₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,346,387 members, 8,522,765 topics. Date: Saturday, 21 November 2026 at 11:41 PM

Toggle theme

Thehomer's Posts

Nairaland Forum › Thehomer's Profile › Thehomer's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 (of 210 pages)

Politics › Re: Shuttered Arik Air Accuses Aviation Minister Of Demanding 5% Share by thehomer: 1:54pm On Sep 21, 2012
Do they have any evidence of this? I even wonder why there is a separate Minister of Aviation. I hope that ministry gets merged with transportation.
Christianity Etc › Re: Adeboye Asks For Inclusion Of Clergy In Mid-east Peace Talks At US Congress by thehomer: 1:51pm On Sep 21, 2012
Seriously this guy must be a joker. He wants to further complicate these complicated political issues by introducing the worst method of arbitration between opposing groups which is religion?

Why hasn't he tried this with Boko Haram in his country? The main questions I would like him to answer are; does he think the land should be partitioned and why.
Christianity Etc › Re: But Why Did Jesus Had To Die For Us...god Could Have Just Forgiven Us by thehomer: 1:38pm On Sep 21, 2012
ITSOLUTIONS: just wondering why jesus had to really die for us?
No reason. It is simply a pointless gesture.
Politics › Re: FG To Scrap Agencies Next Year by thehomer: 6:45pm On Sep 20, 2012
Any reason why it wasn't done this year?
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 6:41pm On Sep 20, 2012
Martian: Are you crazy??!!!!! You already pledged fealty to THE GREAT LEPRECHAUN. How dare you try to start your own "path to enlightenment"? The punishment for apostasy is death!!! I'm going to e-kill you.
Mine is The Reformed Church of the Great Leprechaun aka church of thehomer. Repent of your blasphemy before I send my inquisitors after you.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 1:01pm On Sep 20, 2012
cyrexx: that means that you have managed to suucessfully start and deploy a religion where people will believe with the whole of their heart and chant the statements

"there is no god except thehomer's God and thehomer is his messenger"

"death to anyone who insults thehomer and his god"

"the highest achievement in thehomer's religion is to kill and be killed for thehomers God"
What else would you expect from a master mind? The religious text will be out soon. Grab your copy when it's available.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 9:08pm On Sep 19, 2012
jayriginal: Depends on what tribe theHomer is. Where I served in Nnewi, they were shouting "Nwon Nwon Nwon" (my humble transcription).

Edit:
@TheHomer
Boss, na joke we dey oh. grin
Don't worry. There won't be a protest against the post with people demanding for decapitation. Deep Sight should be safe for now. But if there were cartoons, that would be taking things too far. My minions will have no choice but to start looking for embassies to invade and protest the images.
Foreign Affairs › Re: French Magazine Risks Muslim Anger With Mohammed Cartoons by thehomer: 9:05pm On Sep 19, 2012
nikegbade: The one who insults Rosululah(SAW) is like the one who looks directly up at the sun $ spits at it; his spit falls back on his face'
Yet these Muslims are willing to kill such a person. Maybe the spit doesn't fall back on his face or your analogy is very poor.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 8:26pm On Sep 19, 2012
Deep Sight: In fact i heard him shouting, satan, die, die, die! outside their church
Are you sure it was me? grin

You would be hard pressed to find me attending at any church though.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 7:29pm On Sep 19, 2012
MyJoe: . . . .
I doubt it's possible to discuss this properly since your concept of "body" begins and ends with the physical.
We may as well end this here because i really don't understand what you mean when you talk of a non-physical body with respect to consciousness.
Politics › Re: FG To Establish Rice Mills In Ekiti by thehomer: 3:45pm On Sep 19, 2012
Why is it that the federal government has to establish this? Why not something like a public private partnership with the state as it appears Lagos State does? Does the federal government have to do everything in Nigeria?
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 3:42pm On Sep 19, 2012
MyJoe: I just took a look at the write-up. It’s well-written and I’d like to find time to read everything, but my thinking right now is that the writer appears stuck in his materialist universe. I think the problem is, perhaps, that you guys look for things spiritual with the tools of science.

In asserting that consciousness cannot exist outside of a body because of observations made of humans, science or philosophy may be off its turf.

BTW, if a body is needed to have consciousness, it doesn't take anything away from the God argument.
Actually, it does because it would mean that God would need to have a body to be considered as being a conscious entity. If he does have a body, then it would mean that he exists in space and time.
Foreign Affairs › Re: French Magazine Risks Muslim Anger With Mohammed Cartoons by thehomer: 11:13am On Sep 19, 2012
[quote author=Garri_Activist]Why are you christians looking for trouble na undecided

Is it by force to become a christian? huh

Why not serve your jesus and let others serve whtever they feel like serving!

You people just can't stand the fact that Islam is making progress every blessed day, abi?

You explore hatred, jealousy and even ready to do anything to portray Islam in a bad name but the God is always behind the true religion.

My advice to fellow muslims is to remain calm and let Allah protect us as he promise to.

Thnx![/quote]Why don't you tell those Muslims killing people to remain calm and let Allah protect himself and his prophet? Publishing those pictures isn't hatred, jealousy or portrayal of Islam in a bad light, Muslims do that themselves by murdering people and causing chaos each time such images are published. It looks as if Europeans and Australians will no longer stand for such rubbish.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 7:39am On Sep 19, 2012
Deep Sight: @ thehomer, I heard you are in real life a Pastor at Mountain of Fire and Miracles.
If I were, would it bother you?

I heard someone rename it "Mountain of Fraud and Madness". grin
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheists Pls I Need Ur Help by thehomer: 8:57pm On Sep 18, 2012
[quote author=Hye-Bits]What majority of the population do not know is that Evolution is kept alive not because it has a scientific worth but because it is an ideological obligation. It is simply a dogma that has corrupted scientific world which you must believe, otherwise you are ostracized and labeled as unscientific. So materialist/atheism thrive on the propaganda that atheism lead to science.

They intimidate us that deep knowledge in science will lead religious people to atheism. The simple truth is that the modern science thrive on the believe in God as it ethos.

In ancient Greek, most of the pagan philosophers defended the idea of Evolution as a dogmatic believe to deny the facts of creation. Idea of evolution in that era constitute the bedrock of pagan philosophies.

However, it is not the ancient philosophies that ignite and stimulate modern Science, but believe in God. Contrary to what Atheists make us believe to day, that creationism is unscientific.

Most of the pioneer of modern science has strong and firm believe in God. So when they study science they sought to discover universe in the light of their faith in God. And to perceive His laws and details in His creation.

Astronomers such as Copernicus, Keppler, and Galileo; the father of paleontology, Cuvier; the pioneer of botany and zoology, Linnaeus;and Isaac Newton, who is referred to as the "greatest scientist who ever lived", all studied science believing not only in the existence of God but also that the whole universe came into being as a result of His creation.

One of the founders of modern physics, German physician Max Planck of Plank Constant said: "Anybody who has been seriously engaged in scientific work of any kind realizes that over the entrance to the gates of the temple of science are written the words: Ye must have faith. It is a quality which the scientist cannot dispense with."

The atheist has put forward this deceit of "unscientific" if you see science in the light of God. The theory of evolution is the outcome of the materialist philosophy that surfaced with the reawakening of ancient materialistic philosophies and became widespread in the 19th century.

Evolution-Darwinism/Atheism is simply the reawakening of the ancient Greek pagan philosophies. They do not have any proof whatsoever which make Evolution scientific.[/quote]What do you think the theory of evolution says?
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 8:54pm On Sep 18, 2012
Uyi Iredia: such as ?



Yes it is agreed that there was nothingness before the singularity that led to the Big Bang. For you not to know this suggests ignorance on the subject. BTW I was talking about the statement where I said God was a necessity given the law of cause & effect.



You haven't. You only claim to have.



And if you feel that bodies are all that is required for consciousness to be you must be a careless observer.



Not hearsay, but a shared understanding of the argument. You previously stated that there were several first cause arguments. I pointed out one and now you still want me to state what you should have been taught. You are lazy.



If you don't know the First Cause argument by Aquinas we shouldn't even be talking. I'm sorry for you.
Your dull and lazy attempt at obfuscation and time wasting means this part of the discussion has come to an end. Next time, if you wish to have a serious discussion, first present your argument.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 8:51pm On Sep 18, 2012
Uyi Iredia: Showing that Christianity provided a platform for science to develop means it is progressive. Your fallacy doesn't hold because I'm not attributing progress to the likes of Newton.
Means that what is progressive? Christianity or science? If Christianity, just how progressive can it be when it is all tied down to a Book?
Crime › Re: Suspicious Deaths At A Chinese Company In Lagos by thehomer: 4:30pm On Sep 18, 2012
donlyone: is it a steel company? Here in Ikorodu, people die on weekly basis in steel companies belonging to the INDIANs and CHINEESE. People I know who work with these companies claim they've seen SHRINES where they work.
The deaths are usually caused by negligence some of which are so unforgivable they cause riots, and then the police move in to protect the foreign nationals
So why don't the workers or those who are concerned push for an enforcement of the existing regulations? Or the creation of regulations to protect these workers? Blaming Indians and Chinese won't solve the problem, Nigerians doing what is right will.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 9:01pm On Sep 17, 2012
Uyi Iredia: Does it have several intermatching components ?
Yes.

Uyi Iredia: It is generally agreed that there was nothingness before the Big Bang. That is by the way. You haven't responded appropriately to the original statement I made.
No it is not generally agreed that there was nothingness before the Big Bang. Which original statement are you referring to?

Uyi Iredia: Respond reply same thing. Please respond or reply my statement about God being a necessity. You are straying away from what's important.
How do you wish to show that God is a necessity? I've already shown you why your talk of something from nothing makes no sense.

Uyi Iredia: Maybe you should ask if the physical component is all that is required for consciousness to exist. And that isn't the case with dead bodies and that thing called being unconscious.
I didn't say it was all that was required. But that for it to exist, you need to detect a body. If you have some evidence about consciousness existing without a body, I'll like to see it.

Uyi Iredia: I generally assume my opponent is educated. Weren't you taught basic philosophy in the university. I ask because you should know Aquinas' First Cause argument.
And I generally assume my discussant is both educated and willing to shoulder their responsibility. Whether or not you were taught basic philosophy in the university, I think you should know that the person proposing the argument actually states it rather than relying on hearsay.

Seriously, if you're not ready to even state the argument you're trying to make, then I won't be wasting my time with you after making this same request several times already.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 8:47pm On Sep 17, 2012
Uyi Iredia: I'm saying Christianity provided a platform for science to develop. Note that in the Middle Ages the most common citadel of learning where the Christian monasteries. You need to be reminded of that.
Whether or not Christianity provided a platform for science to develop doesn't mean Christianity is correct. Thinking that it is correct commits the genetic fallacy. You can either accept that you're reasoning fallaciously or try to show that you're not committing the fallacy.
Politics › Re: Boko-Haram Spokesman "Abu Qaqa" Arrested In Kano by thehomer: 3:55pm On Sep 17, 2012
If this is true, maybe the bounty is having an effect.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 3:54pm On Sep 17, 2012
MyJoe: What’s the issue about multiple makers and multiple gods? So if I say there multiple gods, you will buy it?
Not really. I just want to know that you're not tied to some sort of monotheistic idea.

MyJoe: Both physical and spiritual laws. Read my earlier post to Mr_Anony. I already told you what convinced me. I gave you two points. But you are still asking for them – that I why I reminded you that I have no mandate to convince you which is all that remains since I already did all you asked for.
And I responded to both of them. You were wiling to grant that your point on spirituality probably won't be definitive to one such as my self. This left you with your claim on design. I thought you were willing to examine whether or not it was fallacious.

MyJoe: Yes. There probably are others.
According to physics, if time is a necessity, then space too is a necessity. Do you agree? Would space be one of the others you had in mind?

MyJoe: Lol. You need a body to have consciousness? That’s new to me.
Well that is what neuroscience seems to be saying. And not just a body, but a brain of some degree of complexity.

MyJoe: It’s a simple comparison and there is nothing weak about it. For anything to exist, a maker is a necessity. This, of course, is not a self-contained argument.
The comparison is weak because a shirt is not like a person or a planet for you to conclude that they were all designed. Can nothingness exist?
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 11:04am On Sep 17, 2012
[quote author=Mr_Anony]lol poor you, look up a thesaurus for synonyms of the universe then[/quote]The design argument is quite different from the cosmological argument. Even if the universe were designed, that wouldn't mean that everything in it was also designed. Keep in mind that I'm not asking for synonyms, I'm asking for a procedural method that allows one to come to the appropriate conclusions.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Either way it will still be an entity. (entity is not exactly the same as object of matter)[/quote]Then I would like to know what you mean when you say something is an entity because if you do broaden your definition that way, it would rapidly become meaningless. For example, would you say that a mathematical symbol is an entity?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]It is irrelevant to this argument whether an electron is intelligently designed or not. It is not within the scope of what this argument is considering.[/quote]May I remind you that you're trying to make a design argument? This means that anything we observe has to be either designed or not designed and you must have a consistent way to tell the difference.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Your question is for lack of a better word silly. You are asking for the definition of a definition of how I define complexity here and I suspect that even if I broke it down simpler for you, you will also ask for a definition of that definition, Sorry I can't help you further.
You may as well ask the question of matter: "how do you decide that an entity has mass and occupies space?" or of bachelors: "why are bachelors unmarried?"[/quote]Your response is asinine. No, I'm asking for a consistent way of identifying whether or not something can be assessed as being designed or complex and all that.

To respond to your questions, we decide that something has mass and occupies space by observing its interactions with other objects. Bachelors are unmarried by definition. But based on your definition, which members of the list I presented to you were intelligently designed? And how can you tell? Here they are to jog your memory.

thehomer: The sun, the moon, the earth, the ocean, the HIV virus, the malaria parasite and a diamond.
You'll note that they're all larger than fundamental particles and they all obey certain laws.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]I would consider it[/quote]Merely considering it wouldn't be satisfactory. Any way would you say a basalt column is designed.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]****came back when I saw your reply. I really don't like frontpage threads because the crowd muddles things up a bit[/quote]It will sink below the fold in no time and I don't see why you cannot ignore posts you do not wish to respond to.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 11:57pm On Sep 16, 2012
Uyi Iredia: I'm pointing out that the progress first started with a realization that God created order & harmony when he designed the universe and that we could use organized science as a tool to inquiring into his creation. Christianity was the religion which bounded most of the people who founded the sciences which we now know today. When you talk of present day methodological naturalism you are simply moving into the 19th century when it gained its stronghold.
You'll still be committing the genetic fallacy if your conclusion is that science progresses today because some 17th century scientists believed in some God.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 11:54pm On Sep 16, 2012
Uyi Iredia: There is no need for any criteria of any kind. All we need to know is that there is a considerable amount of interacting components.
By that reasoning, a volcano lava flow is intelligently designed. Would you agree?

Uyi Iredia: This doesn't appropiately reply my statement. I pointed out something that could be used as evidence and all you do is ask non-sequiturs.
It is not a non-sequitur. If there was never a state of nothingness, then your question is pointless.

Uyi Iredia: People can REPLY statemants. I said time is abstract I never said it always existed. I note that you still fail to answer the statement about God being a necessity.
While I can respond to a statement, I cannot answer a statement. Let's be clear. When we're talking about time, we're talking about it with respect to how it is used in physics so don't start equivocating.

Uyi Iredia: Come clean. Are you subtly trying to say my point was useless ?
No I'm asking you if consciousness makes sense to you without a physical component.

Uyi Iredia: You should know the main one. The one by Aquinas. Now answer it.
Why don't you simply state it? I don't want to start guessing at what you're trying to say.

Uyi Iredia: You'll have to state them again. I do not have the time to go searching them out.
thehomer: Computers and phones have groups of makers so are you proposing multiple Gods or just one? Then the fatal flaw of that claim is that humans are nothing like computers or phones.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 11:40pm On Sep 16, 2012
[quote author=Mr_Anony]but clearly the phrase is not synonymous with the universe.[/quote]Well i don't know that. I've already explained to you what would help me decide.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Your argument here just got worse. I have satisfied your request. the electron is an entity yes, the electron does not constitute of elaborately interconnected parts yes. (Those are enough to make it an exception to the rule)[/quote]No you haven't. The electron is not really an entity in the way that say a chair can be considered an entity. It exhibits features of both a wave and a particle. If you wish to assert that it is an entity, then I'll simply assert that it is a wave.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Based on my argument, does this mean that the electron is not designed? It doesn't follow. much like saying all men are mortal does not automatically mean that all that are not men are immortal.

Please come up with a better contention or accept the argument.[/quote]Though since you've proposed the electron, you're saying that it is either intelligently designed or it isn't intelligently designed. Now which is it? And why?

I see that you're still yet to answer this same question that I've been posing for a long while now. Here it is again.

thehomer: How do you decide that an entity "works according to a systematic order and is composed of elaborately interconnected parts"?
If I presented you with an entity that "works according to a systematic order and is composed of elaborately interconnected parts" would you say that it too is intelligently designed?
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 2:54pm On Sep 16, 2012
[quote author=Mr_Anony]An argument is only good if it's premises are true and valid. You accept that it is valid, would you mind telling me which parts of it are untrue. Also, you keep saying that it is a circular argument without showing how it is circular.[/quote]That's just it. No one can tell whether or not it is true unless you actually say how you decide that an entity "works according to a sytematic order and is composed of elaborately interconnected parts". I already showed you how it is circular. It would be circular if that phrase is synonymous with the universe but again one cannot tell unless we have a way of parsing the phrase.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]secondly, you asked me if there is any entity that we know of that doesn't work according to a systematic order and is not composed of interconnected parts.
All I have to do is give you one: How about an electron for starters?[/quote]Isn't it interesting that you went to an electron rather than say a phone cable or a haemoglobin molecule? That's just by the way. Now electrons have to work according to a systematic order otherwise we wouldn't be communicating. In fact understanding this order is what drives modern telecommunications.

By the way, it looks as if you don't actually get the dilemma you're in. Let me make it clearer to you.

If you cannot present any entity that meets your phraseology, then what you've said is trivial and pointless.

If you can present an entity that does, it would imply that the entity wasn't intelligently designed. Are you willing to say that according to your conception of the universe, the electron wasn't intelligently designed (your conclusion)? So I'm not so sure that you'll want to gore yourself on either of the horns of that dilemma.

But the question still remains. How do you decide that an entity "works according to a systematic order and is composed of elaborately interconnected parts"?

[quote author=Mr_Anony](Now we jump right into the reductionist bucket)[/quote]Well you introduced the idea of systematic order and interconnected parts and all that.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 1:45pm On Sep 16, 2012
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Thanks for clarifying what your problem was. but then you cannot rightfully say I am making a circular argument if you really don't know the meaning of the terms I used. (I smell pretense)[/quote]It is your responsibility to use words meaningfully when you're making your argument. Besides, you need to keep in mind that in argumentation, a sound argument is more valuable than a valid one. in fact, a circular argument while valid still isn't a good argument. You're free to smell whatever you want.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]let me use synonymous language.

Premise 1: Every entity that works according to a sytematic order and is composed of elaborately interconnected parts implies that there is an intelligence behind/responsible for it.
Premise 2: The Universe/Nature works according to a systematic order and is composed of elaborately interconnected parts
Conclusion: Therefore there is an intelligence behind the universe.

I have laid out my argument again. Is it valid enough for you now?[/quote]Like I said above, validity isn't the only thing being sought in an argument so simply tacking on more words won't help you. Now is there any entity that you know of that doesn't "work according to a systematic order and is composed of elaborately interconnected parts"? If there isn't, then what you're saying is trivially pointless. And that is why you need to show how you decide whether or not an entity "works according to a sytematic order and is composed of elaborately interconnected parts".

Are you now saying that nature is synonymous with the universe?

Sure your argument is valid but it is still bad.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 11:31am On Sep 16, 2012
[quote author=Mr_Anony]Now I think I see your problem....I think your problem is with the nature of deductive arguments and not because there is a fallacy because frankly I don't see any in the arguments I presented to you. I'll come back to take your contentions bit by bit but first let me run a basic deductive argument by you and you can tell me if it is a valid argument or not.

Premise 1: all men are mortals,
Premise 2: thehomer is a man
Conclusion: Therefore, thehomer is a mortal

Does this look like a valid argument to you? If no, please tell why. Then we will move on to dissecting your contentions[/quote]Yes it is a valid argument. The difference between this and what you proposed is that I know what you mean when you use the words "men" and "mortal". In the argument you're trying to defend, you never actually said what you meant by "a complex organized order". Until you're able to explain what you mean by that, then you're simply making a circular argument.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 10:05am On Sep 16, 2012
truthislight: i think therhomer should also answer question in this forum.

Not by directing us to links.
I'm not here to teach you things you can find out for yourself. You're online so you too should be able to study on your own.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheism Vs Deism (vs Theism) by thehomer: 10:02am On Sep 16, 2012
[quote author=Mr_Anony]My friend, I gave you the reason why I wouldn't contemplate your question simply because you were going on reductionist tangent where by looking a parts of a system in isolation, we make them devoid of meaning. take for instance the moon. It is just a simple rock but it's purpose comes from the part it plays within the system it is situated. You are trying to make me look at objects in isolation, and that wouldn't do because my argument with you is that "where we see order, we infer an orderer".....but you'll rather create the strawman argument of "where we see an object we infer a maker". I am sorry I won't go on that tangent. That is why I decided to make a fresh argument because I was giving you the benefit of doubt that you misunderstood myjoe. . . .but now it is looking more as if you are purposely pursuing a separate agenda than the one you are being called to.[/quote]Your comment on the moon actually demonstrates that you don't really understand your argument. The moon is in no way simple neither is it "just a rock" because when you say something is simple, without actually explaining the criteria by which you decide that something is simple, then you're just making arbitrary claims. Your claim on the "purpose of the moon" shows your hubris. Who told you that the moon has some purpose that it satisfies? The maker? How is what I'm pointing out to you a strawman? Please go back and read MyJoe's comment. Switching it to order won't really help you because my question will still be relevant. Or are you saying that none of those objects I mentioned had some underlying order?

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Your question and the way it was phrased is irrelevant to this argument. when asking a question regarding order, you ought to provide systems for evaluation and not individual objects. Individual objects do not necessarily have order unless they are arranged so that they work and are understood a certain way. If you cannot provide systems for evaluation, then you you have not asked me relevant question. unless you are about to describe the universe as an object.
My argument is not circular. If you think it is then please tell how so.[/quote]No it is very relevant. Please take a look at the point of an argument by analogy on Wikipedia. i already provided you with a link. When you request for a system, what then do you mean? Is a phone a system? Is a computer a system? But the sun, a virus, a malaria parasite, the moon aren't? If you don't think they are, then you need to tell us how you decide that one thing is a system while others aren't.

I already showed you how your argument was circular. Let me try again.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Premise one: Everything that follows a complex organized order has an intelligence that organizes it and keeps it in order.
Premise two: The universe is complex, organized and works according to a set of laws
Conclusion A: The universe has an intelligence behind it.[/quote]Please take a look at the parts in bold. You'll notice that you've not actually told us what you mean by "complex, organized order" but you quickly attribute it to the universe and proceed to make that your conclusion. The objects I presented to you were to help you in clarifying this problem of arbitrarily declaring certain objects to be ordered as complex and others as simple. Without some sort of explanation, then you're just arbitrarily classifying things and that simply won't do for a logical argument.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]For the first part, I am not committing the fallacy of composition unless you want to describe the universe as an object.
Secondly, I am not equivocating begins to exist with cause, I am simply saying that beginnings follow from causes.[/quote]Well the very first word of that premise was "Anything" so it does look like you were considering the universe as an object. If you weren't referring to it as an object, then what is it supposed to be?

I didn't say you were substituting one for the other, I meant that your usage of those words and phrases in the various premises were different.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Classic reductionism: for the part about the "rearrangement of existing atoms". Are you then saying that for the universe, atoms were not pre-existing or arranged but they began to exist without being caused to exist? If this is what you mean, then you would be saying that the universe has a fixed number of atoms which rearrange themselves all the time to form stuff. Are you saying that the universe is eternal?[/quote]This is one of the reasons why I said you're equivocating on "cause". From physics, we know of the relationship between mass and energy so the atoms are from the pre-existing energy but to say that this energy caused the atoms in the same way humans cause tables to be made is an error just as it is an error to say the universe was caused by this intelligent creator. Atoms form at high enough energies but the sort of cause you're talking about requires deliberation and conscious manipulation. That is the equivocation on "cause" and "begins to exist".

[quote author=Mr_Anony]If you agree that time has a beginning point where it started, then you must agree that time itself is caused or else you must hold that time is eternal of which it will also be incoherent.[/quote]Why should I agree to that? You're the one trying to make that argument which I must say is incoherent due to your use of caused here. By caused, do you mean that something before time made time or that something rearranged things to make time appear i.e make time begin to exist?

When talking about something causing something else around us, you mean that something came before the other and that it actually influenced something around it to make a second event occur.

[quote author=Mr_Anony]Sorry your attempt was unsuccessful, please try again[/quote]Actually it is your attempts at refutation that have failed again.
Christianity Etc › Re: Fastest Evolutionary Changes Ever Observed by thehomer: 1:25am On Sep 16, 2012
Delafruita: evolutionism is now a religion just like others.adherrents will say anything to defend their religion
Really now is this the best you can do after this very claim and the other claims you've made have been refuted?

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 (of 210 pages)