hfeetham0:
A medium between heaven and earth (barzakh)

The literal meaning of 'Barzakh' is a veil or a barrier that stands between two things and which does not allow the two to meet.

But technically Barzakh is a realm kept by the Lord of the Universe between this world of ours and the forthcoming Hereafter in such a way that both might maintain their individual limits. Barzakh is a state between these worldly and otherworldly affairs.

The Holy Qur’an says:
...and before them is a barrier until the day they are raised. (23:100)

People that claim they died and revived claim they went beyond this "barzakh" but what they claim they saw are contradictory, why?

which means after death, our soul will move to a medium, not the heaven or earth and will be there until the last day (unlike the christian version which you will be judged immediately after death)...

Some Christian doctrine like the catholic believe in Purgatory a state where the dead go through adventures to become pure and holy, so not all Christians sects believes in immediate judgment after death. The concept Purgatory and Barzakh are somehow similar.

I also heard some scholars said, our soul will be placed in various things like animals, plants, trees, rock, stones, fishes and other creation... not Quran confirmed though...

This is reincarnation, are you saying some Islamic scholars believe in reincarnation?

tintingz:
People that claim they died and revived claim they went beyond this "barzakh" but what they claim they saw are contradictory, why?

Their accounts may not be up to 50% valid due to the unconscious or unstable mode... both of us will report different story if chased by armed men at night..

Some Christian doctrine like the catholic believe in Purgatory a state where the dead go through adventures to become pure and holy, so not all Christians sects believes in immediate judgment after death. The concept Purgatory and Barzakh are somehow similar.

yea similar

This is reincarnation, are you saying some Islamic scholars believe in reincarnation?

although its hearsay, not confirmed..

hfeetham0:


Their accounts may not be up to 50% valid due to the unconscious or unstable mode... both of us will report different story if chased by armed men at night..

Lol, if we are chased by armed men at night, at least we will give same description of the armed men, guns, black mask and dress, huge etc but the case is different here when it comes religious afterlife, a Buddhist will claim he saw Buddha which he Is bald, a chtistian will claim she saw Jesus sitting on throne with beards, Hindu person will say he saw kali with many arms, a muslim with claim he saw Muhammad with beards and turban.

Who's lying and who is saying the truth?

yea similar

Ok, So why does scholars opinion differ? Are non-muslims gonna be in hell forever? What's your opinion?

although its hearsay, not confirmed..

Do you believe in reincarnation?

tintingz:
Lol, if we are chased by armed men at night, at least we will give same description of the armed men, guns, black mask and dress, huge etc but the case is different here when it comes religious afterlife, a Buddhist will claim he saw Buddha which he Is bald, a chtistian will claim she saw Jesus sitting on throne with beards, Hindu person will say he saw kali with many arms, a muslim with claim he saw Muhammad with beards and turban.

Who's lying and who is saying the truth?

the truth is they are all FALSE... first point is, none of them knows the original image of the person they saw.. christains will see this powell guy that's why you can nvr see any image portraying Muhammed (SAW) from a muslim

Ok, So why does scholars opinion differ?

i dnt know if its from a scholar, just hearsay..

Are non-muslims gonna be in hell forever?

Those who are shown the proofs and ayats and still disagree are going
Those who have no prior knowledge of islam till they die will be tried with their deeds.
More of these can be found in the Quran...
[url]What's your opinion?[/url]
not even all muslims will enter jannat. answered above

Do you believe in reincarnation?

no

hfeetham0:
the truth is they are all FALSE... first point is, none of them knows the original image of the person they saw.. christains will see this powell guy that's why you can nvr see any image portraying Muhammed (SAW) from a muslim

Lol, but we have read of some muslims that claim they saw Muhammad, angels etc when they revive, are also false?

i dnt know if its from a scholar, just hearsay..

Ok.

Those who are shown the proofs and ayats and still disagree are going
Those who have no prior knowledge of islam till they die will be tried with their deeds.
More of these can be found in the Quran...
[url]What's your opinion?[/url]
not even all muslims will enter jannat. answered above

The things is most people in the world have heard about Islam, some via media propaganda, while muslims have tried to enlighten them about the true Islam but still they are not convince, if we put all these people together they will be over billions in population, over billions of people will be put in hell?
Even the christians and jews the Quran talk about that will escape hell are the ones that believe in the Quran and Allah.

no

Ok

tintingz:
Lol, but we have read of some muslims that claim they saw Muhammad, angels etc when they revive, are also false?

It is possible, but I think most of the ones i saw on youtube are false

The things is most people in the world have heard about Islam, some via media propaganda, while muslims have tried to enlighten them about the true Islam but still they are not convince, if we put all these people together they will be over billions in population, over billions of people will be put in hell?
Even the christians and jews the Quran talk about that will escape hell are the ones that believe in the Quran and Allah.

One of Allah's name is 'JUST' guess you know the meaning... and their judgement belongs to God, am not the judge... the assured person is the one who is showed clear poof and ayat but still deny them..

hfeetham0:
It is possible, but I think most of the ones i saw on youtube are false

One of Allah's name is 'JUST' guess you know the meaning... and their judgement belongs to God, am not the judge... the assured person is the one who is showed clear poof and ayat but still deny them..

Alright