Salaam alaykum dear brothers and sisters....

I nearly had a heated argument with a TMC guy, claiming that repeating the takbir, and "rabana Wa lakal-hamd" after the imam in a loud voice is a bidah. I know there are some learned scholars here that will shed more light into this.

I thought it was a sunnah, as I once heard that it was done during the terminal illness of the rasul, when his voice wasn't loud....

If it is a bidah, why do they do it in makkah and Medina??

Jazaakumullah khairan for your responses....

Walaikum salam,its nt a bid'ah to say aloud d takbir after d iman,provided dat there are lots of people in d masjid dat wont be able to hear d imam clearly,but if d people can hear d imam clearly den its nt permissible to say anytin aloud except d taslim..but d issue of robbana lakal hamd its bid'ah to say it aloud..

bee2me: Walaikum salam,its nt a bid'ah to say aloud d takbir after d iman,provided dat there are lots of people in d masjid dat wont be able to hear d imam clearly,but if d people can hear d imam clearly den its nt permissible to say anytin aloud except d taslim..but d issue of robbana lakal hamd its bid'ah to say it aloud..

Wa alaikum salam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh. Brother please throw more light on it. This Issue was once debated in my place sometimes last year and wasn't conclusive. Why is that of Mecca and madinah different considering the fact that the mic of the Imam is also loud? Jazakallahu khairan!

dont think everything performed in Saudi Arabia is good.they are human as you are .

Sani4382:
dont think everything performed in Saudi Arabia is good.they are human as you are .

true, islaam isn't about what Saudis do or don't.

Lagusta:
Salaam alaykum dear brothers and sisters....

I nearly had a heated argument with a TMC guy, claiming that repeating the takbir, and "rabana Wa lakal-hamd" after the imam in a loud voice is a bidah. I know there are some learned scholars here that will shed more light into this.

I thought it was a sunnah, as I once heard that it was done during the terminal illness of the rasul, when his voice wasn't loud....

If it is a bidah, why do they do it in makkah and Medina??

Jazaakumullah khairan for your responses....

that's your answer, when his voice wasn't loud & also it's not specific to the muadhin, anyone can repeat it in order for those behind to hear if the imaam's voice isn't audible.

walaekum salam, it only becomes neccessary to repeat after imam if other members of the congregation cant here the imam. When the people can hear the imam, then it becomes unneccessary to repeat after the imam. Allah knows best