Nimshi's Posts
Nairaland Forum › Nimshi's Profile › Nimshi's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 (of 34 pages)
rampagain:Unfortunately, what you've written is true, not only for some Muslims in Nigeria, but elsewhere too. It is sorry that some have lost their way of venerating the holy Prophet (PBUH) s much that Almighty Allah takes second place; many of these do this without realising it. Some are honest to examine themselves when this is pointed out to them; others resist, even before they have heard what the objection is. There are examples. . |
ayinba1:How will Nimshi derail this thread? Questions about salat will only continue to be asked. Others will come here to post questions as they wish. Those who have already contributed to the discussion may have new questions. Anyone reading existing answers may think of some new angle meriting discussion. For these reasons, the thread will be alive, even if Nimshi or anyone else do not anymore contribute to it. ayinba1:Shaitan ought to be in chains all the time, Ramadan or no Ramadan. This is sorry. . |
olabowale:I will reply some of your post because some of your post contains soem substance. But I should advice you to stop your wretched attempts at sarcasm; you don't do it well; and it reflects badly on you. It is sorry to go down this road, but your reasoning - what you've offered of it on these pages - leave much to be desired. (O people! I allowed you the Mut`ah marriage with women before. Now, Allah has prohibited it until the Day of Resurrection. Therefore, anyone who has any women in Mut`ah, let him let them go, and do not take anything from what you have given them.) Allah's statement, [وَلاَ جُنَاحَ عَلَيْكُمْ فِيمَا تَرَاضَيْتُمْ بِهِ مِن بَعْدِ الْفَرِيضَةِ]First off; would you then agree that you went foul of historical facts when you said at the beginning that there is no Mut'a in Islam? Think about this carefully. Then the same question follows from the above: Did the holy Prophet (PBUH) allow Zina? Think carefully about this question. If you're able to articulate your thoughts, allowing knowledge and the practices of the faith by faithfuls all over the face of the earth guide you, then you may have done everyone - and principally yourself - some good. It's a worthy exercise, even if you come to the same conclusion as before. "The Messenger of Allah prohibited Mut`ah marriage and eating the meat of domesticated donkeys on the day of Khaybar (battle).''Did you think about the above? Breathe deeply, and think about the statement. I could helo with a simple question: One what day did the Messenger of Almighty Allah prohibit Mut'a marriage and the eating of domesticated donkeys? Now, think about at least two interpretations of that question. Do it; think. Now, do you see another possibility or not? (O people! I allowed you the Mut`ah marriage with women before. Now, Allah has prohibited it until the Day of Resurrection. Therefore, anyone who has any women in Mut`ah, let him let them go, and do not take anything from what you have given them.) Allah's statement, [وَلاَ جُنَاحَ عَلَيْكُمْ فِيمَا تَرَاضَيْتُمْ بِهِ مِن بَعْدِ الْفَرِيضَةِ]What's your source for this? Your post says: "In his Sahih, Muslim recorded that Ar-Rabi` bin Sabrah bin Ma`bad Al-Juhani said that his father said that, " Can you recognise how many links in that chain? Could you supply a verse from the Holy Quran explicitly prohibiting Mut'a? Is there a verse negating what we read at Sura 4 Ayat 24? There is none, to my knowledge (see my discussion of your "self-restaint" comment below. I want to note again that I am here talking of Mut'a of marriage; there is another Mut'a; we may or may not get to that. Yet, it is confirmed that Mut'a marriage was legal, and without opposition from the Holy Prophet (PBUH) during the time of the Holy Prophet. Do you want references from respectable scholars? I can give plenty. olabowale:Do you always conclude so prematurely? Do you know what Mut'a involves? How could you jump to the death of the conclusion that Mut'a implies little or no restraint? Your bias has run so far ahead of your reasoning that you're lost; sorry to come hard on you. This is arrogance; it is worse than ignorance. No, not because you don't agree, but because you're not engaging your mind to recognise nuances where there are shades of gray. Mut's marriage requires restraint. We know what promiscuity is, we know what fornication is. If you say that Mut'a of marriage is fornication, are you then saying that the holy Prophet allowed fornication and promiscuity? This the question you need to answer. Answer this question, and you'D have done some good. |
babs787:No. In fact, you have failed to answer direct, follow-up questions. I re-post them here for your attention and that of anyone who may have missed them: Given the submission you gave about Mut'a: 1) The above is a clear admission that there (at least) was Mut'a in Islam. Do you disagree? 2) It is a fact that the Prophet (PBUH) 'allowed' Mut'a marriage. Do you disagree? The above needs to be established before moving forward. It is my hope that you're able to respond unambiguously. Would you reply unambiguously and specifically? . |
ayinba1: below, I offer specific responses to your post. Should I miss anything out, be kind to point it out if you so wish. ayinba1:Your belief here is an assumption. The post you refer to moves the discussion forward, but isn't it perhaps too early to make a call? Simply because you encounter opinion that appears reasonable cannot imply that you've exhausted all possibilities. There are cracks in that submission; it is wise to examine it in detail. ayinba1:I apologise for posting strange terms; discussion is only possible and reasonable if we're all understand the terms used in the same way. I had wrongly assumed; from now, I'll try to be clear and assist with explanations. It is interesting that you checked my other posts on this forum. It is even more interesting that your post appears to hint that you hoped to figure if I was a Muslim from my posts. Let's go forward. ayinba1:Is the use of Sallam now the litmus test for faith? This is not a rhetorical question; I should appreciate your response to it. Again, is the mispelling of the holy name a litmus test for knowledge? And yes, I agree that the verse is valid injunction; it was quoted to inspire a discussion. Perhaps that discussion will happen someday. ayinba1:Oh, probably yes. What exactly do you mean by this? I ask because this is the first thing I'd not understand in your post so far. What exactly do you mean? ayinba1:Then, the questions following the assertions above are: 1) Were alcohol consumption and gambling Zina? 2) Did Almighty Allah allow Zina? Are you brave enough to attempt to answer these valid questions? Or, would you decree that the questions should not be asked? ayinba1:These are ambiguous questions. "Who are you?" What would I tell you - if I wished - that would satisfy you? "What are you?" What would I tell you - should I wish - that'll satistfy you? In any case, these questions are irrelevant to the substance of the discussion that's on. ayinba1:Could you show me an example of me evading a direct question? And particularly this question? I doubt that your allegation is valid. ayinba1:It is something in your favour to write the above. But, I should tell you: my sincerity shouldn't really be your concern (hint: you have no way of really knowing my sincerity); you ought to continue to concern yourself with my expressed opinion. It is futile to chase "sincerity". Yet, if you would wish for an assurance of sincerity on my part, I perhaps could give it. ayinba1:Have you considered that your thoughts may be wrong? If you haven't, you should. One of the potent distractions in discussions is what you appear to be preoccupied with. Could you deal with that which is clear: the expressed opinion and questions? And, are two options the only possible/plausible options? Do not limit yourself. Somewhere in your posts, you quoted comments from me from someplace else on this forum: "My favourite senior pastor don enter TV. I dey come"Yes, I wrote that, and I did mean it. He is my favourite pastor. So? And: Even Jesus work part time for instant-party brewery.Yes, I did write that. So? Where is your criticism? This I can offer: one of the friends here have advised that it is better to write in English rather than in Pidgin; I found the reasons arresting. It is more difficult for me to write in English, yet, I have tried. I may return to the more natural Pidgin. If you have any comment/question about any of my posts anywhere on this board, do post. Would it make any difference if I ended with Sallam? Salam. . |
olabowale:Your preoccupation with Shaitan has reached the point of obsession; so much so that when asked about farting, you offered up Shaitan as the reason for farting during salat. It's a new outlook Shaitan as reason for everything gone wrong, even from wind from the rectal orifice. Mediocrity. . |
ayinba1:ayinba1, here's the explanation. babs787 asked if the purpose of the thread has been achieved. (The past tense "achieved" carries the notion of a finality). My response mean that the thread must grow as we continue discussing salat; it must grom, like a well-watered plant; it is not like a building of concete which emerges fully formed. I hope that's helpful. . |
babs787:Going by the options you chose to put on the table, what do you think? . |
babs787:In this case, I have no documented support; that's the reason for putting this out there. I have requested the fellow who wrote these to assist with references. Item 1) makes some sense within the context of other nawagis (that's not to mean that one says it is definitely so, but that were vomiting to occur, one would rather advice that wudu be restarted); Item 2) should make sense, but there are 'natural' extenuating circumstances; Item 3) is the tough one. Needs more understanding/finding. It is good to seek it. As to the purpose of the thread, it's more like a living plant than a building of concrete. I believe you should understand that. . |
Now, to the substance of your post: Was Muta Marriage in Islam?Let's stop here for now. 1) The above is a clear admission that there (at least) was Mut'a in Islam. Do you disagree? 2) It is a fact that the Prophet (PBUH) 'allowed' Mut'a marriage. Do you disagree? The above needs to be established before moving forward. It is my hope that you're able to respond unambiguously. . |
babs787:Let's get these out of the way before addressing the substance of your post: 1) What's the meaning of "some of your folks, "? And, how could you quickly conclude anything about my understanding of context? It is quite a foolish (you must excuse the word, and it's for want of an apt one) thing for you to write this; how could you be commenting about a matter you've no way of knowing about? 2) I am not making an allegation; I am referring to words in the Holy Quran, and will further reference reasoning, history, and scholarship. I have not declared my current position as unchangeable; when the facts change, so must my understanding. You should be ashamed of the assumptions you made, particularly, your appearance of imputing a bad motive. You wouldn't be feeling attacked if you haven't been conditioned to being defensive. There's no dividend in it; so you ought to stop it. . |
ayinba1: thanks for the heads-up. The question has been responded to in more direct terms. tpia may be a distraction, but we must remember that even a broken timepiece is correct at least once a day. Especially when questions are asked, it is important to pay attention. And in this specific case, tpia's question appeared to be valid; in fact, a direct answer the question adds good value to the discussion. . |
babs787:A direct question. Good. And the answer is the topic of this thread and matters related to it. . |
olabowale:There you are, flaunting your foolishness. The rest of your post deserves no response; your words were a waste of space and bandwidth: you clearly did not understand the meaning of the opinion you're posing to be against. You're sth of a disgrace to Islam. . |
Why not? Since one example is all that's needed, the answer to your question is yes. But a lot depends on the parties. If one is aggressively attempting to convert the other, then the chance of success almost always becomes reduced. olabowale:It is clearly a lack of wisdom that makes anyone write this sort of nonsense. It is foolishness; it should be beneath anyone with any wisdom. |
olabowale:Your aggressiveness is transparent, and it is unwarranted. Who's the professor? You? Climb down, mortal man; climb down. Where did you develop the omniscient powers to figure that I refused to research? Discussion breeds new ideas; there's only so much one could learn on their own. Questions are asked for different reasons; sometimes, to provoke responses: you never know how such responces will lead to other positive things. A clear example is the contribution I just commented on; a contribution that's far superior to that weak attempt to blame farting on Shaitan. All in all, you appear to be in need of knowledge, to which you may then apply wisdom (which you may or may not have). Cease being aggressive and imputing bad motives to others; perhaps then, you'll be able to help even yourself. Now, enough about this. Let's return to important matters. . |
babs787:Shouldn't the lsit also include other nawaqis? 1) vomiting 2) flow of blood or pus out of any part of the body 3) laughter ? Would these three not also invalidate wudu? . |
babs787:The above, (and all else following it) is a substantive contribution to the discussion; here we have an example of a "rule" that could be useful even when unfamiliar situations arise. The rule isn't perfect (we decline a criticism at this time); but it's very useful. This contribution is appreciated. And because we live to learn, it is important that some of us pay attention so as to leave with something valuable and positive. . |
olabowale:What a reaction! It is evil to mention Mut'a in Islam?! It is Zina! Shut it down if you don't disagree with it, right? Too bad, knowledge, and wisdom is out there; so, my friends, examine it. First off: if it was/is Zina, are you suggesting that the Prophet (PBUH) allowed Zina? Are you? Anyway, the definitive text is found in the Holy Quran 4:24, the so-called verse of Mut'a. The Holy Quran 4:24 - . . . and wedded women, save what your right hands own. So God prescribes for you. Lawful for you, beyond all that, is that you may seek, using your wealth, in wedlock and not in licence. Such wives as you enjoy thereby, give them their wages apportionate; it is no fault in you in your agreeing together, after the due apportionate. God is All-knowing, All-wise. (Source: http://quran-online.net/) So, there you have it. And before proceeding, let's be specific: this is the "Mut'a of women". I write that for be benefit of anyone denying that there is no Mut'a in Islam; perhaps, the Mut'a of pilgrimage may be helpful in not substituting the practical meaning with the linguistic one. If knowledge is being filtered through translations, then let's begin looking at the Arabic. There can be references: both to clear reasoning and scholars and to history, to the extent of the confirmation that this was legal during the time of the Prophet (PBUH) Sura 4 Ayat 24 refers to Mut'a, or Temporary Marriage; the holy book sets out what it is. Let anyone willing to discuss approach with knowledge and not empty words. . |
olabowale:olabowale: this is directly against the spirit of discussion, both your comment and the rather thinly veiled insinuation. Perhaps you're talking about what you know little about? First you give a rather oblique (that's being quite polite) contribution on the reasoning behind wudu being broken a fart: olabowale:I will without any apologies state that the above as reason for a fart emanating from a person's bodily functions is meaningless. You could blame Shaitan for many things if you do like, but hardly for the gas emanating from your rear. Yet, you cite non-specific sources and then broadly advice research; either you've a basis for what you're writing or not; this isn't a forum for children waiting to receiving instructions without some crtitique; if that's what you're used used to, then too bad; such learning by rote does nothing to improve a person. . |
Thank you for the attempt to look it up; please share anything you end up finding. It's more important to have a grasp of guiding principles than having to cram individual injunctions. Regards. . |
rajisaliu:Rather than call this "the more correct view", isn't it more apt to call it the view that spreads the risk of missing the exact date? And, we could move on from the numerology and superstition: why the odd-numbered nights? And why the 27th specifically? We may speak of convention; but [b]more correct[/b]ness? . |
reindeer:The above, one must say, is another myth in the resolution of local violence. It sure helps for influential/respected members of the society to speak out, but to suppose that this could stop the violence is to ask for too much. It is true that many influential people have not publicly spoken out, yet, influential people are speaking out too; random violence doesn't benefit everyone. It is also a misconception to suppose that the loudest voices at the scene respresent the faith; no, they don't. Criticism is effective when not generalized. reindeer:One must agree that censorship, by deletion of posts, is a terribe way to deal with discussion. . |
zayhal:Could you then discuss the underlying reasoning for this conclusion? If you have sources, could you point to them? A related question would be whether farting invalidates Wudu. Would one need to begin again? More important is the reasoning guiding the answer. . |
The racism is emerging from the depths of the soul. It's not new. "I want Obama to be POTUS because he is (identified as) black". "I want Obama to win because he is our brother". Yeye dey boom like atomic bomb. Nonsense dey alive well well. Head ashaking. . |
ayinba1:This is correct. There were murderers on both sides. To begin pointing fingers is to display bias, and an insensitivity to those barbaric events. bilymuse:You may have been up to sth rather good, but you spoiled it all with your opening statement: ", what is it about this Muslims that make them blood thirsty, ". To begin to think these thoughts, and then further type them, is - to exaggerate a little - quite unforgivable. Muslims, bloodthirsty? "[T]this (sic) Muslims , bloodthirsty"?! What a shame. Before painting with such a wide brush of hate, have you considered that violence has no religion? Think a bit and free yourself from the bondage of your misconceptions. bilymuse:Then you probably have no family/relatives living in the North? And/or, you're not a Northerner? And/or you have no friends in the North who've made the North their homes? What as shame to read this sort of opinion. "Northern terrorist"; what is that? Your prejudice and 'racism' is apparent as is your rather incoherent rambling. Sorry to come down hard on you this way; your words deserve no less. . |
abdulreal: here is some practical advice to you. Any of the brothers or sisters could post their knowledge about these matters for clarification. One will not condemn you because you already judged yourself to be wrong. Knowledge is however a shield. Perhaps you should have contracted a Mut'a marriage with your lady friend and taken care of your pleasure and hers and not be in the wrong? You could get some knowledge on this. . |
olabowale:This is a clearly-reasoned and delivered answer. But I have another related to it. Can this new convert, in all righteousness, contract Mut'a Marriage with a Muslim woman? How short could a Mut'a Marriage be? . |
olabowale:What about a fart? Does an involuntary loud or silent fart nullify salat? . |
You know, you just may have ended the justification for the no-open-mouth-in-the-toilet law by saying it is the law of Almighty Allah and that of his Propphet (PBUH), and ended it there. But you didn't. You went ahead to give a justification that should make thinking people question your reasoning: olabowale wrote: @Poster: Not talking in toilet, is more religious and also hygenic.The statement in bold is unsound for a number of reasons. First off, it is irrelevant to the invasion of the mouth with germs whether or not it was necessary to open the mouth; stated differently: airborne germs are not sensitive to the necessity of opening the mouth; either they invade or not. Second - and more important - where is the support for the claim that germs invade the mouth when the mouth is opened in the toilet. Whether or not there are airborne germs in a toilet will involve several factors; do these matter at all? Could you reason this law out with one willing to follow your thinking? If you're not able to do that, then quit attempting to justify the law other than simply saying you will do anything you believe to the law of Almighty Allah and his Prophet (PBUH). . |
olabowale: why being aggressive? The poster asked a valid question. Forget about New Zealand, forget the cheap shots. Give a clear explanation to the seeker of knowledge. If you have sought knowledge to further than the far East, even as the Prophet (PBUH) noted, then you ought to share it. Where does this "dissertation" (apologies) fit into life today? What is Zina? Did you notice where the long submission explained what zina is? If you did, then share it. . |
javalove:Quite a loving response, this one. abdulreal: any improvements? Have you sought the face of the Supreme One? Are things looking better? Anyone who is able to help this man should lend a hand. It is not the time to kick him. He believes/admits he has done wrong; more than nice words, lend a hand if you could. . |