Politics › Re: Kogi: Tribunal Adjourns Indefinitely For SDP’s Election Materials Inspection by garfield1: 8:41pm On Dec 01, 2023*. Modified: 1:58am On Dec 02, 2023 |
fergie001: It's on pdf, send a mail. Just finished reading,the judgment was well written and unassailable.like I told you,pdp failed to obey the justice gyang order.even latest records at the appeal court is a disaster for pdp |
Politics › Re: Kogi: Tribunal Adjourns Indefinitely For SDP’s Election Materials Inspection by garfield1: 7:12pm On Dec 01, 2023 |
fergie001: Kano is less harder to me than Plateau. If the Supreme Court goes against the Appeal Court, all the lawmakers who were earlier sacked will revolt. The only way PDP will fight back is because the Appeal Court dwelt only on the qualifications issue. That is to say it conceded that PDP won the election but for the qualifications issue. So once the PDP wins Ground 1 which is this, then it's all over.
For Kano, it is the party that determines her members and sponsors them. It is not the business or responsibility for anybody who is not a member to begin the probe of membership of another. It is the NWC that determines that.
Again, like I have said continuously; this path been taken by the Court of Appeal is not in consonance with precedents.
This Plateau Congress was accepted by PDP members. After the repeated Congress, no PDP member went to Court again on it, so why will another Party, a meddlesome interloper, a busybody, a hired mourner paid to cry more than the bereaved begin to pry their eyes into the personal and domestic affairs of another Political Party. This is wrong on all fronts.
For Kano.. even though, the lawyers for Abba messed up their case at the tribunal, what is the business of an APC Candidate on the membership of an NNPP Candidate? The Party is registered by law as a body corporate to carry out its activities as our laws demand.
In the case of a former lawmaker in your State House of Assembly who is now Deputy-Governor, Peter Odey, who resigned as a PDP member whilst been Majority Leader of the CRSHA. He told the Court he didn't defect to the APC and remained a member of the PDP and didn't resign. However, Justice Taiwo held that the lawmaker announced it himself before the sitting of the House and hence cannot prevaricate before the Court. The Court sacked him and others as lawmakers. However the same Odey Agbe Peter appealed the judgement telling the Appeal Court that he remained a bonafide member of the PDP and his name is in the register of the PDP.
At the tribunal and now Appeal Court, the PDP has continued to argue that Odey cannot belong to two parties at the same time. The Tribunal and Appeal Court held that it is non-justiciable. They held that the PDP had no business to dabble into who is a member of the APC and who is not, infact they fines the PDP for instituting the suit.
Lastly is the case between Tarfarya Asarya of the APC and PDP's Midala Balami in a Federal Constituency in Borno State. Balami of the PDP won.
The APC approached the tribunal to challenge the fact that the Supreme Court nullified the Primary that brought up Balami and ordered a fresh Primary be held within 14 days. However, the PDP conducted this same Primary well after 15 days. They stretch on the fact that the PDP disobeyed a Supreme Court order.
The tribunal affirmed the PDP Candidate and held that the issue surrounded pre-election matters and the tribunal had no jurisdiction. APC went to the Appeal Court as expected.
On Oct 20, 2023; the panel led by Nwosu-Iheme JCA held that the Court had no jurisdiction.
She held that Section 285(1) of the 1999 constitution, the tribunal had jurisdiction only to determine the validity of an election.
She averred that the scope of the tribunal’s jurisdiction cannot be expanded to include the determination of the validity or conduct of primary election or nomination of candidates by political parties.
This Judgement is not new as we saw in Akinlade v. Dapo Abiodun where the Court per Ejembi Eko JSC (as he then was), made strict judgements towards that.
The Court narrowed down where the qualification criteria might come in but who proves who is a member of the political Party?
In Jegede v Akeredolu, the Supreme Court was clear that APC made Buni their Chairman despite Article 17 of the APC Constitution so it's a Party affair. The Court has no jurisdiction on that.
The second respondent (APC) allowed him (Buni) to be its Chairman in the interim in spite of Article 17 of its constitution.
The vires of this decision of the party is non-justiciable. This appeal fails and it is hereby dismissed per Agim JSC
We should be careful at this trajectory we are headed now. I still haven't seen the judgment |
Politics › Re: Kogi: Tribunal Adjourns Indefinitely For SDP’s Election Materials Inspection by garfield1: 5:47pm On Dec 01, 2023 |
fergie001: A difficult case for the Supreme Court to rule against.
Only God can help Mutfwang now. It is not as hard as Kano. Where is it |
Politics › Re: Tension Grips Nasarawa Over Supreme Court Judgement by garfield1: 2:35pm On Dec 01, 2023 |
shakdav: Eggon are majority followed by Afo tribe, mada, Gbagyi people A toothless majority.they should try again in 2027 |
Politics › Re: Tension Grips Nasarawa Over Supreme Court Judgement by garfield1: 2:34pm On Dec 01, 2023 |
shakdav: Explain to us how AA sule won the election, my brother it is religion u use to play the card, Emmanuel won the election it was manipulated with two ward which are gaya ward and chiroman in lafia local government, if u augr stastucally how can number of voters be more than number of accredited voters in what era, just say u are one those Muslim with strong heart that a christian will not rule Nassarawa state just because u have a dirty secrets you guys don't want to be review to the word that is why in terms of population the christian are much more that you guys and by the way the politics that brought in or about to bring Emmanuel is not of religion but of a die heart need of a real indigen of Nasarawa state, one- eggon are majority follow by Ado, mada, Gbagyi people and the rest... Let talk about state politics if u know much because I am from Nasarawa state, Nasarawa local government Even if you minus gaya and chiroma,sule still won |
Politics › Re: INEC Released The BVAS Reports Of Bayelsa, Kogi, And Imo To Osita Chidoka by garfield1: 2:17pm On Dec 01, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: I am expecting lots of cancellations in Imo state..
I mean,, the type of cancellations that would make people to call for the overhauling of INEC.. Don't expect anything as nothing will happen.bvas reports carry no weight |
Politics › Re: Edo 2024: Shaibu Has The Right To Contest – Obaseki by garfield1: 11:12am On Dec 01, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: I say No. I am not removing it.. At least,, not now.!!
I didn't want anybody to see me as a credible and responsible fellow.. I am a CRAZEMAN. Don't ever forget that.
If that picture represented my particular opinion about that particular issue being discussed at the particular moment when I posted it,, then that's it.
If I change my opinion later,, then, I will release a caveat or a disclaimer.. Which suggested that I got better informed as time went on.
So,, it is still my decision to make., whether to pull it down or not..
And not because some people are telling me that some other people are looking up to a BLUNT-CRAZE-MAN, and expecting the Craze-Man to be a reasonable and credible fellow. The man interpreted the law the way it is.what is wrong with that? Should ordinary Nigerians start misbehaving at their work place |
Politics › Re: President Tinubu And King Charles In Group Picture With Other World Leaders by garfield1: 9:51am On Dec 01, 2023 |
slaawomirr: Damnnn niggar
Look at him looking so odd
Why is it that when people criticise tinubu they quickly tagged them as igbos
The truth is the people who dislike tinubu are the people of South South
I'm a Bini from Edo state I'm from ss and like tinubu.95% of those that hate him are se |
Politics › Re: Edo 2024: Shaibu Has The Right To Contest – Obaseki by garfield1: 9:39am On Dec 01, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: Targeting? How? Explain...
Innocent Judge? Ok naa. No wahalla. Remove his picture.only childish and petty people behave this way.a lot of people see you as a credible abd reasonable fellow |
Politics › Re: Edo 2024: Shaibu Has The Right To Contest – Obaseki by garfield1: 9:29am On Dec 01, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: Hehehehehe..
Is there any enforceable law against “foolishness” in the laws of Nigeria?
Or you're appealing to my conscience?? (which I have decided not to use for now?) Why are you now targeting that innocent judge |
Politics › Re: Why Election Cases Are Difficult To Win(gubernatorial And Presidential) by garfield1(op): 8:01am On Dec 01, 2023 |
Kukutenla: One then wonders how APC especially is suddenly winning election litigation without bothering to prove noncompliance like in Kano and Plateau.
One also wonders why Appeal Court threw away precedence in Kano and Plateau
One wonders why in the case of Nasarawa, non- compliance is established but then the Appeal Court decide to apply something else. Same fit Kaduna and Ogun where just one word proved fatal to the case
The course of justice is not being helped in election litigation Lol |
Politics › Re: Edo 2024: Shaibu Has The Right To Contest – Obaseki by garfield1: 7:26am On Dec 01, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: . . . Let's watch all of you guys again this time.
. . . Enough of the foolishness mr |
Politics › Re: Why Election Cases Are Difficult To Win(gubernatorial And Presidential) by garfield1(op): 10:42pm On Nov 30, 2023 |
Bobloco: It's simply a case of the winner takes it all Read the body again |
Politics › Re: Edo 2024 Analysis by garfield1: 10:41pm On Nov 30, 2023 |
OVB123: Is it only shuaibu? What about Sen. Matthew Urhoghide, Hon. Charles Idahosa, lady Uwa Osunbor and others too numerous mention. Infact PDP and Obaseki are goners in Edo state. Leave the mugu |
Politics › Re: Kogi: Tribunal Adjourns Indefinitely For SDP’s Election Materials Inspection by garfield1: 10:41pm On Nov 30, 2023 |
fergie001: Nentawe v Mutfwang landed on my palms this morning.... 110 Pages,
Digesting it from 11pm. Send it to me before digesting.i also want to digest |
Politics › Why Election Cases Are Difficult To Win(gubernatorial And Presidential) by garfield1(op): 8:56pm On Nov 30, 2023 |
Why Election Cases are hard to win:
Judges have been coming under ceaseless attacks and castigations by those who are disappointed with the outcome of election petitions filed at various election tribunals across the country.
I don't know what they expect judges to do when petitioners woefully fail to bring before judges evidence that judges hearing election petitions would rely on to overturn results declared by INEC in favour of the winners whom they are challenging in the tribunal.
I started doing election cases way back in 1999 when the country returned to democratic civil rule after a long spell of military dictatorship.
I have since then appeared as counsel in two presidential election petition cases (Buhari vs. Yaradua (2008), and CPC vs. President Goodluck Jonathan (2011).
I also counselled in several governorship election petitions including Comrade Adams Oshiomhole v. Professor Osunbor and Onyema Ugochukwu.
In 2007, I was the counsel to the Petitioners in Dr Paul Ukpo and five others versus Senator Liyel Imoke.
I have also handled several National and State Assemblies election petitions in Akwa Ibom and Cross River States since 1999 till now.
Therefore I have first-time practical experience with what election petitions are and even the attitude of the judges.
I tell you election litigation is difficult, tedious, stressful and challenging to the Petitioners, Respondents, Judges and legal practitioners alike.
The first challenge for the petitioner is assembling and gathering evidence from the numerous polling units where the election takes place.
It is usually difficult because some of the polling agents appointed by the political parties to be watchdogs are more often than not nonchalant, ill-prepared,ill-trained and compromised to enable them to gather evidence they can submit to their political parties to use to prepare petitions in cases where there is non-compliance.
The petitioner has 21 days after the day of the declaration of the result to challenge it to file his petition.
This is usually inadequate to enable someone who contested a presidential or governorship election to prepare his papers for filing. Nigeria has 176,974 polling units across the country.
If a petitioner wants to challenge a presidential election for non-compliance he has to call a witness from each of these 176,974 polling units across the country. Is it possible for a petitioner to call 176,974 witnesses or to prove his case when the Tribunal is given just 180 days to hear a petition and deliver judgment?
Also, there are 8,000 electoral wards in the country,776 local governments 36 States and the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja.
A petitioner who wants to complain about the collation of results from the Polling Unit to the Ward to the Local government area collation centre to the State collation centre in presidential election litigation must also call witnesses in all these collation centres.
The same procedure applies to the governorship election. Almost all the States of the federation have not less than 3,000 polling units.
It is a nightmare for lawyers to sit down and gather, and scrutinise reports from these polling units and craft a petition to file within days.
The Rules of Election Petition require the petitioner to frontload the evidence he wants to present before the election tribunal.
In other words at the time of the filing of the petition, the petitioner must file statements on oath of all the witnesses he intends to call. Any evidence not filed at the time of filing of the petition is inadmissible and cannot be used no matter how weighty it is.
The Rules of Election litigation are extremely technical and peculiar unlike in ordinary litigation where the rules are lax and not strictly enforced.
Any infraction of the Rules of an election petition by the petitioner is fatal to his case. The election tribunal is given 180 days from the day of the filing of the petition to hear and determine it.
The law that regulates election petitions is also a challenge. The burden of proof is on the petitioner not on INEC or the person whom a petitioner has been filed against.
Also, the law presumes that an election result is correct unless the contrary is proved. In all these what do we expect judges to do? If the petitioner fails to prepare an iron cast with credible and overwhelming evidence to cause the judge to overturn the result of the election who should take the blame?
The law also says that a judge hearing an election petition should exercise his discretion and allow the result to stand if in his opinion the election was conducted in substantial compliance with the provisions of the Electoral Law.
The legislature or the lawmaker appreciates the fact that elections are conducted by INEC using human beings who are fallible and prone to human frailties and shortcomings that would likely on election probably not follow the rules to the letter because of one reason or the other.
Therefore if mistakes omissions or breaches of these election guidelines and regulations made by those entrusted with the conduct are isolated and cannot affect the outcome of the election in a way to subverts the will of the people that election must stand.
Finally, the principles of law evolving from election litigations laid down as precedence from say 1979 to the present have not changed.
Judges are conservative by orientation and judicial activism is not encouraged under common law system except perhaps at the Supreme Court level.
Even then the Supreme Court is not only a court of law,but also of public policy.
It is very difficult and even smacks of radicalism and discipline for judges down the judicial ladder to depart and disregard precedents laid down by superior courts in the judicial hierarchy no matter what.
I therefore submit that if Nigerians want to see a different trajectory in election litigation the law must change.
It is not the judges that will change the law.
The work of the judges is to interpret the law as it is.
Judges are forbidden to interpret the law as it ought to be. It is the National Assembly that has the power to fundamentally alter or change our electoral law.
Till then, our hardworking and overworked judges should be spared.
@ Okoi Obono-Obla
Mynd44 Nplfmod Seun Fergie001 Dalitigator Bluntcrazeman Oziogu1 Efewestern Penguin2 Muykem Cajal Svoboda Casualobserver Yarimo Ejimatic Coolambience Kukutenla Kyase Ojiofor Naptu2 Oghenaogie Seanfer Indispensable Famology Aiel123 |
Politics › Re: Edo 2024 Analysis by garfield1: 7:10pm On Nov 30, 2023 |
Validated: That was how you boasted about Timipre Silvia in Bayelsa. Where is he now? I clearly said that sylva has 35% chance and will win at least two lgas that if he win SILGA,he wins.diri is going for a second term and many in apc are supporting him and against sylva. In Edo,it is different sir.pdp is heavily divided.shuaibu is no more with him.how is he going to win |
|
Politics › Re: Kogi: Tribunal Adjourns Indefinitely For SDP’s Election Materials Inspection by garfield1: 3:32pm On Nov 30, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: I see You see nada Stevie wonder.obi petition is worthless and deserves the trashcan that is why it was dismissed in seconds |
Politics › Re: Tinubu Targets 18% GDP Growth In His First Budget As President by garfield1: 3:32pm On Nov 30, 2023 |
slivertongue: Buhari's shambolic, deceptive & manipulative govt promised and promised but destroyed all it met but you kept praising him. so it's not new if you do same for the new tenant at Also Rock You said prebendalism which is similar to nepotism.tinubu isn't doing that exactly.most of those tinubu is giving appointment to are well qualified and accomplished unlike buhari. I supported buhari because of apc.tgeres no way I'll allow apc to lose power to pdp.even obi is worse so let apc continue |
Politics › Re: Kogi: Tribunal Adjourns Indefinitely For SDP’s Election Materials Inspection by garfield1: 3:28pm On Nov 30, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: And the person is you??
Trash-can?? 🗑️ 🗑️ What uselessness.rubbish |
Politics › Re: Imo Guber: INEC Frustrating Moves To Inspect The BVAS – Sen. Achononu Laments by garfield1: 3:06pm On Nov 30, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: E don set..
One thing here,, another thing on the other side. Oga,forget this matter.its a dead issue |
|
Politics › Re: Kogi: Tribunal Adjourns Indefinitely For SDP’s Election Materials Inspection by garfield1: 3:01pm On Nov 30, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: You just typed trash.
Which page or which paragraph of Atiku’s petition or appeal did he mention 18,000 blank copies, substantial compliance?
And if the LP brought the case of drug issue, double nomination to them as an appeal,, why would they be silent on it??
If it was going to be a consolidated judgement,, then, they would have listed the two cases of appeals (with their numbers) inside the CTC that was released.
Some times,, I don't understand the way you type. Oga,you are the one typing trash,use your head na.is it so hard to apply commonsense? The apex court at times on several occasions do not write fresh judgment on cases they already align with.like in 2019,they simply adopted the pepc judgment totally.those men are just 10,the workload is much.why should they rewrite a fresh judgment when the pepc already simplified everything? Go and read atiku's petition again,he complained of over 20,000 blank irev copies and substantial noncompliance in anambra,sokoto,zamfara,abia etc. The double nomination issue was already settled by the apex court in atiku vs shettima supra.you are not familiar with legal cases,why not allow those who know better to educate you |
Politics › Re: Kogi: Tribunal Adjourns Indefinitely For SDP’s Election Materials Inspection by garfield1: 1:52pm On Nov 30, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: The Grounds Are Not Similar.
That's where they FAILED.!!
And are you saying that the LP/Obi should now go and pick the Judgement of PDP/Atiku?? Whereas the Judgement was strictly for PDP/Atiku,, (and not a Consolidated Judgement.... as is the case with the PEPT--Judgement) Oga,some grounds are similar like the 18000 blank copies,network glitch, substantial noncompliance,overvoting,fct 25%.atiku judgment will apply here mutatis mutandis. The only ground that are not similar are drug issue,double nomination in which the pepc judgment applies.immediately they finished reading the atiku judgment,they simply decided to consolidate and thrash obi appeal |
Politics › Re: Kogi: Tribunal Adjourns Indefinitely For SDP’s Election Materials Inspection by garfield1: 11:53am On Nov 30, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: No. They didn't write the LP Judgement, neither did they read it out.
They just prescribed an unwritten judgement.
So the real question is...
Why didn't they write the judgement for the LP, and read it out in the court.??
 Nawao.didnt you watch the video of the judgment? They simply voted to dismiss the lp petition and similar grounds in pdp judgment applies to lp and adopted the pepc judgment where necessary |
Politics › Re: Edo 2024 Analysis by garfield1: 9:07am On Nov 30, 2023 |
Validated: Thank you for your opinion. It does not count anyway. Neither Ojezua, Shaibu nor Ogbeide-Ihama is smelling Osadebe House. For others, I do not know. However, just know that Obaseki still hold the 4 aces. Edo no bi Lagos. Obaseki holds nothing,he is finished.apc is producing the next gov |
Politics › Re: Kogi: Tribunal Adjourns Indefinitely For SDP’s Election Materials Inspection by garfield1: 8:52am On Nov 30, 2023 |
BluntCrazeMan: The Supreme-Court Will Not Release The CTC of the Judgement On The LP/PO-vs-INEC/APC/BATSHETT Case..
They never expected that LP would bring up the matter again...
And now, the timeline is over. They may never release it again.
Because,, whatever they would release as the CTC of the PO-Appeal was not actually read in the Open Court. And the timeline for such had passed already.
Their hands are tied.
Fergie001, Dalitigator. Stop this nonsense.which ctc? Did they read any judgment for Lp? |
NYSC › Re: Career Path To Follow : Preparing yourself for the Labour Market by garfield1: 6:14pm On Nov 29, 2023 |
Oziogu1 |
Politics › Re: Tinubu Targets 18% GDP Growth In His First Budget As President by garfield1: 5:48pm On Nov 29, 2023 |
slivertongue: I hope it works out. but honestly I doubt 8% is possible looking at the pre-bendal governance process How does it affect performance |
Politics › Re: Edo 2024: Philip Shaibu Declares Governorship Bid Under PDP by garfield1: 5:36pm On Nov 29, 2023 |
fergie001: I have forwarded the request, I will get it soon. Hmmm |
Politics › Re: Fct Minister Visits Proposed Sites Of Judges Quarters, Court Of Appeal Complex by garfield1: 5:35pm On Nov 29, 2023 |
ottersberger: My man. How far?. Election litigation don end. Let's see how it goes in the next episode. Which episode |