Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,152,222 members, 7,815,276 topics. Date: Thursday, 02 May 2024 at 10:03 AM

Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? - Car Talk - Nairaland

Nairaland Forum / Nairaland / General / Car Talk / Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? (12643 Views)

***Grimaldi, AES Or Hoegh: Which Is Faster? Which Is Safer?*** / Trip From Abuja To Enugu & Anambra With My 505 V6 (1,505 Km/935 Miles) / My Peugeot 505 V6 5sp Stalls & Emits Black Smoke Under Heavy Acceleration. Help! (2) (3) (4)

(1) (2) (3) (4) (Reply) (Go Down)

Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 2:58am On Jul 20, 2014
Try and be a good sport and don't cheat. I know it'll be hard not to cheat for some amongst us grin

Also try to explain your reasoning on which one you think is safer.

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by GAZZUZZ(m): 9:04am On Jul 20, 2014
We all know where this will lead let me take a front seat.

3 Likes

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 9:11am On Jul 20, 2014
I'm not sure which is safer, since I haven't driven either in 9 years.

I do know however, which my choice would be. The Toyota Corolla AE86 RWD is a potent performer, and for an engine that displaces a mere 1.6 litres, really revvy, and nice to drive. I would have one tomorrow, at the right price.

One went through auction last August, for an eye-watering £6,877!

Very well sought-after.

2 Likes

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 9:12am On Jul 20, 2014
Brother Gazzuzz, what you've posted here could be seen as SPAM. It has NO relationship to this thread, unless you posted it here in error?

1 Like

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 9:34am On Jul 20, 2014
Make I park here...@op define your meaning of safe....

1 Like

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by DECOtech(m): 10:51am On Jul 20, 2014
The 1988 Peogut 505. I believe that the heavier a car is, the safer. Though not all heavy vehicles are safe.
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 11:10am On Jul 20, 2014
DECOtech: The 1988 Peogut 505. I believe that the heavier a car is, the safer. Though not all heavy vehicles are safe.

Not strictly true, bro. Newer cars are actually often lighter than their predecessors, yet safer. There are several factors that make any given car safer.

Body shell rigidity.
Seam welds.
Impact beams.
Suspension set-up.
Brakes.
Aerodynamics.
Crumple zones.
Battery location.
Fuel tank location.
Dashboard / fascia.

I didn't mention ABS or airbags here, because I'm looking more at passive safety.

1 Like

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by DECOtech(m): 11:41am On Jul 20, 2014
Siena:

Not strictly true, bro. Newer cars are actually often lighter than their predecessors, yet safer. There are several factors that make any given car safer.

Body shell rigidity.
Seam welds.
Impact beams.
Suspension eat-up.
Brakes.
Aerodynamics.
Crumple zones.
Battery location.
Fuel tank location.
Dashboard / fascia.

I didn't mention ABS or airbags here, because I'm looking more at passive safety.
I believe you sir. however, my comment was based on comparison between the 88 Peugeot and the 88 corolla. Obviously, the 505 feels more rigid than the corolla. Though when it comes to braking distance, I wld go for the corolla. But generally, its my opinion that the 505 is safer than the corolla until I'm convinced otherwise.
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 3:52pm On Jul 20, 2014
smartchoice: Make I park here...@op define your meaning of safe....

An astute question.

Safe, in automotive arena, generally means the car protects the occupants. Example, "oh don't worry that van is safe to put your family in".

1 Like

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 3:59pm On Jul 20, 2014
Siena:

Not strictly true, bro. Newer cars are actually often lighter than their predecessors, yet safer. There are several factors that make any given car safer.

Body shell rigidity.
Seam welds.
Impact beams.
Suspension set-up.
Brakes.
Aerodynamics.
Crumple zones.
Battery location.
Fuel tank location.
Dashboard / fascia.

I didn't mention ABS or airbags here, because I'm looking more at passive safety.

Absolutely on point.

ABS and Air Bags are secondary safety items, IMHO. Accidents have been recorded here in the US where the airbag did not go off and also low speed parking lot accidents where airbags went off like pop corns.

So the basic shell itself, location of key components (Ford Pinto would explode from a slight rear end accident because there is a bolt that gets pushed from the bumper straight into the gas tank causing explosion in as little as 5 mph crash), materials used (all metal dashboard versus plastic materials) (pointed logo - Rolls Royce flying lady is not sprung), choice of tires, etc etc

The airbags keeps the occupants from getting knocked out mostly but it won't stop a poorly designed A pillar from decapitating the occupants.

Roof crush and doors opening is even slight crash are my favorite. It's amazing when I watch those Russian car crashes, some of those cars are complete death traps. There was one episode where the driver was summarily ejected and you can see that he even had his seatbelt on.
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:16pm On Jul 20, 2014
Okay the answer is:

The Corolla is the safest and by an outstandingly wide margin. Actually the 505 i sone of the most dangerous vehicles tested in the 1980s.

Source: http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=1314&dat=19880406&id=j1pWAAAAIBAJ&sjid=mu8DAAAAIBAJ&pg=5386,3313433

I'll find the official test from the US government agency in charge of automotive tests, NHTSA (does Nigeria have one?). The lower the number the better.

Peugeot 505 (driver/passenger) = 1701/1457
Toyota Corolla (driver/passenger) = 593/397
Toyota Tercel (driver/passenger) = 1005/398
Nissan Maxima (driver/passenger) = 907/861
Pontiac Le Mans (driver/passenger) = 819/897

So in any crash people will get hurt to some degree, but the 505 driver will have three times the injury of the driver in the Corolla. It could easily be the difference of walking away from an accident and hitching a ride back home or being in traction and coma for months.

Have I owned a 505 = yes, will I own another = depends. While I won't go looking for one but if I should see one in mint condition and ridiculously low priced I would consider buying it.

So what is the intent of this thread?

There is a reason that I recommend Toyota as a brand to people that ask on NL. If anyone takes time to read the beginning of Toyota and their philosophy (including how they created Lexus 400 which basically beat Mercedes and BMW at the luxury game that they have dominated for decades) they will see a company that is fastidious with designing safe small compact vehicles. The MR2 (2nd gen) is another example of the Toyota brilliance of that era (when it came out there were no test drives and there was a $5-$7k premium on the cars) that's who hot it was.

Anyway thats the data, we are all free to interpret it.

1 Like

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:25pm On Jul 20, 2014
Additional reading materials:

http://www.multinationalmonitor.org/hyper/issues/1990/01/dunlap.html The Audi 100 is the safest vehicle in the world, in that era.

Some quotes in case MB is low on your phones.

Audi earned exemplary test results, it took out full page ads, crowing about its score. Auto writers also touted the results, and based on one score an Audi dealer proclaimed the Audi 100 to be the "safest car in the world." "Auto manufacturers can't have it both ways," says Ditlow. "The results are meaningful when Audi does well, and they are equally valid when Peugeot does poorly."

To those familiar with the company's history, it comes as no surprise that Peugeot lags behind when it comes to safety. Protecting drivers and passengers has never been a priority for the manufacturer, critics charge. Dr. Antione Chapdelaine, an injury prevention expert at Enfant Jesus Hopital in Quebec City, Canada, observes that "Peugeot is behind not only in engineering. It is behind in philosophy."

In 1979, Peugeot registered the worst score in the entire 10-year crash test history. The driver-side dummy recorded an impact over four-and- one-half times the force likely to cause severe brain injury or death. Out of 10 Peugeot 35-mph-crash-test results, nine were disasters, with dummies in the front seats suffering impacts severe enough to kill humans. In 1988, and again in 1989, Peugeot registered the worst results in its class, and by far the worst results among all passenger cars tested.

Even when NHTSA re-tested the 1988 model at only 30 mph, with crash forces one-third less than at 35 mph, the belted driver-side dummy's head and face still struck the steering wheel with considerable force.

1 Like

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:29pm On Jul 20, 2014
Associated press AP is this not one of the papers that incriminated Saddam Hussein? Libya's Gaddafi and a host of others..,well the test is subjective and I will like a French test result not American!

1 Like

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:37pm On Jul 20, 2014
smartchoice: Associated press AP is this not one of the papers that incriminated Saddam Hussein? Libya's Gaddafi and a host of others..,well the test is subjective and I will like a French test result not American!

Fair enough. Please create a thread when you're done so we can learn.

Meanwhile:

"The AP is one of the largest and most trusted sources of independent newsgathering, supplying a steady stream of news to its members, international subscribers and commercial customers. AP is neither privately owned nor government-funded; instead, as a not-for-profit news cooperative owned by its American newspaper and broadcast members, it can maintain its single-minded focus on newsgathering and its c[b]ommitment to the highest standards of objective, accurate journalism.[/b]

AP’s commitment to independent, comprehensive journalism has deep roots. Founded in 1846, AP has covered all the major news events of the past 165 years, providing high-quality, informed reporting of everything from wars and elections to championship games and royal weddings.

Today, AP employs the latest technology to collect and distribute content. It is in the process of overhauling its video and photography content: transitioning to high-definition, expanding its coverage and building a new, flexible, powerful infrastructure. AP has the industry’s most sophisticated digital photo network; a 24-hour continuously updated online, multimedia news service; a state-of-the-art television news service; and one of the largest radio networks in the U.S. Its commercial digital photo archive is one of the world's largest collections of historical and contemporary imagery. AP Mobile, the AP’s award-winning news app, has been downloaded over 9 million times since its launch in 2008, and AP has a strong social media presence, building new connections between AP and its members, customers and consumers.

Since the Pulitzer Prize was established, in 1917, AP has received 51 Pulitzers, including 31 photo Pulitzers.

AP, which is headquartered in New York, operates in more than 280 locations worldwide, including every statehouse in the U.S. Two-thirds of its staffers are journalists."

http://www.ap.org
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:40pm On Jul 20, 2014
Wow. This makes sobering reading.
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:42pm On Jul 20, 2014
City NG while am not attacking your person am not comfortable with your one track perspective to the issue at hand..
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:46pm On Jul 20, 2014
Siena: Wow. This makes sobering reading.

Oga Gbudje it will be nice of you to give us an European perspective to the issue at hand....your wow does little to educate we your followers on this section.
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:48pm On Jul 20, 2014
CityNG:

Fair enough. Please create a thread when you're done so we can learn.

Meanwhile:

"The AP is one of the largest and most trusted sources of independent newsgathering, supplying a steady stream of news to its members, international subscribers and commercial customers. AP is neither privately owned nor government-funded; instead, as a not-for-profit news cooperative owned by its American newspaper and broadcast members, it can maintain its single-minded focus on newsgathering and its c[b]ommitment to the highest standards of objective, accurate journalism.[/b]

AP’s commitment to independent, comprehensive journalism has deep roots. Founded in 1846, AP has covered all the major news events of the past 165 years, providing high-quality, informed reporting of everything from wars and elections to championship games and royal weddings.

Today, AP employs the latest technology to collect and distribute content. It is in the process of overhauling its video and photography content: transitioning to high-definition, expanding its coverage and building a new, flexible, powerful infrastructure. AP has the industry’s most sophisticated digital photo network; a 24-hour continuously updated online, multimedia news service; a state-of-the-art television news service; and one of the largest radio networks in the U.S. Its commercial digital photo archive is one of the world's largest collections of historical and contemporary imagery. AP Mobile, the AP’s award-winning news app, has been downloaded over 9 million times since its launch in 2008, and AP has a strong social media presence, building new connections between AP and its members, customers and consumers.

Since the Pulitzer Prize was established, in 1917, AP has received 51 Pulitzers, including 31 photo Pulitzers.

AP, which is headquartered in New York, operates in more than 280 locations worldwide, including every statehouse in the U.S. Two-thirds of its staffers are journalists."

http://www.ap.org

Culled from their web and you expect them to give a not so impressive account of themselves abi?
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:50pm On Jul 20, 2014
smartchoice: City NG while am not attacking your person am not comfortable with your one track perspective to the issue at hand..

Thank you, I understand where you are coming from.

Is there any untruths that I have posted? Have I embellished any facts presented? Have I not listed a credible source?

I am willing to learn (only a fool will think he knows it all or have all the answers). Please correct me if I have misstated any thing.

I am a dual citizen of the US and Nigeria (I live in both places, not visiting but actually living), I write from the experiences of an American and a Nigerian, unfortunately not as a French because I've never lived there (just vacated there).

Do you know one of the top 5 vehicles on my bucket list?

Renault R5

I have no agenda other than to "car talk".

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:53pm On Jul 20, 2014
smartchoice:

Culled from their web and you expect them to give a not so impressive account of themselves abi?

I do actually expect them to give an accurate, if impressive account of themselves.

They have done nothing in 30 years that I've been reading them to impress me with less than stellar news worthiness.

A question for you: What do you think the AP does?

ALL, and I mean ALL, US news agencies quote from the AP. ALL, and I mean ALL, US TV stations quote from the AP.

The AP is one of the few news agencies with offices in the WhiteHouse http://www.ap.org/Content/Press-Release/2013/AP-names-Julie-Pace-White-House-correspondent
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:55pm On Jul 20, 2014
CityNG:

Thank you, I understand where you are coming from.

Is there any untruths that I have posted? Have I embellished any facts presented? Have I not listed a credible source?

I am willing to learn (only a fool will think he knows it all or have all the answers). Please correct me if I have misstated any thing.

I am a dual citizen of the US and Nigeria (I live in both places, not visiting but actually living), I write from the experiences of an American and a Nigerian, unfortunately not as a French because I've never lived there (just vacated there).

Do you know one of the top 5 vehicles on my bucket list?

Renault R5

I have no agenda other than to "car talk".


Same here just to car talk but I will like to know what the French were thinking of when they rolled out the vehicle
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 4:57pm On Jul 20, 2014
CityNG:

I do actually expect them to give an accurate, if impressive account of themselves.

They have done nothing in 30 years that I've been reading them to impress me with less than stellar news worthiness.

A question for you: What do you think the AP does?

News but from which perspective?
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 5:19pm On Jul 20, 2014
smartchoice:

Same here just to car talk but I will like to know what the French were thinking of when they rolled out the vehicle

Please don't get me wrong.

The Peugeot 505 is not in the same league as a Trabant http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trabant

What brought this on was I was watching one of my Nigerian videos last night (I usually mount my Contour Camera on the windshield when I drive). I was riding with a friend in Ibadan inside his Toyota Corolla (not an FX but same body style). A driver in a 505 who wanted to pass us in traffic said "Ode gbe pangolo e kuro lona" = Remove your tin can from the road.

So low and behold my friends pangolo is actually safer than his almighty 505 grin

1 Like

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 5:24pm On Jul 20, 2014
smartchoice:

News but from which perspective?

From the one I and others like me who appreciate news worthiness appreciates.

AP doesn't create, nor tests vehicles, nor write vehicle safety laws. They just report on it and thankfully.
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 5:33pm On Jul 20, 2014
smartchoice: Oga Gbudje it will be nice of you to give us an European perspective to the issue at hand....your wow does little to educate we your followers on this section.

I am actually more surprised that the Peugeot 505 scored so badly in terms of safety, compared to the much smaller (and thin-steel) Toyota.

I have owned both Peugeot and 2 Toyota. A 1986 Peugeot 505 STI, 1985 Toyota Celica, 1981 Toyota Carina Estate and 1986 Toyota Celica Supra.

The Peugeot felt much more substantial than my 3 Toyota. But there you go - proof that weight and size do NOT automatically equate to safer. I am a Euro fan, and don't care much for Japanese wheels, but the facts speak for themselves.

Here in the UK, French cars tend to lag behind the other Euro offerings, and even Japanese models, with Citroen being the cheapest, and Renault the most expensive. Gasoline-engined PSA cars are extremely poor sellers here, with diesel-engined models making up approx. 80% of sales. Gassers are almost worthless used, even a nice clean 6-year-old 407 gasser can be had for very little money, despite bristling with options.

If I were to pick a Peugeot model today, my choices would be, in no particular order:

1) Peugeot 504 GL.
2) Peugeot 505 V6.
3) Peugeot 604 GL.
4) Peugeot 403 Cabriolet.
5) Peugeot 404.

I would NOT touch a modern FWD Peugeot. Nothing to do with reliability, but more to do with their ultra-thin steel bodies, which do not inspire me with any degree of confidence.

4 Likes

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 5:56pm On Jul 20, 2014
Driven To Write
Motoring Matters …………. Or Does It?

SearchMain menu
Skip to primary content
Driven to Explain
Monthly Themes
Was Then …
… Is Now
Print The Legend
Galleries
Featured
The Archie Vicar Archive
We Like / We Link
Post navigation← PreviousNext →
1979 Peugeot 505 Review 2
Posted on 2 November 2013 by richard herriott
Point Counterpoint



Archie Vicar muses on the meaning of Peugeot´s exciting new saloon, the 505.

“Drivers & Motorists Monthly” (February 1979).

Photo by Crispin Darling

The keenly contested large car sector is very profitable. 2.46 million large cars were bought in Europe in 1976. Manufacturers pick different weapons with which to capture these customers. Ford uses keen pricing and generous specifications to help the set-square Granada find its customers (300,000 a year!). Vauxhall tries to offer reassuring safe handling and predictability. Citroen insist wild-eyed technology and futuristic styling will be the way forward for the CX. Renault offer us mystery and confusion in the form of the ancient 16 or the purposeless 30. Rover suggest brash Brummie modernism with their rakish 2000 and 2600.

Into this hard-fought fray drives the new 505 from the Lion Marque. What is its unique atttraction? It´s a bit early to say.


Attacking it from another angle: the Peugeot 604, as many readers know, is a very fine saloon. We pitted it (October `77) against the Citroen CX 2400 Pallas, Ford´s Granada 2.8 V6 and the Mercedes 230E and it claimed first prize. It is is more spacious than the Granada, more pleasing to drive than the Mercedes (by a wide margin) and more agile and wieldy than the CX, and cheaper too. Hence the puzzlement I experienced when looking at the 505 in Orly airport carpark. It´s 6 inches shorter than the 604 but is much cheaper. It would appear to compete with the 604 since anyone who likes that car (and well they might) may find the 505 to be (nearly) the same but better (in some ways). That said, 505 still not as well made as the Mercedes, not as cheap as the Granada and not as daft as the CX (nothing is, to be frank). The only people who will worry about the Peugeot 505 are the fellows who try to make a living selling the Peugeot 604. Perhaps it would have been better either to fit a 2-litre motor into the 604 and forget the 505 or else make a V6 available in the 505 and pension off the 604. Nobody seems to want it, sadly.


Peugeot 604: excellent but unwanted

After a hearty lunch during the test drive, I stood under an awning and I stared at the car while enjoying a few filterless Gauloises. I looked at rain drops beading on the 505´s bronze metallic paint (an extra cost option). Pininfarina have styled the car (I wouldn´t let Peugeot near such a delicate job). It doesn´t look very Italian nor very French. Nor very German. Nor British. But it does look as if Peugeot have worked hard to make the car look cheaper than the 604. Remember that the 505´s predecessor, the 504, had an outstanding ride. I took a British-market model on a hard charging drive across the green lanes of the Chilterns. The impacts were well supressed and the car veritably floated over the undulations and potholes. I concluded that the 505 is as good as the 504 (but no better). One could say that merely by meeting the standard set by the 504, the 505 is still well-ahead of its peers. But in the increasingly competitive world of motoring, it´s hard to feel that good is good enough. And recall that Peugeot owns Citroen who make the succulently-suspended CX which has the softest and most compliant ride of all.


Peugeot 504: still good

And so we arrive (painfully) at the conclusion. Only by driving this car car across the whole of southern Britain that one can understand it. It is not charming. It will not soothe you nor stir your emotions. Nor will it flatter your good taste, for its styling maintains a reserve of deepest inscrutability. If you wish to enjoy high performance then similarly priced sports saloons from Alfa can best most models in the range. The Lancia Beta offers a more eloquent tiller. Ford can sell you a more comprehensible saloon. If you value French flavour, the CX is roquefort to the Peugeot´s bland port salut. Rover´s Stilton is yet more pungent. Drivers of German machines will assume the Peugeot is not as well assembled (actually it is). The 505 provides a better ride and handling compromise than either BMW´s nervous, over-priced 518 or Benz´s dull taxis (which neither ride nor handle but offer a lifetime of ill-informed self-satisfaction). And so we are still arriving at the conclusion. For every point there is a counterpoint, and for everything the 505 does quite well (and it does much) there is another car that does that one thing slightly better (or differently). What the 505 does well, it does so imperceptibly, and this particular quality is the essence of the car. Peugeot will still sell hundreds of thousands of examples of the 505 (and nobody will notice).

SHARE THIS:
TwitterFacebookGoogle

RELATED
1979 Peugeot 505 Review 1
In "The Archie Vicar Archive"
Something Rotten In Denmark: 1986 Peugeot 505
In "... Is Now"
Transitions : Car Interiors as They Turned Plastic
In "Was Then ..."
This entry was posted in The Archie Vicar Archive and tagged 0 replies, headlamps, leave a comment, leave a reply, Peugeot 504, Peugeot 505, Peugeot 604 by richard herriott. Bookmark the permalink.

About richard herriott

I like anchovies. I dislike post-war town planning.
View all posts by richard herriott →
ONE THOUGHT ON “1979 PEUGEOT 505 REVIEW 2”
Pingback: Something Rotten In Denmark: 1986 Peugeot 505 | Driven To Write

Leave a Reply
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Name *

Email *

Website

Comment



Notify me of follow-up comments via email.

Notify me of new posts via email.

Customized Twenty Eleven Theme. | Blog at .
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 6:16pm On Jul 20, 2014
Siena:

I am actually more surprised that the Peugeot 505 scored so badly in terms of safety, compared to the much smaller (and thin-steel) Toyota.

I have owned both Peugeot and 2 Toyota. A 1986 Peugeot 505 STI, 1985 Toyota Celica, 1981 Toyota Carina Estate and 1986 Toyota Celica Supra.

The Peugeot felt much more substantial than my 3 Toyota. But there you go - proof that weight and size do NOT automatically equate to safer. I am a Euro fan, and don't care much for Japanese wheels, but the facts speak for themselves.

Here in the UK, French cars tend to lag behind the other Euro offerings, and even Japanese models, with Citroen being the cheapest, and Renault the most expensive. Gasoline-engined PSA cars are extremely poor sellers here, with diesel-engined models making up approx. 80% of sales. Gasses are almost worthless used, even a nice clean 6-year-old 407 gasser can be had for very little money, despite bristling with options.

If I were to pick a Peugeot model today, my choices would be, in no particular order:

1) Peugeot 504 GL.
2) Peugeot 504 V6.
3) Peugeot 604 GL.
4) Peugeot 403 Cabriolet.
5) Peugeot 404.

I would NOT touch a modern FWD Peugeot. Nothing to do with reliability, but more to do with their ultra-thin steel bodies, which do not inspire me with any degree of confidence.

Oga Siena but I bet that you'll give this two samples due reconsideration's if only for a couple of track days grin

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 6:18pm On Jul 20, 2014
Smartchoice, what news agency do you recommend for me to read that you consider unbiased?

I'm willing to give it a try.

Thanks.
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 6:21pm On Jul 20, 2014
Lol, CityNG. As I've stated in previous posts, the only Japanese offerings I like are Sport Coupè and Trucks. Family sedans, a big no-no.

The Nissan Skyline R33 and R34 are formidable weapons.
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 6:29pm On Jul 20, 2014
smartchoice:

Same here just to car talk but I will like to know what the French were thinking of when they rolled out the vehicle

Sorry but I had to go back to this for a sec.

It is my opinion that Peugeot was and is still arrogant as far as US and her safety requirements were concerned.

The US auto market welcomes all brands but you have to adhere and pass our stringent safety rules. When you compare some cars, it is not unusual to find the US versions weighing up to 500 pounds more (two grown adults) due to addition of extra required safety measures (5mph bumpers, etc) or having less potent engines installed in them for safety (that I do not believe is necessary but there it is). There is a market for JDM (Japanese Domestic Market) parts here in the US. The Honda Accord/Civic enthusiast usually import Japanese version of the engines offered in the same vehicles from Japan. Why? The Japanese version sometimes have up to 100hp more. And is usually a direct bolt on with a few electronics extra units installed.

Peugeot could and should have simple followed other manufacturers of that era and installed at least a drivers side airbag and address other safety concerns (do you know that the Canadian 505s had to have their gas tanks relocated in order to be importable to Canada). Nigerian 505s have the gas tanks aft of the rear axle which is totally unacceptable in a rear end crash. The US is a free market and we have choices. No one will go and buy a Peugeot back then when there are safer cars available.

So Peugeot was arrogant, they did not bend to the will of the market and they had themselves to blame. FIAT is back in the US and doing exceedingly well, I see them all over the place and some are all tarted up quite nice. I hardly see SMART cars as an example.

So the French were thinking well when they released the vehicle (it still has a timeless and classy look to it) but they did not respond to the demands of the market.
Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by abatically(m): 6:44pm On Jul 20, 2014
Wow, a Peugeot thread and somebody decided to go silent. UNBELIEVABLE.

3 Likes

Re: Quiz: Which Is Safer, 1988 Peugeot 505 GLX Or 1988 Toyota Corolla FX? by Nobody: 7:42pm On Jul 20, 2014
CityNG: Smartchoice, what news agency do you recommend for me to read that you consider unbiased?

I'm willing to give it a try.

Thanks.


Buhahaha you wan jam be that o....try Biafra radio

1 Like

(1) (2) (3) (4) (Reply)

What Is Wrong With Mazda Cars} / 22 Car Parts That Are Related To The Human Body / How To Avoid Truck Accidents

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 95
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.