Christianity Etc › Re: Practical Christianity? by thehomer: 8:27am On Nov 09, 2010 |
sarmy: Performing miracles is one of the gifts of the Spirit, receiving this gift is at the discretion of the giver, one can only desire or ask for it but God is the doer, we are vessels
However, the more we dedicate ourselves to the things of the spirit, the more we can be used for such So, have you been used for such? sarmy: If we love him, we would obey his commandment Faith without love is fake, if there is love, there will be faith
No. because one can not be a true follower without having true love for the master and if there is true love, there will be faith You're getting the order mixed up. One has to first believe through faith of the deity of Christ and the validity of his teachings. After one believes this, then that person can consider loving him or obeying him. So, my question is in two parts. 1. Why should anyone believe in the deity of your Christ considering our knowledge of the world and how it works? 2. Why should anyone love or obey such a being granting that one believes his deity? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Religion Board On Nairaland Doesnt Have Enough Of Christ by thehomer: 9:02pm On Nov 08, 2010 |
OgaMadam: Just my opinion. is there a child board for Christianity? how does one get to it. No there isn't. OgaMadam: I mean before it was Jesus all over this board.
Now its sort of mixed.
Is there a place/board exclusively for Xtrians? Having a separate section for Christians will not solve the problem because this is a public forum and interested parties would simply post there too. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Practical Christianity? by thehomer: 8:46pm On Nov 08, 2010 |
sarmy: performing miracles is one of the spiritual gifts associated with following Christ but not his core message Ok. But the miracles are supposed to go with the message. sarmy: The core message of Christ centered on LOVE, FORGIVENESS and SERVICE, there could be many more but we can summarize them into those three areas. How about obedience and faith? sarmy: If one believes but no love, that faith is in vain.
But, if you love God and fellow men, you forgive others when they offend and also selfless in service, you are a true follower of Christ But if one does not believe in his deity (which requires faith), can such a person be considered a "true" follower? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Practical Christianity? by thehomer: 8:38pm On Nov 08, 2010 |
Pastor AIO: Yes, I do have tried and I do continue to try. And I have witnessed that the measure by which I've tried is the measure by which I've gotten results.
Now you may asked why in that case I don't kuku follow it by full measure if I'm so convinced. That, my friend, is a mystery. The mystery of my gutlessness. Ok. I really do wonder how much you've tried because if you were able to perform half of what Christ did, I don't think gutlessness would be your problem. You would have a greater difficulty hiding from Google. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Is God Evil ? by thehomer: 8:30pm On Nov 08, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: . . . *1 >>> okay, teel me why and give me something to cogitate on. Ok. Can an entity be omnipotent and omniscient? What does an omnipresent mind mean? Is it present through out the Universe and still considered a mind? Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> circular questions amount to asking redundant questions. which is what u still do. If I'm repeating a question, it's either because you're yet to answer or your answer is not clear. In this case, you're yet to answer. Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> pitiable assertion >>> i don't 'feel' on this is a fact one i reckon you are smart enough to know. Actually, some people do feel that "evil" does not change but that its our moral standards that do change. And it seems clear where you stand on this. Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> given WHAT context. You already gave the context of the Old Testament. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Practical Christianity? by thehomer: 3:06pm On Nov 08, 2010 |
sarmy: I strongly believe that it's possible for one to follow Christ's words, in fact the best way to live this life is to follow him I doubt it. Have you been able to successfully perform miracles etc? sarmy: Everything he said anchor on #Love, Forgiveness and Service to humanity. That's not all he said. sarmy: If you can work on these 3 things you will be his follower. Carrying those acts out does not make one his follower. To be his follower, the main requirement is to believe. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Practical Christianity? by thehomer: 3:02pm On Nov 08, 2010 |
Pastor AIO: according to common sense but you'll never actually know until you try. Have you tried or would you like to? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Is God Evil ? by thehomer: 12:08pm On Nov 08, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: . . .
*1 >>> B'cos the OT God is (believed by Christians to be such) Such a belief I think is incoherent. Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> Circular question because the notion 'evil' is ambiguous. What is adjudged evil changes with zeitgeists. Nevertheless, when i refer to evil in this context, I refer to the 'evil' actions committed by God in the OT I know of circular arguments/reasoning but a circular question? Since you feel that our notion of evil changes, I'm asking how you wish to identify what is evil or what you would consider to be an evil act. Uyi Iredia: . . . |
Christianity Etc › Re: Is God Evil ? by thehomer: 11:41pm On Nov 06, 2010 |
@ Uyi Iredia
How do you go from the Old Testament God to some entity that is omnipotent, omnipresent and omniscient (though I consider such an entity as being incoherent)?
How do you wish to define or explain evil for one to have an idea of what you mean? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Practical Christianity? by thehomer: 11:34pm On Nov 06, 2010 |
sarmy: What is practical Christianity, what are the essentials of the Gospel of Christ and how do we apply the tenets of the Gospel to the betterment of our society?
If only we can LOVE sincerely
If only we can forgive wholeheartedly
And if only we can serve selflessly
If only we can practice these principles religiously, more souls will be won for Christ. Is that all? I really don't think one can realistically follow Christ's words or actions. I think anyone who does or tries to may just find themselves in a hospital or jail. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Christianity And File Sharing by thehomer: 7:38pm On Nov 06, 2010 |
File sharing one of the crimes that will land lots of Christians in hell.  |
Christianity Etc › Re: You Own This World by thehomer: 7:32pm On Nov 06, 2010 |
Joagbaje: Galatians 3:29 And if ye be Christ’s, then are ye Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise ().
Many times, as I study and meditate on God’s Word I can’t but shout for joy. Look at the opening scripture again; it lets me know that I own this world, for according to the scriptures, God gave the whole world to Abraham and his seed. That seed is Christ; and if you belong to Christ, you’re Abraham’s seed and therefore an heir according to the promise.
Some people are fighting over states, cities, municipalities, etc., trying to gain influence and control; wanting to be a Senator, Mayor, Governor, or even the President. There’s nothing wrong with that, but for me, I own everything; I own the whole world. If anybody doesn’t agree with it, it makes no difference; I have proof! My proof is the Word of God. If there’s anyone to tell who truly owns this world it ought to be God, for He made the world. And He has said in
1 Corinthians 3:21-22. “…For all things are yours; Whether Paul, or Apollos, or Cephas, or the world, or life, or death, or things present, or things to come; all are yours.”
So as a child of God, it’s not a mere boast but absolute reality when you say “I own this world; all things are mine!” Let this be your mentality and your talk. You say “Father, I thank you today, because the whole world is mine!” Now, if the world is yours, that means you should never be lack-conscious, since you’re and heir of God, and a joint-heir with Christ. That means everything the Father owns, belongs to Christ and therefore to you. In Psalm 50:12, God said “…the world is mine, and the fullness thereof…” As God’s heir, and a joint-heir with Christ, the whole world is yours, and the fullness thereof.
Let it become your present-hour way of thinking that you won this world. There’s a legal document to that effect – God’s Word. So it doesn’t matter who challenges you or thinks you’re nuts for making such a bold declaration; it doesn’t change anything! You still own this world. So walk tall; square up; chest out; chin out; talk big; for you own this world. No you don't own the world and the things in it. If you think you do, then you may try going to an electronics shop and walking out with a nice plasma screen television without paying some money. You may just find yourself with such pronouncements either in a prison or a hospital. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Is A Religion by thehomer: 7:25pm On Nov 06, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: Religion finds its origins in the Latin word religare which means "to bind together". Time and Time again in the religion debate atheists seek to distance themselves from religion and religious connotations. But nothing could be further from the truth- Atheism is a religion. My critique of the 'new' definition of Atheism on Wikipedia should suffice as proof
"Atheism, in a broad sense, is the rejection of belief in the existence of deities."
*1 >>> Given that this is true, and that Atheism needs be expressed in terms of a belief (viz-a-viz the rejection of a belief). Then Atheism itself is a belief, and consequentially could be categorized as a religion; moreso, given the rise and spread of militant Atheism at this turn of the century. Atheism has lost its brand of 'meekness' exemplified by greats such as Paul Satre, Bertrand Russell.
Therefore, Atheism can be defined as: " a belief in the rejection of all belief(s) in deities".
*2 >>> Making a dichotomy of faith and reason amounts to the second volte by atheists to escape being branded as a religion.The fact that atheists have different stances on multifarious issues shows how subjective atheism can be.To further prove Atheism as a religion (albeit inchoate), it is necessary to remonstrate the subtle use of faith by atheists by :
their faith in the improbability of deity/deities whose existence is/are open to possibility their faith in a vague explanation of man's origins which is primarily predicated on materialist philosophy their faith in the validity of a "lack of belief in" which isn't absolute (by absolute I mean self-evident to all humans)
to be continued As Deep Sight has pointed out, if you wish to go by this method of identifying religions, are you ready to accept all sorts of beliefs and their counter beliefs as being religions? |
Islam › Re: Banning The Veil Is Indeed Sinister by thehomer: 6:33pm On Oct 31, 2010 |
AbuHanifa: I was aggrieved this when i read the news that france has passed banning of burqa into law. This occurrence has, in no measure shown the world, islamophobia in this part of the world. As a matter of fact, other countries will begin to follow suit. What can one say? Maybe the French are uncomfortable seeing masked people wandering their streets. AbuHanifa: Other issues like burning the Quran, Curbing the construction of minarets, etc is indeed devilish, hateful, spiteful, barbaric, of course, act of terrorism. Are you actually comparing burning the Quran and limiting of buildings to murder? AbuHanifa: It has come to the fore that muslims are the most patient in the history of mankind! This is absolutely untrue from what we've been seeing and hearing on the news. AbuHanifa: Oh Allah, help the muslims fighting in your course and let the parochial-minded among the muslims see the imminent and inimical evils. Allahumo ndhur l mujahideena fikulli mokan. What's that about mujahideena? |
Islam › Re: Protect Western Muslim Women Against Militant Islam by thehomer: 6:15pm On Oct 31, 2010 |
Why the insults and hate towards her? I think she's gone through enough and that this is a noble cause that she's pursuing. |
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is Faith? by thehomer: 10:26am On Oct 31, 2010 |
Joagbaje: @thehomer There's different between seen by the senses and seen by faith. You perceive by faith and not the senses.faith may not agree with physical fact but yet it is a tangible substance. What do you perceive by faith? Faith is tangible yet non-physical? Really? How do you explain this incoherent description? Joagbaje: 2 Corinthians 5:7 7( For we walk by faith, not by sight Do you really? Have you tried going to a major hospital and emptying out the wards by healing all the patients? Joagbaje: 2 Corinthians 4:18 18 While we look not at the things which are seen, but at the things which are not seen: for the things which are seen[ are] temporal; but the things which are not seen[ are] eternal. What are these things that are unseen but eternal. |
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is Faith? by thehomer: 8:17pm On Oct 30, 2010 |
@ Uyi Iredia
You did not respond to my questions above. |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: Manipulating Mass Psychology. . . I Was In Church On Sunday. . . by thehomer: 8:35pm On Oct 25, 2010 |
This is mind boggling.
Did he really call his victims "thieves" and other derogatory terms? Was he actually a pastor of that church or a visiting pastor? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is The Truth? Christ Or Mohammed? by thehomer: 10:29am On Oct 24, 2010 |
@ OP There's a missing option. That option is "Neither". |
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is Faith? by thehomer: 12:33am On Oct 24, 2010 |
Enigma: And it is these 'outrageous' things, especially on spiritual matters, that these our "intellectuals" struggle to come to terms with. I recently came across a short essay from which I take the extract below: I think we need to clarify something here. On our previous discussion, you need to recall that you claimed that your position was an intellectual one while refusing to meet up to the standards of it being considered intellectual, not I. |
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is Faith? by thehomer: 12:30am On Oct 24, 2010 |
aletheia: And what is the "scientific method"? Observation. Both the Ptolemaic & Copernician Models were arrived at by observation. As I said earlier: "Theories are conjectures proposed to explain phenomena in the real world. These models or explanations of reality are presented in verbal form in less quantitative fields and as mathematical relationships in others. It's not just observation. You're equivocating if you're going to use conjectures in defining a scientific theory because like I said, conjectures belong in hypothesis. aletheia: Both faith and science provide models for reality." Perception shapes how we conceptualize models of reality. Consider that the earth beneath our feet is perceived by our senses as stationary. Juxtapose against this: the apparent daily motions of the sun and moon. Over a period of time, it is observed that there is a regularity to these apparent motions. In attempting to formulate a working model of reality as I perceive it; would I be wrong in assuming that the sun revolves around the earth (what the Ptolemaic Model assumes) if I didn't have other facts at my disposal? In case you don't know, the Ptolemaic Model was quite successful, lasting 1500 years and successfully predicting planetary motion and eclipses. But then you may need to recall that in proposing a scientific theory, the principle of parsimony should be kept in mind. And mind you, we're not simply stating which theories are available or useful but the ones that best describe our observations, facts etc. aletheia: Faith and Science are actually not so disimilar, especially when you consider that some of the earliest observations of the cosmos and mathematical calculations were done by Babylonian priest-astrologers from the top of Mesopotamian ziggurats. That their influence is with us to this day is seen by the fact that we still subdivide our day into 24 hours and our circles into 360 degrees. Again like I said, one can do good science by following the method while still believing some strange things. The fact that a person's science is right does not also mean that their extra beliefs are more valid. aletheia: Before Chemistry there was Alchemy: that quest to transmute lead into gold. . .a feat that today is acknowledged as possible. Daedalus dared dream of flying long before the Wright Brothers. So you see: Science often plays catch-up with Faith. Yes it's possible but could the feats have been achieved by any of the means you mentioned without following the scientific method? aletheia: You had earlier said: Not realizing that so much of Science also relies on some sort of established authority---again not so disimilar to Faith. Consider your personal example perhaps: You believe that the earth orbits the sun, because you have been told it does, not because you yourself by independent observation and experimentation have independently verified it for yourself.Or that the universe began in a Big Bang or that you evolved from some sort of primordial slime (claims that you have not verified for yourself!). So how different is it then from Faith: you believe Science's claims because you were told what to believe. You may want to counter that by saying Science's claims are verifiable. . .but the question is: have you verified them for yourself? The beauty of the scientific method is that it is open for anyone to see how the results were arrived at. I do not have to go about verifying all facts presented to me otherwise, I'll never get any work done. aletheia: Do you begin to see the double-standard employed here by you avowed empiricists. Faith makes claims. So does Science. But you accept the claims of Science because of some sort of established consensus and a priori assumptions while you reject the claims of Faith according to your arbitrary standards. Are you implying that verifiability is not important? It is not a double standard. If the claims made by faith are valid, then verifying them should be very important to those making such claims. If I presented you with some outrageous claim, would you accept it as being true by faith or try to verify it in some way? aletheia: The same way the Ptolemaic Model is still useful at some scales viz, modern planetariums (as pointed out above). You misunderstand me. My view is the best explanation for everything known and unknown ("mysteries" or other unexplainable phenomena) is Jehovah God. (I am not a proponent of the 'God of gaps.' I believe in the Transcendent Personal Holy God Who created all that is and acted in history to redeem man from sin.) And why do you believe this? Is it because it is written down in a book and repeated over and over again or is it because there is something there that you can use to convince someone else that this view is actually correct? aletheia: I said Science is as it were confined to a box. But you interpret the box as the universe. The truth is that we are confined within and part of a system and as such any inferences we can make about the system are limited, for we are not independent or apart from the system we purport to measure---you may want to consider the implications of the Schrodinger's Cat thought experiments. Since you've pointed out that our inferences are limited, then how can you go ahead and accept inferences made by relatively ignorant people several millennia ago? aletheia: What is outside the universe? The Prime Mover; the Uncaused Cause of the universe: My belief is God. The universe is bound in time. God lives in eternity: outside of time. And how do you know this so well that you're willing to give such an incoherent answer? aletheia: For example Faith gives better answers than Science to things like Near Death Experiences and instances of precognition. After all doesn't Science limit itself to things it can measure with instruments at his disposal. Consider for example that you have a mind: Has Science been able to measure and quantify the mind?---Yet you do not doubt that your mind exists separate and apart from your body. No faith does not give better answers. If anything, it gives wrong answers or non-answers. No. My mind and I'm willing to bet minds in general require a body to exist. aletheia: ^You say occasionally. Care to give me the odds or probability of three different individuals in different locations and unbeknownst to each other having detailed precognition of an accident that occurred some weeks later? All your talk about statistics, recall bias etc does not obscure the fact that it happened. . .your Science is at a loss to explain it and so it tries to dismiss it because it does not fit into and consequently undermines its model of reality. If Science was true to itself it would begin to examine the assumptions that underpin its current model of reality since there are instances of events that deviate from it. I cannot give you odds since I do not have enough information to go with. How detailed was this precognition? How do you wish to explain this occurrence? I do not know that it happened. All we have is your claim about some third party occurrence. What suggestions do you have about examining these assumptions? aletheia: Well that is the methodology that Science has chosen. It does not make True Faith any less valid. Your misconception is that you suppose that Faith can not be subjected to scrutiny. The Christian Faith has been subjected to scrutiny and yet it stands! You think it stands because you already believe it before hand. But then, you're wiling to provide some explanations with poor evidence of a donkey speaking. aletheia: Again, your bias and misconception shows. You have faith that the sun will rise tomorrow not because you are already living in tomorrow but based on your personal evidence that the sun rose yesterday and historical evidence that it rose all other days prior to your birth. In the same way I have faith in God because of the evidence I see from nature, history and personal experience. Like I said, this is logical based on what we do know about the motions of the Earth and other facts. What is this evidence that you see in nature and history. aletheia: Consider this appeal to one who was sceptical:
John 20:27 Then saith he to Thomas, Reach hither thy finger, and behold my hands; and reach hither thy hand, and thrust it into my side: and be not faithless, but believing.
They are other well-educated sceptics like you who investigated the claims about Jesus for themselves rather than relying on hearsay. You may want to read Josh McDowell and Farnk Morison. If the body was good enough for Thomas, then it's good enough for me. So I may as well with to touch the holes too. aletheia:
There is misconception of miracles among Christians that sadly has spilled over into the secular world. Miracles are not random gratuitous acts of God. They always occur in a specific place, at a specific time and for a specific purpose. To you it may appear absurd and implausible that a donkey will speak, but that is because by your Scientific Model, it wouldn't do so. Ask yourself this: where it is recorded that the donkey spoke; what was the purpose for it's speech? With God all things are possible----donkeys may speak and the dead can rise from the grave. This is part of the main problems with faith. You simply believe it mainly because it is written in the Bible which you consider to be some sort of great authority. aletheia: But the Truth can sometimes be outrageous. Not so.  Yes it can. aletheia: They may not believe in the sun god but there exist some who still believe in similar entities. Care to visit some aboriginal settlements or villages in some remote parts of Nigeria? Or what about those in our cities, even among our educated elite who still patronize shamans. Or what about those who practice wicca or worship gaea in the "developed" West? You see? When you generalize and are called out on that; you are forced to fall back to defend a narrower position (Classic debating tactic. ) What generalization? I gave you specific examples that majority of people currently on earth do not believe in. aletheia: Man is not just body. He is also Soul and Spirit. It is written, Man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God. A study of the history of Science will show you that Faith has often been in the vanguard of Scintific progress. Consider this quote about Isaac Newton: Do you have good evidence for this soul and spirit you wish to add in your definition of man? Are you ready to define and defend such concepts? I also notice that you refused to answer whether or not you'll believe claims I make without my providing some sort of evidence. |
Christianity Etc › Re: ‘i Am The Door’ by thehomer: 7:41pm On Oct 23, 2010 |
Is there a nice window through which I can get in? |
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is Faith? by thehomer: 7:39pm On Oct 23, 2010 |
Uyi Iredia: @ mazaje & homer >>> SSMH (Seriously Shaking My Head) at you two Why? Uyi Iredia: i see you guys have rigidly determined to obviate faith (in effect) by continuously connoting & denoting it with religion >>> furthermore you ignored my argument that you atheists (tend to) equate reason with logical empericism That is one of the definitions of the word. The definition I respond to depends on the context of its use. What do you mean by logical empiricism? Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> sorry 4 what The same therefore applies to reason.
*2 >>> I'm tired of repeating this >>> mythical or fictional works have verisimilitude >>> they incorporate elements of reality >>> u naively discount this when u brush off The Bible as a fictional work How do you sort out by faith which is real and which isn't? How accurate do you wish to say the Bible is? Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> and u 'believe' evolution is a theory sustained conjecture >>> given evolutionary rubrics >>> a donkey speaking is likely >>> the moment a donkey that can speak is found i'll bet my left balls that evolutionists will point to it as an example >>> of natural selection at work & a plausible pointer to how man could have evolved speech No evolution is a theory pretty much as general relativity is a theory. Are you being sarcastic here? Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> SMH >>> i will (on purpose) jabber your statement >>> man is an example of an animal that speaks human language >>> shouldn't take faith to believe >>> it is a reasonable argument >>> evidenced by how bees, parrots & other animals communicate What point are you trying to make here? Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> what if they do ? >>> what evidence do you have for this a priori >>> another (dogmatic) assertion which i scoff at And what claim are you making here? That you think it's reasonable to conclude that trees cry? Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> then by all means reconcile the Larmarckian, Darwinian & Neo-Darwinian schools of thought >>> u might win yourself a Nobel prize in Biology while you're at it >>> i reckon you are smart enough Lamarck's view has been demonstrated not to be correct when it comes to inheritance of characteristics. Some of Darwin's original thoughts that were found not to be correct have been rejected leaving us with the current theory of evolution. So what's to reconcile here? Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> for an emperical examination perhaps >>> in the end your examination equates to a skeptical analysis How do you wish to go about evaluating whether or not a miracle has actually occurred? Or would you just believe anyone who says so and claims it was God's hand? Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> so that means He doesn't exist >>> yeah right That makes his existence very unlikely or as likely as that of Thor or the Flying Spaghetti Monster. Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> given d fact that your statement isn't evidenced >>> it can jolly well be dismissed But on the contrary, I think with regards to some phenomena or entities, the absence of evidence may as well be taken as the evidence of absence because, if whatever it is that you're looking for is not available, what do you expect to find other than its absence? |
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is Faith? by thehomer: 6:47pm On Oct 23, 2010 |
aletheia: But for the time it was accepted the Ptolemaic model with it's epicycles provided a working and predictable model of the universe as it was then known. If you acquaint yourself with the history of science you will realize that "established" theories are often accorded an authority seemingly writ in stone; hence the conflicts that arise when newer theories seek to displace older ones. "Seemingly" being the key word there. Also, how was the Ptolemaic model arrived at? Was it by a scientific method? The fact that it was widely accepted does not mean that the conclusion was arrived at scientifically. aletheia: I not sure I quite understand your last sentence above. Most models of reality propounded by Science are incomplete. . .which is why newer theories arise seeking to reconcile the differences. Consider this example: Einstein arrived at his theory of gravity after seeing that the Newtonian model could not explain discrepancies in the orbit of Mercury. Yes Einstein's theory is more accurate but Newton's while not being as encompassing as Einstein's, is still very useful at some scales and is applied as needed. aletheia: Science is as it were confined to a box. The saying: "To a man with a hammer, the whole world is a nail." That saying to me applies more to what you're saying because every "mystery" you see in the Bible or perceive on Earth to you demands a God as the best explanation. aletheia: Science may be the best method for acquiring knowledge about the physical universe, but it falls short when considering phenomena that transcends the physical dimension or come from outside it. Indeed the tools at the disposal of science cannot account for events that cannot be explained in purely physical terms. Ok. But then what is outside the Universe? How did you come to the conclusion that there is something outside the Universe when the Universe as it is is mind bogglingly huge. When it comes to events that cannot be explained in physical terms, what makes you think faith gives a better or correct answer? aletheia: Examples of this abound. Here is one: a friend of mine was due to travel. A couple of weeks before his journey, three different individuals in different locations and unbeknownst to each other dreamt that he was involved in a ghastly car accident while undertaking the trip. While travelling he was involved in an accident, fatal to a pedestrian and he barely escaped with his life. How does Science begin to explain this? Someone coming to me with such a story would have quite a number of questions to answer considering statistics and some things we know about humans. Statistics such as the number of motor vehicle accidents that occur daily, the age groups most involved in them etc. Then with humans, with confirmation bias and recall bias etc. Some other questions like how specific were the dreams and how often their dreams even the very weird ones come true. So to me, this is not so much a mystery as the fact that such occurrences may be expected to occur occasionally. aletheia: www.nairaland.com/attachments/203634_atheist_dilemma_gifd9a6f31e7a246547538f9bf64a0cd35f ^^ Faith is belief based on evidence. The dissonance between Faith and Science is that often Science has a priori refused to admit the evidence. . .and to concede that the tools at its disposal are limited. If there were evidence, then faith would not be necessary. Science has refused to consider prior faith as some sort of evidence in arriving at a conclusion. aletheia: You cannot forsee the future, but logically don't you expect the sun to rise tomorrow based on your prior observations. aren't you extrapolating into the future? Similarly, having observed God's interaction in human history, it is logically for me to believe that he will act again in the future. Yes I am but it is not based on faith, but based on evidence such as the periodic rotation of the earth, the shape of the Earth etc that available to me. aletheia: I believe you refer to Balaam's donkey. This is one specific singular act of a donkey speaking human speech---though Science does admit that animals communicate with each other. This was a remarkable supernatural act of God hence it was recorded. Where Science stumbles is to proclaim the non-existence of God and therefore strait-jacket itself when it comes to explaining miracles. Christians don't go around claiming that donkeys speak human language but we recognize that with God all things are possible and so it is not any surprise if He caused the donkey to speak or the dead to rise. Faith confers a freedom that Science lacks. If I said to you that a shepherd reported that his favourite sheep asked him to stop beating its fellow sheep, would you believe me? If no, why would you believe a donkey spoke and that God was behind that but not believe that I am reporting a true occurrence and that God was behind it too? If you do, then I have some interesting stories for you.  What you consider a freedom of faith to me is just an excuse to believe something outrageous. aletheia: Forgive me, but I thought that was what you meant by this:Are you sure? Yes. It is for this reason that a person can have some strange beliefs and still be able to present good scientific results. aletheia: There are still some who believe in such or similar entities. I think you can only make that statement when majority of the humans in existence no longer believe in the existence of God or gods. And that you know is not going to happen soon.  Right now, majority of humans in existence do not think that the sun is a God neither do they think that chicken pox is a God. aletheia: This is not such a snide remark as you suppose. But they that wait upon the LORD shall renew their strength; they shall mount up with wings as eagles; they shall run, and not be weary; and they shall walk, and not faint.
So you see it is no surprise if Faith flies to the summit of the Mountain while Science is still grappling with ropes, crampons and pitons, stuck on a ledge halfway up the ascent.  And which of them would actually produce materials and tools that we can work with? |
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is Faith? by thehomer: 12:15am On Oct 23, 2010 |
aletheia: Science is also guilty of relying on authority figures too! Witness the many controversies between opposing theories in the history of science. Examples would be the acrimonious disagreements between the theories of abiogenesis and biogenesis; and the ptolemaic and copernician views of the cosmos. Which one do we currently see as correct and why? We see the Copernician view as correct not because of who he was but because it fits with observation. aletheia: Your are just quibbling over words. One of the definitions for the word theory is hypothesis or conjecture depending on the context (you can look it up here:). Whether theories, hypotheses or conjectures: we are discussing models of reality. Is there any theory that is not a conjecture (i.e. one that fully explains and predicts phenomena in it's field)? Are theories not discarded when they no longer provide a good fit for the data. When they become discarded, do they revert to the status of conjecture? If you wish to go by that, then it seems to me you're equivocating because, the word theory as used in science is quite different and at times opposite from its use in common English. How can one know when all phenomena possible are explained in a field? If it is discarded, then it was wrong. aletheia: I disagree. I believe this is the narrative that you have chosen to believe: that Faith is the antithesis of Science. This narrative requires you to believe that Faith and Science are engaged in a titanic struggle for supremacy. I see things more as faith being believing something based on poor or no evidence while science is more of the best method that we currently have of acquiring knowledge. aletheia: But if you had paid more than passing attention to my words; you will see that I wrote:
By this I mean that Faith and Science do coexist peacefully side by side in the course of daily mundane existence, a point I tried to illustrate by referring to the self-evident fact of gravity. Faith is similar to Science in that it tries to extrapolate from what it knows to that which it doesn't known. Again a core difference is the method by which that previous knowledge to be used for extrapolation is acquired. You're broadening what you mean by faith from just the religious beliefs to the fact that one cannot foresee the future and so logically expects certain events to occur or recur. But, given my examples, do you think that a person who held such beliefs is correct? aletheia: And what is the evidence before you? It is the same evidence that Faith uses to arrive at the acknowledgment of the existence of God. Perhaps your Scientific Model requires rejigging. Consider the evidence we have of animal physiology, do you think that one who believes that animals e.g donkeys speaking would be in the best position to convince another of the existence of some God? aletheia: Depends on what you define as progress. In any case, alot of scientists do believe in the existence of God---thereby undermining your argument that Faith and Science must needs be in conflict. I never argued that they need to be in conflict. aletheia: My exact words were: "Faith goes beyond Science in providing an explanation of phenomena that Science's deterministic model cannot explain: angels, demons, hobgoblins etc. For thousands of years, Faith has described encounters with beings from other dimensions of reality than this one. Isn't it interesting that only now is Science beginning to consider that other dimensions exist through quantum & string theories &c." Which strange well-defined beliefs have been laid to rest? Care to enlighten us? I think beliefs in sun gods, chicken pox gods and similar entities have been laid to rest. aletheia: By other dimensions of reality I refer to quantum and string theories of the nature of "Life, the Universe and Everything." Ok. But I think with respect to string theory, the dimensions are spatial. aletheia: No conquest. . .just using some mountaineering metaphors. Mountaineers traditionally plant flags on the summit of mountains they have scaled (or vanquished). My point was that after climbing to the top of the Mountain of knowledge, so to speak; Science may find to its dismay that Faith had preceded it to the top. This of course requires a great leap of faith. |
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is Faith? by thehomer: 8:38pm On Oct 22, 2010 |
aletheia:
 ^I disagree.
As always you guys shape your arguments in such a way as to assert that faith is anti-reason: that Faith operates void of proof. Not so. Faith is predicated on evidence. The sort of evidence used by faith seems to me to rely on some sort of authority. aletheia: Science is also predicated on evidence. Theories are conjectures proposed to explain phenomena in the real world. Theories are ranked far above conjectures. Conjectures can be considered as similar to hypothesis. aletheia: These models or explanations of reality are presented in verbal form in less quantitative fields and as mathematical relationships in others. Both faith and science provide models for reality. By and large Faith and Science coexist peacefully side by side (e.g the self-evident fact of gravity is non-controversial in whether from the perspective of Faith or Science) but where the clash often occurs is in relation to questions of origins and endings and existential meaning that have philosophical underpinnings and speak to the nature of man. Being self-inquiring beings, we ask ourselves: Who are we? Where do we come from? Why are we here? And how does it all end? Or to put it more poetically: This is not quite correct. They do clash often. e.g when we consider gravity, we understand that people and chariots do not float away from the surface of the earth. Another example: considering the principle of buoyancy, humans and metal objects do not float on water in certain configurations. Yet some choose to accept stuff like this on faith when these events seem to me to be evidence to the contrary. aletheia: . . . Unfortunately Science, with it's deterministic model does not provide the answers to these questions. Faith on the other hand (whether Biblical or otherwise), does provide answers to these questions that confront us on this plane of existence. Whether these are the right answers is a matter of examining the historical and textual evidence. But if some of these answers do not seem to make sense considering the evidence before us, why should they be considered to be true? aletheia: Those on this thread who make the argument that Medieval Christianity blanketed Europe with a dark pall of ignorance fail to present the full picture. A large part of the descent of Europe into the Dark Ages was as a result of the Fall of the Roman Empire and the loss of Pax Romana. The destruction of the Library of Alexandria with its repository of ancient knowledge also contributed to the decline of learning. Nonetheless, Medieval Christianity also kept alive the banked fires of science by preserving the few ancient manuscripts in its monasteries. Indeed the early roots of modern science are found in what was then called "natural theology" and "natural philosophy". A considerable number of those in the vanguard of scientific progress were men and women who also believed in the existence of God. Belief in the existence of God was the norm in those times even among their scientists this is understandable considering the possible harm one could come to for believing otherwise. But, with more and better information, we can see people at least among the elite scientists that the belief in God is not quite necessary to make progress. aletheia: Faith goes beyond Science in providing an explanation of phenomena that Science's deterministic model cannot explain: angels, demons, hobgoblins etc. For thousands of years, Faith has described encounters with beings from other dimensions of reality than this one. Isn't it interesting that only now is Science beginning to consider that other dimensions exist through quantum & string theories &c. Some of those strange beliefs especially those that are well defined, have been put to rest at least among the less gullible. I'm not sure what you mean by other dimensions here. Do you mean alternate universes or extra dimensions? aletheia: Here's a thought: Imagine the dismay, when after the gruelling climb and slog, Science arrives at the summit of the mountain aiming to plant the flag of conquest only to find Faith already sitting at the top waiting to welcome it! This would be an interesting thought. But I really do wonder what sort of conquest it would be that faith arrives at. |
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is Faith? by thehomer: 8:10pm On Oct 22, 2010 |
@ Joagbaje Your reference to the Bible seems to me to be a part of the problem. I've seen this sort of response as some sort of definition of faith. Hebrews 11:1 1 Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen. If we were to broaden "seen" to imply something like "perceive" or "detect", then I hope the problem becomes clearer. What I mean is, how can you speak of evidence with regards to what one has not detected or perceived in any way? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Contemplation Seeds From Eckankar by thehomer: 10:13pm On Oct 21, 2010 |
benodic: @thehomer
Basic Beliefs of Eckankar
Harold Klemp, the spiritual leader of Eckankar, describes the basic beliefs of Eckankar as follows:
The teachings of ECK define the nature of Soul more carefully than do other current religions. Each person is Soul, a particle of God sent into the lower worlds (including earth) to gain spiritual experience. Purified by the spiritual exercises, he comes into contact with the Holy Spirit. His goal is spiritual freedom in this lifetime, after which he becomes a Co-worker with God, both here and in the next world. Karma and reincarnation are primary beliefs.
Key to the ECK teachings is the Mahanta, the Living ECK Master. He has the special ability to act as both Inner and Outer Master for ECK students. He is the prophet of Eckankar, given respect but not worship. He teaches the sacred name of God, HU, which lifts one spiritually into the Light and Sound of God, the ECK.
The ECK (the Holy Spirit) purifies one of karma (sin), making it possible for him to accept the full love of God in this lifetime. Then he gains wisdom, charity, and freedom.
Personal experience with the Light and Sound of God is the cornerstone of Eckankar. Of all the religions on earth today, Eckankar offers the most direct teachings on the Light and Sound of God. These twin pillars are missing in whole or in part from the rest. People who truly find these two aspects of God undergo a complete spiritual change. Life becomes fresh and new again, as it was in early childhood.
—Harold Klemp "What Is ECKANKAR?" The Temple of ECK
Eckankar teaches . . .
* Soul is eternal. * Soul exists because God loves It. * Soul is on a journey of Self- and God-Realization. * Spiritual unfoldment can be accelerated through conscious contact with the ECK, Divine Spirit. * This contact can be made via the Spiritual Exercises of ECK and the guidance of the Living ECK Master. * You can actively explore the spiritual worlds through Soul Travel, dreams, and other spiritual techniques. * Spiritual experience and liberation in this lifetime are available to all. Ok. Is there some sort of punishment for not accepting this belief? How do you describe the soul and God? Are they similar to that of Christianity? What is karma? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Contemplation Seeds From Eckankar by thehomer: 9:24pm On Oct 21, 2010 |
@ benodic
What are the core beliefs or principles in Eckankar? |
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is Faith? by thehomer: 9:19pm On Oct 21, 2010 |
[quote author=Rhino.3dm link=topic=535346.msg6980206#msg6980206 date=1287592910]how can we be sure that those things are not facts in other level of energy or possible in the later feature may be science will be able to make inventions that that will make them visible. Eg i personally thought UFO's are mirage not until last month i was out in the night and my friend notice two dumbell shape like object moving in a calculated cyclic motion for a while with a bright light like a car head light. I was stunt and that change alot in my perception of things i used to feel arent there,[/quote]What you saw may have been unidentified to you but for others to accept that it may have been some sort of extraterrestrial intelligence would need a lot of evidence especially when we consider the number of satellites and telescopes out there monitoring earth and space. Or to put it in other words, it's a conclusion made after other possibilities have been excluded. |
Christianity Etc › Re: What Is Faith? by thehomer: 9:06pm On Oct 21, 2010 |
aletheia: . . .faith is believing God. And it is based on evidence. . . . . But, if the evidence were good enough, one would not need faith. |