Alhajiemeritus: Na Gymnastics be this my bro... You know say Quran self came with no districts na old Scholars dey give am the marks, whether above or below, that's why we have different recitation methods. Same with this, you can either call it (fight)قاتل or قتل. Depending on the chain/part your Hadith was narrated from. Peace.
قاتل is pronounce as qo'tala while قتل pronounce as qotala..check dictionary
I'm asking this question because of the videos of an Islamic scholar, Sheikh Abduljabbar that I came across last week. He made some points about the hadiths being unreliable and even gave some proofs (which I extensively made a research on and found 90% to be true) and challenged northern scholars to prove him wrong or debate with him. So far, none of them has stepped forward to do so even though they have been condemning and cursing him. In fact, he was kicked out of Kano and barred from holding lectures.
If you still believe that all Sahih hadiths are authentic please give me your reasons. I am not here to argue with anyone but to learn. These are some of the things I find questionable about hadiths:
The collection process: Imam Buhari collected 500,000 narrations and found only 8,000 to be authentic. Looking at these numbers, it's very easy for the sound ones to be excluded and fake ones to be accepted.
Contradictions with the Qur'an: maybe it's my lack of understanding, but it looks to be violating some of the commandments of Allah. For example,
1)the Qur'an says there is no compulsion in religion while the Hadiths call for the killing of apostates.
2) The Quran specifies 100 lashes for Zina (with no distinction between adultery and fornication) while the Hadiths call for stoning to death.
3) The Quran justifies killing only on the grounds of murder or war while the hadiths do so on adultery, apostesy, homosexuality, blasphemy, and so one which are the main issues that the Kafirs use to condemn us.
4) The Qur'an encourages Muslims to refrain from approaching women (sexually) during their periods but the hadiths suggest so.
There are so many others that I noticed.
Contradictions within hadiths: you'll find "Sahih" hadith contradicting with "Sahih" from other scholars or even within the same collection. Take for example,
1) - Hazrat Ibn Abbas said: Rasool (S) slept for a while – went to the Masjid and prayed (‘offered’ Namaaz) without Wudhu. (Bukhari, Kitabul Wudhu)
- The Sahaba of Rasool (S) used to ‘perform’ Namaaz without Wudhu after waking up from sleep. (Muslim with Fathil Mulhim pg 500)
2)
- Hazrat Usman said: If a man withdraws before ejaculation, let him wash the genitals and make Wudhu (No bath necessary). (Bukhari, vol 1 Kitabul Wudhu pg 164 Hadith 176)
- Bath becomes mandatory after penetration. (Muwatta pg 22)
3)
- Rasool (S) said, “Renew Wudhu after eating anything cooked on fire.” (Muslim vol 1 pg 486)
- BUT, Ibn Abbas says, “Rasoolullah ate a roasted goat shoulder and then prayed without ablution.” (Same vol 1 pg 488)
4)
- If someone passes in front of a praying person, stop him. If he doesn’t stop, kill him because he is Shayitaan. (Bukhari vol 1 pg 68)
- But: Abdullah Ibn Abbas said, “I rode a donkey to MINA. Rasoolullah (S) was leading the prayer. I passed before some praying ones and got off from the animal and joined the prayers. None objected. (Bukhari vol 1 pg 107)
Again, I came across many of such examples.
Lastly, the ABSOLUTELY RIDICULOUS HADITHS:
Many of them are absolutely insulting to our holy prophet Muhammad.
Some made narrations of him lying on his stomach while married women rubbed his back.
Some said he used to pee while standing.
Some talked about the sun traveling to prostrate before Allah everyday
Some said Moses sent prophet Muhammad back to Allah multiple times in order to have our salat reduced to 5
Some portrayed prophet Muhammad as a reckless killer
Some said pandemics can never reach Makkah and Madinah but Covid-19 proves otherwise.
Many of them are absolutely degrading to women. Some have grouped them with devils and animals.
Some condone rape and stealing (especially at times of war)
The list is just endless. If you have some logical explanations for these factors please do share with me. I have come to realize that most of the Islamic laws we have today lay much more emphasis on these hadiths rather than the Qur'an too.
NB: I don't completely disbelieve the hadiths. There are many beautiful ones that should be accepted even IF they didn't come from the prophet.
@op,I will implore you seek more clarification from scholars of hadith..for contradiction number 4
The hadith said (fight)قاتل not قتل(kill) these are simple Arabic terms.
dru23: As much as I joke here .. Let me also educate some people here....... Someone might learn 1 or 2 things here....
Number 1.... Cost of parts as gone up due to exchange rate... Some people on nairaland might not be aware. Let us get down to business below.....
When ever I buy cars either at Auction or from personal sellers . you must buy the car cheap enough to make a profit. Most times these cars will need some work done. And labour is cheap in Nigeria compare to the USA. Most cars I do sell will need some fixing before putting up for final sale .....
On average I will spend roughly about 100k to 200k on a car before I get ready for the final sale. Now all these little expenses do add up ........
Most of u know that I don't deal with naija used cars for my uber business .. All my cars are Tokunbo for my uber fleet......
so once the car arrives we have to get it ready to uber standard . That usually cost the same amount as if am getting the car ready for actual sale.....This is why am very selective when hiring drivers.....
This particular civic is already on the road. And for the next six months the only thing that will do is basic oil change... It might look like am spending alot now ,
but the goal is to save more in the long run, by putting the car 100% ready. This is to avoid down time ......
Below is the red civic that have on uber for almost close to 3 years plus .. Due to my maintenance culture the car is still on the road as we speak now....
Ps.. No matter how u look at cost of cars has gone up . if you buying for real real cheap at this currant exchange rate .. The car will still need additional repairs or hidden cost..........
Cost of shipping a car has gone up from $920 to $1020. And this does not include towing cost
Considering the high unemployment rate and many Nigeria wahala,what are the hopes of a ond holder who is still trying to get a degree through part-time schooling, all jobs now are degree required with many years experience, it's crazy.
Imagine being on a queue with MSC holders in an interview..
If it’s a technical course,you have nothing to worry about..just make sure you graduate with a good grade..
emmancecute: we dey the same both. I spend nothing less than 2 hours washing my car. Some dunce go just carry potopoto leg put for rug when there's obviously a carpet. Sometimes, I feel like giving them a factory reset slap but alas I just face my steering and chop my humble pie. Things wey eye dey see.
just carry used newspaper join body after rain stop removal am.. I no fit suffer 2 times..
Josephase: Good day everyone, I have a car that someone drives for me on Uber/bolt. right now my job is at risk and would like to use my car from month end, please I need help how I can startup I. switching accounts on the car(from his own to mine) II. Do I need to go for another inspection?
�� was on 5 star for 3 weeks rating dropped to 4.88 after Sunday surge trips...
Slickleo: Greetings I was on YouTube when I saw indriver advert, it's say install the indriver app and save money, So I was thinking since indriver don't do vehicle inspection and I can't recall indriver app recommending the use of AC. Abeg is AC recommended for indriver since na to save cost.
it will affect your rating negatively..Those riders no send you ooo
godsonn97: So I have started my journey to becoming an Uber Driver, I have downloaded the Driver's App. The following documents are required to complete the Registration:
1.Hackney Permit 2.LASDRI Card 3.LASRRA Identity Card 4.Vehicle Body Tag 5.Driver’s Badge
I know I can get the Lasrra Card from Local government , Please where can I get the others and for how much pls? Thank you
Satellite TV Technology › Re: Solar Energy, A Complement To FTA by Baker77: 11:38pm On Aug 01, 2021
