Giannina Gibelli doesn't believe everyone will be super enthused to see her romance with boyfriend Blake Horstmann unfold on the small screen — but she couldn't care less.

Sources previously confirmed the pair's relationship to PEOPLE in January, noting that they met each other on MTV's All Star Store. Now, fans will get to see their love story blossom throughout the upcoming competition reality series.

"I think it's safe to say that we weren't shy about how we felt for each other and how comfortable we were," Giannina, 29, tells PEOPLE exclusively. "[ur=https://www.fiverr.com/share/pB0Q3Rl]During the show ,[/url]