PastorAIO's Posts
Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 (of 287 pages)
malvisguy212:No, Actually it is a promise that one day it will be written on their hearts. Paul on the other hand admits that the Gentiles have always had the law written on their hearts. |
malvisguy212:Don't worry about this part it seems that you are really busy attacking Muslims and anyway this part hasn't got anything to do with the main bone of contention which is morality not whether the existence of evil supports God or not. If how to answer this is what is keeping you away, please don't worry, come back lets continue to discuss morality. |
malvisguy212:Now to put the lie to that unorthodoxy that Paul wrote.... It would seem that God favoured the Gentiles more than the Jews in regard to this his moral law. Why? Well he said this to them through Jeremiah: For this is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days, declares the LORD: I will put my law within them, and I will write it on their hearts. And I will be their God, and they shall be my people. So the gentiles had the law of God written on their hearts which the Jews didn't so they had to be given the written code and only promised the one written on the heart later. Why would God deprive his own people so? Unless someone is BS-ing us. Either Jeremiah or Paul. Or maybe the Jews were so morally depraved that they didn't have access to the law on their hearts and so needed to get it in written form first. |
Weah96:e squeeze mi! Perhaps I could help. I think that maybe we should make a distinction between God, the office, and God, the personality. An office may bear certain functions that can be fulfilled by various persons. Many people may be president of US, but there is only one presidency of US. The OP, maybe, I don't know, may be asking if there is such an office as God that presumably is responsibly for such functions as creating and maintaining the universe. The question of who fills this office, whether amadioha, sango or Jehovah is not pertinent right now. Weah96 may believe that such an office as 'God' exists but disbelieve that it is filled by any such beings as Jehovah, Allah etc. Abeg, Am I right? |
Are you now agreeing with me because you've thought about what I've said and recognised it to be true? Or are now agreeing because you've found a passage in the bible that concurs with me and you let the bible do your thinking for you? Yes, the gentiles had Morals. Yes, a great deal of the time their morals concurred with those of the Jews. But they also did many things that they felt were morally right however were considered immoral by the Jews. And they also found many things morally abhorrent that the Jews did due to their Moral Law. For example, they found circumcision barbaric. So you see that we are all automatically Moral creatures. The next phase is to understand how and why we are moral and to ascertain whether it really absolutely means that there must be a moral law giver. malvisguy212: |
malvisguy212:You have made an error. Nobody 'creates' moral values for themselves. Morality is instinctive. You don't create sexual desire, it is an instinct. when you see a fine woman there is no contrivance involved in the raising of your phallus. It happens automatically. Now that is probably a great example because just as there are a multiplicity of moral codes there also a variety of sexual types. Some phallus' raise for fat girls, some raise for short girls, others raise for chanel perfume, while others raise only for oyinbo. There is no single standard of a sexually alluring person. Sexuality develops along various lines in different people. So it is with Morality. |
malvisguy212:This one is more than circular, it loops and dives and 'boomerangs' upon itself in a variety of ways. 1) From the very start, you have God right there in the premises. 'God created everything'. 2) Why bother with the evil part. why not just say, God created Good and there are good things in the world so therefore God exists. The evil part is an extra appendage. 3) Evil is not a thing, and neither is Good. It is a functional state of things. Both are. A knife chopping vegetables for dinner is good for the diners. a knife stuck in someone's gut is evil. Good and evil functions can be found for just about any object. None of these suggest the existence of God in the slightest. 4)The idea of evil as a lack of deficiency of good is Rubbish. when a knife is slicing your guts nothing in the knife is deficient. The knife remains intact. Rather Good and Evil are interwoven like Yin and Yang. They are two sides of a single coin. You cannot say one side is based on the other side. The nonexistence of one is also the nonexistence of the other. There is no such thing as UP if there is no such thing as DOWN. |
malvisguy212:Yes, I'm a theist. The word christian means nothing to me, but I'm a theist. I do not agree that the presence of evil indicates that a god exists. If anything it actually casts doubt on the existence of God if indeed such a god is omnipotent. |
malvisguy212:Yes, I believe that many people have invented their 'God'. Command: What about the command that you give to a Computer? What about all the commands that you give to yourself? When you want to lose weight and you put yourself on a diet, have you not commanded yourself to only eat so much and at set times? Again, having a moral Law (objective or not) doesn't necessarily have anything to do with any Law giver. |
malvisguy212:So do you agree or not when the bible says that the serpent is crafty. More crafty than any other animal that God made. How much of an influence did this craftiness have on the serpents speech. I did not in anyway supported genocide, the people you claimed God kill,are they Morally Equivalent? The dog steal the bone and run because of greed.I didn't claim God killed anyone, I claimed that the Bible says that God instructed the Hebrew to commit genocide on the Canaanites. If this claim is wrong and the bible didn't say such a thing then I was wrong and I apologise, although I'm sure that that is precisely what the bible says. I don't know what you mean by 'Morally equivalent'. Do you mean that killing Canaanites is not morally equivalent to killing Jews? Are you saying that Greed is Morally okay? A greedy dog steals a bone and that is morally okay, but a greedy human steals and that is a morally wrong deed? Let me give you one example :[quote]What is the above an example of? I know the different between Laws of nature and Moral Laws, but I don't see what this has to do with what we are discussing. |
malvisguy212:I've explained that Morality can be put down to Instinct. Like all instincts if it can be proved to facilitate survival then we can understand how it would evolve. Then Morality can serve also as an explanation for why people would invent a god as you are aptly demonstrating that you have difficulty imagining one without the other. |
malvisguy212:I don't recall making any excuses for anything. I was simply answering your questions. The op was talking about morality concerning evil , you and I know dogs steal the bone of others dogs and NO one charge him for evil , animal have intercourse with any of their female animals and no one charge him for rape, why will you charge your fellow human of rape ?I maintain , objective morality proved the existence of God. Genesis 3 The Fall 3 Now the serpent was more crafty than any of the wild animals the Lord God had made. He said to the woman, “Did God really say, ‘You must not eat from any tree in the garden’?” In this tale, was the serpent, an animal, evil? (Not that I believed the serpents talk, but I'm sure you do.) another consideration: when A dog steals bone or meat will it stand there innocently eating the bone or will it immediately run away and eat it in a hiding place. If the dog has no sense of doing wrong then why is it hiding? You say God commit genocide in murdering the cannanite but to you the evil this same cannanite commit is not Genocide, NEVER for once God oder the killing of innocent people.You've confused Legality with Morality. Slavery was once legal but it didn't sit right with some people's sense of morality and so they advocated to get it changed. I have no record of Canaanites committing any evil. Perhaps you can tell me what it is they did. anyway, the bottom line is that according to you it can be okay to commit genocide and not be morally evil. If you cannot blame the Hebrews as evil for killing Canaanites, then how do you want to blame Nazis as evil for killing Jews. |
joseph1013:And also if we can understand the causes that drive our behaviour we will be in a better position to come to some harmony with ourselves and our environment. In other words, we would be able to do religion better. |
malvisguy212:What about Animals?? Animals make choices too, yes. Dogs, for instance, They love to poo everywhere but after some training they only poo in the right place. Of course the dog still feels like pooing but if it is in the house it must make the decision due to it's training to wait until it is taken for a walk before it poos. Is that what you're getting at? Are you an atheist?No! Most atheists believe animals have soul , why can't they make moral decision ?How are you sure that they don't make moral decisions? Do you have any examples of any decisions that are not moral decisions? The nazi legalised the killing of the Jews in their camp, will you called this law good ( subjectively) ?Let me answer you with a similar question. The Hebrews committed mass genocide against the Canaanites as recorded in the bible, due to directive from Yahweh. Will you call this directive good? |
joseph1013:There is a lot of psychology in all facets of human behaviour. |
malvisguy212:Because humans have a moral instinct. Instincts are not Rational things and can be quite divorced from our thoughts and beliefs. For example, We all have a survival instinct. Why? Is survival better than death? Even people living in the most abject state of deprivation will still struggle to survive. Even people who believe in a better life after death will still do everything in their power to avoid death. It can be argued that due to the fact that humans are instinctively moral we then project an image of a Law giver. In other words our instinctive morality is an explanation for why we've invented God rather than the other way of God being an explanation for our morality. The big difficulty lies in the fact that no two cultures, nay, no two people share exactly the same moral code. This might point to a multiplicity of Gods. Otherwise we'd have to explain how a single Law giver would give such a diversity of laws to humankind. |
Everybody should be free to boast about what they can boast about. At least he knows that he cannot say he has made a impact on the world more than Bill Gates, or contributed to the world as much as Bill Gates. |
joseph1013: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-j8ZMMuu7MU |
dolphinheart:Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? |
Eddlad:Wow! Weah96 walked straight past that one and didn't call it up. Was it an act of mercy? Or an oversight? |
But the biggest Irony of Christian hypocrisy is that the main thrust of Jesus' teaching were against Hypocrisy. And now we have the most hypocritical religion on the planet supposedly based upon Jesus Christ. |
joseph1013:No I haven't, but I will do soon. I also haven't forgotten that I still have to get back to you on the other thing. |
joseph1013:How about a true Self that is coterminous with one's circumstances, even to the extent of encompassing the entire universe? What I believe can be close to that is the ability to exercise self awareness. Like I have said before, Genes and Circumstances affect us in more ways than we cannot totally explain, and for some of these things we do not have control over them. What we have control over is how we handle what we can handle. Something like, why do I hate whites? Is it because of what happened during the slave trade? Again, should I let that affect whites who had no hand in the slave trade?But with all these cases, our thinking is influenced by the information available to us. That is different for everybody. Different people with different information will come to different conclusions. I don't see how you can arrive at a superior Truth via this means. The only way to think critically would be to have access to all the information in the universe. This is impossible for us. It was seem then that Rationality or Pure Reason is beyond are capabilities. I believe this is a lifelong process. There will be occasional relapse but agin quickly acknowledging these relapse and keeping emotions in check is key.There might seem to be moments or relapse and moments of progress but ultimately how can you progress or relapse when you don't have a standard or a goal you are progressing towards or relapsing away from. How can you make any judgment or evaluation without a standard? |
Demigods:What about if after death he meets God and God says, 'correct guy, I see you like to use the faculties I gave you. In fact that was the true test of life, and you, my son, have passed. So come on in to the garden of glory that has been prepared for you from the beginning of days.' While to the religious he orders his angels to cast them into the burning lake of fire. It is one thing arguing the existence of God. Then it is quite another thing arguing as to what his character is and what he will approve or disapprove of. |
joseph1013:A lot has happened since we started, and I haven't been so consistent on this site. But the Long and short of our discussion so far starts from 1: You said certain things about indoctrination and mind control in religion and it's tendency to make people violent. Which led to us talking about critical thinking and teaching people to think critically. 2: I tried to make the point that all thinking, critical or otherwise, is based on certain criteria that are quite arbitrary. When trying to think about what is Right or True, such a process would require a criteria that was not arbitrary but Adamant. 3. Can such an Adamant basis of our thinking and behaviour exist? Is there a true self? i.e.. a true self that is independent from the accidental self that has been shaped by circumstances and indoctrination. This is at least what I think we have been discussing. |
FOLYKAZE:Maybe a donkey (Ass) or an Ox. At least there is still hope for those ones. And answered them, saying, Which of you shall have an ass or an ox fallen into a pit, and will not straightway pull him out on the sabbath day? |
FOLYKAZE:So what kind of animal are you? |
UyiIredia:That is high praise, sir. Very high praise indeed. I would be worried if you could classify me or stick me in a box. |
joseph1013:I see no reason why genes should be the core of a personality above one's circumstances. Are not your genes themselves circumstantial? They are not fixed but constantly undergo mutations and graftings. Genetic material is constantly being added to our gene pool from outside. For instance from viruses everytime we get an infection. My point is that there is no Right way for a person to be unless there is a True Adamant Core. I'm not prepared to say that this Adamant Core is his genetic material (something that we know is constantly shifting and can be manipulated), however for the purpose of argument I accepted it hypothetically. Once we can accept that there is a True Adamant Core to a person and that circumstances can cause him to veer away from this Core then we can talk about a person ethically being on the Right path or on the wrong path. If we are driven by various urges to do the things that we do and there is a Deep seated Urge that is hardwired into us then no matter how much we gratify out various other urges, if we leave that core urge ungratified we will have a deep sense of dissatisfaction no matter how much gratifications we are getting elsewhere. |
elantraceey:Are you suggesting new denominations. |
johnydon22:Jesus has already defined what he means by 'brother' or even 'neighbour'. His usage of such terms are explained in the Parable of the Good Samaritan. |
stephendamsoho:So you believe there's a difference. |
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 110 111 112 113 114 115 116 117 118 (of 287 pages)
Your point is?To be honest, I have lost track of our discussion. Couple of things have come between it.