kemisuga:

java, if it was my last born, then he is wiser than u.

u lack proper reasoning. I'm sure you are over 20. That was too stupid a post. Muslims dont open their mouths in the toilets, it didnt say nose.

Im still hoping to find one Iota of sense in this rule.


Pity.

@Gamine: Please find a slaughter house or fish depot. Tell them to let you enter. When you get in, please open your mouth for just as long as you go to the toilet to sit! Then you will come out with a better undestanding. Plus the fact that your clothes and your skin will thank you for the wonderful experience yoy have taken them through!

java or script - So why are u annoyed? You started the stupid reply, isnt it.

I am sure u are one of those that carries religion on the head and not in the heart.

@Olabowale

So the people that work in those places dont talk

MAN! i dont get you oh!

They are used to the stench. Thats what i mean. Besides, these places are not the toilet. Remember?

Finally, do you work in the toilet, like the way the slaughter house people and or the Fish depot people do? They are used to the enviroment of their jobs. Are you now so desentitized to "Toilet," that you love it better than all the other places in your home?

Forget the smell of the dump for a moment. What about the enviroment? It is the place you put plungers, cleaning agents, etc. Or do you keep these things in your bedroom and only take it to the bathroom, toilet when you wanna clean the bathroom, toilet?

d£y might not talk, buh d£y wuld def. open their mouth!!

It all dpendz on d type of Sh!t o!!!

Mr MAllam.

i still no get your analogy ooh!

I am looking at my toilet right now

and still wondering why i shouldnt talk or open my mouth dia

You muslim pipu sef

na wa, na wa.

shaking my head!

Its a pity that you can take the man out of the pit latrine but you can't take the pit latrine out of the man. Some people and their brainwashing sha.


No wonder suicide bombers and excessive aggressiveness are the norm in some areas. Its a sign of being anally retentive- to some, even the thought of shitting itself must be from evil spirits. I'm sure there's a hadith explaining that.

The shit wey all of una dey scream over as if na another person own, no be from inside una intestine the thing dey come? If you like oh, don't even use the toilet at all, and keep the stuff inside. That's the easiest route to meet your maker and ask him why he didnt make you without a butthole.



Insects and microscopic objects wey dey inside the air everywhere- them tell you say them no dey pass microscopic faeces? If you no see am- does that mean e no dey there?

Even the carbondioxide you're breathing out is a waste product- any rules about that too? Likewise sweat is a waste product. You no wan sweat again?

Olabawale et al- once again I ask- are you still using pit latrine in this modern age. Because you sound as if you don't even clean your toilet sef, hence your insistence that all toilets must be dirty. I don't even want to imagine the state of the toilets in your home.

What you people fail to understand is that the ability and willingness or effort to clean up is the operative term here, not the demonizing of functions in your body that you still can't do without anyway. If you no shit you go die be that. Take it or leave it. You may prefer to die rather than shit anyway. na you sabi.

abeg if you hear satan talking to you in the toilet go see a mental health specialist.

tpia- thank you.

Why dnt u guys put aside religious sentiments then go ask a medic the likely effects of opening ur mouth in the toilet. . .Thats for Gamine & ksuga
as for u tpia, do u have such a shallow reasoning faculty? or u just refuse to make use of the intelligence which I beleive u have? Whats with the insult & all in ur above post? .You pointed out that the shit comes from inside u bla bla bla. . . . .Thats the dumbest point so far! If the shit comes from inside u, then u can as well go buy a potty and use it for excretion then wash it clean and use for eating at least the shit comes from inside you and the food is going right back inside you!

@kemisuga,

Your question was answered, then you resort to sarcasm. You are not a muslim, the rule pretty much does not govern you. What do you hope to gain by your post?

@tpia and Gamine,

You are not muslims, why does anyone owe it to you to explain the reason why muslims should not talk in the TOILET.

Please, Christian tpia and gamine, use your toothbrush to scrub your toilet, rinse (or maybe not), brush your teeth with it, rinse and repeat; all the while singing "songs of praises". hey, it's your party, knock yourselves out

@Tpia: « #40 on: Today at 03:10:54 PM »

na wa, na wa.

shaking my head!

dont shake too hard because you may break your neck!

Its a pity that you can take the man out of the pit latrine but you can't take the pit latrine out of the man. Some people and their brainwashing sha.

And Auckland, the city you now reside has not taught you any hygiene that it is not decent to go to the
toilet and just open your mouth without any cogent reason. A person going about with his mouth wide open,
will come back home with sore throad, or something. Definitely, such a person should not be surprised that
some bugs and flies are making the wide open mouth a hub! Germs will have a sure residence by that always
wide open mouth!

I bet you when you yawn, you do not cover your mouth. Thats dirty! A christian woman was just so surprised
that a person can be thinking that it is okay to just keep the mouth wide open. She even was using the idea
that one can just imagine a person who went to park to relax for 30 minutes. And all the while just kept the
mouth open! She wonders why would a person be using the toilet as the regular eating place? Thats even
a Christian woman sure that that is a wierd idea all the way.

No wonder suicide bombers and excessive aggressiveness are the norm in some areas. Its a sign of being anally retentive- to some, even the thought of shitting itself must be from evil spirits. I'm sure there's a hadith explaining that.

You are being ridiculous! Even your man god, performed this very anal function! If people are lump in in a general
characterization based on where they come from, you may be having a hard life in New Zealand because they will
thinking that you are about 419! You see how silly your thinking is.

The shit wey all of una dey scream over as if na another person own, no be from inside una intestine the thing dey come? If you like oh, don't even use the toilet at all, and keep the stuff inside. That's the easiest route to meet your maker and ask him why he didnt make you without a butthole.

Hear this Fela's baby brother! Diarrhea mouth man. No wonder you never close your mouth! Abeg comot for road!

Insects and microscopic objects wey dey inside the air everywhere- them tell you say them no dey pass microscopic faeces? If you no see am- does that mean e no dey there?

And opening your mouth like the door kept ajar will make everything easy in your case.

Even the carbondioxide you're breathing out is a waste product- any rules about that too? Likewise sweat is a waste product. You no wan sweat again?

Now you are injecting your own weirdness to everything. I know why I said i should leave you alone now.

Olabawale et al- once again I ask- are you still using pit latrine in this modern age. Because you sound as if you don't even clean your toilet sef, hence your insistence that all toilets must be dirty. I don't even want to imagine the state of the toilets in your home.

Listen to this danfo or molue or kiakia bus guy! He thinks that he got jokes!

What you people fail to understand is that the ability and willingness or effort to clean up is the operative term here, not the demonizing of functions in your body that you still can't do without anyway. If you no shit you go die be that. Take it or leave it. You may prefer to die rather than shit anyway. na you sabi.

I hope you will remember the failing to understand phrase, the next time you call a man god! Orisi risi!

abeg if you hear satan talking to you in the toilet go see a mental health specialist.

Safe it, man! Remember your fore bearers, Adam and Eve? You are not making any sense.
It is the Shaitan that is talking to you that is blocking you from reasoning very clearly!

You who call a man like you god wants to educate us about decency, especially when your
mouth is "Toilet."

You know, you just may have ended the justification for the no-open-mouth-in-the-toilet law by saying it is the law of Almighty Allah and that of his Propphet (PBUH), and ended it there. But you didn't. You went ahead to give a justification that should make thinking people question your reasoning:

olabowale wrote:

@Poster: Not talking in toilet, is more religious and also hygenic.
Religious because it is a commandment from Allah and or His Messenger (AS). There is benefit in obedience.
Opening of mouth is unnecessary if you are not talking or a firm need to do so. Otherwise, the opening of mouth
in or out of the toilet without any reason for it may actually provide good anenue for germs to invade the mouth!(Bold mine)

The statement in bold is unsound for a number of reasons. First off, it is irrelevant to the invasion of the mouth with germs whether or not it was necessary to open the mouth; stated differently: airborne germs are not sensitive to the necessity of opening the mouth; either they invade or not. Second - and more important - where is the support for the claim that germs invade the mouth when the mouth is opened in the toilet. Whether or not there are airborne germs in a toilet will involve several factors; do these matter at all? Could you reason this law out with one willing to follow your thinking? If you're not able to do that, then quit attempting to justify the law other than simply saying you will do anything you believe to the law of Almighty Allah and his Prophet (PBUH).
.

kemisuga:

java or script - So why are u annoyed? You started the stupid reply, isnt it.

I am sure u are one of those that carries religion on the head and not in the heart.

na u know. Whether I carry Islam on the head or in the heart, I'm not foolish as not to recognize a pointless post as urs

I dont know where, it is stated in the Holy Quaran, that I should not talk in toilet, can someone pls help?

The topic reads Muslims dont talk nor Open their mouths in Toilet . .is that so hard for people to understand?

If you do not understand the topic then its simple dont post. Its not by force to post on every topic

Thanks Babs for the hadith

kemisuga are you a muslim ?

Mukina, salam alaykum. . thought u moderators had gone for itikaf. it's been a while

@mukina2
kemisuga is most def not a muslimah, just check back a few posts!

Salaam sisters

i have been around

Ayinba i thought as much . .

How is fasting? and how are you both enjoying the last 10 days . .

Alhamdulillah! We are thankful for this blessed month.

I hope we all make the best of it

May Allah accept it from us AMIN

Salaam

Haha ha.

@Poster.

It dosnt apply to Christians.

God will not give us laws that dont make sense.

Thank You.

@Nimshi: #45 on: Today at 06:24:53 AM »

You know, you just may have ended the justification for the no-open-mouth-in-the-toilet law by saying it is the law of Almighty Allah and that of his Propphet (PBUH), and ended it there. But you didn't. You went ahead to give a justification that should make thinking people question your reasoning:

You are right. However the group of "thinking people," you will not be amongst then, based on your response below.

olabowale wrote:

Quote
@Poster: Not talking in toilet, is more religious and also hygenic.
Religious because it is a commandment from Allah and or His Messenger (AS). There is benefit in obedience.
Opening of mouth is unnecessary if you are not talking or a firm need to do so. Otherwise, the opening of mouth
in or out of the toilet without any reason for it may actually provide good anenue for germs to invade the mouth!(Bold mine)

The statement in bold is unsound for a number of reasons. First off, it is irrelevant to the invasion of the mouth with germs whether or not it was necessary to open the mouth; stated differently: airborne germs are not sensitive to the necessity of opening the mouth; either they invade or not. Second - and more important - where is the support for the claim that germs invade the mouth when the mouth is opened in the toilet. Whether or not there are airborne germs in a toilet will involve several factors; do these matter at all? Could you reason this law out with one willing to follow your thinking? If you're not able to do that, then quit attempting to justify the law other than simply saying you will do anything you believe to the law of Almighty Allah and his Prophet (PBUH).

Read my statement, again! I did not specified it to Toilet, alone. It was a general statement that opening mouth unnecessary for a long time (eg sleep on your back and open your mouth throughout the period of sleep. Say the 6 to 8 hours of sleep). A person may wake up with a sore throat. This does not mean that everyone who sleeps with his mouth open will have infections. Just like not everyone who smokes have cancer of the lungs. the way that not everyone who drink alcohol will have cancer of the liver!

The example that am going to use now is very gross. But you have forced my hand to do so. Yesterday, the christian woman who was talking to me while I was typing the response you responded to, brought up the famous pictures of the young children dying from the Ethiopian famines. You see the little children in the arms of their loving mothers, with amotherly concern for the life that was just about to pass away, unless food can be provided.

However what you see, always about these children, is that their mouths were opened and they are too tired, it seems to close them. You see the flies hovering around their mouths. Think for a second, why it is the mouth area, that you see the flies going to first? Afterall, the rest of the lower torso is probably completely naked or with just little amount of clothings.

If you wanna go about and experiment about it, please let us know how your health is after a whole week of night sleeps with your mouth ajar, all night long. I hope you will be sincere with us, because we do really want to know.

Whatver Allah and His Messemger say and or commanded on the believers is 100% practicable. I want you to test the opening of the mouth, for us. Maybe this will be your way of becoming a muslim, after you find that you wakeup with something you hadn't thought about.
.

abeg it applies only to the muslims

infact i enjoy singing to God wen im taking my bath,or pupuuing

but seriously its no sin to me abeg,wats wrong wt answering a call or singing in d toilet

The same way paradise, Al jannah applies only to Muslims. Enjoying your songs to the three gods.

[size=13pt]
Nairaland Muslims are very weird sha, i read where someone was saying how you should take so long in the bathroom you're kidding right, as for me i read in the bathroom and i don't see my dad complaining about it or telling me how I shouldn’t stay so long in the bathroom or telling me how is against the religion, and yes his an Alhaji.

@posters
The question you asked has nothing to do with the Muslims belief
Common sense should tell you, it is not hygiene to talk while excreting in the bathroom
[/size]

olabowale:

The same way paradise, Al jannah applies only to Muslims. Enjoying your songs to the three gods.

it depends on d god u is worshipping

i worship only one God,and that is d God of d bible,and wen i feel like worshipping him i do dat anywhere even in d toilet whilst taking my bath

if it is a sin in islam then its ur own religion's rules and regulations,but its definitely not a sin in xtianity

olabowale:

@Nimshi: #45 on: Today at 06:24:53 AM »
You are right. However the group of "thinking people," you will not be amongst then, based on your response below.

There you are, flaunting your foolishness.

The rest of your post deserves no response; your words were a waste of space and bandwidth: you clearly did not understand the meaning of the opinion you're posing to be against.

You're sth of a disgrace to Islam.
.

@troOE: « #57 on: Today at 06:33:12 PM »

Nairaland Muslims are very weird sha, i read where someone was saying how you should take so long in the bathroom you're kidding right, as for me i read in the bathroom and i don't see my dad complaining about it or telling me how I shouldn’t stay so long in the bathroom or telling me how is against the religion, and yes his an Alhaji.

MashaAllah. Hajj, though very important, is the last pillar of Islam. Knowledge, in Islam is also very important. Just because your father do not complain about it, it does mean that it is not worth mentioning. The authority in Islam, among mankind, was Muhammad (AS), alone!



@rampagain: « #58 on: Today at 07:00:18 PM »

it depends on d god u is worshipping

i worship only one God,and that is d God of d bible,and when i feel like worshipping him i do that anywhere even in d toilet whilst taking my bath

But between god the son (Please count it with me), and god the ghost (Please not that is another god from the New Testament viewpoint) and god the father (Please note that this is the last god, according to the Protestants, but the catholics never stop praying to a mother god, Mary), which one is the real God, the One One God you are talking about!?

if it is a sin in islam then its ur own religion's rules and regulations,but its definitely not a sin in xtianity

You did not hear anybody say that it was a sin. A suggestion in Islam is not always a sin! When Allah did not put cousins as one of the people a person can marry, it does not mean that a person who does not marry a cousin is a sinner!

This here is one serious discussion
abi shit business no be big business again?

anyways ill find it really funny for someone to open his/her mouth in the toilet without reason when its not as if the mouth has lost its latching properties

but hey does that mean you dont recieve calls in the bathroom?

i really dont see any reason to bring religion into this, if you keep your bathroom in a pristine state, you should have nothing to fear from your air, but if your do-do room is like a public toilet, you'd better close not just your mouth but your nostrils,even your ears and any other orifice in your body.
if it just about foul or vile air, then most mouths should be firmly shut in most markets and bus stops.
so its all about hygiene not religion!
afterall some mouths harbor bacteria that will make an agar pot envious!

@

olabowale:



 
@rampagain: « #58 on: Today at 07:00:18 PM » 
But between god the son (Please count it with me), and god the ghost (Please not that is another god from the New Testament viewpoint) and god the father (Please note that this is the last god, according to the Protestants, but the catholics never stop praying to a mother god, Mary), which one is the real God, t[b]he One One God you are talking about!?[/b]


You did not hear anybody say that it was a sin. A suggestion in Islam is not always a sin! When Allah did not put cousins as one of the people a person can marry, it does not mean that a person who does not marry a cousin is a sinner!

   

d God im talking about is d same one known as :


the I AM THAT I AM in d bible

the BEGINNING AND THE END

the ROSE OF SHARON

the FIRST AND THE LAST

the OMNIPOTENT;OMNISCIENCE AND OMNIPRESENT GOD

the ONE THAT SITTETH IN THE HEAVENLIES AND MAKES THE EARTH HIS FOOTSTOOL

the LION OF THE TRIBE OF JUDEA

the LILY OF THE VALLEY

the MERCIFUL AND SAME TIME CONSUMING FIRE GOD

the one THAT KNOWS THE END AND AFTER THE END

the MIGHTY GOD IS HIS NAME


now thats the God im talking about,

na wa oh!

all this injecting religion into everything from toilet to the right way to cut your fingernails and the wrong way to remove lice from your head, is what makes for all this repressed anger and discontent that breeds suicide bombers and professional fatwa pronouncers.

anally retentive! Making minor issues into major things!

I really don't know why fanatical Arabs and Orthodox Jews don't get along. They have so much in common especially when it comes to all these kinds of issues. One of the reasons why Jesus lambasted the Pharisees too, over rigid protocols and the like.  What goes in always comes out at the other end- as simple as that and no need for fancy bamboozling just to get people frustrated. Or due to the difficulty of keeping the toilet clean!

reindeer:

This here is one serious discussion
abi shit business no be big business again?

anyways ill find it really funny for someone to open his/her mouth in the toilet without reason when its not as if the mouth has lost its latching properties

but hey does that mean you don't recieve calls in the bathroom?

[b]i really don't see any reason to bring religion into this, if you keep your bathroom in a pristine state, you should have nothing to fear from your air, but if your do-do room is like a public toilet, you'D better close not just your mouth but your nostrils,even your ears and any other orifice in your body.
if it just about foul or vile air, then most mouths should be firmly shut in most markets and bus stops.
so its all about hygiene not religion![/b]afterall some mouths harbor bacteria that will make an agar pot envious!

That is all oh!

Dont know why all the angels, archangels and hadiths have to be brought in!