PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 (of 287 pages)
Chuks, Enough na!! Even if you insist on repetition for emphasis, if by now cgift hasn't got your point then he'll never get it. |
cgift: The essence is to establish the fact that Purgatory was never at the inception of the establishment of the catholic church and was only made a dogma centuries after due to some numerous factors which I will like to delve into in a short while. If it was not accepted as a dogma until much later years, that speaks much of the fallacy of the so-called Church traditions that were handed down through the time of Peter which you people claim. I will show you that it was a doctrine that arose at some time in the involvement of the RCC to satisfy some carnal desires other than actual piety.Even today we can learn new things and get revelations of Truth. The fact that the doctrine of purgatory came much later than the inception of the Church does not disqualify it. In fact Jesus promised us precisely this: "I have yet many things to say to you but you cannot bear them now. When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth; for he will not speak on his own authority, but whatever he hears he will speak, and he will declare to you the things that are to come. He will glorify me, for he will take what is mine and declare it unto you. All that the Father has is mine; therefore I said that he will take what is mine, and declare it to you" (John16:12-15). So doctrine did not finish with Jesus. The Holy Spirit guides the Church in forming doctrines. Oh, but you say, 'then why are they not in agreement'. There is a process of revelation called Dialectic. That is when 2 extreme opposite viewpoints are pitted against each other and progress is made from their interaction. The Pharisees whom Jesus tells us are the authoritative interpreters of Mosaic law used this methodology too. There were 2 extremes of pharisaic thought. They were called the school of Hillel and the the school of Shammai. Shammai were pedantic sticklers for legal detail while the Hillel school had a more relaxed interpretation. Talmud brings out teaching through the interaction of these 2 schools. Look it up on Google. p.s Here is an interesting website that addresses your concerns, although here the issue is the canonisation of saints. http://www.mark-shea.com/newrev.html Are Saints "New Revelation?"Disclaimer: Everyone who knows me from here knows that I am not a Roman Catholic, I am merely stating my opinion of the issues as a neutral. |
cgift: You are getting closer to my questions in alluding to the transient nature of this purgatory. What determines the length of stay? Could you please answer my other questions? [b]You are being dishonest by throwing questions back at me in place of my own questions. [/b]That is not a fair way to debate. I had asked you some salient questions and you refused to answer saying you will only answer if I answer yours. Haba!! Chukwudi!! Na so e go be?1One day, as Jesus was teaching the people in the temple and preaching the gospel, the chief priests and the scribes with the elders came up 2and said to him, “Tell us by what authority you do these things, or who it is that gave you this authority.”[b] 3He answered them, “I also will ask you a question. [/b]Now tell me, 4was the baptism of John from heaven or from man?” 5And they discussed it with one another, saying, “If we say, ‘From heaven,’ he will say, ‘Why did you not believe him?’ 6But if we say, ‘From man,’ all the people will stone us to death, for they are convinced that John was a prophet.” 7So they answered that they did not know where it came from. 8And Jesus said to them, “Neither will I tell you by what authority I do these things.”Luke 20 If Jesus can do this then it is not surprising that a follower of Jesus (a true follower that is) would do the same. (I'm not saying that I'm speaking for whether a Chuks is a true follower or not, I'm just speaking for the principle.) Often the best way of making a point is to use a Rhetorical question. The question itself needs no answer, just the asking of the question will be sufficient cos the person that you asked the question, if he has any intelligence, will know how utterly dumb his original question was. This was the case with the Chief priests that came asking Jesus questions. In their bid to avoid the obvious answer they said that they didn't know. You too, if you have any gumption, you ought to know the obvious answers to your questions. Why are you still complaining that it is not fair and dishonest? Would you call Jesus dishonest? |
cgift: AIO, you! In an instance you play a middle man's role and in another you spew angerAbeg where did I spew anger? Or did your 'holy' spirit help you to interpret my words as anger, the same way that he has been helping you to interpret the bible to understand that people are baptised in order to replace those that are dead? As the ghetto youth would say over here, 'you're giving me bare laughs bruv, bare laughs'. Did you strike a nerve? Yes indeed, the nerve that is directly connected to my laughter muscles. |
Deep Sight: ^ ^ ^ Can we address the question of choice and freewill cgift raised concerning purgatory.This Guy!!! You dis guy!! So you dey here too? How long have you been lurking in the shadows? The funny thing is that I've been thinking of your through much of this thread, and I wondered to myself why you hadn't gotten involved yet. Se you see all the gymnastics wey dey go on? That cgift guy will give even you a run for your money. Can you recall what I said in the 'This Matter of Interpretations' thread?' First there is the Axiom, or particular belief of the interpreter. This is often supported by a literal reading of some portion of the bible.https://www.nairaland.com/839087/this-matter-interpretations It is all being played out so beautifully here. When I said that there was no limit to human ingenuity when it comes to this matter, even I did not imagine invention to the extent that cgift has taken things. 'People being baptized in order to replace people who had died.' 'Human beings not being spirits' 'Jesus preaching to the fallen angels after his death' 'Oh sorry, not preaching, but proclaiming' etc etc etc. I'm relishing all of this. I hope this thread is popular and people are reading this vis a vis my thread on interpreting scriptures. |
italo: With all respect, cgift, I think you too mature for this kind of questions you're asking.I thought they were dumb questions too, but then on closer inspection I realised his reason for asking those questions. We are getting into the heart of the matter as I will like to further show you how manipulations, twists, and interpretations for personal gains and outright misunderstanding and misapplication of the scriptures is what underlies the concept of Purgatory and many other false doctrines.I think that in law they say that if you can show a motive for the accused then that strengthens your case against the accused. For instance if someone is to gain by inheriting a dead man's property then that strengthens the case that says he is the murderer of the dead man. Similarly, if you can show that Purgatory (or any doctrine of a continued evolution of the soul after death) will lead to exploitation manipulations, and outright thieving then Voila!, you have the entire raison d'etre of the doctrine. The only problem with this is that if such reasoning is applied to the entirety of christianity, or the entirety of organised religion, but most especially christianity, then we have no choice but to conclude that the entire edifice is deviced precisely for the exploitation of humans and that there is no truth in it at all. The history of the ways christianity has been applied even up to the present day will serve as evidence against it. It is a weak way to argue. It is like saying that if a rich man dies then all his heirs must be charged for murder. But such thinking is not untypical of africans. In Oyo, back in the day, if the Alafin dies then his Aremo (crowned prince) must also die with him. This was done to prevent regicide. I couldn't help but think how idiotic this is when I first heard it. What about the 2nd son? He could kill the father in the knowledge that his elder brother will go to the grave with him and he would become Alafin. Anyway . . . |
goodnewz1: What I will not do is to ARGUE God's Word (the scripture)[size=17pt]Rubbish!! Complete and utter nonsense.[/size] |
Please Berni, Can Spirit also be referred to a Human too or not? Have you at least accepted that point? |
What commandment of God is transgressed by the doctrine of Purgatory? Purgatory is not something that you practice in contradiction to God's commandment. Or is praying for the departed a transgression of God's law. I thought real_berni's beef was that there is no scriptural foundation for purgatory. To be honest I don't think that anything can come of this thread anymore, because of insincerity. What is this supposed to mean?: AIO,You were the one going on as an authority on Noah and the destination and nature of 'spirits' that died at that time. And what is this about scholars? Are you resorting to personal jibes? I hope not. Please explain yourself. The fact that something is a tradition does not make it unbiblical. There are allusions to it in the bible. By the way, you haven't even addressed the source of the doctrine of Holy Trinity. It has been brought up again and again on this thread and I am ready to bet my last pant that you will not address it. How biblical is the Holy Trinity? |
TRADITION The word tradition simply means that which has been handed over. Teachings that are handed down from generation to generation, from teacher to student, are themselves traditions. The Bible is itself part of christian tradition. |
snthesis: a parable is defined as a simple story used to illustrate a moral or spiritual lesson.At your insistence, I yield. @cgift I'm loving your contribution. The Ecclesiastes passage spirit returns to Spirit source and dust returns to dust. This raises interesting points of the issue of Identity again. The Problem of Identity. When something is made up of composite parts then wherein lies the identity of the thing. If the hull of Theseus' ship is replace, and then at a later date the sails are replaced and then at a later date . . . slowly by slowly every part of the ship is replaced can we really still call the ship Theseus' ship. I recall a conversation I had with Olabowale (I miss the days when one could actually have a conversation with him) where we were discussing Ruh, and nafs. He said something about Nafs being the product of Ruh mixing into the flesh. So Nafs is Ruh when it mixes with the flesh. In other words the soul only exists when the spirit is in the body. But does that mean that when the spirit and the dust are separated that the person ceases to exist. That was the position of the Sadducees and one that Jesus and the Pharisees were opposed against. In fact some scholars believe that this was the original Jewish belief and that the pharisees brought in the innovation of life after death later. I love cgift's conjectures. It suggests that there have been offered 3 (and therefore possibly more undiscovered ) routes to salvation in the bible. First- Salvation via the Ark Second- Salvation via the Mosiac Law third - Salvation via the sacrifice of Christ. However it leaves me wondering about those that died prior even to when Noah began 'preparing the Ark'. |
snthesis: too lazy to read the post before mineI found this interesting website. I haven't read it all, and neither do I agree with everything in it, however it provides plenty of food for thought. I definitely think that the parable of Lazarus and the Rich man presents a lot of problems for many contemporary 'christian' doctrines, but what it does not do is address or disprove purgatory. In fact it seems to support it. After all, Why would the rich man be in torment while his family were still enjoying on earth? I thought the dead were to lie unconscious until judgment day when the whole world would be judged together. The Rich man seems to already have his judgment. And if he is not judged yet then at least we know that he is conscious in death. Conscious enough to want to warn his family. Anyway sha . . here's the website: http://www.tentmaker.org/articles/Lazarus-byHuie.htm Lazarus and the Rich Man |
Image123: You have your break. I was specific about the 'was in rome' part. Good morningAnd a very Good morning to you too sir. |
I missed when goodnewz said that. was Jesus 'proclaiming his victory' to wicked spirits or was he, like the scripture says, preaching the gospel to them? Claiming Victory and Preaching Gospel are two quite different things. |
Johnnie ZM: Chukwdi you are here still on this purgatory thing? Guy rest it purgatory does not exist...you know we have discussd this in the other topic (Why are youths leaving the Catholic Church) which you are here quoting my name. And every anti-purgatory person who have commentd here, kudos! Pastor A1 please leave the conversation you are no help...you are nt even taking any stand! Chukwudi and all Catholics here read your bible, give your life to Christ and avoid hell. Jesus gave us two ways: Broad way which lead to hell and narrow way which leads to life eternal!Na bible passage everybody dey take discuss for here. No be by force of repetition of rhetoric. I don't know if you have noticed that. If you get something to say abeg bring your bible passage. The only stand that I take is for Truth. Or at least what I perceive to be Truth. I see too many people who have obviously not thought critically about their positions but try to enforce it by yabbis and cajoling. This is not cool. And I will stand against it. I'm not in cahoots with Chukwudi or any catholics. I am merely recognising the validity of his position. I will agree that I'm not adding anything to this conversation if you can answer this question for me and the answer proves to have no bearing on the thread:
|
Gimme a break. 'Was in Rome' at the time that Paul was writing? Edit: Actually as I read 'Goodnewz4u''s post again I realise that he wasn't saying that Onesiphorus was in Rome at the time Paul was writing but that Onesiphorus and Paul had been in Rome together. So I misunderstood him. However I do not see how that has any bearing on whether Onesiphorus was dead or alive at the time that Paul was writing that letter. |
I generally understand 'was' to refer to the past. |
. . . And the Lord has provided a perfect case study here: https://www.nairaland.com/900588/catholic-purgatory-absolute-insult-jesus Of special interest in this thread is the interpretation of passages such as : 6For for this cause was the gospel preached also to them that are dead, that they might be judged according to men in the flesh, but live according to God in the spirit.From 1Peter chapter 4. and the following is quite something: Here is Goodnewz4u:the poster arrived at the conclusion that the person being spoken about was in Rome. All from the passage. |
[quote author=real_Berni] [size=14pt]also i aknowledge your assersion above,that purgatory is not mentioned in the bible, my question still remains that,is porgatory a holy bible scriptures teaching? or guessing? or speculation?, because bible as a whole has its own teaching outside other scriptures that distinguishes it from scriptures that are 'not holy',so pls explain,im waiting.[/size][/quote]Please while you wait for Chukwudi's response could you tell me if Trinity is 'a holy bible scriptures teaching'? or is it guessing or speculation? How was it arrived at? Can you please also explain to me one of the bible's own teaching that is not the result of someone's interpretation and is a fundamental tenet of christianity? I also posed a question earlier that still requires answering: 6For for this cause was the gospel preached also to them that are dead, that they might be judged according to men in the flesh, but live according to God in the spirit. If gospel was preached ALSO to the dead (ie the unsaved) then who was it preached too before it was preached to the dead? |
chookudi: This question has been on my mind for a while and I have decided to post it here for answers..who determines d particular date(s) every year for Easter Celebration?muslims celebrate their events based on the sightings of the moon but hw do all christians around the world "agree" on a particular date to celebrate Easter?Are you a muslim? I know some muslims have been attacked here for having a moon God or for the moon featuring too heavily in Islam. Well it does so too in christianity and judaism. the Jewish Calendar is a Lunar calendar unlike the Solar Gregorian calendar that the Roman's instituted. So festivals do not necessarily fall on certain positions of the Sun, but rather on the Moon. on the 21 March we have the Equinox. That is the day when day and night are of equal length in the year. ie. the Sun is directly above the equator. The first full moon after this date will mark the time of Easter. However easter must fall on a sunday, so we pick the first sunday after the first Full moon that comes after the Spring Equinox. |
1st John 4:1So you are of the opinion that spirits can apply to human beings too. I wonder what Real_berni has to say about that. |
goodnewz1: Here is Goodnewz4u:Please could you help me with my project. Could you please tell me how you arrived at the conclusion that Onesiphorus was in Rome and not dead. My project is to demonstrate that when you have a text as the basis of your faith then the only limitations to the doctrines of that faith will be the limitations of your imagination. |
If we are to read nakros as sometimes figurative and sometimes literally, I accept that. What I need to know is WHEN to apply the figurative reading and when to apply the literal reading. Is there a criteria? This is what will give this whole issue more rigour. And next, let's discuss the elephant in the room that everybody is ignoring, whether by pretending it is not there or by honestly not seeing it. 6For for this cause was the gospel preached [size=15pt]also[/size] to them that are dead, that they might be judged according to men in the flesh, but live according to God in the spirit. If gospel was preached ALSO to the dead (ie the unsaved) then who was it preached too before it was preached to the dead? |
Quick in earlier English simply means Alive. Quicksilver=Argent Vive= living silver = Mercury |
buzugee: PASTOR AIO who said i was jesting ? i was seriousI guess I was hoping that you were jesting. Now you say you're not, then that puts everything into another perspective. |
This Thread is a brilliant study in the process of biblical interpretations. real_berni, starting with the notion that the dead cannot be saved and that there is nothing that can be done for the dead, must now turn to the bible and read certain passages through a contorting lense. And those passages that cannot be contorted must simply be ignored. And simple arguments must be misunderstood. For instance the issue of 'spirits' being applied to humans in the episode of Endor must be misunderstood as chukwudi's proof of purgatory. And woe unto the guy who makes a mistake and calls the patriarch Abraham, Isaac and ESAU, rather than Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. The entire thread will then become a discussion about the mistake, unless the guy is fast enough to realise the ploy and knock it straight on the head. |
[quote author=real_Berni]@passtorAIO passtorAIO,QUOTE can you kindly prove the bible verse that mention God of Abraham Isaac and Esau'to support your claim, its very important because we want to establish 'what the bible teaches' and it can be done by quoting correctly bible verses to support our claims. i have pointed it out before my last post of which you responded to,that 'any assertion should be backed up by at least a bible verse',that is the only way we can learn,because bible 'interpretes itself'. so, show us where you Got God of Abraham Isaac and Esau so as to learn from you as a pastor. thanks[/quote]Are you trying to jump on the fact that I mentioned Esau and not Jacob? So that is what your argument has been reduced to. Pedantry!! If you don't know the verse that I'm talking about then no wahala. |
so the metaphorical use of the word 'dead' in matthew must now be automatically applied to 2Peter too. Na wa o! All this strengthens my arguments about the lack of rigour in interpretations. When Jesus says that The God of Abraham Isaac and Esau cannot be the god of the dead, what does that say about the patriarchs? |
I don't know why none of the protestants that are attacking the notion of purgatory just don't simply address the verses that chukwudi has posted up. It is a straightforward matter. Only Ikhideman address ONE of the verses and that is because he felt that he could twist it so it didn't support Chukwudi's point. Chukwudi's point is simple. Why pray for somebody who has already died if his fate is already sealed after death. Paul prays obviously because he believe that something can still be done to further redeem the dead after they are gone. This is such a simple and obvious point. Well done, Mr buzugee, and thank you for the light entertainment. As for the rest of those who do not realise that he is joking, take note that the nation of Israel was not even in existence at the time of Noah and the Peter passage talks about people being imprisoned from the time of Noah. So whatever sins the Israelites committed, it has nothing to do with the issue. As for everybody else, instead of foaming at the mouth and cursing Catholicism, why not just go and study the verses that Chukwudi has brought to your attention. Study the Letter and the Spirit and then come back with a commentary or opinion on the verses. One that is actually valid, not jest like buzugee gave us. If there is nothing after death then Jesus must have been deluded to go and preach to nothing. Unless Peter (or who wrote that letter) was deluded to say that Jesus went to preach to nothing. Why would he preach if it was already too late for them to be saved? I think that there is too much arrogance in christianity and it often based on an insecurity and a need to buttress the shaky foundations of one's faith. This is precisely the attitude to religion that causes wars. Anyhow, let me not go on too much. |
GboyegaD: So this is enough to make him your president rightIn any normal civilised country that is not enough to make him president. BUT IN NIGERIA? In Nigeria he is even over qualified for the post. He is the equivalent of 3 presidents. I'm not a fan of the guy but I admit in the country of the blind, one eyed man must be made the king. |
LagosShia: there are men greater than soyinka that bow down in their five daily prayers as muslims.These are very serious allegations. Can you back any of them up? So to practice the religion of your ancestors makes you a tribalist! Luckily this is just Nairaland because if we were somewhere where there are decent libel laws I'm sure you'll do more thinking before you open your mouth than you are currently wont to do. |
This blast from the past ought to throw some light on my recent contentions over the interpretation of scriptures. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 155 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 (of 287 pages)
Let me leave you for now.

I wonder how Nigerians can be so intrigued by little things as this.