tintingz:
- Any history of Jewish people turning into monkeys, are this monkeys still existing today?

- From the OP hadith, it looks like it has happened the way it was constructed(the use of shepherd, mountains), so where are this human turning into apes and pigs? And if it has not happen we are yet to see humans turning into apes and pigs.

First, I really don't know why this thread is on FP. There is hardly constructive comments on FP. I hardly comment on FP. Apart from being usually jampack, insults are of highest quality here.

Anyway, from the hadith, note the following:

# A prophesy that some followers of Islam who are expected to uphold goodness will indulge in vices. No doubt this has started from the time immemorial. Even there are records of some Sahabah drinking alcohol, committing adultery etc. However, that is at a lower nearly insignificant scale compare to how such vices will no longer be seen as vices but normal thing.

# Mountain moving/falling over them

# Changing into apes

The above two phenomenon are first repeated in the Quran as the first brother try to explain. What is the Tafsir of this verses perhaps we can understand the hadith from it?!

Below is Shi'i Tafsir on the subject. You can compare Sunni Tafsir alongside.

Here's the web link for Tafsir al-Mizan:

www.almizan.org/tafsir/2-63-74/

m.almizan.org/tafsir/2-63-74/

Then I provide screenshot of relevant area to the subject.

You can check Sunni Tafsir on sura Baqarah: 65 - 67 here:

www.qtafsir.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=366

# Obviously, there is difference in the way both school understand and explain the ayah. The choice is yours.

AlBaqir:


First, I really don't know why this thread is on FP. There is hardly constructive comments on FP. I hardly comment on FP. Apart from being usually jampack, insults are of highest quality here.

Don't mind those bigots, they have nothing sensible to contribute.

Anyway, from the hadith, note the following:

# A prophesy that some followers of Islam who are expected to uphold goodness will indulge in vices. No doubt this has started from the time immemorial. Even there are records of some Sahabah drinking alcohol, committing adultery etc. However, that is at a lower nearly insignificant scale compare to how such vices will no longer be seen as vices but normal thing.

# Mountain moving/falling over them

# Changing into apes

The above two phenomenon are first repeated in the Quran as the first brother try to explain. What is the Tafsir of this verses perhaps we can understand the hadith from it?!

Below is Shi'i Tafsir on the subject. You can compare Sunni Tafsir alongside.

Here's the web link for Tafsir al-Mizan:

www.almizan.org/tafsir/2-63-74/

m.almizan.org/tafsir/2-63-74/

Then I provide screenshot of relevant area to the subject.

You can check Sunni Tafsir on sura Baqarah: 65 - 67 here:

www.qtafsir.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=366

# Obviously, there is difference in the way both school understand and explain the ayah. The choice is yours.

Good, I've read the screenshot.

So in a nutshell they were all metaphors not to be taken literally. good... Rilwayne001 was right.

With this, it is confusing.

tintingz:
Don't mind those bigots, they have nothing sensible to contribute.

Good, I've read the screenshot.

So in a nutshell they were all metaphors not to be taken literally. good... Rilwayne001 was right.

With this, it is confusing.

# Read the Sunni link.