Elampiro's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Elampiro's Profile › Elampiro's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 (of 561 pages)
Nihilist: I just gave you a classic example of how Wingbacks are employed at Barcelona.* Barca don't use wing backs. They play either 4-4-2 or 4-3-3. Barca uses Mascherano and Pique as Central defenders. They use Alves and Alba as full backs (not wing backs.). Sanches and Neymer/Iniester as wingers. Bousquet and Xavi as CMs. Alves overlaps as a full back. * Man United played 4-4-2. Rafael behind Valencia permanently. Rafael overlaps to support him and interchange passes with Val. Val falls back to help out in defence- but never the full back. Same happens on the left side of the team. * You mentioned wikipedia. Take a look below for the three roles: ................... Full-back The full-backs take up the holding wide positions and traditionally stayed in defence at all times, until a set-piece. Modern full-backs take a more attacking role, overlapping with wingers down the flank. There is one full-back on each side of the field except in defences with fewer than four players, where there may be no full-backs and instead only centre backs.[7] The traditional English full-back was a large, strong man who would make substantial use of "hacking" – deliberately kicking the shins of opponents, a practice that was accepted as legal in Britain but not in other countries, and caused major controversy as the game became increasingly internationalised from the 1950s on. It is now effectively banned everywhere, and it is this in part that has given rise to a different set of defensive roles. The full-backs have become essential in the modern game formation 4-3-3 or the now commonly used 4-2-3-1 formation. In the modern game, full-backs have taken on a more attacking role than is the case traditionally.[8] Wingerless formations, such as the diamond 4–4–2 formation, demand the full-back to cover considerable ground up and down the flank. Some of the responsibilities of modern full-backs include: .......... Wing-back The wing-back is a modern variation on the full-back with heavier emphasis on attack. The name is a portmanteau of "winger" and "full-back". They are usually employed in a 3-5-2 formation, and could therefore be considered part of the midfield, although they may also be used in a 5–3–2 formation, in which they would have a more defensive role. In the evolution of the modern game, wing-backs are the combination of wingers and full-backs. As such, it is one of the most physically demanding positions in modern football. Wing-backs are often more adventurous than full-backs and are expected to provide width, especially in teams without wingers. A wing-back needs to be of exceptional stamina, be able to provide crosses upfield and defend effectively against opponents' attacks down the flanks. A defensive midfielder is usually fielded to cover the advances of wing-backs.[12] .............. . Winger A winger (left winger and right winger) (historically called outside-left and outside-right, or outside forward) is an attacking player who is stationed in a wide position near the touchlines. They can be classified as forwards, considering their origin as the old outside forward who played out on the "wing" (i.e. side of the pitch). They continue to be termed as such in many parts of the world, especially in Latin and Dutch footballing cultures. However, in the English-speaking world, they are usually counted as part of the midfield having been pushed back there with the advent of the 4-4-2 formation which gradually rose to prominence in the 1960s, given the role additional defensive duties. A winger's main attribute is usually speed which is used to attack and dribble past opponent's full-backs in order to get behind the defence and to then deliver crosses and passes into the centre for their attackers. Occasionally left and right footed wingers may swap sides of the field as a tactical move to enable the winger to cut inside against the opposing full-backs weaker foot, looking for a shooting opportunity or just as a means of opening up the defence. Clubs such as Barcelona and Real Madrid often choose to play their wingers on the 'wrong' flank for this reason.[citation needed] Although wingers are a familiar part of football, the use of wingers is by no means universal, and many successful teams have operated without wingers. At the 1966 World Cup, England manager Alf Ramsey led a team without natural wingers to the title; this was unusual enough at the time for the team to be nicknamed "The Wingless Wonders".[17] A more recent example is that of Italian club Milan, who have typically played in a narrow midfield diamond formation or in a "Christmas tree" formation (4–3–2–1), relying on attacking full-backs to provide the necessary width down the wings. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Association_football_positions |
This is full backs and wngers. The full backs take care of the defensive flank. They can overlap. The wingers can fall back to defend, but with the full back with last man responsibility at the flank. *** In the wing back system, these full backs don't exist to protect the flanks.
|
From this pics, it can be seen wing backs are responsible for covering the full back positions. The traditional full backs are not existent, instead there are three central defenders which play close to one another leaving the flanks for the wing backs (particularly when defending as we have seen in Gaals games so far).
|
Nihilist: I completely understand what you are saying, but I think where you are making the mistake is assuming that footballers stay static all game.I didn't understand your Valencia and Rafael's example. However, for Val to be considered as playing as wing back, there shouldn't be a permanent right full back behind him. And for Rafael to be considered as playing as a wing back, he shouldn't be part of a four man defence and playing behind a winger at same time. |
Nihilist: The wing-back is a modern variation on the full-back with heavier emphasis on attack. The name is a portmanteau of "winger" and "full-back". They are usually employed in a 3-5-2 formation, and could therefore be considered part of the midfield, although they may also be used in a 5–3–2 formation, in which they would have a more defensive role.* Did you see that? 3-5-2 or 5-3-2. * You have just helped my argument. Is this not what I have been saying all along? There is a difference between a wing back and a full back, also a winger. Wing backs don't have full backs behind them. They play in front of three CBs. They cover the length and breath of their flank. In 4-4-2, we have full backs and wingers. Valencia is a winger while Rafael is the right full back. They may however support themselves with overlapping runs or tracking back. * Note again. Winger, Wingback, fullback are all different. I will explain soon. If you understood these roles, you need to ask yourself how you can probably pay wing backs in a 4-4-2. |
coogar: when we had keane/scholes in our midfield. you mean both of them played defensive midfielders at the same time or attacking midfielders at the same time?Remember too, compare likes for likes. Apples and Oranges. Lol |
coogar: when we had keane/scholes in our midfield. you mean both of them played defensive midfielders at the same time or attacking midfielders at the same time?You said Evra played wingback all his life. And you also said Young had always played this role everytime. So we have been playing four wing backs ever since? If we add Rafael and Valencia, it meant we had four wing backs in every match. |
coogar: y'all are making this wing-back thingy look like a new concept. every winger in a 4-4-2 playing in the premier league is technically a wing-back, maybe except ronaldo after a while & fergie beefed him for a while.Here, Coogar thinks or even defined wing backs as wingers who track back to help his defence. coogar: you are making this up.....Here it's the defenders, not wingers anymore. How can we have two wing backs on same flank in same match, or even four wingbacks for a team in a particular match? This tells me that what Gaal is doing is far different and special. |
coogar: what is the difference?Here, Coogar thinks or even defined wing backs as wingers who track back to help his defence. I remember he even used Rooney as an example of someone who has played that role previously. coogar: you are making this up.....Here, Coogar think a wing back is a defender (full back) who can overlap to provide attacking threats and cope attacking stats. ........................... * This is contradiction. * Under 4-4-2, it then means Evra and Young/Rooney are wingbacks at same time, on same side of the pitch and in same match. Same as Rafael and Valencia. Gaal in his wisdom has come up with a new formation and new functions for our wingers. He plays three standing defenders and made our wingers specialists in several things. Anyone who has seen our matches this season shouldn't be in any doubt as to the fact that our wingers are operating differently. Enough said already. |
Nihilist: To be honest, the difference between the Wing Back and Winger or Wing Back and Full Back is very minute.I am afraid you got it wrong. First, Valencia occasional appearance at the right back did not start in the last two seasons. It started almost since his arrival. Infact, last season was about his least. Secondly, it doesn't look like you watch United preseason matches to understand exactly the difference between Val's role now and previous. Val didn't usually displace the right back from his position as he does now. He supported the LB. Now he's the LB while while we defend, the actual LB moves to central defence. Thirdly, Valencia used to run ahead of midfielders while we build, now he plays with them on same line, or even slightly behind. Finally, your definition of a wing back doesn't match with Coogar's. I will expose this later when I am free. |
coogar: system is the same, only formation & personnel switched. in your first system, young & valencia become the full backs when defending. in the second one, you claim only 4 defenders maintain the offside trap - that is wrong. the defensive midfielder sits between both centre halves to sweep.* carrick plays in front of Vidic and Ferdinand. He only slots in between when situation warrants. Like when one of the CB has gone to cover for a full back. Carrick is a shield to the CBs and not a CB while we defend. But Valencia and Young are full backs when we defend under this formation. * All the media outlets quoted Gaal at same time, and it's same information. If he were misinterpreted, one or two should have quoted him as saying a different thing. |
coogar: it was their responsibility in the past too. no winger gets to stroll on the pitch. even number-10s these days are told to track back & do some heavy defensive duties. the game has evolved. when ronaldo wasn't tracking back, fergie berated him openly on the pitch to track back & get the ball back - that was part of his duties as a winger. you attack & defend at the same time.No no. It has never been like this. I paid particular attention to their movements. While we defend now. ------------------DDG Val----- Smalling--Jones--Evans-----young. (5 men on same line trained to maintain the offside trap). Before -----------------DDG Smalling----Jones----Evans----Evra (4 men keeping the offside trap) -Valencia -----------------------Young (Protecting the full backs) coogar: no, the media has completely interpreted what he had said.Even though he was quoted by several media outlets? I won't be surprised to hear you say the media misinerpreted him on the 3-5-2 (3-4-1-2) formation. May be he told the media United will play 4-4-2 and 4-2-1-3, then media reported 3-5-1-2 and 4-3-3. |
coogar: so young wasn't doing this in the past? wingers don't track back to help their full backs when we are defending? really?So you still can't see the difference? I have explained their new defence responsibility enough. You use the term 'help'. That's the difference. Now, they don't help, it's their responsibility. coogar: so you cannot even defend this notion of yours - you are just following the media as usual? christ - and you call yourself a football pundit. there's nothing young is doing now that he didn't do in the past seasons, same as valencia.So you implied Gaal is following the media? OMG! The media are quoting professor Gaal. The master of the tactics. |
For those who watched the last match on the glo/MUFC app, what's your experience? How much was charged? Can you repeat the matches? |
Hugoboi: What time is the game?1am. It looks like I'll miss this one. I will watch it later with the benefit of the club website. One can repeat the full matches over and over again once one has paid. |
coogar: what is this thing he enjoyed doing?* The new system. The new wing back role. * “ it’s a new system and I feel capable of going out there and doing well." Ashley Young. http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/ashley-young-happy-play-wing-back-3948731 |
coogar: trash!I hear u. Gaal and Young are lying. Nothing new abi. * Young now has a mandatory duty to defend on same backline as our defenders (once we are being pressed). Once we lost possession, he knows his responsibility is to fall back and fill the left full back. Unlike before where he was meant to shield the LFB or block for the LFB when occasion warrants. I just said it as a lay man. But Gaal knows it all as the prof of the tactics. Even his students have admitted it's different. Beginning from L A Galaxy, we saw Shaw playing an odd role. Today is Monday. I beg. Gaal said it's different for the wing backs. Just take it. |
coogar: stop making your own argument - i asked you a question you haven't answered since last night. what's ashley young doing now that he wasn't doing before the arrival of van gaal?* “I’m enjoying playing there,” said Young. “The Inter game was only the second time I had played there, but we go through it in training, it’s a new system and I feel capable of going out there and doing well." Ashley Young. http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/ashley-young-happy-play-wing-back-3948731 |
RuuDie: To simplify matters... a full-back, wing-back or whatever you wanna call 'em are all DEFENDERS or in our local parlance BACK-MEN! The difference being in they are more attack-minded or are primed to be so...Ashley Young and Valencia now have to seat deeper. But they don't play on same backline as Smalling-Jones-Evans. Smalling and Evans are the full backs when we are in possession, but quickly drift to central defence as we defend. The wing backs are trained to align themselves on same back line when we defend. Under 4-4-2 they play high up the flanks, and only required to shield the full backs (play in front of the FBs as DMs) while we defend, except full backs are out of positions or displaced, then they fill the gaps (voluntarily). |
coogar: this is neither here nor there.....i can't see the point you are making.* At the end of next season. Let's us have Ashley Young attacking and defending stat vs Evra's 2012/2013, same with Rafael and Venlencia/Nani. That will make you to understand that the difference in the formation. * The heatmap you produced says nothing. Even Gary Neville and Ivanovic heat map will reflect same. You also produced Evra's map from an isolated outing. Let's compare that with James against Galaxy. * So you are telling us Gaal is teaching our wingers nothing new? And that Gaal doesn't know what he's saying? Ashley Young said it's a new system. Other players too. |
Dadehmola: In short, the argument has shifted to "whether van gaal knows what he's saying or not".Ok. |
Van Gaal believes that the new system helps him to fit his best players into the team in positions in which they are comfortable. “That’s why I chose this system, I can play them all. But Hernandez can also play in the striker’s position, so can Welbeck,” said Van Gaal, who also played with a back three during the Netherlands’ World Cup campaign, leading the side to third place. “Rooney can play at number 10 and number nine and he tells me he can also play at number 11 and number seven, but I prefer him at number nine or number 10. “When you look at the quality of your players you see Rooney, Van Persie, [Javier] Hernandez, Mata, Welbeck, [Marouane] Fellaini, [Ander] Herrera – a lot of players can play this system. “So with this system, two strikers can play, the number 10 can play, two midfielders can play, so the specialists become the wing-backs.” http://www.squawka.com/news/van-gaal-on-352/149460 After the Roma match. |
The Dutchman has been especially pleased with the way that his defenders have adapted to the 3-4-1-2 system which he h "It's not a new system for Mata, Rooney or Welbeck, who play in their position, neither is it a new system for the two midfielders. "The greatest impact with this new system is on the back line. "It's amazing we had one chance against us in the first half, and two in the second." http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/louis-van-gaal-delighted-manchester-3966349 |
coogar: #jokes!Gaal has said in about three interviews that the wing backs functions are different under this 3-4-1-2 formation. He said they are the specialists. In another interview he went on to state Rooney, Welbeck, Mata and the two central midfielders retains their functions under the new formation. *** As for Evra's attacking stat. It's not peculiar to him. Rafael assist and scores. Even Vidic and Ferdi score. Evra score over about 80% of his goals from set play, particularly corner kicks. Rafael tend to score more from open play. *** When either Rafael or Evra scored from open play, it meant they overlapped. But under the new system, Young and Val can't be said to overlap if they score from open play. |
coogar: you are making this up.....No. There is a big difference between what Evra and co do and what Shawn/Young is expected to do. Evra/Rafael duty is to defend first. They are a part of a permanent backline. Their overlap is a risk to the entire team. On the other hand, Young and Valencia can play freely up front with the comfort that there men behind them. Even Gaal has said in the new formation, only the two central midfielders and the forwards retain their play from 4-4-2. He said the major job, training, coaching and adjustment is on the wing backs and defenders. |
coogar: so tell me.....what are they differently now that they weren't doing before? surely, you and afrodoc have never seen wingers track back before to help their full backs in the premier league. this is the first time it's happening.Before: Our wingers were more of defensive midfielders while we defend. They play in front of our full backs majorly. The full backs are responsible for defending the wing back at the flanks. Now: Our wingers are defenders while we defend. They stay on same defensive line as the back three to form a back five. They maintain the offside line and trap as the real defenders do. They block the defensive flanks while the number two and three drift inwards. While attacking, they don't really play like traditional wingers. It's a whole lot of knocking the ball around which they are involve in. |
coogar: what is the difference?The difference is much. Review the matches well. The wingers functions are far different now. |
teeo: My only fear with Fletcher is the way he breaks down with a flu. Tomorrow we might hear he has fallen sick again, if not I think we can do without Vidal at least till January. I don't think Vidal is worthy £47m, that's too much.I missed Fletcher of 2009. He was very important for us, particularly in the UCL. We missed him in the final. I wish he could get his energy and total game back. He can convert corner kicks too. |
teeo:Yes, that is the area without proper back up. What do you think of Fletcher in the midfield? |
coogar: i saw the goal - young scored it. rooney did nothing to effect the trajectory of the ball. head scores goals not strands of hair.It actually looked Rooney got a head on it and the ball took an immediate bend afterwards. When one reasons the ball hit the upright before going in, then there is a great chance the goal should have been awarded to Rooney if it were an EPL fixture with many cameras available to reach a solid conclusion. But Rooney has not claimed the goal either, so there is no need to belabour this. It was a Man United goal at the end. |
Dadehmola:Yes o. After Young's goals, Coogar is like a mad Cobra now. Until the venon is completely unleashed, he wouldn't be calmed. So keep off. |
^^^ I beg I no fit argue. I am happy we are playing well. But wait, when everyone is fit? It seems you have forgotten Valencia in 2010 before his broke his leg- even in the UCL matches. If you look at UCL again, you will see Young is the under performing. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 (of 561 pages)
