Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,159,045 members, 7,838,637 topics. Date: Friday, 24 May 2024 at 06:58 AM

Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever - Sports (4) - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Entertainment / Sports / Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever (40066 Views)

Supersports Asks You To Select The Greatest Ever African In The Premier League / Eto'o Dismisses Diouf And Drogba Claims To Be Greatest Ever African Player / Wenger Picks Kanu As His Greatest-ever Arsenal January Signing (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) ... (12) (Reply) (Go Down)

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by lamps4blues: 11:15am On Nov 30, 2017
Sagamite:

Which 3 World Cups did Pele win?
1958,1962 and 1970
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Nobody: 11:19am On Nov 30, 2017
Rotty32:
I disagree with you bro..... This guy has to play for another club so we can see more of his talent
this is your mistake!!!messi is not playing for you!!!stop the ‘WE’!!!thats his profession!!!do you need Obama to come and be a president in Nigeria before you rank him high?think about that

6 Likes

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Nobody: 11:21am On Nov 30, 2017
chuckdee4:


The OP was talking about being the best and not being the happiest
Did messi ever tell the OP that he is playing to be the world’s greatest?watch his interviews,he says,he is happy playing football in Spain!!!

2 Likes

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Nobody: 11:21am On Nov 30, 2017
free2ryhme:


What has being happy got to do with this

He earns millions

You that does not have work are you happy

Dey there to look for how happy or no happy when dem no complain give

chai!!!see how stupid your reply reads!!!!kids of nowadays don’t read to understand
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by ObaKlaz: 11:22am On Nov 30, 2017
Sagamite:


You make the arguments, you bring the evidence.








And then get educated and corrected!
What are you even typing?! I mentioned that Pele won three world cups with Brazil and you're trying to be too smart! How is that not a fact? Are you sure you've got the right moniker?
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Jokkarm2: 11:23am On Nov 30, 2017
I LIKE MESSI FOR WHO HE IS, HE IS NOT COMPETING WITH ANYBODY, IF HE CHOOSES TO PLAY ALL HIS LIFE TIME CLUB MATCHES IN BARCELONA, IS QUITE A REMARKABLE HISTORY AND BOTH MERCY AND CHRISTIANO RONALDO ARE GREAT PLAYERS WITH INDIVIDUAL FOOTBALL LEGACIES WHICH WILL REMAIN IN THE HISTORY OF FOOTBALL.

MERCY IS MY LEGEND, I WISH TO MEET HIM SOMEDAY.

1 Like

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by 1wolex85: 11:25am On Nov 30, 2017
KinzyeWriter:
This is it.

And that is why Ronaldo who won everything in England before moving to Real Madrid and Won Euro 2016 for his country will be better.

This is a very stupid argument. If Ronaldo started out at Real Madrid, he would never have left! Why should Messi leave Barca? The omly bigger club is Real Madrid and he cant go there!

2 Likes

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Sagamite(m): 11:26am On Nov 30, 2017
lamps4blues:
1958,1962 and 1970

You should have let him answer, mate.

It is him I want to educate.

ObaKlaz, is this what your Google is telling you?
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by 1wolex85: 11:27am On Nov 30, 2017
KinzyeWriter:
Trashy topics you say... When proved Pele's point?

Pele should shut up! Out of the 3 world cups, he was injured for most of 2 of them.
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Pidginwhisper: 11:27am On Nov 30, 2017
Victornezzar:
Goal.com with their trashy topics cheesy cheesy
u can compare him to Maradona and pele but u can't compare Ronaldo to both

Messi is a genius
The matter wey u dodge that day don come haunt you grin


Ronaldo is the Greatest

1 Like

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Sagamite(m): 11:27am On Nov 30, 2017
Messi vs Ronaldo

Ronaldo is the ultimate goalscorer. He scores spectacular goals and is able to score at critical times of the game to carry the team.

Messi is also the ultimate goalscorer. He scores beautiful and sensational goals and is also able to score at critical times of the game to carry the team.

Now beautiful goals are a notch above spectacular.

Not only that, Messi has a better goal rate (0.8 ) than Ronaldo (0.7) in their football lifetime.

Ronaldo has a marginal better goal rate (1.02) than Messi (1.00) since he moved to Spain. Just a hattrick of goals by Messi, can swing it, so it is very marginal. Far more proportion of Ronaldo goals comes from Penalties than Messi, so that is another factor to consider.

Lest not forget that Ronaldo sometimes plays as a centre forward while Messi does not, yet Messi has better goal rates.

Moreover, not only does Messi score better goals, he has far more assist (50% more) than Ronaldo as he is also simultaneously a playmaker. Messi goes to pick the ball from midfield half the time.

Messi regularly takes out 3 to 6 players in a game. Ronaldo struggles to get past one. If that one is a fast player, he has to pass the ball to a teammate.

Messi humiliates 3 players simultaneously week-in, week-out. Even great defenders. Boateng will testify!

And some would say Ronaldo is faster. Well, yes, he is but marginally. I once saw their top speed stats and it was very close. Moreover, Ronaldo is faster without the ball, Messi is faster with the ball.

Ronaldo is a FANTASTIC GOALSCORER and can compete for greatest GOALSCORER of all time with Messi. Not best player.

12 Likes 1 Share

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by LordAdam16: 11:28am On Nov 30, 2017
Sagamite:


No, I don't know.

Tell me what WCs he won.

1958, 1962, and 1970 WCs.

I'm a CR7 fan, but I don't subscribe to the idea that Messi has to leave Barca to prove himself. Prove what exactly?

Moreover, the answer to the GOAT question is entirely subjective. No one would ever be objectively, unarguably considered the GOAT by everyone (or at least most people) at any time. The only objective statements that can be made relate to the greatest players to ever play the game.

And Messi is on that very, very short list. Along with Cruyff, CR7, R9, Pele, Ronaldinho, Garrincha, Heleno, Zizzinho, and Maradonna.

All of them have their shortfalls and strengths, which is why none of them is heads and shoulders over the rest. For example, at age 32, Pele was already off his stride. But at 32, CR7 was winning the La Liga, UCL back-to-back, and the Euros, contributing positively to the wins and is on track to scoring the most UCL goals in a calendar year by any player in history. That said, you can't take away Pele's 3 WC wins whether he was playing for a star-studded traditional heavyweight Brazil or not.

-Lord

1 Like

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by ObaKlaz: 11:28am On Nov 30, 2017
Sagamite:


You should have let him answer, mate.

It is him I want to educate.

ObaKlaz, is this what your Google is telling you?
Dude, come forth with your points. What EXACTLY is your point?!
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by davibid: 11:29am On Nov 30, 2017
ObaKlaz:
Maybe not the very greatest ever, but THE GREATEST OF HIS GENERATION, and he's surely up there with Pele and Maradona. The argument of him leaving Barcelona to "prove himself elsewhere" (especially in that mickey mouse league they call EPL) is just a weak effort by haters and critics to question his greatness. Asides winning the world cup, he has NOTHING! to prove to any disgruntled critic or hater.

His brilliance, wizardry and legacy remain untainted FOREVER.


I often wonder why some of you are always defensive about Messi trying out other leagues. I love Messi, as a matter of fact, no passionate lover of football will ever argue his precociousness in this beautiful game of football. However, we should not be clouded with sentiments but also consider the few yardstick used to judge other greats of the game. Playing wise none can fault his brilliance but since pro Messi fans are denial of the fact that the club he's at is of little significance to his greatness. Hence, I am also saying let him try it else and if he maintains same level of success in whichever club he goes to then I'll accede to the fact without question that he is the G. O. A. T.
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by 1wolex85: 11:29am On Nov 30, 2017
KinzyeWriter:
Lol the only bragging right that is weightier than messi career goals 2x grin

3 world cup should be overlooked ?

When say technical, yes messi is technical and Pele claimed that, but that doesn't play a vital role in a footballer greatness, but with achievement in different Jersey whether at international level or club level... That is why maradona is better... That is why Ronaldo is better... Afterall

Johan Cruyff won nothing with the netherlands, is Ronaldo better than him?

1 Like

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Victornezzar: 11:30am On Nov 30, 2017
Pidginwhisper:
The matter wey u dodge that day don come haunt you grin


Ronaldo is the Greatest
in scoring penalties and tapins cheesy
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by samisj4real(m): 11:31am On Nov 30, 2017
KinzyeWriter:
Messi wants international trophy... Messi needs to explore other club except Barcelona as you read in the article.

Pele was hindered for not playing in Europe, but his strength is the 3 world cup he won even though he is not the all time goal scorer.

Maradona has the most tiny weakness, to have played in Europe and won trophies and also a world cup in his international level.


Ronaldo has proven himself in the EPL by winning everything, in sporting, in Madrid, and international level.


Messi on the other hand risen into greatness with great players, and failed bunch of times in the international level... Now he hinders himself for being a one club man..

He is just a Barcelona legend bro grin
Hey Cunt, Was Ronaldo the 11 players? Stop saying trash & speak reality, Ronaldo played 4 3 big & in-form team & during his stay there, the team won trophies, so wassup with the Ronaldo won trophies stuff, didnt messi win, THE BEGINNING OF WISDOM IN ONE'S FUTBOL LIFE IZ WEN U KEEP SENTIMENTS ASIDE & PERSONAL LIKE & KNOW THAT NO PLAYER ON EARTH CAN BE COMPARED 2 "MESSI"

1 Like

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by 1wolex85: 11:32am On Nov 30, 2017
Sagamite:


What moronic nonsensical arguments by the author.

Who are the other candidates that can lay claim to the title if not Messi?

What 1283 goals did Pele score? You mean the ones were he counted all his high school and community competitions?

What 3 World Cups did Pele win? Total Nonsense.

Thank you! the argument is so moronic. Pele was even injured in 2 of the 3 world cups! so he should stop carrying that world cup on his head.
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by obonujoker(m): 11:32am On Nov 30, 2017
Sagamite:


Apart from Ronaldinho, Messi was/is the star of the team when he played with those players.

And he was not a star over Ronaldinho because he was too young then.

Henry left UK being the greatest player ever in the EPL, to be like the 4th best player in Barcelona.

Here is what Henry himself has to say about Messi.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zyIgPqOpMWY


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5GGMaz93kgs

Your analysis eh... no wonder you support a clown like Buhari.... who made Henry EPL greatest player??

1 Like

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by positivetaught: 11:35am On Nov 30, 2017
ObaKlaz:
Maybe not the very greatest ever, but THE GREATEST OF HIS GENERATION, and he's surely up there with Pele and Maradona. The argument of him leaving Barcelona to "prove himself elsewhere" (especially in that mickey mouse league they call EPL) is just a weak effort by haters and critics to question his greatness. Asides winning the world cup, he has NOTHING! to prove to any disgruntled critic or hater.

His brilliance, wizardry and legacy remain untainted FOREVER.
messi is good but his success over time is due largely to the wonderful array of supportive talents around him,he really need to clear all doubts by trying other environments, if not out of hate you certainly can't describe the EPL as a mickey mouse league.
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Lhimeet(m): 11:37am On Nov 30, 2017
1wolex85:


Thank you! the argument is so moronic. Pele was even injured in 2 of the 3 world cups! so he should stop carrying that world cup on his head.
Atleast he wasn't injured in 1 of the 3 world cups he won...So what again?...If we take out 2 based on the injury...He still got 1...You can type another excuse again now undecided
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by obonujoker(m): 11:37am On Nov 30, 2017
1wolex85:


Johan Cruyff won nothing with the netherlands, is Ronaldo better than him?

Ronaldo is actually better than all... his records speaks for him....
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by LordAdam16: 11:37am On Nov 30, 2017
Sagamite:
Messi vs Ronaldo

Ronaldo is the ultimate goalscorer. He scores spectacular goals and is able to score at critical times of the game to carry the team.

Messi is also the ultimate goalscorer. He scores beautiful and sensational goals and is also able to score at critical times of the game to carry the team.

Now beautiful goals are a notch above spectacular.

Not only that, Messi has a better goal rate (0.8 ) than Ronaldo (0.7) in their football lifetime.

Ronaldo has a marginal better goal rate (1.02) than Messi (1.00) since he moved to Spain. Just 1 goal by Messi, can swing it, so it is very marginal. More proportion of Ronaldo goals comes from Penalties than Messi, so that is another factor to consider.

Moreover, not only does Messi score better goals, he has far more assist (50%) than Ronaldo as he is also simultaneously a playmaker.

Messi regularly takes out 3 to 6 players in a game. Ronaldo struggles to get past one. If that one is a fast player, he has to pass.

Messi humiliates 3 players simultaneously week-in, week-out.

And some would say Ronaldo is faster. Well, yes, he is but marginally. I once saw the top speed stats and it was very close. Moreover, Ronaldo is faster without the ball, Messi is faster with the ball.

Ronaldo is a FANTASTIC GOALSCORER and can compete for greatest GOALSCORER of all time with Messi. Not best player.

That is entirely your opinion. It is not objective. It is not fact.

And that you're arguing with an obvious prejudiced lens proves it. If Messi is unarguably better than CR7, it wouldn't be a debate, it'd be clear cut. CR7 wouldn't even win a Ballon D'Or, because Messi would simply overshadow him.

But that's not the case. Both have had their stretches. Messi won 4 of 5 ballon d'ors. CR7 has won 4 of the last 5 ballon d'ors. You can argue that Messi achieved the feat first. I can argue CR7 achieved the feat at a time he should be declining. Making his feat impossible for any other player who's ever played the game. We'd both have those who nod and those who disagree, but we'd have both made valid points that can't be thrown out.

Don't even want to debate the points you're bringing up. I'm just relishing the records CR7 keeps breaking and creating and that I can use to prove he is the better of the two. You guys can continue arguing about who's better, doesn't add a cent to my account.

-Lord
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Sagamite(m): 11:39am On Nov 30, 2017
ObaKlaz:
Dude, come forth with your points. What EXACTLY is your point?!

TEAMS WIN WORLD CUPS!!!

Not players. I am not aware of any official record stating Pele won the WC, I am aware of one saying Brazil did!

It is not Tennis.

Don't argue based on misuse of terms you have seen popularly used. Pele was part of a team that won the WC, he did not win.

Now a fine argument might be made that a particular player played an extra-ordinarily exceptional part/single-handedly in winning a WC, so one can say the "player carried his team to win the WC". Fair enough!

But more education:

In 1958, Pele was a top player but the best player in the team was Didi. So Pele was crucial but he did not single-handedly carry the team. Didi was voted the best player at the WC.

In 1962, Pele was tackled hard and injured after the 2nd game and played no further part in the WC after game in the group stages. So Pele did not do anything exceptional, the team was good.

In 1970, the Brazilian team was regarded as the best team ever. Again Pele was crucial and probably the best player, but he did not carry this team full of stars, just like one cannot say Messi is carrying Barcelona when you have Iniesta, Xavi, Etoo, Puyol etc. He is just the best out of many.

So, mate, Pele has not won any WC. He was part of a team that has won WCs.

Messi has carried Argentina to WC final before, where they lost on penalties.

Ronaldo carried Portugal to win the Euros!

1 Like

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by dirtyhokage(m): 11:40am On Nov 30, 2017
Trash! Mr OP go and tell him to leave barca and play naija league for you naw.....who know you sef and your shiity opinion?
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Sagamite(m): 11:42am On Nov 30, 2017
LordAdam16:


1958, 1962, and 1970 WCs.

I'm a CR7 fan, but I don't subscribe to the idea that Messi has to leave Barca to prove himself. Prove what exactly?

Moreover, the answer to the GOAT question is entirely subjective. No one would ever be objectively, unarguably considered the GOAT by everyone (or at least most people) at any time. The only objective statements that can be made relate to the greatest players to ever play the game.

And Messi is on that very, very short list. Along with Cruyff, CR7, R9, Pele, Ronaldinho, Garrincha, Heleno, Zizzinho, and Maradonna.

All of them have their shortfalls and strengths, which is why none of them is heads and shoulders over the rest. For example, at age 32, Pele was already off his stride. But at 32, CR7 was winning the La Liga, UCL back-to-back, and the Euros, contributing positively to the wins and is on track to scoring the most UCL goals in a calendar year by any player in history. That said, you can't take away Pele's 3 WC wins whether he was playing for a star-studded traditional heavyweight Brazil or not.

-Lord

There are only 4 players on the short list for GOAT.

Messi, Maradona, Pele and CR7!
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by solastic74: 11:43am On Nov 30, 2017
The article's argument is quite flawed.

1. No matter the club messi moves to (City, Psg, Bayern) he'll still be surrounded by the best players in the world just as he is at Barcelona. Cause those are the only clubs that can afford him anyway. Don't expect him to sign for West Ham United.

2. ‎The great Pele was surrounded by all time greats like Garrincha, Tostao, Revelino without which I doubt he would have won 3 world cups. It's a team sport after all. (That's why Maradona is probably the greatest cool).

3. ‎He only needs that world cup next year to cement his place along side Pele and Maradona.

Typical British article cause he didn't sign for Man City.

1 Like

Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Sagamite(m): 11:44am On Nov 30, 2017
1wolex85:


Johan Cruyff won nothing with the netherlands, is Ronaldo better than him?

Ronaldo (CR7) is well better than Cruyff.
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by positivetaught: 11:45am On Nov 30, 2017
1wolex85:


This is a very stupid argument. If Ronaldo started out at Real Madrid, he would never have left! Why should Messi leave Barca? The omly bigger club is Real Madrid and he cant go there!
it's not a stupid argument, Nezario Luis da lima(Rinaldo) started at PSV in Europe scoring 58goals in 58 matches move to Barcelona was a success, moved to inter was a success,won the world cup, before retiring,if he had remained at PSV scoring crazy amount of goals like Ally Mcoist of Scottish Rangers of yesteryears,who would have take him serious?.
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Sagamite(m): 11:45am On Nov 30, 2017
obonujoker:


Your analysis eh... no wonder you support a clown like Buhari.... who made Henry EPL greatest player??

You are a cretinous fccktard!

Were you educated in Kaduna State?
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Sagamite(m): 11:46am On Nov 30, 2017
positivetaught:
messi is good but his success over time is due largely to the wonderful array of supportive talents around him,he really need to clear all doubts by trying other environments, if not out of hate you certainly can't describe the EPL as a mickey mouse league.

What nonsense!

The same array of stars that did not make 'Henry the GREAT of EPL' great in Spain?
Re: Messi's Decision To Stay At Barcelona Ensures He'll Never Be The Greatest Ever by Nobody: 11:47am On Nov 30, 2017
Greatest in terms of what? It depends on the angle.

In terms of pure football skills and genius, I would say Ronaldinho and Maradona.

In terms of Trophies I would go for Pele.

In terms of completeness Lionel Messi has my vote anyday.

In terms of abnegation, self questionning, hard work and discipline, Ronaldo takes it anytime.

BUT, though I am a Ronaldo (both of them) fan, it is too early to conclude Messi wont be the greatest. There is a World cup coming... Who knows? Messi is a child of destiny, there is destiny written all over him. No one really knows.

I still love Ronaldo though. He has the right mindset for any one who wishes to go far in life, and does not count on "chance".

5 Likes 2 Shares

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10) ... (12) (Reply)

CAF Withdraws AFCON 2019 Hosting Rights From Cameroon / Shanghai Shenhua Sign Obafemi Martins To Replace Manchester United Loanee Ighalo / Edwin Van DER Sar: Manchester United's Legendary Goalkeeper In ICU

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 76
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.