PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 (of 287 pages)
Whether there is really such a thing as Cause or whether it is just the way that the Mind works, by arranging events into causes and effects, IS ANOTHER BIG QUESTION? |
mazaje: There are creators of what we see, go read the Hindu verders. . . .I dey fear to support this guy because he can then turn on me and start to yab me too, but anyway I like the way that this post demonstrates that most of these people cannot withstand the scrutiny of their own arguments. If only they could apply their own arguments to their religious beliefs then this world would be such a different place. I especially like the part about coming together for a common purpose. That is essential to my view of things. The very idea of Intention that is that is embedded in the very fabric of existence is crucial for people interested in religion to grasp. |
The main reason for my making this enquiry is because I quite taken aback by the reaction I've seen to the idea that the concept of 2 types of Adam was already in Judaism before Paul mentions it. I don't know why the fact should be so offensive. For example, would the fact that there is baptism in Judaism before christianity be offensive to many christians? Would christianity likewise vehemently defend any of it's own inventions if it were suggested that it existed before. For example if we found that original sin had already been articulated in Judaism would this be considered offensive? Wouldn't it au contraire lend validation to the concept? |
I gave examples in the OP of what I was looking for. Like the fact that christians can eat pork. However the idea of a Messiah already exists in Judaism. Also the idea that we are the Temple of God already exists, I believe. So quoting the prophecy that says Messiah will bring God to dwell amongst us in his sanctuary is not invalid if you consider our Hearts the temple of God. There were numerous candidates for messiah in various generations. Some Jews did accept Jesus as the messiah. That is how the whole christian movement started in the first place. I'm sure if you thought about what you said you wouldn't claim that there is 'absolutely nothing in common' with christianity and Judaism. Just the name of the God, Jehovah is one thing in common. However the trinity of father son and holy ghost started in christianity. |
Callotti: . . . That Jesus is not the son of God or Messiah.Interesting link, although there is much inside that I simply disagree with, yet it will digress from what I'm getting at in this thread. |
How much Xtianity originated in Xtianity, How much originated in Judaism? What christian doctrines cannot be found in Judaism? For example the doctrine of original sin. This is a xtian idea that started, I think, with St. Augustine. Eating Pork is christian, as allowed by St. Paul. What more is there? |
Just out of curiousity I wonder to what extent, in the viewpoint of christians, is christianity in tandem with Judaism, and how much of christianity is a new invention that cannot be found in Judaism. It shocks me that the suggestion that the doctrine of 2 Adams existed in Judaism before christianity should be resisted so vehemently by some. |
Thank you Enigma for your response. Me sef, the thread has wearied me a bit. I just want to address one last thing before I too rest my case. I don't believe that I referred to cabala in any of my arguments on this thread. I only mentioned it in response to your not-too-subtle attempt to reduce my position to a cabalist one. The Cabala's earliest reference is the Zohar which is an 11th century text, ba? Even the passage you have now quoted has this to say: In order to elicit the mysteries from the scriptures, the Cabalists employed certain hermeneutical canons, {e.g. Gematria, Notarikon, Temurah or permutation} . . . .Thank God that he didn't say that the Cabalists invented their hermeneutic methods. He admits that these were already applied by Jews in the Talmud and the Midrash. This is critical because I have not quoted any cabalistic texts in this thread, but I simply quoted from the Midrash. Specifically from Genesis Rabbah and the Tehillim Rabbah. These predate the cabalist Zohar by centuries. My entire point has been based on Rabbinical sources and not from Kabalist sources. Yes the Rabbis used these exegetical methods and so did the Kabalists. I personally would not discredit the Cabala unless I knew more about it. yet to bring cabala into this thread would be a red herring. So to address your final point: The one point I will rebut is again the misleading statement that there is no difference between Paul's position and rabbinical positions. Two things are wrong with the statement: one the rabbinical position is not necessarily the Kabbalah position and secondly Paul's last Adam is altogether different anyway.So to address your 2 things fairly and squarely on the head, 1) I made no mention of Kabala and derived all my sources from Rabbinical sources and not the cabala, so whether or not Rabbis tally with Kabala is, as I said, a red herring. 2nd thing), I have already protested that you should present an argument for why Paul's last Adam is altogether different and all you've done is reiterated the statement with a dismissive wave of your hand. The best you did was to quote someone who said this: And that indicates to me that Paul is both aware of and modifying for his own theologic purpose an already well-known doctrine of a “spiritual Adam” that people believed preceded the earthly Adam. Since Jesus came millenia after human creation, Paul finds it necessary for the spiritual Adam be the culmination of humanity, rather then its origin. A position that relies on Jesus' existence being subsequent to creation. You've made your point and I appreciate it. I have made my point too. I don't think that there is anything more that either of us can say. Those that read this thread will, some of them, agree with you, some will agree with me, others will think that we're both talking rubbish, and some might even see value in both our positions etc. Whatever happens I agree that there is probably nothing more than you nor I can say to add to the issue. |
Joagbaje: @OPI will do sir. Thank you very much for the request. I've done a fair bit of writing already today, so I think I'll leave it for another day. but I've got a few good case studies on this matter. |
! Okay, first I need to correct my errors and then properly explain what I was getting at. 1) 'Hating' Davidylan. Though that is not in line with the topic I feel compelled to react to that cos I don't want to come across like I'm just picking on the guy for no reason. I would hardly say that I hate the guy but I would admit to finding him repulsive. The first time he came on my radar was when I started reading threads on Islam. The guy was everywhere attacking attacking attacking. The Muslims asked for their own section so they could be in peace. Well, what do you know, he was all over that section too. E be like say dem take the tin do the guy, like say them mix de tin inside amala give am chop. My reaction to him slowly blossomed from mild irritation to perplexity, to outright repulsion especially after I saw the way in which he then attempted to defend christianity when it was attacked the same way as he was attacking islam. All the boasting, and claiming without provision of evidence was too much for me to bear. It was the quintessential example of a pot calling a kettle black. To be honest, it has now gone beyond the personal stage and it is more on the symbolic level now. So if I mention Davidylan's name it is no longer a personal reference to the guy himself but rather a reference to a certain kind of attitude and . . . er . . what's the word . . . Bloviating way of going on. A Davidylan to me now is a certain kind of person, not just a specific person. 2) Now, bearing in mind the topic of this thread and why we are all here, ie the matter of interpreting scriptures, I have tried to make a number of points and looking back on the thread I realise that I have made those points very badly. There are issues that are a little different that I structured such that it seemed that I was talking on the same thing. First and foremost the point I wanted to stress was the failings of text-based religion. What the moslems call 'Religions of a book'. During the arab empire they only respected religions that could produce a book on which the religion was based or which could be considered an authority in the religion. This is the kind of attitude that leads to religionism and other such intellectual gymnastics in religion. The problem is further compounded when the text in question is translated, not once, or twice, from another language that was spoken thousands of years ago. Such scriptures are at the mercy of the clever, and the wily. I can give you a few anecdotes on how I came to this realisation. Once upon a time, a very long time ago I was having a discussion with a Jehovah's witness friend of mine over the divinity of Jesus. We argued back and forth for a while before I offered to show him incontrovertible proof directly from the bible. He said okay and thrust a bible in my hand. I went to the first chapter of the gospel of John. I read the opening passage again and again, something was not right and I could not find anything there to buttress my point. My JW friend continued to look at me defiantly. Show me the incontrovertible proof, he challenged. I looked back at him, 'What kind of bible is this, for God's sake'? In his bible there was no mention of the word being God. It said the 'word was WITH God, and the word was A god'. Ie the word was divine, yet was not Jehovah himself. That was how that conversation ended. I was thoroughly disgusted with the guy's bible and was convinced that all JWs were lost. It was only a few years later when I had the opportunity to learn some Koine greek and to study the bible in the original texts that I realised that the JW bible was just as valid as any of the other bibles that we are using. The original greek text could be translated with or without the article 'a', because such articles were not necessary in the greek grammar. Theos, or Theon referred to God, and also to just divine. Then it dawned on me that what came first, whether when we are translating from one language to another, or simply interpreting the text for application, was the DOCTRINE and then the interpretation/translation of the text followed on from the doctrine. In other words, once you can accept a text as being an authority then you become susceptible to those who are clever are manipulating text to say what they want it to say. My incident with the JW guy was also repeated shortly after with an Italian girl who was a devout catholic. Menh, I searched inside her bible so taaaaaayyyyy, I didn't find the verses I was looking for. So now that I've realised that Authority can never reside within a text of any sort, but rather resides within the Reader of the text, that informs my position when I come into threads like this one. I made a mistake to conflate the insertion of the word 'them' in the english translation with the matter of there being 2 adams. The original hebrew does not say God created 'them' male and female, but depending on what ideology the translator is trying to effect it can legitimately be inserted. Similarly if one was trying to push the idea of Adam being created androgynous then all one had to do was leave the translation on a word for word basis. In arguing I feel I came down too strongly on the side of an Androgynous Adam when I should have just exposed the difference in interpretation and the doctrines backing them. Now I then went on to talk about there being 2 adams. So when I say this: In fact Jews understand the opening verses of Genesis to be talking about the creation of two very different beings, both called Adam. That is why the Jews say that God created him before and after. There is the prior Adam and then there is the subsequent Adam. Subsequent Adam is then divided into two, Adam and Eve. the first Adam is called Adam Kadmon....then really this should be a new issue and not conflated with what came before it. The Rabbinical belief in the doctrine of 2 adams was not derived from Genesis but rather from Psalm 139, verse 5. In keeping with the topic of this thread, that Psalm is itself just about the psalmist thanking God for looking after him,( for 'enclosing him behind and before'.) The Rabbi now took this one line to be a reference to before creation, and after creation. So my main point with bringing this up is that the guardians of this tradition are themselves known for picking a verse and interpreting it with total disregard for it's context. Me, personally, I believe that first came the doctrine of 2 types of Man, a spiritual man and then a carnal man, and then support for this doctrine was then subsequently found in the scriptures. .This pattern is observed over and over again even here on Nairaland. People like to jump on Joagbaje's back over his beliefs which are derived from the same bibles that most of us read. However the fact is that everything that he says (as deepsight has often noted) is backed up with scripture. The only difference is that he might have interpreted a certain text differently from the way others have interpreted it. The difference is a matter of interpretation, not of scriptural basis. I said that his beliefs are derived from the same bibles, Actually I don't think that his or anybody else's beliefs are derived from the bible at all, but whatever their source the bible is then employed as a support for the belief. So here you confirm that Adam Kadmon of Genesis 1:26,27 is the "primordial adam", "spiritual adam"II'm sorry I led you to believe that Genesis 1:26,27 was referring to Adam Kadmon. And finally I want to once again address your rebuttal of the suggestion that Paul doctrine of the 2 Adams was firmly within Rabbinical traditions. Since Paul insists that the spiritual Adam comes later and this according to the quote above is what makes his 2nd Adam different from the 2 adams of the Rabbis, then tell me, Do you really think that Jesus didn't exist before Adam the progenitor of mankind was created. I see absolutely no difference between Paul's position and the position of the Rabbis. If there is any difference it is that paul has identified the spiritual Adam as Jesus Christ. In fact I wouldn't call that a difference because there were many pharisees at the time that would probably have agreed with him. Such as Nicodemus, for example. So to round of my point of joining this thread, A big chunk of christian/Pauline christology is derived from the Pharisee traditions that are arrived at by picking verses of scriptures in isolation from their context. |
Well the bible states unequivocally that we must not muzzle the Ox where it is threshing the corn, so It follows that where our civil servants are slaving away on our behalf we must allow them to chop whatever they need to chop in order to keep their strength up. That one is in the bible too. |
Let us consider this verse in Genesis:I erred seriously in the above post, I have to admit. I believe that I even misrepresented the rabbinical position. The concept of the 2 adams was derived not from Genesis but from Psalm 139, and then applied to genesis. I don't have time right now to do justice to everything, but I'll be back over the next couple of days to make more comments. |
Enigma:My brother, let's leave the issue there. |
@enigma, You asked some questions and I attempted some answers. It would be nice if you could give me some feedback. |
Enigma:I see why you group yourself with Davidylan now. I looked at the thread you referred me to. please you'll have to show me the actual post where the issue of how and when Jesus was begotten was addressed. And if you can, could you kindly answer some of the other questions I asked too. I've tried to answer your questions as best as I can. I cannot help it if you are determined to misconstrue and twist everything. I showed you a link where they talk about the 2 adams in the Midrash. Please look at it again, I'll copy and paste it for you so that you don't have to work too hard. Midrash. This doctrine concerning the Logos, as also that of man made "in the likeness" ("De Confusione Linguarum," xxviii.), though tinged with true Philonic coloring, is also based on the theology of the Pharisees. For in an old Midrash (Gen. R. viii. 1) it is remarked: "'Thou hast formed me behind and before' (Ps. cxxxix. 5) is to be explained 'before the first and after the last day of Creation.' For it is said, 'And the spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters,' meaning the spirit of the Messiah ["the spirit of Adam" in the parallel passage, Midr. Teh. to cxxxix. 5; both readings are essentially the same], of whom it is said (Isa. xi. 2), 'And the spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him.'" This contains the kernel of Philo's philosophical doctrine of the creation of the original man. He calls him the idea of the earthly Adam, [size=16pt]while with the rabbis the (spirit of Adam) not only existed before the creation of the earthly Adam, but was preexistent to the whole of creation. From the preexisting Adam, or Messiah, to the Logos is merely a step.[/size] Perhaps I made a mistake somewhere and it is not that you are reading stuff into what I wrote that isn't there. Could you please show me where I said that Jesus was created in the first chapter of Genesis. Thank you very much in advance. 2. Assuming it is a "spiritual Adam" and it is Jesus as we are being told, that means Jesus is a created being; Jesus was created; and Genesis 1 is telling us how Jesus was created -- in which case WHEN?I didn't realise how loaded this question was until now. I presumed you accept Paul as an authority, so when Paul says the 2nd Adam is a life giving spirit I didn't think that I would have to argue any further. But I see you have not accepted that yet and you are merely 'assuming it is a "spiritual adam" . . . and that means Jesus is a created being;' Why do I get the feeling that this is not an healthy discussion but that you are trying by any means to get the better of me? |
OLAADEGBU:You haven't got the foggiest idea what my concerns in this thread are. You need not disturb yourself over it. Enigma:ANALOGY!! That is the word that I was looking for. Your analogy with the King's house was totally erroneous. I've tried to explain it to you, but it seems that you don't get it. No worries. |
Enigma:Okay, I can see where you have erred. Let me try to explain it this way: The king's house burns down, it makes it more beautiful. Is this passage about King's Houses. Was the person writing the proverb concerned with King's houses? Or was he concerned with my uncle's hut? He was concerned entirely with my Uncle's hut. The king's house burns down, it makes it more beautiful. Is this passage about King's? Or is it about us the common man? It is ENTIRELY about us, the common man. You see, you are failing to apply the correspondences properly. When Paul says the passage is for our benefit he does not mean that it is for our benefit to apply anyhow that we want to. He means that it is for our benefit the way it seems to be for the benefit of oxen. ie. we are to benefit from it the way the Oxen in the text benefit from not being muzzled. The parallel is between people and Oxen. What applies to the Oxen in the passage can apply to humans too. This is the part of Pardes called Derash. Jews use it a lot. In fact you find it in mathematics too. 3 is to 4 as 15 is to 20. What applies in the relation of 3 to 4 applies to the relationship of 15 to 20. This is where we are at odds, I think. |
Enigma:Thank you, especially for the first question, because it brings us straight back to the original points I was trying to make when this thread started. Remember that the OP said that we should not jump on a single line and interpret it out of it's context. I responded that in fact the Rabbis do this a lot and so does Paul. I gave the example of the Unmuzzled Ox. You agreed that a text or proverb can be applied to different situations outside of it's original context. I also pointed out that this tendency of the Rabbis to interpret scripture like this is called Pardes. Jesus said that we should listen to what they tell us, even if we shouldn't do what they do, because they have the authority of Moses. The sit in moses' seat. Let me try and answer the questions you posed here, but you too, please try and answer some of the questions that I've asked you too ehn. Please. 1. Where in Genesis does it suggest that the Adam referred to in that book was a "spiritual Adam"?It doesn't. Not explicitly anyway. If you're going to limit yourself to Peshat then you won't find any reference to a spiritual adam. 2. Assuming it is a "spiritual Adam" and it is Jesus as we are being told, that means Jesus is a created being; Jesus was created; and Genesis 1 is telling us how Jesus was created -- in which case WHEN?Let us say instead of 'created' he was 'begotten'. Answer these questions yourself. How was Jesus Begotten? (I believe many Muslims have asked this question on NL and no one has answered them). and WHEN was he begotten? 3. To show the incongruity and nonsense of this, then who was having the conversation "Let us make man in our image" in verse 26, which precedes the creation of "Jesus" in verse 27, with God the Father?Your reasoning is totally limited in Peshat. that is why you will see incongruity and nonsense. 4. If Paul was not seen by Jews as a heretic, point to one Jew i.e. believer/practitioner of Judaism who sees Jesus as the Messiah!Dude you're not being disciplined in your reasoning. Stay on course. Paul was not considered a heretic on account of having a doctrine of 2 Adams. Not even for considering Jesus to be the messiah. It wasn't only Jesus there were also other candidates for messiah and there were jews who believed in some of them and Jews who didn't. Paul ran into trouble when he tried to abrogate the mosaic law. especially the parts regarding circumcision and diet. All the original christians were Jews and they all saw Jesus as messiah. There are even Jews today that see Jesus as messiah, but NONE of this has anything to do with what we are discussing. PLEASE STAY ON COURSE. The reason Paul was considered a heretic has nothing to do with the subject of this thread. We are discussing interpreting scriptures. Please try answer some of my own questions na.[quote][/quote] |
Enigma:Moi!!! Adding to the text, Moi?!! Haba! Come clean now. Let us look at it like this. Question: Is this Amala on the table for Olaadegbu? Answer: The Amala is entirely for Enigma. It follows that if Olaadegbu should scoop even the smallest part of the amala then he is stealing cos it wasn't meant for him. Rather all of the amala is meant for Enigma. I totally understand that a statement can be applied to different meanings in different contexts. and I accept that. But me I'm just looking at what a text means in simple comprehension terms. Paul did not say that what applies to Oxen applies, or can apply to humans too. No, he says that the law entirely for us. It is that word entire that does not allow us to apply it to another context. |
I will still come back and address Enigma's last post, but I want to say that we should not forget the subject of this thread which is the issue of how to interpret scripture. I think after dealing with this issue we should come back to that. |
Enigma:As I said before, I don't know much about Hultgren but if you could kindly copy and paste the part that talks about rabbis and their traditions and how it has nothing to do with Paul's christology then I would very much appreciate it. I have skimmed through the link again and found nothing close. As for the rest of your issues and the questions you posed I think they will be best answered after a couple of considerations. First, What does Adam Kadmon mean? Kadmon simply means the original. Adam Kadmon means the Original Man. Second, What is Kabalah? This refers to the oral tradition in Judaism. qabalah comes from the Hebrew 'to receive'. It started to be written down around the 11th century CE. So today we have Kabalah texts but originally the transmission was oral. There is also Lurianic Kabalah which came centuries later. And now we have a new trendy Kabalah endorsed by the likes of Madonna. Okay, one more consideration. Rabbinic teachings were also transmitted orally and only started to get written down after the temple got destroyed, much like the gospels. Originally, Jewish scholarship was oral. Rabbis expounded and debated the law (the written law expressed in the Hebrew Bible) and discussed the Tanakh without the benefit of written works (other than the Biblical books themselves), though some may have made private notes (megillot setarim), for example of court decisions. This situation changed drastically, however, mainly as the result of the destruction of the Jewish commonwealth and the Second Temple in the year 70 CE and the consequent upheaval of Jewish social and legal norms. As the Rabbis were required to face a new reality—mainly Judaism without a Temple (to serve as the center of teaching and study) and Judea without at least partial autonomy—there was a flurry of legal discourse and the old system of oral scholarship could not be maintained. It is during this period that Rabbinic discourse began to be recorded in writing.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talmud Enigma:Okay, let me raise my hand in confession. I am incapable of reading Paul's mind, even if he were here today, not to mention the fact that the dude died 2000 years ago. Of course all I'm capable of doing is suggesting what is LIKELY to be the case. This is the situation with each and every thought or reasoning process. Now you are being dishonest when you say that I 'asserted but showed nothing'. That is so below the belt. -I brought up the fact that Paul claimed to be trained as a Pharisee. He made this claim himself, I didn't put the words in his mouth. -The doctrine of the primordial Adam was a pharisee doctrine that can be found in the Midrash. I even quoted the Midrash. -Even if Paul was not deriving his christology from the pharisees, at least he would have been aware, if he had indeed studied with them, that what he was saying was remarkably similar. However with all things considered I would say that is is MOST LIKELY that Paul's christology was a derivation, like a considerable amount of christianity is, from the doctrines of the Pharisees. I remember asking on NL, even opening a thread expressly for the purpose, what people understood by Pharisee and what they believed in. I asked this question because it seemed to me that people thought Pharisee was just another word for hypocrite. They seem so unaware that they have their doctrines and their ways of doing things and that while there were hypocritical pharisees there were also devout and sincere pharisees. I even went so far as to suggest that Jesus would have been a pharisee himself. Anyway, the thread didn't go anywhere. Further, an argument that Paul believed in the Adam Kadmon myth and speculation and other, arguably, minority Jewish mythology and/or was teaching them in his 'first and last Adam' theology is a misunderstanding of the literature and scholarship and, not to say the least, of Paul! It is one thing to say Paul was aware of Jewish/rabbinical tradition & mythology and another to say Paul accepted and taught such tradition & mythology as part of Christianity (Jews and even the vaunted rabbinical tradition even consider Paul a heretic for seeing the last Adam as Christ or Messiah!)Before I get hasty and shout that you're talking utter rubbish here, let me consider the fact that you've always demonstrated yourself to be a level headed guy and can back up most of what you say. What do you mean by 'minority jewish mythology'? What is a minority jewish mythology vis a vis a majority jewish mythology? Please consider that what you said in the brackets that I bolded is a totally fabrication. Where did a jewish authority consider Paul a heretic for seeing the last Adam as Christ or messiah? 'Thou hast formed me behind and before' (Psalms 139:5) is to be explained 'before the first and after the last day of Creation.' For it is said, 'And the spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters,' meaning the spirit of the Messiah ["the spirit of Adam" in the parallel passage, Midr. Teh. to cxxxix. 5; both readings are essentially the same], of whom it is said (Isaiah 11:2), 'And the spirit of the Lord shall rest upon him.'This is from the Genesis Rabbah. Paul said a considerable amount that would have had Jewish authorities (and some early christian authorities as we can see in Acts and a lot of Paul's more polemical letters) denouncing him as an heretic, but none of it was for articulating a doctrine of 2 adams and making one of them the messiah. The argument in the literature is that being aware of the Jewish/rabbinical traditions and that his audience was similarly aware, Paul took advantage of imageries from such tradition to paint a picture and make an imagery of his own for the purposes of his own different theology.But my guy, don't you find that argument lame? C'mon. Paul was using the imagery of Jewish rabbinical traditions to make a DIFFERENT point? Really? Using it to create his own theology? Really? So what was this different theology that Paul was inventing? Consider what the guy you're quoting is saying: What is most striking to me is Paul’s insistence on the “order” of being. Paul pointedly states the “spiritual Adam” was not first. I take that to mean that Paul is making sure his readers understand that what he is teaching is markedly different from what they might assume. And that indicates to me that [size=16pt]Paul is both aware of and modifying for his own theologic purpose an already well-known doctrine of a “spiritual Adam” [/size]that people believed preceded the earthly Adam. Since Jesus came millenia after human creation, Paul finds it necessary for the spiritual Adam be the culmination of humanity, rather then its origin. So in response to the question, all in all, I would think that this idea of being incorporated into the "body of Christ" is likely a specifically Christian re-retooling of the Jewish esoteric doctrine. Can you not see how stupidd what this guy is saying is from a christian theological stand point. At least he has the honesty to admit that it is his own interpretation when he says, " I take that to mean that Paul . . . ". You sef, as a christian, think about this. How can the carnal Adam preceded Christ, the spiritual adam in existence? Is that a christian understanding? Is it not more LIKELY that Paul is talking about the MANIFESTATION on earth of the 2 adams when he says that Christ came second? Carnal Adam cannot precede Spiritual Adam in existence. Now to answer your questions one by one: A. First and Last Adam 1. Who is the first Adam according to Paul? What was the nature of this first Adam according to Paul? Was he androgynous according to Paul? Was he Adam Kadmon, according to Paul?According to Paul the first Adam was a Carnal man, he was by nature a 'living soul'. Paul makes no mention of his gender status. Paul does not use the word Kadmon (original/primal) in his letter but from his description the first adam does not correspond to Adam Kadmon. How many Adams have there been?In this whole discourse there have only been 2 adams unless you are trying to confuse issues. 2. Who is the second Adam according to Paul? What was the nature of this second Adam according to Paul? Was he androgynous according to Paul? Was he Adam Kadmon, according to Paul?The second Adam was a spiritual being. His nature was that of a 'life giving' spirit. Paul makes no mention of his gender status. Paul does not use the word Kadmon, but in description he corresponds with the Primal Adam (adam Kadmoni) of the Rabbis. 3. Who is the last Adam according to Paul? What was the nature of this last Adam according to Paul? Was he Androgynous according to Paul? Was he Adam Kadmon, according to Paul?Where there are only 2, the second is the last so I believe that I've already answered this part. B. The Adam Kadmon myth in JudaismI wonder why you keep reiterating the word 'myth'. Are you subtly trying to denigrate the idea of adam Kadmon? You are trying to be clever. We all know that throughout it's history judaism has been a rich hotch potch of ideas. A big example of conflicting ideas in Judaism found in the bible would be the Resurrection of the Dead. The Pharisees believed in it. The Sadducees didn't. The Sadducees include the priests and the aristocracy of Israel. If the priesthood of a religion do not believe in a concept then can we say that it is representative of the religion. However the Pharisees believed in resurrection and the pharisees were the common people. So who better represents the jews, their aristocracy or the common man. Better still. How much of christianity believes in infant baptism? Today and in the past. How much of christianity believes in baptism on behalf of the already dead? Today and in the past. Are we now so pathetic that we are resorting to appeals to populism? If many people believe it then it most be right. The doctrine of the 2 adams is a doctrine found in Judaism, in a certain section of judaism, namely amongst the pharisees who were the Rabbis and taught the common people from institutions called synagogues. After the destruction of the temple in 70AD Rabbinical Judaism became the main form of judaism and the Oral traditions of the Rabbis slowly became written down in the Talmud and the Midrashes. Does this deal with your questions? |
Enigma:aw c'mon dude!! the text itself says 'don't muzzle OXEN'. Oxen is an animal. Paul applies the text to human preachers, and asks 'does God care for animals'? It is a rhetoric question but what is the point he is making? Is it that though the text mentions oxen the text is not about oxen? How am I adding animals to the text? Perhaps you could advice me on what you understand by the mosaic text. Also could you explain how you manage to understand this: The sense we get is: this was spoken for our benefit; this was written for our benefit; he was speaking to us; he was speaking for our benefit.. . . without taking the Oxen out of the text. |
Enigma:I did not rely upon Hultgren. I quoted him cos I when I was looking for material to buttress my argument I just googled '2 adams, pharisees, paul' and some other key words and then I posted the links that came up. The following is perhaps a closer link to what I'm trying to argue. ADAM ḲADMON (more correctly, ḲADMONIThe oldest rabbinical source for the term "Adam ha-Ḳadmoni" is Num. R. x., where Adam is styled, not as usually, "Ha-Rishon" (the first), but "Ha-Ḳadmoni" (the original). Compare the very ancient expression "naḥash ha-ḳadmoni" (the original serpent, the devil).—Adam, Hebrew for "man"; Ḳadmon or Ḳadmoni, "first" or "original"http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/articles/761-adam-kadmon |
Enigma:Yes, Paul's last Adam, in my humble understanding, is the primordial Adam. |
Enigma:Because those words all mean approximately the same thing. So if the Mosaic law was altogether written for us, where is there room for Oxen? If the mosaic law was written by all means, surely, without doubt, anyhow-you-look-at-it, totally, for Men then it follows that there is no room for Oxen in the law. 9 I wrote unto you in an epistle not to company with fornicators:Don't hang with fornicators: yet you can't do this totally/altogether/by all means/ absolutely/Pantos-ly because that would require you to leave this world. In other words it is impossible to live in this world with having dealings with sinners, but to the small extent that we can we should try to avoid them. We can't do this pantos-ly. |
I think it will stand or fall on how you interpret the greek word Pantos. I see that some of the translations you put above drop the word altogether (unintended pun). http://concordances.org/greek/panto_s_3843.htm http://biblos.com/1_corinthians/9-10.htm If the law was written altogether for us, ie Pantos for us, then it is NOT about Oxen. Some trying to say it is about oxen but can be applied to humans too are stumped by that word Pantos. If the law is Pantos about humans, then that means it is totally about humans, therefore there is no room for interpreting it in favour of Oxen. |
Doth God take care for oxen? Or saith he it altogether for our sakes? For our sakes, no doubt, this is written: that he that ploweth should plow in hope;I think that Paul answers his own rhetorical question with the subsequent statements. Let me paraphrase what he said: Does God Care enough for Oxen to make a law for them? No, but the law was made Altogether for us humans. (The word 'altogether' or 'entirely' removes any suggestion that the law could be applied to animals. the law was entirely for us, not us and animals). OLAADEGBU:If I ask if the lamborghini in my drive is Olaadegbu's, and then I follow with the question or is it mine, and then I follow that with the statement that in fact it is entirely mine . . . does that no equate to saying that No, the lamborghini is not Olaadegbu's. |
Enigma:I have just read the link you offered above. I cannot see anything there that refutes my suggestion that Paul was passing on rabbinical teachings. What I would have expected was an article that said: 1)this is what Paul says 2) This is what the Rabbis teach 3)What Paul says and what the Rabbis teach do not agree on such and such a point. The link you gave me does not even address the rabbinical position on the issue of 2 adams. |
Deep Sight:I know, I just think it is important in making my point that the 2nd world war came out of the first world war. And that the motivation for Hitler and a lot of German people is the humiliation that they suffered at the end of the 2nd world war. They were not defeated, they signed an armistice which involved being stripped of most of their wealth, and having to pay very heavy reparation. The 2nd world war was their reaction to the humiliation. In fact most analysts would agree that the 2nd world war could have been avoided if the allies hadn't been so hard on the Germans after the first war. |
Doth God take care for oxen? Or saith he it altogether for our sakes? For our sakes, no doubt, this is written: that he that ploweth should plow in hope;Now the question I want to ask you is this: Does God care for Oxen? According to Paul, No! That passage was 'altogether' for our sakes. ie. there is not part of that passage that is about oxen but what he talks about is altogether about humans. All of it. What would Jesus say about that? Look at the birds of the air; they do not sow or reap or store away in barns, and yet your heavenly Father feeds them. Are you not much more valuable than they? |
[flash=400,400] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YXqppJ-L88U&feature=related[/flash] |
@Justcool, please forgive any misquotations I put to you. I didn't actually read your posts again before I responded. I just responded to what I perceived as the general gist of your posts. I look forward to your responses. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 (of 287 pages)


Tell us what it means and how it applies to us today.
: