₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,866 members, 8,519,891 topics. Date: Tuesday, 17 November 2026 at 01:30 AM

Toggle theme

PastorAIO's Posts

Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 (of 287 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Atheists, What's Your Opinion On This One? by PastorAIO: 12:09am On Nov 27, 2018
johnydon22:
Nope
Please enlighten me.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheists, What's Your Opinion On This One? by PastorAIO: 9:31pm On Nov 26, 2018
johnydon22:
Nope. Meaningless
Doesn't the definition of one automatically define the other?
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheists, What's Your Opinion On This One? by PastorAIO: 9:30pm On Nov 26, 2018
johnydon22:
Even though I think the context of your definition is not even close to the context which "meaningless" is used in theOP. Ok though.

So, when the OP said everything is meaningless what does that imply?
He might mean (oops) a state of alienation. A disconnection between the activities that he is engaged in and his inner emotional states and his aspirations.
Christianity Etc › Re: Atheists, What's Your Opinion On This One? by PastorAIO: 9:11pm On Nov 26, 2018
johnydon22:
The question here is; When you say "meaningless" what are you implying?

Define "meaningless"
Define Meaning?


Is meaning not just a Reference? Events refer to other events in some way or the other therefore we can say that event A means event B.

e.g. There are puddles of water on the ground. ... that means that it must have rained last night.

The quest for meaning is just based on the believe that events are not isolated by connected to other events. And the more the various events in our lives are connected the more meaningful life is and the more content we are about life.

So we have a basic need to connect events in life. That is our quest for Meaning.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op):
Ihedinobi3:
So, after nine days, you come back to throw more insults and make spurious claims.

I believe we are done now. You have no further arguments to make, no ability to hold up the claims in your OP and no ability to actually effectively counter anything I have said. And I am not just saying that: the proof is in the reading.

Basically, your thread fails to show that the Bible that Christians rely on today has any problems such as you labored to show in your OP. The Septuagint was a fair work as far as it went but it was problematic and the work of the Masoretes later on to produce a faithful reproduction of the original Tanakh did not produce anything that can be considered an invention without connection to what existed prior to the Septuagint nor can it be considered a derivative of the Septuagint in any way.

Furthermore, the Bible is a living book able and ready to declare its identity to anyone who asks. It is not some dumb book that councils pronounce upon and events happen to. It defends itself and has remained accessible through the millennia to all those who seek the Truth in spite of the obvious attacks on it by men like you, PastorAIO.

That is my conclusion.
As idiotic as ever. Why couldn't you just address accurately what I wrote? Why can't you just follow an argument and answer questions that are asked of you when you make claims?

Anyway, in your mind you are very clever and that's all that matters to you, it seems. In spite of the fact that everyone else on this thread has told you you are off point.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 10:28am On Nov 26, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
It should have been obvious by now that as far as you are concerned, there is no stopping my being a dunce since I am not going to agree with you on the reliability of the Bible. That is why I am a dunce, isn't it? Because I disagree with you and have the temerity to say so, right?
No, wrong again.

You are a Dunce because you cannot follow an argument and you fail to answer simple questions. You are a dunce, not so much because you make daft arguments but because you are stupid enough to think that you can get those daft arguments past me.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 10:24am On Nov 26, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
It is false that you said that you had a penchant for making up words. You said, "I made the word up myself". As I said, you've lost track of this discussion.

And why would I be googling a word in this case if I wasn't researching your arguments?
I've said this so many times in my history of Nairaland, but perhaps you missed it.

Why would you google a word you didn't know, or understand? You tell me smartypants. Especially as you want to respond to the thread, why would you google it to find out what it is you are responding to?
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 10:22am On Nov 26, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
I'll take this to mean that you're unwilling for reasons of your own to engage productively anymore.
Nope, wrong again. I simply showed you that you were spouting rubbish. mendacious rubbish. You made a claim that I agreed with you on something. I asked you to show me where I agreed with you and you responded with copious amounts of rubbish instead of just showing where I said anything in agreement with you.
It's your inability to follow such a simple thread of conversation that leads me to concluded that you are an absolute dullard.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 10:18am On Nov 26, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
It's been proving rather impossible so far for you to show the rubbish in my posts.

And you're the one talking about likes, not me. Classic appeal to popularity...or lack of it.
Au contraire, your posts are replete with rubbish. Pick any paragraph and the chances are 50/50 that it is complete utter rubbish. I, and not only I, have pointed this out to you over and over again.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is The Hebrew Monotheistic Belief A Product Of Religious Syncretism? by PastorAIO: 6:09pm On Nov 21, 2018
JMAN05:
I understand your point. Considering the fact that even some books like Chronicle and Nehemiah were written many years after the Pentateuch was written. Yet we see the writers used Hebrew in the write-up. Again, The translators of the OT into what we know as LXX, had to understanh hebrew VERY WELL to translate, and at about the third century. Checking it from 1200 BC, that is a whole lot of time. Yet they did the translation. But those in Judah was still using Hebrew before the LXX came to them.

Secondly, we see Paul even make use of Hebrew.

Acts 21:39-40

Then Paul said: “I am, in fact, a Jew, of Tarsus in Ci·liʹcia, a citizen of no obscure city. So I beg you, permit me to speak to the people.” 40 After he gave permission, Paul, standing on the stairs, motioned with his hand to the people. When a great silence fell, he addressed them in the Hebrew language, saying:...."


Paul said alot there in Hebrew. These shows that those there understood Hebrew. I do understand your point, but since Hebrew played a significant role both in the Leturgy and religious instruction, it may not have died out as we see in other languages.
There are a number of points that we should also take into account.

Firstly, Aramaic was often conflated with Hebrew when people spoke about it. Indeed the languages are related.

So When Acts says that Paul addressed the crowd in 'Hebrew' it could quite possibly mean Aramaic.

Thirdly, when we hear that the book of Matthew was written in Hebrew what was actually meant was Aramaic.

Papias stated very clearly:
"Matthew compiled the sayings [of the Lord] in the Aramaic language, and everyone translated them as well as he could"

https://www.catholic.com/qa/was-matthews-gospel-first-written-in-aramaic-or-hebrew

In the same source you find....
Origen wrote, "Among the four Gospels, which are the only indisputable ones in the Church of God under heaven, I have learned by tradition that the first was written by Matthew, who was once a publican, but afterwards an apostle of Jesus Christ, and it was prepared for the converts from Judaism and published in the Hebrew language"


Obviously Aramaic was conflated with Hebrew.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is The Hebrew Monotheistic Belief A Product Of Religious Syncretism? by PastorAIO: 9:01pm On Nov 19, 2018
UgwuAghachi:
Are you aware that Ebonyi was formed by the merging of 2 provinces, the Abakaliki province from Enugu and the Afikpo province from Abia. The Afikpo province share cultural similarities and dialect intelligibility with the Ohafia, Abriba, Arochukwu, etc of Abia North. Do your research well before posting half truths in a public forum
No, I'm not aware that it was formed by the merging of 2 provinces. I am also not aware of what that has to do with anything we are discussing. I have done absolutely no research on Ebonyi and in fact the only thing I said about Ebonyi was a wager.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 1:17pm On Nov 16, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
LOL. Now I'm supposed to research your own arguments too? You told me that you made up the title of the thread and it became my duty as a seeker of the Truth to go and determine whether you did in fact or not? Because it matters to me why?
Nope! Stop being a dunce. I told you that I have a penchant for making up words. I thought I was making up a word - Bibliolatry. I make up words by deriving them from greek or latin, as a lot of english words are derived this way anyway.

It turns out that the word I thought I was making up actually already existed and it is used in the same way that intended for it to be used. obviously because I was using the same rules that determines how a lot of english words are formed.

If you had simply googled the word you would have found its meaning to be exactly as I had intended it.

And by the way, it is just a word, not an 'argument'. Bibliolatry is not an 'argument'. You really don't know what an argument is, do you?


argument
/ˈɑːɡjʊm(ə)nt/
2.
a reason or set of reasons given in support of an idea, action or theory.
"there is a strong argument for submitting a formal appeal"


So when you say:

Ihedinobi3:
About the clause in question, there is a difference between:

"(may) Grace be with you" or "the Peace of the Lord Jesus Christ be with your spirit" and other blessings like that

And

"Grace TO you and Peace FROM God the Father and our Lord Jesus Christ" and other such statements.

The first is a prayer and a desire for God to grant Grace and Peace. The second is a definite statement informing the receivers that God was sending His Grace and His Peace in the letter. This is exactly like when you say that "so-and-so sends their love" or "so-and-so greets you". The difference here is that it is put at the beginning of the letter to tell the readers that, yes indeed, this letter is coming from God through our agency. He is not just sending His Grace and Peace in the manner that a loved one asks another who is writing a letter to send their love to a dear one but effectively confirming that the letter is from Him..
What I see here is a point that you are trying to make, which is that God is the Author of the Bible. And a reason in support of the point which I put in bold but I'll repeat here again:
The difference here is that it is put at the beginning of the letter to tell the readers that, yes indeed, this letter is coming from God through our agency.


According to any dictionary definition of an argument what you attempted to do what make an argument. A very stupid lame argument. And when you realise that just how stupid your argument it (kudos to you though for recognizing your stupidity) you tried to back track by saying it is not an argument but an illustration. Only Illustration? Why not Portrait too? Or Caricature sef?
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 12:59pm On Nov 16, 2018
I asked you a question: You said I agreed with you on the matter, I asked you where I agreed with you and you responded with copious amounts of trash. All you have to do is show me where you said one thing and I responded in agreement. It's an easy request. I haven't lost any thread of the conversation. You are the one trying to make everything as convoluted as possible in the hope that the thread will be lost.

PastorAIO:
You said that Paul's greeting of 'Grace of God be on you' is evidence that He was speaking for God and those were God's words. I refuted that. There is nothing I said that repeated what you said.

If I have agreed with you, or repeated your words, on this matter then show me where I agreed with you.
Ihedinobi3:
As I said, you are now practically a dog with a bone with this issue, so much so that you've lost the thread of thought in the conversation.

This is what you were talking about:

Ihedinobi3: 'About whether or not God preserved His Witness, here are some other things I said:

|"Regardless of this desire on the part of the majority of human beings to distort God's Truth, God's Truth is still preserved in the world because of others who not only want to know it in its pure form but want to keep it accessible to others who may come to seek it. This is how God counteracts the power of the Lie. So, in every generation, there have been true believers equipped with the abilities and resources required to either reclaim the Truth from increasingly elaborate distortions that the Enemy and his agents have tried to mire it in."

"Why did God not prevent anyone from corrupting the Scriptures though? It is a fair question because obviously God can and He loves us and wants us to know the Truth or else the Bible is lying about Him, that is, He would be lying about Himself if the Bible is truly His Testimony. The answer to that question is that we have a free will. All sane human beings (the overwhelming majority of human beings) do. Therefore, each of us has a God-given right to decide what to do with God's Testimony. We can receive it in humility. We can ignore it. Or we can actively try to destroy it like King Jehoiakim of Judah tried to do in Jeremiah 36:21-26. Active physical destruction of the Bible has been attempted multiple times in human history but it is not the only way that people have actively attempted to destroy the Scriptures. They have tried too to add or remove or change material in them so that those who read their production will be misled into believing lies masked as Truth. This is hardly novel since Satan himself has been doing that since the beginning of human history, that is, presenting the lie as the truth to try to deceive those who want to be listening to God.

God allows this to make sure that every human choice about him is clearly demonstrated in the eyes of men and angels. But He is also God and He does have people who love His Truth and He commits Himself to helping them to preserve it, covering their weaknesses with His Strength so that His Testimony is preserved pure in the earth. There has never been a time in human history when such people did not exist. Nor has there ever been a time in human history when their opposite didn't either. So at all times throughout human history, both the pure Testimony of God and the adulteration, distortions and outright invented alternatives have always existed together so that everyone can choose what side they want to be on."
'


PastorAIO: "I believe you haven't really given much thought to the idea of Free Will in your entire life.

There are a variety of bibles and they are different enough from each other to be able to facilitate the development of quite contrary doctrines in the many different types of Christian churches.

I never tire for marveling at how people like you take it upon yourself to speak for God and tell us the inner workings of God's mind."

Source: https://www.nairaland.com/1224167/contra-bibliolatreia-ii-septuagint/2#72675233

That was what we were talking about.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 12:52pm On Nov 16, 2018
LOL! You spout so much rubbish here that even your 2 supporters that have been liking everything you've posted so far have given up. Obviously they felt you needed the moral support.




Ihedinobi3:
As I said, you are now practically a dog with a bone with this issue, so much so that you've lost the thread of thought in the conversation.

This is what you were talking about:

Ihedinobi3: 'About whether or not God preserved His Witness, here are some other things I said:

|"Regardless of this desire on the part of the majority of human beings to distort God's Truth, God's Truth is still preserved in the world because of others who not only want to know it in its pure form but want to keep it accessible to others who may come to seek it. This is how God counteracts the power of the Lie. So, in every generation, there have been true believers equipped with the abilities and resources required to either reclaim the Truth from increasingly elaborate distortions that the Enemy and his agents have tried to mire it in."

"Why did God not prevent anyone from corrupting the Scriptures though? It is a fair question because obviously God can and He loves us and wants us to know the Truth or else the Bible is lying about Him, that is, He would be lying about Himself if the Bible is truly His Testimony. The answer to that question is that we have a free will. All sane human beings (the overwhelming majority of human beings) do. Therefore, each of us has a God-given right to decide what to do with God's Testimony. We can receive it in humility. We can ignore it. Or we can actively try to destroy it like King Jehoiakim of Judah tried to do in Jeremiah 36:21-26. Active physical destruction of the Bible has been attempted multiple times in human history but it is not the only way that people have actively attempted to destroy the Scriptures. They have tried too to add or remove or change material in them so that those who read their production will be misled into believing lies masked as Truth. This is hardly novel since Satan himself has been doing that since the beginning of human history, that is, presenting the lie as the truth to try to deceive those who want to be listening to God.

God allows this to make sure that every human choice about him is clearly demonstrated in the eyes of men and angels. But He is also God and He does have people who love His Truth and He commits Himself to helping them to preserve it, covering their weaknesses with His Strength so that His Testimony is preserved pure in the earth. There has never been a time in human history when such people did not exist. Nor has there ever been a time in human history when their opposite didn't either. So at all times throughout human history, both the pure Testimony of God and the adulteration, distortions and outright invented alternatives have always existed together so that everyone can choose what side they want to be on."
'


PastorAIO: "I believe you haven't really given much thought to the idea of Free Will in your entire life.

There are a variety of bibles and they are different enough from each other to be able to facilitate the development of quite contrary doctrines in the many different types of Christian churches.

I never tire for marveling at how people like you take it upon yourself to speak for God and tell us the inner workings of God's mind."

Source: https://www.nairaland.com/1224167/contra-bibliolatreia-ii-septuagint/2#72675233

That was what we were talking about.



LOL. Now I'm supposed to research your own arguments too? You told me that you made up the title of the thread and it became my duty as a seeker of the Truth to go and determine whether you did in fact or not? Because it matters to me why?



First off, how reliable is Wikipedia as an academic resource, PastorAIO?

Regardless, did I claim that the MT was the original text? Is this not rather what I said:

"The original OT was preserved in the Masoretic Text"?

If it was copied and edited from faulty or otherwise imperfect manuscripts in order to regain the original rendering, would the original OT not be preserved in it?

Now, here is Encyclopedia Britannica which while not being recommended as an academic source, mind the word, is very admissible as a resource. Its information is not as comprehensive and detailed as a source would be but it is generally an excellent summary of the research out there:

"Textual criticism
Textual criticism is concerned with the basic task of establishing, as far as possible, the original text of the documents on the basis of the available materials. For the Old Testament, until 1947, these materials consisted principally of: (1) Hebrew manuscripts dated from the 9th century AD onward, the Masoretic text, the traditional Jewish text with its vocalization and punctuation marks as recorded by the editors called Masoretes (Hebrew masora, “tradition”) from the 6th century to the end of the 10th; (2) Hebrew manuscripts of medieval date preserving the Samaritan edition of the Pentateuch (first five books of the Bible); (3) Greek manuscripts, mainly from the 3rd and 4th centuries AD onward, preserving the text of the pre-Christian Greek version of the Hebrew Bible together with most of the apocryphal books (the Septuagint); and (4) manuscripts of the Syriac (Peshitta) and Latin (Vulgate) versions, both of which were based directly on the Hebrew. Since 1947 the discovery of Hebrew biblical texts at Qumrān (then Jordan) and other places west of the Dead Sea has made it possible to trace the history of the Hebrew Bible back to the 2nd century BC and to recognize, among the manuscripts circulating in the closing generations of the Second Jewish Commonwealth (c. 450 BC–c. AD 135), at least three types of Hebrew text: (1) the ancestor of the Masoretic text, (2) the Hebrew basis of the Septuagint version, and (3) a popular text of the Pentateuch akin to the Samaritan edition. A comparative examination of these three indicates that the ancestor of the Masoretic text is in the main the most reliable; the translators of the Revised Standard Version (1952) and the New English Bible (1970) have continued to use the Masoretic text as their Old Testament basis."


Source: https://www.britannica.com/topic/textual-criticism



Again, rather obviously from even Ubenedictus's reference to the Qumran Caves not to mention your own narration in your OP your first paragraph is false. The Septuagint was made for those who could not read Hebrew. You know too that there were Hebrew texts in existence at the time as there have always been. It was those Jews and Gentile believers who could not access the Hebrew text who had to make do with the Septuagint. You are the one who knows what you mean when you say "bible". Until now, you have only asserted the existence of a difference. You are not big on definitions, are you? Maintaining confusion seems to be a real thing with you.

As for the existence of the Bible, again, you are weird. The Bible is what we call the collection of Christian sacred writings. It has always existed for as long as there have been Christian sacred writings. It was only completed by the Apostles and their associates. But it has always existed as long as there have been inspired writings.

So, this is your rebuttal to the explanation you asked for about Genesis 6 and 7: a straw man. So I said that two is equal to seven? Where did I say so, pray tell?



At this point, I'm rather convinced that you are thoroughly confused in this discussion. You pick and choose what arguments you will respond to, unilaterally declining response wherever you want without much explanation (in two cases, you decided the arguments were off-topic, otherwise, you offered no explanation). You keep sneaking around in the conversation sneering and hurling insults. But to actually sustain an argument or a rebuttal is just hard for you.

I will explain one last time:

My argument is that Scripture claims to be God-breathed. That means that anyone who reads it will be able to tell, if they want to, that it is God's Own Thought because - as you yourself agreed - one can tell that something was written by someone if one already knows what that person is like. Every human being has access to Natural Revelation, that is the witness of creation around them and their own conscience and can therefore tell whether something is the Word of God or not.

To illustrate the claim that the Bible makes to be Scripture, I provided Paul's benediction. I decided later that it was a bad example and retracted it when Ubenedictus countered it. A bad example is only a bad example, not a bad argument. You accomplish nothing by harping ceaselessly on it. After all, you cannot deny that Scripture claims to be God-breathed without deciding that Paul's letter to Timothy is not Scripture.

I will give you yet another to think about:

Hebrews 4:12
[12]For the word of God is living and active and sharper than any two-edged sword, and piercing as far as the division of soul and spirit, of both joints and marrow, and able to judge the thoughts and intentions of the heart.

If, therefore, it is truly the Word of God, it will be alive and active. So, again, if you can detect life (incidentally, God breathed into Adam and he came to life, so if Scripture is God-breathed, then it must be living) in any writing, then you have the Word of God on your hands, regardless of claims or the absence of them

Those are my arguments. Perhaps at some point, you will actually bother to answer them rather than look for things to sneer at and insults to throw.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is The Hebrew Monotheistic Belief A Product Of Religious Syncretism? by PastorAIO: 12:48pm On Nov 16, 2018
JMAN05:
On the issue of language of the first century jews, there is a need not to be dogmatic. For example Professor Wright says
"The language spoken by Jesus has been much debated. We have no certain way of knowing whether he could speak Greek or Latin, but in his teaching ministry he regularly used either Aramaic or the highly Aramaized popular Hebrew. When Paul addressed the mob in the Temple, it is said that he spoke Hebrew (Acts 21:40). Scholars generally have taken this to mean Aramaic, but it is quite possible that a popular Hebrew was then the common tongue among the Jews.”—Biblical Archaeology, 1962, p. 243

For example, in Ebonyi, most there speak what we might not technically call Igbo, yet some there can speak and understand the igbo we know. Yet most speak english, while likely few speak french. There maybe some that can even speak other languages. on the issue of Hebrew in the first century, it is better not to be dogmatic. As the source says, there is no certain way of knowing.
Now it is a fact about Language, and a point that I used to discuss a lot here with muslims, that Languages evolves. All languages and they have always done so.

I remember have a long chat with a old timer called Olabowale who came up with a dumb ass statement about the Adam and Eve spoke Arabic, the same Arabic that the quran was written in. The Quran was written in an Archaic Arabic which most arab speakers today would not readily understand. I asked him: 'So from the time of Adam up until the time of Mohammed Arabic language stayed intact, but only after the Quran was written then it started to evolve to the extent that most Arab speakers cannot readily understand it without help.

That being said, because it’s written in an archaic form of Arabic which is not as readily understood today as it was when the Quran was written, there are still many arguments even among the educated about the meanings and intentions of many passages. But that’s a limitation of the written word, period, in any language. That it’s written in a language whose everyday nuances are lost to us just makes it that much easier to argue about. Humans love to argue about an author’s intent when they wrote a particular thing. Why should it be any different when the author is God?-https://www.quora.com/Can-Arabs-understand-the-Quran-without-learning-anything-else-in-schools

No.

Most Arabs don’t understand the language of the Qur’an. That’s why you’ll typically hear the exegesis of a Qur’anic verse during any given Friday sermon, subject to the biases and prejudices of the speaker of course.

Where I live at least, the Qur’an taught in schools was a matter of memorizing verse X to verse Y of a certain chapter. Explaining said verses was secondary
-https://www.quora.com/Can-Arabs-understand-the-Quran-without-learning-anything-else-in-schools


In a thousand years a language can go through a considerable amount of change to the point that it will be unintelligible to native speakers that come later. For example let us take a look at Chaucer, an english poet from the 14th century. This is his Miller's Tale from Canterbury Tales. Please tell me how well you understand this English.

The Millere that for dronken was al pale,
So that unnethe upon his hors he sat,
He nolde avalen neither hood ne hat,
15 Ne abyde no man for his curteisie,
But in Pilates voys he gan to crie,
And swoor, "By armes and by blood and bones,
I kan a noble tale for the nones,
With which I wol now quite the Knyghtes tale."
20 Oure Hooste saugh that he was dronke of ale,
And seyde, "Abyd, Robyn, my leeve brother,
Som bettre man shal telle us first another,
Abyd, and lat us werken thriftily."


Translation:

The miller, who of drinking was all pale,
So that unsteadily on his horse he sat,
He would not take off either hood or hat,
15 Nor wait for any man, in courtesy,
But all in Pilate's voice began to cry,
And "By the arms and blood and bones," he swore,
"I have a noble story in my store,
With which I will requite the good knight's tale."
20 Our host saw, then, that he was drunk with ale,
And said to him: "Wait, Robin, my dear brother,
Some better man shall tell us first another:
Submit and let us work on profitably."



I'm sure that by now you will know where I'm going with all of this. But I'll spell it out anyway.

Presuming Moses wrote the Pentateuch then that would mean that they were written possibly around 1200BCE. 1200 years later the Hebrew language would have evolved to the point that the average hebrew speaker on the streets of Judaea would not be able to understand it readily. It is highly likely that if Moses wrote the pentateuch and it was being read in a contemporary Hebrew in Jesus' time then it would have undergone many updating, translations redactions.

As regards Ebonyi Igbo I can bet my bottom dollar that if you used a time machine to fly back to 500 years ago in your hometown, you would have some difficulty understanding them when they talk. Igbo language too would have undergone some evolution over the centuries. Personally I believe that the further back you go the more likely you are to find much similarity between Igbo and Yoruba. I personally believe that they started off as the same language and forked in different directions at some point many centuries ago. Much like how English started off as a dialect of German.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is The Hebrew Monotheistic Belief A Product Of Religious Syncretism? by PastorAIO: 12:01pm On Nov 16, 2018
JMAN05:
Sorry, maybe something made me say that, I cant remember now. But what matters is that that wasnt what you said. So, anyhow, I may have misunderstood you.
No wahala.

What are you saying is not true?
What you are saying is not true is also what I'm saying is not true. Namely that the christians translated the LXX.

But a manuscript of the septuagint available during Jesus day was found with the DIVINE NAME written there. The manuscript is Fouad Inv. 266. This shows that the removal of the divine name may not have been done by the hebrew translators. So even if Jesus read with the Septuagint, he would see the divine name there.
That may be the case that there were copies of the LXX that used YHWH but that has no bearing on the fact that when Jesus quoted from the LXX he used Kyrios, so the copy used by him would have used Kyrios.

Example Mark 12:29
ἀπεκρίθη ὁ Ἰησοῦς ὅτι Πρώτη ἐστίν Ἄκουε, Ἰσραήλ, Κύριος ὁ Θεὸς ἡμῶν Κύριος εἷς ἐστιν,


Jesus answered, “The most important is, ‘Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one.


On the issue of language of the first century jews, there is a need not to be dogmatic. For example Professor Wright says
"The language spoken by Jesus has been much debated. We have no certain way of knowing whether he could speak Greek or Latin, but in his teaching ministry he regularly used either Aramaic or the highly Aramaized popular Hebrew. When Paul addressed the mob in the Temple, it is said that he spoke Hebrew (Acts 21:40). Scholars generally have taken this to mean Aramaic, but it is quite possible that a popular Hebrew was then the common tongue among the Jews.”—Biblical Archaeology, 1962, p. 243
We may not be certain that Jesus spoke Greek or Latin, but when the gospels tell us that he quotes the scriptures they have him quoting from the LXX, the greek bible. Furthermore he argues from the LXX. So if Jesus never spoke Greek that would mean that the Gospels were lying when they say he quoted from the LXX.

As regards speaking a contemporary hebrew, while it might be true it will have no bearing on their ability to read the scriptures in the hebrew for reasons that I will have to explain in a subsequent post (because it might be long, and I'd rather keep my post succinct and on point).

You might have to research the language Matthew was first written in. That might help you see that Hebrew may not have gone out of use entirely. Secondly, they appear to use Hebrew for there liturgy. So, we cant dismiss hebrew entirely.
I agree that there are strong arguments to suggest that Matthew was written in a contemporary Hebrew. And also that Hebrew was used in Liturgy.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 2:29am On Nov 12, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
Now, I didn't bother to say all that because even those who cannot for some reason learn Ancient Greek and Hebrew can still hear God's Word even if they read the Septuagint for the self-same reason that I have been presenting in my arguments: the Word of God is inspired by God and is thus recognizable to anyone looking for it. So, even in poor translations like the Septuagint, those whose hearts are seeking the Truth will find it and still recognize in such translations what is NOT the God's Word. That is why I could tell what was wrong with the JW Bible and the Apocrypha. However, my experience is mine. I don't offer it as any sort of argument. Each person has a free will and a conscience and the witness of creation, so each person can decide for themselves what is and what is not God's Word.
So recognizing God's word because you have the spirit that others don't have is not your argument. 'You don't offer it as any sort of argument.'

Also, Claiming that Grace to You from God means that the bible was authored by God is not the argument you presented, only an illustration of an argument (lol).

So which one is actually the argument you came here to make. You just entered and declared the OP as false and the went on to write at considerable length on absolutely nothing. Which part of anything you've been writing since is your argument to buttress your point that the OP was false?
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 9:09pm On Nov 10, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
I did say that you were grasping at straws. Any little thing that looks like a victory to you you'll milk for all it is worth.

I never offered the "Grace to You" bit as an argument. It was an illustration for an argument. I did my own further research before Ubenedictus attacked it and decided that it was a bad illustration so when he did, I acquiesced. That was well before you even deigned to respond on it today. I was only confirming to you that I had already yielded the point to Ubenedictus and now you have it in your head that I lost the whole argument to you?
Ihedinobi3:
About the clause in question, there is a difference between:

"(may) Grace be with you" or "the Peace of the Lord Jesus Christ be with your spirit" and other blessings like that

And

"Grace TO you and Peace FROM God the Father and our Lord Jesus Christ" and other such statements.

The first is a prayer and a desire for God to grant Grace and Peace. The second is a definite statement informing the receivers that God was sending His Grace and His Peace in the letter. This is exactly like when you say that "so-and-so sends their love" or "so-and-so greets you". The difference here is that it is put at the beginning of the letter to tell the readers that, yes indeed, this letter is coming from God through our agency. He is not just sending His Grace and Peace in the manner that a loved one asks another who is writing a letter to send their love to a dear one but effectively confirming that the letter is from Him.
HMMMM.... An illustration for an argument but not an argument in itself. So what you wrote above is not an argument or an attempt to make a point, either by illustration, by Singing, by writing or drawing. Even Dancing sef.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 8:52pm On Nov 10, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
no discernible reason. Now we are fighting over terms. I call it the Bible. You have a problem with that. I explain that Bible is only a word that describes the collection of Christian Scriptures but you still ignore that and talk about a conflation. All this because you want to argue about lists.
it is not a matter of terms. It is a matter of facts. The Scriptures of the Jews was the Septuagint at the origin of Christianity. The Bible did not exist at that time.

The Bible as a whole is a different object entirely from the LXX even though the LXX is contained in the early bibles. Using the same terms to conflate these two things is disingenuous.
As disingenuous as saying 2 is equal to 7, as per the Animals in Noah's Ark.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 8:45pm On Nov 10, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
That is not true. The original OT was preserved in the Masoretic Text. The original NT was preserved in manuscripts like the Sinaiticus. Anyone who learns Ancient Greek and Hebrew can access the Word of God in its purest form in them.
You are a liar!! Flesh and blood are not revealing these lies to you , but your Father of Lies.



The Masoretic[1] Text (MT or �) is the authoritative Hebrew and Aramaic text of the Tanakh for Rabbinic Judaism. It is not the original text (Urtext) of the Hebrew Bible. It was primarily copied, edited and distributed by a group of Jews known as the Masoretes between the 7th and 10th centuries CE.
- Wikipedia
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 8:41pm On Nov 10, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
Considering that you are the king of mystery, I would have considered it a great compliment to be told that I played it like that if I thought that that was a good thing. But I don't make up words in Latin and Greek and try to pass it off as some clear term anybody would understand. That's you. I try to explain my arguments and be clear no matter how smart or dumb the person who reads them. That is me, not you.

Bibliolatry (from the Greek βιβλίον biblion, "book" and the suffix -λατρία -latria, "worship"wink[1][2] is the worship of a book or the description of a deity found in a book. In Christianity, bibliolatry is used to describe extreme devotion to the Bible or to biblical inerrancy.[3] Supporters of biblical inerrancy point to passages (such as 2 Timothy 3:16–17) interpreted to say that the Bible, as received, is a complete source of what must be known about God.
-Wikipedia


Even though I thought I was making up the word, if you were a true seeker after Truth and applied due diligence you would not have a problem.
However you are obviously not someone who is concerned with the Truth. And so you see that even though I was not aware of it, you were being exposed by the holy Spirit.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 8:36pm On Nov 10, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
And I did say that you were only repeating what I said. Definitely not denying or contradicting what I said. So, what are you saying exactly?
You said that Paul's greeting of 'Grace of God be on you' is evidence that He was speaking for God and those were God's words. I refuted that. There is nothing I said that repeated what you said.

If I have agreed with you, or repeated your words, on this matter then show me where I agreed with you.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 8:38pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
LOL. So, now it is that I said that you said that Christians are stupid.
Ihedinobi3:
Let me put it this way: I included you because of something you said on this forum a long time ago. The same way you know my Nairaland history and brought it up when it suited you too, yours is easily accessible too.

Whether you believe that the people you were speaking of were true Christians or not, you did sneer at their lower intellectual ability compared to the atheists.

That was almost ten years ago or maybe less than that.

That attitude has not exactly changed with you. You have never, to my knowledge, ever said the exact words in question but what you have actually said amounts to the same thing including a very recent statement about Christians on the forum since MrAnony1 and I left the forum some years back.


So, again, there was no lie. I know that you make some kind of difference between some people you refer to as Christians and others you call "christians" but unless that difference is an objective one, it matters little. [b]You do treat and speak of Christians like they are not very intelligent [/b]with some exceptions perhaps like the people you mentioned.
I'm sure that you have some acrobatics that you can do to demonstrate that 'not very intelligent' or 'lower intellectual ability' is not the same as Stupid and you never accused me of saying that Christians are stupid.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 8:17pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
You are wild with the straw men today, aren't you?

I did not offer an opinion. I expressed a confusion, even an incredulity, if you will. I cannot see how that was a refutation. I did say that I couldn't the first time. And I did tell you that you were only repeating what I had said, unless I'm mixing things up right now.
Perhaps you don't know what a Refutation is:
refute
/rɪˈfjuːt/
verb
verb: refute; 3rd person present: refutes; past tense: refuted; past participle: refuted; gerund or present participle: refuting

prove (a statement or theory) to be wrong or false; disprove.
"these claims have not been convincingly refuted"

synonyms: disprove, prove wrong/false, show/prove to be wrong/false, rebut, confute, give the lie to, demolish, explode, debunk, drive a coach and horses through, discredit, invalidate;

deny or contradict (a statement or accusation).
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 8:14pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
So, let's see...

1. This letter to Timothy is not Scripture. Is that what you mean? Because if it isn't, that would be Scripture referring to "all Scripture".

[b]2. As I already argued, we can always say "Scripture" instead of "Bible" if that makes you happy. [/b]Unless you want to argue that because the sacred writings were bound together into one volume, they ceased to be Scripture. Would you like to argue that? Or perhaps you would prefer to argue that Paul and Timothy had a unique understanding of the word "Scripture" that need not be universal.



To begin, my argument was that, first, yes, the Bible claims to be the Very Word of God and that is a very big claim to make but still, second, that claim only matters if in fact, the book that makes it shows that it was God Who wrote it in the same exact way that you can tell that I wrote something because you see my personality in it.

Any book can claim to be God's Production, but only the book that mirrors God's Personality lives up to such a claim.

The Bible makes that claim. The Bible mirrors God's Personality. Therefore, the Bible is right to claim to be the Word of God.

This is what my argument is in a nutshell.



I don't believe I have said anything one way or another about whether it is the Holy Spirit Who informed you of anything. I just observed that this seems to be the whole interest of your argument: ME. That is the classical meaning of ad hominem.
I have already seen through your technique. Your technique is to try and Conflate the Bible with the Scriptures of the Earliest Christians (the Septuagint). And at the same time to try and dismiss the Septuagint completely as being nothing special while your other Vaguely defined Scripture is the Truly special text.

2. As I already argued, we can always say "Scripture" instead of "Bible" if that makes you happy.
Hahahahaha, you are too clever by half. So you want to complete the Conflation but slip it by me as if it is a concession of some sort. When in actual fact I knew that this is what you were gunning for from the start.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 8:10pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
There's this post I made as follow-up to my first response to Ubenedictus:

https://www.nairaland.com/1224167/contra-bibliolatreia-ii-septuagint/1#72581261

Then there's this too:

"I already told Ubenedictus how the Bible said so. Of course it did say so in many ways. Whenever Paul or Peter said "Grace to you (and peace) from [God]", they were essentially saying that they were writing for God. In each book of the Bible, this sort of thing occurs in one form or another. It may be by implication when a given book simply makes very authoritative statements about things that only God could really say. Or it may be more obvious as in the example I gave. Still, as I said to Ubenedictus too, this is neither here nor there. Any book may claim anything or prefer to make no claim. A claim does not make a writing Scripture. The absence of one does not make it NOT Scripture."

From: https://www.nairaland.com/1224167/contra-bibliolatreia-ii-septuagint/2#72657648

And I'm the libelous cretin? grin
If as you claim this your argument has no bearing on whether the Bible is written by God or from God then why oh why did you bring it up and present it as an argument to demonstrate that. The reason you brought it up is because you thought that it would impress us and when you realised that I recognised it justly as a nonsense argument you want to retract it but without actually retracting it for ego's sake.

The fact of the matter is that that your argument fails woefully because it is clear in the bible that Grace to you from God is a salutation that is a declaration of something that is already established. Paul didn't bring them a new Grace from God with that letter.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 8:03pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
I said this:



and this:



And then there is this thread of yours too:

https://www.nairaland.com/292880/guide-religion-section

and this:

https://www.nairaland.com/251768/huxley-nebuchadnezzar-nairaland#3630956

Suffice to say that your post history is riddled with this low opinion of Christians and their intelligence. The fact that you think some Christians are exempt does not faze me specifically because you treat them like the exception, not the rule.

Now, go on and accuse me again of sophistry. I can't see you actually doing anything more.
Please you have to quote the part where I said that Christians are stupid o.

In the first thread I was making a report of the state of affairs in the forum. The Atheists were the most dominant at the time followed by the protestant Christians. The Muslims had run away to get away from the oppression of the Christians so the protestants were attacking the Catholics instead. Nowhere in that thread did I mention that Christians were unintelligent. More Lies from Ihedinobi, straight from his father of Lies.

In the second thread I suggested that People who attack Christianity or Israel could be messengers from God as such had happened often in the Bible. E.g Nebuchadnezzar was called a servant of God and King Cyrus of Persia was actually called a Messiah.

So this is again more sophistry.
noun plural -ries
1.
a.
a method of argument that is seemingly plausible though actually invalid and misleading
b.
the art of using such arguments
2.
subtle but unsound or fallacious reasoning


You structure your words as if you are building up to a point but there is hardly ever any point made. A common technique you use is to build the entire argument stage by stage on Perhapses and Maybes and Possibilities.
"Mary could have come to see us this afternoon. It's possible abi?
Therefore, Mary could be the Thief who stole our spoon.
Therefore, The missing spoon could possibly be in Mary's pocket.
So if Mary sits down to eat rice it makes sense that she would use the spoon within grasp, the spoon in her pocket.
Conclusion: The Rice was irrefutably eaten by Mary using the spoon she stole from us. QED."
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 7:47pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
Incredible. So, shall we also say that because the Lord Jesus had not been born into the human race from Genesis to Malachi, nothing written in those books applied to Him either?

You are so weird.

Shall we also say that because none of those books referred to Him as Jesus, they don't apply to Him?

You are really really weird.
What do you find incredible/unbelievable? That Paul was not talking about Scriptures in that passage but rather about his words that he spoke/preached to the Corinthians? What is so unbelievable about that? That is what Paul himself says:
1And I, when I came to you, brothers,a did not come proclaiming to you the testimonyb of God with lofty speech or wisdom. 2For I decided to know nothing among you except Jesus Christ and him crucified. 3And I was with you in weakness and in fear and much trembling, 4and my speech and my message were not in plausible words of wisdom, but in demonstration of the Spirit and of power, 5so that your faith might not rest in the wisdom of menc but in the power of God.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 7:30pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
First, you are right: two different accounts. Not two contradictory accounts.

Two, why did you feel the need to point out those differences? In what context did you do so?

Three, I wonder where this need of mine was demonstrated here. Can you show me where I showed that I needed to reconcile these two accounts? What I do remember is a qualified refusal to do so.

Four, your continued reference to my sophistry really just makes me wonder which you really think is the case: that I am not very intelligent or that that I am intelligent enough to make arguments that are hard to take apart even though they are false. You keep saying both things. Make up your mind.

Five, you are really weird. Again, "Bible" is the name given to the collection of Christian sacred writings into one volume. That is, it is a name that refers to the self-same thing we call Scripture and Scriptures. The Scriptures were referred to both before they were completed and after. In other words, if you want to quarrel about terms, I'll just stop saying "Bible" and start saying "Scripture" and your whole thread will be even worse off then, if possible.

You are grasping for straws, PastorAIO, and you know it.
I) 7 pairs of animals does not contradict One pair of animals each. This is Sophistry.

II) I brought it up in the context of your saying this:
Ihedinobi3:
One way to appreciate this is to consider the production of Jehovah's Witnesses. I have already done this. Their Bible [/b]was created to attack the Doctrine of the Trinity and the Deity of the Lord Jesus but the production [b]ended up a contradiction and an absurdity because it taught both that the Lord Jesus is Deity and that He is not. Consistency with its own self is an important test of the Bible. Any version of the Bible that contradicts itself is questionable already unless it can present an explanation within itself for the apparent contradiction. Even modern mainstream translations of the Bible other than those produced by cults like the JW have problems which are discernible to the diligent student. But those problems would not even be discernible unless the student knows God in a way that enables Him to identify things that aren't consistent.

.
Now, how do you want to reconcile the different reports of the number of animals in the Ark? And how would you want to deny the Jehovah Witness from reconciling their own discrepancies in the same way?
I really want to see how you intend to be good for the Goose yet not be good for the gander.


III) I anticipate your attempt to use sophistry to reconcile the different reports. Of course you may just decide to avoid the matter entirely much like you avoided showing how Isaiah was talking about Virgin when in actual fact he was talking about a young woman. A young woman had a baby and before the baby grew up to make moral decisions the enemies of Israel had been scattered. How does that imply that the woman was a Virgin?

IV) I never said you made any arguments that were hard to take apart. You're hallucinating. I do think you are unintelligent enough to think that you can convince me that Hebrew Almah is a reference to a Virgin because the Israel's enemies were dispersed before the Child grew up to the age of making moral decisions. You arrange your words in such a way as if you're making a point when in fact you are making no point at all.

I'll quote you again here to show where you tried to use sophistry to pull wool over your own eyes.

Ihedinobi3:
Isaiah 7:1-16
[1]Now it came about in the days of Ahaz, the son of Jotham, the son of Uzziah, king of Judah, that Rezin the king of Aram and Pekah the son of Remaliah, king of Israel, went up to Jerusalem to wage war against it, but could not conquer it.
[2]When it was reported to the house of David, saying, "The Arameans have camped in Ephraim," his heart and the hearts of his people shook as the trees of the forest shake with the wind.
[3]Then the Lord said to Isaiah, "Go out now to meet Ahaz, you and your son Shear-jashub, at the end of the conduit of the upper pool, on the highway to the fuller's field,
[4]and say to him, 'Take care and be calm, have no fear and do not be fainthearted because of these two stubs of smoldering firebrands, on account of the fierce anger of Rezin and Aram and the son of Remaliah.
[5]Because Aram, with Ephraim and the son of Remaliah, has planned evil against you, saying,
[6]"Let us go up against Judah and terrorize it, and make for ourselves a breach in its walls and set up the son of Tabeel as king in the midst of it,"
[7]thus says the Lord God: "It shall not stand nor shall it come to pass.
[8]For the head of Aram is Damascus and the head of Damascus is Rezin (now within another 65 years Ephraim will be shattered, so that it is no longer a people),
[9]and the head of Ephraim is Samaria and the head of Samaria is the son of Remaliah. If you will not believe, you surely shall not last."'"
[10]Then the Lord spoke again to Ahaz, saying,
[11]"Ask a sign for yourself from the Lord your God; make it deep as Sheol or high as heaven."
[12]But Ahaz said, "I will not ask, nor will I test the Lord!"
[13]Then he said, "Listen now, O house of David! Is it too slight a thing for you to try the patience of men, that you will try the patience of my God as well?
[14]Therefore the Lord Himself will give you a sign: Behold, a virgin will be with child and bear a son, and she will call His name Immanuel.
[15]He will eat curds and honey at the time He knows enough to refuse evil and choose good.
[16]For before the boy will know enough to refuse evil and choose good, the land whose two kings you dread will be forsaken.

Note the bold text. It wouldn't be much of a sign unless the woman was an unmarried virgin at the time, would it?
Why could it not be a sign that a young woman has a child and before the child is grown up Israel's enemies are dispersed? Why does the woman have to be a virgin for it to be a sign? Are you not disgusted with yourself that you can present such an argument.

V) You are lying by conflating the Bible with the Scriptures mentioned in the Bible. It is the very same text that the NT calls Scriptures that you've charged into this thread to try and disavow. That text read throughout Christendom and Judaism was the LXX, aka Septuagint. Why have you come here and tried to discredit it.
Yet you present something else (even though it overlaps with the LXX) and then insist that that is the Scripture by the authority of whatever fanciful notion you are deceiving yourself with.
Ihedinobi3:
It contradicts the idea that the Septuagint was as big an authority for the Church as you represented in your argument.



It certainly clarifies the issue. The Septuagint had problems and was no miracle. Chances are that those who cared then knew that the Septuagint was no miracle and therefore used it carefully. So, while the emerging monolithic Roman tradition at the time may have made an idol out of it contending with Jews too for their own reasons, that was not necessarily the story of the Christian Church.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 6:42pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
So, I am the issue you want to discuss. You have been trying very hard to since my entry into the conversation. And when you do discuss me, you can't avoid the insults. And you can talk about Christians who can't debate very long without throwing insults. grin

You do know what the fallacy of ad hominem is, right?
Hah! Your ego knows no bounds. I would rather discuss your words and your fake arguments. It was the Holy Spirit that denounces you as a fraudulent fellow. I'm only faithfully conveying what is revealed to me. Even you admit that we all have Natural Revelation.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 6:39pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
So, THAT was a refutation, just not a very rigorous one? And it was supposed to demonstrate that you had doubts about my understanding of the terms I used? I confess I'm out of my depth on this one. Your reasoning is too high for me.
Okay o, it wasn't a refutation according to you. In your scholarly opinion I agreed with you totally. Carry on!
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 6:37pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
I already accepted this argument from Ubenedictus. I agree with it. It still does not change my argument. The Bible makes the claim it makes in 2 Timothy 3:16 at least even if you don't find an explicit claim in each book of the Bible. As I also said, the proof that a writing is Scripture is neither that it claims to be nor that it doesn't claim to be. Rather it is that it contains God's essence or His Spirit. I don't see you refuting that.
Your argument is that because of the Greeting "Grace from God to You" Therefore the bible is from God.

If you agree that the Grace of God is already established in the lives of the Christian recipients of the Letter and that all the apostle is doing is affirming that Grace of God in their lives then your whole Argument has fallen on it's ass. That you feel that it doesn't change your argument just demonstrates that you are pig-headed.

You continue to lie that the Bible makes a claim about itself when in fact it is the Letter to Timothy that makes the claim about those writings revered as Scripture. The Bible did not even exist at the time that the letter was written.

I don't know why you raised all these failed arguments when you then claim that it doesn't matter whether or not there is a claim to divine authorship in the Bible, but your belief is based on something else.

It is God's spirit in me that informs me so categorically that you are a fraud. Call it an ad hominem if you like but the Holy Spirit denounces your words in my heart. And furthermore it is done with evidence.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 (of 287 pages)