Thehomer's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 (of 210 pages)
Boxer Dollar. The guy failed in bringing up his daughter in the way of the lord and bribed policemen. The best punishment he could think of on his adolescent daughter is to box her? Yet we see some so called Christians supporting him. They'll support anything it seems. |
Avicenna: I was travelling in a commercial vehicle recently. As usual with people, they started arguing and debating all sorts of issues. Marital,girl-child education, female rights,corruption,same sex relationships , politics, just anything.One thing you could try is just to pick one person that you feel is closest to you in some way maybe in age or educational degree and try to have a conversation with them by asking them pertinent questions on questionable issues such as God crashing the bus. You could begin by wondering why God who is good would want to crash this bus with so many people who have families. You could also point out that the bus and vehicle accidents in general are human caused or machine caused and that this is why people get sued for accidents in courts etc. What I mean in effect is that you just try to settle on having a conversation with one person and others may join in. If you're asked a question on God and all that but you do now wish to identify yourself as an atheist, you could simply say that your own personal belief in God is different from theirs. |
AlvinPlantinga: First of all, the Free Will Defense presupposes Libertarian Free will.That is free will that is not determined by factors that is outside the Agents own will.In your North korean example, their choices are limited,in that they can only chose that which God has permitted.Any attempt to chose otherwise would be prevented or met with punishment.You say that eventually they will learn to Chose good,but thats not the question, the question is,can they chose otherwise if they wanted to?Nothing binds say,5 of these people to once in their lifetimes chose evil or attempt to.No, I'm saying they may chose otherwise but they may not get their intended outcomes. That already happens today. I may choose to take some coffee on my way to work but never get to take it because I was running late or the coffee shop was closed or a million other things. Their choices aren't affected. AlvinPlantinga: Remember you cannot give guarantees that these people will by their own free will chose good everytime, since they learnt that chosing evil was punishable early on in their lives.What if 2 decide to commit evil,despite all the learning?if god prevents these people from chosing evil by punishing him immediately,then God has interfered with their free will.Are these people psychopaths or are they unable to learn from prior experience? I specifically chose healthy people. I would think that would be within God's abilities. AlvinPlantinga: For an agent to be truly free God cannot gurantee only a single outcome of a person's choices no matter what his choices are.For example if i was told to chose between red, green and blue balls, and God made it in such a way ,as indirect as it maybe, i ended up with a red ball,even if i chose blue balls, then i do not have Free will to chose a blue ball.I may think i have Free Will to do so, but any action i perform will end up in me chosing the red ball.Basically are you saying that for one to have free-will, they must get any outcome that that they choose? I ask because that isn't obtainable in this world. From my example above, does the fact that I didn't get coffee on my way to work mean that I didn't have the free-will to take coffee on my way to work? AlvinPlantinga: Mmh.I am blinking twice to see whether am reading this right.Morality,without Morality!So when you allude to "people only performing moral actions" what do you mean by moral actions?You mean an action can be called moral yet devoid of Moral obligation,responsibility and praise?Two things to note. 1. In that world, morality is pretty much a part of the people there such that praising them for it or making it an obligation or responsibility would be like praising someone with a stomach for having it and saying they're obligated to have a stomach and bear some responsibility for the stomach. In that world, the God's goodness is already absolute. 2. I think an action can be called moral yet devoid of obligation, responsibility and praise e.g when a dog drags another dog out of traffic to safety, is it deserving of praise? Is there any obligation or responsibility on the dog? Yet, we do praise the dog. AlvinPlantinga: Moral Responsibility, obligations and praise are the heart of the problem of evil! For you to even say someone is good, you must assume that this person bares Moral responsibility and obligations.Otherwise we do not have a problem of evil.On a side note, I hope you know what the Christian God's responsibilities and obligations are. AlvinPlantinga: So you are saying that God does not have sufficient reasons for allowing x number of earthquakes or y number of floods, and they were totally unnecessary?He has no reasons for them because they're not logically impossible for him to do if he actually cares about humans. I think you would need to show that it is logically impossible for God to prevent earthquakes and other disasters for your defense to stand. AlvinPlantinga: What does heaven have to do with it?Heaven is the end product of earth.the product of the good choices and life lived here on this physical world.therefore even if heaven was physical or non physical,how would it advance your argument that the existence of god and evil here on earth is impossible.If heaven was physical it would help since God is willing to have a world without evil and without free-will. So why damn the earth by granting free-will? He has given free-will and suffering on earth only to take them away in heaven. |
AlvinPlantinga: I am not sure what you mean here.Clarification needed.Look at it this way. There are two Gods. God A is deemed to be good by definition. God B (the Christian God) is taken by Christians to be good. My question is how do we know that God B actually deserves to be called good given his past and present activities? AlvinPlantinga: Moral Argument, Ontological argument, Resurrection of Jesus Christ, Witness of The Holy Spirit.All different topics and arguments.I thought they were arguments for the existence of some God which with the Jesus stories becomes the Christian one. None of them actually tells us how to decide on whether or not he is good. AlvinPlantinga: Because, and i will repeat myself for the 15th time, If We do not know God's reasons for allowing evil, it does not follow that therefore He does not have good reasons.If this was God A that may be acceptable but it isn't acceptable for the Christian God because of his other attributes. AlvinPlantinga: At some point, hopefully we will get an argument for this assertions.Examples already abound for what I said. And the argument for it is still the same one that started the thread. This Christian God loves people and the defenseless yet he permits children to be brutalized by paedophiles why? You say you don't know. He just may have some good reasons for it. I say his attributes aren't correct or he is just evil or immoral. Given the example of the crime, brutalizing children, why should I think he is good? AlvinPlantinga: Since i responded by saying that God could have good reasons for allowing evil, thereby showing that there can exist a Tri-Omni God and evil, your task was to show that neccesarily God does not have good reasons for allowing evil.I pointed out to you that this is a burden that cannot be sustained since it would need you to know all current and future possibilities and their contingencies.In short you would need to be omniscient yourself.Saying that God could have good reasons for the evil we see actually doesn't solve your problem because such an answer that can be used to justify anything actually says nothing. AlvinPlantinga: So far your only defense to has been to say that God is evil or ammoral since we do not know his reasons for allowing evil.Which is invalid argument as i have continuously outlined.That isn't what I said. What I said is that we are justified in thinking that the Christian God is evil or amoral. AlvinPlantinga: true, but i have also proposed that my first defense, that god may have good reasons for allowing evil also covers natural disasters as well.The fact that you can't see these reasons, only leads to the conclusion that either, our faculties are limited or God does not wish to reveal these reasons.But it does not follow that therefore God does not have good reasons.Asking,how then would we know that God is good,If we are talking about the Christian God, then i know God is Good, because of a)the Moral Argument b)Anselm's Ontological Argument C) God's revelation in Scripture d) The Resurrection of Jesus Christ.You see, saying that God may have good reasons simply vacillates between God A and God B. God B isn't known to be good by definition so you would actually need to know this God's mind fully in order to say that he had good reasons. That is why I say that for all we know, he may just be gratuitously evil. The deeply flawed arguments you listed don't tell us that he is good just that he may exist. Also, you keep misrepresenting what I said about the need for us to know the good reasons that would serve as justification for forming a certain belief. AlvinPlantinga: Shown above.Just to add, it is invalid because it contains false premises, and therefore the conclusion would not follow.P1 isn't what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that for one to be able to say that a God X is good, one would need to know the reasons why he allows evil especially if he is also omnipotent and omnibenevolent. Note that this God X isn't defined as being good. AlvinPlantinga: The conclusion does not follow alone from the fact that we do not see these reasons then therefore God must not have any reasons.You will need much more than mere conjecture, you would need much more facts to ascertain the range of possibilities and truths to come to the conclusion that God did not have these reasons.What you stated above isn't actually what I'm saying. AlvinPlantinga: But remember, you cannot just use any definition of benevolent you want.Since you are talking of the christian God, you must use the Christian definition of the word.And that is simply all-loving.What entails Omnibenevolence is what is in question here.What concept of all-loving is the Christian God using that doesn't take human suffering into consideration? AlvinPlantinga: I refuse to go back on this point, since i sufficiently addressed it in our opening discussion.Actually, you didn't. You abruptly ended that aspect of the discussion when you found it difficult to sustain your idea of "epistemic distance". This was my last post on that aspect of the discussion. Your following post didn't address it. |
Image123: @thehomerNo, if it were reasonable, I would believe you. I guess the devil too sees you. Are you sure that he hasn't deceived you? Image123: Obviously you've chosen to believe what you want to believe, even when it doesn't involve the issue of your salvation. i clearly stated the opposite/reverse of what you claim that i said, and i've corrected you on it incase you mistakenly missed it. But it's evident that devils are messing with your comprehension. I SAID IT WAS NOT GOD'S INTENTION OR WILL THAT THE DANA PLANE SHOULD CRASH. You even quoted my saying it, yet you remain blinded. you're an unrepentant liar like your master the devil "God did not want the plane to crash."How do you know the devil is messing with my comprehension? After all, when I wrote my first post on this thread, it was appropriately wondering how you know what you claim to know. My question still remains about how you know that it wasn't God's will that the plane should crash. He could have prevented it from crashing yet he did nothing. Have you asked yourself why? Image123: We don't believe in God so as to avoid plane crashes. We believe in God so that we would not perish with the world and unbelievers, and so that we can be saved from sin and be made ready to live with God for ever.Aren't you believers supposed to get some benefits here on earth based on your beliefs in God? I mean how sure can one be that a God who cannot or rather would not protect his loved ones here on earth will actually be able to provide them with heaven? Image123: i meant in the context of routes as in believing in Jesus as the way/route. there remains no other way. Atheism is no way, unbelief is no way, even religion is no way whatever the religion, Jesus is the way. talking about nice ways to die is at best child's play. Death is simply an exit into eternity. your destination overrides and is of more importance than your 'route'. What's the gain or point of dying a pleasurable death(whatever that means to you), and then going into a damnable eternity in hell?The gain there is that the God you're talking about can provide them with pleasurable deaths here on earth and still send them to heaven. Why should he maliciously torture them? Image123: Typical. Yes, it would, out of respect for the relative, and for human life. but it's not an important decision. We all have our toys and pet desires, but maturity helps to submit them to the bigger scheme/plan. life is vanity, get that.The person is already dead and the person no longer needs it. You see, you're already being inconsistent when you say you wouldn't care about the body. Image123: Hope is a good thing for an atheist to have. you're close.Hope is something that humans generally have. Image123: Who are we? Typical of you to try to divert from the real issues. you know how Peter died, or Jesus, or Stephen? Do you even believe that any of them ever existed? Or you want us to take your little toy on how Paul died and play together?I'm not diverting from issues I'm simply correcting a factually incorrect statement. Why don't you simply accept the correction? Image123: Rom 8:35 Who shall separate us from the love of Christ? shall tribulation, or distress, or persecution, or famine, or unclothedness, or peril, or sword?Was Jesus' faith shaken when he was wondering why God had forsaken him? Was Peter's faith shaken when he denied Jesus? Also, having an unshakeable religious faith isn't the good thing you're trying to portray it to be. Image123: You sure most have spoken with dead people to know these things, or assume this position right? you do not know that life is vanity, that's your problem. You think the exit is so important, and you muse on the fairness and the unfairness of the exit door or 'route'. You should take some percentaage of your musings and thoughts on the destinations, which you currently do not believe in. What if?I don't have to speak to dead people to know that being tortured is painful. People experience pain when they're alive you know. If life is vanity and all that, then why bother going to work? |
joe4christ: [size=15pt] Bunch of fools who thought they knew any better. Bible: Matthew 5:22 |
[quote author=Master_1]. . . . @ the homer, so what started it all!!!!![/quote]All we know for now is that there was a big bang beyond that, I don't know. And I don't know if we could know due to the nature of the concepts involved. [quote author=Master_1]@ thehomer nd logicmind, if such a God exists, u shld be bothered coz unlike d odas gods, he is UNJUST, nd literally doesn't giv a f++k what we think.[/quote]You're referring to a God who just creates the universe and leaves. In such a case, why should I bother with him since he doesn't bother with me? |
Image123: @thehomerHow you know concerns me due to the sorts of pronouncements you're making. Whether or not I believe what you're saying isn't as important as whether or not what you're saying is reasonable. Well, since you know the devil, why don't you tell him to come see me or something? Image123: If you were not such a forgetful person, you would recall that i clearly stated that it wasn't God's will or intention. You even quoted me saying that. no, God did not want the plane to crash. God's will is not often done on earth as it is in Heaven BTW.I know you said it was God's intention. I'm simply wondering how you know that it was actually God's intention and not maybe the devil's intention who is also deceiving you into saying what you're saying. Image123: your solution is late and is not borne out of not knowing God. Believers and religious people also want better regulation here on earth. i've not asked you to call on God, have i? Your unbelief didn't avert the crash, neither did the beliefs of those who died. the point is that you do not have anything better, or unheard of to offer. All you can do is mumble and grumble about a God you don't believe in. You definitely have a stress with those that have an Heaven to get to, i've not mentioned anything like "calling on heaven"(whatever that means). i don't think i said/thought about nice routes to Heaven. i asked you if atheism was a better route. Obviously you don't know the way, nor believe in the journey, so what's up with detracting those who want to go to Heaven like moi? You know i don't have time for waste, going by your history.Since there were those who died believed in God, what is the point of believing in him? Is it going to heaven? If it is, is a plane crash really the best way for God to achieve that? You did speak about routes to heaven. This is what you said: Image123: no, God did not want the plane to crash. God's will is not often done on earth as it is in Heaven BTW.What you said above implies that there are nice routes and not-so-nice routes. Image123: For christians, our perception of the human body is very different from other's perception. The body to us is just like a garment or a house where we temporarily reside. the real you lives forever either in eternal life or in eternal damnation. So the christian is more concerned about resting in peace then in leaving in peace. Resting is forever, in Heaven. Leaving is for one day, one minute or second even. it's so like the world to spend millions on the wedding day, and unable to build a marriage/home. marriage is for life(at least in true Christendom). Wedding is one day or two. i care less what happens to my cloth(body) after i'm through with using it. Whether someone else start using it, or it's burnt up, or used to clean excreta, or dust, or hung in the museum does not matter to me much. i'm through with it. it's same with our bodies. that's why we exhort that people be ready for eternity at all times, ready for departure. How your body is treated at and after, that's child's play at best. Some people want a 'befitting burial', some want memorials and all sort. An exit is an exit. God's beloved Son Jesus exit through crucifixion. peter, paul, Stephen all exited in 'unpleasant' ways. No real christian's faith is shaken because of a plane crash? It's an exit, even if you die at 150years with all your g children surrounding you, it's still just an exit. more important than depart in peace, is resting in peace.Would it bother you if someone decided to copulate with the body of a dead relative? Also, I hope you're going to donate your body to medical science since you really don't care what happens to it after you're dead. Actually, we don't know how Paul died. And the claim that "no real Christian's faith is shaken" due to x simply tends towards a No True Scotsman fallacy because how one reacts to a plane crash has no bearing on whether or not they're Christians. Image123: People would undergo crude things and shame at the hospital to get health. endure insults and smells at the hospital. people would call cow "daddy" at higher institutions to obtain a degree, go through all sort of meniality and trash to hold a job and get promotion. people are ready to trek from nigeria to America if it is legal. But to get to Heaven, you are here arguing literarily on whether the exit door was painted or made of wood. You have real issues with the devil homer.Actually, what I'm wondering is how you know what you claim to know and whether or not a God who cares for his people can make their exit less painful. Comparing the death of people to the colour or finishing on a door to me sounds quite callous. Someone who dies after being tortured and someone who dies in their sleep have quite different experiences as people. |
jmoore: I will leave it for now. You did not understand the previous post, you can't understand another one I will say.Sure you can leave it but I didn't understand it not because the issue is complex, but because what you said is devoid of meaning. |
jmoore: Why will you understand? You don't believe in God.The breath of life from God is a spirit? So the child born 24 hours ago was breathed upon by God? And I don't think babies are formed from "the dust of the ground". Is there such a thing as a dead soul? |
[quote author=Master_1]The only reason I feel there should be a God is simply because contemporary science has failed to provide a reasonable answer to d questn of who created d universe.[/quote]Have you considered that you're asking a badly phrased question? What I mean is that the universe may not have been created by a person or people. [quote author=Master_1]What if there is a God, but not in d common religious sense of the word, what if he isn't perfect, isn't completely just and all dat stuff d religious organizations preach! What if there are errors in his design, what if he isn't all powerful nd can't really defy logic. Then there isn't a God, not the God the religious preach, but there is a God, in d sense of him jst being the creator. More over, what really kickstarted religion was the d need for man to explain d seemingly unexplainable. What are ur tots, atheists??[/quote]With respect to the sort of God you're referring to, I would see no reason to bother myself with such a God. |
cryptic: And so why would some people blame God for errors committed by their fellow men? And the fact that I am a saint don't mean I cannot die a horrible, painful death.If you believe in God and God actually cares, why should he make you die a horrible death? cryptic: My fellow humans did it to me and not God. The big picture that people don't get is this: The world has got a predetermined course. If anyone dies right now, then there must have been a reason why that person died.Who set the predetermined course? If God set the course, why shouldn't he get the blame? There is a reason why e.g George Bush is being blamed for the 2nd Iraq War. cryptic: How they died is of no consequence.Really? Which of these would you prefer; death after 6 days of torture in your thirties or death during sleep in your nineties? cryptic: Maybe people don't really know...Almost everyone in that plane would have died from the shock of the impact before the explosion. So why are people saying that because some of them are born again, they go to church, worship God then God should have averted it... God is not a magician.He moulded people out of clay and breathed into them, did a burning bush special effect, he resurrects people willy-nilly but he isn't a magician. cryptic: Take a look at this: In the next 40 years, most people the age of those people in the crash would have died; besides the children of course. How long is 40 years? I remember when I left high school 12 years ago...It is just like yesterday.But, most people who can afford a plane ticket in Nigeria don't die at the prevailing death rate. 40 years is a long time though he fact that someone will be dead in 40 years doesn't make it okay for them to die in a plane crash today. cryptic: Death is inevitable. How it comes, where it comes and when is entirely dependent on the choices you and those around you make. They say don't smoke...You smoke...we all know the consequences of that....Don't drink excessively...You become an alcoholic...there is a consequence...The world is like a pre-programmed computer: The input determines the output. There are laws and you have to abide by them...What did Jesus Christ tell the devil when the devil asked him to jump from the mountains? If Jesus Christ obeyed the laws of the Universe then who are we mortal men?Actually, based on your idea of predetermination, someone who smokes cannot help themselves since it is pre-programmed. Also, which Bible did you read that tells you that Jesus obeyed the laws of the universe? Was it the Jefferson Bible or the canonical one? The guy defied the principle of buoyancy, he even performed a nuclear reaction turning water to wine and some serious lich activities by coming back from the dead with magic powers. Is it the same Jesus that we're talking about? |
Logic Mind: hehehehehe ![]() Time will tell. |
cryptic: You are a complete idi.ot. was it your retar.ded father that created the first cell? Of course we all know that all cells are made up of organelles that perform specialized functions. The question is simple id!ot. Should I break it down? Heard of the last universal common ancestor (LUCA), or the cenancestor? Was it some spontaneous chemical reaction that brought about it due to the conditions of the environment in the primordial earth? Why haven't we had a similar occurrence in some other planet?Do you really want to start this discussion with such abusive language? I could do that too but I'll just let this one go because it may be that your God has touched you somewhere. You are raising several issues here that you don't seem to understand. To help you along, simply answer these questions. 1. Was there a time when there were no cells on earth? 2. How does the concept of the last universal common ancestor help whatever point you're trying to make? 3. Do you understand how big the Milky Way galaxy is? (I ask because your question on a similar occurrence on some other planet is simply naive especially when one realizes that humans know relatively little of the planetary bodies closest to the earth.) cryptic: One of the idiots? Newton's Law dont do what?Newton's laws don't work at the sub-atomic level. An entirely different branch of physics takes care of that. See [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newton%27s_laws#Importance_and_range_of_validity]this paragraph[/url] of a relevant article for its limitations. cryptic: We all know that the universe is a closed system of random particles that travel with varying energy intensities. quantum mechanics provides a mathematical description of much of the dual particle-like and wave-like behavior and interactions of energy and matter. Experiments have shown that the world began with a single quantum,What is this "single quantum" that you're talking about? cryptic: the notions of space and time would altogether fail to have any meaning at the beginning;If they fail to have any meaning, then how do you wish to apply Newton's laws? cryptic: they would only begin to have a sensible meaning when the original quantum had been divided into a sufficient number of quanta like all of the quanta that abounds on earth. The force that brought about the first quantum obviously would not have been another quantum. Debunk this...I am waiting.It looks as though you don't understand what physicists mean when they use the word "quantum". Asking me do debunk your pet idea is simply an attempt to shift the burden of proof. The onus is on you to show that what you're saying is true. Also, I cannot debunk it because what you've said is devoid of meaning. Edit: Closed bracket. |
Image123: abegi, leave me and my God with some privacy, na everything you wan know. since it doesn't make you happy, don't bother.My question is how do you know what you're claiming? I really have to bother because if this same God tells you to go out and kill three children he picked out, with the sorts of justifications you're ready to present, you probably would do that. Image123: Unbelievers presence in the plane did not stop it from crashing. So no unbeliver should come on this thread with some air of superiority. Believers presence, or relative of believer's presence did not stop the crash, neither did unbelivers.So should believers now come out and say it was actually God's intention? Image123: You don't have a solution neither do you have an Heaven to go, so what's your stress with those that have an Heaven to get to? It is not the tar quality of the road to Heaven that matters most to us, but Heaven itself. you don't believe in Heaven, yet you're arguing on the best route, mind your business lady.Actually, I do have a solution which is better regulation here on earth. It is something that we humans can do without calling on God. I don't have a stress with those calling on heaven neither am I arguing on the best route. You were the one who thought death in a plane crash was a nice route to heaven. I simply disagree that even if there was a heaven, death in a plane crash isn't really a good way there. |
Logic Mind: you are wasting your time with himWell, we may yet be able to learn from each other. |
I find this idea of a trinity to be virtually meaningless. What is a spirit and what is a soul? What is the difference between them? |
cryptic: 1. Heard of the theory of biogenesis? That states that nothing that's alive came from anything that is inanimate? So where did the first cell come from? Has a protocel been synthesized from inanimate organic substances?I don't think this idea really helps you because at some point in time, there wouldn't have been cells on earth. Even if you wish to claim that your God created the cells, he would have used inanimate matter. cryptic: 2. You give me the big ba.ng theory...I wanna ask this: there is a law of motion that states that an object will continue to be in a state of rest or of uniform motion unless an external force acts on it...so what brought about the force that initiated the big ba.ng?Newton's laws don't work at the atomic and sub-atomic levels so it is actually quantum physics that dominates there and not mechanics so you're basically asking a wrong question. |
Image123: God told me, happy now?This isn't about my happiness, it is about how you've come to know what you're claiming to know. Since God told you this, did he give you a reason? Or was it actually your devil talking to you? Image123: Did i mention that the presence of any one prevented God from stopping a plane crash? Do you think atheism is a "better" way to heaven?No, you said unbelievers didn't stop the plane from crashing. I was simply wondering whether you expected them to otherwise, the statement would have been pointless. Actually, atheists don't think there is a heaven. You Christians that think there is a heaven and that dying in a plane crash is a nice way to get there have a question to answer. |
[quote author=Missy_B]. . . . Suzie is a good kid and she ought to get a pat on the back. But, the point of that video is?. . . .[/quote]The point is to show you the sort of magical thinking you espouse. |
babestella: Airlines should run brand new aircraft, this is human lives we are talking about. If they don't have enough money for brand new, then let FG invest in them so they can be able to buy brand new aircraft, spread repayment over a period of time. This is gross, that we even have aircraft that has lived for more than 40 years still flying our airspace and we say we have a minister of aviation, and a director generalWill you buy it for them? Do you only drive brand new cars? And do you understand that in fact, with proper maintenance, servicing and inspection the planes would be in a good condition? There is a speculation that the engines had a problem. If that were true, would you expect the entire aircraft to be discarded because he engines have a problem? Would you discard a car because its engine or tires had a problem? |
[quote author=Missy_B]Nothing happens without God's permission. . .Not even this plane crash. If he permits it, it's for a reason; always a positive reason for His children. The only thing is, we usually do not see things from God's perspective. . .What we deem trouble/disaster may not necessarily be so in God's eyes. I read of a girl who was supposed to board that plane but missed it because she fell asleep . . .That, too, is for a reason. Believers believe nothing happens by chance, accident or luck. . .God makes the choice. Likewise.[/quote]I think this video appropriately describes the mindset you're displaying. <object width="640" height="360"><param name="movie" value=" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vM5n8jESUEk?version=3&hl=en_US"></param></object> |
[quote author=Busy_body]Forget all those cowardly tribalistic trash you see these so-called igbo/yoruba e-warriors spewing online, it does not happen in the real world. They live side by side and intermingle freely. Its only intertribal marriages that makes people's hair stand on end. But we have none of those honour killings which is rife amongst these Asians.[/quote]It doesn't happen in the real world? Would you like articles such as this and this. Why should inter-tribal marriages make people agitated? Could it be because they don't think the other tribe is as good as theirs? What does honour killing have to do with communal clashes? But don't think it doesn't happen in Nigeria too because killing a woman for sex outside of marriage is also a form of honour killing. [quote author=Busy_body]Moreover, you cannot compare those sporadic and retaliatory clashes to something ingrained into people's psyche via a rigid inherited social status.[/quote]Why not? Have you also forgotten that in Nigeria, the caste system has also been practiced just as in many other parts of the world? You can see here for more information. |
Image123: no, God did not want the plane to crash. God's will is not often done on earth as it is in Heaven BTW.How do you know God didn't want the plane to crash? Did he tell you? Does the presence of unbelievers or relatives of unbelievers prevent God from stopping a plane crash? Do you think dying in a plane crash is a "better" way to Heaven? |
ibadan1: Are you serious what planet do you live on, these people have carried out a catalogue of atrocities towards Nigerians, how many safety violations in the industries they control have maimed Nigerians and how many have they then dismissed with no compensation, ask any person who has worked in an Indian manufacturing company in Nigeria. Our complex knows no boundsFactories are a common source of work related injuries. Well, how many have been dismissed without compensation? Do you have an answer? Then also find out why they didn't approach any union or lawyers to take up their cause. |
hernyhorla: I agree with you.all these still drill down to corruption in the country.this makes the indians cheat nigerians cos our authority won't stand for usIf your authorities don't stand for you, then why don't you make them stand for you? Are you expecting the Indians to do that for you? |
[quote author=Busy_body]Nigeria did not entrust nada, Nigeria has sold most of the Country's infrastructure to mainly the Indians and they are here to stay. And if they treat their own darker-skinned country people as castes and as subhumans worse than animals, what respect do you expect them to have for their Nigerian employees who are darker than their own castes [/quote]Just how well do you Nigerians treat other Nigerians from other tribes? Have you so quickly forgotten the communal clashes? |
alexleo: If as an atheists you were in the crashed Dana plane, while christians and muslims are crying and praying before the crash would u have prayed? If yes, to who? if no, what would you have done?These sorts of questions are the ones that sometimes get me annoyed especially shortly after such a dramatic accident. What do you think? What was the outcome of the prayers of the Christians' and Muslims' prayers? Would they not have been better off probably speaking with their loved ones? Or just sitting there peacefully? |
AlvinPlantinga: I mean a very real freedom of the will and not just an APPARENT or Illusory type of free will.Okay. Would this be a freedom of choice of action but not necessarily the outcome? AlvinPlantinga: We have been through this since the beginning of our discussion and i will refer you back to our previous discussion of my views on Free will in heaven and the Fall.Please see my previous post on why your response on this so far hasn't been satisfactory. AlvinPlantinga: ok.But this is the contention, Given Libertarian Free will, devoid of any Determinism,why is the Free Will Defense inadequate.I think my examples show this. AlvinPlantinga: As i had stated earlier, for the free will defense to fail, you are supposed to show that a world with free human agents who do not CHOSE to commit evil is actualizable by God.No, in that world, they learn very early on to perform only good actions since they're ten physically and mentally healthy people who have learned to perform these acts based on the God's rewards and punishments. Their choices aren't limited just that they've learned to do the right things. AlvinPlantinga: But furthermore, such a concept itself is self deafeating since, people who are only able to chose good cannot be said to be truly Morally responsible.They could not have done otherwise.Its like praising the coffee machine for making you coffee.That is what it always does.Mother Teresa was hailed as a Morally responble person for her works on poor and sick people.Her Moral actions were deemed as good.She received Moral Praise.She could have chosen not to do what she did.She was not compelled to give and treat the sick.Sure they won't be praised for the outcomes of what they do and I don't see why the praise would be important. The question is whether God can create such a world. Also keep in mind that, they actually could do evil but because they're physically and mentally healthy people on a nice and very hospitable planet who have learned right and wrong from God himself, they see no reason why they should do these evil acts. AlvinPlantinga: Mmh, interesting suggestion i must say.Again, he isn't interfering with their free-will, just the outcomes of their choices. If you decide to verbally abuse someone but the person leaves because they received an important phone call, has anyone's free-will been tampered with? Note that the option of not verbally abusing them is still well within your power. If you want to throw a stone at someone, a bird or bat could fly between the stone and the person thus preserving free-will. Again, no one's free-will has been tampered with. AlvinPlantinga: Extrapolate this to 5 billion people, and potentially millions or billions of moral decisions to be made every minute every day for thousands of years. Imagine that 5 billion people once in their life, chose a moraly wrong decision,God must somehow bring about Free-Will-Preserving non interventionist actions that will physically prevent these people from following through on their acts .This is just one moral decision, we make possibly tens of moral decisions daily.He is omnipotent and omniscient so these numbers mean nothing to him just as long as it isn't logically impossible. AlvinPlantinga: Even if somehow it was possible (not feasible),Given our physical world, it would be a bizarre world where randomness would be the order of the day.Things would happen for no apparent reason.It would soon dawn on people that the free will they possess is really not Free since no evil actions could be actualized.This would again fall into the problems highlighted above.Problems of moral responsibility, obligations and praise.No, the reasons may not be apparent to the people but this God is actually good. The key word there being "apparent". What do moral responsibility, obligations or praise have to do with anything? These are physically and mentally healthy people. It isn't as though they wake up each morning looking for ways to commit evil. AlvinPlantinga: It would bring into question why God would create such a world in the first place.Whatever reason it could be, he at least cares about the people in that world which is what it means to be omnibeneficent. AlvinPlantinga: read previous posts on free will in heaven.Read and responded to. AlvinPlantinga: The Free will defense does not deal with natural evil. but my other defense, God having Morally Sufficient reasons for allowing evil could cover natural disasters.Furthermore, given the physical nature of our universe, natural disasters are bound to happen.earthquakes are a result of shifting of plate tectonics,weather changes are the property of having a dynamic atmosphere and oceans.therefore the only way, natural disasters can be prevented is by God not creating a physical universe bound by laws of physics.No the morally sufficient reasons response doesn't work because it implies that God has picked his favourites. I mean, certain natural disasters cluster in certain places. He could have reduced the severity of earthquakes and weather changes or is it logically impossible for him to do what he's done in the past? He could stop plagues and other such pestilences but he doesn't. Would heaven and a the new earth be non-physical worlds? |
AlvinPlantinga: I must apologise for the Long absence.I work 8-5 and by the time i reach home,spend time with family, watch TV etc i am too tired to do anything else.In other words, you're defining this God as being good aren't you? (I know it is a given for the problem of evil but it isn't for the Christian God so we are talking about two different Gods here.) AlvinPlantinga: As to how i know such a God is good?then i would point out to you that that is a problem of Moral Epistemoloy and Ontology.Moral argument and Anselm's Ontological argument are good points of discussion on that argument.Nevertheless, that is a different discussion as i have pointed out to you numerous times.To cut this short, how do you know the God of the Bible is good? Since that is the God we're talking about. AlvinPlantinga: And again, even the argument you are proposing is still invalid.Since it does not follow that the lack of knowledge of reasons for God allowing so much evil equals to us being unable to to know whether he's actually good.Oh? If we do not know why he allows evil, how then can we actually know that he is good and not actually evil or indifferent? AlvinPlantinga: I might also point out that some of God's reasons for allowing evil are not soo mysterious.Preservation of Free Will, Development of Good moral virtues such as Courage,humility, forgiveness , compassion and a closer personal relationship with God could all be Morally Sufficient reasons for allowing evil.Those so-called reasons are bad reasons. A God that feels preserving the free-will of a torturing paedophile is better than preserving the free-will of a child is not good. A God that feels that the best way to inspire courage, humility and the other virtues is by permitting plagues and natural disasters to befall others should be sacked. AlvinPlantinga: Point taken.But remember you task is to show that God and evil are logically incompatible and not merely questionable.This is what was given at the beginning of this thread. . God is omnipotent, omniscient, and perfectly good. . A perfectly good being would want to prevent all evils. . An omniscient being knows every way in which evils can come into existence. . An omnipotent being, who knows every way in which an evil can come into existence, has the power to prevent that evil from coming into existence. . A being who knows every way in which an evil can come into existence, who is able to prevent that evil from coming into existence, and who wants to do so, would prevent the existence of that evil. . If there exists an omnipotent, omniscient, and perfectly good being, then no evil exists. . Evil exists (logical contradiction). So far, you've proposed libertarian free-will as being your method of solving this problem but as has been said already, it doesn't address natural evils like natural disasters and pandemics. AlvinPlantinga: And this is what i have pointed out to you is an invalid argument.Can you show how it is invalid? AlvinPlantinga: I will take it that you do not have any justification for this assertion.The justification is in the meanings of the words. When one refers to another person as being benevolent, what do you think it means? I ask because the definition I'm using is the second one here. AlvinPlantinga: I am still waiting to see the logical inconsitency between the existence evil and god.See above. AlvinPlantinga: And as i have pointed out several times, i do not hold the view that there is Free Will in heaven due to God's overwhelming presence.So i find your question rather misconceived as it is basically asking why didn't God just NOT create earth?Yes you've said that but you didn't clarify on how his presence would prevent people from performing evil acts if it didn't prevent angels who were there with him. It also raises a question on whether this heaven is all that good since people don't have any free will there. AlvinPlantinga: But more importantly, you have still not shown the logical inconsistency between God and evil.Merely asking WHY questions does nothing to advancing the Problem Of Evil.(especially the logical version espoused here).See above. |
OLAADEGBU: Did you read what Enigma has just quoted?What he said is simply more straw-men. Just take the time to read what is at this link. They are Jefferson's own words and ideas in context. A simple way to test this is by asking yourself if such activities would be acceptable if done by wiccans. OLAADEGBU: Your "good reasons" for believing is based on what you see, do you know about optical illusions? We surely can believe in a lot of things that we cannot visibly see. Have you ever seen the wind, have you seen history? or have you seen your brain? I know we can see the effects of the wind which is invisible. It is by faith that I can believe the records of history, that those historical events actually happened since I was not there. Television waves can be detected with a receiver even though we don't see it with our naked eyes. Your dead spirit needs to be made alive to so as to be aware of the spiritual realm and be able to tap into it.You are committing the fallacy of ambiguity here. There are various meanings of the word faith and you're conflating them. Please see this link and tell me the particular definition you're using above. OLAADEGBU: Most of the constitutions of the developed countries today was based on the Bible, the United Kingdom for instance. Go read the constitution of the U.S. and give me a feedback.This is an example of the genetic fallacy. The fact that Christianity used to be prevalent in e.g the U.K doesn't mean that the content of their current laws are based on it. Especially when we know that some of their laws are actually contrary to the Bible. So, why don't you read through the U.S constitution and tell me the laws that are derived exclusively from the Bible. OLAADEGBU: The Bible has answers to foundational questions, such as the ultimate cause of the universe, the origin of life and information which the evolution theory has no clue about. You just believe all those conjectures and claim it to be science when it is only fantasy of the fertile mind.Is Christianity a religion? And are biologists scientists? The answers you give to these questions will really help you respond understand the issues. |
OLAADEGBU: This is why you need to understand the concept of the constitution that enigma is lecturing you about, you don't seem to be getting it, that the so called Separation of Church and State is a myth that has no basis in the constitution but what the Secular humanists are using to attack Christianity and the Bible.I understand the concept but both of you obviously do not. How can it be a myth when courts in the U.S have used that as a basis for many rulings? OLAADEGBU: When I say faith I mean the substance of things hoped for and the evidence of things not seen. You practise this kind of faith when you sit down as you don't check to see whether the seat/chair has the strength or capacity to bear your weight and if you do everytime you sit in a bus or a plane then you need help.No I don't because I have good reasons based on evidence for thinking that the chair can support my weight but the faith you're talking about if often based on poor evidence or against the available evidence e.g that only praying for someone with HIV will cure them. OLAADEGBU: Our faith rests on the solid foundation of the Word of God which has been tried and tested on the past and it proves true in the present. We also have confidence of its claim in the future and the Bible is what the American's constitution was founded on which you Secular humanists with the help of some deluded "Christians" are trying to pull down.Are you willing to test it again today? The American constitution wasn't founded on the Bible. Or have you seen any references to Jesus or the Holy Spirit? OLAADEGBU: The theory of evolution has been fraudulently and erroneously taught as science when it provent that it has no foundation to rest on. It has no answer to foundational questions and thus qualifies as a religion of the atheists, pagans and comprising "Christians". This is what is called blind faith. If you want to know how science confirms the Bible you need to check out the thread where this was addressed.Are you saying that if a scientific theory has no answer to "foundational questions" (whatever that means), then it is a religion? Do you think Christianity is a religion? Does the Bible confirm the theory of evolution? |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 96 97 98 99 100 101 102 103 104 (of 210 pages)

But, the point of that video is?
??