₦airaland Forum

Welcome, Guest: Register • Login • With Google • Trending • Recent • New

Stats: 3,345,867 members, 8,519,893 topics. Date: Tuesday, 17 November 2026 at 01:38 AM

Toggle theme

PastorAIO's Posts

Nairaland Forum › PastorAIO's Profile › PastorAIO's Posts

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 (of 287 pages)

Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 6:25pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
This from the man who said:



Feel free to make up straw men that suit you. And hurl any insults you can find. I can take it.
You are still committed to your Father of Lies. Where did I say anyone was unintelligent due to being a Christian? In that post you so desperately presented I made reference to other more intelligent christians. Just because I think you, a christian, are unintelligent does not amount to me saying all Christians are unintelligent. Unless you really believe that your intelligence represents the intelligence of all of Christianity.

PastorAIO:
oh, okay. Yeah, I do that already but every now and again I forget. The levels of stupidity he exhibits are mindboggling. And gone are the days when there were actually other intelligent christians on NL to rein him in. The Christians have given themselves wholly over to Idiocy as their only recourse to protect their positions.
Christianity Etc › Re: Could Jewish Success Be Evidence Of The Existence Of Yahweh by PastorAIO: 5:40pm On Nov 09, 2018
urahara:
True .

But what if Yahweh decided that 150 to 200 tears was the right time to prosper them
Why not?

And he could also have decided that 1400 years was the right time to prosper the Romans. And 2000 years was the right time to prosper Chinese. And 100 years was the right time to prosper British empire.

And he could have decided that the only people he was going to prosper were the people who were capable of questioning Authority.
Christianity Etc › Re: Could Jewish Success Be Evidence Of The Existence Of Yahweh by PastorAIO: 5:19pm On Nov 09, 2018
urahara:
If by vanguard , you mean plagiarising inventions of other nations then I don't know what to say.

China is way past it's golden era.

When it comes to dominance , Europeans even dominate more than Chinese people
When I mentioned China I was talking about consistency. It might not dominate now but up until about 2 hundred years ago it was for a long time the most advanced society in the world.

Persia is also way past it's golden era. Egypt is way past it's golden era. Scotland is way past it's golden era. Italy is way past it's golden era. But that's my point exactly. They all have eras/periods in which they dominated for a while, but it wasn't consistent.

Your suggestion is that there is something special about the Jews because they have risen in prominence in the last 150/200 years. My point is that if it is something ingrained in the people it would always have been there throughout all of their history.

If you have something to say about Scots plagiarising other people's works then just spit it out, otherwise I don't know what you're talking about.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 3:51pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
As to where the Bible said that only those who possess the Holy Spirit can understand it:

1 Corinthians 2:7-16
[7]but we speak God's wisdom in a mystery, the hidden wisdom which God predestined before the ages to our glory;
[8]the wisdom which none of the rulers of this age has understood; for if they had understood it they would not have crucified the Lord of glory;
[9]but just as it is written, "Things which eye has not seen and ear has not heard, And which have not entered the heart of man, All that God has prepared for those who love Him."
[10]For to us God revealed them through the Spirit; for the Spirit searches all things, even the depths of God.
[11]For who among men knows the thoughts of a man except the spirit of the man which is in him? Even so the thoughts of God no one knows except the Spirit of God.
[12]Now we have received, not the spirit of the world, but the Spirit who is from God, so that we may know the things freely given to us by God,
[13]which things we also speak, not in words taught by human wisdom, but in those taught by the Spirit, combining spiritual thoughts with spiritual words.
[14]But a natural man does not accept the things of the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him; and he cannot understand them, because they are spiritually appraised.
[15]But he who is spiritual appraises all things, yet he himself is appraised by no one.
[16]For who has known the mind of the Lord, that he will instruct Him? But we have the mind of Christ.
I'm sorry for you but in the passage where you are quoting the Bible is not mentioned. In fact the bible did not exist then. Neither is Scriptures mentioned. Paul didn't mention any writings in particular but spoke of his words and deeds when he encountered the Corinthians.
The book of Revelations did not exist when Paul wrote that and neither did the Gospel of John or many of the other letters.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 3:37pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
This is an example from this particular post that I am responding to. I am sure that you have some way of explaining it that will not amount to scoffing at the Bible. I will be very happy to hear your explanations:

"there are variations in the facts and figures about events contained within the bible. How many pairs of each species of animal went into Noah's Ark? One pair each, or 7 pairs of the clean ones and one pair of the unclean ones?
What Time did Jesus die? It is a very simple question that could kindly just answer for us. How many different ways can different writers say 3pm?"


"Bible" is a word that was used to describe the collection of all the sacred writings of Christianity into one volume. The common name that was used for those writings before "Bible" was "Scripture" or "Scriptures". Do you want to ask your question again?
So it is now scoffing at the bible to point out facts about it's contents. The fact is that within the bible there are 2 different accounts of how many animals were taken up into the Ark. That's just a fact. If you think that pointing that out is scoffing then I feel even more sorry for you than I started out.
What I will scoff at, not happily but with a sad heart, is your desperate mendacious need to reconcile these facts with sophistry.

While books of the bible were still being written, and while some books of the bible had not yet been written there was already reference to the Scriptures. So therefore what is being referred to as the Scriptures existed before the Bible existed. If you want to deceive yourself that Scriptures is equal to Bible please feel free, I cannot help you.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 3:29pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
It's entirely your prerogative what you want to believe. It's not my problem really.

I'm not sure how this is any kind of counter to what I said.

Good. You shouldn't take such a thing for granted. There are not that many people who have really bothered to learn "the inner workings of God's Mind" and there are even fewer who possess the gift of explaining it to others for their own spiritual benefit.
I wasn't a rigorous refutation of what you said. I merely said that I doubt that you understood the terms you were using and I didn't think you'd thought about it much. If it wouldn't lead us off topic I might go into why I said so a little bit more.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 3:26pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
Now, that psalm along with Romans 1:19-21 is your answer. In theology, it is called Natural Revelation. That is, the whole world around us, our own consciences and the fact of physical death are all witnesses not only to the existence of God but also to His Personality. This is why I said that everyone - whether believing or not, good man or bad, Hindu or Sikh - will know that the Bible is the very Word of God Himself once they read it. Everyone of us is born knowing from the evidence of creation, death and the human conscience that God does exist and what He is like. So, we all know what is likely to be His Testimony and what isn't.

But each person possesses a God-like ability to choose to completely ignore these witnesses (as you can see from the Romans 1 passage) and make up their own "truth" and do as they please. So, of course, it is entirely possible for a human being to deny that the Bible is indeed God's Word. We can and the vast majority of us unfortunately do because we want to have life on our own terms rather than God's.

Natural Revelation, however, is not the end of the story. It does make it possible for every human being who actually wants to to recognize the Bible for what it is but it does not make the Bible understandable to everyone. We will come to that in another part of your argument.
Interestingly enough, it is my 'natural revelation' that tells me that you are a fraud. It witnesses very strongly in my heart and it is a witness that submits proofs.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 3:18pm On Nov 09, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
So you say.


About the clause in question, there is a difference between:

"(may) Grace be with you" or "the Peace of the Lord Jesus Christ be with your spirit" and other blessings like that

And

"Grace TO you and Peace FROM God the Father and our Lord Jesus Christ" and other such statements.

The first is a prayer and a desire for God to grant Grace and Peace. The second is a definite statement informing the receivers that God was sending His Grace and His Peace in the letter. This is exactly like when you say that "so-and-so sends their love" or "so-and-so greets you". The difference here is that it is put at the beginning of the letter to tell the readers that, yes indeed, this letter is coming from God through our agency. He is not just sending His Grace and Peace in the manner that a loved one asks another who is writing a letter to send their love to a dear one but effectively confirming that the letter is from Him.
And when the same person greeting then bestows blessings on God himself perhaps that means that the letter is actually addressed to God and it is a message from Paul to God. After all this is how it goes innit?

2Grace and peace to you from God our Father and the Lord Jesus Christ. 3Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of compassion and the God of all comfort, 4who comforts us in all our troubles, so that we can comfort those in any trouble with the comfort we ourselves have received from God.…

2Corinthians 1


I would prefer to say that Grace and Peace from God is already an established fact just as the Blessedness of God. And what Paul is doing is stating the fact as a greeting. It is already established that God's Grace has manifest for Christians and Paul not only declares this in his salutations but he teaches his disciples to do the same.

11For the grace of God has appeared, bringing salvation for all people, 12training us to renounce ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright, and godly lives in the present age, 13waiting for our blessed hope, the appearing of the glory of our great God and Savior Jesus Christ, 14who gave himself for us to redeem us from all lawlessness and to purify for himself a people for his own possession who are zealous for good works.

15Declare these things; exhort and rebuke with all authority. Let no one disregard you.

Titus 2

In short, The Grace of God has appeared... Therefore.... Declare it with Authority.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 2:47pm On Nov 09, 2018
This is all just utter bovine feces. If I said any one was unintelligent due to being a christian you will have to show me where I said so because right now you are just being a nasty libelous cretin.

And what an awful lot of words.

Ihedinobi3:
I am responding to this because it would be wrong of me to have made a false accusation of this sort against you and fail to apologize or argue for my innocence of such an accusation.

Let me put it this way: I included you because of something you said on this forum a long time ago. The same way you know my Nairaland history and brought it up when it suited you too, yours is easily accessible too.

Whether you believe that the people you were speaking of were true Christians or not, you did sneer at their lower intellectual ability compared to the atheists.

That was almost ten years ago or maybe less than that.

That attitude has not exactly changed with you. You have never, to my knowledge, ever said the exact words in question but what you have actually said amounts to the same thing including a very recent statement about Christians on the forum since MrAnony1 and I left the forum some years back.

I am not interested in a debate about this. It is of little consequence to me and to anyone who cares for Truth what your opinion of me is, especially when you think the way you do about the Bible and fellow Christians. If you had a more pleasant attitude toward these things, then I would be worried about why you see any reason to treat me differently than them.

So, again, there was no lie. I know that you make some kind of difference between some people you refer to as Christians and others you call "christians" but unless that difference is an objective one, it matters little. You do treat and speak of Christians like they are not very intelligent with some exceptions perhaps like the people you mentioned.

Because this is not anything I care that much about - being attacked in one way or another comes with the territory in apologetics, for me - I am not going to offer proof. This is not that big of a deal. You do know of what I speak. They are your posts. If you want to split hairs and insist that they say exactly that Christians don't use their brains, I will concede the point and let you have your merry way. But your post history is long and prodigious. Anyone who is that concerned can take the trouble of finding the proof for themselves. I said what I said for educational purposes, not to embarrass you.

In any case, I won't discuss this any further. Your opinion of me is noted and accepted (it was years ago too). And I choose not to care about it.

Perhaps we can now actually deal with the "sophistries", "nonarguments" and all that other more boring stuff, can we?
Christianity Etc › Re: Could Jewish Success Be Evidence Of The Existence Of Yahweh by PastorAIO: 2:41pm On Nov 09, 2018
urahara:
So it isn't weird how in every field apart from sports and crime , Jews always dominate.
I also note that you failed to address my point that Jewish dominance has not been the case throughout their history. It emerged in the 19th and 20th century.
Christianity Etc › Re: Could Jewish Success Be Evidence Of The Existence Of Yahweh by PastorAIO: 2:39pm On Nov 09, 2018
It is just as weird as the fact that for a few decades in the 18th and 19th centuries Scotland was at the vanguard of intellectual achievements in almost every field. The period was even known as the Scottish Enlightenment.

The Scottish Enlightenment (Scots: Scots Enlichtenment, Scottish Gaelic: Soillseachadh na h-Alba) was the period in 18th and early 19th century Scotland characterised by an outpouring of intellectual and scientific accomplishments.

the thinkers of the Scottish Enlightenment asserted the importance of human reason combined with a rejection of any authority that could not be justified by reason. In Scotland, the Enlightenment was characterised by a thoroughgoing empiricism and practicality where the chief values were improvement, virtue, and practical benefit for the individual and society as a whole.
Or as weird as the fact that most of Europe's greatest cultural trailblazers seem to all be German. You name the field. Is it Music? They produced Beethoven, Mozart, Bach, Haydn ......
Is it philosophy? They produced Hegel, Heidegger, Nietzsche, Kant, Schopenhauer, Leibniz ......


Again, it is obvious that most cultures at some point or the other have a period when they flourish above others. It only lasts a period. What would be weird is if it were a consistent thing throughout their history. If the Germans or the Scottish or the Jews were always at the vanguard of progress all the time throughout their history then I would say that that was weird.
However this isn't true of any of these peoples. In fact the only people that I can say have been at the vanguard of human accomplishments with any consistency would be the Chinese people. Now what do you have to say about that?

Finally, if we are to study those periods of flourishing amongst different cultures one thing that strikes me as being a common thread is the tendency during that period to rigorously question Authority.
Is it not also interesting that most of those outstanding Jews that impress you are mostly Athiests?

urahara:
So it isn't weird how in every field apart from sports and crime , Jews always dominate.

Or that in South Africa , Jews who are merely 70 000 are also able to dominate there .

South Africa of over 50 million in population.

70000 Jews produced 5 Nobel prize winners in the hard sciences.

Produced a former South African central bank governor.

28 percent of South african billionaires are Jews.

It got to the extent that even South African blacks started to complain that the Jews were becoming to successful for their liking , controlling all the banks.


Several of South African ministers are Jews.

Their positions in South African government isn't normal for just 70k people.

The best schools in South Africa are Jewish schools.

The man who sentenced Mandela to life imprisonment was a Jew , the man who was Nelson Mandela's lawyer was also a Jew .

Bros , their success defies logic.
Christianity Etc › Re: Could Jewish Success Be Evidence Of The Existence Of Yahweh by PastorAIO: 10:51am On Nov 09, 2018
urahara:
What if yahwehs promise was never contingent on their beliefs ?

The success of the Jews was and is very weird
It hasn't been consistent throughout their history so it's got nothing to do with any yahweh promise.

And I don't think that it is that weird.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 3:17pm On Nov 04, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
Also, you think it's okay for you and other antichristians to come and throw your weight around claiming that Christians can't use their brains and then lose your mind when someone else starts to show you "faux superior condescension"? Haha. Very funny.
This is pathetic. So now you are just making up lies. Where did I say that christians can't use their brains? Are JMAN05 and Ubenedictus not Christians? Where did I say they were not using their brains?
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 3:14pm On Nov 04, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
I do think that I will point out how interesting it is that you clam that you didn't make an argument when you said this:



So, what does "contra bibliolatreia" mean and what was the point of this thread if it was not to present a reason for opposing the worship of the Bible? Isn't that what your title means: "against (or, in opposition to) the worship of the Bible"?
The title of the thread is Contra Bibliolatreia meaning against the bible worship. Still the OP is not an argument. You know what an argument is, do you? An argument seeks to demonstrate something. I have yet to present the argument, however just discussing with you and allowing you to spout sophistry is a subtle kind of Argument in itself.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 3:08pm On Nov 04, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
I have heard you. And I don't care that you think so.

If you want your statement to mean anything, go and address my actual arguments and prove them to be nonarguments.
I know you don't care what I think. I think you don't care much about anything in this matter. Your motivations quite removed from the topic of conversation.

I have addressed your sophistry in a subsequent post.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 3:05pm On Nov 04, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
I am not going to have an entire debate on this with you, PastorAIO.

You claim that I am an intellectual fraud who hypocritically claims that other people cannot form or properly attack arguments.
This is not a claim. This is a fact. Abi, are you not the one that wrote this:

ihedinobi2:
Makes for interesting browsing. This was back when antichristians could still string together a sophisticated but false argument. Today, they can't even talk without finding an insult to throw in. And they never even bother to properly attack arguments or properly construct one. They could take a library out of your book, PastorAIO.
If it is not you then I apologise. However if it is you then yes, you came here to claim that 'other people cannot form or properly attack arguemts'.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 3:00pm On Nov 04, 2018
Please can you isolate which parts of my post you are responding to when you reply because it is quite difficult to follow your posts, especially as they are quite lengthy.

Ihedinobi3:
The conversation moved on some before your response so I'm thinking you are only dragging me back to respond to things I already put a response to.
I read your response to Ube which did not touch the matter. It didn't even come close.


I already told Ubenedictus how the Bible said so. Of course it did say so in many ways. Whenever Paul or Peter said "Grace to you (and peace) from [God]", they were essentially saying that they were writing for God. In each book of the Bible, this sort of thing occurs in one form or another. It may be by implication when a given book simply makes very authoritative statements about things that only God could really say. Or it may be more obvious as in the example I gave. Still, as I said to Ubenedictus too, this is neither here nor there. Any book may claim anything or prefer to make no claim. A claim does not make a writing Scripture. The absence of one does not make it NOT Scripture.
Saying Peace of God, and the Grace of God be on you is not a claim to writing on God's behalf. This is just the way Christians greet each other. To say it is a claim to be coming from God is so utterly spurious. So if I say to you, 'God Bless you' that must mean that I'm now speaking on behalf God. That makes about half the human population orators for God.
I repeat the Bible makes no such claim. I am more certain of that now that the only proof that you have is to take a common greeting out of context and claim that it is a claim to be speaking from God.



I believe we will come back to the passage in Psalms, but not just right now. As for how I find signs of God's Personality, I don't know that it is much different than how you find signs of anybody's personality in what they write. Maybe you can explain the latter?
Wow! You're going to duck the Psalms passage.

How do I identify a personality in a writing? If someone showed me a letter that was full of spurious sophistry, I might ask the person who showed me the following question. "Was this written by Ihedinobi, it's sounds like him, I've read lots of other stuff by him on Nairaland and this certainly has all the hallmarks of this reasoning"?
The fact is that outside of the letter I already have experience of Ihedinobi which I can compare to what I see in the letter.

In order for you to be able to identify God's personality in the bible then you must already have some foreknowledge of God's personality outside of the bible. You will then be able to show that what you encountered outside the bible is strikingly similar to what you are seeing in the bible.

Pray tell, where did you know God before that tallies with the God that you read about in the bible?

About whether or not God preserved His Witness, here are some other things I said:

"Regardless of this desire on the part of the majority of human beings to distort God's Truth, God's Truth is still preserved in the world because of others who not only want to know it in its pure form but want to keep it accessible to others who may come to seek it. This is how God counteracts the power of the Lie. So, in every generation, there have been true believers equipped with the abilities and resources required to either reclaim the Truth from increasingly elaborate distortions that the Enemy and his agents have tried to mire it in."

"Why did God not prevent anyone from corrupting the Scriptures though? It is a fair question because obviously God can and He loves us and wants us to know the Truth or else the Bible is lying about Him, that is, He would be lying about Himself if the Bible is truly His Testimony. The answer to that question is that we have a free will. All sane human beings (the overwhelming majority of human beings) do. Therefore, each of us has a God-given right to decide what to do with God's Testimony. We can receive it in humility. We can ignore it. Or we can actively try to destroy it like King Jehoiakim of Judah tried to do in Jeremiah 36:21-26. Active physical destruction of the Bible has been attempted multiple times in human history but it is not the only way that people have actively attempted to destroy the Scriptures. They have tried too to add or remove or change material in them so that those who read their production will be misled into believing lies masked as Truth. This is hardly novel since Satan himself has been doing that since the beginning of human history, that is, presenting the lie as the truth to try to deceive those who want to be listening to God.

God allows this to make sure that every human choice about him is clearly demonstrated in the eyes of men and angels. But He is also God and He does have people who love His Truth and He commits Himself to helping them to preserve it, covering their weaknesses with His Strength so that His Testimony is preserved pure in the earth. There has never been a time in human history when such people did not exist. Nor has there ever been a time in human history when their opposite didn't either. So at all times throughout human history, both the pure Testimony of God and the adulteration, distortions and outright invented alternatives have always existed together so that everyone can choose what side they want to be on."
I believe you haven't really given much thought to the idea of Free Will in your entire life.

There are a variety of bibles and they are different enough from each other to be able to facilitate the development of quite contrary doctrines in the many different types of Christian churches.

I never tire for marveling at how people like you take it upon yourself to speak for God and tell us the inner workings of God's mind.


Perhaps those folks have a point. The Bible itself does say that only those who have the Spirit of God can discern and understand what it says. So they are not making it up. I can understand that you scoff at such appeals if you scoff at the Bible, as it seems to me that you do.
Why are you resorting to lies now? Where did I scoff at the bible? I scoff at your attitude to the bible, that is quite a different matter.
Where did the bible say that only those that have the Spirit of God can understand it? Where does the bible even ever refer to itself from Genesis to Revelation? Certain books or letters refer to other books or letters, and sometimes to themselves but there is absolutely no reference to the bible in the Bible.

So, let me get this straight: you made up the very title of this thread, that is, it would take someone who knows Greek and Latin to figure out what your title is about but you still thought "it was clear from the title" whatever your thread was about? And I got no points for figuring out what you were doing? How was this not disingenuity on your part?
the suffix '-latry' is common in the english language and you don't have to be a greek scholar to know that Latria means worship. Ido-latry, Idol worship. Mono-latry, worship of a single being. etc etc etc....

Excuse me for giving you more credit than you merit.


Okay. So a Christian is one who is loyal to the Roman Church? Why do you believe that? What authority defines the Christian that way? And what are these "new fangled baseless ideologies and doctrines" I'm supposed to be following?
I said the Church, you added Roman. However the apostolic traditions can be found outside of Roman Catholicism too. Are you trying to be clever? I believe that a christian would be loyal to the Church because it was founded by Jesus Christ himself who they purport to follow, and he promised to preserve the Church. So when one attacks the Church from outside I can only conclude that they cannot be christian. All this is getting rather off topic don't you think?


Well, do you believe in the Virgin Birth, PastorAIO?
Off Topic. The Virgin birth is a corner stone of Christianity and Matthew says it occurred in order to fulfill the prophecy of Isaiah that a Virgin would conceive and bear a child.


It is not true that the Hebrew Bible does not support the Virgin Birth. The fact that a different Hebrew word was used than the word for "virgin" does not necessarily translate to "the Hebrew Bible does not support the Virgin Birth. The context does have a say in this. And the context in the Hebrew Bible not only does support the Virgin Birth but it emphatically teaches it.
The virgin birth occurred in order to fulfill the prophecy that a Virgin will conceive and bear a child. If such a prophecy did not actually exist then not only is the Gospel wrong, but the Virgin birth is pointless.



How did I dismiss the entire Bible with that argument? As for your questions, it is not true that the answers vary. The same thing was just stated in different ways as different writers tend to do about the same things.
You dismissed the bible because there are variations in the facts and figures about events contained within the bible. How many pairs of each species of animal went into Noah's Ark? One pair each, or 7 pairs of the clean ones and one pair of the unclean ones?
What Time did Jesus die? It is a very simple question that could kindly just answer for us. How many different ways can different writers say 3pm?

I'm not sure that it didn't. It's a long time now since I had such discussions. But even if I did, people grow and change and I respect expertise now in other people. I know that history is not merely reading a bunch of books. There are tools and specialized knowledge that help historians make decisions about historical truth. So, I try to respect that now. Now I know what I know and what I don't know and know when I'm making an educated guess and when I am saying what I am certain of.

As to the question, why do you ask that when I also offered an explanation in the comment you are responding to? Why don't you fault the argument instead of require me to repeat it?
Well, if you've grown and changed then you've done so very fast, in the last week or so. You forget how you entered into this thread which is about the historical origins of the Septuagint. You entered like a know-it-all to tell us that OP was sophisticated but false.
ihedinobi2:
Makes for interesting browsing. This was back when antichristians could still string together a sophisticated but false argument. Today, they can't even talk without finding an insult to throw in. And they never even bother to properly attack arguments or properly construct one. They could take a library out of your book, PastorAIO.
On what basis did you say it was false if you don't know history, yet respect history and realise that history is more that just reading books (or britannica for that matter.



It's not my job to tell you. When you read it, you will know. If you want to know, that is. That is after all what I have been saying about the argument of councils. No one needs anyone to tell them what is Scripture and what isn't.

Christianity is rooted in the Bible, not just this or that version or this or that opinion of it. The Septuagint is not all wrong or all bad. But it certainly is not perfect by any standard.
all of a sudden it is not your job, but pontificating on baseless sophistry is your job abi? There are many versions out there and you say there is a war but God's true witness is preserved. Abegi, which one of the versions out there is God's true Witness. Nor be exam question.

Christianity cannot be rooted in the Bible. The New testament of the Bible was all written AFTER Christianity was established.
If you can tell me another version of the OT that is quoted to support Christian doctrines like the LXX you can say Christianity is not rooted in LXX.


Of course it was a Virgin. Isaiah just didn't use the exact Hebrew word for virgin there. Still, the context made it clear that he was talking about a virgin. Excuse the imperfection of my earlier statement. I did say though that the context limited the interpretation there to virgin.
What context made it clear that the Almah means virgin? Please explain the context.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 12:42pm On Nov 04, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
Does it occur to you that I may have some opinion of you too? Why do you think you have more right to look down on my "pseudo intellectual posturing" than I do to look down on yours? Or do you possess unique rights to all true intellectual posturing and confer it only on those who please you? Can't we just be two people who disagree with each other? Why does there have to be any intellectual posturing, whether true or false, involved here?
I have absolutely no doubt that you have your opinion of me. I also have no doubt that you'd have no qualms about expressing that opinion as you would with any of your other opinions with the same faux-superior condescension. An example can be found in the post you entered this thread with. You assumed a superiority over those you'd argued with on NL in the past.

ihedinobi2:
Makes for interesting browsing. This was back when antichristians could still string together a sophisticated but false argument. Today, they can't even talk without finding an insult to throw in. And they never even bother to properly attack arguments or properly construct one. They could take a library out of your book, PastorAIO.
You said I strung together a false argument. Apart from the fact that I didn't actually make an argument but rather a cursory look at the history of the LXX you called it false without, till now, being able to provide an argument as to why it was false.

And as if your plan is to destroy us all with the power of Irony you then go on to claim that others are incapable of forming arguments or properly attacking arguments. Abeg remind me what it is that Jesus said about the Log in the eye and the speck in the eye.
Christianity Etc › Re: Is The Hebrew Monotheistic Belief A Product Of Religious Syncretism? by PastorAIO: 8:33pm On Nov 02, 2018
JMAN05:
I didn't know that this thread is still ongoing.
It wasn't till you came back.

There seem to be a problem I have observed here. You seem to think that Christians translated the Hebrew scriptures to Greek and used it extensively, rather than the Greek translation of the OT.
Really? Where did you observe that? From the very start I stated that the LXX was commissioned in the 3rd century BCE. That is 300 years before Christianity. Kindly show me where I said the LXX was a Christian translation.


I don't think that is true. The Christians didn't translate such. It was a translation available even before Jesus birth.
I don't think that's true either. And I never said anything of the sort, however if you want to take out your frustrations on a straw man I won't stop you.


Permit me to say that the version that is available with which Jesus used when he goes to the temple to read, is not the Septuagint, but the OT written in Hebrew. This was the primary version used in the temple. Jesus was conversant with it and he would quote from that version.
You don't need my permission to say anything you please, or even to make up fables without evidence or backing. Please go ahead, but be prepared to have your fables scrutinized when you do.

Where is your evidence that Jesus did not use the LXX in the Temple. Where is your evidence that it is the primary version used in the temple? I'm not saying that it isn't but I suspect that you are just pulling out that conjecture from your hat without any actual evidence or sources.

The fact remains that according to the gospels which are our main source for Jesus' life Jesus quotes again and again from the LXX, not any hebrew bible. Unless you want to say that the Gospels were lying on Jesus' head.

and btw, Hebrew wasn't the lingua franca of the Jews in palestine anymore by the time of Jesus, it was Aramaic.

Secondly, I observed that you think that the Septuagint never at all used YHWH. That view was quite popular, but any bible researcher will agree that the Septuagint we have today is not the autograph produced by the 70/2 scholars in Alexandria. There is hint that the divine name in the Septuagint could have been removed by later christian writers. That the first century disciples of Jesus used a Septuagint with the divine name written there.
Have you got the autographs then? What is the hint that the YHWH in the LXX was removed by later christian writers? and why christian writers? It wasn't just christians using the LXX. All diaspora Jews used it too. What is this hint that the LXX of the disciples had YHWH written in it?
I really hope you are not just making up your argument now building on non existent 'facts' and 'hints'.


Thirdly, Septuagint was most necessary when the preaching went to the gentiles who cannot speak or understand Hebrew. Greek, as an international language, was used to let them know the truth. As such, they made good use of the Septuagint. (Of course, this Septuagint evidently had the divine name).
The entire purpose of the LXX, according to the legend, was make the scripture available to JEWS (not gentiles) who could no longer speak or understand Hebrew.
When you say it 'evidently' had the divine name please present this 'evident' Evidence. I say that what is evident is that you are trying to rewrite history and failing badly at it.

However, back there in Jerusalem, Jesus and other apostles could not convincingly be preaching to a Jew with a Septuagint version. From there youth, Jews were trained with OT written in Hebrew, not Greek. So I don't agree that Jesus will be quoting from the Septuagint. Septuagint would be more effective for those who do not understand Hebrew.
Jews at that time spoke Aramaic, NOT hebrew.

You don't agree that Jesus quoted from the LXX so why don't you just come out clearly and say it.... You don't believe that the account of Jesus' life given to us in the Gospels are true.

This Blue part is the truest thing you've said in this post and possibly in the whole thread. The Jews of Palestine did not Understand Hebrew so Septuagint would be more effective for preaching to them. Religious scholars would have studied some hebrew to enable them to study scriptures etc but it wasn't in common usage on the streets

Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Part of a series on
Jesus
Jesus in Christianity
[show]
Jesus in Islam
[show]
Background
[show]
Jesus in history
[show]
Perspectives on Jesus
[show]
Jesus in culture
[show]

P christianity.svg Christianity portal
Allah-green.svg Islam portal
Wikipedia book Book:Jesus

vte

It is generally agreed by historians that Jesus and his disciples primarily spoke Aramaic (Jewish Palestinian Aramaic), the common language of Judea in the first century AD, most likely a Galilean dialect distinguishable from that of Jerusalem.[1] The villages of Nazareth and Capernaum in Galilee, where Jesus spent most of his time, were Aramaic-speaking communities.[2] It is also likely that Jesus knew enough Koine Greek to converse with those not native to Palestine, and it is also possible that Jesus knew some Hebrew for religious purposes.[3][4][5]
-https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Language_of_Jesus
Christianity Etc › Re: Cry Me A River. by PastorAIO: 5:56pm On Nov 01, 2018
LoJ:
Hello Pastoraio,

I did enjoy this thread a lot. I would like to bring it back to life and further the discussion, especially with the development of crypto currency as an alternative to classical finance.
Brother, please go ahead, I would like to know what your thoughts are on Cryptos. Personally I am extremely skeptical about them. Is there a religion angle to your understanding of Cryptos?
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 2:15pm On Nov 01, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
Now, there is one thing that you are ignoring. It is that the Bible claims to be the Very Word, the Very Truth of God. That is a very big claim for any bit of literature to make. And the only way one can know for sure who wrote what is to look for signs of that person's personality and character in what is attributed to them. The fact that different versions of a literature are attributed to anyone does not mean that one or other of them was really written by them. Nor does that confusion mean that none of them were written by them.
As Uben has already responded to you. The Bible makes no such claim. Unless you have another bible that you are reading that makes that claim. There is nowhere from Genesis to Revelation where the Bible says 'This Tome is the Very Word, the Very Truth of God'. There is nowhere in the bible that you'll find that.
On the contrary you'll find the following claim in the book of Psalms:

19 The heavens declare the glory of God,
and the sky above proclaims his handiwork..
2
Day to day pours out speech,
and night to night reveals knowledge.
3
There is no speech, nor are there words,
whose voice is not heard.
4
Their voice[b] goes out through all the earth,
and their words to the end of the world.



But out of curiousity how do you look for signs of God's personality in the Bible. Where did you first get to know his personality which you can then compare to what's in the bible?


That is one important thing to note. There is another. It is that if any witness or communication was given by God to all human beings in order to provide them with all the information they need to fulfill the purpose of their existence, then it would only follow that God would also preserve that witness or communication to make sure that all human beings who ever want it can get access to it.

For this reason, all questions of authenticity will always be settled by an appeal to spiritual discernment since God is Spirit and any witness such as the Bible must necessarily be spiritual in nature. The history makes for an interesting intellectual exercise but in the end, however old manuscripts may be and however preserved the contents of a given manuscript or the other may be, the question will always be a spiritual one:

"does this witness - whatever it is - say what God would reasonably be expected to say?"
With those words in bold you've undermined the authenticity of the bible. The fact is that there are numerous versions and translations of the bible and there are numerous cults and groups formed on the basis of these different translations (or sometimes the translation are based on the doctrines of the cult). If the witness is from God then God would preserve it? Well the bible hasn't been so accurately preserved so does that mean that it could not be a witness from God?

Excuse me if I scoff at your appeal to spiritual discernment, but it has been my observation that folks run to hide under 'spiritual discernment' when they have no logical or intelligent argument left to defend their position.


I only just started learning ancient Greek and Hebrew, PastorAIO. I have neither reason nor interest in Latin - which I think is the language the title was written in - so I can't say with much confidence that I know what your title means. I had a guess and you have confirmed it but I couldn't have categorically said that you were clear about anything. So, it may really take a Sherlock Holmes to know what your thread was really about.
That's okay. It's not actually Latin. I made the word up myself. The Biblio part is from Greek for book, and the Latria part is from Latin for worship. So I put them together to refer to what I observe as people worshiping the bible beyond what the bible is or claims to be. People like you actually.


Additionally, throughout the time I have known you on Nairaland, I have never been sure what your deal is. I just know that you attack Christianity a lot. That's why I call you an antichristian. I don't know if you're an atheist, a deist or an agnostic. From something you wrote years ago which I read recently, it seems that you reject all labels and simply attack Christianity for the behavior of Christians and for the things about the Bible that you don't find acceptable. But from your words right now, you clearly don't accept the Virgin Birth or at least you question it. So, I assume that you don't accept that Jesus is God Who became Man to die for our sins. That leads me to think that whatever else you may claim to be, you do not claim to follow Jesus Christ even if you have issues with the behaviors of Christians and with the Bible.

So, no, clarity is not something I have ever associated you with.
Have you ever considered the fact that it could be you that is the antichristian? It is you who disavows the Church in favour of some new fangled baseless ideologies and doctrines.

I don't know how you've come to the conclusion that I don't accept the Virgin birth. I mentioned that the Virgin birth is supported by the LXX but not the Hebrew text.


I disagree with your categorical statement. I already stated the major reason in my statement above. God has preserved His Word by Himself through free will choices made by different men through the ages and in spite of schemes and agenda and preferences of different groups.

One way to appreciate this is to consider the production of Jehovah's Witnesses. I have already done this. Their Bible was created to attack the Doctrine of the Trinity and the Deity of the Lord Jesus but the production ended up a contradiction and an absurdity because it taught both that the Lord Jesus is Deity and that He is not. Consistency with its own self is an important test of the Bible. Any version of the Bible that contradicts itself is questionable already unless it can present an explanation within itself for the apparent contradiction. Even modern mainstream translations of the Bible other than those produced by cults like the JW have problems which are discernible to the diligent student. But those problems would not even be discernible unless the student knows God in a way that enables Him to identify things that aren't consistent.
With these words you have pretty much dismissed the entire bible with your argument. What time was Jesus crucified? what time did he die? The answer would depend on which part of the bible you were reading.

I can't speak to what Martin Luther did since I am not a historian but it does not "smell right" judging by what I do know of the Reformation. I may try to find more information on that.

Differences in the different versions of the OT is to be expected given that this world is a warzone and the issue is the Truth. What is truth? That's the question every human activity is concerned with. The Bible is God's Answer to the question. So, of course, it will be attacked with forgeries at least.
Oh come on now. Not being an Historian never stopped you in the past.
How can different versions be expected when God supposedly protects his Witness? You are contradicting yourself man.

Can you tell me which of the various versions is the authentic Witness of God in your opinion? Is it the KJV? Or the ESV? or the Douay Rheims? Which one?


As for the argument that Christianity is rooted in the Septuagint, that is false. The Lord Jesus and the apostles quoted the Septuagint because the known world of that time was steeped in Greek culture and language. That some people decided to make that much more out of the Septuagint does not mean that Christianity is rooted in the Septuagint. It just means that some people decided to make more of it than they should. Those who have followed Christ have always sought to know the Truth wherever it could be found. That is why you could mention someone like Jerome. And before Jerome there was Origen. That too is why even with so many versions of the Bible today, there are still people who sift through the traditions and errors to find the Truth.
Traditions and errors in the only Witness that God is taking special care to preserve.

Pray tell, Why do you insist that Christianity cannot be rooted in the Septuagint?

Regarding the Virgin Birth, what I have learned is that the passage in Isaiah used the Hebrew word for young woman, not the one for virgin, but the use of that word does not exclude the possibility of virgin. This makes sense if the prophecy had more than one application (as the context and other Bible passages confirm). Isaiah was speaking first of a young woman who was contemporary to him and may or may not have been a virgin (the context does limit the interpretation to "virgin" ) but he was also speaking of another young woman who would be a virgin and exist much later.
You should go back to your bible and study it better. The virgin/young woman is not just mentioned in Isaiah but Matthew chapter 1 makes it explicitly clear that it was a Virgin and it had to be a virgin to fulfill what God said:



22 All this took place to fulfill what the Lord had said through the prophet: 23 “The virgin will conceive and give birth to a son, and they will call him Immanuel”[g] (which means “God with us”).



It had to be a Virgin, not just a young woman, and Matt 1 goes into detail of what happened and how it all happened in order to fulfill Isaiah.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 1:12pm On Nov 01, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
First of all, Ubenedictus, why do you sound like you're on the war path? You opted to respond to me when I addressed myself to PastorAIO. The least you could do is maintain something of a neutral attitude, right? If I have offended you, it was completely unwitting. There is no reason to treat my arguments like a personal affront.
I can't speak for Ubenedictus but for myself I've got to admit I find your pseudo intellectual posturing quite irritating, especially as its blatantly uninformed, and it has required quite a measure of discipline and restraint to not respond in a sharper tone with you. I have been quite aggressive in the past and I've usually ended up feeling remorseful about it. So I try to be as cordial as possible.

You introduced yourself to this thread with the following ....
ihedinobi2:
Makes for interesting browsing. This was back when antichristians could still string together a sophisticated but false argument. Today, they can't even talk without finding an insult to throw in. And they never even bother to properly attack arguments or properly construct one. They could take a library out of your book, PastorAIO.
You fancy yourself to be some sort of superior intellect and that can easily rub many people the wrong way. Especially if you then go on to write considerable amounts of nonsense on the subject discussed.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 1:00pm On Nov 01, 2018
JMAN05:

We do not reject the Septuagint.
But keep researching, you will discover things I hope will help you. If I tell you, you may not believe until you do your own personal digging. So its good. Keep it up.

You can check the other thread, I wrote something there.
OneJ:
My bro, in your other thread, ("syncretism & monotheism", u know the topic U originated) PastorAI0 is making such claims simply because I pointed out that contrary to his opinion, "ego himi " in John 8:58 is NOT the same as "I am" in Exodus 3:14.

Whenever JW present the truth about a subject matter, it is often twisted & distorted by the opposition.
Jah bless.
Shalom
I don't see how you can be so totally given over to Lying that you can brazenly contradict yourselves and not care.

'Ego Eimi' is greek for 'I Am'. John 8:58 says Ego Eimi in the original text. Exodus 3:14 says Ego Eimi in the Septuagint.

When you say 'ego eimi is not I Am', your mind has become so distorted by lies that you cannot even see how ludicrous you look. (I Am is not I Am, lolz).



OneJ:
In Hebrew "ehyeh asher ehyeh" means. " I will become what/who I will become" ( Exodus 3:14 ). "Ego himi ho on " is not the Greek equivalent for Hebrew's ehyeh asher ehyeh. Stop being dishonest,Oga Pastor. White can never be black. pls Stick to the bitter truth.
If Ego eimi ho on is not the greek equivalent for ehyeh ahser ehyeh then you are saying that the septuagint got it wrong.


OneJ:
Oga, the Hebrew scriptures existed before the Septuagint. Their scrolls were often kept in the synagogues. In these bible verses of Matthew, U referred above, Jesus himself paraphrased what he learnt from the Hebrew scriptures .

Na the cover versions of the Hebrew Scriptures naim dey for the Septuagint

This is a brazen rejection of the Septuagint in favour of some 'hebrew scriptures' but it is based on ignorance.

OneJ:
LIES &FALSEHOOD!
All these your long epistle are half hearted measures at best. Where & when did Jesus "quotes extensively from the Greek translation"?
Rather, Jesus extensively quoted the Hebrew scriptures for instance, in Matt4:4 he quoted Deut8:3. In John 10:34 he quoted Psalms 82:6 etc.

You call the fact that Jesus quotes extensively from the Septuagint 'LIES AND FALSEHOOD'. Why do you hate the LXX so much that you want to lie that Jesus was quoting from them in the gospels. Is it because you hate the text because it does not support the doctrines of your cult?

OneJ:
... Well, i just saw this post now...
From time immemorial, the Jews rejected [b]"I am" (even till tomorrow) [/b]because know its a man made fallacy that has no connection to the name of God just as they too rejected the Trinity. However, there exists apostates in their midst who would fall for any man made philosophy they fancy.

Is this ignorance or mendacity? the majority of Jews in the first century in fact used the LXX and so they did not reject 'I Am'. That is just a lie. or hopefully, just ignorance.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 12:27pm On Oct 26, 2018
OneJ:
My bro, in your other thread, ("syncretism & monotheism", u know the topic U originated) PastorAI0 is making such claims simply because I pointed out that contrary to his opinion, "ego himi " in John 8:58 is NOT the same as "I am" in Exodus 3:14.

Whenever JW present the truth about a subject matter, it is often twisted & distorted by the opposition.
Jah bless.
Shalom
and this is another example of you rejecting the LXX. LXX translates Exodus 3:14 as Ego Eimi, so you are saying that the LXX is wrong.

Whenever JW are faced with the truth about a subject matter, they often twist & distort it.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 12:21pm On Oct 26, 2018
JMAN05:

We do not reject the Septuagint.
But keep researching, you will discover things I hope will help you. If I tell you, you may not believe until you do your own personal digging. So its good. Keep it up.

You can check the other thread, I wrote something there.
OneJ:
Oga Pastor said "it doesn't matter whether this (Septuagint ) is an accurate translation or not for the student of Christianity..... & that is what they built their theology on".
For example, if U wrote a book in Yoruba & U gave permission to a Greek translator to publish a Greek version of your book. After the work is done, U later found out that in chapter 3 ,the content & meaning is very different & contradicts your original book, would U accept that & praise the work & recommend it to the general public ?
Any deviation from the Hebrew texts (the original source) ,God says it's Unacceptable.1Thes5:20,21. Rev22:18,19
Nairalanders, PastorA10 doesn't mind to propagate the theology built on falsehood & man made fallacy (trinity).
IF you say the 'content and meaning is very different and contradicts your original work' that sounds like a rejection to me.

When you say that God says it is Unacceptable then that sounds like a rejection to me.

So you have been caught in a lie here. Do you consider it 'unacceptable' or not? Because everything you've written so far has been a rejection of the LXX.
Christianity Etc › Re: The Many Mistakes Of Apostle Paul's Teachings: Mistake No. 7 Correction by PastorAIO: 6:38pm On Oct 25, 2018
HungerMustGo:
Op, you're either Femi Aribisala or you're one of his disciples.

You all are telling God that he made a mistake by including Paul's writings in the scriptures.
I'm more interested in the mistake that God made by founding a church that many call the Harlot of Babylon. It was this so called 'harlot of babylon' that actually compiled much of the Bible.
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 1:19pm On Oct 25, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
Some points of departure in Britannica from your deposition, PastorAIO:

1. "The name Septuagint (from the Latin septuaginta, “70”) was derived later from the legend that there were 72 translators, 6 from each of the 12 tribes of Israel, who worked independently to translate the whole and ultimately produced identical versions. Another legend holds that the translators were sent to Alexandria by Eleazar, the chief priest at Jerusalem, at the request of Ptolemy II Philadelphus (285–246 BCE), though its source, the Letter of Aristeas, is unreliable. Despite the tradition that it was perfectly translated, there are large differences in style and usage between the Septuagint’s translation of the Torah and its translations of the later books in the Old Testament. In the 3rd century CE Origen attempted to clear up copyists’ errors that had crept into the text of the Septuagint, which by then varied widely from copy to copy, and a number of other scholars consulted the Hebrew texts in order to make the Septuagint more accurate."
Source: https://www.britannica.com/topic/Septuagint

So, your version of the legend is weird and your later assertion that the Septuagint was the original Scripture of Christianity perhaps on the strength of this legend is problematic. Also, it is clear that the Septuagint had problems and scholars used Hebrew texts to compensate. Origen, incidentally, is a church father.
My general view of legends is that they are not factual. That's why we call them legends and not History. However I'm curious as to where 'my' version of the legend is 'weird' or even where it contradicts your version. I don't recall saying anything in my telling of the legend that contradicts your version of the legend above.
About being the original scripture of Christianity, the fact is that the LXX is the version most quoted in the New Testament and it is used also as the basis of some Christian doctrines. For example, the Virgin Birth, and the identification of Jesus with divinity via the use of the phrase 'I Am'/Ego Eimi.
This is the basis of my saying that LXX is a fundamental scripture of Christianity. Nothing to do with the Legend which is a story, that it may or may not surprise you to realise but, I don't believe it happened.


2. "In addition to all the books of the Hebrew canon, the Septuagint under Christian auspices separated the minor prophets and some other books and added the extra books known to Protestants and Jews as apocryphal and to Roman Catholics as deuterocanonical."
Source: https://www.britannica.com/topic/Septuagint

So, it's not like the Septuagint always had those extra books. It was at the hands of men of the Church visible that they were added.
You continue to miss one of my main points that I've made over and over again on NL. The entire thing is the product of 'the hands of men of the Church visible' and of other people too, ALL MEN, and All very very very VISIBLE. From Genesis to Revelation. All the different versions only tell us that humans are a diverse bunch.


3. "The Christian church received its Bible from Greek-speaking Jews and found the majority of its early converts in the Hellenistic world. The Greek Bible of Alexandria thus became the official Bible of the Christian community, and the overwhelming number of quotations from the Hebrew Scriptures in the New Testament are derived from it. Whatever the origin of the apocryphal books in the canon of Alexandria, these became part of the Christian Scriptures, but there seems to have been no unanimity as to their exact canonical status. The New Testament itself does not cite the Apocryphal books directly, but occasional traces of a knowledge of them are to be found. The Apostolic Fathers (late 1st–early 2nd century) show extensive familiarity with this literature, but a list of the Old Testament books by Melito, bishop of Sardis in Asia Minor (2nd century), does not include the additional writings of the Greek Bible, and Origen (c. 185–c. 254) explicitly describes the Old Testament canon as comprising only 22 books."
Source: https://www.britannica.com/topic/biblical-literature/The-Christian-canon

So, there was a more complex situation than you represent in your argument.
Thank you for filling out the details, however nothing you say above contradicts anything I said previously.


4. "The story of the Greek translation of the Pentateuch is told in the Letter of Aristeas, which purports to be a contemporary document written by Aristeas, a Greek official at the Egyptian court of Ptolemy II Philadelphus (285–246 BCE). It recounts how the law of the Jews was translated into Greek by Jewish scholars sent from Jerusalem at the request of the king.

This narrative, repeated in one form or another by Philo and rabbinic sources, is full of inaccuracies that prove that the author was an Alexandrian Jew writing well after the events he described had taken place. The Septuagint Pentateuch, which is all that is discussed, does, however, constitute an independent corpus within the Greek Bible, and it was probably first translated as a unit by a company of scholars in Alexandria about the middle of the 3rd century BCE.

The Septuagint, as the entire Greek Bible came to be called, has a long and complex history and took well over a century to be completed. It is for this reason not a unified or consistent translation. The Septuagint became the instrument whereby the basic teachings of Judaism were mediated to the pagan world, and it became an indispensable factor in the spread of Christianity.

The adoption of the Septuagint as the Bible of the Christians naturally engendered suspicion on the part of Jews. In addition, the emergence of a single authoritative text type after the destruction of the Temple made the great differences between it and the Septuagint increasingly intolerable, and the need was felt for a Greek translation based upon the current Hebrew text in circulation."


Source: https://www.britannica.com/topic/biblical-literature/Early-versions

A clearer picture of the issue.
Okay, however nothing you've said above contradicts anything I've said previously. Remember you said that the OP was a 'false argument'. I'm waiting for a refutation.


5. "Jerome produced three revisions of the Psalms, all extant. The first was based on the Septuagint and is known as the Roman Psalter because it was incorporated into the liturgy at Rome. The second, produced in Palestine from the Hexaplaric Septuagint, tended to bring the Latin closer to the Hebrew. Its popularity in Gaul was such that it came to be known as the Gallican Psalter. This version was later adopted into the Vulgate. The third revision, actually a fresh translation, was made directly from the Hebrew, but it never enjoyed wide circulation. In the course of preparing the latter, Jerome realized the futility of revising the Old Latin solely on the basis of the Greek and apparently left that task unfinished. By the end of 405 he had executed his own Latin translation of the entire Old Testament based on the “Hebrew truth” (Hebraica veritas).

Because of the canonical status of the Greek version within the church, Jerome’s version was received at first with much suspicion, for it seemed to cast doubt on the authenticity of the Septuagint and exhibited divergences from the Old Latin that sounded discordant to those familiar with the traditional renderings. St. Augustine feared a consequent split between the Greek and Latin churches. The innate superiority of Jerome’s version, however, assured its ultimate victory, and by the 8th century it had become the Latin Vulgate (“the common version”) throughout the churches of Western Christendom, where it remained the chief Bible until the Reformation."


Source: https://www.britannica.com/topic/biblical-literature/Versions-after-the-4th-century

Perhaps there were riots. Perhaps Jerome and Augustine had words. But I wonder if you exaggerated the actual events.
Perhaps perhaps perhaps.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GUVT1NZtZPo

The words between Jerome and Augustine are well documented.

Augustine to Jerome. Written about A.D. 394

... I beseech you not to devote your labour to the work of translating into Latin the sacred canonical books, unless you follow the method in which you have translated Job, viz. with the addition of notes, to let it be seen plainly what differences there are between this version of yours and that of the Septuagint,

http://www.bible-researcher.com/vulgate2.html

Perhaps I over-exaggerated, but perhaps you just want to seem like you're rebutting me when in fact you are not actually presenting anything that rebuts what I've written. I wonder why you would wonder so much that I was exaggerating. Have you heard contrary reports? Or are you just predisposed to resist anything I say whether you know it to be true or not.


I think I'll stop at this point. Other duties call. If it is necessary, I may continue this examination and comparison in the future.

Cheers.
Okay, but a few rebuttals would be quite nice. Thanks
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 12:43pm On Oct 25, 2018
Ihedinobi3:
The part in blue seems to be a flat out falsehood and in my thinking it is the single most important falsehood in this argument:

"Masoretic text, (from Hebrew masoreth, “tradition”), traditional Hebrew text of the Jewish Bible, meticulously assembled and codified, and supplied with diacritical marks to enable correct pronunciation. This monumental work was begun around the 6th century AD and completed in the 10th by scholars at Talmudic academies in Babylonia and Palestine, in an effort to reproduce, as far as possible, the original text of the Hebrew Old Testament. Their intention was not to interpret the meaning of the Scriptures but to transmit to future generations the authentic Word of God. To this end they gathered manuscripts and whatever oral traditions were available to them."

Source: https://www.britannica.com/topic/Masoretic-text
I do not remember where I got the information that there was some translating back from the Septuagint so I'll concede that point. Also, for sure, there were still some of the ancient hebrew texts around. The earliest Hebrew text that we have today are from the 2nd century bc, found amongst the Dead Sea Scrolls, I believe.

Right from those earliest days we find that there were already marked distinctions between these different copies of the earliest extant hebrew texts. There is even a Talmudic story that claimed that there were 3 copies of the Hebrew bible in the Temple that were at odds with each other and needed to be resolved. We must consider any claims of Authenticity in light of these facts.


What I perceive to be the real aim of this argument is to call the Bible into question on the basis of cleverly twisted historical events woven to disguise the major falsehood it seeks to perpetrate, namely, that the Bible we have today may not be quite the same as what existed before the Septuagint but is rather the product of different schemes/agenda/beliefs held by different groups.
I'm terribly sorry but you don't get any points for that Sherlock Holmes. Right from the title it is clear that I'm questioning the worship and elevation of the bible to divine status that we often witness. I've been doing ever since I've joined Nairaland and you're well enough acquainted with me to know this.

I can state categorically that the bibles (note the plural) that we have today are not the same as what existed before the Septuagint and is rather a product of schemes, agendas, and beliefs of different groups. It is a process that continues till today. Right before our eyes we see the Jehovah's witnesses reinventing their own bibles, Martin Luther changing words and trying to scrap books like James... etc

The fact is that there are discrepancies between the earliest copies of the OT. Furthermore Christianity is rooted in one of those versions that, The LXX, and that version is at odds with all the other Hebrew texts including the masoretic. Never mind that the hebrew texts are often at odds with themselves.

And we are not just talking about slight unimportant variations, but variations upon which whole doctrines have been based upon. For example, The Virgin Birth. Virgin Birth is not a trifling issue in Christianity. Yet it is at odds with the Hebrew bible which doesn't mention anything about a Virgin giving Birth.

Regardless whether the legend about the creation of the Septuagint is true or not, the Septuagint was known to have problems in translation. Scholars tended to use existing Hebrew texts to correct it a lot. This was during the 3rd Century AD (see the link) which was a long time after the destruction of the Temple. That means that contrary to your argument, Hebrew manuscripts survived from which a more correct translation of the Hebrew Bible could be made.

Those were the source of the Masoretic Text. And till date, it has proved completely reliable in preserving the truths of the Old Testament.
Would one of those problems in it's translation include where it says that a Virgin has bear a Child? It is only Septuagint that says that.

Or perhaps you consider it a problem that Septuagint has Yahweh confess his name as 'Ego Eimi', i.e I Am, upon which so much of christianity's claim to Christ's divinity is based on. What do you think of LXX's translation of Exodus 3:14

14 God said to Moses, “I am who I am.[c] This is what you are to say to the Israelites: ‘I am has sent me to you.’”

Would you consider this an error in Translation?

And when Jesus supposedly references it in John 8:58 was Jesus misguided?
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 12:39pm On Oct 20, 2018
ihedinobi2:
Makes for interesting browsing. This was back when antichristians could still string together a sophisticated but false argument. Today, they can't even talk without finding an insult to throw in. And they never even bother to properly attack arguments or properly construct one. They could take a library out of your book, PastorAIO.
Could you kindly explain to us how this thread makes a false argument?
Christianity Etc › Re: Contra Bibliolatreia II -the Septuagint by PastorAIO(op): 12:38pm On Oct 20, 2018
truthislight:
Lol. Transferred aggression that is. cool

That you have a disagreement with one or two persons on Nairaland on a different topic, does not translate to such generalization of what JW as an organisation accepts or rejects. Things must be seen from their perspectives.

Your statement above is a false accusation.
Since you were one of the two persons that I had the disagreement with, the other being OneJ, are you about to declare that your position in that disagreement is Not the accepted position of the JW organisation?

If you were not representing the JW position then I might accept that I made a generalisation about JW, BUT if you were accurately representing the JW lies then any rebuttal of your lies is also a rebuttal of the lies of the JW Organisation.

For those who don't know the 'disagreement' stems from this thread: https://www.nairaland.com/3753404/hebrew-monotheistic-belief-product-religious/12#69128895

I connect both threads with links because they are pertinent to each other.
Christianity Etc › Re: Who Is The Woman Clothed With The Sun, With The Moon Under Her Feet? (Rev 12) by PastorAIO: 5:01pm On Oct 13, 2018
solite3:
Mary does not fit into the woman in Rev 12 because of various reasons.
it is written that the woman was clothed with the sun and the moon under her and crowned with twelve stars. this does not relate with mary.
secondly, the 1260 days cannot apply to mary.
thirdly, her children that would be persecuted, who are they?

I love Mary but it is wrong to accord to Mary what she is not.
Has anyone ever considered that the period of 3 and 1/2 years may be a symbolism for a period of respite. So it is not a measure of how long in days and years.

3 1/2 may also refer to years not as a measure or time, but as a cycle. A year being one cycle. So 3 and one half years being 3 cycles and half a cycle. And this may be used to represent a state of repose or rest.



Also has anyone had any thought as to what may have happened to Mary after Jesus died. Maybe she did have to flee somewhere. There is no more mention of her in the bible after Jesus' death. Was she in danger? Did she have to flee into a wilderness? Perhaps she fled to Spain....
Christianity Etc › Re: "As People Leave Religious Values Behind, Economic Growth Improves!!!"-new Study by PastorAIO: 5:44pm On Oct 12, 2018
But Jesus said you can't love god and mammon. It is one or the other. What do you prefer? Either your god or money. You can't have both.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 ... 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 (of 287 pages)