Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 1:03pm On Sep 01, 2020 |
ahiboilandgas: Nigeria has stop subsiding forex for pilgrims hence hajj money jump from 700 to 1.5m per seat .....2 why will Nigerians and foreigner choose smugglings and selling of contrabands and other illegal act as a way of live? What was the 2 labanese doing with 900k cash of dollars ?How many more have smuggled such sum.out .....if they are genuine bussiness why didnt they transfers the sum ,why[b] will demands from criminals,smugglers,corrupt incomes be used to determine the exchange rates[/b] ? Why should exchange rates be DETERMINED in the first place? This desire to control every form of price in the economy is one of the reasons Nigeria's economy is stagnating. Let's accept price controls as a good thing for instance, how do you stop people from exploiting these policies? Using the dollar issue as an example, what stops those who the CBN sell for at a preferential rate from selling to those willing to pay higher prices? There is a fairly inelastic demand for the dollar. The CBN is losing money by selling those dollars at rates far below what the market is willing to pay. It is sad that you guys are dancing around this issue, afflicted by misguided patriotism and economic nationalism. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 12:34pm On Sep 01, 2020 |
Tvegas: So the CBN should follow the black market and keep selling at the black market rate as if they don't have access to any research or data. Your analogy is confused in itself. Since you are the CBN governor then tell us the fair value of Naira and tell us what you will do to defend that fair value. Another person who doesn't get the point. If the CBN likes, let them sell at 180 Naira when people are willing to buy for 470. You can decide for yourself what the consequences are of such an action. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 8:40am On Sep 01, 2020 |
ahiboilandgas: cos naira is picked in dust bins and dollars earned .....hear ur self... The point is flying over your head. Let me try to be clearer: if people are willing to buy diesel at 300 naira per litre and a father Christmas somewhere is selling at 200 naira (delivery inclusive), what do you think is going to happen? Won't people who have access to that Father Christmas buy and then sell at the proper price? In such a situation, what is better to encourage the Father Christmas in such foolishness or to tell the Father Christmas to allow the market to operate at the proper price? If you still don't get the point, then sorry that's the best I can explain |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 8:37am On Sep 01, 2020 |
As long as the CBN sells dollars at below fair value, people would always speculate and people would always defraud the country by "roundtripping" |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 8:34am On Sep 01, 2020 |
ahiboilandgas: which people ? Speculators, smugglers, laundering rings , and confused and follow follow people.........genuine people like manufacturers,students , importer of legitimate goods are buying with form M and form A other bta and pta .... What are you talking about? Please read what you quoted because I don't understand how what you are saying and how it's appropos to my point. By the way, yes genuine people like students are buying from the CBN and repatriating it to sell at the proper price. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 8:32am On Sep 01, 2020 |
awesomeJ: You should rather say you're ignorant, and you shouldn't be proud about it.
You only need basic school maths to understand that. If there's N10trn in investable funds, and yields are at 20% pa, the yield market would create N2trn in fresh naira supply . To help you comprehend better, buying 10trn worth if Bonds, t-bills, CPs, and OMOs at 20% yield, investors get N2trn as interest, taking the naira supply to N12trn.
On the other hand, in a 4% yield market, the same 10trn only creates 400bn in interest earnings, taking the naira supply to just 10.4trn.
I guess you're confusing SUPPLY with LIQUIDITY.
In this low yield market, what we've had is excess liquidity as investors are short of investment outlets. But Supply growth has been much slower. Even when you factor in the stimulus funds from the CBN.
Except you can explain how-according to your ignorant assertion-naira SUPPLY,(not liquidity) increases in a low yield environment, you'll have to admit that you're the one talking nonsense, and learn to polish off your ignorance.
How much do you think it was costing the CBN to manage liquidity via OMO.
You know not enough, you'll be quick to be calling something nonsense! You are wrong. I am not going to belabor the point. If you think lowering interest rates (which would lead to increased loan books on the part of banks) leads to a decrease in Naira supply, then I have nothing further to say. And on the part of the dollar/Naira issue, if you think 380 is the fair value for the dollar, I am willing to offer you as much naira as you want for as much dollar as you can supply at that price. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 8:28am On Sep 01, 2020 |
awesomeJ: You wrote too much for just one point. The only "obstacle" you pointed out is about currency reparation.
First, it'll be flawed if your reasoning is that in a time of limited forex resources, the CBN's priority above the domestic economy is briesfcase hot monies (FPIs in case you're confused about that).
Nobody forced them to come, and they didn't come to give the money for free. They were earning 13-17%. They were aware of the potential repartriation risk, and they had the forwards market to hedge with.
They want to spend as little NGN as possible to get their USD, that's why they're waiting on the CBN. But obviously, unlike you expect, the CBN will not priotize their demand above that of the local economy, so they have to wait. Even school fees and medicals are probably treated with more priority as they should. It's only in your reasoning that proceeds of Nigerian oil should be used to settle foreigners, with Nigerians' needs ignored. Most of us think it should be Nigerians' first, and that's what the CBN is doing.
And as for FDIs, the expectation already is that they shouldn't be in as much of a hurry to run away with their money. Plus for the past three years, we've been supplying them enough to repartriate with. If they won't be patient. Dollar is available at 470. But I guess they know better than you, and would rather wait to but at 380.
So what other "obstacle" can you mention? And you conveniently skipped the issue of subsidisation of currency rates. The market has shown that people don't mind buying dollars at prices as high as 480 yet your CBN is selling it at much lower rates than that for such things as personal travel and pilgrimage (let's even forget about those who will get at cheap CBN rates and sell at the correct rates). Any serious person knows who loses in this arrangement. If the CBN should make mistakes and offer dollars at prices cheaper than fair value, then people would swap it up and the prices would go back up. No matter of enthusiastic whining on your part can change that. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 1:11am On Sep 01, 2020 |
awesomeJ: Most dollar loans are to Oil and gas companies who have oil proceeds in dollars. They are not entirely funded with customer FX deposits as banks have other forms of FX liabilities such as Eurobonds. They also get FX as they trade naira for FX with IMTOs and exporters.
Before LDR banks like GTBANK and ZENITH had LDR below 60% meaning that 40% was idle. So even if they were lending out their FX deposits at the same rate as naira deposits, about $8bn was still idle.
And about offshore operators coming to fill the gap in the event of dorm account closure, how would you move your paper dollars to them after buying from aboki? DHL everytime? Your last paragraph is that a serious question? |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 1:09am On Sep 01, 2020 |
awesomeJ: What obstacles is the CBN putting in the case of Nigeria? None absolutely.
If as a prominent person in my community, I say that youths who have financial issues should come to me and I would give them interest-free loans. But I mentioned some things my loans couldn't be used for to include bet 9ja shops and beer parlors. Would it make any sense for any youth in such a community to say I am putting obstacles on his way to starting a business?
The CBN is not saying you shouldn't import private jet or toothpicks or whatever, it's just you would have to get your forex for such imports elsewhere. What's the obstacle in that? Or it makes sense to you for the CBN to give you $200m of scarce FX to import a jet for you and your family alone, and then be unable to meet up with a $20m demand by a pharmaceutical that will produce drugs for the benefits of millions of citizens.
We should only read theories in the context of their applicability/relevance to our peculiar situation. So the capital controls are not obstacles? Investors brought in both FDI and PI and exchanged their Forex at official rates and got a CCI in return with a guarantee that they would be allowed to repatriate profits at official rates and the CBN reneges on that and you say there are no obstacles? The CBN subsidizes certain goods up to and including such useless things as pilgrimages and you say that's no obstacle to free trade? Your problem is not just a lack of understanding of macroeconomics but a belief in Economic Nationalism which is sad really. We would see in the near future if the foreign reserve would'nt be depleted by the bad economic managers of the nation |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 1:04am On Sep 01, 2020 |
awesomeJ: Those boys wen dey wait, they have unlimited naira supply? if you dey wait with 90m and rush buy to $200k at 450, what else can you do when price crash go 420. You're out of liquidity. Na to dey hope say CBN will run out, it won't happen! You are obviously unfamiliar with speculative attacks on currencies. If the UK, Switzerland, Thailand and Indonesia could not survive speculators attacking their currency, is it Nigeria with a mono-product economy that would survive it? |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 1:03am On Sep 01, 2020 |
awesomeJ: You're on your own. You've forgotten that between the CBN and speculators, none controls dollar supply but one does naira supply. Or you think as the naira is in endless supply to speculators? If the CBN decides to limit money supply to the system as they are currently doing with this ultra low yield market, where will speculators get enough naira to buy dollars at funny prices?
If as a speculator, you only had 100m naira.
Would you certainly have to choose between buying 250k dollars at 400 (limiting the price) and buying just 100k dollars at 1000 (limiting the demand)?
So since your naira supply is also limited you won't be able to make high dollar demand at a high price. This is something we've seen before. Sorry but your first paragraph is absolute nonsense. How does a low interest environment limit Naira supply? Please think it through. There is a lot of reaching for yield by investors (including an engagement in speculation of various sorts) and this is primarily caused by the low risk free interest rate. For clarity, Naira supply increases in low interest environment. Unless T-bill yields increase sharply, Crude Oil revenue increases and the CBN eases on its capital control, then any intervention by the CBN is ultimately fruitless and would simply allow speculators who have the wherewithal to play the game make undeserved profits at the expense of the national treasury. |
Sports › Re: Manchester City Offers Messi A Bumper €750m - 5 Years Contract by einsteine(m): 12:53pm On Aug 31, 2020 |
SEGLIZ: to me that is outrageous on the part of the club, on that of the player 5yrs is rather too much. I believe any contract that would tie him down should be out of it. it is time to tour and enjoy the other side of football while still playing actively. filling different leagues out should be part of his plan. If you had read the post, you will see that he is to spend two or three years of the contract playing in the MLS with Manchester City's US club, New York City FC |
Sports › Re: Manchester City Offers Messi A Bumper €750m - 5 Years Contract by einsteine(m): 12:51pm On Aug 31, 2020 |
GEEBITE: Never knew the Saudis own city.A breaking news for me. The Saudis don't own City. The City football Group (Man City FC, New York City FC Melbourne City FC, Mumbai City FC, Yokohama F Marinos, Kimmel SK, Sinchuan FC, Girona FC, Montevideo City FC) are all owned by a UAE (Abu Dhabi) company owned by the royal family of Abu Dhabi. They own 24 football clubs |
Sports › Re: Barcelona Must Pay €14 Million To Terminate Luis Suarez Contract by einsteine(m): 5:24pm On Aug 30, 2020 |
gangstarmonk: There are fam!
Check and... Stop arguing. Real Madrid and Barca are member owned clubs. They are owned by the fans, the socios |
Sports › Re: Barcelona Must Pay €14 Million To Terminate Luis Suarez Contract by einsteine(m): 3:03pm On Aug 30, 2020 |
gangstarmonk: WTF?
The "INVESTORS" need their monies back that's why you see all these confusion in barca.
Most of them WANT OUT!!!
This is business. The managers have realised it's not about favouritism but making money for the "INVESTORS". Spanish economy is quite difficult, it's tighter in Spain than it is in England. Barca like Madrid is a fan owned club. There are no "investors". |
Crime › Re: We Don’t Need Bank Insider To Transfer Money From Victims’ Phones ― Suspects by einsteine(m): 8:48pm On Aug 28, 2020 |
executive12: Did she lock her sim? She didn't lose her SIM. Her SIM was retrieved using a forged ID card of hers |
Crime › Re: We Don’t Need Bank Insider To Transfer Money From Victims’ Phones ― Suspects by einsteine(m): 11:15am On Aug 28, 2020 |
StRichard: how can you retrieve my sim when you don't even know the number. Just activate PUK lock on your sim, you are safe. Oh ok. Hopefully, it doesn't happen to you. A woman recently lost 3 million that way. |
Crime › Re: We Don’t Need Bank Insider To Transfer Money From Victims’ Phones ― Suspects by einsteine(m): 11:11am On Aug 28, 2020 |
Kendumazy: Just set a sim code for your sim card. If they remove it and insert it into another phone, without them knowing the sim code. The sim is useless to them. Doesn't work if they retrieve the SIM. And yes, illegal SIM swaps are a problem worldwide these days. A guy in the US lost $12 million after someone retrieved his SIM. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 11:02am On Aug 28, 2020 |
ojesymsym: I cannot blame individuals who hold USD, I do also. My response was where you say free market worked in those countries and so must work here. By free market, except of course I do not understand what you meant by free market The market works whether the government likes it or not. In Zimbabwe, people refused to transact with the government issued currency. I stated that those countries tried to go against the markets and failed/are failing. For example, in 2015, people around the world saw the Swiss Franc as a stable currency and started converting dollars and euros and yuans to it. The Swiss tried to prevent this because an appreciating currency hurts their export. They couldn't because the market always wins and the CHF eventually appreciated. Putting obstacles to free markets would always lead to undesirable consequences, in our case, the depletion of the foreign reserve, economic uncertainty and eventually Investor apathy |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 10:53am On Aug 28, 2020 |
pluto09: Sold at 469 and will be waiting to go in again when and if price drops below 400. I don't gain anything by arguing with market or complaining about what the CBN is (not) doing. I am out to take advantage of whatever happens in the market to make some money. The price would drop then go back again. The CBN position is not backed by fundamentals. They can't keep up with the demand in the long term. People are waiting with billions (just like you waiting for it at 400) to snap at any cheap dollars. At the end of the day, the foreign reserve will be depleted. It is a bazaar for speculators and currency hustlers. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 10:50am On Aug 28, 2020 |
ojesymsym: The countries you listed earlier are not import dependent. Nigeria is over 80% import dependent. That's of no relevance to my submission. When the Nigerian auditor at KPMG sees his pension not keeping up with inflation and decides to hold some foreign currency to protect himself, it does not cross his mind that Nigeria is an import dependent country. Even @ahibooilandgas here has been holding dollars (from his posts) and complaining of inflation, why doesn't he offer his dollars to the foreign reserve of the CBN at 360 Naira to a dollar |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 10:24am On Aug 28, 2020 |
ahiboilandgas: u are encouraging criminalilty...tell the chinese govt that that u wan hold dollar by force ....free markets an advertise by the west is not the only principle to develop ....control markets like shown by communist party have lift 500m Chinese out of poverty... Lol, okay sir. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 10:20am On Aug 28, 2020 |
ahiboilandgas: yes husppuppy and Burberry held over 12m dollars on cypto....so we know the source of the dirty income.. Sorry but you are remarkably uninformed. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 10:19am On Aug 28, 2020 |
ahiboilandgas: what percentage can the bank lend from people dorm accounts saving ? infact a large junk will be idle endlessly cos of the risk of paying back by the borrower in dollars cos the enterprises borrowing is earn in Naira and depend on hawish nigerian system to convert back to dollars to feed this dorm accounts with short call time ... Companies are borrowing in dollars everyday. I have read quite a few Credit Approval Memos where the currency was dollars. Also, many loans these days are hedged. That's why there is a forwards market. Besides, you don't make money without a little risk. And there's no problem even if the dollars lie idle. Those dollars could as well be offshore. They are not the entitlement of the Nigerian government. Nigerians have been so used to governments of force and centrally planned economy that the concept of a free market flies over people's heads. If people don't want to hold Naira, you can't force them. There are banks in Cook Islands right now that would open an offshore account for you right from your home and they are full reserve banks. Pretty sure they will be happy to accept Nigerians' idle cash. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 10:12am On Aug 28, 2020 |
ahiboilandgas: u are free to keep it under the pillow ..u are free to do explanations on why u are travelling with over 10k into Nigeria ...u are also free to not send any dollars to nigeria ... Duh. Nigerians are one of the highest holders of cryptocurrencies. I am talking billions. You are talking about cash dollars, lol |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 10:11am On Aug 28, 2020 |
ahiboilandgas: how will they get the dollars since we dont print or plant it in our farms ....meanwhile 20 bn dollars is held by people u dont need it and they buy ever day.... Who says they don't need it? You buy a land and you don't build on it, waiting for it to appreciate, does the government take the land from you? Should they? Secondly, like I pointed out to you, the bank's lend in dollars everyday. Where do you think the money they lend for comes from? Just their capital or capital and deposits? The dollars in domiciliary accounts are not idle. Don't fall for the Buharinomics propaganda |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 10:08am On Aug 28, 2020 |
The free market always wins.
We have seen such economic foolishness in areas like drug prohibition before. We saw it when George Soros broke the Bank of England and the BOE exhausted its foreign reserve trying to defend the pound before giving up. We saw it when the Swiss tried to prevent their currency from appreciating but were forced by the market to give up. We see it when China tries to prevent capital flight and enterprising hustlers still find a way to provide "capital flight services" to those who don't have faith in the CCP and the CNY.
The CBN refusal to allow the Naira a bit of freedom is economic idiocy and only benefits currency profiteers and hustlers. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 10:04am On Aug 28, 2020 |
ahiboilandgas: Dangote is looking for dollars to complete his refinaery via equipment import while some 20bn unproductive dollars are sitting in some accounts including the vp holding over 1m pounds and shouting job creations....they dont need this dollars in the near term ....this hurt the economy and bring in uncessary pressure to rates .....any araka seller can just walk into wema bank open a dorm accounts go to surulere buy at 460 and deposits 100 dollars and add to the pressures.....what does she need the 100 dollars for ....import beans, or fire wood.....or speculative purpose....while xxxx pharmaceutical needs the dollars to import sulphuric acid to make live saving drugs ....he competing with million of akara sellers holding unproductive xxxx million of dollars... Are you familiar with banking at all? Yes, the money is in domiciliary accounts in Nigerian banks, that does not mean that it has also not been lent out to Dangote. It's just like saying SMEs are looking for loans yet there are trillions of Naira in Nigerian bank accounts. |
Investment › Re: Treasury Bills In Nigeria by einsteine(m): 10:02am On Aug 28, 2020 |
ahiboilandgas: what is the monthly genuine demand of dollars by the Nigeria economy ? What is the speculative demand...what is the corrupt income demand .....the last two demads are false demands and many Nigerians holding dollars up and down dont have any tangible reasons ,buying and hoarding dollars to speculative....going forward i will advice the cbn to shut down dorm accounts holding ...once your are in Nigeria u must spend Naira .....Naira is the tender here ....why do americans, British and other dont hold dorm naira accounts in Britain .......20 bn dollars unproductive dollars warehouse in dorm accounts .....this false demand must be taken out.... Your policy would be completely counterproductive. You assume that domiciliary accounts are the only way to hold foreign currency in a globalised environment. Some of us would be happy to take advantage of such economic stupidity should the CBN engage in it. It is simple, if people don't have faith in your currency, even if you carry guns to force them to hold your currency, they won't. That's how free markets work. |
Jobs/Vacancies › Re: FG Moves To Absorb N-power Beneficiaries Into Mdas by einsteine(m): 9:51am On Aug 28, 2020 |
LeitaP: We are No we are not. Facts. This is a country of 200 million people. To be super rich we need to have a GDP greater than Germany's. We are not super rich. I don't know why people keep repeating this lie. Nigeria produces two million barrels of oil which provides majority of government revenue. Go check out Norway, a country with less 4% of Nigeria's population producing the same amount of crude oil. Yet pikers would say Nigeria is rich. Don't let the fact that a few people get high pay fool you. As an example, $4.6 billion is the total Abacha loot returned since 1999. Divide it by each Nigerian and you will get about 10,000 each. Is that what you call super rich? |
Jobs/Vacancies › Re: FG Moves To Absorb N-power Beneficiaries Into Mdas by einsteine(m): 9:45am On Aug 28, 2020 |
LeitaP: Olujoba, Nigeria is super rich, don't mind the loan thing, our leaders are just not advanced to respect it's citizens.
A good government regards it's citizens with respect ours is the opposite. Nigeria is not super rich. |
Jobs/Vacancies › Re: FG Moves To Absorb N-power Beneficiaries Into Mdas by einsteine(m): 9:44am On Aug 28, 2020 |
Scam. How will they be paid? |