Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 9:00pm On Oct 04, 2010 |
Enigma: Well, it seems to me you are indeed making a critique of Christianity and I believe that it is fair to say that the modus operandi is as I mentioned. It might look that way to you but you need to realize that you chose the field to which you wished to apply some for of intellectualism. This is also why I ask questions to find out where you stand on some issues. Enigma: 1. Most of the entire chapter is about promises and rewards; a very small part of it is about threats. 2. As I said before, appeal to the intellect and a threat of punishment (and even a promise of reward) are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Example: father says to seven year old son, do not play with the iron; it is dangerous, it can injure you; plus, if you do it I will smack you and if you don't do it I will give you chocolates. Threatening someone with punishment is not appealing to their intellect it is appealing to their emotions. Enigma: As I keep saying, the point at issue is whether Christianity teaches that a person should not take conventional medicine; it does not thus you need to reappraise your understanding of the 'mustard seed' passage. Then can you explain your understanding of the passage since I've presented mine. It also seems curious to me that if one has such a large faith (say the size of a mustard seed), why would they decide to rely on conventional medicine? Enigma: It is outside of science because it does not account to science for its truth, reliability or believability. What does it depend on? And how does this dependence demonstrate intellectualism? Enigma: Then let scientists continue with their own jobs/tasks. I have put in enough work to satisfy me and I do not ask you or any scientist to accept what I believe. I am very happy for you to doubt it. But, if you wish to label whatever you've done as some form of intellectualism, you need to show your workings. Enigma: So, based on various things that we do know, we accept the virgin birth. Such as? Enigma: My point is that reasoning is a valid intellectual exercise in its own right and it is one of the things that inform my acceptance of Christianity. Of course reasoning is valid. But, if you wish to label what you're doing as some form of intellectualism, you would need to avoid the pitfalls that have already been previously identified. Enigma: This was about the punishments in the Bible (presumably the Old Testament); as I said before, if you have a proper understanding of Christianity and Christian doctrine, the question will not arise. Read for example what Christ said about a lot of these things 'you have heard x but I tell you. . .' But he also said he did not come to abolish the previous laws so those laws were still in effect. Enigma: Christians, like others, are entitled to have political opinions. Sorry, if I do not proffer my opinion here beyond saying I do not seek a theocracy. Ok. Is there a reason why you do not seek a theocracy? Enigma: I do not think it can be reasonably denied that there are misrepresentations and caricatures of Christianity. The fact, for example, that some fools seek to use Christianity to justify apartheid, slavery or bestiality etc does not mean that Christianity or true Christian doctrine supports any of these things. How do you differentiate? Again you need to show how you arrived at this conclusion. How can a non-Christian or even a Christian of a different sect decide which is the true form of Christianity? Enigma: Again, it does not matter much to me whether people consider me an "intellectual"; I know what I know; I realise how much I do not know and indeed I am humbled by how much I do not know. Paradoxically, this even encourages my Christian faith. Don't get me wrong I've not said or implied that you're not an intellectual. It's simply that when it comes to your religious belief, you may wish to skip such a label when describing it. Enigma: My faith is supported by both reason and a personal experience of God; both of these are sufficiently "intellectual" in my view.
 But they alone do not merit the use of the term "intellectual". You could have simply left it as your "religious faith" rather than trying to add the word "intellectual", which already has some meanings ascribed to it, to your reasons for believing what you believe. |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 3:57pm On Oct 04, 2010 |
Enigma: For a start you are misrepresenting the passage and I'm afraid this is a very poor modus operandi which, sadly, is evident throughout your critique of Christianity. OK let me indulge with what you asked on this point in the first place i.e. what does the rest of the verse actually say? I'm not interested in critiquing Christianity but simply pointing out your inconsistencies if you wish to subject your particular views of it to some sort of intellectualism. Enigma: "Come now, and let us reason together, saith the LORD: though your sins be as scarlet, they shall be as white as snow; though they be red like crimson, they shall be as wool.
Do you see how the verse itself readily gives the lie to your interpretation? And the rest of the chapter is in the same tenor - which is why I asked you to read the chapter! Did you not read the following verses about God describing himself and the threats that may follow if they rebel? Enigma: Glad not to have to spend any further time on this digression! The issue here is whether the Christian faith teaches that people should not use conventional medicine. That is the issue. Now, don't take my word for an answer on the issue ---- go and study the Bible on the point and reach your own conclusion on what the Bible teaches on the point. I already presented the example of the faith of the mustard seed or is that not in your Bible? Though I understand that some choose to ignore such statements. Enigma: Because you are trying to take back into science something which I claim to be outside science, simples. You think science is all, I do not think science is all. Why do you claim it is outside of science considering the other possibilities that we know of? Enigma: Nah, I claim that I believe that one woman (Mary) gave birth to one offspring (Jesus) without fertilization. Yes, it is a physical occurrence from a scientific point of view and I leave it to science to keep working on how it could have happened; maybe in a thousand years' time they will come up with a plausible theory; in the meantime, I believe it anyway. It is not the job of scientists to try to justify all claims that may be present in old texts. If you believe so strongly that your hypothesis is correct, then you should put in the required work if you want others to accept it as correct. Enigma: Funny some scientists can assume the truth of something when it suits them even though they have no proof yet; many will tell you there must be aliens out there ---- they will still claim that to be an intellectual proposition. But how is such a proposition different from faith based on reason? You're making another mistake here. What they say is that it is possible that there could be extraterrestrial organisms out there. This conclusion is arrived at based on the fact that we know that there are organisms on one planet, and that there are billions of galaxies out there. But they do not go about living their lives as though they may just run into one of them tomorrow. Enigma: So reasoning is now not "intellectual"? Only science is "intellectual"? Tell that to Plato, Socrates, Kant etc. How have I implied this? Using circular arguments to demonstrate your point is simply an anti-intellectual method of proceeding. Enigma: Again, if intelligent reasoning is not "intellectual" for you, good luck! Again, using circular arguments is anti-intellectual. Enigma: I find this unfortunate. Again, it demonstrates what I have been talking about ----- you need to go and read and understand the Bible first! That way, you really would not ask this type of question! I'm simply wondering what your views are. Since it seems that after reading the Bible, my understanding is different from yours. So I simply want to find out your understanding. Enigma: Christians can legitimately express a view on how to run the government: we can say we prefer a democracy; we can say we do not want corruption; we can say we want the rule of law etc etc etc In fact, a lot of these fundamental principles were introduced by Christians and informed by Christianity. I know Christians have opinions so I'm asking for your opinion. Enigma: However, Christians are not advocating a theocracy! To suggest otherwise would be another caricature/straw man! It would not be a straw-man because we have seen such requests made using passages from the Bible. Unless you wish to label such Christians as caricatures". Enigma: I don't think I care to be considered an "intellectual" in the way that you want. However, I do know that my faith is indeed intellectual. I also know that Christianity is intellectual and even beyond that; it is supra-intellectual. Again it's not what I want but what comes with the use of such a label. I wonder how it is that you know your faith is intellectual while it seems to demonstrate the very opposite. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 3:27pm On Oct 04, 2010 |
nuclearboy: @thehomer:
I wish one of you would have the nerve to try these warped arguments against the veracity of the spiritual with people who are not mainstream christians yet know their onions. How are the arguments I've presented warped? nuclearboy: There's one here on NL - Mad_Max.
https://www.nairaland.com/nigeria/topic-436863.288.html#msg6872384 from which I quote - I merely check science now and then to see how well it's coming along. That's why people who claim there's no God from 'science' are a real hoot. Understandable, but a hoot nevertheless. When it comes to the spiritual, science is far behind. Unquote
Do me a favor and match your "knowledge" of science against her on that thread. But the problem you guys have is Christianity so I wager you'll find a way out of such a dare.
. . . I'm not ready to put in the required effort in joining that thread. It's progressed quite a bit. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 3:20pm On Oct 04, 2010 |
vescucci: Enigma. Thank you for being so objective. That is a rare commodity.
Nuclearboy and Thehomer don't understand each other. What Nuke is saying is that not everything that science cannot prove NOW is false. It may be shown to be perfectly possible later. What thehomer is saying is what we can't prove NOW is likely not true and why should we take some dude's 2000 year old word for it anyway. Trouble is thehomer is absolutist since he's probably not religious and Nuclearboy is absolutist (as per the Christian faith) because he's a Christian. To me both stances make some sense but the atheist standpoint is superior because a Muslim will be equally faithful and also a Hindu and all others. If as Enigma wishes we treat Christianity specially, thehomer would be right to ask why. The Bible and the Quran and all other 'holy' are essentially nothing above Shakespearan literature as far as non-believers are concerned. That's why I refuse to separate Christianity from the broad brush of religion for this would be special pleading. . . . An incisive paragraph. But I am not absolutist in any way. I have simply decided to go where the evidence leads. So, if I'm going to make some conclusions, there must be good evidence behind it. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 12:47pm On Oct 04, 2010 |
nuclearboy: "Truth" is that there are 2 sides to this divide.
One side [AA] says here is why, when, what.
The other [ZZ] says NO, it cannot be, BASED on what we can observe, study, see
Then [AA] says - "look, this is easy. One thousand years ago, you guys couldn't see Parthenogenesis and thus said it was impossible. And you expected ALL to believe. That position is TODAY false. Today you say this issue is impossible. How do you know that it will not be resolved into your understanding in another 1000 years"
But [ZZ] insists - "We are right because we don't see it"
[AA] - "no wahala. You truly haven't seen it. YET!"
Truth then for me is that, your position is not planted on solid ground. It shifts based on "advancements", which are in turn based on "findings", which are in turn, based on time! Christians cannot shift goalposts and thus, you appear informed because of "doubt" rather than knowledge. Are you implying that what you have taken to be true, which in this context is the words contained in the Bible, are planted on solid ground and do not progress or change? If you are, my question is how did you arrive at this conclusion? Do you consider the method by which you arrived at this conclusion to be an intellectual manner? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 11:44am On Oct 04, 2010 |
Enigma: 1. Please read the whole chapter again and particularly verses 1-17 and you will see a constant appeal to the thinking faculty , to the intellect.
2. In any event, the giving of commands/instructions and reasoning together are not necessarily mutually exclusive. They are in this case since it is "obey my commands or I will punish you". Enigma: I'm sorry this is now off-point. If you have issues with the Christian lobby, please take it up with them. The activities of the Christian lobby stem from similar reasoning as Christians display but since you wish to keep that aside, that's fine. Enigma: It is a straw man because the Christian faith does not teach that a person should not take conventional medicine --- hence my reference to Christian doctors. This is such an obvious matter that I actually resent having to answer this point in the first place. And you bring up another question with such a statement. Who then is practicing the real form of Christianity? Is it the person with the mustard seed type of faith that can move mountains or the one with selective faith? Enigma: I repeat that it is a fallacy to assume that Christianity must conform with science. Now, no matter the "classification" which one gives the fallacy, the critical matter is that the assumption is a fallacy. See e.g. the quote of Lord Rees in my immediately preceding post. I'm not asking for a classification of the fallacy but I'm wondering how it is fallacious to request for a mechanism by which your claimed virgin birth may occur. Enigma: This relates to a specific question about the virgin birth: we do not challenge science's claim about normal conception/birth by a woman; if we were challenging that, maybe you'd have a case; we say we believe that Jesus' virgin birth is outside that; yet, you keep demanding a comparison to science! But it is a challenge. You are claiming that female humans have given birth to male offspring without fertilization from a man. Attempting to put such a clearly physical occurrence beyond the realm of science is not a solution to the problem. Enigma: Oh yes, I do! It was a deliberately provocative statement: provocative in two senses i.e. provoking the interlocutor to further thought as well as a minor irritation. I believe because I have faith; I have faith because I have reason (i.e. intellectual basis) to have faith. Again, I will keep it this cryptic to still remain mildly provocative. I don't find it provocative I'm simply pointing out that by making such a statement with such a poor backup, you are simply demonstrating the anti-intellectualism that you're trying to avoid. Enigma: So are you going to force a choice or force a person to choose? Is that intellectual? A person says irrespective of whether you take all of the Bible literally or allegorically, he has enough reason to subscribe to Christianity ---- yet you say he must choose? He must operate on your own terms? Maybe you do not understand let alone appreciate his reasons for his faith? You're getting things mixed up. I'm not forcing anyone to choose. I'm simply pointing out that, if you wish to present your views as not being anti-intellectual, then you have to first have to understand what being an intellectual is about. Enigma: As a Christian, I know that the Bible is authoritative on Christian living. Is it? Can you be considered a good Christian if you do not carry out or support the punishments for crimes listed in it? Enigma: I'm sorry this is another of those pretty obvious things; please read the "render unto Caesar" refrerence from the Bible. Here I'm asking for your opinion on what would be the best way to run the government not what to do with the current system so the rendering reference is not relevant. Enigma: For a start, as long as you expect my faith to prove itself to science, then you do not truly understand my faith. My faith is indeed intellectual because it is grounded in part but not only on reason i.e. the intellect ---- however, this reason is informed and conditioned by something far greater than scientific proof or the "scientific method" ---- personal experience of God. You see you're still claiming the label "intellectual" for your faith. If you actually wish to be considered intellectual, you need to realize that while personal experience is important, it is not as important as the proper use of logic, critical inquiry and similar processes. Enigma: Ah, there you go! Current knowledge --- is that the be-all and end-all? It should rank highly if you wish to be considered intellectual. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 7:57am On Oct 04, 2010 |
nuclearboy: @thehomer:
This has gone past the realms of truth and entered the realms of "I have made up my mind to disagree". But that is fine by me.
If the statement in my penultimate post about considering the lessons of the past flew by you without any impact or lessons learned, no problem. I remain commited to truth, not conjecture, not argument, not sturbbonness. I guess it seems "hype" to not back down at some levels. Not where I stand. Readers can make their own deductions on what is true and what is "evidenced" from the conversation.
. . .
Enjoy your week. All right then. But I was simply pointing out that the two situations are not comparable. I also wonder what you mean by "remaining committed to truth". But, since you've made up your mind to disagree, that's fine by me. Enjoy your week too. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 7:50am On Oct 04, 2010 |
Enigma: If you have an inerpretation of the verse, let's have it. I think it's about one person giving commands and instructions to be obeyed by another. Enigma: The thread is concerned with the Christian faith; it is not concerned with political activists even though it is actually normal for different interest groups (e.g. environment lobby, gay lobby etc etc) to seek to influence public policy. Are you about to claim that the Christian lobby does not try to influence public policy? Enigma: Typical caricature come straw man ---- otherwise how does one then explain the millions of Christian doctors world wide including our very own aletheia? How come several Christians on this forum constantly challenge faith healers and so-called "healing ministers"? In fact there are still a number of threads on this --- one of them near the top. Please explain why you think it's a straw man. I already mentioned how some may simply choose not to critically review their previously held religious beliefs. Enigma: In the first place "the scientific method" (if we mean the same thing) is not a necessary part of my Christian faith. I believe it is a fallacy to assume Christianity must conform with science or perhaps even vice versa. What sort of fallacy is it? Enigma: The same fallacy of assumption! You forget that I first acknowledged the scientifically recognised method of conception --- yet I believe in the virgin birth. How is it a fallacy of assumption? Enigma: Because I believe; because I have faith. If that is not enough for anyone, tough! This is circular reasoning. Do you wish to consider this an intellectual response? Enigma: It does not matter; whichever option you choose does not make a difference to my Christian faith. I'm not the one choosing. It's whoever wishes to consider their religious belief on an intellectual level that has to decide. Enigma: The Bible is authoritative on matters of the Christian faith and life/living as a Christian. But I say it is not authoritative on living as a Christian. Enigma: Another caricature come straw man; 'render unto Caesar' and all that. How is it a caricature or straw man? Enigma: The worst you can say is that these things are not true based on your knowledge of science? Well, it still makes no difference to my Christian faith. If your faith is as I understand faith to be, nothing would make a difference to it. So why would you wish to consider such a stance as being an intellectual one? Enigma: And we Christians are continually grappling with them and trying to improve our understanding of these matters. We recognise that we look through "a glass darkly" but we are convinced and happy that one day we will know all these things. Are you actually trying to understand them or are you trying to force current knowledge to fit your preconceived notions of what it's supposed to be based on old texts? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 7:28am On Oct 04, 2010 |
vescucci: You guys have spiralled out of control with your arguments. I do not think this is what Enigma meant to begin with. We're not talking (at least, not I) about occurrences that have no scientific explanations now as if there would be a scientific explanation later. You can't approach the issue of the soul with any kind of science because that's supposed to be on another plane. Jesus' birth is not a mechanism but a specific act. You can't liken that to technology. It just reminds me of the Noah thread. The thing is supposed to be a miracle. Or a grand meteorological event. But it can't simply be both. Science and miracles are immiscible. Miracles defy science and are not compatible with it; that's why they are called miracles. There's no point looking for a common ground.
Belief and faith are not straight forward things. Any miraculous event that can be easily explained by science ceases to be a miracle. There is no need to feel it is wrong to accept that faith is anti-intellectual. It simply is. Even laws that govern our known universe can not really be universal in the truest sense of the word. Different planes have different laws. Religion should keep its nose out of science and Science should keep its nose out of religion. QED.
Oga Nuke! How are you feeling? Much better I hope. There you've said it. But as we can see, religion cannot keep its nose out of science neither can science keep its nose out of religion. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 7:21am On Oct 04, 2010 |
I thought I already answered this. Ok to make things a bit clearer, nuclearboy: ^^^ I know you understand the above posers I put before you.
[1] I am using parthenogenesis as a poster child for "impossibility" or whatever you wish to say is not possible. Based on that, [2] 1000 years ago, parthenogenesis was a lie. Yet there was science Obviously, based on what we know now, it should not be considered a lie. But, if someone proposed it without having studied and understood the process, it would not be intellectually satisfying to accept it simply because someone has proposed it. nuclearboy: [3] Today it is true because science has advanced [4] Tomorrow, we assume science will keep advancing [5] 1000 years from now, prove that "science" would not have advanced to the point where it "understands" the virgin birth. The point is this why would any one today accept such a claim made thousands of years ago with little evidence today to back it up? nuclearboy: I ask [5] of you on the premise that the same science that discounts the "virgin" birth today as a lie also refused to accept planes could fly or ships would sail or parthenogenesis 1000 years ago based on the information science had then. We have thus shown/seen that science "then" has become a "lie" today. How then do you know that science "today" won't be a lie in 1000 years time?
Remember, science is based on "current" findings and current "1000 years from today" will obviously not be what is current "today". You're mixing these things up. One (the virgin birth) is a claim about a biological event that has happened. The other is a proposition in the future about what is technically feasible. In such a field (biology) we do not "prove" statements etc. Besides, how do you expect me to "prove" your negative statement? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 10:31pm On Oct 03, 2010 |
nuclearboy: ?
Ok, put yourself 1, 500 years AGO and explain "parthenogenesis" or better still, explain how a man living 1, 500 years ago would have explained the concept which you now take for granted because of advancements, wikipedia and the web. But parthenogenesis has been pointed out to be a non-viable hypothesis in this situation. nuclearboy: Then fast forward to 1, 500 years AHEAD and prove to me why the advancements that make you (rather than the man 1000 years ago) understand parthenogenesis today will not by that time, have explained HOW a virgin birth is possible! But this is about 2,000 years ahead and you're yet to explain how a virgin conception is possible. nuclearboy: No hype, no fight, no hiding - all we are saying is that we are limited on this plane and are learning. Till we know the answers, you cannot prove it impossible. Science is a developing "thingy" and has its limitations. What you are saying is tantamount to a man 500 years ago saying air travel is impossible (remember they too had science then)! At the very least, we know from science that even if some technology was available to do it, it is obvious that those in the past would not have it to use. What I'm saying cannot be compared to flight because we're talking about the regular functioning of the human body and not technological advancement. While it is true that we are learning, at the very least, the current knowledge about the functioning of the human body simply has no place for conception without some sort of fertilization. Besides, will you be willing to accept that someone (other than a character in your particular religious text) conceived while being a virgin, without asking questions? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 8:55pm On Oct 03, 2010 |
nuclearboy: @thehomer:
I think you are making a mistake. You're confusing Enigma and the understanding behind this thread with some others and the idea their ilk have. I don't think I'm making a mistake here. The same sort of reasoning can and does lead to such outcomes. nuclearboy: Those have something to gain from you and so tell you not to cater for your aged parents but rather bring that cash to their coffers. Same with your diabetic - bring it to them and when the child dies, its YOUR faith that was not enough. That is the situation where you'll find suspension of "common sense". This thread and author don't subscribe to such. Is faith to be valued more than common sense or less? nuclearboy: Your queries make sense on the surface! But let me ask you how reasonable/sensible/intellectual you would have been suggesting 1, 000 years ago that iron cities (ships) would float and men would sit in iron and fly or I would be in Israel and see a man in Rome live on a metal contraption with a glass tube? Hey, whats glass? When you understand that, you will understand that mankind is learning and the fact that we do not know how something is possible today does not mean it is not possible. If it was 1,000 years ago, it would be perfectly logical then based on the knowledge and abilities available then. For this reason, an informed person cannot make such a statement now. nuclearboy: I believe its easier to accept a virgin birth than to believe the iron used to forge a battle-axe in the 11th century would be merged together so large that 5, 000 men would climb on it and it would float half across the world. Think from the perspective of the 11th century man then fast forward your mind to 1, 000 years from now! There you go. Why do you believe that it is easier to accept a virgin birth? What mechanisms do you wish to propose for it to happen in humans? And you're comparing it to something that has already been done for which the principles are clear and easily understood. Besides, we have more knowledge and information now compared to 2,000 years ago. What mechanism do you wish to give for the occurrence of this virgin birth? Or does it mean something else? |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: Why Do Some Christians Hate To Pay Their Tithes? by thehomer: 7:30pm On Oct 03, 2010 |
It's because paying tithes is expensive. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Come Now Let Us Reason Together by thehomer: 7:24pm On Oct 03, 2010 |
Enigma: As many will know, the thread title is obviously taken from Isaiah 1:18. What does the rest of the verse say? I don't think it's actually about reasoning together. Enigma: It seems fashionable to denigrate Christianity (and other faiths, I suppose) as anti-intellectual. Well and truly, the gospel is not primarily an intellectual matter and the duty of us Christians is to preach the gospel and leave it to the Holy Spirit to convict. That's all well and good. But the clashes and denigrations tend to occur when the religious overstep their boundaries into public policy decisions. Enigma: Nevertheless, Christianity (or even faith for that matter) does not preclude the use of intellect or even require its suppression or suspension. The intellectual challenge of Christianity (and of faith I suppose) is not to prove or disprove the everyday intellectual disciplines such as science, history and the like. Rather, the intellectual challenge of Christianity (and of faith I suppose) is balancing what we believe as of faith with what we know is true in the intellectual disciplines like science etc. But it does. I think faith does preclude the use of the intellect how else can one explain an act like only praying for a diabetic child to get well who ends up dying yet the perpetrator of such an act actually thinks this was a good approach? How do you wish to find a balance between faith and science? The way I've seen it done is by the person simply suspending the scientific method from their religious inquiries. Enigma: An example: science says that a woman cannot get pregnant without the involvement of spermatozoa from a man: I believe in the virgin birth of Jesus Christ. To the purely intellectual minded, my belief is "daft" because science contradicts it; I say all well and good with your science which is true that spermatozoa is necessary for conception. But I believe in something greater than your science ---- something which can override your science. Now I say emphatically ---- that stance is not anti-intellectual. In fact I am even now going to coin a new term to describe that stance ---supra-intellectual ---- i.e. recognises and understands the intellectual position but yet rises above that intellectual position. What you've mentioned above is a very good example. How is your solution better than science? Your method of going around it which is by inventing a new field/term is simply not an intellectual solution and it is not better either. It's just a work around you've invented for your special exception. One question is why do you believe the concept of the virgin birth? Is it because it's in a book? Or because you were told? Or that you have some other unmentioned reason to think it is possible? Enigma: Now on this "anti-intellectualism" charge ----- even a cursory reading of the Bible and a casual knowledge and understanding of church history very easily refutes the charge that Christianity is anti-intellectual.
Acts 17:1-2 Acts 18:4 Acts 18:19 Acts 24:25
The Anglican tradition is often seen (sometimes jokingly derisively) as one given to: Scriptures, Reason and Tradition as exemplified by this line taken from this wikipedia page: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglicanism
For all their faults, church fathers and various theologians throughout history down to Calvin or, contemporarily, to N T Wright cannot sensibly be accused of being intellectual pigmies or "anti-intellectual".
Anyway to summarise ---- to believe in the sufficiency or authority of the Bible is not necessarily to be anti-intellectual. How much of the Bible do you believe literally? Or do you think it is allegorical? Is it the entire old and New Testament that you believe? How authoritative do you think the Bible is? Should we run our government on the rules and punishment in it? How about those not in it? For example, do you believe in speaking animals? How about plants? How about zombies? How about flying people? How about global floods? How about the origin of the rainbow? There are simply too many questions raised by believing the Bible in any particular way you wish to choose. |
Christianity Etc › Re: May 21, 2011 Is The Judgment Day Of Christ. by thehomer: 11:23am On Oct 03, 2010 |
Chuksmomay: It has been revealed from the bible that this world would completly be destroyed by christ by 21st of may 2011(8 months from this present time). By this, God demands that every true believer warn the world of this awful event(Eze 33:1-7). I know you may not believe this world will one day come to an end(2nd peter 3:2-5), but it is absolutly true we are right at the end. Much of the people I tell about this tell me that we can't know the day of Christ's return. Yes it is true that the Bible did tell us that"No one knows the day nor the hour except Christ himself (God)". Wonderfully, God did tell us the reason being that some information of the Bible was hidden and that no one will understand it untill we are close to the end time(Daniel 12:8-9). God did tell us in Ecc 8:5 that a true child of God will know time and judgment. God is a merciful father that he promised he will not do anything unless he first reveals it to his children(Amos 3:7). One important thing that should be remembered is that a true child of God should not be in the church any longer b/c Christ did tell us to leave the church when we see the abomination of desolation stand in the holy place(Matt 24:15). He also went forth to tell us that He(God) will not come except the devil first rule in the churchs(2nd Thess 2:3-4). For more info, visit:www.familyradio.com OR write to: international@familyradio.com OR call 08095807245 I hope you've sold your possessions to be prepared for the event and I also hope you're not trying to get people to donate their possessions to your organization. |
Christianity Etc › Re: "Nigeria Will Be Among The World Powers By the Year 2020" - Bishop David Oyedepo by thehomer: 8:17pm On Oct 02, 2010 |
That's an interesting statement considering that right now, Nigeria is on track to miss all the Millennium development goals by 2015. I wonder what excuses will be proffered if Nigeria fails to be among the World Powers considering that 2020 is not far off. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Do You Think Knows More About God And Religion? by thehomer(op): 8:24pm On Sep 29, 2010 |
I can understand why some may try to sidestep the issues raised by the results of the survey.
But I think people who self identify as Christians and are proud to do so may want to put some effort into trying to understand the reasons why some people do not believe as they do; if they actually want to pass their messages across. |
Christianity Etc › Re: The Deepsight Tribunal. by thehomer: 7:41am On Sep 29, 2010 |
Deep Sight: . . .
One such aspect is the fact that I do pray. I do not go down on my knees or set about it in any particular or consistent manner. I simply have a quiet and extremely brief inward communication with that eternal element that I understand to be GOD. Mostly my prayers consist not of intelligible words but simply of a feeling that is within my soul. I believe that such inward feelings do communicate with the spiritual more powerfully than words can. And that's all there is to it.
. . . I think one might as well call this meditation rather than using a loaded word like "prayer". |
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Do You Think Knows More About God And Religion? by thehomer(op): 9:26pm On Sep 28, 2010 |
Pastor AIO: this must be due to that obsession with religion that NL christians are always accusing atheists of having. It could also be due to atheists being better informed about religions than Christians. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Do You Think Knows More About God And Religion? by thehomer(op): 9:21pm On Sep 28, 2010 |
vescucci: Thehomer! Where've you been? I thought Oladeegbu took you to Jupiter. Yeah but I had to leave him because he failed to understand that Jupiter was a God too.  |
Christianity Etc › Who Do You Think Knows More About God And Religion? by thehomer(op): 8:30pm On Sep 28, 2010 |
This is interesting. If one wants to know more about religion and God in the U.S, he would be better off talking to a non-religious person or a Jew. The article from L. A. Times [url] http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/wire/sns-religion-survey,0,7375137.story[/url] The actual research and further analysis http://pewforum.org/Other-Beliefs-and-Practices/U-S-Religious-Knowledge-Survey.aspxIf you want to know about God, you might want to talk to an atheist.
Heresy? Perhaps. But a survey that measured Americans' knowledge of religion found that atheists and agnostics knew more, on average, than followers of most major faiths. In fact, the gaps in knowledge among some of the faithful may give new meaning to the term "blind faith."
A majority of Protestants, for instance, couldn't identify Martin Luther as the driving force behind the Protestant Reformation, according to the survey, released Tuesday by the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life. Four in 10 Catholics misunderstood the meaning of their church's central ritual, incorrectly saying that the bread and wine used in Holy Communion are intended to merely symbolize the body and blood of Christ, not actually become them.
Atheists and agnostics -- those who believe there is no God or who aren't sure -- were more likely to answer the survey's questions correctly. Jews and Mormons ranked just below them in the survey's measurement of religious knowledge -- so close as to be statistically tied.
So why would an atheist know more about religion than a Christian?
American atheists and agnostics tend to be people who grew up in a religious tradition and consciously gave it up, often after a great deal of reflection and study, said Alan Cooperman, associate director for research at the Pew Forum.
"These are people who thought a lot about religion," he said. "They're not indifferent. They care about it."
Atheists and agnostics also tend to be relatively well educated, and the survey found, not surprisingly, that the most knowledgeable people were also the best educated. However, it said that atheists and agnostics also outperformed believers who had a similar level of education.
The groups at the top of the U.S. Religious Knowledge Survey were followed, in order, by white evangelical Protestants, white Catholics, white mainline Protestants, people who were unaffiliated with any faith (but not atheist or agnostic), black Protestants and Latino Catholics.
Muslims, Hindus and Buddhists were included in the survey, but their numbers were too small to be broken out as statistically significant groups.
Stephen Prothero, a professor of religion at Boston University and author of "Religious Literacy: What Every American Needs to Know -- And Doesn't," served as an advisor on the survey. "I think in general the survey confirms what I argued in the book, which is that we know almost nothing about our own religions and even less about the religions of other people," he said.
He said he found it significant that Mormons, who are not considered Christians by many fundamentalists, showed greater knowledge of the Bible than evangelical Christians.
The Rev. Adam Hamilton, a Methodist minister from Leawood, Kan., and the author of "When Christians Get it Wrong," said the survey's results may reflect a reluctance by many people to dig deeply into their own beliefs and especially into those of others.
"I think that what happens for many Christians is, they accept their particular faith, they accept it to be true and they stop examining it. Consequently, because it's already accepted to be true, they don't examine other people's faiths.
That, I think, is not healthy for a person of any faith," he said.
The Pew survey was not without its bright spots for the devout. Eight in 10 people surveyed knew that Mother Teresa was Catholic. Seven in 10 knew that, according to the Bible, Moses led the exodus from Egypt and that Jesus was born in Bethlehem.
The question that elicited the most correct responses concerned whether public school teachers are allowed to lead their classes in prayer. Eighty-nine percent of the respondents correctly said no. However, 67% also said that such teachers are not permitted to read from the Bible as an example of literature, something the law clearly allows.
For comparison purposes, the survey also asked some questions about general knowledge, which yielded the scariest finding: 4% of Americans believe that Stephen King, not Herman Melville, wrote "Moby Dick."
Copyright 2010 Los Angeles Times Make of it what you will. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Are Athiest The Most Intelligent People? ? by thehomer: 9:01pm On Sep 24, 2010 |
Deep Sight: Rejection of religion is not the same thing as rejection of belief in the existence of God.
I do reject religion and yet I very much believe that God exists. Is it the same type of God described in the religions you reject or is it some other entity you've thought of and named God? You may be able to better get your message across if you were to give this entity another name or a better definition rather than using the overloaded word "God". Deep Sight: We cannot presume that Darwin was conclusively an atheist.
These are Wiki Quotes from the Page on Darwin's religious views - I don't presume that he was an atheist. From what I read, he was answering another question. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Are Athiest The Most Intelligent People? ? by thehomer: 8:50pm On Sep 24, 2010 |
Deep Sight: This is false. Atheism is a rejection of the existence of God or gods.
Accordingly no person who accepts belief in so much as one god, goddess or GOD, can be described as atheist.
If that were the case, then in the eyes of the Hindu, the Christian might be an atheist. That is an absurdity.
Theism is acceptance of the existence of GOD or gods. Any acceptance of any god removes an individual from the class of atheists, for atheists subscribe to NO god. Well do you believe in the Hindu Gods? If not, then you are an atheist with respect to the Hindu Gods. Deep Sight: Again you are being clever by half. I did not merely say "many people." I said "the generality of the most brilliant minds throughout history" - and the relevance of that statement is in reference to the OP's suggestion that Atheists are "the most intelligent people." Why use ancient history? We now have more and better information. Do you not think that if you're going to make such a decision based on the prevailing minds and knowledge, it would be better to use more current information? |
Christianity Etc › Re: "How Wind Could Have Parted Red Sea" by thehomer: 7:57pm On Sep 24, 2010 |
mystikal: This new wave of aggressive secularism is quite pathetic! What do you mean by aggressive secularism? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Are Athiest The Most Intelligent People? ? by thehomer: 7:46pm On Sep 24, 2010 |
Deep Sight: Atheism makes no sense. Not even a scintilla of sense. Why do you think so? You do realize that you are an atheist with respect to some deities. Deep Sight: It is much, much smarter to be agnostic. Indeed I find that the vast majority of atheists on this forum do not know what atheism is. They are in reality agnostics who are yet to come across the word "agnostic." Most of them are simply anti-religionists. That is NOT pure atheism. I've addressed this in my recent post. Deep Sight: Seconded.
It is a certified fact that the generality of the most brilliant minds throughout history believed in the existence of God. Even Darwin made several allussions to this. Nobody can study nature as extensively as he did and not end up absolutely blown away - not just by its magnificence, but by the gross improbability of its existence in the first place. Try the human eye. Or a giant tarrantullar. Or Ant Hills that contain air-conditioning mechanisms. No be today. Noetic is right - atheism denotes ignorance: willfull blindness.
The immutable and eternal element or factor responsible for all that exists. Darwin rejected his religion and his work has been misquoted at times to make it seem as though he still believed. But so what if many people in the past believed in some entity? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Are Athiest The Most Intelligent People? ? by thehomer: 7:36pm On Sep 24, 2010 |
I must admit from the outset that I do tend to be biased towards logic and reasoning so I cannot paste what was requested by the OP. Agnosticism and atheism address two different questions and are not mutually exclusive. One can be an agnostic atheist another can be and agnostic theist etc. The way I see it, gnosticism/agnosticism is about knowledge while theism/atheism is about acceptance of belief in a particular supernatural entity. Now about intelligence, I understand that there are difficulties with trying to assess it. But there is an unscientific analysis that seemed to show that at least when it came to a self selected group of people interacting online, the more non-religious people tended to score higher. While this does not decide the case one way or another, I think it is an interesting food for thought. Here's the site with the data analysis and result. Just skip down to just before the comments began. http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/the-real-stuff-white-people-like/ |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama Thanks Satan, Could This Be True? by thehomer: 8:38pm On Sep 16, 2010 |
OLAADEGBU: Here is the video clip its only a click away and just over 4 minutes and I know that it wouldn't do you any harm.  If you have nothing better, then I'll just have to leave you to your videos until you do. Or you present your summary. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama Thanks Satan, Could This Be True? by thehomer: 9:06pm On Sep 15, 2010 |
OLAADEGBU: If you want to know what he said you will have to click on the videolink, you can't continue to depend on hearsays and gossips to arrive at your own conclusions. If it's coming from a christian as good as yourself, can it be considered gossip? Do you gossip? It seems I'll have to keep dodging your video posts due to the time required to recuperate from watching them. So tell me, what was the video all about? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Obama Thanks Satan, Could This Be True? by thehomer: 8:13am On Sep 15, 2010 |
OLAADEGBU: I don't expect you to understand what the guy is saying since you and your atheists folks can't even fathom the supernatural. Well what was he saying? Do you consider reverse speech manipulations to be supernatural occurrences? |