmpatibilist view of free will.I have not alluded to any sort of detrminism on my posts to suggest any other version of free will.And this remains your only excuse as to why you have not addressed the argument.

All answered above.but you keep repeating them.

I think the readers will be the judge.I like having a concise argumental structure,where i restate my position and continue to address your responses. I think to the best of my knowledge, and i am reading through every response you write,i have given a response.The problem with your response is you keep shifting from argument to argument.and when i point this out to you,you cry foul.

Constantly mixing the arguments,abandoning the original POE in its logical version as stated has been the case throughout.

Point taken.
I don't shift from argument to argument, I simply keep in mind a broad point of view on the issues under discussion. One of them here is the actual God under consideration.

Note also that nothing you've said above addresses evils like diseases, earthquakes and what not. I don't think your notion of free will addresses them. That is something else that I've pointed out to you previously.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is God Dead? by thehomer: 4:08pm On May 20, 2012
AlvinPlantinga: I can see that we will be going round in circles on this one.You cannot make a sound argument from " We do not know God's reasons for allowing evil, then it follows that there are actually no good reasons for evil".
I don't see why we will be going round in circles because that too isn't what I'm saying what I'm saying is if we do not know the reasons why a God is allowing so much evil, then we cannot say he is actually good.

AlvinPlantinga: I am saying the argument you are presenting is a new argument and not the Problem Of Evil.You MUST assume first that God is Good for there to be a problem of evil.And secondly, your argument that since we do not know God's reasons for allowing evil, then it follows that he does not have any good reasons, is invalid.Simply because you cannot make such a conclusion based on lack of knowledge on your part on God's reasons.
I agree that it would be a different argument but recall that the argument is referring to a particular known God.
I know that for the problem of evil, one assumes that the God is good but the existence of evil puts his goodness into question. Oh and what you're saying isn't my argument.

AlvinPlantinga: You are offering me a way out, how kind of you.You are offering a new argument.Your argument is:-

If God is Good, and he has good reasons for allowing evil, then we should be able to know these reasons,since we do not know these reasons, then it follows that God is amoral.
That too isn't what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that for one to even say that a certain God is good, we should be able to tell the reasons for his allowing evil. If we do not know these reasons, then we're also justified in thinking that he is evil or amoral.

AlvinPlantinga: Yes it is out of the discussion. You are the one bringing the Problem of Evil and asking, if God is Good, All knowing and All powerful, why does evil exist?But if what you want to discuss is how do we know God is Good, then i will point out to you that you have abandoned the problem of evil.You have now moved to Moral Epistemology,Semantics,Ontology etc.And this is where the Moral Argument comes in.
While it may be out of the discussion for the Problem of Evil, it isn't when we're talking about the Christian God.

AlvinPlantinga: Ofcourse i did not say that minimizing pain plays no part in God's Omnibenevolence, i said it is not the primary role of his all-loving nature.I also said that being all-loving does not entail maximizing pleasure since there are more important virtues and goods to be obtained according to the Christian Worldview.I said Soul Building, Preserving Free Will and getting a personal relationship with God are all much more important than minimizing pain.

You are the one who has the burden of qualifying your statement that a benevolent God should prioritize Maximizing of pleasure.
An omnipotent, omniscient and omnibenevolent God should prioritize maximizing pleasure because he can.

AlvinPlantinga: Yes ofcourse, we are talking about earth here aren't we?
Yes. If he can do it in Heaven, then he can do it on earth.

AlvinPlantinga: Sorry, it does not work that way.I do not have to show anything of the sort.You have the burden of proof of showing that an Omniscient and All-loving God lacks a good reason for allowing such evil.How You cannot abscond your duties here.
This is with regards to deciding on whether or not a certain God is good isn't it? My point is that if you wish to propose that your God is in fact good, yet so much evil abounds, on what basis do you conclude that he is good? I know that this is a separate argument from the Problem of Evil as I've already said.

AlvinPlantinga: I will keep reminding you that you should first own the Problem Of Evil.It is your argument.You have asked me, if God Exists,and he is all loving and omniscient, why does he allow evil,and i am saying he may have good morally sufficient reasons to allow such evil. And as long as this is even possibly true, then you do not have case.I do not have to explain these reasons,because, it does not follow that since i do not know these reasons, then God does not have good reasons for allowing such evil.

It is your burden now, to make this argument sound:-

If we do not know God's reasons for allowing evil,then it follows that God is not good or amoral.I will be really interested to see how you can make a sound argument with those premises.
And I said if he can create heaven with no evil, he knows all things and can do all things, then he should be able to create a world without evil.
Note that the argument you're expecting me to rectify isn't actually my argument at all.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is Homosexuality Demonic? by thehomer: 1:57pm On May 20, 2012
Deep Sight: Can you see how you are?

Who can say that the words "free", "adult" and "consensus" are mysterious words?
Has it ever occurred to you that words and phrases can mean different things? e.g do you know what the words "backseat" and "driver" mean? What does "backseat driver" mean?
Education › Re: Emphasis On Mathematics & English Causes Mass Failure - Educationist by thehomer: 12:14pm On May 20, 2012
ishmael: You're too fake. You don't even know what trig or geometry is. Ok tell us one area where the law or history student applies trig or geometry in law or in history; i'm waiting. A prospective law or history student at best requires knowledge of basic statistics which they will eventually apply in the area of research data collection and data analysis, and not all those irrelevant topics like geometry, trig and other irrelavant topics that he or she will never make reference to.
You must be missing some doses of your medication.
What part of having a basic knowledge didn't you understand? Anyway, you can take a look at this book. You can read it online for free or download it to help you understand that everyone to some extent needs some basic knowledge of these principles.
Then take a look at this article. It is more on geography but as we know, lawyers and historians can be involved in understanding geography.
Note that statistics hasn't been remove, it is still in the Mathematics curriculum.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 99 100 101 102 103 104 105 106 107 (of 210 pages)