Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 5:43pm On Apr 10, 2017 |
The notion of various sources in the bible is one accepted by most scholars today. The main sources are called J E P and D. https://web.cn.edu/kwheeler/Genesis_texts.htmlWhat Are the J, E, and P Texts of Genesis?
To understand what scholars are talking about when they discuss the "J" or "E" or "P" Text of Genesis, it helps if we look closely at the first two chapters of Genesis*, which illustrate the subject. If we note some textual oddities first, it becomes easier to see how scholars formulated the ideas of the J, E, and P text.
To begin, when textual criticism and its systematic techniques for analyzing ancient manuscripts first became available in the 18th and 19th centuries (and even earlier in nonscholarly readings from the Renaissance) many readers noticed some odd details in the book we call Genesis. The first part of Genesis (1:1-2:3) differed from the later parts (Genesis 2:4-3:23) in interesting ways.
(1) First, each of these two sections of Genesis contains a different introduction for the creation story. Genesis 1:1 launches with the eloquent and imminently quotable, "In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. Now the earth was formless and void, and darkness was over the surface of the deep, and the Spirit of God was hovering over the waters."
The text reaches its conclusion in Genesis 2:1, where the narrative voice announces, "Thus the heavens and the earth were completed in all their vast array." Finis. The end. However, a second introduction appears in Genesis 2:4: "This is the account of the heavens and the earth when they were created. When the Lord God made the earth and the heavens, no shrub of the field had yet appeared on the earth . . . ." This initially seems a little redundant--at least on the surface of things. It seems to suggest a second creation story rather than one alone.
(2) The sections also differ in genre. One is written in poetry and the other is written in prose. Genesis 1:1-2:3 is a poetic text. It is metered, and probably the writer(s) intended for it to be sung as a hymnic chant. Rhyme is not all that important in Hebrew poetry, but Hebrew poems commonly use repetition, chiasmus, parallelism, and other rhetorical schemes and tropes. The Genesis 1 text uses "high style" and those artistic devices common to Hebrew poetry--especially catachresis, anaphora, and parallelism. To indicate these artistic qualities here, most NIV translations reproduce the text with hanging indentation to mark the poetic structure. Each section begins with an anaphora: "And God said . . ." Each section ends with epistrophe: "And there was evening, and there was morning--the . . . day." Likewise, after the first two days, we have the artistic repetition of the phrase "And God saw that it was good," leading up to a final crescendo, "and it was very good" in Genesis 1:31. This structure is high poetry in the best Hebrew style.
Contrast that with the material following. Genesis 2:4-3:23 is a non-poetic text. It is written in prose rather than in poetic lines--no meter. It does not use anaphora and parallelism the same way as that first section. To indicate the non-poetic nature of the text here, most NIV translations break the text into paragraphs. In terms of literary devices, the primary schemes and tropes are puns providing Hebrew folk etymologies. For instance, the narrative voice tells us that humanity (the Hebrew word adam) is called adam because God made him from adamah (ground or dust). The folk etymology provides an etiology explaining why the word for "woman" in Hebrew sounds so much like the Hebrew word for "man."
(3) Partly because of the difference between poetic devices and puns, and partly because of changes in diction, the tone of each passage is quite different. In the Genesis 1 passage, the diction is grandiose--designed to emphasize the majesty and the ordered nature of creation. In Genesis 2:4 and following, the tone becomes more familiar--more "folksy" and simple. We have moved away from the grandeur of the heavens where a disembodied Spirit of God hovers over the dark waters to a smaller setting--the muck and dirt of a single garden where we find God shaping men out of mud and where animals like the serpent can talk in the best beast fable tradition. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 5:34pm On Apr 10, 2017 |
MuttleyLaff: Watch yourself catch on and if not now, then sooner or later, do your own disappearing act too
I missed nothing and nothing went over my head I actually addressed the chronology and more and if your are a honorable man, it takes not much decency to admit this
I have previously mentioned to recall that King Saul had never met or set eyes on Jesse before. King Saul doesnt know Jesse from Adam, King Saul has had no one-to-one with Jesse, has had no direct association nor personal relationship with Jesse
King Saul had sent messengers and word, only, to Jesse alright but he had no diddly squat face-face nor have any knowledge of who Jesse really is
King Saul in effect, had twice (i.e. messengers and word) sent to Jesse but never had sent for Jesse King Saul didnt have to send for Jesse, because whatever King Saul wants or demands, King Saul haves or gets and Jesse has to be honky-donkey with it Remember God's warning about subservience etcetera concerning the Israelite wanting to have an earthly king (i.e. 1 Samuel 8:11-18)
Were you expecting otherwise
So? So then, what?
Of course he knows David BY SIGHT and he knew him to be Jesse's son, but does he know Jesse? Does he personally know Jesse? Has he ever met Jesse? Is King Saul acquainted with Jesse BY SIGHT?
If No, then I submit, it is a valid and reasonable King Saul question to ask [b]It is a King Saul question begging for more details about David [/b]King Saul obviously had an understandable reason for asking Suddenly it is now a royal request, an official request investigation before a royal announcement Not only a rogue but a liar too!! lol. Let us even skip that and get right to the bone. Saul was not begging for any 'more details'. In chapter 16 before Saul even met David he was told that they are bringing the son of Jesse for him because he knows how to play music. Then David came. And Saul was so pleased with David that he wrote a letter to his father that he should let David remain with him. David doesn't need to see Jesse face to face to know that there is someone called Jesse and David is Jesse's son. All this is in Chapter 16. Then in Chapter 17 Saul then sees David and asks, 'Whose son is this?' Does that make sense? To ask whose son someone is after you've written letters to his father asking for him to remain with you? If you cannot explain that then it is best to just shut up instead of embarrassing yourself with idiocy. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 5:28pm On Apr 10, 2017 |
I believe that you missed this so I'm posting it again. You said 'the bible is not always a cogent narrative'. What did you mean and how does that tally with everything else that you are saying. MuttleyLaff: As you can seen from the above underlined, unlike you going on a rant my comment is on topic and related to refuting that the bible is not always a cogent narrative MuttleyLaff: The bible in some places is cogent, some places not cogent, another place silent and some other places deductive reasoning is employed Olboy, take a minute to take a deep breathe or 5 deep breaths sef. Then clear your mind and come again. Are you saying the bible is coherent or are you saying it is not coherent. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 4:27pm On Apr 09, 2017 |
MuttleyLaff: I've answered this already. Calm down and stop getting over-excited over nothing
SMH. Can you for a second, stop bumbling about
Sometimes it is uncomplicated and easy to understand, sometimes it isnt
Sometimes it looks like things in the Bible dont add up, and thats why untrained eyes and minds like JhyMedex's, post threads and OPs, like this one Hoping to hit the jackpot by trying to catch the Bible out lol |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 4:26pm On Apr 09, 2017 |
What it has to do with the matter is that the op pointed out that Felixomor had a somewhat unpleasant manner of communicating and I proposed my understanding of why not only him but a certain type of 'christian' (and I would include you in this group) have a tendency to be nasty when the bible or Christianity is debated. I believe that it comes from the subconscious realisation that they (you included) lack legitimacy and so are trying to force it. So all one has to do is doubt your position and you see it as an outrageous and violent attack on your beliefs. You must impose impose impose on others by force and invectives, not by rational arguments. You cannot and will not engage in a rational manner examining arguments because you know that if you try it you will fail. MuttleyLaff: You presume wrong. Now take a minute to take a deep breathe or 5 deep breaths sef to clear your mind and go again over your ''though they have no lineage to any of the actual apostles of Jesus'' comment and then come again with what being a direct descendant to any of the actual apostles of Jesus has to do with the matter?
You brought up questioning the ancestry of the ''christians'' to any of the actual apostles of Jesus. Didnt you?
I am claimimng that direct descendant to any of the actual apostles of Jesus doesnt add or minus. It is irrelevant to the matter you ranted on |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 4:19pm On Apr 09, 2017 |
Actually he didn't refute anything. At the point when the OP brought up the issue of chronology that is when Kondomatic disappeared. It seems that you missed it or it went over your head. I'll take time to take you through it one more time very slowly. Chapter 16: Can we presume that the events of chapter 16 happened before the events of chapter 17? I hope so. Chapter 16 - Saul meets David as the son of Jesse the Bethlehemite. 19Therefore Saul sent messengers to Jesse and said, “Send me David your son, who is with the sheep.” 20And Jesse took a donkey laden with bread and a skin of wine and a young goat and sent them by David his son to Saul. 21And David came to Saul and entered his service. And Saul loved him greatly, and he became his armor-bearer. 22And Saul sent to Jesse, saying, “Let David remain in my service, for he has found favor in my sightSo Saul according to this narrative was well acquainted with David BY SIGHT. And he knew him to be Jesse's son. Now in Chapter 17 we hear a different story of how they met. Note that in chapter 16 the deity is mostly called Yahweh and only once is Elohim used towards the end. Starting from verse 12 we have what is obviously a new narrative because once again David is introduced as a character that we are meeting the first time: 12Now David was the son of an Ephrathite of Bethlehem in Judah, named Jesse, who had eight sons. In the days of Saul the man was already old and advanced in years
If 16 and 17 are the same narrative then why introduce the character twice. Obviously we've entered a new version here. In this version Saul does not know David. Asking whose son is this of the boy that had 'found favour in his sight' and to whose father he had sent messages that to let David remain with him. That doesn't tally. Further more there is a proliferation of the use of the word Elohim for the deity. These 2 chapters sound like a stitching of two different narratives that don't tally with each other neatly. MuttleyLaff: He did, within the scope of OP there was any cause to exhaustively refute OP
In 1 Samuel 16:17, King Saul said to his servants: ''Provide for me a man who can play well and bring him to me''
In 1 Samuel 16:18, a young man told King Saul about David, saying: 'I have seen a son of Jesse of Bethlehem who knows how to play the lyre. He is a brave man and a warrior. He speaks well and is a fine-looking man. And the LORD is with him''
In 1 Samuel 16:19, King Saul then sent messengers to Jesse and said: ''Send me your son David, who is with the sheep''
In 1 Samuel 16:22, King Saul proceeded to send word to Jesse, saying, "Allow David to remain in my service, for I am pleased with him."
Recall that King Saul had never met or set eyes on Jesse before. King Saul doesnt know Jesse from Adam, no one-to-one with Jesse, no direct nor personal association with Jesse
King Saul had sent messengers and word only to Jesse and not had a face-face or knowlede of who Jesse really is
And the men of Israel said, Have ye seen this man that is come up? surely to defy Israel is he come up: and it shall be, that the man who killeth him, the king will enrich him with great riches, and will give him his daughter, and make his father's house free in Israel (i.e. exempt his family from taxes in Israel) - 1 Samuel 17:25
King Saul had to ask the 1 Samuel 17:55 ''whose son is this?'' question because of the promise(s) in 1 Samuel 17:25 above It is necessary to identify who David really is, in order to pinpoint or know where and how to honor the pledge, especially the tax exemption one |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 1:35pm On Apr 09, 2017 |
MuttleyLaff: As you can seen from the above underlined, unlike you going on a rant my comment is on topic and related to refuting that the bible is not always a cogent narrative MuttleyLaff: The bible in some places is cogent, some places not cogent, another place silent and some other places deductive reasoning is employed Olboy, take a minute to take a deep breathe or 5 deep breaths sef. Then clear your mind and come again. Are you saying the bible is coherent or are you saying it is not coherent. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 1:28pm On Apr 09, 2017 |
MuttleyLaff: Please tell how being a direct descendant to any of the actual apostles of Jesus counts in this matter
Tradition evolves and regardless of what the actual apostles of Jesus did in Biblical times, it changes. Let me get you straight. When you say 'in this matter' I presume you are talking of this issue of being a Christian. Yes or no? Secondly you are claiming that you do not need to receive the apostolic tradition in order to be a Christian. Is this what you're saying? |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 1:19pm On Apr 09, 2017 |
MuttleyLaff: As you can seen from the above underlined, unlike you going on a rant my comment is on topic and related to refuting that the bible is not always a cogent narrative ] So in your mind now you have refuted it. No, can do. I deplore needless waste of time getting me to reinvent the wheel. - Kondomatic did justice to OP's JhyMedex: thanks alot for taking your time to explain... But 1Sam 16:19-22 will make us understand that Saul knows and has been in contact with Jesse the Father of David.. Not just once but twice...
1st when he sent for David 2nd when he talked to Jesse about David staying permanently on his Service..
he was said to be very fond of David and made him his Armor bearer...
We are to understand that there is a relationship between Saul and David prior to the Goliath incidence...
But we hear Saul asking during the Goliath rage as if he had never met or Known David or Jesse his father . ... So since you are now advocating for kondomatic then perhaps you can take up the baton for him at the point where he ran away. His response was refuted with the the bible passages in the above quote. Please address that and tell us how you square the circle. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 12:24pm On Apr 09, 2017 |
MuttleyLaff: The bible in some places is cogent, some places not cogent, another place silent and some other places deductive reasoning is Please stay on topic. We are talking about blatant contradictions. Some examples have been mentioned. If you feel you can explain the discrepancies according to your worldview then please go ahead. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 12:19pm On Apr 09, 2017 |
MuttleyLaff: No, not as you want to make all believe, in regards to any of the actual apostles of Jesus Please explain this in plain English. Are you saying Christianity is NOT a tradition? Or are you saying that 'actual apostles' don't need to receive the tradition? |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 12:09pm On Apr 09, 2017 |
MuttleyLaff: https://i57.tinypic.com/34sp9j4.gif Pinocchio!
If as many as received Him, to them gave He power to become the sons of God, even to them that believe on His name: then why would lineage to any of the actual apostles of Jesus be of importance Lineage is important because Christianity is a tradition. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 11:56am On Apr 09, 2017 |
The problem starts when you try to endow bible with some power or meaning or authority that it doesn't possess. And all this in spite of the fact that in the very same bible they are told that god will write his laws in their hearts and it is the Holy Spirit that is to guide them in all things. But these people insist on clinging onto texts and letters. Why?? Well I suspect it is because they needed to create an authority with which they could use to challenge the authority of the church itself. So from the Protestant reformation the seeds were sown for all the hogwash that you see today. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 11:52am On Apr 09, 2017 |
felixomor: Why mention me to write this? Because I was addressing the manner in which you (and others) behave, not only on this thread but on others too. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 11:38am On Apr 06, 2017 |
JhyMedex: I really Don't like you that much.. I've seen how you respond and tackle issues on this forum.. And it's just despicable and unbecoming of someone who claims to be a Doctor ...
I'll appreciate if you let the intelligent people speak... Thanks.. felixomor: Next. Please .....  Mscheww You see the problem is that there is a whole new cult that has being invented based on the text of the bible and the twisting of it's meanings. In a bid to try to insist that the bible is one cogent narrative these cult members are actually turned into sociopathic hateful disciples of mendacity. Very rarely will you see them present an argument. Rather they will attack and curse anyone that doesn't agree with their inanity. This is the state of affairs with these people who insist on calling themselves Christians (though they have no lineage to any of the actual apostles of Jesus). |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 11:31am On Apr 06, 2017 |
JhyMedex: Yeah Pastor in the house.. how about your explanation Sire?.. My brother, the question should not be whether or not there are contradictions in the bible. But rather the question should be why the writers of the bible blatantly and obviously took contradictory stories and laid them side by side. If you read the bible is not just you will see some seemingly inadvertent contradictions as if it was sloppy work, but instead they are laid side by side in such a manner that it is obvious that the writer intends for you to compare and contrast them. So the question is Why!! What are the authors of the bible trying to get at when they do this? Take for example the opening two chapter of the bible. The creation story in Genesis 1 is in total contradiction to the creation story in Genesis two. Abeg you can ignore those fake assed Biblianist apologists. These contradictions are obviously a literary device in the bible. Take for example the story of Noah and the Ark. first the animals are brought in 2 by 2. Then the another version has the clean animals brought in 7 by 7 etc. Why? And the writers of the bible are obviously not even trying to hide these blatant contradictions. The first thing that we can say is that the writers of the bible were [b]NOT [/b]trying to write history. That was not their goal or agenda. You cannot take the tales of the bible as historical facts. There is a theory that what they were doing was documenting their folk tales and mythologies. For example in Ancient Greece the very first historian ever was a guy called Herodotus. What he was do when he would write the story of an historical episode is first write one version and state that this is the version that he learned from so so so and so place then immediately write another version and say that 'but the people from the other side have this other version'. The idea was to document all the versions of a tale that he could find, not necessarily to ascertain which version was the actual facts. Then there is also a very clear literary pattern that can be seen in the different version. For example when we look at the first two chapters of Genesis we find that when the second creation story starts, the literary style (in Hebrew so it is lost in translation into English) changes. In the first chapter the creation is done by Elohim. In the Second chapter the style changes and also the name of the deity. Now it is Yahweh. Throughout the OT there is obviously a stylistic disctinction between Elohim and Yahweh. For Example Elohim seems more lofty and transcendental. More mystical, metaphysical. Yahweh on the other hand seems so much more physical. Yahweh goes on a walk through the Garden of Eden in the Evening. Jacob wrestled physically with Yahweh all night. Moses saw the back of Yahweh's head etc. You can even call Yahweh to come and eat with you as Abram did. These are two very clear depictions of Deity, and often the same story is told twice. With a Yahwist version and an Elohim version. What is obvious is that the writers were not writing history but were getting at something else altogether different, a lot of which is lost in translation when you read the bible in English. |
Christianity Etc › Re: EXPLANATION :BIBLE STORIES THAT DON'T ADD UP by PastorAIO: 12:30am On Apr 04, 2017 |
Kondomatic: I think you should rephrase your question to make it a bit understandable.
In my own opinion and understanding, their first meeting was when he was sick and David played musical instrument for him.
It didn't say in Samuel that they met for the first time, in fact, Saul didn't say anything to prove that he never met David.
His question was "whose son is this youth". Although it is possible that Saul have completely forgot he had met with David before then but the question here isn't about David as an individual but his true identity.
Remember he was to marry Saul's daughter because Saul promised to give his daughter to whoever slays the giant and his family too were to be exempted from paying tax so it just right that Saul enquired about his true identity to know were his daughter is going.
In their first meeting, Saul met an ordinary musician but in Samuel, he asked for the true identity of the young man who's to become his son Inlaw. felixomor: Thanks for the explanation. Once it comes to the bible, some people seem to pretend not to understand english..... LWKMD!!! Hee hee hee heee hee hee hee! |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 8:32pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
|
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 8:32pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
Ishilove: Is this a scientific fact? I know say inside everything wey we don talk for this thread if Ishi must enter it will be when the conversation turns to sex. How you dey Ishilove? It's been a while. I don't know if it's a scientific fact but it's certain a meme that is out there. I think what might be scientific is that the male hormone production peaks in the late teens while the female hormone production peaks around 30. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 8:25pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
PastorAIO: Please, what exactly is wrong with Solipsism? I repeat my question in case you've forgotten to give an answer. I didn't ask for a like, I required an answer. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 8:20pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
KingEbukasBlog: Of course , we can less or more conscious of things . Consciousness is a state isn't it ? A child develops a sense of awareness (sense of self ) of himself at about 4 years old or so when the orbito frontal cortex is developed . You and a baby are on different levels of consciousness . And self awareness is totally from person to person ; people who have a greater sense of self awareness tend to more in touch with their emotions and even manage them . Spiritual enlightenment some religions practice lets you increase your level of consciousness - you become aware of things beyond the usual sensory perception .
Sha last last , there are types of consciousness and every type has its own level of awareness different from another type . If you look at what I coloured red there in your post you'll see what I'm talking about when I say you are conflating different things . Sense of Self is not Consciousness. You can remain conscious without a sense of self. What you just said amounts to saying that a child is not Conscious until they reach the age of 4. The sense of identity does change, yes. It can grow as you get older, but also with certain practices you can get rid of it too. You can change your emotional state and your sense of self with the use of alcohol and other drugs. These things are not about consciousness. I am actually quite dubious about a lot of neuroscientists. I think that they conflate a lot of issues too. What we learn about when we say that a dog recognises itself in the mirror is not Consciousness but Identity. Self Awareness. Sometimes I think that without deep meditative practice it is very hard for people to properly even have a grasp of what Consciousness is. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 8:11pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
I believe men peak at 19 years and women at 30 years when it comes to the urgency of the sex drive. KingEbukasBlog: He is 20/21 sir . He shared his testimony online . I'll get you the site's address later . |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 8:09pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
UyiIredia: I am not tired. I can go on debating. The problem is the motivation. Why argue with people showing bad reasoning or lacking critical thinking? Conflation and obfuscation of definitions. Ignoring instructions. Wilful ignorance.
There has to be some basic ground rules however ill-defined or not when arguing. A central one is logical reasoning. There is only so much bad logic one may tolerate, outside that argument is futile and as such best left alone.
Good side. On rare occasions I like a post for being very stupid. That way I can refer to it later. That one on solipsism was great. UyiIredia: If you do not agree with the premises which includes the definition of consciousness then I think it's best you state your problems with them before you answer my questions. So you are moaning about that which you specifically asked for in your OP. I disagreed with your definition and use of the term Consciousness and instead of presenting an argument to back up you position you resorted to insults and ad hominems, and now you have finally resorted to crying and whingeing. Eeyah! Oo ma se o!! |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 1:40pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
I"ve got to go now, but se you know (about your friend) that sexual drive tends to wane over the years as you get older. KingEbukasBlog: Even if I have to agree that there is cognitive participation though we are not aware of it , it is not utterly weak to restrain us from engaging in a sinful act . You still made my point sir .
Salvation is supernatural isn't it ? I've got a friend who was once an incorrigible smoker and womanizer . He resorts to masturbation whenever he has no woman to please himself with . I had a discussion with him : He explained that he no longer has those impulses or urge to sleep around , smoke or masturbate . He also told me that has lost total interest in those sinful acts . And I asked him if no longer has even a little urge to do so , he said 'yes' .
Maybe the science is that the destructive behavioral patterns have waned since God intervened . But when the bible said we are new creatures it obviously talks about a rebirth or a new sense of self . You have a new identity . I can't explain it scientifically but the change was instantaneous according to him .
Surgeries can correct addictions that are so strong . Even AA group rely on belief to change their addiction to alcohol . Only God can evidently provide an instantaneous change . |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 1:37pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
KingEbukasBlog: Of course , we can less or more conscious of things . Consciousness is a state isn't it ? A child develops a sense of awareness (sense of self ) of himself at about 4 years old or so when the orbito frontal cortex is developed . You and a baby are on different levels of consciousness . And self awareness is totally from person to person ; people who have a greater sense of self awareness tend to more in touch with their emotions and even manage them . Spiritual enlightenment some religions practice lets you increase your level of consciousness - you become aware of things beyond the usual sensory perception .
Sha last last , there are types of consciousness and every type has its own level of awareness different from another type . It would help if we all could give the terms we are using tight definitions. For me personally I define my terms as follows Consciousness, a self reference where the Act and the Object of the Act are the same, so Consciousness is the act of being Conscious of Consciousness. Conscious beings are Aware that they are conscious beings. Awareness. Apprehension of events that we experience. This can be diffuse (spread out to many events) or it can be concentrated (focused on a few events to the cost of other events). There is a subtle but essential difference between Awareness and Consciousness. Consciousness is unchanging but Awareness can be manipulated. Attention. The act of directing awareness. Identity. Experience can be organised in such a way that it is perceived from a certain perspective. that Perspective is what we call our identity, and it is often associated with our human body. It is constructed (you've said that it is formed around the age of 4, I don't know about the neuroscience behind it so I cannot verify) and can be dissolved. The identity is often conflated with Consciousness too, and this is one of the gravest errors that cause the pitiful state of the human condition. After Identity is dissolved we find that Experience still continues and that Consciousness still persists. There are many spiritual practices that are aimed at the dissolution of Identity. Identity can also be laden with characteristics etc. I say it is often associated with the human body but not always, it can also be dissociated from in in which case you will continue to experience events but as if from a location separate from your human body. Identity is mostly constructed with the aid of memories. So you are not just a perspective but also the guy that went to such and such school and was born into such and such family in such and such town. If you don't remember doing something as a part of your constructed Sense of Self then it will not form a part of your Identity, how you see yourself. To construct Identity we purposely relegate such events that do not fit into our desired construction to the dustbin of Forgetfulness. Then we remember those things that edify our constructed identity. The person who believes himself to be a heroic chap will have a hard time remembering all the cowardly acts he has performed in his life. etc. Of course this Sense of Identity is totally false and most of us on this planet are walking around with this false construct (false Ego) shrouding our minds. Not just that, but worse still, this False Ego has the temerity to claim to be the ultimate Consciousness. This is its false teaching and this OP is dangerously close to preaching it. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 1:12pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
UyiIredia: Based on the responses of atheists here and in the past and the crap from PastorAIO it is the same case as always. Same old, same old.
Seun's has been the best so far. His reply was the mozt comprehe sive as it addressed my premises and most of.my posers. ifenes is a disgrace to reason. JackBizzle and johnydon22, read his posts here and tell me you are ashamed. akintom is foolish but honestly I am used to his idiocy. I have encountered many atheists redefining consciousness as activities in the brain.
Maybe it is good I did not get much responses. LOL!! The boy taya!!! next time don't start a thread with half baked information. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 12:52pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
KingEbukasBlog: I used that analogy to explain why we go on with destructive habits or do bad things no matter the deterrent or disincentive . I can go ahead and disobey my mum even if she is there because of the desire to do what pleases me ; the gains of my actions , the joy and satisfaction I get from doing so . You did not explain why anything. To explain why would involve a breakdown of the process itself. all you did was try to show that it occurs in other instances. ie as it occurs with our belief in God so it occurs in our dealings with our parents. That is not explaining 'why'. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 12:48pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
KingEbukasBlog: I used that analogy to explain why we go on with destructive habits or do bad things no matter the deterrent or disincentive . I can go ahead and disobey my mum even if she is there because of the desire to do what pleases me ; the gains of my actions , the joy and satisfaction I get from doing so .
We crave for the reward and when a habit is so ingrained in us we can go ahead to do it with a paucity or no cognitive participation ( thoughts about what the consequences are would not even stop us or our strong cravings will override any form of discouragement ) . Someone can be lecherous because he so craves the orgasms or pleasures from sex . This is so because we are in the world and of the world . Like I said earlier , salvation disassociates us from this world and makes us Christ-like . Such pleasures won't matter to us . That's my point sir . You dig ?
Or should I explain the science behind it ? You see where you say 'no cognitive participation'. There is cognitive participation, but your are just not aware of it just like you are not aware of 99.9 per cent of the events going on in your mind. Even though your awareness of the thought process that makes you sin is subliminal that doesn't change the fact that there is a process. And that process is often based on beliefs just like the thoughts that you are aware of. Since these things are subliminal brain processes and you say that they will stop when we are saved and christlike then I wonder... Does Salvation involve some sort of Lobotomy? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 12:17pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
KingEbukasBlog: The dead man knowing nothing simply focuses on the material perspective of life . In one of your posts to Uyi , you clearly said that while we sleep our awareness is turned to other realms totally oblivious to our surroundings . So while the dead sleeps but eternally , his awareness is turned totally to other realms . But he certainly knows that he has experienced physical death since he has now gained a copious sense of awareness .  Sleep and death are two very different things. I've been asleep many times before and can talk at length of my experiences of sleep. However I have never died before (not that I can recall) and so anything I say on the subject of death will be pure speculation. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 12:15pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
KingEbukasBlog: This is so simple sir .
Even as children , we knew how parents disciplined us whenever we become recalcitrant but the punishment never deterred us from being disobedient or obstinate . That is the same case , we totally understand God's punishment but there are many reasons why we still carry on with sinful acts .
The most common of them all is the pleasure from sin . A good study of habits show that some destructive acts we carry out are so ingrained in our brains that we have little or no control over them . We crave for the gratification we derive from these acts . And most times , we carry out these habits unthinkingly no matter the bad consequences or disincentives . So here is what salvation offer us : a disassociation from the things of the world as new creatures we are or have become . We no longer crave the rewards or pleasures we derive from living in sin but the things of God or things that matter to God . When you disobey your parents it's because you believe that you can get away with it. It's called taking a chance. You will not touch that forbidden thing if your mother was in the same room standing over you. And so your analogy does not work because unlike your parents you believe god to be everywhere and omniscient, seeing your every move. He was there in the same room when you were knacking that ashawo, yet that didn't stop you, did it? |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 12:08pm On Apr 02, 2017 |
UyiIredia: Ah! I was going to reply the nonsense rife in your reply but when one sees this
"Now if you want to discuss and defend your baseless claim that it [consciousness] is based on physical things then I'm all ears"
what's the use. It would be like arguing with a flat-earther or conspiracy theorist. So mired in their delusions reality makes no bearing on their fancies. In your case, a hit on the head with a baseball bat MAY drive home the point. Still . . . But sebi you'll first try. Don't be ashamed of your position. One wonders where yogis and experts derive their definition of consciousness from. Or whether their definitions aren't to be seen in dictionaries.
Some people wisely question authority. Many people stupidly do so and make fools of themsleves while at it oblivious to the fact. You fall in the latter class. Yogis derive their expertise on the subject from years of practice and meditation. You can call me a fool all you like, I still question that you know what you're talking about when you talk about matter and energy. Anyway, in my village it is not the person that is asking questions that can ever be a fool. It is the person that stands on a podium to make statements that are baseless and ill thought out that we call a fool. But then that's just my village, maybe in your village it is the other way around. "Awareness can be more intense or less intense depending on how your attention is directed, the more you concentrate on something the less aware you will be of everything else."
Saying this validates my point. Of course you don't see that which is why you wrote it. Consciousness is awareness.
That would be all. Good day. Consciousness is not awareness. We can be more or less Aware of certain things, but we are not ever More or less Conscious. If you don't get that simple issue then don't worry, let's move on to other things that you can understand. |
Christianity Etc › Re: Consciousness: Posers For Atheists by PastorAIO: 11:34am On Apr 02, 2017 |
KingEbukasBlog: Hmmmm
So what is real and what is false ? Are all truths real ?
Take a look at this :
I want you and ifenes to focus on these types of truths :
1. Necessary truth :1+1=2 .This is a necessary truth . It is not dependent on our thoughts or beliefs . It can never be false because necessary truths are proposition that could not possibly have been false. The are true in every possible world .
2. Contingent truth : A contingent truth is a true proposition that could have been false . This is true in some possible worlds and not in other possible worlds. 3. Synthetic Truth : In this case , this truth can only be determined by relying on observation and experience.
With these , not everything is dependent on our thoughts and beliefs . Sometimes our experiences mould our thoughts and beliefs . I mean ontological arguments are formed or are based on these truths and more . All this big big grammar... and for what? I'm only aware of one kind of Truth. I define it as ... That which is, and always is, the case.
Hasty generalization .
There are Christians who have willingly laid their lives down because of their beliefs . During the communists regime (past and present ) led by the wicked despotic atheists , there were numerous cases of Christians who died because of their beliefs . The martyrs did same - historical evidence buttresses this .
Christians who are afraid are obviously not sure of their salvation .
But err , the fear of death is a natural thing . Even the brain is designed to ensure your survival . Emotions that are triggered in the face of danger are just concomitant and involuntary . None of this has any bearing on what I said. There are people who claim to believe one thing yet their behaviour suggests that deep down in their subconscious they believe differently. The fact that some other people exhibit total belief does not change the fact that many people believe only 'consciously' but in their subconscious it is a different story. A man who believes God will punish sinners and thieves yet continues to steal and sin obviously is not convinced of his conscious belief at a subconscious level. And guess what? The subconscious has more influence on our behaviour than our conscious. (please I'm using the terms conscious now to mean awareness.) |