frosbel: Atheists defend the right of homosexuals and lesbians to pursue their life styles. Furthermore, they promote the erroneous view that the God of the Bible is unfair and oppressive toward them. Does God hate homosexuals and lesbians or are His prohibitions a supreme manifestation of love and deep concern?
God since the beginning has given clear and undeniable pronouncements about homosexuality. He has declared in both the Old and the New Testament that homosexuality is a sin that He strongly disapproves of. Some have erroneously assumed that this manifests hatred on God's part toward his gay and lesbian children. This is the furthest thing from the truth. In fact what His prohibitions really indicate is a deep love for his children and an attempt to keep them from choices that can cause them serious harm and that can shorten their lives dramatically.
Because there are plenty of web sites that offer well-documented facts on the damaging effects of homosexuality, I will simply direct the reader to them, at the end of this article. . . . .
You do realize that your God says they should be killed. Is that a sign of love? If you can interpret killing people for their own sexual orientation as being good, then you can probably interpret anything whether good, evil or unknown as being good.
See my post #67. Simply read the two statements you made. They are self contradictory.
Uyi Iredia: Can 'nature' exist as both a word and a concept ? Can a concept select ?
These are absurd questions that are based on the same fallacy. Has it occurred to you that there is e.g the word "computer" and the concept of a computer. Can "computer" exist as both a word and a concept? Can a concept process information? You're still committing the same use-mention fallacy. This time around the word "concept".
Uyi Iredia: Not so. You should have brought examples of creationist arguments and pointed out their faults (in that post). Calling them rubbish based on your arguments with other posters here is a mistake on your part.
Those are some of the creationist arguments. Do you have another one you wish to be addressed?
Uyi Iredia: This implies that you are older than me and have some professional qualification (in the natural sciences). Could you intimate me with these details ? If you don't want to do so here you can send them to me via e-mail.
Maybe it does. Maybe I am a student in some advanced class or just a gifted 15 year old girl. Such details are irrelevant. I would rather you looked at the evidence and argument presented rather than at who it was that was presenting them.
Uyi Iredia: Your treatment of that post was poor. I will give a reply much later.
Sure, sure
Simply make sure you read properly before making your response.
Uyi Iredia: I am simply saying that is an assumption (i.e given the possibility of other reasons)
What are these reasons that you cannot mention given the fact that the needed information should be available on the thread?
Uyi Iredia: This implies that it isn't possible to give a causal mechanism for something uncaused. Am I correct ?
Sure that is one implication. Another is that as far as we know, it is uncaused such that a cause may be discovered later.
Uyi Iredia: No ! I am saying the attraction between bodies causes a force and that force is called gravity. Besides, consider how absurd your statement will be if you replace the word 'attraction' with 'force'.
Again, no. The attraction = a force = gravity. The attraction isn't causing a force, it is the force. Now how would that make my statement absurd? Why don't you take a look at the dictionary definition I presented in #55
Uyi Iredia: It's in plain sight in Wikipedia. Evolution covers the origin of life (also called abiogenesis)
This will depend on how you wish to use "covers" here because the origin of life isn't what the theory is about. The theory assumes that there is life.
Uyi Iredia: It wasn't. You gave a scenario in which an inference was based on fact. There was no assumption beforehand.
Go back and read that scenario. The assumption was that they were siblings.
Uyi Iredia: Point out the statement in question and your problem with it.
What is the empirical data which supports methodological naturalism (on which science is based) ? Besides, science was birthed by metaphysical rationalism espoused by people like Descartes, Leibniz e.t.c that should tell you that naturalism is not the only basis for science.
What does metaphysical rationalism mean? What sort of empirical data would you consider as supporting a methodology?
Uyi Iredia: A better option would be to discuss whether bias is (and should be avoided) in science.
Simply read the article and the answer to that will be clear to you. I need you properly informed to some extent if we're going to be discussing it.
Uyi Iredia: Explain your position on why reason and logic are dependent on human minds.
Present your argument on what reason and logic have to do with the existence of God. See your post #141
Uyi Iredia: What you need to realize is that evolution also deals with the origin of life. It is clearly stated (in UC Berkeley's website) that : "Evolutionary theory does encompass ideas and evidence regarding life's origins."
You still don't understand your own reference. Here, they've simplified it even further maybe due to the sort of error you made in misunderstanding the language. Pay attention to my emphasis.
[quote author=berkeley.edu]MISCONCEPTION: Evolution is a theory about the origin of life.
CORRECTION: Evolutionary theory does encompass ideas and evidence regarding life's origins (e.g., whether or not it happened near a deep-sea vent, which organic molecules came first, etc.), but this is not the central focus of evolutionary theory. Most of evolutionary biology deals with how life changed after its origin.Regardless of how life started, afterwards it branched and diversified, and most studies of evolution are focused on those processes.[/quote]You could consider it a parallel to the idea that plate tectonics encompasses ideas about the origin of continents but the actual theory is about the movement of the continents whatever their origins may be.
Uyi Iredia: * What gives you grounds for this conclusion ?
Your response to the fossil evidence.
Uyi Iredia: * You are the one missing it. If you didn't you wouldn't state that the fossils can be used as evidence for UCD. They can't be used because they contradict an expectation based on the evolutionary theory (i.e abundance of transitional species in the fossil record)
I already told you that fossilization is a rare occurrence. For some reason, you're unable to understand what I said even after clearly pointing out the two strains of thought.
Uyi Iredia: * Simply concede that vestigiality is based on the aforesaid fallacy. You opposed this saying that vestigial organs could have minor functions in an organism (e.g the appendix). I countered by saying major functions can be found later.
I'm not the one saying that. That is what biologists who use the term say. This is why you should learn to read articles to be enlightened. Simply look up the reference I gave you.
Uyi Iredia: Hinting is not what is required but a presentation of the arguments. My reply in #337 was apropos since the evidences presented do not involve observation of UCD.
Direct observation isn't necessarily the best method of inference.
Uyi Iredia: You are a nit-wit. I have defined my use of 'kind' in this context: organisms in the same genus. I have also refferred you to an article which describes the meaning of 'kinds'.
You are a bumbling buffoon. You haven't defined your use of "kind" in this context neither does the article use it the way you do. So once again, your own reference destroys your idea. To help you understand that you're saying rubbish, substitute the word "kind" with "sort". Now tell me if your so called definition makes any more sense to you.
Uyi Iredia: Then let's leave it at that.
If you want. All I ask is that you understand what has been said.
Uyi Iredia: I said "quite different" not 'different'. To find out what tallies read the article. Apparently, you didn't.
Do you think the use of the phrase "quite different" somehow negates what is meant by "different" in that context? It appears that your core problem lies with the English Language.
frosbel: I can see that Nigerians are getting brain washed and beginning to accept western concepts of s.exual perversion and atheism. Many years ago this sort of thing will be considered an abomination.
More grease to your elbows, just carry out your lusts in your private closets.
But when you bring it into the public domain, hoping that this deviant trait will be accepted as a normal life style, those of us who have children have to fight with the Truth and Prayer.
We had to contend with militant atheism, now we are contending with militant homosexuality, spreading their filth all over the social media, airwaves and forums . Christian and I also trust Muslim parents now have to monitor their children round the clock to make sure they do not mistakenly land on one of these demonic inspired web sites, we have to spend money buying and installing security filters to stop this invasion of our homes.
Not to worry , Judgement is coming , Keep scoffing.
"Because the sentence against an evil deed is not executed quickly, therefore the hearts of the sons of men among them are given fully to do evil." - Ecclesiastes 8:11
Make sure they don't go to their friends houses to access the internet or to proper universities for education. Just lock them up and home school them. Don't forget to hide the televisions too. I will continue scoffing. You keep whining.
dekung: — NASA's planet-hunting Kepler spacecraft has confirmed the discovery of its first alien world in its host star's habitable zone — that just-right range of distances that could allow liquid water to exist — and found more than 1,000 new explanet candidates, researchers announced today (Dec. 5). The new finds bring the Kepler space telescope's total haul to 2,326 potential planets in its first 16 months of operation.These discoveries, if confirmed, would quadruple the current tally of worlds known to exist beyond our solar system, which recently topped 700. The potentially habitable alien world, a first for Kepler, orbits a star very much like our own sun. The discovery brings scientists one step closer to finding a planet like our own — one which could conceivably harbor life, scientists said. "We're getting closer and closer to discovering the so-called 'Goldilocks planet,'" Pete Worden, director of NASA's Ames Research Center in Moffett Field, Calif., said during a press conference today. [Gallery: The Strangest Alien Planets] The newfound planet in the habitable zone is called Kepler-22b. It is located about 600 light-years away, orbiting a sun-like star. Kepler-22b's radius is 2.4 times that of Earth, and the two planets have roughly similar temperatures. If the greenhouse effect operates there similarly to how it does on Earth, the average surface temperature on Kepler-22b would be 72 degrees Fahrenheit (22 degrees Celsius). Hunting down alien planets The $600 million Kepler observatory launched in March 2009 to hunt for Earth-size alien planets in the habitable zone of their parent stars, where liquid water, and perhaps even life, might be able to exist. Kepler detects alien planets using what's called the "transit method." It searches for tiny, telltale dips in a star's brightness caused when a planet transits — or crosses in front of — the star from Earth's perspective, blocking a fraction of the star's light. The finds graduate from "candidates" to full-fledged planets after follow-up observations confirm that they're not false alarms. This process, which is usually done with large, ground-based telescopes, can take about a year. The Kepler team released data from its first 13 months of operation back in February, announcing that the instrument had detected 1,235 planet candidates, including 54 in the habitable zone and 68 that are roughly Earth-size. Of the total 2,326 candidate planets that Kepler has found to date, 207 are approximately Earth-size. More of them, 680, are a bit larger than our planet, falling into the "super-Earth" category. The total number of candidate planets in the habitable zones of their stars is now 48. To date, just over two dozen of these potential exoplanets have been confirmed, but Kepler scientists have estimated that at least 80 percent of the instrument's discoveries should end up being the real deal. More discoveries to come The newfound 1,094 planet candidates are the fruit of Kepler's labors during its first 16 months of science work, from May 2009 to September 2010. And they won't be the last of the prolific instrument's discoveries. "This is a major milestone on the road to finding Earth's twin," Douglas Hudgins, Kepler program scientist at NASA headquarters in Washington, D.C., said in a statement. Mission scientists still need to analyze data from the last two years and on into the future. Kepler will be making observations for a while yet to come; its nominal mission is set to end in November 2012, but the Kepler team is preparing a proposal to extend the instrument's operations for another year or more. Kepler's finds should only get more exciting as time goes on, researchers say. "We're pushing down to smaller planets and longer orbital periods," said Natalie Batalha, Kepler deputy science team lead at Ames. To flag a potential planet, the instrument generally needs to witness three transits. Planets that make three transits in just a few months must be pretty close to their parent stars; as a result, many of the alien worlds Kepler spotted early on have been blisteringly hot places that aren't great candidates for harboring life as we know it. Given more time, however, a wealth of more distantly orbiting — and perhaps more Earth-like — exoplanets should open up to Kepler. If intelligent aliens were studying our solar system with their own version of Kepler, after all, it would take them three years to detect our home planet. "We are getting very close," Batalha said. "We are homing in on the truly Earth-size, habitable planets."
To put the 600 light years in perspective, if the Voyager probe were headed in that direction going at an assumed rate of traversing 1 light year in 14,000 years, it would take about 8.4 million years to get to that vicinity.
bodeade: THIS IS AN OPPORTUNITY FOR CHRISTIANS TO HAVE A FREE BIBLE AND #400 RECHARGE CARD IF CAN JUST BUY A BIBLE STUDY OUTLINES AND NOTES COVERING THE MAJOR TEACHINGS IN THE SCRIPTURES. This Volume contains all that is usually called SYSTEMATIC THEOLOGY In seminaries or bible training college useful for pastors, evang, yeachers and all christian workers. Special attention has been given to studies on RELATIONSHIP with GOD AND WITH ONE ANOTHER, PRAYER, FAITH,EVANGELISM, MARRIAGE, AND LAST DAY EVENTS. For you to have this bible taining book . You must have passion for reading bible, have an e-mail add, phone no to receive your credit card and #2,500. for more details call 08027823720. Take note the book is more than #10,000 but i want at least 50 christians to have it. yours in christ israel
frosbel: A Navy tradition caught up with the repeal of the U.S. military's 'don't ask, don't tell' rule when two women sailors became the first to share the coveted home-coming 'first kiss' on the pier.
Petty Officer 2nd Class Marissa Gaeta of California, descended from the USS Oak Hill after 80 days at sea and shared a kiss in the rain with her partner, Petty Officer 3rd Class Citlalic Snell of Los Angeles.
The crowd screamed and waved flags around the couple as they shared the short embrace, with Gaeta, 23, wearing her Navy dress uniform while Snell, 22, wore a black leather jacket and blue jeans.
I dare not show the actual image for reasons of our spiritual health.
The ship returned to Joint Expeditionary Base Little Creek-Fort Story following an 80-day deployment to Central America. The crew of more than 300 participated in exercises involving the militaries of Honduras, Guatemala Colombia and Panama as part of Amphibious-Southern Partnership Station 2012.
Both women are Navy fire controlmen, who maintain and operate weapons systems on ships.
They met at training school where they were roommates and have been dating for two years, which they said was difficult under 'don't ask, don't tell'. 'We did have to hide it a lot in the beginning,' Snell said.
'"A lot of people were not always supportive of it in the beginning, but we can finally be honest about who we are in our relationship, so I'm happy.'
Navy officials said it was the first time on record that a same-sex couple was chosen to kiss first upon a ship's return. Sailors and their loved ones bought $1 raffle tickets for the opportunity.
Gaeta said she bought $50 of tickets, a figure that she said pales in comparison to amounts that some other sailors and their loved ones had bought. The money was used to host a Christmas party for the children of sailors.
Snell said she believes their experience won't be the last one for gays and lesbians in the military.
'I think that it's something that is going to open a lot of doors, for not just our relationship, but all the other gay and lesbian relationships that are in the military now,' she said. Snell is based on the USS Bainbridge, the guided missile destroyer that helped rescue cargo captain Richard Phillips from Somali pirates in 2009.
Pastor Kun: This should interest our scientific atheists on this forum.
"The image on the Turin Shroud could not be the work of medieval forgers but was instead caused by a supernatural ‘flash of light’, according to scientists.
Italian researchers have found evidence that casts doubt on claims that the relic – said to be the burial cloth of Jesus – is a fake and they suggest that it could, after all, be authentic.
Sceptics have long argued that the shroud, a rectangular sheet measuring about 14ft by 3ft, is a forgery dating to medieval times."
Did you read the entire article which contained statements such as
In 1988, radiocarbon tests on samples of the shroud at the University of Oxford, the University of
Arizona, and the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology dated the cloth to the Middle Ages, between 1260 and 1390.
Those tests have been disputed on the basis that they were contaminated by fibres from cloth used to repair the shroud when it was damaged by fire in the Middle Ages.
More recently, further doubt was cast on its authenticity when Israeli archaeologists uncovered the first known burial shroud in Jerusalem from the time of the Crucifixion.
Its weave and design are completely different from the Turin Shroud, they said.
The Jerusalem shroud has a simple two-way weave – but the twill weave used on the Turin Shroud was introduced more than 1,000 years after Christ lived.
Then we have this further clincher.
There have been numerous calls for further testing but the Vatican has always refused.
OLAADEGBU: This is what is a fallacy of the highest proportions, that:
[list] [li]About 15 billion years ago the universe exploded into existence.[/li] [/list] [list] [li]About 4.6 billion years ago the earth evolved[/li] [/list] [list] [li]About 3.5 billion years ago life evolved[/li] [/list] [list] [li]About 0.5-1.0 million years ago humans evolved from ape-like creatures[/li] [/list] (By time, chance and natural processes).
For anyone to believe this fairytale is to be committing intellectual harakiri.
How are they fallacies when those are the implications of the information we have based on scientific evidence and reasoning?
OLAADEGBU: Do you see why the evolutionist thinking deprives you of reconcilling with reality?
No I don't. Evolution is a fact of reality.
OLAADEGBU: My true myth is based on facts while your myth is based on fairytales. Have you forgotten that you share the same ancestors with those guys in the zoo?
How is it factual to claim that humans were moulded from sand, a donkey spoke, a man lived in a fish for a few days? It seems you're unable to tell reality from fantasy. Besides, they're your ancestors too.
OLAADEGBU: How do you recognise the evidence of intelligence?
By proper analysis of the evidence.
OLAADEGBU: The God of the Bible created all the basic entities of life and the universe and that is what we see and so you've got no excuse to feign ignorance of His intelligence.
No. What we have is Christians claiming that the God of the Bible did all that. What evidence do they have for such an assertion other than their flimsy book?
OLAADEGBU: So you think it is not fallacious to think that objects are products of time and chance?
No it isn't necessarily fallacious. After all, the Andromeda galaxy was a product of time and chance. So were stalactites.
OLAADEGBU: Do you think that metal, left to itself would eventually form into engines, transmissions, wheels and all the other intricate parts needed to produce a car?
No I don't. What does this have to do with anything?
OLAADEGBU: Yes. True myths, that is. Tell us about your own myths that say that you evolved from the primordial soup via the zoo?
Looks as if we mean different things by the word "true". What on earth are you talking about? What zoo?
OLAADEGBU: When you look at the Great Wall of China, the U.S. Capitol building in Washington or the Murtala Muhammad airport in Lagos do you conclude that such structures were formed after explosions in a brick factory?
No I don't. Again, what does that have to do with anything?
OLAADEGBU: Answers to my questions above will show you that you are the one guilty of fallacious reasoning. Any rational, logical and reasonable thinking person will recognise that design of man-made objects is the evidence of the outworkings of our intelligence. What other evidence are you expecting to find if there was really an infinite God who created all things as the Bible has stated? How would we even recognise the hand of the Uncreated Creator. To recognise His handiwork, you must know how to recognise the evidence of the works of His intelligence.
I would have expected the Bible to be factually correct but it isn't so why should I believe in the God it introduces?
For some reason, you never did tell me what you meant by an "increase in information". Any way, here goes.
Uyi Iredia: Apparently thehomer did not read the Lee Spetner/Edward Max Dialogue in full. thehomer clearly had insufficient background information on genetics to forward the following statement as a reply to my question on the possibility of mutations increasing genetic information. This is his statement: "I hope you know that there are genetic mutations that cause duplications of genes." This statement implies that genetic duplication is an increase in information. Let me first make it clear that mutations do not cause gene duplications however, they usually occur during genetic duplication. I will embolden important parts of this discussion which refute thehomer's stance and make my commentaries afterwards.
Uyi Iredia: *1 >>> The newspaper analogy clearly connotes that gene duplication is not an increase in information. Let readers not that gene duplication occurs when somatic cells (body cells e.g skin cells, nerve cells, muscle cells) or germline cells are dividing. Of course, everyone knows cell division is germane to growth.
I know that a mere duplication isn't an increase in information in that abstract sense but it provides an important raw material for the process of evolution.
Uyi Iredia: *2 >>> This statement clarifies evolutionists position. One that thehomer either did not know or did not express properly. He must be guilty of either. Random mutations occurring in the duplicate gene is assumed to have made that gene gain a new function which denotes increase in genetic information. This should then be preserved by natural selection otherwise it would be lost. This implies the new genetic information should lead to better reproductive success of the organism for it to be preserved.
Actually, I know that. The implication is not about leading to a better reproductive success but to something different from the parent. It is via the process of natural selection that one knows whether or not there was success.
Uyi Iredia: *3 >>> That's an evolutionist being careful to avoid the mistake I ascribe to thehomer. He also agrees gene duplication doesn't equal information increase something strongly thehomer's insinuates.
Sure the duplication isn't an increase in information in that abstract sense, but in the biological sense, the duplication of a gene gives us lots of information and in cancers, it signifies an amplification which of course is some sort of information.
Uyi Iredia: *4 >>> A fair analogy of what we expect to see if random mutation works with gene duplication to create new genetic information. Problem is this has never occurred. The examples I mentioned to thehomer were forwarded as those kinds of mutations (that produce de novo information) and were refuted. The one of citrate-digesting bacteria never specified if the mutation created a gain in function (which denotes new genetic info) and besides wasn't particularly new since bacteria digest citrate under oxic conditions. The mutations in nylon-digesting bacteria and the B-cell hyper-mutations actually produce information but aren't random (where they occur and how they occur is dictated by as-at-yet-unknown enzymes).
Has never occurred? Take a look at this article. Still, what does the B-cell hyper mutation have to do with what I said? The information isn't random because of the process of natural selection. Note the word selection there. Selection implies non-random.
It appears that you've managed to shoot yourself two or three times in the head just to be sure that you have no idea of what you're talking about.
Uyi Iredia: Whilst you ignored my reason as to why your so-called inconsistencies don't apply. As they say in these parts: [size=15pt]You are on a long thing ![/size] A very 'long thing' I must add.
Do you want another referral? Yes or no.
Uyi Iredia: This: "I'm not referring to the word "nature" but to the concept of nature." Explain how it shows that my question is fallacious.
[quote author=knowledgerush.com][size=14pt]Use-mention fallacy[/size] The use-mention distinction is the distinction between using a word (or phrase, etc.) and mentioning it. In written language, mentioned words or phrases often appear between quotation marks or in italics; some authorities insist that mentioned words or phrases always be made visually distinct in this manner. Used words or phrases, being more common than mentioned ones, do not have any typographic distinction.
For example,
Cheese is derived from milk.
is a statement about the substance cheese, while
Cheese is derived from a word in Old English
is a statement about the word cheese.
Source[/quote]I'm talking about the concept of nature not the word "nature".
Uyi Iredia: Did you address these 'rubbish' ? You should have pointed out these 'rubbish' and why they are so (which is the purpose of the argument) and that's why your statement is an ad hominem. Simply saying they are rubbish without pointing out fallacies in their arguments is itself fallacious. Accept your mistake and stop rationalizing.
I've addressed a few of them as we've gone on. See my post #8 on improbabilities, #22 on life being the product of a free floating mind, #41 on the argument from design among others. They are rubbish that is unacceptable in scientific journals. Not just free-floating rubbish but rubbish of a specific type.
Uyi Iredia: I learn here because I have to gather more knowledge germane to points you and I raise whenever we debate. I could choose to do nothing. You, on the other hand, appear to learn nothing. I say 'appear' to give you the benefit of a doubt.
Sorry but you're not really showing the signs of learning. In my case, you're not qualified to even be in my class on the topic under discussion.
Uyi Iredia: Your naivete here is enogh to start another thread. However I'll deal with it in another post on this thread.
Uyi Iredia: Look up the meaning of both 'implication' and 'assumption'. Implications are sometimes assumed.
<sigh> This is what I get for pointing out that your inability to back up your own claims in a documented discussion, implies that you're lying.
Uyi Iredia: The bolded is what I had in mind. I have repeatedly told you your answer is redundant because by definition facts exist. Your answer is akin to saying uncaused things exist as things that exist. By asking how uncaused things exist I am asking for a (causal) event that leads to their existence. You are confusing the adverb how in my question. How so ? Here's the definition for how (from Dictionary.com):
how [hou] adverb 1. in what way or manner; by what means?: How did the accident happen? 2. to what extent, degree, etc.?: How damaged is the car? 3. in what state or condition?: How are you? 4. for what reason; why?: How can you talk such nonsense? 5. to what effect; with what meaning?: How is one to interpret his action?
The bolded is my use of how. Your answer assumes my use of how to be the 4th one. An example: If I answer the question "How did the accident happen?" with "The accident is terrible" it would be wrong since is doen't describe the process or manner it occurred.
So: How do uncaused things exist ? I already know possible answers. Be careful it is a correct one or a subtle one
You have successfully shown that your God doesn't exist and that you're still having problems with the language we're using to communicate. You're asking for a causal mechanism for something that is uncaused? Do you know what the word uncaused means?
Uyi Iredia: I suspect we are saying the same thing in different ways. The attraction is a force: the one that causes gravity. Attraction should not be called gravity or it can be confused with attraction that gives rise to the electromagnetic force between similar charges.
No we're not saying the same things. You're saying that two bodies cause an attraction that is called gravity. I'm saying that gravity is a force of attraction that is simply present between those bodies. Note that yours is talking about bodies causing gravity while mine isn't.
Uyi Iredia: Have you considered that the fault could be yours ? No one's perfect. I won't cast stones on you for admitting your error.
Uyi Iredia: It does. That quote from Berkeley's website should've put paid to this.
Go back and present the paragraph that does this.
Uyi Iredia: * I have the pre-requisite background knowledge. Just answer my question on how a stage of embryonic similarity supports common descent (without assuming it) ?
No you obviously don't and you're unwilling to educate yourself.
Uyi Iredia: * That evolutionist's quote didn't enter your brain abi ! Here it is to refresh your memory:
“Wallace’s first point is ‘that one’s interpretation of the fossil record will invariably be influenced by one’s presuppositions.’ He is absolutely correct. Any historical science will be subject to interpretation because we can only test theories in the present, not the past, The fossil record does not, in the strict sense, provide evidence for evolution.”
- Wayne Duck
Where is this quote from? Not that it really matters because it seems you missed the part in bold. Ask yourself what that phrase meant.
Uyi Iredia: The rarity of fossilization contradicts the expectation of numerous transitional fossils. At best, the evidence from fossils is porous.
Uyi Iredia: * This from an ape ? A blockhead who believes that minority in function implies a major function in a never-before-seen organism.
You're an ape too you dullard. Why don't you actually read what scientists mean by vestigial organs rather than attacking fantasies in your empty head?
Uyi Iredia: Present arguments my friend and not headings. Or would you prefer I brought headings of proper refutations.
I hinted at them on my post #335 and you simply said rubbish in post #337 so it appeared that your brain couldn't handle that degree of complexity. Follow the link I presented above and you will find an introduction to the huge stack of evidence for evolution.
Uyi Iredia: Olori buruku ! When I was substituting I made it clear. You pressed on for a definition, I gave one to you (i.e organisms within a genus). Now you're saying that I should present a 'proper definition'. You are daft ! Go and check your dictionary for the word "kind''.
No, you claimed substitution was your definition. Now you proceed to commit the fallacy of shifting the burden. You're the one to define your use of "kind" yet you wish me to do your own work? What a daft, imbecilic air-head.
Uyi Iredia: Everything to be honest. I didn't get the significance of the statement.
Then your problem lies with a difficulty in understanding English Language because I don't know how easier I can make it. [url=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Use%E2%80%93mention_distinction]Here read it in an encyclopaedia[/url]. Though it may not do you much good since your command of the language is very poor.
Uyi Iredia: You are a nit-wit. A scallywag and a nit-wit. If you read it you would have seen that it tallies. The difference is that, in this context, I restricted my application of the term to only 'genus'.
Your stupidity and self contradiction knows no bounds. Weren't you the alzheimer's disease suffering slowpoke who said in post #378 that your use was different from that of other creationists? So what tallies? Or are you on drugs? Note that thus far, you've not presented a working definition of kind.
OLAADEGBU: There are two positions at stake. Evidence that there has to be a God and Knowing and relating with this God. The former needs no faith while the latter does.
I hope you realize that you haven't provided arguments backing up your claims for this God that isn't fallacious.
OLAADEGBU: If you see a building will you conclude that it was built by someone or that it just appeared out of the thin air?
The universe isn't like a building.
OLAADEGBU: You will realise that you need mercy from your Creator God just like your mentor Ingersoll must have found out when he passed through the gates of death. My definition of faith is simply what I said earlier; It is having confidence in something we have not perceived with our physical senses.
Like things you've been told? e.g myths?
OLAADEGBU: Let me use the analogy of a building that I referred to above. When you look at a building, how do you know that there was a builder? You can't see the builder, nor hear him, touch him, taste or smell him. But the building is the proof positive that there had to be a builder. The evidence that there was a builder is the building that you have in front of you. You don't need faith to know that there was a builder. All you need are your physical senses that are in good working order. The same principle applies with the existence of God and His creation.
The universe is not like a building. Neither are the sun, earth and other cosmic objects like buildings.
OLAADEGBU: As I said, they don't even need to believe in God to know that He exists, it is obvious to them that He exists because of the work of His creation. Look at the video clip below to see God's handiwork on display.
davidylan: The problem is that many who suppose they are relying on "evidence" are themselves either unaware or dishonestly projecting the myths and speculations of others as "fact".
Yes. As is often seen among the religious.
davidylan: I would agree that relying on the scientific explanation for malaria is key to managing your health in a malaria-endemic area. The issue is whether there is sufficient scientific evidence for the "theory" of evolution besides the usual myths we are constantly badgered with. I cannot help but notice that as usual, my CLEAR question is glossed over and ignored in favor of intellectually empty grandstanding.
There is sufficient scientific evidence for the theory of evolution though it appears that you're using an unfamiliar or made up definition of myth in your statement. Which clear question was glossed over and ignored?
davidylan: I agree . . . neither atheists nor christians have any empirical evidence of their points of view. However the atheist is too deluded to realize his own "religion" is built squarely on the shifting sands of speculation and blind faith in metaphysical pontification.
I like how the word religion is in quote. Also, I think relying on science to make life changing decisions is much better than relying on superstition. Would you agree? The fact that scientific knowledge is adjusted to fit the evidence is its strength while religious ideas not shifting to fit the evidence is to its detriment.
lagerwhenindoubt: Do you realize you can nail jello to a wall The Divine Mystery revealed - Atheists and Christians are really talking about the same thing
Sure the question of course is whether one thinks that this thing is present. Some rely on evidence to make up their minds, others rely on fantasies, fallacies and cognitive biases.
davidylan: Like someone once said - getting an atheist to commit to a definite stance on how the earth appeared is like nailing jello to the wall. It seems the atheist position consists SOLELY of irrational, mindless and extreme opposition to the religious alternative.
As has been said earlier, jell-o can be nailed to the wall. For this non-Christian, my view parallels that of the appropriate scientists. Though the religious alternative of course is just fantasy which is taken seriously by adults.
davidylan: Again i will ask for the 4076th time, what is the alternative explanation for how the world came about?
Here's one.
Deep Sight: "From the point of a singularity, the universe following the initial expansion called the big b[b]a[/b]ng has expanded outwards in a flow of matter of energy, the movement of which has resulted in the formaltion of stars and galaxies, and colliding rocks around stars coalesce to form planets such as the earth, which under the right conditions could also harbour life."
Uyi Iredia: Clearly bad behavior from Christians. One that is very unlike the calm character Jesus displayed against people who were skeptical of his divinity. Did they remove the cross or not ?
Uyi Iredia: You haven't that's why I'm asking you to do so by showing inconsistencies in my statement. The one you pointed out has been accounted for.
I showed you the inconsistencies and you simply skipped over them ignoring that demonstration. Do you want another referral to that post?
Uyi Iredia: Explain how the use-mention fallacy applied to my question. Make your explanation simple and precise.
I already did that please read it once again.
thehomer:[size=14pt]You've committed the use-mention fallacy. I'm not referring to the word "nature" but to the concept of nature.[/size]
Now, please tell me what confuses you about that post.
Uyi Iredia: Bolded implies ignorance of creationist arguments. You did not address any argument, you said: "No wonder they're spewing rubbish that is unacceptable . . . " That is a clear ad hominem.
Have you presented the creationist arguments? Also, it isn't an ad-hominem when what they are spewing is in fact rubbish that is actually unacceptable in scientific journals. A cautionary note. As a student of philosophy, you should be aware that an ad-hominem is an informal fallacy so the fact that the word "rubbish" is used to describe the work of creationists, doesn't mean that it doesn't apply there. Maybe you need to look up what "rubbish" means to see how apropos it is.
Uyi Iredia: You must have poor knowledge in genetics not to know that the nucleotide sequences code for amino acid sequences. The following statement from this article backs it up: "The sequence of nucleobases on a nucleic acid strand is translated by cell machinery into a sequence of amino acids making up a protein strand."
The amino-acid sequence is not genetic information but is as a result of it. I will need to make a correction in my earlier statement on nylonase-eating bacteria. That'll be later.
Actually, it appears that I've managed to force you to learn something new today. I told you that an amino acid sequence isn't genetic information and you've agreed with me in your second statement there yet you have the temerity to accuse me of ignorance? Wow. Talk about psychological projection.
Uyi Iredia: Look up the pat on B-cell hypermutations. By now it should be clear to you and anyone following this dicussion that your talk of gene duplications was bogus.
You're one funny guy. How does the part on B-cell hypermutations negate what I said? In fact, just after that heading, there is the heading "The Role of Gene Duplication" did you read it? Once again, your own references disagree with what you're saying.
Uyi Iredia: You should realize that what you think is implied is an assumption.
Simply look up what an implication is.
Uyi Iredia: This is a lazy cop-out. However, let's give you the benefit of a doubt. He doesn't exist (in the concrete sense). Now, how do uncaused things exist ?
Excellent. This of course means God either doesn't exist or exists in an abstract sense. Now on uncaused things, they simply exist pretty much as a brute fact. Especially when we consider that such things have been detected.
Uyi Iredia: Your 'evidence' described gravity as a force not as an attraction. It stated: Gravitation, universal force exercised by two bodies onto each other
Please tell me you're joking. Don't you know that attraction is a force? And that repulsion too is another force? Please go back to school and learn English.
Uyi Iredia: I did (especially in the thread Descendant of Apes) you rejected them with bad reasoning.
For some reason, you were unable to show the bad reasoning you're claiming here. Have you considered that it could be that you basically have nothing?
Uyi Iredia: so what ? In your example no assumption was made beforehand. Axiomatic has several definitions, one of them is that . In this regard it is clear that presuppositions are axiomatic.
You're saying rubbish again. What definition of axiomatic are you using? Or are you simply making one up?
Uyi Iredia: Another ignorant reply. Methodologies are usually based on philosophical position. In this case, its naturalism. Demonstrate how it makes no sense.
Another feeble-minded reply. If you understood what a methodology was, you would understand that your question is meaningless. Please take a look at what methodology means. Pay close attention to definition 1.
[quote author=Dictionary.com]1. a set or system of methods, principles, and rules for regulating a given discipline, as in the arts or sciences.
2. Philosophy . a. the underlying principles and rules of organization of a philosophical system or inquiry procedure. b. the study of the principles underlying the organization of the various sciences and the conduct of scientific inquiry.
3. Education . a branch of pedagogics dealing with analysis and evaluation of subjects to be taught and of the methods of teaching them.[/quote]
Uyi Iredia: Yes. Sometimes for the better, sometimes for worse. Bias isn't avoided it is part of any scientific endeavour.
Bias affects research for the better? Bias isn't avoided in science? My, my what mind numbing ignorance or falsehood. Please educate yourself on the scientific method. Read the beliefs and biases heading.
Uyi Iredia: It does hence your subsequent statements are redundant.
Did you even read the article on macroevolution?
Uyi Iredia: A straw man applies to an opponent's argument not yours hence your reason is asinine.
Another stultifyingly cretinous and imbecilic response. I said I wished to [b]avoid [/b]a straw man argument so I would like to have your own actual argument to address.
Uyi Iredia: Typical impertinent reply. The point in contention is that evolution covers abiogenesis which was attested to in the forwarded statement.
I've already pointed out to you that the theory of evolution says nothing about abiogenesis. Please look up what the theory of evolution is about and carefully read your own references.
Uyi Iredia: Present your explanation here for discussion. That was my condition.
You need some self education for that to be fruitful.
Uyi Iredia: * Not so because I have pointed out the found fossils can be interpreted differently. And the rarity of fossils is exactly why the fossil record can 't and shouldn't be used as evidence. It is a porous one.
This is a dumb response. You don't even seem to understand the two points I presented on the fossil evidence please read each of them properly then tell me, what do you think fossils show?
Uyi Iredia: * You are silly. I have pointed out why it is a fallacy. I repeat the reason again: It is a fallacy because it is based upon ignorance of a function. Knowledge of an unknown function (which could be major) would wipe out the assumption of vestigiality.
You are mentally deranged. Read up on what it means for an organ to be vestigial in biology.
Uyi Iredia: Engage in your self-delusions. You have countered nothing. If you have other evidence present them. Keep in mind that the evidence for common descent is not fact giving my choice of the best definition of the word.
I presented the broad headings, but you ran from them. Also, I already told you that your definition of fact is rubbish and presented you with evidence showing this.
Uyi Iredia: * Yes and so ? I have given my definitions twice. Your article is unnecessary since definitions change given contexts. If you aren't satisfied consult your dictionary.
No you haven't given a definition. That article is to show you how to present a definition and not the word substitution you've presented in your folly.
Uyi Iredia: * Clarify what you had in mind with these:
The cheetah and the wild cat share those similarities. Are they the same kind? Or are you still sticking with the fact that actual biologists have classified them as being in the same genus? I hope you realize that these classifications aren't set in stone.
What part of it confuses you?
Uyi Iredia: You are silly. I have pointed out my use of the word. I have given the contextual definition of the word (you asked what I meant by kinds) and its definition (as meant by creationists)
You are dumb and cretinous. Your use of the word is a substitution which incidentally doesn't tally with the idea of creationists that you referred me to is not a definition. Please educate yourself on proper definitions.
davidylan: and that something was? Your "evidence available" would be?
Carefully read what I said which was that your statement was meaningless.
davidylan: So essentially you place blind faith in an idea based on an alleged possibility of available evidence which itself also requires faith to believe? Good. Just as blind as a bat.
Please show me where you think I'm applying blind faith.