PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 (of 287 pages)
Pastor AIO: I think that Deepsight is being fundamentally misunderstood in this thread. Possibly because 'Morality' is such a murky idea here, and each of us actually has a different thing he is talking about when we mention morality. At the risk of sounding like a broken record, or being dismissed again with a disdainful 'I don't do definitionism', I think we need to set out a definition of Morality so we know what we are talking about here.And it is obvious now why Deepsight is getting so hissy. He is arguing for a Morality that has an independent ontological existence (yeah tautology, whatever), while I'm arguing for a Sense of Morality, or rather the experience of Morality. I fear he will have a hard time proving this objective Morality. |
Deep Sight: In the bold, you will see why you are being either clever by half, or completely missing the issue.Oh! Maybe you're making a distinction between our sense of Morality, Morality per se (in se, or even sen se millia). Okay if we grant that there is a Morality which is objective, how can we be aware of it? is it not with our Sense of morality? How can we be sure that the sense of morality is accurate? We can't? It is the whole epistemology/ontology question. How can you Know that something exists? The Truth is that all that is available to us is not knowledge but beliefs, Beliefs with varying measures of certainty. Bottom line is that Sense of morality is subject to change. We are limited to what we can sense and the only thing that we can meaningfully talk about its our sense of morality. I Sense morality therefore I am Moral. lol Deep Sight: You therefore assert that the notion and idea of mala in se is actually a false notion and idea and does not exist. Are you willing to stand by this assertion?So to answer the above I say that I am not equipped to make any pronouncement on Mala in Se but I can make pronouncements on my sense of Mala. You can only discuss 'Mala in Se' with people from the same wider cultural milieu as yourself. People say that genocide is wrong is wrong is wrong. Tell that to the Israelites that invaded Canaan. It wasn't just during the invasion. But for centuries afterwards is was an issue of pride. Reading the bible there is nowhere at any point that you get any sense of remorse and the bible spans centuries. So for centuries we have an act of genocide that not only were the perpetrators not ashamed of, but furthermore it was actually a matter of pride for them. Go and tell them about Mala in Se. |
Deep Sight: What is Mala in se?I would say that what is deemed Mala in se is 'merely' deemed so. it is the deeming part . . . The issue of euthanasia suffices to complicate the murder part. The idea of theft suggests the violation of ownership, yet there are those who would say that ownership in itself is theft. What it all boils down to is that it is wrong to make people do things against their will, or to violate the will of others. Of course having your will thwarted is not a nice experience, whether it is your will to live, your will to hold own to your possessions, or your will to be left alone. I have my own subjective attitude to these things which I will defend with absolute vigour but I cannot get up to argue that these values are objective. |
Deep Sight: In the bold, you will see why you are being either clever by half, or completely missing the issue.Okay, so can I take it that you think there is an objective morality beyond the human sense of morality? Even then I still think that is subject to change. But I won't go into that part. Rather I'll press you to demonstrate this objective morality. ps. I get that you are making this thread over a somewhat different issue. That against the claims of materialists etc etc. |
yeah, 'naughty lady' works too! lol! |
Deep Sight: Yeah yeah yeah, neither here nor there as always. I can't believe you do not recognize that your last few posts entirely contradict everything you have said before on this thread. Worever. We are used to you by now.Stop whining. It doesn't befit you. My last few post do not contradict anything that I've said before. I am of the opinion that the sense of Morality changes from time to time and culture to culture, you obviously aren't. I'm okay with that, you obviously aren't, but you don't have to bitch about it. |
Deep Sight: Then you are also confused and contradicting yasef.I was referring to the abandoning of twins actually. Worldview has a great effect on what you think is morally right or wrong. |
Deep Sight: Even Hitler's irascible determination led to a great many inventions, discoveries and acts of industrial capacity building.I agree. His was the first government to really use Fiscal policy, I think even before Keynes talked about it. If Hitler had just stopped there, and not gone on to start WWII we would probably be calling him the greatest leader in 20th century europe today. The determination with which he lifted a war damaged germany from the doldrums to the great military power it became by the end of the 30s was laudable. Not to mention the building of the autobahns etc. |
Deep Sight: Because they were evil people. Same as those who burnt "witches" and "heretics" at the stake in the Medieval Western world.LOL! I wouldn't agree. I'd say because that was right in their moral opinion, but that Morality has evolved. By Morality I now mean the plurality of all moral codes. In other words you could say that One set of prevailing moral codes have been replaced by another set that come into prevalence. |
plaetton: Alexander the Great, Ghengis khan, Napoleon, Hitler, etc., are celebrated for their Notoriety, not for any positive contributions to human progress.There is another reason that all of the above except for Hitler are celebrated. None, apart from Hitler, executed a program of mass systematic genocide against a racial group. This is Hitler's great ill. Alexander, apart from being a conqueror, set about spreading Greek philosophy and technology around the world. He was worshipped as a God in many of the nations he conquered. He actually took philosophers on his campaigns with him and introduced them to the thinkers and intellectuals of the nations he conquered. Ghengis Khan . . . Okay, that one too was just a maniac . . . but he is not celebrated in history books except as a war leader. Napoleon too, went around spreading the Napoleonic code which is imho is one of the greatest things that europe experienced at that time which helped to free them from feudalism. He too took scientists on his campaign. When he conquered Egypt he spent the occupation studying the ancient ruins. That was when the rosetta stone was decoded (I think). Personally I'm a napoleon fan (apart from his ego), I feel that the british just had Bad belle for him. |
plaetton: The UN declaration of of fundamental human rights and the Geneva convention is are two great example of contrived morality.I'm sorry if I'm seeming to misunderstand you Plaetton. When I read the above what I understand is that Man quite arbitrarily contrives a Morality (such as UNDR and Geneva conventions) that is subsequently" enshrined in the legal codes of all nations." When you call them examples of contrived morality, I feel compelled to point out that the moral sense already existed long before the enactment of these things. If however I've misunderstood you and you are not claiming that UNDR and Geneva convention are not the inception of a moral attitude, then I'm sorry, but I'll need you to explain what it is exactly that you mean. plaetton: I say no, it is contrived, made up, and then evolves over time.Could you give one example of a moral attitude that was arrived at by Contrivance? I believe that you've denied that UNDR and Geneva Convention are such. |
Evil Brain: Rwligious statues are constantly being hit by lightning because they are often the highest points in the area, and they commonly dont include basic safety precautions like lightning rods.I find it odd that the quran should say that ( striking with it anyone He wills and averting it from anyone He wills.) Cos surely for many centuries mosques would also have been the tallest buildings in the area meaning that Allah would have often struck his places of worship. According to his will, of course. It appears God has sacrificed his only son. Again.LOL!! |
I would like to see some documentation of the arguments that passed between the religious and the scientists. I would have thought since church were, for hundreds of years, the tallest buildings in any town that if there was a thunder storm the church would be hit first. I'm surprised that people felt that the church would be the safest place from a thunder storm. Evidence ought to have proved against it. |
plaetton: I do not think that you and Deepsight take time to read my post.I think that the enactment of moral codes is nothing more than the articulation of a moral predisposition. What you are saying is like, 'If I already love my wife then there is no need for to open my mouth to say that I love my wife'. As if one only starts to love commencing with the pronouncement of love. However you touch on some very interesting and important points when you ask why human behaviour would need any regulation. Why would people commit acts that they well know ( or have a subtle sense) is wrong? We can start to investigate the nature of this innate moral code and how it affects behaviour, we can investigate whether there is just one or rather a number of them at play in any individual, |
striktlymi: Wow!!! A politician couldn't have done a better job... Anyway, I hope we also notice that there is a big presumption in the 'definition'. That we are creatures that can make choices. We can recognise options and choose from them. The whole notion of optional futures (no, I'm not talking finance) is in conflict with the idea of a deterministic universe. |
kwangi: BTW... Pastor AIO, where do you stand in all these? Even though Deepsight's issue is settled.I think that Wiegraf almost defined it for me, according to my own understanding. My definition of morality is a scale of values, from Most preferable (good) to Least preferable (evil), and as Moral creatures when faced with options we choose that which according to our scale of Values is the More preferable. Where this Scale of Values comes from is another matter. Also of interest is how it evolves over time. It determines all of human affairs on an individual level, and also on a social and global level. |
truthman2012: Beg your pardon. ......''I don't think Allah is Satan''. Are you saying Muhammad's Allah is the Christians' God?I give up! |
Maybe a little off topic but anyway . . . Nietzsche's table of values [edit]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fact–value_distinction#Nietzsche.27s_table_of_values |
wiegraf: Actions are deemed moral when they satisfy a value system. Value systems need not be logical or objective, at all. For instance, if you subscribe to a religious moral code, that would entail basing your actions around faith based system, not logic. Logic is viewed as just a tool, a tool to satisfy goals which are based on values.Gbam-u!!! Now we're getting closer to What morality actually is. |
plaetton: Animals don't wake up in the morning with several options or choices for sustenance and survival. Man does.For example? How do you know that animals don't have options for sustenance? I would say that they have as much options as humans. Some animals have less or no options, as do some men too. |
plaetton: The UN declaration of of fundamental human rights and the Geneva convention is are two great example of contrived morality.There is a chicken and egg ish here. Let us take Magna carta for example. Do you really think that someone just arbitrarily came up with Magna Carta and then that became the moral viewpoint of the english. OR is it not more likely that first came the moral sense that King's ought to be held accountable and this then after a lengthy struggle became enshrined in law. If the Moral sense did not precede the Law making then why the struggle to have laws made, struggles that are often seen as fights for Justice. If morality came from written laws then how comes we can feel a sense of injustice towards even the Law itself. Can you really say that before the UN declaration of human rights that people did not feel that other humans had fundamental inalienable rights? It seems to me that the examples you gave are not examples of contrived morality, far from it, they are Laws contrived specifically to attend to a pre-existing moral disposition. |
mazaje: I wonder of the same can be done in aplace like dubia or qatar. . . .Radical islam is a malignant cancer in the west that will cause a lot of trouble if not removed quickly. . .How Timely!! Did you see the news this afternoon about 2 muslim guys hacking down a soldier with axes. In the name of Allah. |
kwangi: What's this?I never said that they were more valid that yours. I just said that they were interesting. kwangi: I know say you don dey follow dis thread from page one, so your demand for examples are unnecessary.Actually it is very necessary cos I think that people are talking about rather different things from the looks of the thread. |
Pastor AIO:28 views and not one comment. |
Some interesting thoughts on Morality by the Anti X, Morality makes stupid.-- Custom represents the experiences of men of earlier times as to what they supposed useful and harmful - but the sense for custom (morality) applies, not to these experiences as such, but to the age, the sanctity, the indiscussability of the custom. And so this feeling is a hindrance to the acquisition of new experiences and the correction of customs: that is to say, morality is a hindrance to the development of new and better customs: it makes stupid. from Nietzsche's Daybreak,s. 19, R.J. Hollingdale transl. Whoever has overthrown an existing law of custom has always first been accounted a bad man: but when, as did happen, the law could not afterwards be reinstated and this fact was accepted, the predicate gradually changed; - history treats almost exclusively of these bad men who subsequently became good men! from Nietzsche's Daybreak,s. 20, R.J. Hollingdale transl. Suspicious.-- To admit a belief merely because it is a custom - but that means to be dishonest, cowardly, lazy! - And so could dishonesty, cowardice and laziness be the preconditions for morality? from Nietzsche's Daybreak,s. 101, R.J. Hollingdale transl. Get more from here: http://www.theperspectivesofnietzsche.com/nietzsche/nmoral.html |
kwangi: I know Deepsight is fundamentally and greatly understood, hence the clear answers and explanations to his questions.Examples please. ps. and a definition of morality too, Thanks in advance. |
kwangi: "Until lions have their own historian, the history of hunting will always glorify the hunter".-- Chinua AchebeNapoleon was defeated in Russia and finally in Waterloo and then sent to exile. Yet we do not hear that he is not to be emulated. He brought freedom to a lot of the peoples he invaded. We hear a lot about what an amazing war general he was. |
I think that Deepsight is being fundamentally misunderstood in this thread. Possibly because 'Morality' is such a murky idea here, and each of us actually has a different thing he is talking about when we mention morality. At the risk of sounding like a broken record, or being dismissed again with a disdainful 'I don't do definitionism', I think we need to set out a definition of Morality so we know what we are talking about here. Morality is a contrived set of rules by groups for mutual benefit. Is has supremacy over the instinctive individual drive for survival by means of domination and self aggrandisement.Can you offer up an example of where and when some Moral was contrived? |
kwangi: What is survival?Good question! What survives? Are we talking about the survival of the individuals or are we talking about the survival of the genome? Does the genome survive from one mutation to the other? Doesn't everything change, isn't everything subject to processes(death is a part of process)? Panta Rhei (Uyi Iredia ) Is it the same genome if it mutates? This brings us back to the problem of identity. Has the species survived if it evolves into another species? Have Pterodactyls survived? |
Are we discussing Morality or Survival of the Specie. Is Survival of the Specie intrinsically linked to morality? What about self sacrifice? Could that ever be a moral thing to do? kwangi: What happens when everybody starts using their high intelligence to STEAL food from each other? |
Rossikk: What technology? What knowledge? Will the increase in your knowledge about Buddha ever turn you into a Buddhist? You have this idea that people reject Christianity out of ignorance of it. Get such evil, arrogant, misguided thinking out of your system.The technology that will allow man to physically see God face to face and thus make not only his existence as portrayed by the religion, but the religion itself, incontrovertibly proved true. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 133 134 135 136 137 138 139 140 141 (of 287 pages)

Anyway, I hope we also notice that there is a big presumption in the 'definition'. That we are creatures that can make choices. We can recognise options and choose from them. The whole notion of optional futures (no, I'm not talking finance) is in conflict with the idea of a deterministic universe.
) Is it the same genome if it mutates? This brings us back to the problem of identity.