PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 (of 287 pages)
Image123:Actually I was tired because it was late and I spent a lot of time on a post that did nothing but demonstrate the ignorance of the poster. I'd rather have been dealing with pertinent points than with 'needless rigmarole and much ado about nothing'. |
Image123:Actually I was tired because it was late and I spent a lot of time on a post that did nothing but demonstrate the ignorance of the poster. I'd rather have been dealing with pertinent points than with 'needless rigmarole and much ado about nothing'. |
I'll come back to deal with this post tomorrow. I don tire. Image123: |
Was minor Textual variations like commas etc the main thrust of Ehrmann's work. The answer is No. Why is it the only thing that these guys can address? Even Ehrman himself said they were not that important. It smacks of dishonesty. Image123: |
Image123:No wahala, we are here now. To this, i replied,I hope you are not suggesting by putting research in open/close inverted commas that Ehrmanns views are not backed by research, or that his research had no part to play in his argument. Yes, I agree that they both brought their facts. So it is those facts that we now have to turn too. The first video that frosb presented on the thread, that sort of brought us to this point of the discussion implied that the Bible is not reliable, and that this view is the consensus view among critical scholars. Now, he subtly adds that the new testament contains errors and discrepancies and variants and uses that to arrive at the implication that the Bible is unreliable. This is dishonesty subtly used on the undiscerning. THE FACT is that the majority of what he calls errors, discrepancies and variants are insignificant and trivial stuff. They are things like punctuation marks and spelling errors. Every one knows this, every scholar consents to this. It is almost common sense implied, because we have so many Bible versions and the majority of christians refer to them all as the Bible. Of course different versions have different wordings, spellings, sentences , punctuations etc. Cunningly implying that the Bible is not reliable as a consensus is the issue here.First let's know what we are talking about. The topic of this thread is 'Who wrote the New Testament'?. The discussion have ranged in and out of the confines of this but that was the initial gist. My contribution to this thread really got involved when the issue of inerrancy came up. This is different from knowing who wrote the bible. People are claiming, and I believe that you don't disagree with them, that the bible is inerrant in matters of history and in matters of science. This is my bone of contention. I say that the bible is not an historical document and it is not a scientific document either. Ehrmann and I are in agreement on that. in fact in the second link that frosbel posted Ehrman started off like this: Our ultimate question comes down to whether the gospels are reliable or not. My view is that the gospels have mistakes, discrepancies, contradictions, factual errors, textual alterations, additions, omissions and corruptions in them. Now I have noticed from the responses of people like yourself, and the scholars opposed to Ehrman that they constantly and continuously fixate on the fact that the discrepancies are things like commas etc. But you all seem so terrified to address any of the other points that makes which he himself says are the more crucial points. Ehrmann agrees that the minor details are not that important. I noticed that you are trying to make him sound dishonest by saying : In the 35th minute, Ehrman finally confesses like a possessed man by saying "Most of these 400,000 mistakes IN FACT are not important AT ALL. The mistakes are COMPLETELY INSIGNIFICANT, immaterial and matter for nothing." So you mean to tell me that in the entire video and with all that he said it is only the minor discrepancies part that he himself says is 'completely insignificant', that is the only part that you can make any comment on. Who is being possessed with dishonesty? Who needs to make confessions? He says every new testament agree with him and teaches it in every Ivy league school. What are the teaching and agreeing with him? That the Bible is not reliable? Of course not. What they teach and which is truth is that the manuscripts contain variants. The Bible is both theologically and historically reliable. He claimed to be searching for the truth and not afraid to go wherever the truth seems to lead. For me, i cannot follow such blind search. i already found the truth, and it is in God's Word. Of course, you know God's Word. i'm not going to leave it because there is a comma here that is not there. Only someone who has not found Jesus would be so foolish.You see where you said historically reliable there, together with theologically reliable. That is where God has caught you. Professor Bruce Metzger is an authority, he has done research. Actually, he taught your lord Bart in Princeton where Bart received his PhD and M.Div. Though he is late now, but if we are talking about scholar or research or critical or whatever other high sounding title you hope to bamboozle us with. Bruce Metzger is Ehrman's daddy, lord, oga and master. Professor Metzger says it is safe for any scholar to say at least 99% of the New testament Bible is reliable. He said the New Testament Bible is more than 99% accurate. no ancient document or literature has the kind of documentary support that the New testament Bible has. This is fact. It follows that whatever conclusions we make on the New Testament Bible, we should be prepared to make same on ALL ancient literature.Ol boi, even Einstein had a teacher. Einstein's teacher cannot claim to be his daddy, lord, oga and master when it comes to modern physics. what you've said up there is so inane... At the end of the day I will be more likely to give a theory consideration if it is put forward by a scholar than by you. Now that doesn't mean that it should be swallowed hook line and sinker, but it makes it worthy of consideration. At the end of the day you have your own brain to think with. I can understand Ehrmann referring to a lot of authorities in bible scholarship in a debate because he wants to demonstrate that he is not a crank acting on his own. That is his purpose for making references to other authorities. If you doctor tells you that you have to undergo a very expensive operation and then noticing your consternation he refers you to another doctor for a second opinion, it is to help you confirm what he is saying has merit. If you like claim that the dead doctor that taught your own doctor medicine said otherwise so you'll dismiss your doctor's advise, especially when you know that medicine advances everyday and there are always new discoveries. Oh.. and before I forget. 99% reliable or accurate is NOT inerrant. We haven't even gone into reliable as what. Does he mean reliable as an historical document? That part in brown is a very correct fact but what those of you that keep going on about that fail to get is that No one is making those claims for any other ancient literature that are being made for the bible. Yes, we all know that there are mistakes in copying Homer and Plato etc and that their student added to their works. We all accept that as a fact. We can not fully know what Socrates' philosophy was. But why is it so hard for you to accept the same for the bible? Why this supernatural claims when we know how distorted all books from antiquity are? Ehrman and his minions make all the fuss and noise and ado about the New Testament manuscripts having textual variations. What he should emphasize more is the fact that more than 75% of these textual variations are irrelevant spelling differences and punctuation.He, after making note of the variations, emphasizes over and over again how irrelevant they are. He then goes on to make some very salient points. Why do you tremble when it comes to considering those points for discussion? I actually think Ehrmann is gentle. Me, I would construct more devastating arguments, personally. 8 minutes into your video in quote, Bart Ehrman states that the debate is not about the validity or importance of the Bible. An extremely confused man if i may so point out. Anyways, aio, frosb and other minions should carefully note that. The validity of the Bible is not in question by scholars. The Bible is valid and more than 99% reliable. The importance of the Bible is not a debate. It is not time to throw away the Bible and go on some wild goose chase looking for what is not missing.No, the debate is NOT about the validity and importance of the bible. There is nothing confused or confusing about that. The debate is about whether or not we have the Original New testament. It is the very title of the video, how can you miss that? I never said that the bible was not valid (ie to have value). And please note that by stating that the bible is 99% reliable you have already admitted that it is not inerrant. even if you think that the error is only 1%. It's game over, but I'm having such fun so I'll continue. Bingo!! The importance of the bible is not a debate, or even The debate. Please acquaint yourself with the title of the video one more time. and furthermore no one has told you to throw away your bible. Again, i'm assuming that the evil spirit that lives inside Bart came late for this debate. In the beginning of the presentation around the 11:20 mark, Ehrman says again that "Whoever Mark was, he wrote the gospel".What is your point? Nobody is saying that the gospel wasn't written by someone. Those that are claiming that God wrote it have ducked. This is before he started ranting and blustering about original manuscripts being copied, and that he somehow knows that mistakes are being made everywhere along the line. Well, we should apply that line of reasoning on every ancient literature possible. Socrates, Herodotus, Shakespeare, Caesar, Homer and other important and unimportant historians. Also, the early christian fathers like Augustine, Ignatius, Iraneus, Jerome etc. All their works are copied, we do not have their original manuscripts.Such line of reason is applied to every ancient literature possible. But it is only raises anxiety amongst people such as yourself when it is applied to the bible. So what? We cannot conclude what their original text is. So there is nothing like Shakespeare. Forget all those Macbeth and whatever books you have read. Shakespeare didn't write them, because we cannot conclude what his original text might be, as we do not have his original manuscript. Let us conclude that it has all being doctored and twisted. That is a most insane thing to embark on, that is not critical thinking but a manipulation by the devil on poor human souls who are taken captive by him at his will.Now you are just being f oolish. Why should I forget Macbeth even if it were discovered that Shakespeare didn't write it? This has been suggested so many time already in fact and nobody threw Macbeth away. It has been suggested that his actors improvised and devised some of his lines and he just polished them up. You can acquaint yourself with some of those arguments here: http://www.shakespeareoxfordfellowship.org/wp-content/uploads/Oxfordian2010_top_ten.pdf Yet no one is throwing macbeth away and nobody is crying and pulling their hair out over whether or not shakespeare actually existed. The difference is that you have a vested interest in a certain narrative of how the bible came to be and your psychological well being rests on that narrative. To suggest anything other than the narrative is nothing short of an attack on your sanity. Bart claims that 2Corinthians is made up of five separate letters, that somebody copied and pasted from each five and made one. i say that is an assumption at best. There is no proof to that super story and its similar ones which i am aware of that some 'scholars' bandy around. What i know and do not just assume is that the Scriptures cannot be broken, and that the Word of God cannot pass away. You can take that to the bank with Bart and others. The Bible will continue to outlive its pallbearers. Voltaire was more vociferous, i can tell you what happened to him if you do not know.Leave the 5 letters becoming corinthians part because he makes reference to the research of other scholars but does not lay out the arguments, most likely because of lack of time, so we cannot peruse and examine them. Even to call them an 'assumption at best' is an assumption on your part. I'm sure Ehrmann doesn't go hunting for manuscripts himself, so I doubt he can ever say 'that I can find'. It is the academic community as a whole that discovers texts from various sources and they then present it to the community as a whole. Peer review is very important. Earliest may not be more authoritative but it is definitely more likely to be closer to the original. That is a desperate point you are making there. Papyrus was in use through all of the first millenium and so was parchment which was more durable (I think). The dead sea scrolls which were written in the first century before CE survived and they were written on paper. Another of your desperate arguments. Also, when Bart asks where are the original manuscripts, i take that as a senseless question. Because he knows about papyrus and scrolls and how they cannot survive for long. This is without mentioning the gruel history of persecution and wars particularly against the Bible, and major efforts to obliterate it. Is he unaware of these or has he forgotten? Should we take it from him that all books rewritten, reprinted, or having editions are problems? This is his conclusion on the New testament Bible for not seeing the original manuscript.Ehrmann asks a very sensible question consider the title of the debate. If you are looking for the Original New Testament what questions would you ask? The Dead sea scrolls survived, so what are you talking about? Desperation. But you are actually starting to get interesting when you talk about wars and persecution against the bible, and efforts to obliterate it. Me o, I'm not aware of this. Pray tell. I cannot speak for Ehrmann but I don't know about any war fought against the bible or attempt to obliterate it. If it is not your imagination going kookoo please give us the historical facts on this new story. The problem of not finding the original manuscript is very very problematic when you are trying to ascertain whether the New Testament we have today is the Original one. It makes sense to me. When he(Bart) says 4th century manuscripts differ significantly from 9th century manuscripts, he forgets to highlight his context of significance. Textual variations of spelling differences or synonyms or punctuations are not christian significant.None of these significant differences changes any cardinal truth of the christian faith. There are no blatant contradictions that we would lose sleep over.The issue is not of the cardinal truth of the christian faith. The issue is whether the bible has preserved it's form over the centuries. I've pointed this out about 3 times now so I hope it has sunk in. at the 35th minute, he didn't finally confess like he was under duress or something. He stated quite clearly in his opening talk that they were not significant to the christian doctrines. you ask, what on earth are we arguing about? I'll repeat it one more time. The issue is whether or not the bible has changed from it's original form or not and whether we can say that we have the Original bible. Not it's reliability as a source of doctrines but whether what we have is reliably true to the original. You really gave me an assignment here with this your long post that only shows that you're not even on the topic of discussion. Like I said before Ehrmann doesn't go into more devastating points on the bible probably because he was sticking to the topic of the discussion but if it is about reliability in matters of science and history that you want to talk about then I have some points that I'd happily share with you and I'm an anonymous guy so I can afford to be more devastating than Ehrmann. |
ekochris:Yes, I'm saying that you can see other planets with naked eyes from earth? Please let's not extend this. there are 7 planets (wanderers) that can be seen with unclad eyes from earth and we have been aware of for thousands of years. Namely, The Sun, The Moon, Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter and Saturn. We used them to name the 7 days of the week. Sun- Sunday Moon - Monday Mars (german twi) - Tuesday (french Mardi) Mercury (german woden)- Wednesday (french Mercredi) Jupiter (norse Thor) - Thursday (french Jeudi) Venus (norse Freya) - Friday (french vendredi) saturn - Saturday when telescopes and stuff were discovered that was when we became aware of other planets that the eyes cannot see, such as uranus, neptune and pluto. |
vooks:What's going on here? What did I dismiss on the basis of having no death records? Where did I do this? Sebi you asked me whether certain people died and I answer to the best of my ability. I didn't know. Furthermore there are accounts claiming that they didn't die. The bible itself is full of stories of people who didn't die. Enoch and Elijah spring foremost to mind. There is also this passage in the 21st chapter of John. …21So Peter seeing him said to Jesus, "Lord, and what about this man?" 22Jesus said to him, "If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you? You follow Me!" 23Therefore this saying went out among the brethren that that disciple would not die; yet Jesus did not say to him that he would not die, but only, "If I want him to remain until I come, what is that to you?"…So obviously the notion of never dying was not that strange to early christians. I'm still at a loss as why you feel anxious that this undermines the bible. vooks:I am not assured. Although I'm sure that you've assured yourself. Catholics would disagree with you and tell you that Mary, Jesus' mother, is still alive. Elijah was alive in the 1st century and is still alive today, according to most christian and judaic beliefs. Please read the following: Li Ching-Yuen or Li Ching-Yun (simplified Chinese: 李清云; traditional Chinese: 李清雲; pinyin: Lǐ Qīngyún; died May 6, 1933) was a Chinese herbalist who supposedly lived to be over 256 years old.[1][2] He claimed to be born in 1736, while disputed records suggest 1677. Both alleged lifespans of 197 and 256 years far exceed the longest confirmed lifespan of 122 years and 164 days of the French woman Jeanne Calment. His true date of birth was never determined. He was reported to be a martial artist, herbalist and tactical advisor.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elixir_of_life |
vooks:I don't, although I'm aware that Catholic's claim that the vatican is built around his tomb. I can't remember the name of the cathedral built on it. I'm also aware of a tradition that says that Mary was assumed into heaven. There are many such traditions both within orthodox christianity and outside of it. But I don't get what you are trying to get at. Is there a point to any of this? |
ekochris:Lots and lots and lots of times. Last night Venus was the evening star. as time goes it will set later and later in the evening till it reaches a certain distance from the sun then it'll reverse and start setting earlier and earlier. I've done a little bit of study of astronomy and so I'm not just believing what scientists say. I see it. The following is photographic evidence of venus and mercury setting together a few days ago. Above them you can also see mars. http://astronomer.wpengine.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/Mercury-Venus-1024x609.png |
Bidam:See mumu o! Your guy has yet to produce a single argument and you're telling him to not wast time arguing here. That is the time honour get-out clause of deluded religious fantasists. At least you're admitting your demonic origins with all your trembling and getting upset. Next time you see me, 'visibly' in your hallucinations go up and introduce yourself and then tell us what the PastorAio that you hallucinated said to you. |
vooks:I don't. |
Bidam:This one just dey come and already he is yarning methane gas. I don't know where he saw me that I was 'visibly upset'. where you even fit see me sef? If you were not so desperately anxious to stop me from exposing your nasty dirty lying delusions you would take time to watch the video and see therein that Bart Ehrmann presents some of his research in his arguments. But I understand that you would call me an atheist, and I suppose when the deity in question is your fantasy of a schizoid God that specially wrote the bible for you to make up doctrines according to the opacity of your imagination, then it will have to be admitted that I am an Atheist. I don't believe in the existence of your Fantasy deity. |
Image123: please explain the logic of this to me, it makes no sense to me. If I call it erroneous with unknown authorship that means that you cannot appeal to it as an authority? You are free to appeal to anything as an authority. that's your business. The bone of contention is your claim that it's authorship is from God. You say God used the people who are traditionally supposed to have written it to write it, but you cannot prove any of this. There you go, you're doing it again. Even after showing all the areas where your claims for it fail with a capital F you still insist on calling it infallible. Again that's your own private business. I never said that I'm the only one in the world who has done research you are getting emotional and desperate in your anxiety. I have only asked you to present your research. While I posted a video of a debate where Bart Ehrmann discusses his research in arguments to prove his point, you have presented nothing. Your latest claim now is that God himself wrote the bible. How did you arrive at this conclusion? Can you present any argument to support this assertion? Anyway I'll come back to this spurious claim with some scriptures. Hah! 'Dumb' donkey. see desperation. I quoted a common saying that you can't make a donkey drink even if you took it to the water. You've added 'dumb' to my words. Please o! unless the shoe fits you leave the shoe alone. However if it fits then feel free to wear it anyhow you like. Oh so it is not known to you or your authority? And because of that, it can safely be assumed that it is unknown to me?Since it is known to you because you have so much inside information that scholars studying ancient documents don't have then you should tell us and provide the evidences to back it up. You put up a debate video as your research. i'm sorry, you have put up mine too. The video contains two 'scholars' on opposing assessments. i'll put up a summary in my subsequent posts though.You are soooo desperate. If you watch the video you will see therein where Ehrman is talking he is presenting various evidences and arguments in favour of his viewpoint. The strongest point that the opposing scholar made is that he was a private witness of some manuscripts that are not yet in public circulation. And Ehrmann says until such a time that he himself can see the evidence he'll have to suspend judgment on that (or words to that effect). You have to be joking i am certain. Ehrman is 59years oldHave you heard of Parody? maybe you haven't. I was parodying your comment about your Gods and heroes having studied the bible for 'decades'. [size=15pt]so let us get back to you God authored the bible claim. Who was 'God' referring to when he wrote the following: 12 But to the rest speak I, not the Lord: If any brother hath a wife that believeth not, and she be pleased to dwell with him, let him not put her away 1Cor chapt. 7 or this in the same chapter: 25 Now concerning virgins I have no commandment of the Lord: yet I give my judgment, as one that hath obtained mercy of the Lord to be faithful. When your God was writing this what was going on in his head? Is he a split personality mentally deranged God? He says: "I, not the Lord". So is he God or is he not God, or is there a different lord? If your God has such schizoid tendencies then your behaviour makes perfect sense. You need deliverance, my guy. But first let me wait for you to come and explain why your Author would refer to himself as not being the author of his judgment even as he is giving the judgment. [/size] |
it is quite interesting that xtianity for some should be dependent on whether the authors of the bible are as we have been told and that the contents of the bible must necessarily be without error. PastorOluT: |
Joshthefirst:No sir, it is not called hypocrisy it is called science. In science works are peer reviewed and consensus is reached. The authority does not need to be convenient, there is already a community of experts and authorities of all shades and hues. Aha! Persecution complex!! Now we're getting to the bottom of things. 'Everybody is wrong and I am right' and 'they are just jealous'. But no consideration of the fact/possibility that you might just be plain wrong and living in kuku land. Please tell us about these other issues. Where is the scientific evidence for the darkness? and please remember that Jesus was crucified in Jerusalem. |
Joshthefirst:Right, so it was an assumption without any basis on anything. Thank you for at least being honest enough to admit that. I didn't ask for your motivation for making the baseless assumption, I just asked what your assertion was based on. |
Joshthefirst:Let me try again. I didn't ask if he discovered evidences. I asked, what are the evidences? break it down for me in layman terms. I suspect that you don't understand any of it. I've already stated that I don't know geology so you are not returning any favour. I've only said that you are as in the dark as I am on geology. Unless you can break it down for me in layman terms (which I'm certain that you can't because you don't have a clue) then you are just appealing to authority (your accusation) even when you don't actually know what the authority is saying. Yes, I'm appealing to authority too, but my own is boosted by the authority of consensus. Geoogists whose works are peer reviewed are criticising the guy as a crank and you have not showed me any evidence that is corroborated by peer reviews. So between relying on the authority of one guy who is known as a dishonest crank, and relying on the authority of a community of geologists who rigorous review each others works, I believe I am the one on firmer ground. Let me break down my points for you so you don't get confused. - To submit a paper to GSA does not make the paper scientific evidence. Not until it has been rigorously peer reviewed. - Neither you nor I are geologists and we cannot claim to understand the papers. If you understand it then please explain it to me in layman terms. - Other geologists who do understand geology have identified your authority as a dishonest crank. |
ekochris:But the planet Venus is still in the sky. So where did he fall to? |
The star in question is Venus. Hesperus is the personification of the "evening star", the planet Venus in the evening. His name is sometimes conflated with the names for his brother, the personification of the planet as the "morning star" Eosphorus (Greek Ἐωσφόρος, "bearer of dawn" or Phosphorus (Ancient Greek: Φωσφόρος, "bearer of light", often translated as "Lucifer" in Latin), since they are all personifications of the same planet Venus. "Heosphoros" in the Greek Septuagint and "Lucifer" in Jerome's Latin Vulgate were used to translate the Hebrew "Helel" (Venus as the brilliant, bright or shining one), "son of Shahar (god) (Dawn)" in the Hebrew version of Isaiah 14:12.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hesperus |
shdemidemi:What will happen is that people will be unable to play gymnastics with text to force falsehoods on each other. People will be forced to awaken their spirit if they want divine guidance. They'll go to the true source of guidance which is and always has been the Holy Spirit. The bible has been used as a poison almost that has distracted people away from the guidance of the holy spirit. shdemidemi:correctomondo, who is to say that God's will is not working through the evolution of the bible. Who is to say that God's will is not working through the whole of history, through every incident and every accident. Through every book ever written, through the flight of the clouds in the heavens, through the rustling of the breeze, through the silence of the rocks. Do not the heavens declare the glory of God, does not the earth show his handiwork? Why can I not get a rhema from reading my morning newspaper? Why are you trying to give the bible an extra-significance that no other artifact in history has, that no other artifact of the church has? The bible is not inerrant and just the fact that it is not consistent within itself is enough to show you that. If your God is true as your bible is true then you're in deep trouble. |
Joshthefirst:What evidence has he presented? Can you explain it to me in layman terms, in your own words? I suspect that you don't even understand what he presents but you've accepted it because you are not prepared to think on this issue. His method has been criticised by other scientists and I'm yet to see a peer reviewed appraisal of his work. Showing me that some 'research' was submitted to the GSA is no proof. Show me the work that was accepted and acclaimed by other geologists and you'll have my attention. |
Joshthefirst:How do you know that they died later on? Please provide sources. Unless you are guessing or presuming based on your preconception. |
so this is the toasting hour on NL. no wahala. Carry on.... sukkot: |
Joshthefirst:They appeared to many. That is enough to cause commotion, I think. And furthermore the verse 52 of that chapter of Matthew said that they were raised on that day. Whether they only came out of the tombs after Jesus was risen or not is besides the point. They had already risen. Before Jesus. Like Lazarus. Before Jesus. Like the Shunammite Widow's son. Before Jesus. |
Joshthefirst:I researched the link you gave. Very interesting. First, check this out: 33 A.D. Jerusalem. This earthquake(s), which is said to have occurred during the Crucifixion and Resurrection of Christ in Jerusalem, caused darkness over all the land, tombs to open and the ground to split open. The source for this information is the Gospel according to St Matthew, who mentions two earthquakes. The fact that these earthquakes in Jerusalem are not mentioned by contemporary pagan writers, or by three out of the four Evangelists, suggests that they may have been inspired by the topos of Nature's reflecting events of great importance, and hence must not be considered to refer to historical earthquakes. http://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/nndc/struts/results?eq_0=8178&t=101650&s=13&d=22,26,13,12&nd=display So all you have to corroborate it is a geological discovery. This is where it gets interesting. The research was done by a certain Steven Austin of Cedarville University. Let us find out who Steven Austin is. Cedarville University is an accredited, Christ-centered, Baptist institution with an enrollment of 3,620 undergraduate, graduate, and online students in more than 100 areas of study. https://www.cedarville.edu/About.aspx Here is a little article that will tell us about the likes of Steve Austin and the problems that the scientific community have with his sort. It is called Creationism creeps into mainstream geology It was easy to miss the part where the field trip leader said the outcrop formed during Noah’s Flood. After all, “During these catastrophic flood flows, turbulent, hyperconcentrated suspensions were observed to transform laminar mudflows” sounds like a reasonable description of alluvial fan processes. And “massive marine transgression” sounds scientific enough. But when creationist geologists use those phrases, they take on a very different meaning. Admittedly I know next to nothing about geology so all these grand sounding words would have impressed me too if I am not hearing a scientist question their use of them. But in reality, the trip was anything but a normal geology field trip. Instead, it was an example of a new strategy from creationists to interject their ideas into mainstream geology: They lead field trips and present posters and talks at scientific meetings. They also avoid overtly stating anything truly contrary to mainstream science. But when the meeting is over, the creationist participants go home and proudly proclaim that mainstream science has accepted their ideas. It’s a crafty way of giving credence to creationism. But is there anything mainstream scientists, or the conveners of meetings and field trips, can or should do about it? Many attendees seemed unaware of the backgrounds of the five trip co-leaders: Steve Austin, Marcus Ross, Tim Clarey, John Whitmore and Bill Hoesch. Austin is probably the most well-known; he is chair of the geology department at the Institute for Creation Research, which describes itself as the “leader in scientific research from a biblical perspective, conducting innovative laboratory and field research in the major disciplines of science.” Austin has been very active in promoting a Noah’s Flood interpretation of the geology of the Grand Canyon. So that is the gist of who this Steve austin guy is and where he is coming from. During the trip, the leaders did not advertise their creationist views, but rather presented their credentials in a way that minimized their creationist affiliations. Austin introduced himself as a geologic consultant. ... Furthermore, the field trip leaders were careful not to make overt creationist references. If the 50 or so field trip participants did not know the subtext and weren’t familiar with the field trip leaders, it’s quite possible that they never realized that the leaders endorsed geologic interpretations completely at odds with the scientific community. Even the GSA Sedimentary Geology Division had initially signed on as a sponsor of the trip (though they backed out once they learned the views of the trip leaders). To many outside observers, those on the scientific side can sometimes come across as confrontational, while those in the creationist camp often maintain a cheerful, friendly demeanor. Ross’ presentation, and my interactions on the field trip, confirmed this observation: All the trip leaders were courteous and friendly, and seemed genuinely concerned that all attendees enjoyed a safe, pleasant trip. Although the trip leaders probably knew that I strongly disagreed with them on the science (my name badge clearly identified my affiliation with the National Center for Science Education), they were never disagreeable about it. Quite the contrary — they seemed to go out of their way to be friendly. Regardless of the degree of friendliness of the creationist trip leaders, some in the science community may argue that an organization such as GSA should not allow creationist-led field trips. Some may go even further, and suggest that posters and talks by known creationists not be approved. I think such actions would be a mistake. http://www.earthmagazine.org/article/creationism-creeps-mainstream-geology GSA is the institution your dead sea proof of earthquake was sent to. I noticed also that it was just a site showing that it was Submitted. It hadn't been peer reviewed yet. So that doesn't count as scientific evidence. |
You've hit the nail on the end. 'if' santa exists. Now think, does Santa exist? 5solas: |
5solas:I used to think that santa Claus was real but then I fell. |
Joshthefirst:Kindly present the evidence. Thanks. |
The one wey surprise me pass na say dead bodi go enter town and town nor go scatter. talk less of there being not a single report of the incident. Not only that but no further mention of the incident in the bible itself. surely if that happened everybody will still be talking about it even around the time of pentecost. Not a single mention of it thereafter. Haba! frosbel: |
Joshthefirst:For example, what is your historical evidence or corroboration that the following happened: …52The tombs were opened, and many bodies of the saints who had fallen asleep were raised; 53and coming out of the tombs after His resurrection they entered the holy city and appeared to many. 54Now the centurion, and those who were with him keeping guard over Jesus, when they saw the earthquake and the things that were happening, became very frightened and said, "Truly this was the Son of God!"… Matthew 27 |
Image123:Please do the same for your side thanks. I've already put up a video. Oh, and something else. When Bart Ehrmann goes on about all the bible scholars that claim bible authorship is unknown it is not because he just likes dropping names or appealing to authority. It is because his authority was first being attacked. And in defence he is saying that it is not just him that has come to that conclusion but very many eminent scholars. So what we have is not just an appeal to Authorities but also an appeal to Consensus. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 116 117 118 119 120 121 122 123 124 (of 287 pages)

or Phosphorus (Ancient Greek: Φωσφόρος, "bearer of light", often translated as "Lucifer" in Latin), since they are all personifications of the same planet Venus. "Heosphoros" in the Greek Septuagint and "Lucifer" in Jerome's Latin Vulgate were used to translate the Hebrew "Helel" (Venus as the brilliant, bright or shining one), "son of Shahar (god) (Dawn)" in the Hebrew version of Isaiah 14:12.