PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 (of 287 pages)
Truth does not lend itself to Rhetoric. |
I think i'll leave you guys to bash this one out. I'm not getting involved. |
SeanT21:Truth is Fact like Chalk is Cheese. madamkoko:No! I disagree. Facts are relative but not Truth. The experience of Truth can be subjective in the sense that it cannot be demonstrated to another. wirinet:I get your point but you've made a small contradiction. 1)Truth is a universal interpretation. and 2)truth also must be . . . not subject to interpretation. I would put what I think you are saying like this: No matter which way you look at it, when you look at it, or perspective from which you look at it, regardless of Conditionality, Truth remains the same. The moment you interpret it according to a certain perspective it ceases to be the Truth. Various perspective will always come up with various interpretations of the truth. Yet truth remains integral, constant and beyond the interpretations that our brains can form. |
@Wirinet. Thank you for the appreciation. I'll try not to let it go to my head. I've heard of Carl Sagan and I'll look out for the book. I am an Evolutionist to the core. Evolution mean change brought about by changes in conditions, situations and time. Evolution takes place not just physically, but also socially, politically, economically, etc. I trace most problems besetting Nigeria as being traced to our stage of social evolution.Granted. Yet conditions are different in different parts of the world, not only at different times. Now a gripe that I have with Marxist theory is that it is too Eurocentric, and I suspect that your theory of social evolution is quite eurocentric too. The conditions that applied and will apply in Europe with the rise of the bourgeoisie from feudalism to the predicted eventual rise of the proletariat cannot be applied to africa. So therefore the idea of a global movement of workers is flawed. Even if Europeans evolve to become atheist doesn't mean that it will happen in africa. Evolution takes a few cells and eventually ends up with birds that fly on one hand and fish that swim on the other hand. Let us presume that the first humans all thought the same and europeans evolved into atheists which is the equivalent of the flying birds. Why do we have to evolve into ideological birds too? Couldn't we evolve into ideological fish? I find this problem a lot in social sciences where there is too much of a eurocentric approach. Besides religion is not just a social phenomena to be studied by social science. A lot of it has it's basis in human experience. So until humans evolve away from being able to experience divinity I think that religion will still be around. |
Truth has it's place in Eternity. Facts have their place in Temporality. Facts have their time span. The Grass is Green. Yes, but only for one week. After that it becomes brown. Therefore it is not a Truth that Grass is Green. These are Ontological questions really. Ontology is the study of what can be said to exist. For many mystics and philosophers Facts do not actually exist but are an illusion. Afterall how can something that eventually ceases to be evident be said to have existed. Therefore only Eternal things exist. Indeed those that experience eternity say that afterwards this temporal world does not feel real to them anymore. Feel real? Could it be that the reality of something is just a feeling, a subjective experience. You don't even have to have an experience of eternity. If you've ever fainted, or sometimes just woken up from a deep sleep, it takes time before sensual experiences take on their starkness and realness again. The realness of it can also be affected by the occurrence of certain events. Like the day that you get you exam results and you pass to go to the college that you've been dreaming of all your life. You have to pinch yourself. "Is this real"?, you'll blink twice. And then again sometimes things feel so much more real and in your face than they normally do. So how does this subjective experience of realness work? I suspect that endurance has a lot to do with it. For instance I believe that we dismiss dreams as being unreal because most dreams are one off experiences. Whereas every morning you awake, you awake to see the same four walls, the same window, and the same gorgeous wife lying next to you. Therefore your waking experience is considered more real than the dream. Awake is reinforced by repetition. However imagine that you dreamt every night of going to the same well and there meeting 3 friends with whom you converse. Imagine the dreams have continuity. Like one night you advise one of the friends to stand up to his wife. Afterall he is the man in the house. Then the next night you dream again and you see him with a black eye and a swollen jaw. And he is very upset with you for previously advising him to stand up to his wife, advise that has led to such abysmal consequences. If we dreamt like that, with consistent scenarios and continuity in the story then I dare say that we would consider our dreams real and invest some of our energies into ensuring that our dream life is suitable. If endurance and continuity are what lead us to accept something as being real, then it makes sense when philosophers like Plato and the Pre socratics considered FActs to be unreal. Is Grass really green or does it just give the illusion to be in the state of greenness for a time? Anything that doesn't last forever or isn't eternal cannot be Real. Everytime you contemplate eternal things they remain as they are, True, so therefore they are ontologically speaking the only real things. |
What exactly are the benefits of religion or spirituality for us here on earth?I believe that one of the constituent parts of the human being is the spiritual and it needs exercising and nourishing just as much as the body does. This is how the whole being of man can become properly fulfilled. It might seem that spiritual development does nothing for the physical part of man's being but it is not so. Let me give an example like this. Sometimes I get terribly busy. So busy in fact that the day is not long enough for me to accomplish everything. I can't go jogging or go for my regular swims because that would be too much of a distraction. Just dealing with one issue in the day can take me up to 4 hours. I feel the strain. The last thing in the world that I would accept as good advice is someone telling me to just take 1 hour out of the day to go for that jog. But is it such bad advice. Say I accept the advice, what happens? First I find that my mind is a lot clearer after the run, my body is more relaxed and at the same time more alert. Also I find that the issue that it took me 4 hours to deal with before I now conclude in an hour and a half. So all in all I have saved an hour and a half of the day's time just by going for an early run. Because of the increased sharpness of my mind and the good humour I find myself in it seems that all those things that weighed me down before are slight things. We find that exercising the body helps the mind to work better. I would also suggest that being more spiritual helps the entire constitution of the human being to work better. But by being spiritual I mean a lot more than going to church and clapping and singing and babbling incoherent syllables. |
It is not only religion that offers hope. politicians offer hope too. Salesmen offer hope to. In fact without hope you cannot sell or convince anyone of anything. The Salesman will not be able to sell his perfume if he didn't convince you that with it you had better hope of getting the girl you want. "oh yeah, spray this on and your latter will be better than your former". Hope is what keeps everything going in this temporal place. Nothing works without hope. Oh yeah and FEAR too. "Don't spray this and you won't ever find love . . . EVER!" |
Babalegba:Could the real Esu please stand up. |
. . . . Soooo . . . , why do we need religion? Because we have a tendency to follow and engage in Misappropriation of our being and our resources. Therefore we need the discipline of religion to subdue this tendency and follow rather the tendency for Truth. |
[quote author=Negro_Ntns link=topic=152632.msg2534867#msg2534867 date=1216630437]On the part of corrupt and sinful Priests, do you not agree that they are misleading and mis educating the masses? That in the name of Christianity, they are leading men and women away from what is truly Christ-like and that they do so very successfully by using tactics that were skillfully employed by colonial missionaries to conquer Africans in ways that the guns and mortars of colonial Armies could not? It is not fair to excuse them on fear of condemning remarks while their tongues and teachings are instrumental in the condemnation of multitude souls that follow them blindly, believing in their false messages of prophecy.[/quote]There are many things that will cause people to lose their way in life, but as regards certain priests etc, I do not feel that it is my place to accuse them. If someday the spirit moves me to say something about that then I will, according to the inspiration. However what I am inspired to say is that there is an appropriation for each and every individual. There is a blueprint, a Truth within, a script, an anointing, an appointment, an Iranse (a message), an eudaimonia within each and every human being and that to follow this is the purpose of our creation and the way to please God. This is the essence of religion. To re-connect you to this gameplan. From this flows everything that is good in a human being's life. To find that which has been appropriated for you and to stick to it is what is Proper, Right, Righteous, Worshipful and True. To deviate from it is corruption. I would rather go on about this than have my rhetoric reduced to nothing but Priest bashing. I favour positivity than negativity. Priest bashing will not tell the people that they have a portion. They have a Reservation at a table that is better than any other table in any restaurant on the whole planet. Yes, I would rather just get down to the crux of the matter than waste time swatting at those flies called crooked priests. |
wirinet:Fairyland calling to Lala land, do you read me? My dear wirinet, I do not get how you arrived at your theory of the evolution of social thought. Did you study the history and archaelogy? In that case I need citations. I will tell you why religion cannot evolve from monotheism to polytheism.I would agree that thanks to our developed Neo-cortex we have the ability to abstract information from our sense impressions. This allows us to 'create' another abstract world of ideas and concepts apart from the physical world that our senses perceive. However this does not necessarily lead to the belief in a god that is controlling the objects. Even the mere fact that humans try to fit their world into a cosmology does not necessarily lead to the belief in Gods. Do you mind if rather than use the word god I used the word spirit? The human tendency to make abstractions and cosmologies doesn't necessarily have to end up with the belief in a spiritual world. I think you need a more rigorous explanation for why the belief in spirits is so rampant. A class of people would then naturally emerge to claim to communicate with these gods and act as intermediary between the gods and humans. These priests/shaman would then be given special privileges, wealth, respect and reverenceI don't see how this process is so natural either. If all primitive men believed in the existence of spirits then what allows one to claim a closer relation? I don't see how a priesthood arises out of necessity. Now as people begin to explain natural phenomena better, the number of gods will naturally reduce. You will not need a sun god anymore once you know sun is a natural object, so also thunder, rain, etc.Can't you just skip to a natural explanation straight away. Must absolutely everyone in the world first believe in the supernatural before they evolve in to believing in the natural. Pastor, Muslims never claimed than monotheism turns to polytheismI really ought to leave this for muslims to answer for themselves. But my understanding is that muslims say that everyone is born a monotheist and that they get corrupted later in life. Therefore muslims seek to make people 'revert' rather than convert. It is a fallacy to say that every religion is monotheistic, most religions starts out polytheistic. The Yoruba religion you mention had lots of god. Of course there is always a superior or ruler god, there is a hierarchy as in every other religion. In Yoruba religion the superior god is Olorun ( ruler of the sky), then next in command in Olokun ( ruler of the seas), then there is Orunmila (oldest son of olorun), Obatala (creator of man and dry land at Ife), Esu and a host of other gods.I hope I can prompt you to take a closer look at the mythology. According to yoruba mythology the world is ruled via Olodumare's lieutenants called the Orisha. Olodumare is not one amongst many, not even the greatest amongst a kind. All the orisha have cults attached to them and their interaction with devotees is cultic. Olodumare has no cult attached. There are no ile esin (temples) for olodumare neither are there ritual objects or or forms of worship. There is no priesthood etc. All these cultic aspects apply only to the orisha which include Olokun, orunmila, obatala, esu etc. Also, as regards to hierarchy, each cult will try to elevate it's patron orisha to the position of second in command to olodumare. It is not a pantheon as such in which all the orisha live together and share duties. A lot of devotees worship one orisha and one orisha only. Anyway, my main point is that your version of the history and evolution of religious thought is unfounded. You have not brought forward one thing that will help substantiate any of it. This is similar to what I feel about Marxist theory, but at least Marx tried to fit actual historical events his theory of social evolution. As it stands your theory is a far cry from doing that. |
huxley:Ah aaah! Huxley. Let's consider what the guy is saying, even if just a little bit. Such outright dismissal is not scientific. What are your arguments to suggest that he is talking rubbish. ps. I'm not agreeing with him, I'm just saying that he deserves proper consideration. |
[quote author=Negro_Ntns link=topic=152632.msg2531438#msg2531438 date=1216547899]Religion was meant as a communal recharging station for the individual soul to redeem itself and maintain its sense of divinity on account of the imperfection and propensity of the body in which it resides to perpetually be engaged in acts of corruption and sin. For this reason, temples are created and designated as sacred. The intention being that on entry, the body is humbled and the ego subdued for the beginning of the cleansing and rituals that take place on the temple grounds. This is different from spirituality. Spirituality is a individual quest for truth, a yearning desire to merge the soul to a divine source. The ways of peace, the ascent to unravel the unconscious part of self.[/quote]QTF!! There is nothing for me to add here but to say that I concur totally. I took out the part about the dirty religious leaders though because it is not my place to pass judgement on them. |
IbrahimB:As indeed they are all etymologically connected to El which is the chief god of most semitic peoples yet who had sons and daughters etc. Cognate forms are found throughout the Semitic languages with the exception of the ancient Ge'ez language of Ethiopia. Forms include Ugaritic ’il, pl. ’lm; Phoenician ’l pl. ’lm, Hebrew ’ēl, pl. ’⁏lîm; Aramaic ’l, Arabic ʾilāh; Akkadian ilu, pl. ilāti. The original meaning may have been 'strength, power'. In northwest Semitic usage ’l was both a generic word for any 'god' and the special name or title of a particular god who was distinguished from other gods as being the god, or in the monotheistic sense, God. Ēl is listed at the head of many pantheons. El was the father god among the Canaanites. However, because the word sometimes refers to a god other than the great god Ēl, it is frequently ambiguous as to whether Ēl followed by another name means the great god Ēl with a particular epithet applied or refers to another god entirely. For example, in the Ugaritic texts ’il mlk is understood to mean 'Ēl the King' but ’il hd as 'the god Hadad' Taken from here:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_(god) In yoruba thought we have the different Oosa. They have a leader called Obatala who is on many occasions just called Oosa. Oosa refers to the head as well as the individual dieties. There is still a distinction from Olodumare. There is no where in the Qur'an where it is stated that God has daughters (or sons or children or father or mother or whatever). I think we should cite the Qur'an as the authority concerning Islam,I take it that you haven't heard of the Satanic Verses. |
Is Aparo a bird or a human being? |
The Arabs had many gods and also Tribal Gods. The Tribal god of the Quraishi was called Allah and he had three daughters. Al -Lat, Al-Uzzi, and Manat. The qureishi also controlled Mecca and the Kabba which was the place where all their idols were stored. I think europe was doing quite well prior to christianity. Remember that Rome ruled the world and the culture was basically hellenic, with it's attendant strong philosophical and humanistic traditions. It was after the final fall of Rome and the rise of the christian Holy Roman Empire that Europe fell into what is today called the dark ages. This continued until the renaissance when europe rediscovered the Classics of Ancient greece and rome (interestingly enough, thanks to the islamic arabs). This revival was strongly resisted by the Church on many fronts. (although to give credit where it is due the church also preserved many greek texts). I seem to sense a kind of reverence for europe which i think is misguided. But most importantly I find it necessary to point out that its seeming advancement has nothing to do with christianity. If anything, the scientific and social 'advancements' made in the western world and the arab world occurred as a result of their contact and reverence of greek humanistic philosophy. |
wirinet:What town in Lala land is this guy from? Where is the historical evidence for this scheme of social evolution that you've graced us with. why can't religion evolve from monotheism to polytheism, as indeed the moslems claim it does? Also I think there is a very basic mis understanding of religion going on here. Pretty much every religion that I'm aware of is monotheistic. Consider Yoruba religion. There is one God who is called Olodumare. There is no ritual worship of Olodumare. His worship does not require altars and priests and any specialised knowledge. It is from the heart of the creature to the heart of the creator. Yet this world is formed via the agency of Orisha which are found in the features of the earth. Orisha are approached ritualistically. You have methods and cultic shrines whereby they are consulted. There is no way you are going to meet any yoruba man who knows anything about his own culture that will put orisha and olodumare on an equal footing or even say that they are co-dieties in a pantheon. That is impossible. |
Tasma:I didn't think that flat earth was an article of christian belief. I thought that the idea of a global earth was around for ages as well as flat earth. Anyway, there are many different gifts that the spirit can confer. I believe that a person filled with the spirit whose calling it is to investigate geology and astronomy would make great strides and arrive at much knowledge of his chosen subject. Similarly a doctor with spiritual guidance will be a greater doctor. |
olabowale:What is the means of activation? There seems to be a putting the cart before the horse scenario being suggested here. What is the process or the practice that will enable the awakening of Al Fitra? For if the 5 pillars are the consequence of an awakened Al fitra then they cannot precede it. What must one do prior to the awakening that will bring about the awakening? olabowale:But is it the Al Fitra that makes you a mooslim or is it being a mosslem that brings out al-fitra in you. What am I saying really is making a distinction between Religion and Worship. Religion being a practice that will put you in concordance with the Truth and Worship being the outcome of Walking in the truth. I am suggesting 3 steps in a sequence that runs like this. Religion (practice) - Realisation (Al-fitra) - True Worship (which as we said above is living in concordance to God's will for you). Or as the quran put it: “See you not that it is God Whose praises are celebrated by all beings in the heavens and on earth, and by the birds with extended wings? Each one knows its prayer and glorification; And God is aware of what they do.” An-Nur vs.41John Coltrane would suggest 4 steps: Acknowledgement - Resolution - Pursuance - Psalm. These all make up A Love Supreme. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HMrK7564Egs |
[quote author=m_nwankwo link=topic=149239.msg2508845#msg2508845 date=1216129848]Do you dispute that God is still the creator even when he has not created man. What exactly do you mean by replacing one authority with another. Be specific. Thanks[/quote]Friend, I never specified the creation of Man. I said what is a creator without a CREATION. To be a creator you have to have a creation. And as regards Authority I rely on one and one only and that is the spirit given to me to guide me in all things, indeed the very one promised. It has been my observation that many reject one text as an authority for whatever reasons and then uphold another text. Text can never be for me an authority. With the authority that I have I can read Winnie the Pooh and get guidance and edification. I can feel a raindrop on my forehead and get a revelation from that. Mosulems will reject the bible and carry koraan put for top head. What is the justification that koraan has that bible doesn't have, I don't know. You, I presume from reading some of your post, reject bible and carry Grail book put for head. Ultimately what occurs is that you do not think for yourself but rather turn to this authority for ready made answers. Spiritual things are spiritual things. Earthly things are earthly things. If you try to present Spiritual things in eArthly terms you will falter, you will miss road, you will fail. God cannot be defined, delimited, or confined into our various theories and concepts. If you put fresh wine in your crusty old skins it will be burst asunder and you will be left with neither wine nor skin. |
[quote author=m_nwankwo link=topic=149239.msg2478715#msg2478715 date=1215535728]Thus God can exist without man but a "perfect man" cannot exist without God.[/quote]What is a Creator without a creation?[quote author=m_nwankwo link=topic=149239.msg2478873#msg2478873 date=1215537505]That something is mentioned in the bible does not in itself constitute the truth or lack of it. All the same it is your own view and you are entitled to it. Thanks[/quote]That something is mentioned in any book at all does not in itself constitute the truth or lack of it. I generally find that when people reject one authority, it is merely to replace it with another authority that hardly has a better foundation, in fact often a far worse foundation. |
Well I believe that to truly excel in education or any skill for that matter one requires the spirit. I don't mean wishful thinking 'spirituality' but real spirituality. Seek ye first the kingdom of God. It manifests differently in different people. One can recieve the spirit and the spirit will prompt him to go and train in medicine. Others can be prompted to study architecture and build homesteads for people. Those to whom the spirit has not granted the gift of healing yet believe that they can tamper with the prone body of an accident victim are only suffering a conceit. I too see a distinction between Sensible knowledge and Intellectual/spiritual knowledge. One form of knowledge you receive through your senses and the other you receive via the agency of the spirit. The two can work together in harmony or they can be at odds with each other. So in answer to your question . . . . Should things be this way, should Christians and other religious people not strife to gain further knowledge about the world they live in in order to be better equipped to take care of themselves?. . . My answer is that people should strife to gain further knowledge about the world in accordance to the promptings and guidance of the spirit. Schools, hospitals and other such ostensibly 'good' things cannot, in my opinion, yield Good fruit if they are not done according to the guidance of the spirit. |
I'm not sure I understand your question, but I'll try to answer anyway. There is God everywhere in everyland. I don't know what the purpose of human sacrifice is. Perhaps to appease spirits or to use as surrogate for themselves. By God I assume you mean the creator and author of all that exists. In yoruba land he is called Eledumare. Do some research and you're sure to find out about him. |
Does the example above really indicate a spiritual person? It suggests someone who believes that they can effect a cure by praying. That belief can be the result of delusion. I wonder, what exactly is your definition of a spiritual person? |
thehomer:Hi thehomer. "Worldly logic" is based on facts, not truth. There is a distinction between facts and Truth. Facts occur in the temporal world and Truth is Eternal. This is even obvious from the Etymology. Fact comes from Factorum which is a Done thing. the French call it Fait. Which is also the past participle of To Do. A fact is something that had occurred at some point in time. It is temporal. Something that hasn't yet occurred cannot be called a fact. It is not a fact that you will wake up at 8am tomorrow morning, though it may be a fact that you woke up a 8am yesterday morning. try: A conjecture is when you arrive at a piece of information by following the implication of at least 2 other bits of information that you accept as fact. It is impossible to arrive at a certain summary using this method because human sensory experience is limited. We can never know all the factors that are brought to bear on determining any event. For example: I come home early from work one evening to find my best friend walking out of my house and doing up his zip with a satisfied grin on his face. I've spotted this from afar and by the time I actually arrive at the front door he has left. I enter the house to find my wife in a state of dishevelment and worse still, she is not supposed to be at home. She told me that she had a very important meeting that afternoon at the other end of town. It doesn't take a conjectural genius to put the pieces together and realise that the two people i trust the most in my life are playing me. I pull out my shot gun and end her life swiftly. Was that a reasonable reaction? Was my conclusion a certain fact? Or was it just the Likely story? Isn't that just what, based on my experience of these things, most probably happened? Imagine after I've killed my wife and the police are investigating it transpires that my little daughter was ill and so my wife had to abandon her meeting to tend for her. the child's condition was so critical that she had to call for my best friend who is a doctor. My wife had been soo worried and stressed that her hair and clothes became disheveled. Luckily my friend was able to stabilise my daughters condition. He then seized the opportunity to use the toilet to relieve himself as he had been holding back the call of nature for the last 2 hours. After using the toilet he left. It was at that point that I spotted him from afar doing up his zip and looking satisfied. Can you not see how easy it is to get the wrong end of the stick? Any attempt to build a picture of what happened based on information recieved by the senses can only lead to the likely story because the senses cannot and can never get the whole picture. We are limited to PERSPECTIVE. Our evidence is not PANORAMIC enough. Just consider sight. We see such a limited range of lightwaves in the atmosphere. We don't see ultraviolet we don't see InfraRed. To the extent that these frequencies of light come to play upon determining an event I will be unaware of the outcome. To make an absolutely accurate conjecture I will need to know absolutely every detail of facts that will come to play in determining the event. That is impossible. e.gBy the way, this is called a syllogism. It is not logic but is an aspect of the study of 'logic'. There are other 'logical' systems.Today, some academics claim that Aristotle's system is generally seen as having little more than historical value (though there is some current interest in extending term logics), regarded as made obsolete by the advent of sentential logic and the predicate calculus. Others use Aristotle in argumentation theory to help develop and critically question argumentation schemes that are used in artificial intelligence and legal arguments. Taken from here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logic Conjecture is reasoning that involves the formation of conclusions from incomplete evidence.Clap for yourself! Now tell me, When has Perspective ever produced Complete evidence? You had already stated that the propositions have to be factual. How can something be factual and still be conjecture?Indeed the propositions are facts. Therefore I'll have to correct you when after siting propositions A and B above which indeed ought to be evidential facts, you then present the inference as a Fact. No! The inference is not the facts but the Likely Story based on the Facts we are aware of. Conjecture is the procedure of taking facts and coming up with a likely story by methods of inference. A fact is either true or can be verified to be true.Nope! A fact is simply something that has happened. There are many things that have happened in history which cannot be verified, though they are true and that is because it is impossible to verify from our PERSPECTIVE. From your definition of faith, it seems that only Christians can have faith. But it would also apply to anyNot merely believe in a supernatural being but have experience of a supernatural being. Faith is the faculty that allows you to experience and act in the supernatural world. Also, if a christian traveling on a bus has faith that he will not have an accident,If a christian sees spiritually that he will not have an accident. eg if he has had a vision of himself safely at his destination then he has faith and can trust that he will not have an accident. If however he just read a book and talked to his pastor who assured him that he will not crash, and by sheer effort of wishful thinking he convinced himself that he would not crash, then he is taking a chance. More of a chance than the person who is using a more critical form of conjecture. In other words, your definition of faith is belief in a conjecture and is therefore not logical.Non! Non!! Non!!! I repeat that Faith is a faculty of perception just like the senses are faculties of perception but it is primed at another reality, not the physical natural reality, But rather a supernatural reality. |
The Purpose of religion is to put you back in touch with yourself as God intended you to be. That way you can be truly happy and fulfilled and worship God perfectly. |
Cristalz:Walk down the downtown of any major city, or even go to dinner with rich white middle class people and you will easily see that it is Opium (and cocaine and other drugs) that have become the Religion of the masses. What appetite are these people trying to assuage by the use of all these substances. |
Ndipe:Ologbon kan o le ta koko omi si eti aso no wise man can tie a knot of water with the edge of a garment. - The King of Edu |
@thehomer My definitions are as follows: Christian: Someone who is a follower of Christ. Christ means the Anointed one. Someone who therefore adheres to the Life that has been Appropriated for him. Logic: I will refer to my previous post which you might not have read. Is this a common habit in Nairaland to respond to threads without reading them. Anyway, this is what I wrote above again. Pastor AIO:My final definition is for faith: I do not believe that Faith is suspension of disbelief or critical thinking. No, Far from being synonymous with gullibility I hold that Faith is a faculty by which we can perceive and evidence things that we cannot see with our physical senses. It is a gift of the spirit. Refined conjecture can be found to be consistent, sound and complete, but alas that is not enough to know anything for certain. Still all it leaves you with is the LIKELY STORY. It is probabilistic. It will tell you what most likely happened or will happen but it can never tell you for sure, 100 per cent certainty. |
Thank you everybody, for all of this |
But what comes first, the fitra or the 5 pillars. Is it possible to be sincere and perform the ostensible aspects with the whole being if one is not in concordance with Fitra? |
I've nearly passed out from holding my breath for your reply. Anyway, Like I promised I have a part 2 which brings us up to the first 10 minutes of his interview. I hope that I'll have demonstrated why I refuse to acknowledge that he's an intellectual but rather a conjecturer. My dismissal of him was not without reason, or just to be rude and I do not want to discourage you from posting links or suggest that I don't appreciate your links because I do appreciate them, probably more than what anybody else on this forum has to offer. Part II) At 7:20 he makes some humungous sweeping comments that convinces that not only does he know little about philosophy but he also knows even less about religion. What religion tells you to look outward to God for solving your problems? Are we not told rather to look within and that God has written his statutes in our hearts and that his will is the very substance of our natures. I think that he is picking and choosing, like they all do, which ostensible aspects of religion he is going to pit himself against. It is a lot easier to challenge those demagogues and religiously derived ideologies that have little in fact to do with religion. All religion and philosophy that I'm aware of teach that there is an essential nature or aspect to man. And that man has deviated from this essential nature. In other words man is an appropriated being. Appropriation means that something has been set aside for a specific purpose. To be employed in any capacity other than that is to become misappropriated. Christianity teaches us that we have an anointing, ie we are chosen/appropriated. Islam teaches that we have Al Fitra which too is an appropriation. Philosophy teaches that we have an eudaimonia. Hinduism teaches that we have Dharma. Ifa teaches that we have Ori or Ayanmo, which is a chosen destiny. Taoists too say we have an essential nature. Please I need to know the religion that tells us to look outside of ourselves to find fulfillment because I don't know of any. Our interaction with God is within ourselves, that is where God speaks to us, and it is a part and parcel of us, without this you are not a complete human being. Kurtz is just picking and choosing what face of religion to attack according to if he thinks he can get away with it. So you see we don't lack confidence in man, as he says, but rather in man's sinful nature. In other words we lack confidence in the misappropriation of man. (I will use the word misappropriation a lot because it is a theme that runs through my disagreement with Paul Kurtz). For example at 09:00 He discusses the need to go beyond the 'courage to be' to arrive at the 'courage to become'. What a plagiarist. Here again he plagiarises Plato (and others before Plato) who makes the distinction between the world of Being and the world of Becoming. But of course he misappropriates the terms. The World of Being according to philosophy (real philosophy) is the eternal world where there is no past, future or movement of time and but things are constantly the way they are. This is contrasted with the world of Becoming which is the physical world of the senses where everything is a process and in a state of flux. So the human body is constantly becoming, changing from one form to another. Whereas the eternal aspect of a human is in a state of constant stillness. The world of Becoming is a projection of the world of Being. In other words it is a derivative of the world of Being. So when he says we have to move from Being to Becoming he is talking absolute kaka. We are already becoming. It is impossible to just Be in the physical world. Nothing is still in the physical world. So what exactly is he saying here. I have no idea. It doesn't just stop there. At 9:49 he goes on to talk about The Good Life. This is another misappropriation from Platon. He credits Aristotle, but Aristotle was a student of Platon. What is that nonsense about him being vindicated by modern science and the 'science of happiness'? The Good Life has been talked about for millenia before he even existed. How dare he credit himself with it! It is again central to every school of religion and philosophy that I'm aware of. What about Epicurus who wrote extensively on the subject? "For the secular Humanist the goal is happiness for the individual and for the community . . .", he says. As well as in religion I say. His doting interviewer says that the way to achieve happiness is to develop the capabilities of the human being. I totally agree. However I don't see how they hope to succeed if they deny the most essential features of the human being. How are you going to develop something that you deny exists? Man, I could go on and on but then I'll just sound like I'm ranting. How do people like this get to be Professor Emeritus of anything? Maybe I'm just bitter because I want to be able to get paid to talk nonsense too. It must be a great job. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 271 272 273 274 275 276 277 278 279 (of 287 pages)