Android22:
I am a city fan. I know the game you are referring to. Salah goal from half way out? Praise Salah for the goal. The ball was at the half way line.

who made the clearance?

Expert17:


Pep is not double-tongued, he will always pick Messi as his best talent/player, and Busquets as the best DM.... nothing will change this fact

You know him but some people don't.

Android22:
I was going to mention that but I did not want people to say "what did you expect him to say?"

Nah.. I don't think that will work with Pep. There are certain players he can never change his opinion about. Messi, Busquest and Ederson probably, would always rank first.

Android22:
You're changing the argument. Everybody makes mistakes. You cannot point to 2 let alone 1 with Ederson's legs that led to a goal.

That’s not what I read.

I saw someone wrote he has never made a mistake with his legs.

When the correct statement should have been the mistakes he makes with his feet have never been punished.

neztar:
who made the clearance?

He did. What is your point?

Illimitable:


That’s not what I read.

I saw someone wrote he has never made a mistake with his legs.

When the correct statement should have been the mistakes he makes with his feet have never been punished.

Can you make reference to the quote?

Illimitable:


That’s Pep’s opinion and what works for his style of play.

Ederson won’t be in my top 10 of the best goalkeepers in Europe. We are discussing his legs instead of his hands. Why is he even in a conversation of the best goalies?

Dean Henderson is a better shot stopper than Ederson.

The topic was "the best ball playing GK/legs" not "the best GK/hands".

Ederson is the GOAT in this category, ahead of Neuer and Ter Stegen.

And for the general goalkeeping, Ederson will make Europe's top 15.

Illimitable:


That’s Pep’s opinion and what works for his style of play.

Ederson won’t be in my top 10 of the best goalkeepers in Europe. We are discussing his legs instead of his hands. Why is he even in a conversation of the best goalies?

Dean Henderson is a better shot stopper than Ederson.

thank you my brother. Ederson is to what david luiz is in defence

Expert17:


The topic was "the best ball playing GK/legs" not "the best GK/hands".

Ederson is the GOAT in this category, ahead of Neuer and Ter Stegen.

And for the general goalkeeping, Ederson will make Europe's top 15.

Of course, he is top 15. Better at PKs than De Gea. Great at sweeping. Very press-resistant. Very calm. Just that some Keepers are better with their hands. That PSG main GK for e.g is arse with his legs and that is a big problem for them.

Wonder why people are trying to downplay the role keepers have to do with their legs.

Expert17:


The topic was "the best ball playing GK/legs" not "the best GK/hands".

Ederson is the GOAT in this category, ahead of Neuer and Ter Stegen.

And for the general goalkeeping, Ederson will make Europe's top 15.

We can both agree on top 15.

Android22:
Can you make reference to the quote?

You said his mistakes with his legs are zero but there are plenty of mistakes with his legs on YouTube.

It’s just that those mistakes weren’t punished but they were mistakes regardless.

Illimitable:


We can both agree on top 15.



You said his mistakes with his legs are zero but there are plenty of mistakes with his legs on YouTube.

It’s just that those mistakes weren’t punished but they were mistakes regardless.

I meant mistakes leading to goals. How can I say he has never made a mistake? Even Harry Kane has had his PKs saved.

Illimitable:


We can both agree on the top 15.



You said his mistakes with his legs are zero but there are plenty of mistakes with his legs on YouTube.

It’s just that those mistakes weren’t punished but they were mistakes regardless.

If they are not errors leading to goals then it's useless

You remembered what happened when DDG tried to play from the back against Brentford

neztar:
thank you my brother. Ederson is to what david luiz is in defence

Alisson is the better keeper overall. He has at least 8/10 in every goalkeeping attribute.

Ederson has 9/10 with his feet but he’s average in every other goalkeeping attribute but Pep doesn’t mind. Ederson’s good footballing ability suits Pep just fine cos he’s going to hug possession 80% of the time anyway.

Opponents will have to make every chance count to get the better of Pep. They will have to produce 2 or 3 goals with their 20% possession which is very very rare and Pep is fine with that low probability than getting an actual goalkeeper.

Android22:
He did. What is your point?

he made a mistake which led to a goal

Expert17:


The topic was "the best ball playing GK/legs" not "the best GK/hands".

Ederson is the GOAT in this category, ahead of Neuer and Ter Stegen.

And for the general goalkeeping, Ederson will make Europe's top 15.

Boss Ter Stegen is the better ball playing GK, That's the main reason why he's not been moved on despite his past pure shot saving turbulent years, There's not been a suitable option found who's also also as good with his feet, He even uses his both feet effectively

Expert17:


If they are not errors leading to goals then it's useless

You remembered what happened when DDG tried to play from the back against Brentford

I have told you many times, that wasn’t a De Gea mistake. It was Eriksen’s mistake. De Gea passed to Eriksen, Eriksen got the ball and his pass to another defender was intercepted.

Illimitable:


I have told you many times, that wasn’t a De Gea mistake. It was Eriksen’s mistake. De Gea passed to Eriksen, Eriksen got the ball and his pass to another defender was intercepted.

Nah, it was De Gea's error he passed to a red zone and an already marked player

What am I reading? Neuer is the one who revolutionalized goalkeeping with his ball playing and sweeping ability. Perfect combination of shot stopping with ball playing and sweeping ability. Ederson has nothing on him.

Expert17:

Nah, it was De Gea's error he passed to a red zone and an already marked player

It wasn’t a red zone, Eriksen wasn’t strong enough.

OPTA had it as Eriksen’s error.

DDG completed a pass.

Illimitable:


I have told you many times, that wasn’t a De Gea mistake. It was Eriksen’s mistake. De Gea passed to Eriksen, Eriksen got the ball and his pass to another defender was intercepted.

But you are trying to downplay the role Keepers play with their feet. DDG passed the ball to an Eriksen that was already being pressed. Eriksen even had the excuse of not knowing he was being pressed but not DDG who had the full view.

Agenda must not always agend. DDG is absolutely horrific with his legs/feet when it comes to anything that does not involve saving shots.

Kilishihunter:

Boss Ter Stegen is the better ball playing GK, That's the main reason why he's not been moved on despite his past pure shot saving turbulent years, There's not been a suitable option found who's also also as good with his feet, He even uses his both feet effectively

Than Ederson? lol

Bombblacks:
What am I reading? Neuer is the one who revolutionalized goalkeeping with his ball playing and sweeping ability. Perfect combination of shot stopping with ball playing and sweeping ability. Ederson has nothing on him.

Ederson is better at sweeping and ball playing.

If Neuer is 9.5/10 with his hands he is 8/10 with his legs/feet. Ederson is 7 with his hands and 9.9/10 with his feet. That is what makes Neuer the overall better keeper.

Android22:
Than Ederson? lol

Yup, Ederson is a god in playing out from the back but MATS is slightly better, I had a graph on my phone ranking them for last season, I'll try and search the internet for it, MATS makes less mistakes than Ederson that's if the latter even makes any sef and plays mostly accurate balls to even our wingers since that's xavi's preferred system now, That's the reason why he hasn't been kicked out when he's been poor with his hands

Bombblacks:
What am I reading? Neuer is the one who revolutionalized goalkeeping with his ball playing and sweeping ability. Perfect combination of shot stopping with ball playing and sweeping ability. Ederson has nothing on him.

Their coach (pep) pick Ederson as the best.

Sweeping - Neuer
Ball playing - Ederson.

Fun fact- Ederson can pass the ball better than McFred.

Kilishihunter:

Yup, Ederson is a god in playing out from the back but MATS is slightly better, I had a graph on my phone ranking them for last season, I'll try and search the internet for it, MATS makes less mistakes than Ederson that's if the latter even makes any sef and plays mostly accurate balls to even our wingers

lol

Android22:
Ederson is better at sweeping and ball playing.

If Neuer is 9.5/10 with his hands he is 8/10 with his legs/feet. Ederson is 7 with his hands and 9.9/10 with his feet. That is what makes Neuer the overall better keeper.

Neuer is better than Ederson in all aspects. Shot stopping, ball playing and sweeping.

Android22:
But you are trying to downplay the role Keepers play with their feet. DDG passed the ball to an Eriksen that was already being pressed. Eriksen even had the excuse of not knowing he was being pressed but not DDG who had the full view.

Agenda must not always agend. DDG is absolutely horrific with his legs/feet when it comes to anything that does not involve saving shots.

If that pass had gone to Pogba in the same circumstance, he would have maneuvered his way out of the press through sheer strength and his love for ground duels.

Eriksen was a wet pipe. Rodri, Fabinho, Kante, Casemiro and even Partey would have received that ball, beat the press and move the ball along like the incident never happened.

No player should be comfortable on the pitch thinking he won’t be pressed when receiving the ball. It was Eriksen that actually demanded for the ball by darting towards De Gea to receive the ball.

How is that De Gea’s fault?

You can see Eriksen running towards the ball in this image even before the ball left De Gea’s boots. He demanded for the ball and then lost the ball. De Gea could have ignored and passed to Maguire but he doesn’t trust neither Maguire or Shaw.

Illimitable:


It wasn’t a red zone, Eriksen wasn’t strong enough.

OPTA had it as Eriksen’s error.

DDG completed a pass.

Check the image below, De Gea ignored an unmarked Maguire and passed to Erikssen who wasn't just marked but also in front of the post.

Bombblacks:

Neuer is better than Ederson in all aspects. Shot stopping, ball playing and sweeping.

Hahaha. Pep disagrees with you.

Illimitable:


If that pass had gone to Pogba in the same circumstance, he would have maneuvered his way out of the press through sheer strength and his love for ground duels.

Eriksen was a wet pipe. Rodri, Fabinho, Kante, Casemiro and even Partey would have received that ball, beat the press and move the ball along like the incident never happened.

No player should be comfortable on the pitch thinking he won’t be pressed when receiving the ball. It was Eriksen that actually demanded for the ball by darting towards De Gea to receive the ball.

How is that De Gea’s fault?

You can see Eriksen running towards the ball in this image even before the ball left De Gea’s boots. He demanded for the ball and then lost the ball. De Gea could have ignored and passed to Maguire but he doesn’t trust neither Maguire or Shaw.

DDG can see that he is being pressed right?

Expert17:


Their coach (pep) pick Ederson as the best.

Sweeping - Neuer
Ball playing - Ederson.

Fun fact- Ederson can pass the ball better than McFred.

Ofcourse pep will pick his current goalkeeper to boost morale. Same way he praised Bravo as the best goalkeeper in the world and how he said Foden is the most talented player he has seen. Neuer tops Ederson in all aspects.

Expert17:


Check the image below, De Gea ignored an unmarked Maguire and passed to Erikssen who wasn't just marked but also in front of the post.

The damage had already been done here in your image. Check my image before the ball left De Gea’s boots.

Eriksen ran towards De Gea to receive the pass. He’s touted as one of the best ball players in the league and he’s better on possession than Maguire or Shaw.

De Gea trusted him but Eriksen betrayed that trust.