PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 (of 287 pages)
MuttleyLaff:I never said Cyrus Cylinder is a brouhaha. I said you are making a brouhaha about the Cyrus Cylinder. Please do a quick google check to find out what brouhaha means. Please go read the Cyrus cylinderI've read it. I didn't see anything that said He was a worshiper of Marduk. Before you go on about his getting a mandate from Marduk, do you actually believe that Marduk exists? It is a known fact that Cyrus was invited into Babylon by the Priesthood of the cult of Marduk. That is why the city gates were flung open, and the citizens welcomed him with open arms. Is that what you mean by a 'mandate' from Marduk? Cyrus was a Persian. Marduk is a Babylonian God. How/Why would a persian be a worshipper of a Babylonian deity, especially when the Persian had Conquered Babylon? He was a benefactor to YHWH, no doubtCyrus was a benefactor to all the peoples, and the religious cults, he met. Is Yahweh the same as Marduk? Because a minute ago you said he got his mandate from Marduk and now you said Yhwh gave him the authority. These are basically the same thing so you are saying that Yahweh and Marduk are one. Who were the first people in recorded history to refuse to worship any image of God/gods? That's right the Persian. In Avesta religion they forbid the use of temples altars, images etc etc etc. I wonder where the Jews got that Idea from? The customs which I know the Persians to observe are the following: they have no images of the gods, no temples nor altars, and consider the use of them a sign of folly. This comes, I think, from their not believing the gods to have the same nature with men, as the Greeks imagine. - Herodotus on the religion of the Persians. http://www.ancient.eu/article/149/ Now tell me, How can a man who does not believe in the worshiping of idols become a follower of Marduk, a religion that involves the worshiping of idols in a temple? Judaism is a derivation of Avesta mixed in with the Hebrew religion that they had before the exile to Babylon. |
MuttleyLaff:Inside all that you wrote the only thing worth responding to is this Cyrus Cylinder brouhaha. Cyrus had a policy of live and let live. He allowed everybody to go back to their homes and worship their gods again. Those whose cults had been destroyed he helped rebuild. For example, he helped the Jews to go back to Israel and to rebuild their temple, and they Jews were so delighted that they called him a messiah. However they were not the only ones that he helped. The cult of Marduk was similarly delighted with him. And am ready to predict that if some new text were discovered of some other tribe that he helped it would probably celebrate him as the messiah (or whatever equiavalent in their culture) of their God. The King of Babylon had neglected the local cult of Marduk in Babylon, and it was the priesthood of Marduk ( think of them as a political faction within Babylon) that invited Cyrus to come and depose the Babylonian empire. When Cyrus arrived the gates of the city were flung open and it was a bloodless conquest. Cyrus was probably the only conqueror in the whole history of mankind to have done it so easily and without the usual loss of life. He was a man admired all over the world by all nations and all religious cults. He truly set the people free. In my opinion he was the greatest man who ever lived. The same way he was lauded in the bible is the same way that he is lauded in the Cyrus cylinder. Cyrus is as much a worshipper of Marduk as he was a worshipper of Yahweh. He helped rebuild the Marduk cult after neglect, he helped rebuild the yahweh cult after their exile, he helped many people all over the world rebuild their cults. That didn't make him a member of the cults. I haven't read the Cyrus cylinder but I've read summaries of its contents and nowhere did anything I read say that he was a Marduk worshipper. The text on the Cylinder praises Cyrus, sets out his genealogy and portrays him as a king from a line of kings. The Babylonian king Nabonidus, who was defeated and deposed by Cyrus, is denounced as an impious oppressor of the people of Babylonia and his low-born origins are implicitly contrasted to Cyrus's kingly heritage. The victorious Cyrus is portrayed as having been chosen by the chief Babylonian god Marduk to restore peace and order to the Babylonians. The text states that Cyrus was welcomed by the people of Babylon as their new ruler and entered the city in peace. It appeals to Marduk to protect and help Cyrus and his son Cambyses. It extols Cyrus as a benefactor of the citizens of Babylonia who improved their lives, repatriated displaced people and restored temples and cult sanctuaries across Mesopotamia and elsewhere in the region. It concludes with a description of how Cyrus repaired the city wall of Babylon and found a similar inscription placed there by an earlier king.[3]- Wikipedia Cyrus was such a cool guy that everybody was claiming him. Marduk's priests were claiming him, Yahweh's prophets were claiming him. But the fact remains that he was a worshiper of Ahura Mazda. I know that such a fact would pain someone like you, but sorry sorry o. He was a benefactor to Marduk, he was a benefactor to Yahweh. Yahweh didn't give him anything, he gave Yahweh his temple back. The giver is superior. |
A gospel that can only be advanced with lies is a HELL of a gospel indeed. |
luckyCO:Can I take a guess about you? You are a guy that one day picked up a book (a rare event) on catholicism and history. The book filled you with awe and wonder because you had never had information like that before in you life. it was written simply so even simpletons could understand, in fact the entire thing was directed towards simpletons. Being filled with awe and wonder you read the book once again and let it's contents sink in, and then you passed it to a friend and he too was filled with awe and wonder. Throughout this whole process you didn't once seek to verify the information in the book, everything in it seems so filled with information from another world, it seemed so authoritative. Once you got the gist of the book its ideas took root in your brain and took on a life of their own. You yourself started to invent amazing information sprouting from your own mind. You found a community of people who would share in the awe and wonder of this unverified historical information. together you supported each other in the unverified delusions. Thus here we are today, you've come to a public forum to share the misinformation without backup and when you are questioned about it you have no answer. Shame. |
luckyCO:Perhaps you misread my post and questions. I'll repeat them. 1) Please at what point in history, after withdrawing and regrouping, did Satan join the church to mix up everything and become their leader? Just the year will do. And why was God so powerless to rebuff this attack? 2) And please, what is the problem with semantics exactly? You make it sound like a dirty word. 3) Are you suggesting that one shouldn't strive to get the meaning of a text? |
analice107:You haven't responded to me on the criteria used and how that applies to books like Esther. But that's okay. Let's leave that now. Maybe you can answer this instead: Who are the people who applied the criteria for selecting the bible? Where was it done and when? |
luckyCO:Please at what point in history, after withdrawing and regrouping, did Satan join the church to mix up everything and become their leader? Just the year will do. And why was God so powerless to rebuff this attack? And please, what is the problem with semantics exactly? You make it sound like a dirty word. semanticsAre you suggesting that one shouldn't strive to get the meaning of a text? |
MuttleyLaff:1Thus says the Lord to his anointed ( Messiah ), to Cyrus, whose right hand I have grasped to subdue nations before him and strip kings of their robes, to open doors before him— and the gates shall not be closed: Isaiah Chapter 45 verse 1. |
MuttleyLaff: sonmvayina:Just one small point of correction for you both. Actually Cyrus did not worship Marduk. Cyrus was a worshipper of Ahura Mazda. But there is a point where Somnaviya is a bit correct. Much of Judaism after the exile to Babylon was modelled on the religion of Ahura Mazda. Ahura Mazda was a single creator God was no peer. It is from his religion that the whole notion of a final day of Judgement came from. They brought the idea that History was an epic battle between the forces of Light and Darkness. Almost all of the most recognisable aspects of Christianity and Judaism and Islam can be seen to be derived from the religion of Ahura Mazda even down to the use of phrases like King of Kings, Lord of Lords, in Parsee it is Shahanshah. So please, the bible never said Marduk was the God of Cyrus. |
analice107:There are many things I know nothing of. Of those things, anyone that you feel you can help me to get better knowledge, I would appreciate that. So What are these Criteria that were used? Where did Esther forecast Christ? Where did Proverbs forecast Christ? (I know you can wangle and contorted reference to christ from it (as one can from any text), but I want to see it. |
JMAN05:"By my name Yahweh I did not make myself known to them" but the name Yahweh is not the discussion. Wedone! |
analice107:You keep going on about authorship but only you. No one else is talking about authorship. Let me put it this way. Christians did not create bread, and they did not create wine. Yet there is a particular way bread and wine are used sacramentally in Christianity. Now of course you are free to eat as much bread and drink as much wine as you like however you cannot claim to do so the way christians properly do so. There were debates and appraisals against certain criteria. The books in the bible were picked because they supported certain Christian orthodox catholic doctrines. To pick the bible up outside this context is merely to do your own thing. You're free to do so but you're deluding yourself if you think you're Christian. |
rhektor:That's why they said you should read the thread from the beginning. Mr man your interjections are adding nothing to this thread. |
Exodus6:3 3and I appeared to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, as El Shaddai, but by My name, YHWH, I did not make Myself known to them. Funny thing is that Yahweh is all over the place before Moses turns up. |
shadeyinka:I couldn't say if the are available online or not. None of that is the point. You said only books that were written by apostles, OR in circulation in their lifetime, .... These books ( to the extent that we can know) fulfil your criteria as much as the gospels. Why would you not accept these books as scripture? May I suggest it is because they are not a part of the tradition that have come down to you via the Catholic Church. |
DoctorAlien:Okay o, anyhow you like it. |
DoctorAlien:I think a big part of the problem here, and generally in threads like this is that many people are unaware that the bible contains a variety of theologies, and a variety of cosmologies. You run into the problems you do when you think that the bible is coherent all over. It is neither coherence nor cogent. |
shadeyinka:What about books Like The Shepherd of Hermas? Clement1? Didache? |
shadeyinka: shadeyinka:So please when did it start? A) in the upper room on Pentecost B) in Antioch a few years later C) on 397ad by Constantine D) in the life time of jesus when the bible says he called out ( ekklesia) his disciples. E) all of the above and more F) none of the above and less |
shadeyinka:If it is a matter of tracing it to the apostles then the 4 gospels fail. Just the trial of Jesus alone is enough. How do we know what happened in the trials when the bible itself told us that all jesus' followers fled when he hot arrested. So how do we know all the things that happened during his trial if the only acceptable sources were not even there. |
italo:Please, what institution was Jesus referring to in Matthew 18:17 |
Mcowubaba:Please read my post again. It has been amended. |
I see no correlation of the priestly garb of the roman pagan priests and the priestly garb of the Catholic Church, There were very many books and letters in circulation amongst early Christians. Canonisation occurred to stop the spread if heresies. I agree. The criteria for selecting books was in tws of their theology/doctrine. Those text whose doctrines were not acceptable to the church were rejected. I think the matter of fabrications mattered less than the matter of doctrine. shadeyinka: |
shadeyinka:No wahala! Sebi they are human beings too. |
Are you Shadeyinka? Oops! Na you even write the post wey I respond to. Okay, now using your own same reasoning consider this: Catholic just means universal therefore Catholic Church spread out over the earth like 'Kingdom of heaven' that Jesus described. Christian means Christ follower. Bcatholic means universal. These two words are not mutually exclusive. Mcowubaba: |
Following your reasoning... Jesus didn't start Christianity. After all we know when it started. Christianity started in Antioch where the term was first coined. Mcowubaba: |
shadeyinka:But canonisation of scriptures is pertinent especially as you've conferred all authority in Christian matters away from the church onto to bible. I'm also curious as to how you became familiar with Jewish fashion and roman fashions of antiquity. How do you know that priestly garb is not similar to Jewish priestly garb? |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 (of 287 pages)
