DoctorAlien: I know it's so painful seeing me cherrypick the bias in your allegory.
The onus is on you to prove how Christians bend facts to support theories.
With a brief google check this is what I found:
So I would like to take a look at these 10 pieces of evidence and explain why they could not be further from evidence for something as silly as young earth creationism.
1. Very Little Sediment on the Seafloor
If sediments have been accumulating on the seafloor for three billion years, the seafloor should be choked with sediments many miles deep.
This argument may make some sense if you read it naively of geological science, but it is simply not the case. According to Matthew S. Tiscareno of Cornell University:
Due to Plate Tectonics, ocean floor is continuously created at mid-ocean ridges and subducted into the Earth’s mantle at ocean trenches. This process moves at about an inch or two per year, so the average age of the ocean floor is in fact a few tens of millions of years, and thus the result is completely consistent with old-Earth science.
As you can see, science has explained this via plate tectonics, a proven, verifiable and natural occurrence. So no, very little sediment offers no proof of a young earth.
2 Bent Rock Layers
In many mountainous areas, rock layers thousands of feet thick have been bent and folded without fracturing. How can that happen if they were laid down separately over hundreds of millions of years and already hardened?
This argument is the same as their “the geological column doesn’t exist” argument. Creationists think you should see the layers of rock like those of a cake, all over the earth, and apparently if there is any bending, that is proof the earth is young.
Not so much. No one expects there to be an unbroken record of the earth as creationists are claiming must exist for the earth to be over 4 billion years old, so the claim they are making is very misleading from the start.
To quote from Matthew S. Tiscareno again:
Deposited layers can be later eroded away or destroyed in other ways, and drought can prevent layers from being deposited at all for long periods of time. However, the above statement is very misleading in that it insinuates that the geologic column is somehow a “figment of the evolutionist’s imagination.” The truth is that the geologic records all over the world are very well correlated with each other, not only with stratigraphy (i.e., which layer overlies which layer) and fossils, but with paleomagnetism, radiometric dating, and many other important factors, all of which fit together remarkably well.
The earth’s record may not be perfect, and if it was, geologists could just go home, but we have enough evidence and understanding to have a very good grasp about on what the geological record says.
So again, no young earth evidence.
3 Soft Tissue in Fossils
Ask the average layperson how he or she knows that the earth is millions or billions of years old, and that person will probably mention the dinosaurs, which nearly everybody “knows” died off 65 million years ago. A recent discovery by Dr. Mary Schweitzer, however, has given reason for all but committed evolutionists to question this assumption.
Actually, Dr. Schweitzer’s discovery, as remarkable as it is, is also fully explained, and our previous thought about how long tissue can last has shifted since discovering this.
In fact, these findings have enhanced our knowledge of the dinosaur and their DNA, but have also helped us confirm their very old age. The Smithsonian Magazine claims that young-earth creationists have hijacked Dr. Schweitzer’s find, and Dr. Schweitzer herself, a faithful Christian, believes the age of the tissue to be millions of years old, not thousands of years.
So Answers in Genesis is trumpeting Dr. Schweitzer’s findings, and using her name and she doesn’t even agree with them.
4 Faint Sun Paradox
Evidence now supports astronomers’ belief that the sun’s power comes from the fusion of hydrogen into helium deep in the sun’s core, but there is a huge problem. As the hydrogen fuses, it should change the composition of the sun’s core, gradually increasing the sun’s temperature. If true, this means that the earth was colder in the past. In fact, the earth would have been below freezing 3.5 billion years ago, when life supposedly evolved.
So this may be the closest creationists get to actual science, not actually doing science, just simply exploiting science that is not fully understood yet and claiming that to be evidence for their position.
This is not actually how science works, but it’s cute to watch them try. The original issue was actually raised by Carl Sagan and George Mullen in 1972, because studying sun like stars shows that the sun should get brighter and hotter over time, but the earth’s geological record shows a rather steady temperature with the exception of one really cold phase.
This does not however help the argument for young earth creationism though, because the layers that are being studied to measure the temperatures in this research are millions and billions of years old, so that alone means using the sun as evidence simply will not work.
If scientists today still don’t have a full understanding of the faint sun paradox, why would anyone think a group of people who believe in talking snakes do?
5 Rapidly Decaying Magnetic Field
The earth is surrounded by a magnetic field that protects living things from solar radiation. Without it, life could not exist. That’s why scientists were surprised to discover that the field is quickly wearing down. At the current rate, the field and thus the earth could be no older than 20,000 years old.
Not really, because evidence shows a fluctuation in the magnetic field, not a constant decay as Answers in Genesis is claiming.
According to Talk Origins the concept itself was dreamed up by two creationists who often had to use divine intervention in their explanations for the for the magnetic decay they claimed to have found, and according to Matthew S. Tiscareno again:
“[…] The evidence shows that the magnetic field has fluctuated back and forth in strength as well as direction. These fluctuations are clearly observed in places where the stratigraphy (i.e. which rocks are older than which rocks) is obvious due to either layering or distance from a sea-floor spreading ridge. The decrease measured in the past few hundred years, therefore, is nothing more than a downward trend as part of an overall fluctuation, and has no implication for the age of the Earth.”
6 Helium in Radioactive Rocks
During the radioactive decay of uranium and thorium contained in rocks, lots of helium is produced. Because helium is the second lightest element and a noble gas—meaning it does not combine with other atoms—it readily diffuses (leaks) out and eventually escapes into the atmosphere. Helium diffuses so rapidly that all the helium should have leaked out in less than 100,000 years. So why are these rocks still full of helium atoms?
Talk Origins explains this rather perfectly in that helium diffusion is not a straightforward rate that applies universally; subsurface pressure and temperature affect just how quickly helium would leak out of these rocks.
Creationists would have you believe that what is true for one rock is true for all, and this is simply dishonest and misleading. In fact, the leader young earth creationist pushing this theory, Dr. D. R. Humphreys has invoked miracles in his findings when he cannot explain a phenomena and has refused to publish or submit any of his findings to a single peer-review journal, instead publishing them in his own books.
7 Carbon-14 in Fossils, Coal, and Diamonds
Carbon-14 (or radiocarbon) is a radioactive form of carbon that scientists use to date fossils. But it decays so quickly—with a half-life of only 5,730 years—that none is expected to remain in fossils after only a few hundred thousand years. Yet carbon-14 has been detected in “ancient” fossils—supposedly up to hundreds of millions of years old—ever since the earliest days of radiocarbon dating.
You can basically read everything in #6 above to understand the methods used to make this claim. Creationists simply ignore how radiocarbon dating works and how the process actually takes place.
If you ignore the actual science and invent you own, you can claim anything is possible, as creationists have.
8 Short-Lived Comets
A comet spends most of its time far from the sun in the deep freeze of space. But once each orbit a comet comes very close to the sun, allowing the sun’s heat to evaporate much of the comet’s ice and dislodge dust to form a beautiful tail. Comets have little mass, so each close pass to the sun greatly reduces a comet’s size, and eventually comets fade away. They can’t survive billions of years.
The basic claim here is that comets would not exist if the universe was old because they would have melted by now.
According to Matthew S. Tiscareno:
“[…] The point is a valid one. However, this claim is a One-Sided Equation that considers the rate at which comets are destroyed without considering how the comet population is replenished. The population of comets is kept in equilibrium by new comets which are continuously introduced into our solar system from beyond Pluto’s orbit. When they are far away from the Sun’s deteriorating effects, comets can last indefinitely.”
The claim by creationists would posit that no new comets are being created and that they all make such regular trips around the sun they would be gone, but this simply isn’t the case.
9 Very Little Salt in the Sea
If the world’s oceans have been around for three billion years as evolutionists believe, they should be filled with vastly more salt than the oceans contain today.
These claims are starting to feel a little desperate aren’t they?
And to quote Matthew S. Tiscareno for the thousandth time:
There are many processes that take salt out of seawater, including sea spray, high-temperature alteration of brine into albite at undersea hydrothermal vents, and deposition to the ocean floor. Precipitates on the sea floor will be swept clear periodically by plate tectonic subduction. It is also important to realize that there is a great deal that we do not understand about the deep ocean floor, due to the obvious difficulties in studying it, and it is likely that there are other important processes going on there that have yet to be discovered.
So as you can see, it is not as simple as saying salt should be there when there are scientific explanations for why it is not.
I think there should be a million dollars in my bank account, but there are many reasons there are not. None of them being that because I stated it, it must be true.
10 DNA in “Ancient” Bacteria
In 2000, scientists claimed to have “resurrected” bacteria, named Lazarus bacteria, discovered in a salt crystal conventionally dated at 250 million years old. They were shocked that the bacteria’s DNA was very similar to modern bacterial DNA. If the modern bacteria were the result of 250 million years of evolution, its DNA should be very different from the Lazarus bacteria (based on known mutation rates).
For starters, yes, the age of the salt is dated to be 250 million years old, but the age of bacteria has not. So while it is believed the bacteria is old, it is most likely not as old as the salt.
Answers in Genesis leave that nugget of info out of their explanation. But the real thing here is simple; scientists themselves still don’t understand this ancient DNA and are still studying it. Yet Answers in Genesis, an organization that conducts no scientific research and has zero access to this DNA claims to have it all figured out.
Yet their discovery has not been published in any journal, or presented to any scientific organizations, they simply sit in their own arrogance and claim to know all about it.
So as you can see, not a single one of these 10 claims proves creationism and none of them even provide something close. All they provide is proof that Answers in Genesis is either completely scientifically ignorant, or they think their members and supporters are, so they exploit that ignorance.
Given that they are consistently untruthful, I think we can safely assume they know they are lying, but have a great understanding that their lies are worth money.
DoctorAlien: Has the term changed? The singularity no longer exploded 13.8 billion years ago? Please tell me, what did the singularity do? What was contained in the singularity? It's funny seeing you claim that the formation of stars and planets are fully understood. Goes to show how knowledgeable you are. Let me mercifully give you a hint: read up the "meter size barrier".
15God, furthermore, said to Moses, "Thus you shall say to the sons of Israel, The LORD, the God of your fathers, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob, has sent me to you.' This is My name forever, and this is My memorial-name to all generations.
Exodus 3.
"How long will this be in the heart of the prophets who prophesy lies? Indeed they are prophets of the deceit of their own heart, who try to make My people forget My name by their dreams which everyone tells his neighbor, as their fathers forgot My name for Baal."
Jeremiah 23
And as for Seth, to him also a son was born; and he named him Enosh. Then men began to call on the name of Yahweh.
Genesis4
3and I appeared to Abraham , Isaac, and Jacob, as El Shaddai, but by My name, Yahweh , I did not make Myself known to them. Exodus 6
Compare and contrast the purple text.
Pikin wey nor know him papa name, na pikin be that?
LightandDarkness: [b] No not necessarily. I think a christian existentialist, like all existentialists, must believe that it is impossible to rationally find inherent meaning in the world and any attempt to do so will fail. [/b]These links explain the ideas of christian existentialism http://www.allaboutphilosophy.org/christian-existentialism-faq.htm and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_existentialism#Major_premises. This is interesting because if you are an atheist but also a rationalist you cannot actually be a pure existentialist so to speak in that rationalism believes humanity and the world can be rationally understood which existentialism believes to be impossible.
I would try and do a bit more reading on it, in all honesty it took me a while to get my head around it.
I get that, but I'm compartmentalising it. Where an existentialist may believe that it is impossible to find meaning anywhere in the world, I divide the world into compartments where the Christians finds meaning in the worship of God and trying to 'make heaven', while elsewhere (e.g like with civic duties, filial obligations etc) they do not find inherent meaning. So within the compartment, or limits, of Civic duty, say, they don't believe in inherent meaning so they are existentialists when they impute meaning to it.
I think that a lot of the problem is that many of the christian folks have given up even trying to make reasonable arguments that one can engage with and most exchanges now are just invectives. The quality has certainly gone down.
PastorAIO: I'm presuming that this work is being done with the approval of the Local council and it fits in with the Planning designs of the town. Is he liaising with the local authorities in this work?
Oops, i beg your pardon. I forgot that we are talking about nigeria.
I'm presuming that this work is being done with the approval of the Local council and it fits in with the Planning designs of the town. Is he liaising with the local authorities in this work?
MuttleyLaff: "Very truly I tell you," Jesus answered, "before Abraham was born, I AM!"
Jesus told them: "Truly, I tell all of you emphatically, before there was an Abraham, I AM!" - John 8:58
The ''I AM'' designation is reminiscent of God's personal and/or official name, ''Yahweh'' which means ''One who always was, is, and will be'' Funning thing is Yahweh is not just only all over the place before Moses turns up but is even before Abraham was born
Err... you missed my point. Again.
The name Yahweh is all over the place, he is being addressed as Yahweh before moses turned up in the bible. If they didn't know his name to be Yahweh then how comes they are addressing him as Yahweh.
Exodus 6:3 3and I appeared to Abraham , Isaac, and Jacob, as El Shaddai, but by My name, Yahweh , I did not make Myself known to them.
Genesis 14:22 22Abram said to the king of Sodom, "I have sworn to the Yahweh , God Most High, possessor of heaven and earth,
Simple question: Did Abraham know Yahweh by name or not?
OtemAtum: OH, I didn't know it's going to be a daily affair. BTW, rather than doing that daily, I'd rather work hard daily and save my income. It's not as if I'm condemning the act though, but for me, I would rather work to get money instead of looking for alternatives.
OtemAtum: All those who made the Forbes rich list were known people who had great companies and organizations before making the Forbes rich list. None of them was poor and then suddenly made the Forbes list.
You're right the OP says it's a daily affair, so the windfall will come in one day.
OtemAtum: There is no money ritual that can put anybody on the Forbes rich list. It is either you get your money through legit business, fraudulent activities, politics or you were given money by a human being like yourself. Money don't fall from the skies. Nobody gets to Forbes list. Work hard legally to get your money. Don't try the fraudulent way, but I am not saying that you shouldn't do what baba is telling you to do. Who knows whether the power of coincidence will work with it and make you stumble upon money?
Yet my answer remains unquestioned. How do we know that those on rich list didn't do money rituals, whether or not they made money by the power of coincidence?
1) History is a battle between the forces of Light versus the forces of Darkness. One day the sons of Light will eventual win and History will be culminated.
2) The final redemption will be brought about by a Messianic figure known in Avesta as the Saoshyant. This teaching influenced Jewish Eschatological Messianism. Till today it persists amongst the Persian people, though Islamic, as the belief and expectation of someone called the Mahdi.
3) Universalism. For the first time the Avestans introduce an idea of God that is not tribal but rather their God is a god of all people throughout all of history. Anybody that gets right with Ahura Mazda and strives for the Light against Darkness (through Word, and thought and Deed) will be saved.
4) Belief in an after life. Originally Judaism didn't believe in it and even during the time of early christianity it is obvious that not all jews believed in the resurrection of the dead, it was mainly the pharisees and a few other sects like christians.
5) Linguistically the Jews borrowed appellations like 'King of Kings, and Lord of Lords' from the Persians
6) The christians too borrowed the notion that the main fields of battle between Light and Darkness is in the 3 realms of Words, Thoughts, and Deeds. In other words, what you say, what you think and what you do will manifest the battle between good and evil.
PROPHETmichael: Show me a man whose name is on forbes list rich list and is into powerful spells and i will show you a man whose name disappears after one or two years. Those ones you constantly see on the rich list are "like a tree planted by streams of water, which yields its fruit in season and whose leaf does not wither-- whatever they do prospers." Psalm 1:3
This doesn't answer my question, but I'll presume that your answer is that you don't know and you're just making conjectures but you don't want to admit it.
You make it sound like Forbes List is a religious cult and that psalm was written for them.
Joshthefirst: I said a lot of things, and I wasn't joking, theorizing or making conjectures. Saying that the universe may be infinitesimal doesn't really add anything to the argument in this case.
And I remember saying in similar words, that God, is the transcendental sum total of all reality. Everything about ceation is drawn from, and is a subset of his infinite presence and reality. He is the eternal "something" that gave the cause to creation, and sustains it.
This is the consequence of logical thinking and extrapolation of the cosmological argument. It is not conjecture.
There is nowhere that I was joking or theorizing or making conjectures. 2 plus 2 equals 4. That is not a conjecture, it is an a priori fact.
I never said that the universe may be infinitesimal. Perhaps you need to read my posts again.
{1} Through out that day this spell was casted, you should not curse anybody {2} You should avoid anything that has to do with menstral blood {3} You should not drink alcohol or take drugs {4} You should not walk under rope that clothes are hanged {5} You should give money to beggars {6} You should not indulge in fornication or adultery {7} You should keep yourself holy
Thank you for reading, leave a comment
Babalawos
Some of these taboos go hard anybody wey dey frequent nairaland.
Sarassin: No sir, no conflation here, how can you state that Abraham's "EL" is different from Melchizedek's "EL"??, there was no such thing as "Abraham's EL". Abraham swore to the "Most High" that is "EL" of the Canaanite pantheon. The conflation is that of bible writers assigning the omnipotence of "EL" to the Hebrew deity YHWH. I would also point out that Baal was the vizer of EL, the first among his "Sons", the original "rider of the clouds" whose characteristics are later transposed into the Book of Daniel and appropriated into the New Testament of the person of Jesus of Nazareth, specifically, the Baal attributes of the cycles of life, death and rebirth.
What I don't understand is how a Biblian could claim that the El of Abraham is different from the El of Melchizedek when in the same bible we read this:
11 Now if perfection had been attainable through the Levitical priesthood (for under it the people received the law), what further need would there have been for another priest to arise after the order of Melchizedek, rather than one named after the order of Aaron?
“You are a priest forever, after the order of Melchizedek.”
oh, and one last thing on the Cyrus Cylinder Brouhaha....
Though Marduk's priests, with a bias, quote Cyrus as acknowledging their Marduk...
And though Yahweh's priests and prophets, with their own bias, claim and quote Cyrus as acknowledging Yahweh...
Yet there are independent, non religious documents on Cyrus. For example Xenophon wrote a history of Cyrus' life and in his history Cyrus is surrounded by Magi who he consults.
Now at peep of day the first thing that Cyrus did was to call the magi and bid them select the gifts ordained for the gods in acknowledgment of such success;
So the only non religious person, a foreigner (greek) talks about Cyrus consulting Magi, while those that have a bias to push describe him as being a worshipper or at the very least an acknowledge-r of their respective Gods. Add to this the fact that Cyrus is Persian and the religion of the Persians is Avesta.
MuttleyLaff: "Cyrus' admission is found in the ''The Cyrus Cylinder'', a cuneiform tablet now in the British Museum" You're such as a drama queen, aren't you, now what in the above, that I typed had to do with brouhaha.
You've just learned the word and you itchingly couldn't wait to use it. Inappropriate usage wouldn't matter or mean anything to you
Hardly anything noisy, or loud, or over-exciting in that simple and plain remark, where "Cyrus Cylinder" was mentioned only one time or reference to it done only once
Cyrus Cylinder is not brouhaha and my one sentence comment about it was not brouhaha
Please do a quick google double check to find out what worshipper means, after that, then go and properly read the Cyrus Cylinder, particularly lines 12, 14-17, 20, 23, 26, 34-35 and 44 to see how Cyrus reverenced & worshipped Marduk
Right, so Cyrus Cylinder says that Cyrus worshipped Marduk. Cyrus Cylinder was written by Marduk's priests. The text takes a form that is common when a new lineage in Babylon is established and divine validation is needed.
You just have to do a tangential here, isnt it? OK, yes, I actually believe that Marduk exists ''So tan? Bo si ngbangban ko wa se ife inu e''
That your yoruba sef, you might as well have written it in Cyrillic letters.
So as you believe Marduk exists, I take it that you believe that Marduk actually came to talk to Cyrus rather than the whole thing being a fabrication of Marduk's priesthood. By the way, how many different Gods can speak to Cyrus and give him mandate? Which one is giving the real mandate?
Partly and also went by Cyrus' admission in the Cyrus Cylinder, where he said Marduk gave him the mandate etcetera (i.e. Cyrus Cylinder lines 12, 14-17)
Yes he 'said' that Marduk gave him the Mandate in Cyrus Cylinder which must mean that the Bible is lying. After all the bible makes exactly the same claims for Yahweh and Cyrus and it also quotes Cyrus as saying as much.
: 2“Thus says Cyrus king of Persia: Yahweh, the God of heaven, has given me all the kingdoms of the earth, and he has charged me to build him a house at Jerusalem, which is in Judah. Ezra Chapter 1.
Because there is no nation which so readily adopts foreign customs as the persians But why ask me anyway? Ask Cyrus, not me. I didnt pay homage to Marduk. He, Cyrus did
That is just true for all of humanity and just as true for Israelite/Hebrew/Jews as it is for Persians, if not more so, and with Judaism we have plenty and plenty of evidence. More than for Persia.
No, Yahweh is not the same as Marduk but all that is Yahweh's is attributed to Marduk
I believe that the subject of much of this thread is contesting that and making the diametrical opposite claim. You guys haven't settled that yet before you go about stating claims.
Glad and pleased you realised that happening He wrote in the Cyrus Cylinder that he got his mandate from Marduk, when the truth and actual fact is that it was given by YHWH People often mix YHWH up with other gods (e.g. Marduk)
According to Ezra He claimed to have got his mandate from Yahweh. He made a proclamation about it. So which is it? Marduk or Yahweh. Personally I say neither. Cyrus was just a pragmatic man who let the Marduk priests make whatever claim they wanted to make about his relationship with their God. And likewise he let the Jews make similar claims in their texts. I'm sure if we found more texts from other nations that he set free we would find more of the same but in the version of each one's own religion.
Yet they worshipped many gods (e.g. the sun and moon, the earth, fire, water, and the winds
Worship of many Gods is a far cry from using images to worship God. Nice try though.
Cyrus himself said Marduk looked around and checked all the countries, seeking for the upright king of his choice. Marduk then found and took under his hand Cyrus, king of the city of Anshan etcetera Please dont spread your ignorance, you really need to read more on Cyrus
He also said that Yahweh charged him to build a house for him. And Yahweh gave him all the kingdoms. So was he lying. Which version do you want to believe? Or you don't want to recognise an astute politician when you see one?
So? Nothing wrong in ''borrowing'' and/or ''importting'' The irony is that Magi must be privy to some sacred truth & knowledge for them to have journeyed and come to Bethlehem to worship God
Nothing wrong unless you claim that it is from a source other than where you are actually borrowing from. If you say the bible was written by God, then it is shocking that the creator of the whole universe should show such utter lack of creativity when it comes to writing his holy book and devising a religion.
err... Where does it say in history, the bible, or anywhere for that matter, that Magi (ie. the Priests of Ahura Mazda) went 'to Bethlehem to worship God'?
No, you didnt say I am making a brouhaha about anything You said: ''Inside all that you wrote the only thing worth responding to is this Cyrus Cylinder brouhaha
I know what brouhaha is without having to resort to a google check. Its you who recognise how you improperly used it in your construct
It's okay, I'll do it for you: brouhaha ˈbruːhɑːhɑː/ noun noun: brouhaha; plural noun: brouhahas
a noisy and overexcited reaction or response to something. "the brouhaha over those infamous commercials"
A cylinder, being inanimate, cannot make a brouhaha, but an excitable person such as yourself can, and is making brouhaha. Anybody that can understand english will know that this Cyrus Cylinder brouhaha is referring to the person making a brouhaha in reaction to the cylinder, not the cylinder making brouhaha. Sorry to sound so simplistic but it seems that is the only way you can understand.