Welcome, Guest: Register On Nairaland / LOGIN! / Trending / Recent / New
Stats: 3,158,299 members, 7,836,305 topics. Date: Wednesday, 22 May 2024 at 04:12 AM

Nairatalks's Posts

Nairaland Forum / Nairatalks's Profile / Nairatalks's Posts

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (of 6 pages)

Islam for Muslims / Re: Saudi Prince Exposes Saudi Arabia On Oppression by Nairatalks: 1:42pm On Aug 16, 2013
^^^^
Salaam

Thank you Lagoshia for that expose.


The others are not ready to tell the truth about their "second country"


Saudi Arabia has a multitude of problems to solve.
Islam for Muslims / Re: Sports And Fun-An Islamic Perspective. by Nairatalks: 1:39pm On Aug 16, 2013
lanrexlan: Sahih Muslim Book 028,Number 5612: Buraida reported on the authority of his father that Allah's Apostle (may peace be upon him) said:He who played chess is like one who dyed his hand with the flesh and blood of swine.


Well, let us consider 2 things

1) Modern chess is different from the chess played in 700 ad in the Arab areas

2) There is disagreement among scholars on the status of chess. One opinion is that chess is halal if it is not sed for gambling.
Islam for Muslims / Re: Sports And Fun-An Islamic Perspective. by Nairatalks: 3:18pm On Aug 14, 2013
lanrexlan: WHAT IS FORBIDDEN IN FUN AND GAMES:
There are good and bad sports/games in the light of Islamic truth even though it may not appeal to us or those who make them professions.
The prophet(pbuh) prohibits dice,chess and the likes such as backgammon and card games.Likewise there are bad or sinful ways some games are played.
Any game that reveals the body parts counted as naked by Islam in both men and women is not lawful.Salat should not be delayed by any game as even wars fought by Muslims did not deny them salat,and such must not include any falsehood, obscenity,swearing or insulting,it should be free of alcohol and drug abuse and must avoid betting,gambling,staking.

It should not be for fun only without application to social life or jihad fiisabilillah. And the sport or game or fun itself,must not be allowed to dominate or occupy one’s life to the extent of stifling worship,academic pursuit,professional practice,moral development,family responsibility and spiritual growth.


Contemplation of Allah’s sign is far better than any kind of fun. All games and fun are unpredictable, there is always degree of uncertainty about the winner or result, whereas not so the path and act of essence of life.Therefore,one should not allow certitude to be overridden or defeated by probability,and in fact it cannot!




Yes, gambling games like poker, cards and dice are haram because their mainly due to chance before numbers

However, chess is not a gameof chance. It is a game of strategy.



Chess is not haram
Islam for Muslims / Re: Saudi Prince Exposes Saudi Arabia On Oppression by Nairatalks: 2:32pm On Aug 13, 2013
maclatunji:

He means opposition is difficult to sustain when the "activists" bellies are full.
True talk but how does that relste to the actions of the Saudi government?
Islam for Muslims / Re: Saudi Prince Exposes Saudi Arabia On Oppression by Nairatalks: 1:42pm On Aug 13, 2013
vedaxcool: grin grin grin very soon barrel of dollars would flow on the streets


Islam for Muslims / Re: Richard Dawkins Embarrasses Himself On Twitter With Muslim Comment by Nairatalks: 1:41pm On Aug 13, 2013
How did the topic change to christianity?


The fact is that some western secularists always belive that they are intellectually superior. Unfortunately, ptide come before a big fall
Islam for Muslims / Saudi Prince Exposes Saudi Arabia On Oppression by Nairatalks: 1:38pm On Aug 13, 2013
Saudi Arabia, a major supporter of opposition forces in Syria, has increased crackdown on its own dissenters, with 30,000 activists reportedly in jail. In an exclusive interview to RT a Saudi prince defector explained what the monarchy fears most.

“Saudi Arabia has stepped up arrests and trials of peaceful dissidents, and responded with force to demonstrations by citizens,”

Human Rights Watch begins the country’s profile on its website. Political parties are banned in Saudi Arabia and human rights groups willing to function legally have to go no further than investigating things like corruption or inadequate services. Campaigning for political freedoms is outlawed. One of such groups, which failed to get its license from the government, the Saudi Civil and Political Rights Association (ACPRA), was cited by AFP as saying the kingdom was holding around 30,000 political prisoners. Saudi Prince Khaled Bin Farhan Al-Saud, who spoke to RT from Dusseldorf, Germany, confirmed reports of increased prosecution of anti-government activists and said that it’s exactly what forced him to defect from his family. He accused the monarchy of corruption and silencing all voices of dissent and explained how the Saudi mechanism for suppression functioned.

http://rt.com/news/saudi-arabia-opposition-prince-374/
“There is no independent judiciary, as both police and the prosecutor’s office are accountable to the Interior Ministry. This ministry’s officials investigate ‘crimes’ (they call them crimes), related to freedom of speech. So they fabricate evidence, don’t allow people to have attorneys”, the prince told RT Arabic. “Even if a court rules to release such a ‘criminal’, the Ministry of Interior keeps him in prison, even though there is a court order to release him. There have even been killings! Killings! And as for the external opposition, Saudi intelligence forces find these people abroad! There is no safety inside or outside the country.” Prince Khalid Bin Farhan Al-SaudThe strong wave of oppression is in response to the anti-government forces having grown ever more active.

A new opposition group called Saudi Million and claiming independence from any political party was founded in late July. The Saudi youths which mostly constitute the movement say they demand the release of political prisoners and vow to hold regular demonstrations, announcing their dates and locations via Facebook and electronic newspapers. Human rights violations are driving people on to the streets despite the fear of arrest, according to activist Hala Al-Dosari, who spoke to RT from Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. “We have issues related to political and civil rights, freedom of expression and freedom of assembly. These are the main issues that cause a lot of people to be at risk for just voicing out their opinions or trying to form associations, demonstrate or protest, which is banned by the government.”
Islam for Muslims / Richard Dawkins Embarrasses Himself On Twitter With Muslim Comment by Nairatalks: 11:07am On Aug 10, 2013


Richard Dawkins, in attempt to ridicule muslims, got a backlash over his twitter comment;

"All the world's Muslims have fewer Nobel Prizes than Trinity College, Cambridge. They did great things in the Middle Ages, though."


Many people on twitter have complained that the tweet from Richard Dawkins is nonsensical when you consider that the Trinity College has had more nobel prizes than most groups of people. Furthermore, nobel prizes have nothing to do with the truth of Islam. Islam evaluated on a Western prize?


For more reading
http://www.theguardian.com/science/2013/aug/08/richard-dawkins-twitter-row-muslims-cambridge
http://metro.co.uk/2013/08/09/athiest-richard-dawkins-in-hot-water-over-islam-dig-on-twitter-3917965/
Islam for Muslims / Re: Algerians Eat Lunch In Ramadan Protest by Nairatalks: 1:15pm On Aug 07, 2013
maclatunji: Fasting is a an act of worship to your creator. Anybody using it as a political tool is either very ignorant or deluded.


Well said
Islam for Muslims / Algerians Eat Lunch In Ramadan Protest by Nairatalks: 11:49am On Aug 07, 2013
A group of Algerians have publically eaten lunch during Ramadan to demonstrate against the persecution of people who do not observe the religious fast.

Around 300 people in the north of the country made the protest, knowing there can be serious consequences for not fasting during the Muslim holy month
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-23564925



Smh...I wonder about some muslims today! I dont think that this is a proper way to protest

1 Like

Islam for Muslims / Re: Saudi Arabia's Public Worship Policy by Nairatalks: 4:39pm On Jul 20, 2013
Saudi Arabia can learn from Malaysia. Malaysia is a great Islamic country. A peaceful country with Sharia law and an effective method of living in peace with non muslims. A country where you will hardly hear of the royal family's extravagance.
Islam for Muslims / Re: Saudi Arabia's Public Worship Policy by Nairatalks: 4:36pm On Jul 20, 2013
BetaThings:
So Oklahoma bombing shows that American does not have security?
Forget what Shias claim. Everyone has an agenda. And everyone tries to safeguard himself. It is human nature
Here in Nigeria were we not told that Yaradua did not hand over to Jonathan because
Jonathan is a Christian from the South?
What reason did they give when Enugu state gov did not hand over to his deputy? - Religion? Tribalism

Please let us argue based on reality and not on the basis of some imaginary principles that the proponents have never implemented and will never practise anyway


What are you talking about, sir?

Focus on the issue at hand. Saudi Arabia lacks security and it is an intolerant country when it comes to freedom of religion. Christians should practice their faith freely.

And yes, America has poor security compared to its European counterparts. Oklahoma bomber is one bomber but what about the multiple bombers that came from Saudi Arabia?

I gave an example of Malaysia but everyone kept quiet and went back to their political agenda. Seems that we have some extremists among us.

May Allah guide us. I pray that we treat others as fairly. Remember that when you do something bad to someone of another religion, he can do worse to you in his own haraam religion
Islam for Muslims / Re: Saudi Arabia's Public Worship Policy by Nairatalks: 4:27pm On Jul 20, 2013
BetaThings:

You don't need to remind us of honesty. Do Christians tolerate Muslims even in Nigeria where we are?

Are you stopped from practicing Islam in southern Nigeria which is the Christian stronghold of Nigeria?

How shameful that you would even try to compare the situation in Saudi Arabia to Nigeria. Apples and oranges to me.

Nigeria has its problems but they are not related to the topic at hand which is Saudi Arabia destruction of freedom of religion.
Islam for Muslims / Re: Saudi Arabia's Public Worship Policy by Nairatalks: 4:52pm On Jul 18, 2013
maclatunji:

Hahahaha, yes, Saudi has problems and it will change over time as everything involving human activity does.

You chose Malaysia as an example, the question is: can we Muslims afford the bitter politics that goes on there in Saudi? I seriously don't think so. Nothing in this world beats security. The Saudi government has managed that for years and for that alone, I can overlook many of their shortcomings.

When I say security, I mean it as a total concept that affects an individual's and societal wellbeing.



What security does Saudi have? Isn tht where the 9/11 bombers came from?

Isnt that where a lot of our Westernized and Shia muslim brothers claim the Extremist Wahabbi ideology comes from?
Islam for Muslims / Re: Saudi Arabia's Public Worship Policy by Nairatalks: 10:28am On Jul 18, 2013
It is sad when some of my fellow muslims are not honest about Saudi Arabia just to win an argument.


Saudi Arabia gives a very wrong impression of Islam and sharia. A great country to look at is Malaysia- Christians are allowed to practice their religion and build churches in Malaysia. However, it must be noted that the permits to build churches in Malaysia are not easy to obtain.

Saudi Arabia shows a very intolerant attitude to christians with the banning of their freedom to openly practice their religion and banning other religious items like bibles and co.

This is the same Saudi Arabia that prohibits women from driving and is the only country to do so. If any Nigerian muslim here that has a wife/sister/mother that drives or is a woman that drives supports Saudi Arabia, then there is a real problem.


Please, let us be honest

2 Likes

Islam for Muslims / Re: 10 Incredible Health Benefits Of Fasting. by Nairatalks: 7:07pm On Jul 09, 2013
deols:

dont be too happy.


Fasting is not compulsory on everyone.

People who cannot fast for health reasons are exempted.


@op, I need it for no.7 cheesy


Happy for what? I'm confused
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 7:05pm On Jul 09, 2013
vedaxcool:
After you



You are not someone to be reasoned with. To even compare my comment with your own. I am off this thread. I have discussed with the person I wanted to discuss with.
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 11:42am On Jul 09, 2013
vedaxcool: ^
grin yes only one who has no understanding of what commonsense and reasoning is,would make such a statement that epitomize drunken stupor.

Behave yourself, please.
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 11:41am On Jul 09, 2013
vedaxcool:

it seems u have never heard of prophet Muhammad pbuh. u have a lot in common with dummyboy or what's that his name again? as typical making an argument that relies on emotional appeal, as thathaba.point is puts the how a Muslim is suppose to react to calamity which is captured best as a test from Allah,no one prays for misfortune but Muslims must rely on the Qur'an for guidance both in times of comfort and adversity. as thaba rightly captured, the decadence and failing in Muslim land is as a result of deviation from Islam, a society can only be as good as the system it's runs, most Muslim dominated country r running a system that is alien to Islam, nd ur talk of theocraticies r quite false , only two countries that r Muslims claim to b such, Iran & SAudi.now Iran has done a lot in the field of science, as it remains one of the few countries where disel engines r produce and saudi Aramco oil one of the world most highly organized oil company has actually patented some technology it invent, they r many more, but the bottomline is the was plainly myopic and clearly did bring to context other issues involved, we can start by asking why is Nigeria not technologically advanced? I hope u won't blame Muslims for it too?


Sir,

Please what are you talking about? You seem to be talking with misguided anger.

You seem to have the same arrogance with Tbaba. First Tbaba tells me to read the Quran and then you claim that I did not use the Quran to justify my reasoning. You also ask me if I have heard of Muhammad (Pbuh)? Do you have any idea how this is insulting to a practicing muslim?

You dont even understand the point of the thread. You even missed where I used the Quran and theology to explain why Tbaba's answers were incomplete.





Nairatalks:

I just researched on Hamza Tzortzis after going to that website. He is a good philosopher. But I want to play the devil's advocate here with some of the points;





Incomplete theology and misinterpretation of the Quran. While we were created to worship God, we have 3 options;
-worship him in sadness
-worship him in happiness
-worship him with a neutral state of mind.

The Quran does not say that we should worship in sadness

Imagine someone losing his whole family to a hurricane on Thursday, do you honestly expect to see him in the mosque on Friday? He has to grieve and take time to calm down. The hurricane deaths have affected his ability to worship, so your distinguishing between secondary and primary purposes of human life is not as black and white as you see it.




Incomplete theology again. Yes, God tests us but is that all? How do we know when we are tested? To describe somebody losing his whole family to a hurricane as a test from God is borderline psychopathic. We dont know if it is a test or just the way God created the earth to function. Who knows if it is all science and the earth needs such a strong water cycle to keep on surviving as a planet.

I am not saying that God cant test us with hard times. The fact is that we dont know when we are tested and how God tests us. It is rather more reasonable to assume that God tests us with our faith directly rather than with machinations of biology, physics and geology of our bodies and our planet----- I am not sure of this but it seems more sensible




Suffering adds to the experience no doubt.

But if there is a thing like unnecessary suffering then it doesnt bring us closer to God.


Also sins have nothing to do with hurricanes and earthquakes
Islam for Muslims / Re: 10 Incredible Health Benefits Of Fasting. by Nairatalks: 7:36am On Jul 09, 2013
Many people observe fasting as a religious obligation but only few know the health benefits it has. Fasting is a good practice, if properly implemented. It promotes elimination of toxins from the body, reduces blood sugar ans fat stores. It promote healthy eating habits and boost immunity. Here are top 10 health benefits you ca derive from fasting.
1. Fasting Promotes detoxification

Processed foods contain lots of additives. These additives may become toxins in the body. Some of them promote production of advanced glycation end products (AGEs). Most of these toxins are stored in fats. Fat is burnt during fasting, especially when it is prolonged. And the toxins are released. The liver, kidneys and other organs in the body are involved in detoxification.

2. Fasting Rests Digestive System

During fasting, the digestive organs rest. The normal physiologic functions continue especially production of digestive secretions, but at reduced rates. This exercise helps to maintain balance of fluids in the body. Breakdown of food takes place at steady rates. Release of energy also follows a gradual pattern. Fasting however does not stop production of acids in the stomach. This is reason patients with peptic ulcer are advised to approach fasting with caution. Some experts believe they should not fast.

3. Fasting Resolves Inflammatory Response

Some studies show that fasting promotes resolution of inflammatory diseases and allergies. Examples of such inflammatory diseases are rheumatoid arthritis, arthritis and skin diseases such as psoriasis. Some experts assert that fasting may promote healing of inflammatory bowel diseases such as ulcerative colitis.

4. Fasting Reduces Blood Sugar

Fasting increases breakdown of glucose so that the body can get energy. It reduces production of insulin. This rests the pancreas. Glucagon is produced to facilitate the breakdown of glucose. The outcome of fasting is a reduction in blood sugar.

5. Fasting Increases Fat breakdown

The first response of the body to fasting is break down of glucose. When the store of glucose is exhausted, ketosis begins. This is break down of fats to release energy. The fats stored in kidney and muscles are broken down to release energy.

6. Fasting Corrects high blood Pressure

Fasting is one of the non-drug methods of reducing blood pressure. It helps to reduce the risk of atherosclerosis. Atherosclerosis is clogging of arteries by fat particles. During fasting glucose and later, fat stores are used to produce energy. Metabolic rate is reduced during fasting. The fear-flight hormones such as adrenaline and noradrenaline are also reduced. This keeps the metabolic steady and within limits. The benefit is a reduction in blood pressure.

7. Fasting Promotes Weight loss

Fasting promotes rapid weight loss. It reduces the store of fats in the body. However fasting is not a good weight loss strategy. Reducing fat and sugar intake, and increasing fruits and rest are better measures to achieve weight reduction.

8. Fasting Promotes Healthy diet

It has been observed that fasting reduces craving for processed foods. It promotes desire for natural foods, especially water and fruits. This is one way fasting promote healthy lifestyle.

9. Fasting Boosts Immunity

When an individual is on balanced diet in between fasts, this can boost immunity. Elimination of toxins and reduction in fat store also helps the body. When individuals take fruits to break a fast, they increase the body's store of essential vitamins and minerals. Vitamins A and E are good antioxidants readily available in fruits. They help to boost immunity.

10. Fasting May Help to Overcome Addictions

Some authors show that fasting can help addicts reduce their cravings, for nicotine, alcohol, caffeine and other substance abuse. Although there are other regimens required to resolve addictions, fasting can play a role.
[size=14pt]
Despite these benefits, fasting has some demerits. It may cause reduction in body water called dehydration. This leads may lead to headaches and even trigger migraines in predisposed persons. It may worsen heartburn and peptic ulcer. Pregnant women, nursing mothers, malnourished people, and individuals with cardiac arrhythmias, renal or liver problems are advised not to fast.

[/size]

1 Like

Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 6:22am On Jul 09, 2013
alexis:

Are you a muslim?


A muslim convert. Yes, I am a muslim.
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 7:02pm On Jul 08, 2013
NL member: This is an excellent thread smiley

Great points, Nairatalks and rhymz smiley


Thanks bro
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 7:25am On Jul 08, 2013
usermane: @Tbaba1234 and Nairatalks, what brought the issue of female Islamic scholars? Am not disputing the issue of 8000 female scholars versed in Qur'an and Hadith. We, however were talking about backwardness of the muslim in terms scientific application and technological invention. You guys should give response to why the east is lagging behind when it comes to innovations. Why do they have to import most of their electronics,vehicles or computers? Why dont we have anything in our countries like Nigeria imported from them?



The issue is very simple-

People like Tbaba and other islamic leaders/govt will prefer to preach more religion (which they think they are an authority on) rather than focus on solutions that work.

Imagine Tbaba claiming that the solution is more Islam. Was that the solution that gave the West technological advancement? More islam? Tbaba is living in some past glory of the Arab golden age.


More religion is not the answer. More science, more sensible laws, more education and more sensible investments are the key to catching up with the west. I am a religious person myself but religion is not everything. God is! And I believe God is in each and every hardworking man who wants to progess in th world

2 Likes

Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 7:18am On Jul 08, 2013
tbaba1234:

If i engage in shirk, then Ameen. But Allah Himself told us that we would be tested with difficult times. I did not claim to know the unseen. I specifically said that some things are above our pay grade.



You made statement like the Quran said something without actually knowing what it says.

Maybe, i was not clear. The fact you are given a test means you can handle it because Allah has promised that You might not know that you can but you can.

Maybe, i am a bit harsh. Forgive me for that. If i make an error, correct me, i am not perfect, if i recognize the error, i correct myself.. Do not say i spread falsehood without providing your evidence for it. That is not criticism, you are accusing me of lying.

If you make a good argument with evidence, i will accept it. Do not say, i am spreading falsehood.

Our tests are different, some are tested with luxury and others with difficulty.

Salaam,

All I will say is that I have never seen a man who has lost his wole family and isnt mentally damaged beyond repair from the loss. Also, that you would make a terrible friend to any person who has lost family members by telling them that it is a "test". May Allah save you from the person retaliating by throwing you out of his house and calling it a "test".
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 7:13am On Jul 08, 2013
tbaba1234:

What is unverifiable about the claim?? It is better for you to say : I don't know...

Now go to Youtube: Type Women scholars of Islam by Dr. Hesham al-Awadi

Better still watch it here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z_BzMwnGsE8

It is a four part series.

Also Read: Nadwi, Mohammad Akram, Al Muhadithaat, Interface Publications, (2007)

And please do not make statements from ignorance.



So, you are now pointing me to videos of people that brainwashed you with an unverifiable claim? Why not use Islamic historical documents to prove your claims? Quran, Hadith or other historical documents.

8,000 female muslim scholars with no evidence whatsoever. Kindly admit that you made a false claim
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 10:20pm On Jul 07, 2013
rhymz: what I am trying to say is pretty much simple and obvious, there's compulsion in religion.



No problem then!
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 10:19pm On Jul 07, 2013
tbaba1234:

The order to worship has no conditions, it is irrespective of your condition. You should read your Quran, more. I am serious. So that you do not make statements like: 'The Quran does not say that we should worship in sadness'

Infact, the Quran promises you difficult times in this life:

We shall certainly test you with fear and hunger, and loss of property, lives, and crops. But [Prophet], give good news to those who are steadfast, 156 those who say, when afflicted with a calamity, ‘We belong to God and to Him we shall return.’ These will be given blessings and mercy from their Lord, and it is they who are rightly guided. (Surah 2:155-157)

Your patience and recognition of your primary purpose is important, here. Nobody said a test is easy but life is full of them. We have to recognise that we can not despair too much over our losses but be thankful for the gifts.

Do people think they will be left alone after saying ‘We believe’ without being put to the test? We tested those who went before them: God will certainly mark out which ones are truthful and which are lying. (Surah 29:2-3)

It is easy to believe when everything is rosy, what happens to that belief when something happens. That is the test of faith. That will determine how deep you faith runs.



You should look at the points as a whole , which one be incomplete theology?? I wrote more than one point.

A person losing his whole family is a test. The world is not the end point. The Quran talks of people facing such desperate times:

Do you suppose that you will enter the Garden without first having suffered like those before you? They were afflicted by misfortune and hardship, and they were so shaken that even [their] messenger and the believers with him cried, ‘When will God’s help arrive?’ Truly, God’s help is near. (Surah 2:213-214)


As muslims, we believe that the laws of biology, physics and geology are completely in the control of Allah. So He determines whether a tsunami hits a place or just misses it. Misfortune itself is a test of faith.



Well there is suffering in which man inflicts on himself by his own greed.

Sin is one of the reasons for destroyed nations in the past according to the Quran. Ofcourse, it is not the only reason. Sometimes things happen for reasons, we can't fathom. It is beyond our pay grade.

Allah has set the laws of the universe and he determines what happens on it.



I have truly come to conclude that you are used to preaching to people here without any criticism. Why would you tel me to read the Quran? Are you the only muslim here that has a copy or are you some final authority?

I dont understand the God you are describing in your comment. The God I know is reasonable and doesnt give us more than we can tolerate.

For you to claim that you know when God tests us, it shows your arrogance. I am sorry to say that but I can no longer hold it in. You behave like someone who doesnt like to be questioned. How can you make such a comment that God is testing someone when a hurricane kills his own family? Who died and made you a speaker for God? May Allah have mercy on you for this shirk you are engaging in.
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 10:11pm On Jul 07, 2013
tbaba1234:

It seems you just like claiming falsehood. Unfortunately many muslims are not aware of this fact. We have had over 8,000 popular (to varying degrees) female scholars in our history.

Islam gave women scholarship. Our history is filled with women who have dedicated their lives to teaching Islamic sciences. Have you ever heard of Fatimah Sa`d al Khayr? She was a scholar who was born around the year 522. Her father, Sa`d al Khayr, was also a scholar. He held several classes and was “most particular about [his daughters] attending hadith classes, traveling with them extensively and repeatedly to different teachers. He also taught them himself.” Fatimah studied the works of the great al-Tabarani with the lead narrator of his works in her time. You know who that lead narrator was? The lead narrator of Fatimah’s time was not named Abu someone (the father of someone, indicating that he was a male). The leading scholar of her time was a woman. Her name was Fatimah al-Juzadniyyah and she is the scholar who men and women alike would study under because in that era, she was the greatest and most knowledgeable in some of the classical texts. Fatimah Sa`d al Khayr eventually married and moved to Damascus and eventually to Cairo and she continued to teach. Many scholars travelled specifically to her city so they could study under her.

Fatimah was brought up in a family that valued the education and knowledge of a woman to the point that her father was the one who would ensure she studied with scholars from a young age. Before marriage, she was not told to sit around and be inactive in the community out of fear that some men would find an educated woman unattractive or intimidating and would not want to marry her. She was not going through the motions of studying random things in college because she was stalling until she got married. She sought scholarship and Allah (swt) blessed her with a husband who was of her ranking, who understood her qualifications and drive, and who supported her efforts to continue teaching this religion even after marriage. She left a legacy we unfortunately have most likely never heard about because we rarely hear about the over eight thousand female scholars of hadith who are part of our history.

Why do we never hear about Fatimah Sa`d al Khayr and the thousands of female scholars who were like her? I think that one of the reasons—and it’s just a personal theory—that as a community, we are so focused on grooming our women to be wives and mothers that we lose sight of the fact that this is not even our number one role.

I have a lecture at home that talks of the Female Islamic scholars of the past.




Just pitiful. Here I was thinking that you were really great in islamic history and knowledge.

All I see in this comment is someone who told an untruth and is scrambling to continue the lie. Your 8,000 femalse muslim scholars is an unverifiable claim. Please, stop the falsehood
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 9:29am On Jul 07, 2013
tbaba1234: So why do bad things happen to the good people?

• God’s punishment as a result of our sins and bad actions.

• God’s wisdom, as there may be divine wisdom in permitting evil and suffering. Even if we can’t evaluate what the wisdom is, it doesn’t mean it is not there. To argue such a thing would be a logical fallacy, known as the argument from ignorance (argumentum ad ignorantiam). The story of Khidr which can be found in the 18th chapter of Qur’an from verses 60 to 82 is an eloquent account of how God’s wisdom, whether understood or not, has positive results and benefits for humanity.

The intellectual richness of Islamic Theology provides us with many reasons, some of which include:

1. The primary purpose of the human being is not happiness rather it is to know and worship God. This fulfillment of the divine purpose will result in everlasting bliss and happiness. So if this is our primary purpose other aspects of human experience our secondary. The Qur’an, the book of the Muslims states: “I did not create either jinn or man except to worship Me.” (Qur’an 51:56-57)

2. God also created us for a test, and part of this test is to be tested with suffering and evil. The Qur’an mentions “The One Who created death and life, so that He may put you to test, to find out which of you is best in deeds: He is the all-Almighty, the all-Forgiving” (Qur’an 67: 2)

3. Having hardship and suffering enables us to realise and know God’s attributes such as ‘the Victorious’ and ‘the Healer’. For example without the pain and suffering of illness we would not appreciate the attribute of God being ‘the Healer’. Knowing God is a greater good, and worth the experience of suffering or pain as it will mean the fulfillment of our primary purpose.

4. People can also suffer from past, present or future sins. God has knowledge of everything which is not contingent on time. Please refer to the story of Khidr in the Qur’an where it mentions Khidr’s reply to Prophet Moses “All this was done as a mercy from your Lord. What I did was not done by my own will. That is the interpretation of those actions which you could not bear to watch with patience.” (Qur’an 18:82)

5. God has given us free choice, and free choice includes choosing evil acts.

Read more here: http://www.hamzatzortzis.com/essays-articles/philosophy-theology/a-response-to-the-problem-of-evil/


I just researched on Hamza Tzortzis after going to that website. He is a good philosopher. But I want to play the devil's advocate here with some of the points;



1. The primary purpose of the human being is not happiness rather it is to know and worship God. This fulfillment of the divine purpose will result in everlasting bliss and happiness. So if this is our primary purpose other aspects of human experience our secondary. The Qur’an, the book of the Muslims states: “I did not create either jinn or man except to worship Me.” (Qur’an 51:56-57)

Incomplete theology and misinterpretation of the Quran. While we were created to worship God, we have 3 options;
-worship him in sadness
-worship him in happiness
-worship him with a neutral state of mind.

The Quran does not say that we should worship in sadness

Imagine someone losing his whole family to a hurricane on Thursday, do you honestly expect to see him in the mosque on Friday? He has to grieve and take time to calm down. The hurricane deaths have affected his ability to worship, so your distinguishing between secondary and primary purposes of human life is not as black and white as you see it.


2. God also created us for a test, and part of this test is to be tested with suffering and evil. The Qur’an mentions “The One Who created death and life, so that He may put you to test, to find out which of you is best in deeds: He is the all-Almighty, the all-Forgiving” (Qur’an 67: 2)

Incomplete theology again. Yes, God tests us but is that all? How do we know when we are tested? To describe somebody losing his whole family to a hurricane as a test from God is borderline psychopathic. We dont know if it is a test or just the way God created the earth to function. Who knows if it is all science and the earth needs such a strong water cycle to keep on surviving as a planet.

I am not saying that God cant test us with hard times. The fact is that we dont know when we are tested and how God tests us. It is rather more reasonable to assume that God tests us with our faith directly rather than with machinations of biology, physics and geology of our bodies and our planet----- I am not sure of this but it seems more sensible

3. Having hardship and suffering enables us to realise and know God’s attributes such as ‘the Victorious’ and ‘the Healer’. For example without the pain and suffering of illness we would not appreciate the attribute of God being ‘the Healer’. Knowing God is a greater good, and worth the experience of suffering or pain as it will mean the fulfillment of our primary purpose.

4. People can also suffer from past, present or future sins. God has knowledge of everything which is not contingent on time. Please refer to the story of Khidr in the Qur’an where it mentions Khidr’s reply to Prophet Moses “All this was done as a mercy from your Lord. What I did was not done by my own will. That is the interpretation of those actions which you could not bear to watch with patience.” (Qur’an 18:82)

5. God has given us free choice, and free choice includes choosing evil acts.


Suffering adds to the experience no doubt.

But if there is a thing like unnecessary suffering then it doesnt bring us closer to God.


Also sins have nothing to do with hurricanes and earthquakes
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 8:29am On Jul 07, 2013
rhymz: "there is no compulsion in religion", really You believe that as a statement of fact or just part of the very wonderful condiments of religious claims even when in reality there is no
such thing as non-compulsive spread of any known major religion, Christianity and Islam bring the chiefs of such methods.
Let's be honest in the way we choose to understand certain claims from our holy books even when it is obvious that such claims do not reconcile with the very ideology of our religion.


Sorry, I do not understand.

What are you trying to say? Please explain.
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 8:27am On Jul 07, 2013
I found your reply to username interesting. I hope you dont mind if I jump in!

tbaba1234:

1. Some of the greatest philosophers and scientists from the muslim world were actually religious scholars or had very good religious background.


That is true. But is it their religion or their personality that made them great scientists or philosophers? I remember having a discussion with christians when I lived in USA about some of their past presidents and founding fathers. The liberals were arguing that many of their great presidents were christians but their religion had nothing to do with their politics, hence, the adoption of the idea of separation of church and state.

I find the liberals' argument interesting.




tbaba1234:
2. The problem in the muslim world is a lack of Islam not a presence of it, Do you know the kind of corruption that exists there? Have you been to any of the gulf countries?

It is not about the wealth. It is the lack of accountability and Justice. It is not a care for the hereafter, it is too much indulgement in this life..

And yes, they care way too much about this life, come to vegas and see how many wealthy arabs come there to gamble. See the obscene wealth among the elites.

Muslim countries have the worst kinds of financial corruption by the elite, the worst kind of racism and class society, the very worst kinds. Even though they claim to follow Islamic law, they make a mockery of the entire process.

I agree with your claim of corruption and injustice in Arab/gulf countries but how can you make the case that it is because of a lack of Islam?

Are countries that are more just having a better dose of Islam? These Arab countries are very religious compared to some (eg Turkey)

I think you meant to say that these countries are practising the wrong Islam or their leaders misunderstand the islam they practice. But then, you will have to explain the correct islamic way of leading a country. This is where I am lost....



tbaba1234:
3. Muslim history is filled with thousands of female scholars, At some point some of the greatest scholars were women and they were dressed exactly the way they dress today probably more conservative. We are not interested in fashion that falls outside the boundaries of Islam.

Have you been to anywhere in the muslim world to even make an assessment of the dressing?? seriously??

Stop this falsehood. There are female scholars in Islamic history but I doubt it is in the thousands that you claim. The Quran, Hadith and Arab history are there. I challenge you to get past 100 female scholars in Islamic history.

Also, there is no fashion that falls outside the boundaries of islam (except nudity). Islam permits modest dressing. An unbiased person would know that "modest" varies and a sensible approach would be to accept all fashions except those which expose private parts.

tbaba1234:
4. Socializing?? It seems you look at Islam from a prism of halal and haram. How many muslims from the Arab world or muslim world have you met to talk about their socializing habits? I have met quite a number, they socialise just fine all within the limits.

In Islam, there are limits. You have to abide by them. It didn't stop them from being at the top of the world in the past. There are fundamental problems beyond socializing.

Agreed here


tbaba1234:
5. Every civilisation will have its highs and lows, the level of corruption amongst muslims today mean that unless we work of establishing Justice and accountability in our societies which are the basis of Islam, we still have a long way before getting to the top.


Agreed

tbaba1234:
6. It is not a matter of been scared, it is a failure of leadership. It is the failure of proper education, we have separated religious knowledge from acquired knowledge, we have made it one or the other when in actual fact they compliment each other.


It is a failure of leadership, agreed!

Religious knowledge and acquired knowledge as you put it, are quite separate. We can learn both but we must first admit that they are different.


tbaba1234:
Before you go criticizing Islamic values, know that those values promoted innovation, took the muslims to the top of world and hundreds of years ahead of europe at some point.

Local technological innovation depends on things you have not mentioned here. It depends on the right education, the right environment politically and socially, the right guidance which comes from understanding the message.

There is no Islamic state in the world today, What we have a pseudo Islamic States. Since the fall of the ottoman, we have no really had an Islamic state.

Thanks.


But was the Ottoman/previous islamic civilization something to emulate when it came to civility? The brutality of that era was frightening.

While I agree with our golden islamic age that produced a lot of great scientific work. We shouldnt carry outdated baggage from that era. This is one of our problem, we carry the outdated culture of the Goldne age rather than its attitude to science and learning
Islam for Muslims / Re: Do We Really Worship An Almighty God? (tough Questions For Tbaba) by Nairatalks: 7:59am On Jul 07, 2013
usermane: Now, why do bad things happen to good people? Becos the so called good people have a somewhat bad past and believe me the past is always affecting the future. The law of retribution always holds. Because despite their goodness, they still do a lot of wrongs, make a lot of poor judgements and decisions, make mistakes they may be too blind to notice.
This what is haunting some islamic nations today. Even though they strive to be good generally, encourage good and forbid evil, they are still lacking in areas of mordernisation, mainly because of a lot of flaws in their lifestyle and mindset, bad things still happen to them, e.g lagging behind technological wise. And as long as they believe their living is flawless ,nothing 's gonna change.
Let me get one thing clear,am not here to bash muslims as my post may appear to some of you folks. Am here to speak the truth from my own understanding or observation. Its just happen that the truth doesnt favours the muslims in this subject. And am not forcing anyone to accept or believe all my write up. I just gave a response to the OP and anyone dissatified can let us know his/her answer or version of the truth as well.


I dont believe in your theory of retribution.

-However, I think the case may be that certain things are random and certain things a a direct result of actions

Random
We should learn to take the good with the bad. We should accept our blessings whenever they fall upon us. If something bad happens, we should try to solve it rather than lament all day. We dont know the mind of God therefore, it is better for us to focus on solutions rather than attributing every single moment in our life to Him.


Direct actions
Regarding the case of our islamic countries today, people should realise that many muslims mix culture and religion together. Some things in religion are outdated or are a practice of culture. Take for instance, Burkha or Niqaab- women that wear the veil or cover up are not anymore religious or better dressed than women who do not. This is a culture that got mixed up in islam. A woman can cover up her whole body or not- it is her choice. However, any man or woman who claims that it is good religion or better or a must to wear the veil is confusing ancient Arab/Jewish/Middle eastern culture with religion.

We should take responsiblity for our actions. Many of our muslim brethren in silamic countries practice outdated things and mix culture with religion then complain when their countries are not progressing or are far behind the west in certain Areas.

1 Like

(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (of 6 pages)

(Go Up)

Sections: politics (1) business autos (1) jobs (1) career education (1) romance computers phones travel sports fashion health
religion celebs tv-movies music-radio literature webmasters programming techmarket

Links: (1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6) (7) (8) (9) (10)

Nairaland - Copyright © 2005 - 2024 Oluwaseun Osewa. All rights reserved. See How To Advertise. 130
Disclaimer: Every Nairaland member is solely responsible for anything that he/she posts or uploads on Nairaland.